4 Female Idols Looking STIFF For Abusing Plastic Surgery?

[@purva_4]

Instead of making Karina like her Æ they could have just made the Æ like her

[@youxme7520]

Omg I know right ??

[@annimaus5890]

facts

[@gia_d26]

This comment is so true

[@suyeesia7770]

Yes

[@ririrolland5132]

Lmao so true

[@SK-oz8yx]

I remember when I saw Taeyeon in Into the New World MV, she was the most eye catching one, her natural face was so cute 😢 plastic surgery could be done to enhance beauty but here it is used to achieve ONE beauty standard, make them all ended up looking the same

[@SK-oz8yx]

@@teatree3130 uhm no, female in 30 is not as old as k-entertainment want you to believe, second she's not saggy AT ALL, third aging doesnt miraculously makes your nose extremely sharper and your eyes rounder. Kim tae hee and song hye kyo are obviously older and also had some works done, but not to as extreme as their natural features dissappear

[@madz8936]

Im a taeyeon bias and I agree she had plastic surgery especially to her nose, But i think she had too many botox done and maybe to fix that uneven smile that she has since pre debut. Its kinda fix now but she still has it. I hope she will not do more ps but if she thinks thats the best for then then we should just accept it

[@user-dv9xx3yy8v]

@@madz8936 is plastic surgery that addicting? I hope too that they stop wanting the need to when they already looked better in their previous surgeries. The more they go on the worse it becomes. Like hollywood celebrities

[@madz8936]

@@user-dv9xx3yy8v yeah, i think you have the means and money the pressure will get into you to look more 'pretty'. Just imaging being out there, millions of people looks into you everyday. Thats scary.

[@irneaa]

​@@madz8936 it is her choice

[@MariaCenturia777]

This kind of plastic surgeries are very toxic in my opinion, they set unrealistic beauty standards and ruin young girls confidence.

[@kihara4244]

Yes,but no one should be judged or hated for it as they might have been the young girl with no confidence but now all these girls are confident and beautiful ✨

[@wendykpop]

Totally agree

[@rosebloom5813]

yea but like the netizen are the one who demanding perfect visual from idols every single time and when they're get a plastic surgery people are still bash them, you can't go right with this.. its happen since a long time

[@pedrogil9490]

Its all about money

[@wendyshoowaiching4161]

Korean Plastic are high standard because of their professionalism. Many ugly women became beautiful and marry well thanks to the professionalism.

[@chameleon28]

I’m gonna break some delusions here but literally every K-pop star has had some form of plastic surgery or tweaking. It’s just the way it is when in any form of limelight…but South Koreas beauty standards are so extreme that even small things that western stars can get away with idols cannot…so they have to get them fixed.

[@Dd-us6xn]

Maybe not all but the majority and that’s ok

[@chameleon28]

@@Dd-us6xn I would say 99%. There is probably 1% that have had nothing and that’s me being generous. The kpop industry goes to extreme lengths to make idols look good…like waaay more than Western stars. I was really surprised how common contact lenses, filters, heavy editing was in kpop.

[@Dd-us6xn]

@@chameleon28 I agree with you on this

[@ohrenschmalz]

Even the greatest visual of all time, Eugene of S.E.S., had her jaw shaved, her eye corners cut, her natural eyelids upgraded and her nose done. Almost everyone has had some sort of surgery done. Even Jisoo, she had her nose, lips, eyelids, eye corners, jaw etc. done. Now they have the same nose. Tbh Jisoo overdid it with the eyelids and nose btw. Looked better before.. .

[@DracoMalfoy-ty4pt]

What!? There's a huge difference between K pop ot any other beauty standard! Beauty standards doesn't even exist in Western one except that plastic boobs and butt like Kardasian and uh maybe those fishy lips?

[@MineralTown]

sm idols tend to look very uncanny. something about their preferred ps style is unsettling. winter looks a lot like tayeon & i find both of their faces jarring at times

[@pocoyina]

In the Stamp on It dp taeyeon winter and wendy look so much alike I always get confused differentiating them 😭

[@starsign0805]

I've been a long time Taeyeon Stan. When I first came across her, she immediately became my favourite visual in K-pop and I thought she was one of the prettiest people I'd ever seen. I did have a certain struggle coming to terms with the various facial changes Tae went through over the years, even though she still looks super beautiful. And ofc this is not a topic where my opinion matters at all it's completely her choice, but I sometimes feel bad that a girl who was already so pretty felt the need to undergo so many procedures to feel beautiful. I just hope she doesn't get anymore procedures done and has finally come to a place where she's comfortable in her own skin.

[@xxgxxnismilan6374]

Taeyeon 2008 HD VIDEO kzbin.info848y2JYvvMI?feature=share

[@KazOoZles1412]

I've been an snsd fan since 2010. I save her photos before she had ps. She is my bias. But after I noticed she looked different and her smile that captivated me looks different, I don't.

[@blinkonce9785]

Taeyeon was so GORGEOUS in ITNW mv like she's glowing. She didn't need any plastic surgery because she's already one of the "pretty girls" but can't blame her, the Korean beauty standards are so high and the society being so toxic doesn't help at all. I just hope she knows that she's always been so beautiful and is content with her appearance

[@8luvbug]

​@@blinkonce9785Right it's crazy to me that idols who already fit Korea's beauty standards (some were scouted solely because of their looks) still were pressured to get plastic surgery.

[@AA-ed6ek]

@@blinkonce9785 And idols like her only make the beauty standards worse by raising it when they get ps.

[@caz5624]

Surprised you didn’t talk about Nayeon. Her face seems to get more frozen every time I see it, and idk who attacked her nose…

[@mjgoat2366]

really to me she has done a normal amount of PS for an didol not too much, a few nosejobs the rest are assumptions so u cant really prove it 100%. Also ur last statement seems offensive

[@lm.1221]

same...

[@12k-y4q]

Oh gosh its so true. Her nose is very weird

[@nikienhypen6334]

It's not only her nose. Her whole face looks botched now.. I didn't wanna say it, but this is something that I noticed

[@beautifulstranger101]

And too much face fillers too

[@safz15]

Plastic surgery is common in korea, its normal. Only problem is the fans, they cant accept their idols did have ps, some see it as a crime when people say idols had ps

[@mrmaclipstick5183]

I think fans can handle it fine. But when you have videos like this making it negative and haters using P.S. as an insult when it comes to fanwars and humiliating idols. then of course people are gonna be defensive about it. It's like when people use the word "gay" or "fag" to insult someone. There's nothing wrong with being gay but when someone calls you that... they get pissed right? Also it's absurb most of the time cuz people use comparison photos when the idols is 5 yrs old vs. 23 yrs old. Like of ofc their face will change. if anything use more recent photos. ie. a few months apart, a year apart. smh.

[@piss-v4l]

the problem is the society, even korea shames others for having surguries. youd loose 80 points already if u got surguries done when compared ur beauty to someone else that had no ps. these kind of videos does nothing but make people view ps more negative. classic example is the kardasians, all of them got surguries and are constantly shamed for that, but its funny how people hating them demands them to admit surguries when thats what theyre shaming them for

[@safz15]

@@piss-v4l but i guess in sk its more acceptable compared to other asian countries / western countries. People cross lines & make fun of ps in those places, like i have so much worse talks.

[@lolaBee9]

I don't know if people necessarily see it as a crime more like it's concerning when they get so many. Also it's good for people to talk about it and not pretend that it's natural so fans don't think they're ugly because they're comparing themselves to people that don't look like that naturally either

[@AA-ed6ek]

@@lolaBee9 Thank you. Most sensible comment in this thread.

[@kimpiero2525]

The thing about rhinoplasty is, its not permanent. As you get older, you would need to undergo more procedures to keep that "perfect" nose.

[@i-nerd9978]

Really? Isn't that damaging tho? I mean to keep retouching it?😳

[@lolaBee9]

That sounds concerning. Especially if you already had a lot of nose shaved down

[@sapphireemerald6109]

Yes! It's called revision rhinoplasty.

[@Kaito-Ipn]

My mom has 2 friends who went with rhino and they are on their late 50’s now and still look good tho? I think it depends a lot on the surgeon.

[@Marzyart]

@@Kaito-Ipn I also think it depends on the type of the nose job. Reducing the size of the nose must be different than implanting a cartilage to add a bridge to the nose

[@bleusapphires]

taeyeon's face always looks like it'll melt if she stands under the sun for too long

[@noodles6281]

The bad part about plastic surgery is when you have children. Your children won't have your current features but your old one. It's kind of like the plastic surgery family photo meme.

[@flaky_salt]

oh please you care about that than it ruining ones mental health and feeding into their body dysmorphia

[@doudish3696]

But taeyeon was extremely beautiful without plastic surgery tho 😮

[@xxgxxnismilan6374]

Taeyeon 2008 HD VIDEO kzbin.info848y2JYvvMI?feature=share

[@Mezman999]

Still is. Even with surgery 😂

[@blinkonce9785]

Srsly in ITNW mv, she was so gorgeous that I thought she was Yoona (I heard Abt Yoona even b4 SNSD)

[@cartr4236]

the only reason i disagree with surgery is because then people will compare themselves to an unobtainable standard. i think if people get plastic surgery they should disclose it, especially if they have fans that are fawning over them and might be young enough to think they were just born looking 'perfect'.

[@irneaa]

right

[@LeeKnowsCatss]

I agree. Not to mention many kpop fans are adolescents and teenagers, when they have the highest chance of developing self image problems

[@rhaenyraitargaryen6360]

I have not followed SNSD for while after Jessica left in 2014 but I knew their materials up until 2015 and I would always watch their Japan tours online. When I saw Taeyeon again for the supergroup and her recent music, I was genuinely in shock. She always had a very strong jawline and it was always highlighted on stage when she's belting the high notes especially when she faces sideways. Now her chin and jaw has been shaved off for a softer look. Jessica had orthognathic surgery too to correct her jaw but she had no further surgical procedures aside from possible fat transfer to the face or fillers. Taeyeon's features has changed a lot including her cheekbones and eyes.

[@xxgxxnismilan6374]

Taeyeon 2008 HD VIDEO kzbin.info848y2JYvvMI?feature=share

[@anishabhatta6663]

Karina face look like this emoji 👽

[@divafubanga]

She's an artificial face 😓

[@Cuties.blooming145]

True 😅

[@ayu08]

I liked Taeyeon's beauty prior to I dont know Lion Heart / Party era? I especially loved her look in Genie and The Boys era. However, I feel like at some point after Mr Mr era / Lion Heart era, her overall look kept on changing in unnatural way. I dont know how to explain it but like her skin is so pale now and she seems skinnier now especially her face. Her face especially her nose dont look natural now. Even Tiffany's skin is so pale now I know they had some surgeries done even before and it was fine because at least they still looked natural back then compared to now

[@saavage321]

Tayeon seems to be sooo skinny for a 30yo woman, compared to when she debuted I hope she doesn’t starve herself

[@megosaur.]

@@saavage321 idk if her depression might have result in the weight loss but i just hope she is eating ok and overall healthy

[@megosaur.]

taeyeon was naturally pale but im pretty sure some other members skin lightened either over the years or through skin lightening prodcedures tbh i loved taes visuals in debut era all the way to igab lion heart was goddess level but she def changed some features she is still beautiful either ways but i hope she doesnt overdo it cuz her jaw rrly became so much sharper over the years and her nose became so much higher too. she is pretty both inside and outside and i hope she knows that

[@therosesloveee]

@@megosaur. Taeyeon has fair skin since debut but literally not as pale as right now.. She's definitely consume or go through some skin lightening procedure.. same goes to her members..

[@xxgxxnismilan6374]

Taeyeon 2008 HD VIDEO kzbin.info848y2JYvvMI?feature=share

[@Everythingz127]

"She looked more pretty after doing surgery " So if she had her "unpretty" face with all the talent, y'all would have thrown her away ?

[@selene214]

I have absolutely no issue with idols getting plastic surgery but what it does annoy me is the fact that these idols keep insisting that their completely natural. I mean i get it if their fans found out I don't think any of them would have a healthy response (since it seems they all choose to believe that these idols are in every way perfect in order to worship them in peace lol ) but still by doing so they are claiming that beauty like that exists naturally and in process make us normal real natural people with lots of imperfection compare our looks with them and loss our confidence and self love . In my opinion they all looked much better without the surgery no need to sugarcoat lmao especially the sm girls .

[@Bamgeutcutiepie]

Taeyeon is scary skinny these days. Not to shame. Just. I know her past. With food. So I’m worried. She looks sooooooooo fragile. And yes. Her face is very much different to a few years ago. She’s very perfect. Too much perfection in general takes away charm. I hope she cools it for the future but as for now. Her work is flawless

[@meme8934]

Her face looks weird because she’s scary thin I don’t think she’s ever been that skinny before She looks aged because of it I’m sure she’s being overworked because it’s a reoccurring thing for her to lose a lot of weight when she’s overworked I looked at some old clips from amazing Saturday from weekend era and she looked so good and youthful i hope she gains weight soon and takes care of herself

[@i-nerd9978]

@@meme8934 yes I agree damn that girl is hella overworked 😥

[@xSummeraain]

@@meme8934 respectfuly I don't think her weightloss is due to her being overworked. Between weekend and INVU she looks the same and she promoted tjose songs a lot. I'd say that maybe she over stressed herself for SNSD's comeback because the whole world was waiting to see it. There are scenes in the mv where she looks great (when she has long hair) but the scenes with short hair she's very very thin. It's a shame that she can't (or doesn't want to) gain the weight that she lost. She's clearly not ok. She's small and is even losing muscular mass. It's sad.

[@rhaenyraitargaryen6360]

Jessica has pointed this one out to her too before their falling out.

[@sodafraka]

Right now, she looks really skinny, it's worrying

[@haewon_iee]

Her : The video starts now Sm : IT'S MY TIME TO SHINE

[@eniddeltacross4410]

I miss taeyeon's original face. Now she looks like a female version of Shinee's key

[@8luvbug]

She looks like Karina in those videos

[@thats_not_breezyshes_soo_windy]

Soyeon (G)I-DLE started to look soo botched nowadays too

[@jkv5332]

nah she doesn't

[@8luvbug]

She looks like she got lip filler which never looks good on anyone

[@coquetteishfetish]

yeah her lips look crazy big now idk

[@Cuties.blooming145]

True, I love her but the lips…. 🤦‍♀️

[@soobindilf338]

1:10 wasn't Karina, it was already been debunk since 2020. That girls photo has been used by anti fans to drag Karina, so imagine this girl felt when her photo have made fun of.

[@soobindilf338]

The controversy surrounding Karina's alleged surgery was so big at that time to the point that bunch of her classmates during middle school had to protect her and they uploaded her photos though instagram and she still looks the same. But regardless of having plastic surgery or not, we as a public has nothing to do with it because its her face in the first place

[@patitah1661]

@@soobindilf338 yesss I don’t know why people still use that photo. It’s not her and when you look at her photos before she actually looks the same except her make up and eyebrows are different. She also matured.

[@Wonbin11300]

True, I feel bad for the girl.

[@yujiminmylove]

this channel only used the things that already got viral without searching if that's true or not

[@chrisomi5929]

Omg thanks for that, I was so scared and was about to be like "what the fuck did they do to that girl, the singularity of her face is gooone" they should pin your comment to reassure people and be careful with their sources in the future. This could really be misleading 😩

[@aapjm]

high standards in beauty but low standard in vocals

[@i-nerd9978]

Huh?

[@earthshuman3864]

People pressure them to that level to get surgery They were beautiful They are beautiful Their body their choice I just wish people will accept everyone as how they are

[@Everythingz127]

Yeah, a choice of pressure 😑, it's honestly sad

[@allanmhanson]

Sadly korean fand see idols as their dolls, companies see idols as their puppets. Everyone treats them like their toy, not like humans.

[@3xitthissid3]

people don't pressure them, companies do. as does the industry. stop blaming everything on fans and netizens

[@allanmhanson]

@@3xitthissid3 korean people do. They even blackmail idols, it's pretty common. Cancel cumture in Korea is way bigger. They can cancel an idol because they looked someone else in the eyes.

[@kihara4244]

Yesssssssssssssss

[@Karawoolfe]

Finally someone talking about it, Taeyan should've stopped way back. She never needed it to begin with Hyuna maybe thinks we are stupid, that is not over lining.

[@habshi0974]

Taeyan 💀

[@xoluciaxo_3721]

Taeyeon really be doing too much💀 She looks different every time i see her. Most times i don’t even recognize her

[@Ailba]

Taeyeon really looks like a combination of Winter and Karina. Don't get me wrong. I love them so much.

[@DanyEverest]

no one talking about Hyoyeon from SNSD, turned into a completely different person?

[@piggysiblings_official]

I know she did a surgery. But I feel like her overall look is still recognizable because When I start liking SNSD because their debuted song I compared them to Forever1 MV and Hyoyeon is the first person is recognized.

[@Lliuon960]

Not sure why they always deny having plastic surgery even if it's obvious? If it makes you feel good then there's nothing wrong with getting plastic surgery. They work hard to pay for it. They should advertise their doctors

[@MagisterialVoyager]

Maybe it's somehow still considered "negative". I believe they get plastic surgeries. I think a lot of them are very well done. But we're not in the industry and we don't know their code of conduct, if you will, regarding these things.

[@nnnn-sc2im]

bc anti-fans usually use it as a way to attack idols

[@harrie4667]

fans will shame idols for having surgeries (and want them to be natural) but if they're not beautiful enough they will shame them into getting them. make it make sense

[@fleija482]

Don't call fans haters, a fan doesn't make mean comments. Bullying is practiced by the hater and he doesn't deserve to be called a fan.

[@gabdongipark]

True

[@8luvbug]

Fans don't do that antis do

[@Angel_Phoenix94]

I think people care too much about appearance, it's not what's on the outside that counts and people are attracted, it's what's on the inside

[@fannyalexander5906]

They all got botched nose and extreme jaw-facial reshaping surgery.

[@lovely-gui452]

Taeyeon looks like a mix of Karina and Winter in her new mv!

[@mariahlol2488]

i wouldnt say karina

[@xxgxxnismilan6374]

TAEYEON 2008 HD VIDEO kzbin.info848y2JYvvMI?feature=share

[@earthshuman3864]

Karina is way beautiful than AI And she fit her group's concept perfectly

[@purpleeyebrows19]

imo karina fits aespa's concept the most from visuals to stage performances. There's a reason why she's the center of the group.

[@irneaa]

plastic

[@bunnywar]

What happens when the group disbands?

[@irneaa]

@@bunnywar exactly

[@mariahlol2488]

@@irneaa wasnt plastic before

[@peachgreentealuvr]

taeyeon's smile scares me

[@mroao1988]

Taeyeon was VERY BEAUTIFUL without the plastic surgery. Like, SUPER pretty. I still don’t get why they thought they had to change anything.

[@anintrovert5302]

All SM female idols look same to me. They are like copy paste of each other by same plastic surgeon.

[@Ash.e__Mayy]

True

[@yasminchan7425]

"Netz felt uncomfortable looking at her" Well don't look at her then, all of you are hypocrites cuz you put so much pressure on to idols and expects them to have "perfect" visuals, but then you "criticise" them for having too much sugery done Karina is literally one of if not the most gorgeous female idol I've seen, her visuals are so unique and I find it really cool how much she looks like an ai, it's very different compared to all other "visuals" in kpop

[@jamangel]

!!!

[@cjsoov]

couldn't agree more!! this video is so toxic honestly

[@Akurisuwa]

Especially their noses looks like micheal jackson's 😬

[@tahinirodriguez4425]

I just want SM to drop the name of the surgeon tbh...

[@Malalalaika]

I’ve been searching high and low for their surgeons 😂

[@jasubion2377]

The surgeon probably signed an exclusive contract with SM haha Even if we found him or her, we cant be a patient haha

[@muuukhhu7534]

Karina looks a whole different person

[@revilivaille7861]

Aespa's Jaws (or rather lack of jaws) is so fkn scary

[@faizaniftikhar8732]

I'm not against k pop idols getting plastic surgery I'm just weirded out by the idea why they are all getting same type of procedures that make 'em look the same. same eye shape, same lip fillers same nose bridge , same jawline implants and if that's not enough same same skin tone with similar makeup. At least bring some individuality while doing so. that's why I like Tzuyu, Jihyo, Hawasa, and all those female idols ho don't follow standards and look authentically them. you can recognize them miles away due to their uniqueness and individuality

[@Cuties.blooming145]

True😊

[@bemyhope5059]

Please Taeyeon and Karina look very weird with that jaw sme have a big history with jaw surgeries

[@purpleeyebrows19]

Yeah I think karina's jaw shave was slightly overdone but she's still beautiful and talented

[@bemyhope5059]

@@purpleeyebrows19 ofc she's talented i blame her company

[@AAA-kr7nh]

@@purpleeyebrows19 why do people like you have to put talented into something that has nothing to do with this topic? Discussion is about her face ,not her talents. Desperate attempt.

[@LegallyBoopy]

A lot of people may not realize that your nose will likely shrink a bit after a nose job - so that is why you shouldn't go too small on your nose job since it will only get smaller... I think that has affected several of these women who had procedures done when they just started out in the industry until now.

[@mistygrixti7378]

they were all so beautiful before, now they all look the same 😭😭

[@carmen_chuuu5224]

As gorgeous as all these girls are i can’t deny it does make me slightly uncomfortable how “perfect” they look, like aespa for example are all gorgeous but due to their ps they almost edge into uncanny valley territory (no hate to aespa they were just the first group I thought of) obviously it’s no problem and they can do whatever they want with their faces and their money (as long as they are adults who are mature enough to make such drastic decisions cough cough hybe) but yea idk sometimes it makes me kinda uncomfortable to look at idols because they look almost inhuman (again no hate to any of the idols as they’re just doing their jobs and doing what makes them happy)

[@hermionegranger8798]

Yep totally agree tbh. Also I think its only fair for them to be honest about the procedures that they have had done, so people know that you can't attain those sort of visuals naturally.

[@serenereese3486]

Karina and Taeyeon looks identical now

[@LaughingBoostshorts]

Some of them don't even need plastic surgery make them look more ugly. They need to listen to christina aguilera new music video.

[@iamnel3141]

when Aespa debuts... it's a random joke in Taeyeon's fandom that SM is debuting a new Girl group composed of many Taeyeons

[@mariahlol2488]

nah winter

[@arilambily]

I don't understand this obsession SM has with replacing Taeyeon, either vocal wise or visual wise. I don't understand the obsession they have in general with cloning their own idols on purpose. Irene looks like Taeyeon, Karina looks like Taeyeon, Winter looks like Taeyeon. Why? Wasn't Yoona the one Soo Man wanted in the company at all cost? Why Taeyeon exactly? She's not even Bermuda line, Seohyun, Yuri and Yoona are. Also Tiffany.. Irene also looks like Tiffany, Joy looks like Tiffany, Karina looks like Tiffany. Disturbing.

[@iamnel3141]

@@arilambily you mean.. SM tried copy pasting SNSD into newer gg?🤧 Don't worry other companies ALSO tried copying SNSD into their ggs

[@canny1485]

Aespa's obsession of making members like their AE is killing me

[@8luvbug]

*SM's obsession

[@МарияПетрова-ъ6н]

Taeyon just looks underfed and overworked, in my opinion. Seems like she's dealing with an ED

[@diandrabro]

1:10 Why would you even use that before picture for Karina? It was already debunked that that wasn’t her.

[@coquinho019]

The Karina predebut pic you used is fake! Its just a regular girl who some weirdos on the internet bully all the time trying to drag Karina.

[@hdypynitgof]

Damn, I wish they'd stop altering their faces just to have facial features that may stop being the beauty standard in 5 years. You could tell that many idols (esp 2nd gen) who did PS did so to fit the current beauty trend, and they'd probably do it again when the trend changes. I mean, I'm all for enhancing your beauty however you want to, but there's a point when it becomes unhealthy. I just hope that their decision to have PS (if they're not forced by their companies at all) is simply because they enjoy looking good on camera (wc is a part of their job ofc), not because they've beaten themselves up about not being "pretty enough."

[@hdypynitgof]

@Unknown Unfound That, too. I wish idols and other public figures are allowed to represent ordinary people with realistic looks, because while they make many fans happy with their visuals, they're also contributing to a toxic culture that implies your worth depends on your beauty.

[@hasnoname.4654]

Wow,I wonder if Karina's relatives can recognize her after all that surgery

[@youxme7520]

Lmao

[@kihara4244]

She has not changed that much and also she is beautiful, u gotta get a life

[@jaejaenu]

the pic in the video wasnt even her. her graduation pic before ps prove it. she was uzzlang and known for her beauty in her school

[@youxme7520]

@@kihara4244 just because someone gave their opinion doesn't mean they are hating ?

[@CraftFoxy]

bruh go look at her predebut pics, she looks the same

[@Scrappy._.0216]

on 4:12 it's more ironic to Knetz that they want their idols to be natural as possible but when someone pointed out that idols face are not theirs to comment, they don't want to acknowledge that and juat straight up ignoring it

[@ErinnEarth]

They just look and act ridiculous.

[@beverlyledbetter4906]

People are not stupid: you can tell these girls had plastic surgery, and most of them didn't really need it!🙄

[@safz15]

Dont look if you feel uncomfortable, nobody forced😌

[@jjiri8305]

lion heart era is the peak of taeyeon visual, she looks so cute and pretty

[@crystal-ll6im]

And in the new world MV she looked so cute when she was busy with the plane

[@piggysiblings_official]

Yep. My favorite is Mr.Mr.,Party.Lion heart. Her visual is the best. It start to look weird after her beautiful jawline completely gone and recently I felt like she does change a bit more But I'm still her fans tho.

[@val_99]

I dont get why people are so pressed when their faves are said to have plastic surgery. It's like they would do anything to defend their faves that their beauty are all natural when it's really not🤣 i mean, just accept the fact that their faves have, indeed, had plastic surgery and move on. The entire industry has had ps before so it's not embarrassing to admit it

[@i-nerd9978]

Lmao I still have a friend who will argue with me to the core if I told her black pink also had PS🥲, she'd tell me no they're banned from doing it 💀

[@ktyss1626]

The girl in Karina's "before" is not her. It was a rumor that is already debunked

[@kimanid.929]

it is lol nice try

[@ktyss1626]

@@kimanid.929 it's not, those pics are from 2020, and the girl in those already came out and said it was her

[@mcberry2521]

"her face now looks no different from her AI version" I'm the only one who thinks that statement is completely horrible.... 😱

[@soojin224]

"Many kpop fans have always wondered why the female idols have to suffer from so much scrutiny, when all they wanted was to appear as flawless as they can." lol the hipocrisy

[@hayu6788]

What we’re not gonna do is putting blame on these women and calling them stiff. They did plastic surgery because they suffered from social pressure. Let’s talk about that instead. Change perspective. Talk about the psychological outcome for example. There is so many things I didn’t like about this situation but one thing that angered me is what people think about Taeyeon. I saw ppl commenting on how she used to be ‘so beautiful’ during her debut days. Ok?! That was 15 years ago. I’m sure in 15 years your face change as well. Add that to the fact that stress was a major factor in her career. Clearly plastic surgery isn’t the only thing that made her looking like the way she’s looking right now. It’s very hypocritical of us to show our support to ‘natural’ looking boys and girls but throwing shade to the ones that went under the knife. What this create is this ‘vilainisation’ of plastic surgery when the only thing we should vilainise is the human kind. We don’t make sense at all and we don’t think before posting something.

[@hayu6788]

@keepitsecret-dl1pr You clearly didn’t read my comment carefully, please read it again.

[@imegacameplz]

It is so sad how these girls are getting dragged because of such a small issue, Its not even that serious because its their body not ours, and as fans we should all respect that. I think if their happy with how they look then just let them be happy. You dont have to make comments about it, because it can really destroy their confidence. And these idols already go through it as it is, so just let them be happy with the way they look.

[@Marzyart]

Nobody is hating on them for plastic surgery. In fact they look good with it. People are just pointing out the obvious, that these people are not natural and people shouldn't compare themselves with unrealistic and fake standards. These idols idols set the standards sp high which impacts ordinary people's confidence. So, I think its healthy to be honest about the work done

[@imegacameplz]

@@Marzyart Yeah I understand, but most kpop stans just point it out to make fun of idols.

[@Purrl1775]

Tayeon and Nayeon had a slight resemblance before the surgery.

[@angelbiscuits]

tbh i think the extreme normalization of plastic surgery has been more harmful than beneficial to society (esp women). so many uniquely beautiful people unecessarily go under the knife for the weirdest and smallest things :(

[@cotton_kenny]

They look like video game characters so stiff

[@effingcool1780]

Taeyeon was very pretty during SNSD high era. But after her solo debut i've realized some extreme surgery and change. But she was still recognizable, still pretty just more "in trend" kind of tweeks here and there. But now she looks like Karina. She really might have tried to look like Karina because Karina is like new IT girl in SM. She might have felt pressured to look same as new generation idols.

[@albertxiri]

She has indeed numerous plastic surgeries, but its not fair to compare her 15 years younger face, even without the surgery she would look different, shes 35 years old. And about Karina, I thinks its SM who is making everyone look like Taeyeon, like Karina and Winter.

[@8luvbug]

I think it's mostly sm pressuring these idols to get plastic surgery. I remember a former idol from a nugu group said plastic surgery was listed in her contract.

[@cheesecake4648]

i wonder how they are going to get old, like, i want to see when they are like 60 years old, or older. that shaved jaw like would look daunting.

[@nadiamahni4944]

first of all the photo you showed isn't karina it was prooved her friends said it

[@LyraReid]

Lol that's clearly her.

[@sakurasai781]

Karina is so uniquely gorgeous. She started off already pretty, but the surgeries made her stand out even more imo.

[@indieray4773]

You know it's good that you appreciate her visuals. But us appreciating their visuals after surgeries is the reason they undergo surgeries.

[@sakurasai781]

@@indieray4773 I understand that, but I don’t see the point in not supporting their visuals post-surgery. They need to feel loved and appreciated, because some of these idols unwillingly have to undergo these surgeries in order to become perfect idols.

[@indieray4773]

@@sakurasai781 what you are saying I agree with it. But we can simply say she/he is beautiful/ she stands out instead of saying she stands out after the surgery. As in we need to stop emphasising the surgeries...

[@Jasmine-rc8oi]

They overdid it cuz they know you all would still pick on even the tiniest imperfections they have. Tbh I see several people degrading idols who chose to undergo plastic surgery but at the same time bullied idols for their natural imperfections. And what's the most annoying is seeing Idols get hated for their natural features then get praised if they changed it. Then after that people would suddenly change their mind and think she looked cuter before, wish she didn't do ps and even call em plastic monsters LIKE MAKE IT MAKE SENSE!

[@i-nerd9978]

💯

[@danielh377]

You think Taeyeon looks more attractive now than in the past? Wow.

[@mimiokoi]

Stop spreading misinformation. That picture of Karina was debunked, that young girl is indirectly being hurt because y'all keep implying she's not pretty by using her picture in comparison to Karina and Karina's classmates literally posted her real highschool pics and she looks nearly the same.

[@kiki246810]

Netizens need to mind their own business.

[@autumnrainn23]

Taeyeon looks terrifying in the thumbnail 😬

[@yjmohua5546]

The only reason why SM visuals are look similar because they all have similar plastic surgery. Literally everyone knows it but refuses to accept it.

[@FlecheDeFer]

Tae should stop, because she dosen't look like herself anymore.

[@buddyriri]

Why is SinB even mentionned lol

[@justarandom_girl]

Right, this is stupid. She looks the same.

[@buddyriri]

@@justarandom_girl yeah this is misleading and thats why she shouldnt even be on the Thumbnail

[@meeks0903]

If you're gonna call out these girls. You better call them all!

[@starsintheskyID]

When I first got into K-pop. I believed in those shorts & tiktok videos about Aespa members especially, Karina that they've gone through multiple surgeries which is enough to call them PLASTIC but, later I checked their M/Vs and fell in love with their songs & concept. I noticed Karina's facial expressions are kinda limited. She never seemed happy and it felt like she is carrying the burden from her company or the amount of hate she gets from netizens is directly showing on her face. In my opinion, it's not because of surgery ( I'm not denying the fact that she got plastic surgeries) It can be her natural expressions and after all SM's the visuals are supposed to have cold appearance. But, I really think people should stop K-pop idols judging that harshly. It can only create insecurity & negativity.

[@axcc0267]

if aespa are plastic, so is every other idol. majority of idols get surgeries, fillers, botox etc

[@starsintheskyID]

@@axcc0267 Yes!! Those YT videos in which idols get harshly criticized, misleads new kpop fans and I regret blindly believing in them. But, Aespa doesn't deserve even ounce of the hate they're getting. Karina and other members are so pretty in their own way.

[@mariahlol2488]

@@starsintheskyID tbh the "karina" in the pic is not karina

[@ssfghjgghhgrdcbbnmjgddxcggg]

​@@mariahlol2488yep its her indeed, there are old video that prove that the one in the picture was actually her, they more likely denied that the one in the pic was her because idols most of the time do not say if the dis plastic surgery, just like that girl from nmixx that edited her pre debut picture pretending that she had no nose job

[@queenlove2535]

Karina surgeon must be the best in korea cuz he or she did a good work, cuz it suits her

[@td5168]

And what was the point of making this video 💀💀besides to create a space to talk about other people and their choices…so weird

[@user-sg3pt6we3v]

Funny that Sunny's almost non existent nose is no where to be found on this list

[@shizukagozen777]

That's what I've been saying about Taeyeon for a while now and in her recent come back, especially in INVU, she looks the worse but her fans are so delusional... 🤦‍♀️

[@МарияПетрова-ъ6н]

The girl they always show as a "before-Karina" is not even her. She was gorgeous and beautiful even in school. Yeah, maybe she enlarged her eye slit a bit, but it's so common in Korea, lol.

[@missbcat6386]

If they ever have kids, those poor kids will look absolutely NOTHING like their plastic robot moms, and they will end up resenting their moms, lmaooooo 🙃😭

[@Blue.Lemonadee]

They'll probably never have kids because most female idols don't get their periods

[@hellbound1030]

They all look like androids lol

[@segazora]

way too many idols are ruining their lips these days, lip fillers DO NOT LOOK GOOD

[@someone_existing4267]

The picture people compare with Karina , isn't even Karina it is someone else. Look at her real pics .

[@LP-ct9nk]

Celebs like Hyundai blatantly lying about their procedures is the whole reason people get so up in arms about plastic surgery. She goes from having normal lips to having a pair mrs. Potatohead would be proud of and then has the nerve to say “overlining” 💀💀💀. People are tired of the lies that help to perpetuate harmful beauty standards hence plastic surgery callouts

[@fleija482]

Yes, public figures are going to be criticized, and it's our job to piss off haters and make them stop being insufferable.

[@leaderstxt]

I don't agree with Taeyeon and Hyuna Taeyeon looks like that because she lost so much weight due to constant stress and depression, just look at her body alone and you will see what I'm talking about, there is a chance that she did her nose, but her jaw and everything else is natural, and Hyuna probably did botox on her lips. They are still the main slayers + so beautiful SinB is pretty but her nose always bothered me and for Karina I have no comments, I never liked her beauty, especially her jaw, she looks too unnatural for my preference, that's it, but they can do what they want idc

[@ya-si127]

The irony is that when they don’t fit the standard the idol get hate but when they do this happens

[@superbluerock8327]

1:10 ISNT KARINA !!!! SM & even her classmates all said Karina was always the center of attention due to her sharp beauty. Even the Super Junior member that saw her predebut stated her visual stood out from the crowd when he first discovered her at an audition. P.S. if you want to see Karina’s ACTUAL predebut face, go and look it up because her classmates all upload images of her. You guys are literally bullying 2 girls by comparing them to each other when they’re 2 different people.

[@gabrielfrost9134]

Netizens are brutal and a lot of them are straight up toxic, stop cyber bullying kpop idols!.

[@Yiyithaa]

About hyuna, it’s pretty obvious she only gets injections on her lips but her face shape and eyes has always been the same, it only changes with makeup

[@PearlNikki]

Honestly, seeing Taeyeon as she is now, its a bit weird. Maybe cause I'm used to seeing her back in The Boys, Run Devil Run eras, I mean she's still beautiful but I absolutely loved how she looked back then, I wished that someone told her she was beautiful and didn't need to change a thing.. but I'll support her either way