#4 of 16: PAKISTAN: ORIGINS, IDENTITY, AND FUTURE

[@JaghataiK]

Iqbal is a great example of how intellect and talent are no guarantee of incorruptibility.

[@siddhantjaiswal9115]

I'm shocked to see 0 comments and only 550 views even though the video has been uploaded 5 hrs ago. This shows priority of Pakistani people. Such valuable content with intellectual person and no response from Pakistani people. Please be serious about your country and start consuming content on serious topics.

[@subratamallick9353]

Extremely valuable discussion!!!! Sincere thanks to Prof Hoodbhoy.

[@sanjithkmemon8525]

Today we marched on champes ullese in Paris singing sare jahan se ache 😊

[@agonnoga6100]

Sir Syed came from a family who were themselves colonizers of India before the British. So, his admiration for the British could be similar to Adolf Hitler's admiration of the British and their empire upon which the Sun never set. The British and their empire was the inspiration for Hitler's Lebensraum.

[@orissa72]

Very nice discussion. Prof. Hoodbhuoy as usual is at his analysis best.

[@chakradharmahapatra1958]

I am surprised and shocked to know what I listened about Iqbal. One thing they missed discussing is the common complaints of Pakistanis about Iqbal missing Nobel Prize, and Tagore getting it, and the comparison between the two. Great discussion indeed. However, Pakistanis can't have any discussion complete without invoking Narendra Modi. So sad.

[@muhammadakmal4167]

Thank you for great discussion. I am reading the book and these videos are reinforcing the key points in an amazing way. Both of the people are doing justice to the viewers' time. 👏 👏

[@hamidhamidi3134]

Thank you for these videos. Now I can see why Pakistan and many other Muslim countries are so miserable. Not a word I have heard in these founder's thoughts about the right of man, dignity of human beings, etc. Ibal is outright a Taliban type of thinker.

[@xs2nasir]

This guy should be education minister of Pakistan

[@blindeagle9109]

On a lighter note , Prof.Hoodbhoy , you resemble with Hollywood star , Harrison Ford....😊 Expecting your candid reaction.❤

[@bala8669]

Jinnah was great indian who wanted to save india from green snake's and green cancer. Due to nehru and Gandhi, still green cancer exists in India and suffering

[@fallenman-j9r]

Sir, but Iqbal in one of his interview says that: "I never advocated for Pakistan by heart. I had to made this address becuase at that time I was chosen for the presidential address". I can provide yout the proper reference, author name, book name and the time of interview and in which newspaper it was publised at that time. However, What is your take on Iqbal after getting this information?

[@raziagauhar9018]

بہت دلچسپ اور معلوماتی پروگرام ۔ اقبال کی شاعری میں ہر پیچ کا مانجھا ملتا ہے ۔ کسی۔ ماہر نفسیات سے بھی اقبال اور سر سید احمد کے بارے میں رائے جاننے کی ضرورت ہے ۔ کیا یہ کتاب ایمیزون میں دستیاب ہے ؟

[@haidervlogs8359]

Many of ours messages are not showing up in the comments section of your video, can you please resolve this issue.

[@talksbyravians]

Great Sir, We also want some physics lectures

[@akanshayadav4768]

What is formula of power 🎉

[@irfanhaider5042]

What would have been the situation of Pakistan right know if we were tough these thing in our school's and college's.

[@sharjeeljawaid]

2:49 He was a master poet in two languages, Urdu and Persian but I would not rate him high in politics.

[@GP-wk2vh]

Iqbal, how could a man be called great because of his mystical poems who does not have moral value just because he was annoyed n humiliated. This is exactly the problem with muslims who will not accept humiliation and dive into abyss. Shame even to remember him as a great man he needs to be buried

[@anilthapa5631]

What good is Iqbal if failed his people. Even Nehru is ten times better than him. If he was such an intellectual he should have seen what's coming.....so sad for pakistan😢.

[@kassimtufail9061]

Hello 👋 hello everybody

[@mkpandyapandya5188]

Dear u know Iqbal grand father was Hindu bhrahmin , n why he was converted to Muslim, please find out

[@GP-wk2vh]

Probably iqbal had a problem of split personality like dim imran khan

[@decosiddique712]

Professor's understanding and knowledge about Allama is very limited he should have done more study about him for example he compared Natches super man with Mard a Momin which shows very less knowledge about Allama .