Why Abdus Salam Isn't Celebrated As Pakistan's Hero Ft. Pervez Hoodbhoy EP158

[@xzx255]

Dr . Salam is celebrated in India too among physicist and so proud of this renowned noble laureate 🙏

[@rohitpal73]

Lol 😂😂😂

[@Kingzombiemyanmar]

@@rohitpal73?

[@akshayrathore2882]

What do you mean lol. Ictp is destination for aspiring indian scholars

[@tubajalil4902]

Pakistani nation is the only thankless nation who never celebrated their heroes just because they ain't Muslim they ain't sunni Muslim or they ain't pathaaan or punjabi ... pity on us

[@anjurkrishnan7831]

37:14 When Dr. Salam visited India after winning the Nobel prize he made it a point to visit his old Math teacher from SD College Lahore, Mr. Anil Ganguly and had the humility and bhakti to put the medal on his teacher's neck and said "Thank you for instilling in me a love for math so many decades ago". India honored him , If I am not mistaken in one of the IITs a physics department is named after him.

[@kashifvirk3571]

Likewise, back in 1987-89, we would see the portrait of Dr Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar hung in the Physics Department of Forman Christian College, Lahore to honour the Nobel Laureate who was born in Lahore.

[@kashifvirk3571]

Optimistically, things will change when religious fundamentalism subsides in the region. It took several centuries to recognize the discoveries of Galilei Galileo in the West

[@muneer3016]

ماشاءاللہ بہت عمدہ طریقے سے آپ نے ڈاکٹر عبدالسلام صاحب کے اوپر تبصرہ کیا اللہ تعالیٰ آپ کو جزائے خیر عطا فرمائے ۔

[@sikandarchaudry662]

salute & Hats off to Pervez Hoodbhoy !

[@husnainhyder6713]

As an Electrical Engineer from Pakistan I own Dr. Abdul-Sallam and his face should be on Pakistani Currency.

[@somerandomthoughts7403]

Much needed conversation and Thankyou Shayan for being wonderful host

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙏🙏

[@mshazaf]

It is very unfortunate Dr. Abdul Salam was Pakistani and why Pakistani discrimination. Pakistanis should be proud of him.

[@whiteknox477]

He was a kafir

[@ssssssssssama]

@@whiteknox477 And that's why it is dangerous to follow someone who blinds you so bad you can't see another human being, but only his/ her religion

[@canadianbillo]

Great podcast on Dr Salam sahib. I am so proud to be related to Dr. Salam sahib. I met him few times when I was very young. He was a true Muslim and loyal pakistani.

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙏🙏

[@omairpirzadah8063]

Dr Salam was a qadiani,not a muslim.

[@dastango1649]

میں آپکے چینل کو سبسکرائب کرنے یا نا کرنے کا سوچ رہا تھا۔ مگر سر ھود بھائی کی گفتگو کی وجہ سے آپ کا چینل سبسکرائب کر رہا ہوں۔ اور ہوسٹ آپ کا کام بھی بہت خوبصورت ہے۔

[@MrSufiSeeker]

Around timestamp 18:00, it was asked if a scientist could get or actually got two Nobel prizes in Physics. Yes, it happened. John Bardeen is the only laureate who has been awarded the Nobel Prize in Physics twice, in 1956 and 1972.

[@Quiskit]

Exactly

[@kashifvirk3571]

Dr John Bardeen won his first Nobel Prize for his theoretical explanation of semiconductors and his second Nobel Prize for his theoretical explanation of superconductors. Apart from that, Marie Curie won her first Nobel Prize in Physics and her second in Chemistry. There have been Husband-Wife, Mother-Daughter and Father-Son Nobel Prize winners as well

[@sukhpalsingh-pk5zs]

There are five peoples awarded nobel prize twice 1 Marie Curie (physics and chemistry) 2 Linus Pauling (chemistry & peace both unshared ) 3 John Burdeen (Both in physics) 4 F. Sanger (Both in chemistry) 5 k Berry Sharpless (Both in Chemistry)

[@hasanmuthawaqqil3414]

Oneday will come soon Inshallah, when Abdus Salam will get the recognition he deserves.

[@syedahsan3123]

I feel sorry for how we as a pakistani treat Dr Abdussalam as a pakistani

[@HumaraSaleem-i5o]

And Dr 😢Abdul qadeer saab

[@wali3429]

Very correct

[@Sindhi001]

@8:48 Professor said in 1947, Abdus Salam was 14 years of age. But the Professor also said, Abdus Salam was born in 1926 - so in 1947, Dr. Salam was 21 year old.

[@khadijaazhar8057]

You've just noticed the small mistake...... The whole thing he said was true ... You didn't noticed

[@AR-yk1kv]

We have to ignore small mistakes But some people are living all the time finding small streaks from others . Unfortunately Unfortunate

[@Sindhi001]

@@khadijaazhar8057 Did I say the professor made a mistake? He made a minor error. What’s the problem with pointing out the error?

[@khadijaazhar8057]

@@Sindhi001 Ok I am sorry ....

[@vikramodedra4351]

He is a physist not a mathematician so it's ok..

[@saeedahmad3748]

I wish we can give Prof Pervez Hoodbhoy what he deserves. We as an nation could not celebrate Dr Salam but lets hope we will acknowledge Prof Hoodbhoy's services.

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙌

[@zms7186]

What are the services of Dr hoodbhai, other than being a physics teacher in a university. Yes he keeps criticising the very foundation of Pakistan, yes he was against the nuclear program of Pakistan.

[@saeedahmad3748]

@@zms7186 I am sorry if you don't think that any "teacher" is worth to be recognize. He inspired a generation of new scientist in Pakistan and look at him now at this age he is trying to do something for society. I wish we can understand the worth of "a teacher"

[@afrazamjad1644]

​@@saeedahmad3748 The Teacher with some Noble Act of Performance must be Acknowledged. But the criteria in Prof hoodboy comes out is the teacher of any US university which should not be the one. Even Pakistani Teacher will be taken equivalent to that

[@joal9235]

Is it because he is also an Ahmedia?

[@mohammadyousuf6273]

It would have been great if Dr Salam would have chosen India as his country..would have got the recognition he deserves as a scientist

[@fawazcoolyaar]

💩

[@azharawan3395]

Abdus Salam was a true Pakistani and he took be Pakistani his life time honor

[@ameymarathe1]

​@@azharawan3395Pakistan did not reciprocate

[@akhil999in]

pakistan is like a cannibal zoo whose ordinary people are like live food kept in strong cages. the management are cannibals. they find the people more tasty when fully marinaded in religion. mr. jinnah was the master chef who originated this recipe. he grew the first batch of food by rewillding a large population of domesticated humans. he then steeped them in religion. the recipe turned out to be very popular indeed. it is being thoroughly followed ever since.

[@Chuglieeeee]

@@azharawan3395and Pakistani responded by destroying his grave and calling him kafir

[@tahirqadeer9348]

I am so glad to see this podcast. I have a request, where there is such a difficult question that why there is a clash between Islam and science. The answer is that only because Salam has been made a special CATAGEORY ClASS in our country Pakistan, intellectual development is not done in MADRASSA (Religious Schools), Imran Khan's vision was to teach science to the students of madrasas. Hopefully, the solution to this problem will be very easy but alas...

[@AR-yk1kv]

Dr salaam was a beautiful mind.❤ Unfortunately we lost great man but we’ve Dr Pervaiz. We’ve no chance in Pakistan.😢😢😢 Thank you dr Pervaiz and host🙏

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙏

[@abdulhameedkhatti9231]

One atheist is supporting a kadiyani What a shame

[@anubhavgangwar1383]

​@@abdulhameedkhatti9231 koi muslim scientist aaj tk paida hi nahi hua jiski tarif ki jaye😂😂

[@AliHashmi-ln6qq]

So Glad to see this podcast Thank You ProPakistani and Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙏🙏

[@MirzaArshad-h5e]

It's always very interesting and joyful when professor Hoodbhoy talks about dr. Abdul salam. But one thing about professor Hoodbhoy is also very interesting that he chose to live in Pakistan when a professor of his caliber could have lived anywhere in the west.

[@Irfanrabbani]

Do to him what was done to abdusalam and he will leave pakistan too.

[@moon_valley]

پروگرام بہت اچھا تھا آپ دونوں سے ملنے کی خواہش جاگی۔ اللہ سامان پیدا فرمائے

[@mohammadfarooqshah3796]

Dr. Salam donated part of noble prize money to Aligarh Muslim university. He started many scientific projects in Pakistan. Unfortunate that he was born in an illiterate country called Pakistan. Gen. Zia put Pakistan in dark era. Thank God our part of Kashmir is not part of Pakistan. Islamists should think why Muslims have lagged behind Hindus in Indian subcontinent.

[@AHMED..KHAN.]

Don't put it on Islam it's the Fault of GENERALS of Pakistan who Destroyed the country on the order of USA for DOLLARS.

[@abdurrehman3697]

mulla ko jo hy sajdy ki azadi, nadan samajta hy islam hy azad..................... ghulam kia jany azadi kia hoty hy......

[@nuzhatakhtar2278]

This person is an ambassador of minorities in Pakistan

[@CyberMDK]

Well I think you should've started with an introduction of the person you are going to be discussing. P.S: It's a good podcast overall.

[@mem1001953]

Actually, he don't need an introduction as Pakistan knows him very well.

[@safdar1955]

Thanks for the well-researched podcasts about brilliant minds of Pakistan.

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙏🙏

[@anwerrizvi1847]

Dr Salam is not celebrated because of iron fist control right wing religious legacy of Gen. Zia present to Pakistan Very sad 😢

[@ibratnak]

Religious parties are mistaken for being right wing, but that's not really true for Pakistan. Not only do they preach Arabization of our culture (which is opposite of conservatism), they are also communist in practice.

[@kknrcss]

He was not celebrated because of non muslim and as per quran and Mohammad, non muslim are not allowed to live. If you do not understand it iI will show it in quran

[@NaeemAhmad-cd2lx]

@@kknrcss you are so ignorant very very, very sad.

[@RED-47]

​@@kknrcss I don't understand, show in the Quran

[@Realityunboxed]

​@@kknrcss Quran and Hadees never said this for non Muslims in general. But only for those who are part of an army against Muslims and are in battlefield and attacking Muslims , Islam also expels those non Muslims from a Muslim country who are living under a contract and have committed breaking of contract. You must read whole surah and not one verse to reach a conclusion.

[@nizarali4091]

It is indeed tragic that Pakistan, as a nation, failed to honor and fully embrace Dr. Abdus Salam, one of its greatest physicists and scientist.

[@rafiqarif]

Thank you for podcast on Dr Abdus salam.

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙏

[@Lonecurious]

A good show and on a vary important matter as well. However, the interviewer should not call Dr.Hoodbhoy as "Pervez," and Dr. Salam as "Salam." I do believe that what these individuals have achieved in life demands some form of respect. Otherwsie, the show is great! I hope you, considering the very young age of the interviewer, he will at least give the "respect" element some thought. Thanks

[@sammara0929]

100% agreed

[@munawarkarim8026]

Respect and deference are two different attributes.Respect is due all individuals. Deference is a choice.

[@HarjinderSingh-ww4cy]

Excellent conversation and very informative.

[@afsheeninayat3744]

پرویز صاحب آپکا شکریہ ھم کو بتانے کا سکھانے دکھانے کا کہ کون عبدالسلام جیسی اعلیٰ پایہ کی ھستی کے بارے

[@abdulhameedkhatti9231]

Both bullshit. An atheist is supporting a kadiyani

[@educationforall2021]

Yes you can win the Nobel Prize twice. There are quite a few who have done that. John Bardeen is one (invention of transistor and theory of superconductivity)

[@zebaurang6590]

Whole world ahmadi community admire Dr hood bhi Salam sir

[@pervaizakhter3684]

Quantum mechanics Riaz ud Din and Fataz' ud Din were two students of Dr salam whi did PhD from Cambridge born in 1926 in jhang and topped in matric studied in GC and then went to Cambridge. Became Prof in Imperial College UK . Pervaiz hoos parsi did his phd from MIT USA.

[@genuinebombayite1966]

I have a huge amount of respect and admiration for Dr Hoodbhoy so I was especially surprised that Dr Hoodbhoy wasn’t aware that there is one person who has actually won the Nobel Prize in physics twice - That man is John Bardeen. His first Nobel was jointly won with the invention of the transistor - the second Nobel Prize was also jointly won for the BCS theory of superconductivity.

[@eunice9066]

You know why he do not aware about that because he totly foucsed on other matter rather then his department

[@merlinraja2863]

Also Marie Curie won two Nobel Prizes - in Physics in 1903 and in Chemistry in 1911. Knowing Bardeen's work in BCS, Cooper and Schreifer did all the work.

[@saqibahmad7680]

good program, maza aya

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙏

[@hikerover7045]

عبدالسلام ہیرو تھا ہیرو ہے اور ہیرو رہیگا ۔

[@ejazmalik4401]

Excellent interview 🍁

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙏

[@MAP-k5r]

Thankyou for great information

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙏🙏🙏

[@essakhan-oh2vh]

Houd Bhi should also be celebrated for his excellent work and services actually he has not done you can not educate the masses and still claiming your great feasts .

[@fridaytrainersindia]

What a talk. Repeat, what a talk. mindset, if too conservative, can be poison to any entity Conservative mind setting is manifestation of deep fear The interviewee as genius as the interviewer. Top class.

[@hanzlaharoon9]

A candid conversation on a sensitive topic. Simply Amzaing. But one thing that I would like to point out is that host come unprepared for the talk, even a simple internet search could have answered many questions.

[@imqadoos]

Excellent informative discussion with bitter truth and knowledge

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙏

[@qadeerhussain1274]

Agreed 👍 with you Sir Hoodbhoy...

[@ibratnak]

Dr Hoodbhoy had an excellent role model in Dr Salam which inspired him to become like him. Unfortunately, Dr Hoodbhoy was supposed to be a role model for the next generation of physicists, but even he wasn't spared from the communist virus endemic to our part of the world that forced him to shift his focus from STEM subjects to a useless subject like history.

[@shatnermohanty6678]

Those who fail to learn the lessons of History are Doomed to Repeat it .

[@wasifjalal6965]

​@@shatnermohanty6678those who read history are doomed to helplessly witness their people repeat history

[@shatnermohanty6678]

@@wasifjalal6965 if you don't read about the past , how will you know which mistakes to avoid ?

[@wasifjalal6965]

I am just making a sad remark that even if a read history, people of power will continue to repeat history (because they don't study history) which will put me in a position where I will suffer by seeing people take destructive steps and witnessing the history repeat helplessly and hopelessly. @@shatnermohanty6678

[@deepsareen1]

So you mean Islamists are Communists? Mischievous!

[@virendraSingh-je3sx]

Muslims are radicalised in India too. When late Dr Abdul Kalam ex President of India died hardly hundreds muslims were present when Mafia Don Ansari died in UP, lakhs of muslims were present at his burial site.

[@Dopamine1217]

U r right, and abul kalam was right too with his predictions about indo pak division

[@MuhammadUmair-t4t]

LOOK HINDUS ARE LECTURING ABOUT RADICALIZATION😂😂, THIS WHOLE NATION WORSHIPS THAT GUY WHO KILLED MR GANDHI JUST BECAUSE HE BELIEVES MUSLIMS AND HINDUS ARE EQUAL, SHAME ON YOU

[@Krieky]

Great discussion!

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙏🙏

[@ThinkTourism]

Fantastic personality, great topic and generates interest

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙏

[@nowie4007]

Much needed podcast ❤❤

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙏🙏

[@shatnermohanty6678]

Make a video on life of Abdus Salam vs life of APJ Abdul Kalam . That would be the best explanation of how India and Pakistan are different .

[@p0029739]

As an Indian myself...i would ask u drink some strong tea or coffee and wake up....APJ as great as he was, is not in the league of Abdus Salam....Abdus Salam solved problems that Eintein could not...

[@shatnermohanty6678]

@@p0029739 the difference in the attitude of both nations towards their respective Genuis Scientists is the topic of my comment .

[@shatnermohanty6678]

@@p0029739 I don't know why my comment was blocked . The topic of my comment was how India and pakistan treated their respective Genuis Scientists is the basic difference in nature of the two countries .

[@shatnermohanty6678]

@@p0029739 my comments keep getting blocked

[@shatnermohanty6678]

@@p0029739 BTW , who is " EINTEIN" ?

[@quddusquddus136]

It’s questionable that the scientist shed tears for a Jihadi state. “In order to love a country, a country ought to be lovely.” Soldiers of a lovely country do not rape helpless young Bengali women in Bengali villages. They don’t selectively murder intellectuals and professors in Dhaka university campus. A country worth shedding tears for is not run by the military generals for the benefit of an army state. The military generals wouldn’t know what is gravity, let alone black hole.

[@Irfanrabbani]

The answer to your statement is that countries have armies and here an army have a country.

[@na789]

Marvellous, thanks a lot. See you again soon.

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙏

[@munawarahmad2217]

Respected Dr perwaiz A great salute for you For telling us about Dr Abdus slaam... Our national Hero...

[@learnaryzone]

Wonderful 🎉

[@mateenmalik6691]

Zabardast

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙏

[@nusratsatkohi1751]

God bless you for your honesty

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙏

[@khalidaahmad7835]

Great conversation

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙏

[@nasrbhatti]

Thank you for this podcost , I mean it. Regards

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙏

[@maqboolbhatti6213]

Very absorbing and informative interview. What however looked heavy on ears and mind was the way Dr. Sahib name was beibg taken by podcaster. He must have been called Dr.Abdul Salam...and not Salam... Reasons are understandable.

[@hdiwpodcast]

Thanks for pointing that out!

[@msimsi6912]

Very well said sir

[@javaidmairaj4610]

IN PAKISTAN GOD HAS GIVEN RESPECT & LOVE REALY BY THE GRACE OF GOD *** LOVE THE HONESTY IS THE BEST POLICY ***

[@Salman-pw4hl]

Can’t wait for this one!!!

[@pervaizakhter3684]

He excelled in Physics'.and shares Nobel prize in

[@hoodmuhammad]

He was 21 in 1947. And in 1996, there was no Geo TV, no Mamnoon Hussain and no Nawaz.

[@rafiaamjad422]

Excellent podcast

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙏

[@HumaraButtar]

Very informative episode , Sir Pervez very intelligent, open minded ❤, unfortunately Pakistan majority people think they are good muslims but I believe they are not even human being.if you have humility, mankind you are not good Muslim.

[@pslamba51]

Very sad to know of Salam sb treatment by religious fanatics. He is from land of my ancestors. Wish there was some Nehru to encourage him in Pakistan. He was pride of our subcontinent.

[@foodeliciouss121]

A proud Ahmadi Muslim , that's why he was denounced cos of his relegion

[@muzaffariqbal3750]

Jhang was not a village and dr Salam house is still present very small and humble

[@4x4minitruck660cc]

Thanks to this Podcast. Nice to listen Hoodbhoy.

[@wajahatalam4531]

Dr abdul salam was a hero we should be ashamed of how we treated him

[@m.saleemkhan9936]

Beneficial discussion.great

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙏

[@akkhansodozai423]

Abdus Salam is a great scientist

[@arifabdullah4237]

It would hav been an excellent podcast had adequate element of respe t to both pakistani geniouses have extended. Please keep up our norms of respect to elders and better Pakistanis. ❤

[@Muk8411]

Sir chhotu ram was a prominent politician in British India's Punjab Province, A substantial portion of his salary as minister was set aside for scholarships and stipends for economically poor & bright students. As Punjab's Revenue Minister, he set up the Peasants' Welfare Fund. Future Nobel Prize laureate Dr. Hoodbhoy rmentor & guru Abdus Salam was one of the beneficiaries of this Fund.

[@kknrcss]

This we Indian know and Pakistani do not teach this because islam ,quran and Mohammad want only to kill non muslim

[@anthonychinnappan610]

Parvez Sir thank you very much sir

[@rebasingh258]

Dr. Abdus Salaam was an Ahmadiya. In Pakistan Ahmadiya's are officially regarded as non Muslims. That is why he has been rejected by Pakistan.

[@atokimruk937]

This post is not to take away from the brilliant achievement of this person but to add perspectives to his life. He attended " Santana Dharma School in Lahore and also attended Bombay University but returned to Pakistan right after partiton and enrolled in Lahore. His desire to be a Muslim plus retaining his Pak passport (while not being religious initially) was mainly due to having an Ahmadiya wife in Pakistan and bigamously marrying again a British woman in Cambridge and having children with both wives. It has been reported that he was considering wife # 3 when his devastating disease was diagnosed Like many, he enjoyed his booze and British pork chops.

[@pramodvyas4862]

He received his MA in Mathematics from the Government College, University of Lahore in 1946. That same year, he was awarded a scholarship to St John's College, Cambridge, where he completed a BA degree with Double First-Class Honours in Mathematics and Physics in 1949. He went to Cambridge from undelivered Inda. He was 20 years old then.

[@javaidmahmood7561]

Very entertaining talk.?

[@saharakhatun2010]

Abdus Salam is a gift of God.. pride of Asia ❤❤

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙌

[@Lonecurious]

Interviewer ka sawal: "Jab woh paida hue 1926 ma to kiya woh Pakistan tha ya India?" (Sigh)

[@BholuUPPb]

John Bardeen won it twice, first for transistor and other one for BCS theory for superconductor

[@vijay-1]

Honest analysis

[@RavinderKumar-p5q]

Sad to hear about Dr . Salam. When Dr . Salam came to New Delhi to see prime minister Indira Gandhi then for utmost respect for Dr . Salam, Indira Gandhi made cup of tea and served to Dr . Salam.

[@moon_valley]

فزکس میں بھی 2 دفعہ مل سکتا ہے اور ڈاکٹر صاحب بہت تیزی سے اس کی طرف بڑھ رہے تھے لیکن زندگی نے وفا نہیں کی

[@sardarkhan2520]

Sorry for correction , in 1947, he was 21 years old not 13 years. Kindly do not mind it.

[@AR-yk1kv]

Religion is a personal part of a person. I think any interference in a religion unfair unfair.😢

[@shayanmahmud6832]

Let us know if you enjoyed this content!🙏

[@deepsareen1]

Great conversation; this will stay in the annals of podcasts!

[@vetdoc95]

Never ever do any good for Pakistan. The consequences will be dire as what had happened with Dr. Abdus Salam and Dr. Abdul Kadeer Khan.

[@ahmedaziz6685]

Sir As u say Dr.Salam was born 1926 n Pakistan became 1947, so at that time Dr.Salam age was 21 not 13 years Dr.Hoodbhai please caraction

[@chaitanyatuckley4666]

18:30 The professor of TD Lee and CN Yang was Subramanyam Chandrashekhar. Only two students in a course. 🇮🇳🇵🇰 took a altogether different turn.

[@nooruddinunar2019]

سائين انگريزي کي تڪليف ن ڏيو اردو استعمال ڪيو

[@kannanpothi]

Also discuss in detail how Pak made him a non Muslim

[@mem1001953]

It is high time that intelligent minds to reconsider to rewrite Quran that fits todays world. This is good for all muslims especially to Pakistan.

[@googleuser-fo7td]

it is high time you found out about your real father and not the one presented by your mother

[@mem1001953]

@@googleuser-fo7td d

[@mem1001953]

@@googleuser-fo7td no answer? Good. Your reply shows your respect to mother and a father. Allaha will take care of you.

[@usmanrahman1632]

Great conversations.

[@hdiwpodcast]

🙌

[@saeed-ur-rahman9936]

God bless you and Pakistan.

[@MushtaqHussain3335]

nice

[@jawadhider3713]

Even if he as Ahmedi was not considered a Muslim, but as a Pakistani national he had full right of safe living in his native place. The constitutional amendment didn't privide for killing of Ahmedis.

[@lynnbhatti9179]

How about Dr.Suleman Rushdi He is more popular L4all ❤Salamati Pakistan❤ ❤❤ ❤❤ ❤❤❤

[@mustanserahmad6827]

You can win nobel prize twice. John Bardeen won twice in physics. One on invention of transistor and other on developing its theory.