40 S&W Sinter Fire Special Duty vs Liberty Civil Defense testing

[@erichanson7293]

Lung shots, neck or head shots, and groin shots with either of the fragmenting rounds would be absolutely devastating. I could see a use for them in an enviroment where overpenatrating the target is not an option. Your videos and tests are well done! Thank you for sharing your tests with the rest of us.

[@NorthwoodsTesting]

Thanks! I agree there are scenarios I could see these as very useful. Residing in an apartment complex for example. Certainly would be painful.

[@richki.24]

thanks for the 40s&w testing ...

[@glennwithnell7070]

I appreciate you testing in both mediums. I don't think I would use either as long as HST exists.

[@poseidon5003]

It is said that these frangeable rounds have the best stopping power. i see why now! Wow. Deadly

[@frankhinkle5772]

Thanks for comparing them to the 180 grain HST. That puts things into perspective. And I agree, lets be pragmatic and stay with the proven JHP giving both excellent penetration but also excellent expansion. And I believe you can buy HST in 50 round boxes, which is always a little cheaper per round.

[@funwithballistics1016]

Id take Civil Defense or Sinterfire over HST imo.

[@UpstateOutdoors03]

Where can you find a 50rd box of that civil defense

[@almaadams3631]

Any mention of weight on the Sinterfire?

[@davidzimmerman7770]

So the sinter fire is not over penetrating?

[@MichaelMiller-op5sx]

Both awesome rounds I have Both the sinterfire is alot cheaper