5 Overrated NFL Free Agent Signings Of 2024 So Far…And 5 Underrated That Are Flying Under The Radar

If you’re new, Subscribe! → bit.ly/Subscribe-to-TPS
TotalProSports on Social Media:
Website: www.totalprosports.com/
Facebook: / totalprosports
Twitter: / totalprosports
Instagram: / totalprosports
For copyright matters please contact us at: [e-mail]
All images licensed through GettyImages
Host: Aaron Leger
Editor: Kyle McCormick
Writer: Alex Hoegler

[@southside1260]

Saying Calvin Ridley relied more on his speed rather than his route running is laughable

[@user-vg4vq4bf3x]

He's a route running guru but that isn't the issue the issue is what I said 50 million is already in his pocket the rest is just whatever he can so choose to not play or strike or whatever fake an injury not produce or live up to expectations 50 million is in his pockets.

[@MrWaffles-lv9wu]

Video idea: 5 washed star players, and 5 stars just getting started

[@Aunt_Tifa13]

Dak Prescott.

[@ModernMerc]

daks just on a bad team ngl. if he was on any other team he'd probably be way better@@Aunt_Tifa13

[@robertgarcia5924]

Pat Mahomes

[@12thMandalorian]

He could be both 😂

[@Arthu342]

The "fan voice" he did at the Saquon Barkley section was hilarious 😂

[@neo1343]

I think the saquon situation is kinda like the CMC one. It feels unnecessary, and he’s struggled with durability lately, but he could just become their best player on offense

[@natedeanmaan2]

Exactly. Going from a terrible team to one with the greatest potential could be a career changing thing for Barkley. The Eagles O-line is FAR BETTER than the Giants, and with all they have, Barkley won't be the only playmaker on the team.

[@shawnjohnson8675]

@@natedeanmaan2Facts.

[@Skyskwatch297]

Carolina signing Robert Hunt was strategic, I believe. They got him because of his work ethics. If Carolina is beefing up their O-line with the draft, Hunt would be a good example for them.

[@EliAlexander-yj9zx]

Video idea: The top players that came from every draft round from the past 20 years

[@12we34be]

The Panthers went out and addressed an issue that has been plaguing the team for more than a decade and they deem it as being overrated? What were they suppose to do? Go and offer a low amount to a player when it's evident the team needs the player more than the player needs the team? This one shouldn't be on the list at all

[@masterrace4005]

Pretty mediocre lineman. Thats why it’s overrated.

[@12we34be]

@@masterrace4005 You don't consider him an upgrade over what the team currently has? Who were the Panthers going to get instead of him?

[@kaseysamples8001]

I know the qb and the 2 guards and no one else on that team. 😂😂

[@adamdent9824]

People also needs to realize he is getting paid 3 million more then that lineman who went from the lions to the rams

[@jshah1961]

Yeah but Jonah was a beast for us and a Pro Bowler.

[@carlosbeard6658]

"They’re paying like he’s a top 5 wide receiver" immediately followed by "the fact the Ridley has the 9th highest average annual value…" 🤔🤔🤔

[@TBGames23BM]

I feel like no one is talking about Patrick Queen to the Steelers

[@rkooscar6866]

Over rated? Or under?

[@6speedArks]

@@rkooscar6866overrated , only reason he did good and looked good was due to roquan smith being by his side .

[@JordanO317]

@@6speedArksobviously a Steelers hater 🙄… Queen has been a feared LB since he came in the league

[@JordanO317]

I swear the Steelers just has the best off season and nobody is talking about it, 2 starting QBs, one a proven pro bowl and SB champ, the other still young. Pro bowl defender AND still have a draft

[@pauleilerman3]

Russell Wilson had a "stellar" year last year? I guess I missed that

[@wankertanker1813]

Agree. A better than the previous would be fair

[@VenomTNT]

​@wankertanker1813 that doesnt really say much though does it?🤣😅 It would have been hard not to

[@larenzowesley30]

Rebound is the keyword

[@Waddle_breaks]

I feel like the Kendall Fuller signing by the dolphins was underrated

[@nickevans7477]

Jordyn Brooks is going to be great in Miami, too!

[@Waddle_breaks]

@@nickevans7477 I agree

[@postnutclarity3105]

Poyer as well

[@Waddle_breaks]

@@postnutclarity3105 yeah, it’s just he’s on the older sign of things, but is still good

[@user-zi8nx2hm8y]

Wilkins was a great signing for the raiders your high bro

[@louilu___]

No…..he’s average

[@user-zi8nx2hm8y]

@@louilu___ look at the media. Most think this was a home run for us, I’m gonna belive them over fans who really don’t know what they are talking about since they haven’t been directly involved

[@louilu___]

@@user-zi8nx2hm8y I’m a dolphins fan I watch every game bro….he’s not a dominant lineman he’s got at what he does which is hold the point of attack and fill in his gap…and he’s a rotation guy he disappears when he’s not fresh.

[@user-zi8nx2hm8y]

@@louilu___ what about the other rushers on the dolphins? He’s paid with Maxx now did he have any other help on the D-line?

[@louilu___]

@@user-zi8nx2hm8y all I’m saying keep him fresh he’ll get you a couple run stuffs and finish up sacks maxx started but don’t think you’re getting disruptive lineman with him….think a super agile and fast big body not necessarily strong enough to move people…and not polished enough to hit you with swim/spin moves or dip his hip….he also hustle hard he always run to the ball….except 70+ tackles not 9+ sacks

[@callmecon15]

the broncos oline wasn’t “crappy”. Im pretty sure it was top 10. he just holds on the ball for to long and can’t read the middle of the field

[@Charles_Werner]

Video Idea: Before the draft you should do a video grading/ranking every NFL teams free agency

[@rxj171]

Bro wanted us to sign gabe davis instead of Ridley, when it's a 2 year 48m deal in reality with an out after 2 years and you're worrying about his age, such a casual channel LMFAO

[@callmecon15]

still an overpay

[@DarthBinky89]

If it’s a casual channel watching it makes you a…. Casual😂

[@wraynephew6838]

that is still 24 million a year. Do you think Calvin Ridley is worth more than Justin Jefferson?

[@Kong_X400]

Saquon is and was the face of the Giants franchise team. He was injured so much bc he put the team on his back all these years!

[@WeenieGOATJr]

Saquan has been wasted with the Giants, I’m not even an Eagles fan and I love the pickup. Not overrated at all for the price.

[@capitalbeanie8812]

Literally said the titans are paying Ridley like a top 5 receiver to immediately say he’s paid as the #9 average salary. The titans signings are hated ONLY because the titans got them, the media hates talking about them. Simple

[@justinwalker3112]

The point you made to discredit saquans 1k yards in each of 4 seasons he played most games in being he was the only player who could get the ball is literally backwards, if he was the only good player on offense then defenses focus on him and he still productive? Seems like you’re just biased

[@davidterry8254]

Saquon is about to be behind a o line that can block for the first time in his pro career

[@darkwulf2k]

In fairness to Barkley and his injuries, 8 games a year were at metlife. now only have to play there once, maybe twice a year might help lol!!!! Oh and don't just past Raiders D draft pics under Gruden and McDaniels. You got Pierce a former beast of a defensive player. Will be interesting to see if Wilkins provides some help for Crosby.

[@SpectacularSports21]

3:41 Didn’t know TPS was like this 💀💀💀

[@LINESNDASHES]

That Saquon take is so bad. Saquon went from worst oline to top 3 ol & was putting up superstar numbers on that horrible oline.

[@jamarvinb6252]

TPS just be saying anything without any logic or statistics behind it they’ve never been good at these list

[@monteellis4436]

I hate when y'all say "This team has never done this" without context. Asking how Clelin Ferrell draft went when that was two regimes ago with an offensive minded head coach to boot. They have AP and Marvin Lewis as the coaches of the staff now. And one was a draft pick, this is already a proven NFL player. Pretty terrible comparison. Not even saying it will work but the reasoning is stupid.

[@Eddieavina123]

Love your video TPS and keep up the great work you are awesome

[@TinyCat1015]

You literally never say ANYTHING good about the titans. You only point out the mistakes they make. All you want to do is call out that we overpayed for Ridley even though we have all the money in the world to make a contract like that. But you won’t say us signing Lloyd cushenberry is underrated who is one of the best centers in the league?

[@jackripper5270]

Ridley was the best WR to hit free agency! I think they wanted Tee Higgins? Or Mike Evans? But they never came available... Ridley was the best option on the table... 1k receiver, less than AJ Brown .. where is the mistake? I don't understand the h8? I love what the Titans are doing..

[@kyle99223]

TPS has to just look at us Titans fans and say fuck yall

[@theviskinsfan]

I don't know what I was expecting to hear when he did that silly voice, but it was hilarious. I will be waiting for that to pop up again😂

[@vinnievinnie-sj5kr]

You’re being ignorant by brininging up saquons injury history he’s missed like 5 games the last 2 years

[@rothed16]

Being a Texans fan from the start seems like we are finally doing things right. Great coach, QB, OC and GM. Future looks bright

[@thatDUDEfromMAINE]

that image of saquans ankle will haunt my dreams for some time.

[@ellegwaapo619]

Philly losing Kelce is understated, and underappreciated.

[@santiagoherrera1849]

Video idea:5 underrated vs overrated careers defined by team dynasties like someone who defined the team vs someone who maybe has multiple rings to be average in hindsight

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

As a Steelers fan this is one of the most if not the absolute BEST and underrated moves in free agency so far now that Russell Wilson is a upgrades at QB Wilson and Fields a.k.a Danger Fields😎 1:48

[@lars1303]

Greenard to the Vikings is underrated af. He is a young pass rusher who can take his game to another level

[@westDcastro]

If you think Christian Wilkins is a meh player you know NOTHING about football

[@finalflash6074]

Rams signing Jonah Jackson and Kevin Dotson was underrated. Kyren Williams went off as the starter and bringing back Dotson and adding Jackson to beef up the guard position and putting Avila at Center, this will be run first team like when we had Gurley and make us so much better in the run game to open the passing game

[@donbur1553]

Over paid

[@finalflash6074]

Not at all. To bolster an already fantastic run game

[@llama_god4880]

Every commanders signing has been underrated

[@stevegallo8483]

The two quarterbacks mentioned may not be starting for their teams by midseason. There's been a lot of talk about the Raiders trading up to get a quarterback. Plus, the Steelers traded for Justin Fields who could take the job from Russell Wilson.

[@Alexsaldivaslo]

Calvin Radley is a good wr stop playing 😢

[@user-fk1fw1jq9o]

Detroit signing pro bowl G Zietler for under 5 million a year should be up here.

[@keithclayton5255]

Steelers upgraded their qb situation with the Russ/Fields combo!

[@melanietatco1838]

8:25 one man David Tepper

[@adamdent9824]

Don't know what this is supposed to mean

[@melanietatco1838]

@@adamdent9824 the owner of the Carolina Panthers ho over pays a lot of people

[@gigabyte9584]

The Panthers are screwed with how much money they paid for an OK lineman. Could be me, but Carolina could’ve tried to use some of that to sign someone on defense or potentially a super star playmaker

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

I can't wait to watch of how Hollywood Brown will make big plays in big games in big time moments Mahomes to Brown would be really cool to see 11:20

[@zachdamenti4387]

Bears will remain as such a typical offensive line no matter how much money they offered D’Andre Swift!

[@OptimisticOilersFan]

I don’t think you know but would you rather have Bryce young get destroyed again, they are the panthers you are going to have to overpay everyone to come to Carolina, hunt is basically signing knowing he will never compete for a Super Bowl, and it’s not like Carolina wouldn’t be able to sign any of there stars because of hunts contract

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Russell Wilson is going to take them to Super Bowl Championship in 2024 Here we go Steelers here we go 2:20

[@adamdent9824]

Delusional

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Tiki Barber said that Saquon Barkley is DEAD to him in New York Giants now 2:57

[@diehardeaglesfansince1994]

The Barkley is a good signing solely because defenses will fear him no one feared Swift or sanders

[@DeCurtaRican]

I wouldn't say Russ's rebound was "stellar," but it was as good as it could have been under the circumstances. Sean Payton was working against Russ, and every coach in the league knows Payton was trying to tank. The Giants asked Russ to back up Daniel Jones??? What were THEY smoking?! Russ will be a top-5 QB this year, and I won't be at all surprised if he's #1.

[@NP148]

I think the Jacoby Brissett signing is underrated. He's not a great QB, but I wouldn't call him bad. He played well under Van Pelt in Cleveland, who is the new OC in New England and he's an upgrade from Jones

[@billhope914]

Ridley's deal was ridiculous. ty jags 4 massively raising the asking price even more by WR. smh

[@coltDagoat33]

nah saying calvin ridley is overated is crazy and saying gabe davis is better

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Thanks to Omar KHAN 2:04

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

I'll miss Mason Rudolph but Screw Trubisky and Pickett now that both of those JABRONI'S are gone 2:26

[@pleasestop7017]

Everyone was saying that Calvin was a good receiver until the titans got him and now he’s washed

[@nomadkeller8612]

most under-rated = Jerome Baker ILB by the SeaChickens

[@jeffridge3727]

Teams saw how the much better the niners got with CMC and went after RBs… there’s only one CMC tho

[@vee_del_sol]

Saquon take is trash. He wasnt added as a "thousand yard rusher." He was added as a guy that can rush for 1000, and catch out the backfield, or line up outside. Its like 2022 more evolved. Defenses will struggle knowing where the ball will go. And since hes playing behind a good o line, its fair to believe he will be able to stay healthy. Giants are trash and when Odell left, it was all Saquon. Now hes stepping into a loaded squad where he can make more impact in less touches.

[@MNfishingwiffleballandoutdoors]

As a Tennessee titans fan what star edge rushers are he talking about

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Even if Brown doesn't get a Super Bowl Ring with the Chiefs I'd say don't worry about it I really wanna see him reach the top of the mountain grabbing the Brass Ring maybe with another team but let's see how he will do with the Chiefs for now in 2024 season 12:00

[@TheMILVSCR]

Ridley was so good for us, and the punishment for betting pretty much ruined him. I was so ready to see him be our WR1 and fill the void that Julio would leave... just sad now.

[@isiahbarfield5]

As a jags fan this guy has no idea what he’s talking about, he said calvin relies on speed more than his route tree to get open which couldn’t be more wrong

[@Engineers1985]

I LOVE the moves the Texans have made! They’re starting to look pretty scary on paper AND in Real Life 😮‍💨

[@dpan97]

What about the fact the Giants had an awful oline during Barkley tender? Leading to ineffectiveness and higher chances for injuries.

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Kirk Cousins signing to the Falcons should be a Underrated move right now cause you got new coach Raheem Morris everything on offense is moving to a positive direction cause you are now the team to beat in the NFC South but don't forget Falcons do hold the 8th pick here so you wanna take a defensive player or a offensive player? Well it's up to the Atlanta to decide come draft day April 25th to 27th at the moment 12:12

[@Z_Rodriguez13]

I get what you’re saying but it is an older Kirk off a torn Achilles think that’s why you can’t say underrated

[@stephenjablonski3261]

He list Jerry Jeudy as a better option than Calvin Ridley. The very next segment said the broncos didn't have a 1000-yard receiver. So Ridley is 1000 yard receiver and Jeudy is not.

[@heyohalo]

I love how TPS spins videos to arouse fan bases

[@TimFieldsJrMedia]

Yall were hating on Saquon can’t even lie

[@mawile2468]

All the Running Backs. Big name RB acquisitions NEVER work. The only exceptions I can think of are Christian McCaffrey, and Marshawn Lynch back in the day

[@Johnny82Utah]

Agree with the thumb. Way overpay for Ridley.

[@goldfish1786]

Lmao your take on saquon to the eagles is horrid, usually your pretty fair but that was bad

[@ryaneugenelawrencewalls1987]

Marquise Hollywood Brown going to Kansas City Chiefs Underrated cause once upon a time he was a 1st Rounder by the Ravens coming out of the University of Oklahoma Sooners but in his rookie season his debut vs Dolphins he'd had 2 touchdowns and 150 receiving yards at the time but they won the game he finished with a 14-2 record in 2019 but kept in mind Hollywood Brown has played with 3 Heisman Trophy Winners Baker Mayfield and Kyler Murray at OU then Lamar Jackson with the Ravens but he went to Arizona to reunit with Murray but now he'll be playing with Mahomes in Kansas City let's just hope for the better that Brown will be a better player catching DEEP Bombs from Mahomes and hopefully Brown is gonna win his 1st Super Bowl Championship too Good Luck Hollywood Brown 11:04

[@TNSportz]

Did you really just say “Ridley relies on his speed, more than his route running” 😂. That is 🧢 sir!

[@smithronnie20]

Idk who’s running this channel but they clearly don’t know nothing

[@gmasglizzy5488]

I swear each time I listen to a TPS video I lose more respect for their opinions

[@Jadon-hs3kb]

Same

[@paulshwag8053]

The fact that his guy called saquon overrated and failed to mention that he played behind a historically bad O line his whole career shows me he knows absolutely nothing about football

[@andrewbabrowicz4526]

no you're just a delusional eagles fan. barkley is washed

[@Woodstodaface]

Man im not paying all that money for a rb that can never finish a full season

[@DaddyTankGod]

@@Woodstodafacedon’t forget how many injuries happen at net life with that crappy turf they use. He only has to play at net life once a year now

[@paulshwag8053]

@@Woodstodaface prime Walter Payton would be shit behind that line .

[@paulshwag8053]

@@andrewbabrowicz4526 prime Walter Payton would be shit behind that line

[@RiVer-Parish]

Do a video about what is wrong with Washington's franchise😢😢.

[@Viltronic]

How is a 3yr 24M deal an overpay for a RB? That’s 8M/year that’s not bad at all, them mfers wanted 15-16M a year not too long ago

[@PILLAGINGJUST4FUN]

Hating on the Raiders? What about the Khalil mack draft or maxx crosby ? Nate Hobbs? Amik Robertson? Malcom koonce? MOEHRIG?! and u said we were 9th in scoring, looks like raiders know how to deal with defense now.

[@FEL_Official]

3:40 💀

[@mythicul]

What was that😂 3:40

[@laserxman779sports]

Underrated josh jones Baltimore ravens after losing both Morgan Moses and John Simpson to the jets Baltimore signed ex Houston offensive lineman josh jones to make the pass blocking better for Lamar Jackson and for Derek Henry

[@jenniferpratt3007]

Everyone’s thoughts on Hip-Drop rule and how it will affect he game?

[@SteveWhite-wv2wk]

Two hand touch football by 2030, just you wait. Lmfao I'm just glad that I can watch games from the 1970's and the 1980's, when the violence was glorified, as it should.

[@Saucelight88]

Bobby wanger signing is underrated too me u still got alot left in the tank

[@BallCapHalo4]

I could see Eric Krendricks have a better season with the Cowboys! It won't be miles better! But better! I see that by reuniting with Mike Zimmer!

[@chrisfreimiller4878]

Honestly arent all the players overrated and over payed to play a childs game.

[@milosbrkanovic948]

Swift is better than all those guys and he was solid on the lions while splitting carries. I wouldn’t say overrated .

[@thomasgarrett7990]

TPS always hating on the bears because it's the bears lol

[@kumlikeitspromnight2342]

They said despite a stellar year to start lmao

[@williambozek5458]

I think TPS hates the Bears I bet TPS gonna say trading for Keenan Allen was the worst offseason move this year

[@TheSid2355]

Wilson was a dud signing. Wilkins was a beast signing. Pairing him with Maxx will guarantee Wilkins will finish with double digit sacks.

[@olszewski422ify]

I want to know when tps got smarter than NFL gm. You say you don't have to pay for RBs anymore, yet every RB was paid well.

[@kidd_sports_101]

what about Chase Young and Willie Gay?

[@theMF16-26]

Must of the underrated signings made since,but a lot of the overrated didn’t.TPS looked to much at the money and not the impact or filling of a need.Sometimes teams have a ton of money and they are willing to overpay because it fills a crucial need.

[@theantiwokereviewer]

They are desperate to kiss the Chiefs’ ass. Marquise Brown is ok at best, and will not fix their shit receiver core

[@SomeRandomParticle]

No Bryce Huff is wild

[@OftnCghn]

How the heck does wr get paid so much? They touch the ball maybe 8 times on 12 targets. Poor RB's they catch the ball roughly that n carry the ball 15 + times.

[@qmoneythebest5306]

You going to eat your words with Saquon Barkley watch

[@SteveWhite-wv2wk]

Underrated Jacoby Brissett by the Patsies, imho. Overrated could be Queen from the Ravens. Could be...

[@kenison8170]

Now I know why the dolphins let hunt and wilkins go. They certainly was overrated but hats off to them because other teams was more than willing to pay these overrated guys big bucks. The person to me who deserves Big bucks is Tua and I hope the dolphins don’t blow it?

[@Jimmy2Guns]

10:16 A guy with zero pro bowls 😂😂😂 Christian Wilkins is a game wrecker. The man all been productive and he just had 9 sacks 😮 U worry about the wrong shii

[@stephenjablonski3261]

What? A steller year with the Denver broncos. Is that why he was benched? Because of his steller year? Russel Wilson has been terrible for three years. It doesn't matter the weapons or coach.

[@lambert581]

Underrated Patrick Queen to the Steelers