64 Netaji Files To Be Declassified : The Newshour Debate (18th Sep 2015)

In a debate moderated by TIMES NOW's Editor-in-Chief Arnab Goswami, panelists -- GVL Narasimha Rao, National Spokesperson, BJP; Ardhendu Bose, Nephew of Netaji Subash Chandra Bose; Chandra Kumar Bose, Grandnephew of Netaji Subash Chandra Bose; Anuj Dhar, Author & RTI Activist; Sharmistha Mukherjee, Spokesperson, Congress; Prof. Mridula Mukherjee, Professor Modern History, JNU -- discuss the West Bengal Govt releasing 64 secret documents on Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose, one of the files revealing that his family was snooped upon, and whether it is time for the the Centre to declassify the 130 files it has since the mystery regarding Netaji's disappearance remained unresolved in the last 70 years.
Subscribe to NewsHour Debate | Click Here ► goo.gl/LfNgFF
‘Download the official TIMES NOW mobile app - Give a missed call on 1800 4190 300. Stay updated, stay ahead.’
Subscribe Now To Our Network Channels
ET Now : goo.gl/5XreUq
Times Now : goo.gl/U9ibPb
To Stay Updated Download the Times Now App :-
Android Google Play : goo.gl/zJhWjC
Apple App Store : goo.gl/d7QBQZ
Social Media Links :-
Twitter - goo.gl/FzJIpz
Facebook - goo.gl/CC7rGc
G+ - goo.gl/O1iEp5
Also visit our website - goo.gl/XPUXe8

[@vivacious4284]

If Congress comes to power again. They will destroy most of the files with Central Govt. So BJP should declassify without anymore delay. In free India was treated like terrorist and traitor instead of being honoured. This is unacceptable for any self respected Indian.

[@shaliniadarshsingh9455]

+Blue and Green it already has been in 1972..mukherjee committee report..i think only a bollywood movie can intensify the demand at world devel..to expose the congi dolts..

[@nikhil4utube]

+Viswadeep Das I agree with you...history needs to be re-written and the role of our hero Subhas Chandra Bose be highlighted, along with the conspiracy of Nehru-Gandhi family...BJP is the only party that can do it.

[@johnmathew5464]

Dnt worry they will declassify in the next assembly election u guys have lots patience

[@pabitranandan3114]

Afrer two years BJP gov also silent.shame

[@adarshguptak]

Motilal Nehru to Rahul Gandhi, can we just undo them from Indian history? :(

[@johnmathew5464]

u can invent a another GODHSE ,u r good at enlighting dead brains

[@praveensinha9674]

@@johnmathew5464 and u r just another poop.

[@subrataranjandalui6387]

Thank you ARDHENDU SIR

[@subrataranjandalui6387]

Thanks you mr. Anuj

[@subrataranjandalui6387]

THANKS ARNAB DA

[@mohammadzubayer8084]

A Big Salute to Beloved Great Leader Natajee Subhas Chandra Bose,Sheik Mujibur Rahman Father of The Nation of Bangladesh kept his words to Give Freedom to his Bangali People,Bangla vasha Kotha Boli amar preyo Bangladesh.Opar Bangla vaider Jonnao royelo sarodio Durga Pujar Suveccha.

[@hai7a]

kick nehru family out of the politics

[@HariKSamineni]

What a rubbish, Sarmistha Mukherjee, shoutng from the roof top to "Declassified the Nehru files". Why the hell Congress declassify it ??? Can you answer Ms.Mukherjee ???

[@SURJO12]

Look at the enthusiasm of Arnab !!

[@ratulsengupta6388]

Are you saying this sarcastically??

[@subrataranjandalui6387]

I SALUTE YOU MR.ANUJ

[@DaSnipy]

the old so called historian got exposed SO HARD. .. LET TRUTH PREVAIL .. SATYAMEVA JAYATE.

[@ajaymittal5239]

+DaSnipy: Woh toh, shakl soorat se badmash dikthi hai.

[@shashanks4903]

Both Mukherjee's are being killed royally ......Damn !

[@zorosama5744]

+Shashank S bro,why the nazi symbol? Instead use swastika.

[@shashanks4903]

It will be surely changed bro......i appreciate the suggestion .

[@amicoz]

I kept laughing at this lady Sharmistha Mukherjee... she is too nervous. She does not have ANY insight.. but I must admit, she shouts very well.. :) And simple question is if Congress is NOW wanting the files to be declassified why didn't Congress do it when they were in power??

[@sanandadey6333]

If the Government's of India (since independence) are accepting Netaji as Patriotic Son and not as a war criminal, then why the governments are not declassifing the files? Where is the problem?

[@sayantanchowdhury5650]

the person who has sacrificed so much for this country is now and was always being a victim of heinous politics....seriously feeling so sad for Subhash Chandra Bose - the true hero of this nation...

[@manishneb2099]

Father of nation SUBHASH CHANDRA BOSE. Jai hind

[@amitdudeja1981]

अखण्ड भारत के पहले प्रधानमंत्री नेताजी सुभाषचंद्र बोस जी को शत शत नमन 🙏🚩🚩🚩🇮🇳🇮🇳 मेरी जिंदगी का कतरा कतरा मैं नेताजी के नाम करता हूं शर्मीठा मुखर्जी तुम शर्म से डूब मरो भगवान जी उर्फ गुमनामी बाबा ही नेता जी थे मैं अनुज धर का समर्थन करता हूं ओर अगर मोदी जी ने यह क्लियर नहीं किया तो जिंदगी में बीजेपी को सपोर्ट नहीं करूंगा जय हिन्द जय श्री राम जय श्री श्याम जय हिन्द फौज 🚩🚩🚩🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@adarshguptak]

Don't even mention Vadra and Netaji in the same sentence.. LOL, that's a good one, Arnab!

[@shaliniadarshsingh9455]

hope lies fed to us discontinues...also before nehru many other theories such as aryan-dravidian theories and other and so called benevolent invaders after 1000 ce in india gets there true place..history needs to be written..a lover of edvina mountbaitein can not be lover of childrens..i will not call such a person as my chacha..neither celebrate bal diwas..

[@drewtocrewoffense5082]

@35.45 - 37.00 .... GVL Narsimha Rao almost put Mrudula Mukherjee into coma

[@sanjaybose7193]

Subhash Bose was a natural leader at that time of 40's. what people had done If; he returned india?....what we taught in school was false,...british left india coz of INA (indian national army),...26,000 INA soldiers died ....n history written as India Got independence by Non-Violence....................................Subhash Bose was People's great leader, his speech electrified with enormous crowd (listen his speeches in internet) ... & pandit nehru was leader of a party...so nehru murdered him.....................................NO ISSUE,...NOW WE HAVE NARENDRA MODI & WAIT; WE WILL RE-WRITE THE HISTORY AGAIN

[@nit23sharma]

In Delhi ..you can't even solve a small traffic issue with non voilence....but the dumbos sitting in Delhi want us to believe that the British empire just packed up and left because they were afraid of our 'non voilence'.......we should send the congress party to Iraq & Afghanistan to fight ISIS and Taliban with non voilence to prove their theory...... whatever may be the result...it will be good for india

[@debasishchakraborty4196]

Watching this kind of debate our blood boils. It's so far good for Congress party only 64 files are declassified.. I guess if all comes out over time..BJP don't have to struggle much to decimate Congress.. it will be buried under soil forever..:)

[@chandrasahoo4878]

True of death of Hon'ble Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose should be disclosed in front of National and International as it is last 70 Years past in a unknown date for celebration as a National & International Neta for all

[@shivethvan]

hi Arnab, nice one again... but Arnab, I m very much interested to know about the case of DK Ravi's mysterious death... As you promised on a earlier debate I presume you are following that particular case.

[@aniketaggarwal1224]

23:30 Worst will be that Netaji was alive and was tortured in some Bunker by British with congress involved in getting Bose caught . And then Bose having an escape but to be recaught and starved or beaten or dosed with drugs / infections / poison to death

[@jaankush]

Netaji is the greatest freedom fighter a True Legend Hats off to you Netaji. Nehru n Gandhi's constantly distorted the history . Real disgrace the Gandhi's the Congress and Nehru

[@MrHINDNIK]

true brother Netaji was truly great along with so many like sardar patel, rajendra prasad, BHagat singh, gk gokhale and many many more and far better than opputunists congress and gandhi nehru families...the traitors.

[@banikaur5157]

The heroes of this debate are Bose brothers and Anuj Dhar.

[@aniketaggarwal1224]

31:00 Galois was not a trained mathematician but did immense contribution to mathematics before he was killed in a dual fight at age of 21 . You don't have to be trained to be a prodigy or an expert on certain matter . Training is only to make research easy but it doesn't guarantee that trained will do full justice to the subject

[@SAFFRONINFERNO]

HAHAHHAHA The look on Mridula Mukherjee's face on being shown the TOI link exposing her duplicity.Filthy Congress keep

[@johnmathew5464]

Filthy fake CHAAL of bjPEE

[@mysoreshekarmgc]

We are feed with wrong history for all these years..Let Truth prevail ...

[@tomhanks2461]

the ending 1 min was epic

[@Arunava_Sar]

Netaji a legend freedom fighter Netaji our great nation hero Jai Hind ❤️🙏

[@anandkrishan9054]

Arnab, this one is the best I liked one..

[@raaas2050]

just loved it.

[@kutty1234]

NEHRU IS A VILLAN

[@JoshiA0212]

NEHRU WAS THE LAST COLONIAL RULER OF INDIA!

[@stylishsannigrahi]

Please some one stop congress spoke persons..They are ridiculous man!!!

[@kuttyghosh1406]

Jai hind rashtrapita devatma Netaji subhashchandra Bose Amar rahe Amar rahe we love you Netaji

[@biswapriyokarmakar3341]

so sad

[@vishalsingh273]

we are happy to know,truth will come out..now we are living in independent Bharat,/// chor Nehru. mukerjee madam...suna bhi karo...chiilane se sach nhi chupega

[@Abhishekkumar0379]

like the smile of anuj dhar whem Miss Mukherjee is being destroyed..

[@DrAbdulwadoodQureshi]

See regarding Nata ji subhash Bose 👇👇👇👇👇

[@bytas7428]

Its a shame Congress exist...

[@siboprasadde6145]

This sharmishtha n mridula both are having very thick skin. They both are the spoon feeder by gandi-nehru familis

[@banikaur5157]

We need the truth of what happened to Netaji.

[@anandkrishan9054]

Congress chamchas --- It is shame on all of us...!!

[@Narsimham-xz3os]

nehru family curse on india. ran after pm post .

[@sanmendeep555]

Sharmistha is shouting to declassify the files..Then why didnt her Congress regime declassify the said files? As Mr. Arnendu bose told i fear that lot of files may have been destroyed by the royal party of india..

[@subhajitbanerjee3773]

After the Trinamul Govt. exposing the Files of Netaji, the Central Govt. is under pressure, but Modi is a great Opportunist, perhaps he will wait for the right time (Say before some election) before publishing some of the files . All these Politicians are only interested in Vote banks and their own benefit. Even if they are literate and scholar that does not stop them to be more Selfish and more Greedy.

[@somnathparui2460]

Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose Great Freedom Fighter

[@neeratron]

Holy fuck Anuj Dhar kicked some serious ass!!!

[@HariKSamineni]

I'm shocked to know that in 2007 Congress said that they do not have enough evidence to prove that Netaji Bose took active part freedom struggle.

[@bibekghatak5860]

I do not agree with Ms. Mridula Mukherjee .Any distortion must be castigated in strong terms .

[@arunkumarmukherjee9466]

It is not understood what kind of shameless defend or Support for Surveillance of Netaji 's family which was conducted by Congress Govt and Key man was Pd. Neheru . It is nothing but only to cover up the mischief & sub press the "Truth". All contemporary leaders are equal responsible.in this sensible issue. Mrs. Sharmistha Mukherjee , Did you know why order was issued not to display photo of Netaji in Govt Building?

[@sajidsohail748]

This is just another foolish debate, nothing new came up, no conclusions, no new information.....first have debate on Information from revealed files. I don't want to hear nonsense, I want truth of a great leader

[@shaliniadarshsingh9455]

+Sajid Sohail info from the file is that nehru snopped bose family for 20 years till his wife died..and that was the debate

[@shivayashutosh798]

THE BEST PART OF THIS DEBATE WAS THE REPARTEE OF ARNAB WHICH WAS STaRTED AT 26th MINUTES .. #_awesome_arnab

[@evaamas7801]

Narsimsha Rao i am Kishor Rao Release the file forget review i want my NAMO to release the file immediately

[@ManojKumar-hz1vx]

nehru gdaar

[@evaamas7801]

its High time Release the file

[@narenjain8924]

It may be too late to dig out the truth as also the master mind in then ruling government to whom Bristish handed over the power and since then clinging to power

[@steelnerve762]

congress spokespersons are getting long due drumming these days... slowly the skeletons from past are coming in the open... cheers democracy !

[@sheetalpriyagatphoh1083]

paid historian talk..

[@mysoreshekarmgc]

Its pathetic to see the congress spokesperson... Look the behaviour, will tell many things to us..

[@YohesvaranRam]

What is holding back of of the files is of any benifit to BJP

[@PremKumar-ke5oy]

Like Neta Ji Subhash Chandra bos revolutionary ( person) hiden by the Congress government on time of Pt. Neharu it is a matter of shame to whole Congress leaders and volunteers.

[@aathisokkar3152]

1. The whole world still today believe that Nethaji Subash Chandra Bose died in aircraft fire accident. 2. But that's not true at all. It's all just picturised. 3. A Swamiji whose name is Aadhi Sokkar from South Tamilnadu (India) strongly says that his body is burried at Kodukku Mountain in Theni District (Tamilnadu). 4. He has also got the proof for his saying. His funeral took place on 3rd September 1945. 5. Actual death day of Subash Chandra Bose is 3.9.1945. But it is recorded as 18 August 1945. That's not the correct one. 6. World war-I (28 July 1914 to 11 November 1918. 7. World war-II (1 September 1939 to 2 September 1945 - 6 years and 1 day) Here the one day seems to be the primary one because on that day only he died i.e 3.9.1945. 8. All this incidents have been recorded in a file and now it is under the custody of British Government. Now Swamiji is asking the britishers Can you deny my saying?

[@evaamas7801]

Mridula Mukerjee and historians like her are shame to humanity about shamishta i can understand being a congress women and is not concerned about our country

[@swatitambe4322]

We don't trust bullshit on this international relations... Problem is inside.... We r not telling you to prepare files we r just asking for open the file... 60years to just open the files....

[@WWHTechSpace]

The best part was 25th minute Arnub just tearing the skin of Nehru.... who was not even a well appreciated in congress group before the 1947. Just read history.... don't follow school books....

[@dhruba1975]

Sarmistha is the representative of Nehru family.

[@zorosama5744]

lol hardcore congress family at 25:30

[@siboprasadde6145]

Mr. Arnab Goswami i really want to thank u heartly because u brought wonderful debate for viewers of all over indian n abroad. I must congratuate for that. I have observed whenever u brought such topics on discussion the CONGRESS paneled people wheather they are Historians or Sookesperson's from Nehru-Gandi family or i can say pimp of these two family they do not even bother or allowed to speak any paneled member's of dt bebate. They are all simply SHAMELess Creatures. They doesn't even learnt the simple Courtesy even when a person talks these guys has to keep their mouth close. They donot allowed other people to talk. They deleberately speak of their learned speech by GANDI NEHRU family.

[@jaankush]

shame of Congress shame on the Gandhi's and Mr Nehru

[@stymarkojindal1512]

Sir,this debate should be hindi

[@nagarajangadi3972]

shame on this lady defending their party inspite of having such clear evidence from intelligence department

[@prabhatthakur8250]

Indira gandhi has done a big ugly crime of distroying netaji files modi stop doing politics and for god sake realise all files of netaji

[@prabhatthakur8250]

What about Anderson report mr modhi you are doing politics

[@smithsonsunny5918]

this debate is very one sided and has been given an upper hand to BJP. we should find the actual reason why the Congress government did what they did. there is no point on debating things like this. if teh congress has done something wrong let them answer it. well if Netaji didnt die why didnt he come back to INDIA and why was he hiding in other places.

[@MrHINDNIK]

Because if he would have come back the british and their congress brothers in india would have him and his family killed as they considered him and his family to b terrorists. INA TREASURE and political power of the bose family and his image as a lion and true liberator of the country alongwith his good and respectable relationship with so many avoided or deleted greats and fighters like lala lajpat ray, vallabhai patel, rajendra prasad and many more were very good and they would hv made him the prime minister or head of state and congress would have never survived. it was a political assassination of netaji and his legacy. theres lot more reasons these r just some of it. NO OFFENCE BUT Dont u know anything or just a blind stooge of congress and its distasteful lineage and legacy. NETAJI ZINDABAAD JAI HIND JAI BHARAT

[@shaliniadarshsingh9455]

+Sayan Moitra nehru feared for his post..he lost 1930 pres election of congress badly..only after blackmailing of gandhi to congress members he was elected pres..but if u see bose won 1938,1939 pres election even when gandhi was opposite to him..he won in 1939 ,,such was his stature even greater than gandhi i think if not equal..we have been fed wrong history...

[@MrHINDNIK]

+Adarsh Singh True brother,,, people dont understand the kind of supreme sacrifice great sons of india like Netaji made. he was not a crook or hungry for power they had only one thing in mind poorna swaraj. Nehru and congress feared him a lot as he knew the party is corrupted and wanted India to b a weak nation always. He was an imminent danger to the corrupt congress power who rewrote history as per their convinience and fooled the nation. The legacy of congress and gandhis must be removed for poorna swaraj now.

[@shaliniadarshsingh9455]

nehru just got saved gandhi appointed him as pm in 1947 although 1st election took in 1952..by then patel already died,rajendra was made pres(aaram posting)..bose sent to russia jail..gandhi died,ambedkar painted as dalit leader..that's why nehru became a big leader in presence those dwarf leaders of those times..after independence his image building started in india..that megalomaniac character while being in pm office gave himself bharat ratna ..while discarding same to patel who got in 1992,ambedkar in 78 and many others such that he cant be dwarfed in front of them..also this character while being alive documented awards,parks,universities in his name..and kept a company of sycophant historians hust like kings do..

[@subrataranjandalui6387]

MISS SARMISTHA YOU ARE KALANKA OF BENGAL

[@chinmoysarkar4786]

Howler (sharmistra)

[@republicmediakarnataka.online]

congress should not be admitted to Court , Public and defense personality , should get together and punish congress fired and hanged to death , no one should be spared , for what they did with India and Indians , for making communal clash and killings

[@nikhil4utube]

look at how pissed and defensive this lady sharmishtha mukherjee and that dumb historian mridula mukherjee have gotten...truth will come out anyways...count your days Congress...you and the great "Nehru" are going to be exposed!!

[@subrataranjandalui6387]

. MISS SHARMISTHA MUKHERJEE YOU TOLD LIE