If I lost 95 watts Id brag that I once had 95 watts
@ldakotatransplant64853 ай бұрын
After watching this video I decided to put it to the test myself and can with absolute certainty say you are 100% correct! When I adjusted the front tire pressure I gained 5 watts in Zwift!
@pompeymonkey32713 ай бұрын
lol
@powerbastion10833 ай бұрын
hoohoohoo
@fylbike3 ай бұрын
😂😂😂
@cotillion16873 ай бұрын
What about the rear?
@ldakotatransplant64853 ай бұрын
@@cotillion1687 It's flat, leaning up against the wall. 🤣Bike is attached to my Tacx Neo trainer.
@insanecomicdude3 ай бұрын
My main takeaway here is that, on tarmac, running the wrong pressure is only going to cost me up to about 3 watts, so I don't really need to be too precious with my tire pressure for everyday riding. Great vid, Ollie!
@davidzof3 ай бұрын
I tested this myself and agree that there isn't a huge difference over a wide range of pressures: kzbin.info/www/bejne/rXOToGSdebp7bpIfeature=shared
@deDANIEL116093 ай бұрын
but it will fuck up your comfort?
@mattshipstone93613 ай бұрын
Equally swapping tyre width doesn't really make much difference. I got 28s rather than 30s because they were on sale. Looks like the right choice!!
@jbstepchild3 ай бұрын
Long term 100km ride that 3 watts is gonna show in time an pace but no matter
@billincolumbia3 ай бұрын
Great summary. We don't need super accurate gauges. Just get the tire at a pressure that gives you the most comfortable ride, and know that it's not costing you more than a couple of watts,
@joe2mercs3 ай бұрын
This whole exercise revisits the concept of Dunlop. He invented the pneumatic tyre at a time when tyres were solid. The result was a faster and more comfortable ride. Very high pressure pneumatic tyres effectively revert back to behaving like solid tyres. As with any suspension system the principle is to maintain tread contact with the surface being travelled over and this means keeping unsprung weight to a minimum whilst maintaining a well damped but highly compliant travel.
@jackofalltrades93933 ай бұрын
I just have to thank you for using the word "damped" instead of "dampened". It's amazed how many engineers these days say "dampened". Buy hey, both words are correct, like nuclear and nucular. Yeah...no.
@Orgakoyd14 сағат бұрын
@@jackofalltrades9393 Or libery...
@Stefano-cz6bo3 ай бұрын
As a mechanical engineer, I would welcome a next GCN video with an interview to the designer of this test rig. Some of the questions I would suggest are: 1 - only the rear wheel sits on the drum, whilst in the real case both wheels roll over the road, how do you factor in the resistance from the front wheel? 2 - How do you estimate the power loss? The only viable way I see is to get it as the difference between the power input by the cyclist at the cranks and the resisting power at the drum. However, when we talk of a resistance as small as 20 W, the accuracy of the two powermeters becomes crucial. Ollie: it's not a matter of the sampling frequency (Hz) that matters, it's rather the accuracy of the sensors. If the accuracy is 1% of the range and the range is, say, 2000 W, or maybe even just 1000, it's AT LEAST 10 W uncertainty at each one of the two powermeters, so the total uncertainty is more or less the same as the power loss to be measured, for the good tyre at least. 3 - again assuming the power loss is obtained from the difference between the power input at the cranks and the resistance at the drum, do you remove the effect of the aerodynamic resistance arising from the rotation of the drum?
@ericd_br3 ай бұрын
Silverstone uses the Body Rocket pedals, which are accurate to 0.1% across the functional range. So Ollie shouldn’t have been dropping those 1 watt claims at the end, but otherwise he was OK.
@OUTDOORS553 ай бұрын
The cycling world is full of claims with these exact questions. When you question them they just say you're too stupid to understand the testing procedures. We have a word for it down south, its called snake oil.
@samuelebressan36763 ай бұрын
My guess by looking at how the bike is fixed at the fork is that the measurement is done at the front hub, by how much the whole bike is pulled backward by the rolling in-efficiency, which is generated then by the sum of rolling resistance, drivetrain resistance and a small other factors probably neglectable…
@benbrindle81653 ай бұрын
Literally minute 3-6 explains all this. Fml. Most of what you’re writing has already been well known a long time. They change one variable at a time which gives the difference. The whole system is measured and they are not using commercially available power meters - it’s lab grade transducers and strain gauges. By the 7 minute point this is all apparent. It’s as good a system of tests you’re getting. It’s not a wind tunnel. It’s simply for the non-aero factors.
@Pastamistic3 ай бұрын
I would assume that they're just trying to gather data for comparisons. Even though it's not a perfect test relative to real world riding the rolling resistance data comparisons between different pressures and tires should remain true.
@l.d.t.63273 ай бұрын
17:00 you shouldn't forget that tires at 2 bar tend to drift much more in corners. The testing rig, while very well designed, doesn't take this into account. And don't forget that while you're not bottoming out on that test rig, pro riders in a peloton, hitting a rock at 55k/hr, will have a much higher chance bottoming out.
@einundsiebenziger54883 ай бұрын
I understood it that when you lose 95 Watts at four bar, you lose "another" 74 Watts at two bar, meaning in 169 Watts in total. Totally agree that 2 bars only worked in this specific lab set-up. On the road it would feel all squishy, your tyres would slip away when cornering even at low speed and the tiniest bump would make the rim hit the road surface.
@jameshisself73753 ай бұрын
Agree. I love to corner very hard and I always preferred a higher pressure just to keep the tires from feeling like they were rolling off the edge of the rim. Straight and flat efficiencies are good to know but the world is a lot more dynamic than that.
@MrTandtrollet3 ай бұрын
Yeah, conrnering with low pressures is how you end up in a ditch!
@zperdek3 ай бұрын
@@einundsiebenziger5488No it's only 74w at 2 bars. We shouldn't forget that tire is air pillow. High pressure makes it sturdier and bouncier while lower pressure makes it softer and floatier. If you go through rough terrain do you want to float over rocks and sticks or do you wanna bounce on them?
@joeshmoe79673 ай бұрын
@@MrTandtrollet Especially on the front. You can ride out a back end slide, but a front end wash out, can leave you picking debris out of your face. LOL
@kunzworld23093 ай бұрын
Ollie at his best. Totally geeking out about the test machine and its results. And me? Glued to the screen and just loving it!
@joeuser23603 ай бұрын
Not only is Ollie at his best, he is the best GCN staffer for this kind of data intensive tech testing.
@-Demis-3 ай бұрын
I'm under a lot of pressure, but I'm still rolling with it! 🚴♂️
@DetroitJohnny3 ай бұрын
This is the comment I was looking for. Congratulations!
@user-nu5fx6en9h3 ай бұрын
Congrats then 😂
@SoulClubCoffee3 ай бұрын
must be rather tiring
@Gugner3 ай бұрын
😅😅😅
@gcntech3 ай бұрын
Not the most efficient, though
@rolandmg13 ай бұрын
This is a really interesting subject and as an engineer I find the test rig set up fascinating. I agree with lower pressures being more efficient on a rough surface but in a real life situation which includes climbing, sprinting and descending I don't concur. I'm in the Alps presently running Vittoria Corsa 28mm tubulars on Dura Ace 28mm wide rims and set the pressures to the Silca calculator which was 5.4 / 5.25 for my weight 72kg. This is great on the valley roads but climbing out of the saddle was too bouncy and descending and cornering fast around the hairpins was sketchy as the back tyre was slipping. Yesterday I increased the pressure to my normal 6.2 / 5.8 and the bike felt like it was on rails cornering and climbing felt so much more efficient. I know it's difficult to replicate these conditions on the rig but the results are a good starting point but everyone should tweak them for the terrain and conditions.
@joeshmoe79673 ай бұрын
I am very wary running too low on fronts. Back slipping is bad enough but I have had near wash out of the front when i had a leak that was dropping the front pressure until it was scary in the corners. I had to stop and pump back up until home. Downhill into a hard corner on soft fronts is not fun. I think the data is interesting, but point to finding ones best balance of f actors. - Cheers
@vo2maximus1773 ай бұрын
To my knowledge, Pogačar routinely rode 30mm Conti tyres on fat, tall Enve aero rims for this year's Tour win. Although his body weight is very low which makes that counter-intuitive, of course his average speed is a lot higher, plus the aero gains when he attacks off the front become far more significant with that combination. Re: your comments about best tyre pressures on cobbles Olly, don't forget that most of Paris-Roubaix is ridden on tarmac or concrete slab, so the tyre pressures the Pros ride are necessarily a compromise between the rolling resistance on all those surfaces. Finally, of course we all wince at the thought of 70s Pros riding 23mm tyres in the very same race, but then they rode skinny, very shallow aluminium sprint rims for tubs, and there'd have been a lot of deflection and shock absorption going on within those rims, plus much looser spoking, also the forgiving steel frames and forks of the time. But for sure, the ride would have been harsher. Nice piece though Olly, fellow Physics nerd here!
@prestachuck28673 ай бұрын
He rode 28mm tires this year. Last year he rode 30s on the road and 32mm for tt.
@vo2maximus1773 ай бұрын
What did he ride for TTs this year?@@prestachuck2867
@therider49093 ай бұрын
Flexy rims and steel frames might reduce a bit of road buzz but there's absolutely no way they'd soften something as significant as Roubaix cobbles. Pogacar's tyre pressure is not really relevant to recreational riders doing half the speed at best. It's like comparing an F1 driver's tyre choice to the cheap rubber for my 1.2 litre hatchback.
@vo2maximus1773 ай бұрын
I disagree over the steel frames/forks and thin aluminium flexy rims, as well as the much looser spoking from those times. These would all, together, have had a softening effect on cobbles, although not as much as the much larger tyres used these days. I'm just making the point that you can't simply compare tyres now and then, its not that simple. The entire bike "system" was different, you take it as a whole. Modern carbon fibre bikes can be made with more flex, but for big, instant impacts steel is very absorbent. And Pogačar's tyre pressure IS relevant to me. I ride a Colnago, I ride Schwalbe Pro One Tubeless 30mm, and although I'm in my mid-60s I can still average Evens on my own, and faster in a group. I get the same big tyre benefits as him, with perhaps 0.5 bar higher pressure because I'm fatter than he is, but I get those same rolling resistance gains. He'll of course get more from them aero gains than me, because he goes a lot faster than me. Thanks. @therider4909
@RevoltingRudi3 ай бұрын
they also rode 13-15c rims and Tyre stood over the rims. now 19C-21C and sindewall are very straight.
@richardclinker8133 ай бұрын
I dropped my pressures to 4.5 bar front, 5 bar rear 28mm and did a ride past Silverstone. For me, no faster but felt a lot nicer, easier. By the way. Have also been experimenting with a thin layer of talc between butyl inner tube and tyre casing to see if that reduces internally induced rolling resistance. I think it might do...
@ronsorrell778913 күн бұрын
why not switch to tubeless?
@kidShibuya3 ай бұрын
Might want to change the title. I thought this was a clickbait type video with nothing useful, but I watched when I saw the runtime and I am glad I did, always love good testing.
@space.youtube3 ай бұрын
So the title is NOT click bait, but because you thought it was they should change it? Wouldn't that make the new "changed" title click bait to attract people who mistakenly think the original title is click bait? lol
@elgrego3 ай бұрын
I second this,. This was the only time the title is less promising than the content.
@KelvinSuddith3 ай бұрын
@@space.youtubenope because it sounds like an ad, which it is not. He’s suggesting changing to a title that doesn’t make it sound like an ad for some product
@FrancescoDiMany3 ай бұрын
I agree, the title and the picture don't give the feeling that the video will be very interesting. And yet it is nicely done, with such a good scientific test. If it wasn't a GCN Tech video, I would not have try to watch it
@space.youtube3 ай бұрын
@@KelvinSuddith You think the title of this video sounds like an ad? What sort of product, in your imagination at least, do you think the title of this video would be trying to introduce? It literally states what's on the tin and you people are aren't happy? lol Some people just like complaining I guess. Ps I don't think you understood my original comment, but thanks for trying all the same. 😁
@tonym8353 ай бұрын
Great video. Just to add, on Arenberg alone the system takes approximately 23000 hits (2300m x 5 cobbles/m x 2 wheels). Within those 23000, it's the random missing or proud cobles and wide gaps that are the problem.
@l.d.t.63273 ай бұрын
The system doesn't take 23000 hits. You often don't hit anything for a full meter with either or both wheels. At 40k/hr you fly over a lot of those cobbles.
@gtmedley3 ай бұрын
Excellent tech video. I proves what I always have believed, the more you get into bike racing, the more it turns into car racing. Silverstone, even!
@mpvsystems93023 ай бұрын
This rig looks ideal for comparing the performance of an old school tubular with a TLR. For example, the Pirelli P-Zero is readily available in both formats in size 700 x 28. I would expect the casing material and layup to be identical too. Of course the big difference is that the tubular will have 30% more usable casing making it much more compliant and comfortable at any given pressure not to mention almost impossible to pinch flat. Also, one would expect the tubular to handle a much wider range of pressure especially on the low end owing to the flangeless rim profile.
@matthiaswuest72713 ай бұрын
How is it near impossible to pinch flat a tubular? It still has an inner tube, it's just woven into the casing
@mpvsystems93023 ай бұрын
@@matthiaswuest7271 A tubular rim has no flanges. Pinch flats are caused when an inner tube gets "pinched" over the flanges.
@macvos3 ай бұрын
This has been tested before, frequently. Tubeless tires had a lower rolling resistance at equal comfort levels.
@GregoryVeizades2 ай бұрын
Tubeless will be better than the tubular. There is a reason cars don't use tubes. Tubulars, despite their name are just constructed with a built in inner tube and that layup will have more internal friction reducing compliance at a given pressure. Tubeless tires only have the casing flex to tune.
@JanGoh-jb5ge3 ай бұрын
I'd like to see more about tubeless tyres and inserts and how they affect handling and puncture resistance. The drift that I get on my tyres with a foam insert is very much like the feeling I got with high-quality CX tubulars. There's a drift, but it's controllable. You don't want that on the road necessarily, but it feels good on gravel bikes. But I think there's a lot to be done there. High quality TPU tubes are nice I guess, but they're still a tube and I feel like that has very specific drawbacks that most riders and unsupported racers shouldn't have to contend with.
@CatManDoSocial3 ай бұрын
Great stuff, Ollie. Well done.
@ItachiGT3 ай бұрын
Interesting stuff. As a recreational road cyclist though I don't dive this deep into the setup. 5.5 to 6 bar pressure on 28mm tires is all I need to know good to semi good roads.
@svr54233 ай бұрын
same for me. I typically pump it up between 5 and 6 bar. Good compromise. When I look at other riders, many of them barely have 1 or 1.5 bars in them.
@Andy_ATB3 ай бұрын
Plenty of bike shops have been guilty of this as well. I recall buying a few bikes, and them pumping the tyres up to over 100psi - despite me asking them not to. Got home and let the tyres down to a proper pressure.
@pierrex32263 ай бұрын
If bike shop people were super smart, on average, let's be real, they would have had a different career. Cycling is also a world that's resistant to change.
@stevengagnon47773 ай бұрын
@@pierrex3226Ouch! Spent four decades as a professional bicycle mechanic in a LBS. My customers would disagree with that sentiment.
@raybaxter46833 ай бұрын
@@stevengagnon4777 You missed the "on average."
@michael13 ай бұрын
@@stevengagnon4777 No they wouldn't. The dentist coming in to buy his pinarello or cervelo wasn't thinking you were smart. Bikes are simple as fuck too - you can build a bike from scratch in a few hours. Now, of course, perhaps the average member of the public who goes to a bike shop can't remove the back wheel so maybe he or she thinks it's an incredibly complicated mechanical device and you're a genius or something, but you'd be a fool to measure yourself against them to give yourself the impression you're highly skilled. if you spent 4 decades doing bike maintenance you wouldn't learn anything new after the first 2 or 3 weeks.
@DANCINGWITHTHEFAILS3 ай бұрын
They may pump it up to that to seat the tire
@cjsa92533 ай бұрын
Fascinating and well researched test (given the constraints), very well presented by Ollie. I need to lower my tyre pressures 🙄. More of these please GCN.
@abirkhanrafee18893 ай бұрын
gcn should keep doing videos like these
@gcntech3 ай бұрын
Thank you, that’s what we’ll try.
@helmutjarn3953 ай бұрын
Hey Olli, just to make sure: When you compared results to the SILCA website you put in the "measured width" of the tire at 28mm. While I do not have the Pirellis for comparison, my 28mm Schwalbe Pro One TLEs for example are actually 31-31.5mm wide (hookless rims). The difference in recommended pressure acc. to SILCA is a full 1 bar compared to a tire that is really only 28mm wide.
@skipcycle45803 ай бұрын
Or go to 18:06 and pause if you're in a hurry. I think I'll try 80 psi (5-10 psi lower) on my next ride and see how it feels. No mention of whether tire pressure should vary front to rear. Early 80's it was 105 psi with 20 width. Times have changed!
@Thezuule13 ай бұрын
Just use a tire pressure calculator
@JohnCourtenayLewis2 ай бұрын
Ollie, geeked out to the max! LOVE IT!!!! Ask the lab nicely if you can go do some of those other test protocols you mentioned. I. for one, will be glued to the screen!
@bobfoster6873 ай бұрын
Dylan Johnson recommends 45mm or wider tires with pressure about 15-20 psi for gravel racing.
@kpsig3 ай бұрын
These numbers refer to his body weight, while he also is running tubeless. If I do that on my clinchers which have to support my 95kg, I would have a flat within 10km.
@Foxtrottangoabc3 ай бұрын
Continental Racekings
@demil36183 ай бұрын
How much is that?
@rabidsminions20793 ай бұрын
20 psi is like flat.
@demil36183 ай бұрын
@@rabidsminions2079 Is it? Sounds a lot. If it was 20 bar it'd burst
@cyclingcomputer3 ай бұрын
In other words, on tarmac: it will depends of the type of tyre, rider weights, and pressure to get more or less 3 watts. I'll continue use my 80 psi (between 6 and 5 bar) and it will not going to affect my super 195-205w on average rides.
@AllanHundeboll2 ай бұрын
Actually there a different kinds of tarmac and silcas excellent calculator also account for this. But of course the calculator depends on the values you enter. Looking at graphs showing coalition between rough/average/smooth tarmac and tire pressure shows the penalty from to high pressure is significantly higher vs the penalty riding with to low pressure.
@fiddleronthebike3 ай бұрын
I don’t think the pros can go lower; the cobbles at Paris-Roubaix are totally different! This drum simulates „urban“ cobbles with a relative regular pattern - at P-R you have random stones and the wheels are hitting steps up to 5 cm and more. On that you will get pinch flats much easier
@macvos3 ай бұрын
That's probably why some riders run tire inserts
@ByronJackson-e5h3 ай бұрын
I noticed the front end was rigidly fixed with no wheel or drum. This DOES have a huge effect. Would LOVE to see the test rig with a front wheel setup. In the days before my spinal prolapse ended my riding, I played around with this. Different width/pressure tires on the front (Keeping the back fixed) had a noticeable effect. I was running Conti 4000'''s 21/23/25.. Nowadays I potter along on my flatbar roadie and Schwalbe Mrathon at 60-70 psi, so it was interesting to see maximum comfort probably equals maximum efficiency. I think I'll go down another 10 psi. Thanks. informative video.
@dudleyarnold57453 ай бұрын
Possibly the best cycle science video I have seen. Vindicates my view that a lot a cyclists inflate their tyres to high. 65 to 80 psi is a good median for most terrain.
@AllanHundeboll2 ай бұрын
Totally depends on weight and tire width
@lux-wattage3 ай бұрын
Videos like this really get me excited! I’d love the chance to visit test facilities like this myself (especially alongside Ollie). If slightly heated tires offer performance benefits, do you think we might see 'tire warming' technologies in the future, allowing riders to start with optimal tire temperatures from the get-go?
@edmundhodgson25723 ай бұрын
Good vid, so narrow is faster? Shame not to have had a 25mm in the mix.
@heinik43493 ай бұрын
Yes it is.
@dmitryhetman15093 ай бұрын
If your rims made for 25mm tires yes it is
@Pastamistic3 ай бұрын
Such a high quality video! I love that Pirelli have been putting such a massive investment into this. I absolutely love the Pirelli Gravel H tires on my gravel bike. They roll so good on gravel and surprisingly well on pavement too. It would be fun to see how they compare to other tires and at different pressures.
@pcat0073 ай бұрын
I found the table towards the end of the video great for some of us. For the rest of me, going lower than 35 km/h would be more helpful.
@jeffpabilonia3 ай бұрын
have they tested front wheel as well like on training rollers, front constantly moving with steering inputs especially on TT bikes correcting for wind gusts and most of the weight shifted forward onto front wheel, also bikes are frequently rocking side to side when out of saddle climbing and sprinting with different contact patches around the tire, and high speed cornering on long descents...so many variables to consider with rolling resistance, surface type, ambient temperature, rider weight, weight balance, tire aerodynamics, wet surface, etc
@CaryCotterman3 ай бұрын
My first mid-end road bike, long ago, had 1.25-inch (32mm) tyres, with a recommended pressure of 60 psi (4 bar). When I got some money, I switched to 20mm sew-ups running at 125 psi (8.6 bar), and the decrease in resistance and increase in speed were dramatic. Today I ride 23mm clinchers at 110 to 120 psi (7.6 to 8.3 bar). Sorry, I'm sticking with "old school", never going back to fat, soft tyres. Those are for paperboys. Yeah, I know, Tadej goes big and squishy and wins everything, but I suspect the advantage he has over me is probably down to something other than tyres.
@benedictearlson90443 ай бұрын
You just feel like you are going faster due to the vibrations, time yourself 5x on higher and lower psi on long rides and get back to us. Maybe you are heavy, in which case 120 could be your optimum.
@mikehermesmeglioАй бұрын
I still have a bike with 23mm tires. Vittoria on Mavic Open Pro.
@0mabel03 ай бұрын
I run on 28mm tire a long time. It's the sweet spot for me. Thanks for the Tech info. videos like this! Adds efficiency every time.
@stevesimpson60213 ай бұрын
Now I need to throw a spanner in the works. What about hookless rims/tubeless which have a psi max of 72 (contin 5000)
@markh91943 ай бұрын
My hookless rims have a max pressure of 45 for my 35mm summer gravel tyres and a max of 40 for my winter 42s, honestly I can't tell the difference but I've not done any personal testing, I usually run 5 psi under at the rear and 3-5 less at the front and it's all been hunkydory, might drop it a bit and see if there is any discernable difference 🤷
@stevesimpson60213 ай бұрын
Gravel tyres seem to avoid the problem that road rims are having. My road bike has 28mm and there seems some concern with tyre blow outs due to narrow rims. Haven’t had an issue yet but lots of stories of issues. Argghhh
@markh91943 ай бұрын
@@stevesimpson6021 I think also the higher pressure needed for a narrower tyre also plays a massive part in this...go wide, go low and you'll be fine😉
@levestane63833 ай бұрын
Very interesting. This is the best drum testing I've seen and probably the closest to roll-down tests (e.g., Jan Heine's stuff). The whole-system approach is much more important than simple small drum testing of just a wheel, for example it is likely that most of the power lost on rough surfaces is dissipated as heat in the riders body. I look forward to many more results from this kit!
@MrTeff9993 ай бұрын
I don’t run the same pressure in both tires. Front is always about five psi lower than the rear.
@jimm40293 ай бұрын
And that should be rigth... if it the rigth pressure
@benedictearlson90443 ай бұрын
That is standard advice, but without a rig testing both tyres at the same time its hard to know if its the correct policy. Seems legit due to less weight over the front, but the arms act as shock absorbers unlike the lower body effectively reducing weight on rough surfaces? So who knows for sure, maybe it should be 10psi lower?
@MrTeff9993 ай бұрын
@@benedictearlson9044 In addition to the rear weight bias, my theory goes like this: 1) A softer front tire is more comfortable and reduces numbness on long rides. 2) I’m less likely to get a pinch flat on the front because I can more precisely absorb or avoid hard bumps, and 3) I can avoid road hazards such as glass better with the front tire compared to a back tire.
@craigsawyer64533 ай бұрын
Running lower pressure in the front tire is for comfort and traction. Every thing is a trade off, if you want the least resistance High pressure and the smallest contact patch are the your friends, if you want a less fatigued rider, that five PSI lower is nice. Every ones riding style is different some crazy people can handle rattling their brains and a few of these riders may even have uncanny bike handling ability, these are the ones that seem to walk away from other riders when the going gets rough. A more aggressive tread pattern on the front, if necessary rear too, coupled with a narrow width, has less resistance than an under inflated wider tires. Question is are you the type of animal that can take all that punishment? For one race fine, for the season???
@tuber78533 ай бұрын
yeah...i feels the same with your point 1
@MMMS753 ай бұрын
At 2 bar on cobblestones, do You risk snakebite punctures or destroying the rim from impacts?
@einundsiebenziger54883 ай бұрын
If you are over 70 kg, the tyres would bottom out long before you reach the first cobble stone. My car feels squishy in corners at this pressure and when this happens I need to pump them back to 2.4 bar.
@MMMS753 ай бұрын
@@einundsiebenziger5488 that’s a great point. Hahah! I’m at 110kg. That pressure would not actually get the rim off the pavement.
@ericpmoss3 ай бұрын
Ollie asked how they managed Paris-Roubaix on 23mm tires back in the day. Well, they had much more forgiving steel frames and forks, and 28mm tubulars on light aluminum rims that were 10x as forgiving as wide and deep carbon aero wheels.
@einundsiebenziger54883 ай бұрын
In the steel-frame era they rode on 20- to 22-mm tubulars pumped to the maximum allowed pressure. Indeed the flat box-section alloy rims factored in, it's only a few years ago that pro teams put these on bikes especially for Paris-Roubaix when they would usually ride deep-section carbon wheels for everything else.
@stevengagnon47773 ай бұрын
Many used Paves for the Roubaix...I used Paves all the time . Switched to 26 mm to 28 mm tubulars in the early nineties...I was heavy so it made everything better.
@rkentwenger50953 ай бұрын
Well, I think they had way more punctures, too. It was routine for riders to have multiple punctures and still win, which is pretty rare today. (My recollection is that when Hinault won in 1981 he had 4 punctures and 2 crashes, or vice-versa.)
@beeldpuntXVI3 ай бұрын
@@rkentwenger5095not nescesary, riding on cobbles is more technique than you think, arenberg is an exception, but every cobbles pave has a ridge, ther where you would preferably ride. And every section has his own few golden speeds. On this speeds you fly from one ridge to the other. A little faster you jump more, a little slower the same. You see it even in action when Alex was riding 35 km /h he was in discomfort. When he slowed just a little the vibration was smaller. At even slower speeds, he vibrated more,….. High tire pressure gives puncture resistance, it is total system, material choices matter
@stevengagnon47773 ай бұрын
@@einundsiebenziger5488 as you mentioned the flat box section rims ( that I still use) made a big difference. They were relatively strong ( stronger and much lighter than clincher s) and could be easily tuned with spoke count, rim weight. spoke guage and tension. Being flat and wide they had good vertical compliance and good lateral stiffness. They really are a joy to ride and thanks to the acceptance of and availability of wider tires in tubulars , even better. I always rode paves anyway but the newer tires certainly give superior puncture protection. Those tubulars were also made from cotton which also softened the ride and for that special day with absolutely no rain in the forecast there was silk . Even at 100 kilos I could ride a 330 gram rim with 32 skinny double butted spokes will alloy nipples and a decent 23 mm training tubular up front ( being dishless made it possible) and as long as I didn't hit an immovable object they were plenty strong for daily use. Once I discovered Paves and those wider rims I never went back . The ride and confidence in the twisties was awesome.
@RobLarsen3 ай бұрын
This was fascinating. Keep heading back! It'll be like Alex Dowsett testing everything he owns in the wind tunnel which was full of surprises (and even generated a product for Nopinz)
@bubblesezblonde3 ай бұрын
Loved this content Dr Bridgewood.
@davidparker84752 ай бұрын
Ollie, perhaps the most geeked out video to date for you. I couldn't stop watching it! 😂
@richardking69853 ай бұрын
great video...more width testing please
@gcntech3 ай бұрын
You’re insatiable when it comes to tyres 😀
@joeshmoe79673 ай бұрын
For myself, I would be wary of running too low on the front tires, as it tends to wash out the front end in hard cornering. Over all good data is good to have, and can lead to the sweet spot. Different set ups for different conditions, seems like a normal way to look it things. Always interesting content. - Cheers
@musclelessfitness20453 ай бұрын
One of your better tire pressure videos, but you should've picked a better brand for the second tire.
@trepidati0n5333 ай бұрын
You actually don't. One thing about "science" is you always start with a wide a difference as possible to make sure you can actually measure something of value. If they would have gone in with a GP5000 and a superfast tire, there may not have been much to talk about or worse yet, the wrong conclusion.
@PhilAndersonOutside3 ай бұрын
I'm good with the cheap tire as a base. Though in an ideal situation they'd have tested like 10 different tires. But that could have taken days.
@TheCharnwoodCyclist3 ай бұрын
Interesting stuff. I find the Silca calculator a good starting point but I’m not sure on their definitions of road surfaces and sometimes am not sure which one to choose for uk roads. Usually their recommendation results in a pressure slightly too high for me. I would suggest that tyre pressure is considered as a whole rather than just for power efficiency, for example I set my tyres as low as I can for comfort, I might be giving away a bit in rolling resistance but the bike feels so much nicer to ride. It should be fairly obvious when you find the right pressure, the bike will feel too crashy with pressure too high, and won’t handle corners with too low pressures.
@dmitryhetman15093 ай бұрын
Faster you go smoother road becames.
@bobnelson28283 ай бұрын
Great content!! More of this type would be appreciated.
@gcntech3 ай бұрын
📝
@jhollandization3 ай бұрын
Silva does not have a TOU tube option and could be more specific on surface as well as class of tire.
@10ktube3 ай бұрын
Couple of things. First one, if pressures are this important, what is the most accurate and CONSISTENT way we should measure our pressures as normal riders at home? What's the go-to gauge for measuring? I'm going to guess if I took 3 different floor pumps, couple of mini pumps, my air compressor, etc, they'd all read differently. Second one, pros are drilling cobbles at way faster than 35k/h, their pressures are different than us noodling around. Plus some of those classics riders are heavier (most are). Thirdly - Dylan Johnson has been saying for years pros should be on 40-50mm wide tires for the cobbles, no one will do it, but after seeing this data, it's something to consider (different bike frame of course).
@derek751163 ай бұрын
What your saying makes obvious sense i would have thought..
@MrTeff9993 ай бұрын
My floor pump over states the actual pressure by 18psi. I didn’t know until I bought a digital pressure gauge.
@_Tp___3 ай бұрын
For the third point, maybe for cobbles that is the best option but most races with cobbles have significant amounts of smoother surfaces so mid 30s is probably the right way to go for them. I agree with your first point though, normal people just have to go off a track pump or something and kind of see if it feels the right pressure.
@MercuryDIY3 ай бұрын
@@_Tp___exactly what I was thinking. tire choice has to consider the tarmac and cobbles. If you just take a 50mm tire to monster truck over the cobbles, then yeah it will be faster but on the tarmac the rider would suffer and be much slower than the group riding 32’s or 30’s
@jonathanzappala3 ай бұрын
GCN made that video, a mountain bike, with mtb tires, is faster across the cobble sector. The thing is Paris Roubaix is a race mostly on regular roads.
@JorisVanDeuneghemАй бұрын
I’m a newbie to cycling and I’ve learned so so much from the channel. I really enjoy the content. This video is a bit above my knowledge, but very interesting. And like you said there are so much more variables that will change that data in a real live world scenario. But I’m wondering what the best pressure is on a normal road ride? Is it like 6 bar or maybe 5,5bar? We ride on smooth surfaces but also rough surfaces on a ride.
@Gugner2 ай бұрын
Facts you need to know, about the right pressure😊😊: Once I crossed Australias Outback (5678 km). On the first day on my mission, using a steel MTB bike and a Yak trailer, starting from Adelaide (arrived by aeroplane from Denmark), I only did 37 km…!!!👀👀 Maybe the many hills on my way out?? The next day I did 77 km. More, but it was far too little! I NEEDED to cover 130-256 km/ day, in order to reach each tank station, with water supply and camping, along the road. The 3rd I did 116 km. More, BUT still toooooo little! From the 4th day and onwards I would be out in the Outback. I NEEDED to cover up to 200 km/day. Had I overestimated my own capabilities? Was close to cancel the mission across up to Darwin. THEN I checked the tyre pressure…..I was WAY TO LOW!!! I pumped up to the maximum for the tyre (4,5 bar). The next day I left for the Outback. I did ride SOOO easy and fast!!👀👀👀😁😁😁🚴🏻♂️💪🏻😊 I even had time for a siesta by noon. And I arrived well in time before darkness, having done 180 km👀👀👀👀😃😃 After this, I checked the pressure EVERY single day. Constantly. By getting the right feeling using my weakest finger. Morale: Always the right pressure. Always! You will be rewarded!!🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼💪🏻🚴🏻♂️😊😊😊😁😁
@terryforsythe83423 ай бұрын
Great video and some really interesting comments. Will be adjusting front and back pressures before my next ride. Thanks so much.
@PsyKeks3 ай бұрын
On finding optimal pressure, an industry professional said* to "search for smoothness". When you feell the vibrations, it's too high. But much lower than that isn't great, either. *) It was an interview with the less mainstream and less performance oriented chanel "the path less pedaled" (home of "partypace"). I think, Ollie and another presenter have met Russ and Laura on a shoot on some mountain this year or so.
@tomthumble2383 ай бұрын
I'm running a slow 23mm gatorskin at 100 psi on a steel condor fratello and it seems to work for my 17 stone self. I was going to opt for 28mm ones to keep up with the new trends but wld hate to lose any speed. The steel frame soaks up alot of the bumps and road vibrations caused by the lack of rubber. I run 60 psi on my 26"mtb road tires .
@leighhewitt54763 ай бұрын
Why are we accepting Watts down to the 0.00 decimal, yet using single diget Bar as the pressure difference. Why not psi for a more exact test result?
@fishyerik3 ай бұрын
If you want higher resolution you can use parts of bars. Stating the exact precision of the measured the pressure is irrelevant in this context, maybe they adjusted the pressure to the stated number of bar, +/- a few millibars. But also, it's not that important, and, in a given volume and amount of air, pressure changes with temperature, so pressure is not constant, so unless you keep measuring the pressure, or temperature of the air, you won't actually know the pressure.
@nomadcarpenter85493 ай бұрын
1m is the same thing as 1000mm, provided its measured accurately
@tauncfester30223 ай бұрын
I used to ride our local century on my FWD recumbent with a 24"x1.375" width Cheng-Shen commuter tire on the driving wheel. Didn't need to pump up it to 80 psi, and it was more comfortable at 60 psi. This was on average US spec tarmac with all sorts of local differences in quality, from being less than a year old to 20 year old weathered/old tractor tire washboarding and pitting.
@julianwalsh84003 ай бұрын
Not gonna lie, those reflective stripes on the cheap Amazon tyres actually looks pretty cool and is a pretty innovative way to add some retro-reflectivity to your bike at night.
@Jean-jk4zv3 ай бұрын
It’s not innovative Vittoria and Shwalbe do this for a looong time in my experience.
@MrTeff9993 ай бұрын
I wish Continental would add reflective stripes to their GP5000 line.
@SebastianTominec3 ай бұрын
They have reflective strips on a GP5000 AS tyres.
@stevengagnon47773 ай бұрын
The relflecive strips are a big difference for motor vehicle drivers at night. Would like to see them on most tires.
@stevengagnon47773 ай бұрын
@@SebastianTominecit's definitely an underrated tire. The small loss in rolling resistance is well made up in real world riding...especially in the wet and cold weather of both spring and fall. It doesn't necessarily have to be wet as they will give better grip on dry and cold roads too. I would like to see more tires with actual treads too ... I don't believe that slick tires are good for all around real world riding. Especially since the acceptance of the wider tire.
@jeremynorth3 ай бұрын
Excellent video Ollie. You are the best at all of this scientific stuff.
@davidadamus1773 ай бұрын
Has anyone noticed their bike has sketchy steerting under 90 psi on 25s with tubes? Tried it once, wasnt confidence inspiring in turns.
@gregorygoldbarth74643 ай бұрын
awesome video as usual, kudos. In regards to the wider tire, if you’re putting a wide tire on a rim that’s designed for a narrow tire when we talk about optimal fitment of course it’s going to be slower. It would’ve been interesting to fit a wider tire on a wider rim that is optimized for that tire size.
@peterleffler20623 ай бұрын
Interesting stuff, good work👏 I suspect that in the cobble classics the road surface is rougher and far more variable. The cobbles are laid fairly roughly from the start (relative to Swiss tarmac) and are then punished by years of heavy farm traffic and neglect so there is no regularity in the surface in terms of up- bumps, down-bumps, exposed edges etc (hard to describe but I hope you get the gist). So that is perhaps part of the reason that the pros use a slightly higher pressure than your testing would suggest. It doesn't invalidate your results , like you said any results throw up more questions.
@grahamcollins68103 ай бұрын
"96% of Cyclists Get Their Tyre Pressure Wrong. How To Get It Right" Step 1. Build a multimillion pound rolling road facility Step 2. Test every type of tyre at every possible pressure on every possible surface Step 3. Let a bit of air out of your tyre Seriously though, the video was much better than the title - good info!
@billmmckelvie51883 ай бұрын
Thanks for the video. The science behind the sport has come on in leaps and bounds. However I am left wondering how they match the adhesive surface on the rubber roller compared with that of an actual cobblestone and get the adhesion figires correct? Although I am not a Pro or amateur racer, you did mention the Silca tyre pressure calculator, which is ideal for us recreational riders who are overweight and what the tyre pressure should be for our set up? I wonder if the lab would be able to replicate the 20mm chippings that litter our back country roads?
@einundsiebenziger54883 ай бұрын
I have been riding MTBs and roadbikes since 35 years, even rode some competitions and countless alpine passes and granfondos all over Central and Southwestern Europe. Always pumped my tyres to the point they "felt fast", which may have been all wrong. I don't care, because the only point I did not enjoy a ride because of tyre pressure was when it suddenly went to zero - aka I suffered a flat. If you do not make a living by racing bicycles, there is no need to overthink this, just pump your tyres and go for a ride!
@AllanHundeboll2 ай бұрын
Well if you spend a lot of money on a fast and/or comfortable bike not optimizing ture pressure seem like wasting money....
@danielotero44843 ай бұрын
GREAT VIDEO. I have question all that testing will it take it into account the surface temperature. What is the rolling resistance from cold to hot summer day with a tarmac temp reaching 140 deg. and viseversa when it's 65 degree and bellow. And what is the nominal surface temperature for the best rolling resistance? Thanks
@sventice3 ай бұрын
Love this nerdy content; please keep it going if you can! I'm currently running 32mm tires with TPU tubes on my road bike. According to the Silca calculator, I should be running my tires at 4.5 Bar (65psi) on paved surfaces. That's actually very squishy in my opinion. Instead, I run 5.5 Bar (80psi), which seems to be ideal: comfortable, smooth, but it doesn't feel like I'm riding through thick sand. OK, I don't actually run 80psi all the time. Most of the time, I'm not even sure what my tire pressure actually is. When I inflate my tires, I go up to 90 psi, sometimes even up to the recommended max of 100, and then don't mess with them for 2 weeks or more. The tires lose a couple of psi a day. For the first couple of days, they're honestly way too hard, sort of bouncy, which isn't good, but then they feel fine, and when they finally start to feel too squishy, which is at about 70 psi for me, I start over.
@onnoH963 ай бұрын
Same here! It creates some variety in the rides haha
@the_kingd0m3 ай бұрын
Bad practice. Should just inflate tires before every ride. Just aim for between 60-80 or pumped before every ride. Tubeless tires lose a lot of pressure every day, very unpredictable
@TimothyTakemoto3 ай бұрын
@@the_kingd0m "Bad Practice. Should..." Cycling is like a church.
@sventice3 ай бұрын
@@the_kingd0m If I wanted to inflate my tires before every single ride, I would just use latex tubes.
@tj_h30053 ай бұрын
Great video. Wish you could have explained why the higher pressure was less efficient on the asphalt.
@bertrandsalaun37213 ай бұрын
I used to run 23mm tyres on cobble at 7 bars, for my commuting through Paris and her suburbs. It's shaky, but you simply get used to it. :) I run 28 at 6 now, and it's already a smoother and more efficient ride, even as an amateur. As you mentioned, however, in a racing situation, it's easy to conceive how different the mindset and savings would be.
@IgorKlajo3 ай бұрын
One of the most informative and educational videos from GCN Tech. Learning a lot from these kind of videos. 👌
@LukeGJPotter3 ай бұрын
Science Viewers, at 4:50, when Ollie says "One Hertz a Second": 😮 Excuse me while I withdraw money at the "ATM Machine".
@_Tp___3 ай бұрын
Oh dear, poor from Dr Bridgewood.
@PsyKeks3 ай бұрын
It gets faster and faster! First it's one Hertz, a second later it's two Hertz, then three Hertz. Soon you can hear it. Ride long enough and you can see it it.
@benoitbvg28883 ай бұрын
One hertz a second, how many BPM per minute is that?
@DaanHoogland3 ай бұрын
/ss
@Randombourg3 ай бұрын
Don't be too harsh, he's a chemist!
@christianemeiners92243 ай бұрын
But what about the impact of the front wheel in the total system? E.g. Silca puts out a front and rear pressure value, how does this rig figure out which value should be used for the front tire. And finally, what is the impact of wet surfaces on tire pressure selection? I would bet that a lot of people ride with too high pressures in wet conditions.
@mcg423873 ай бұрын
id love to see a calculator that we can enter our weight, tire width and riding type and then just get the right pressure to add
@GCNuser1233 ай бұрын
the silca one does that
@fredeberlein3 ай бұрын
Excellent report. Very helpful. My pressure has been too high at 7 bars... will test at 5 bars on next ride.
@savagepro90603 ай бұрын
When GCN applies Peer Pressure: "96% of Cyclists Get High Blood Pressure when they get Their Tyre Pressure Wrong . . ." Slow Leaks: 😉 Local Priesthood Cycling Club: "Pray Sure!"
@einundsiebenziger54883 ай бұрын
Definitely true for the time I used a pressure gauge in addition to that on my floor pump. Re-adjustment of pressure took time, effort and ruined my mood. When the gauge was not working properly at one time, I smashed it on the ground, completely destroying it. I never replaced it and using just the gauge on my pump leaves me a much happier cyclist now.
@whazzat80153 ай бұрын
Pssst... Wanna tip on comfort?
@savagepro90603 ай бұрын
@@whazzat8015 "Psst"
@jamesro19627 күн бұрын
Very interesting. Thanks. Really valuable information. As someone who likes upgrades, this was very important. As someone who rides normally at 6 or 7, usually 7, this was invaluable.
@millermiller753 ай бұрын
It seems like you want the pressure low enough and tire size large enough to absorb the average road bump size, say 1 cm, plus a little firmness for the big bumps without bottoming out. And if the road is only bumpy for a portion of the ride and smooth for the rest, then you want to increase pressure a bit to balance out the efficiency of high pressure on a smooth surface. The trick is to find that balance point, approximately.
@tiagotiagot3 ай бұрын
Back when I was younger, as soon as I could afford it I got a full-suspension mountain bike with rear and front suspension that were good enough to handle jumps beyond what I myself felt safe performing, and always kept the tires at the maximum pressure allowed to reduce the odds of sharper bumps or hard landings pinching the tires and hitting the rims, to maximize the life of the rims and reduce the risk of cutting into the tires with the the rims, leaving the suspension to take care of making it a smooth ride (it was always a bit of a tense moment pumping the tire to the limit if I didn't had my mind elsewhere and instead remembered there was a chance the tire might happen to not handle the pressure anymore and would explode this time; never had an explosion though, but I always bought reasonable quality tires, so it wasn't worse case scenario)... I have no idea whether that was the best thing to do, but it's what I did.
@kevingregoire10423 ай бұрын
2bars on 28c for a Roubaix or even average hard cobblestone has one huge problem… That the drum doesn’t recreates! The usual Potholes and protruding cobblestone odd edges every 10m-20m. Great content as often on theese topics !
@dusanmal3 ай бұрын
Physicist Cyclist to Physicist Cyclists with the experiment (and others): I think that you'll agree with me as to the obvious next level of precision needed. Front wheel! Different conditions are experienced by front tire and rear tire. For front one, there is no power delivery just push and free roll. May I suggest that you advise experts with the system to incorporate the whole bike with two drums and do a lot of testing.... In my personal bike life (mostly rando' riding long distances) I indeed keep the two at different pressures just from experience and experiments. I ride front tire typically at higher pressure than rear (but for the really bad roads, worse than UK)... Worth knowing and hence, testing!
@stanlee-eq7lu3 ай бұрын
Sounds like those roads are literally death traps for guys that ride motorcycles.
@AllanHundeboll2 ай бұрын
Have you considered the weight distribution between front and rear before you decided to run higher pressure in you front tire? It seems like a bad decision...
@MisterE3313 ай бұрын
What a joy to wake up and geek out on some bike research...can't believe we get this content for free!!!
@gcntech3 ай бұрын
🗣Tickets please 👮♀
@DDai-qd8uk3 ай бұрын
What about rider/system weight? Would a heavier dude be faster on a wider tyre at the recommended pressures?
@chriscarol49653 ай бұрын
This is always my biggest issue in these tests. There is no real take away, as let’s say Ollie weighs 60kg and myself weighing 80 or 100kg. The results will differ a lot!
@Roger-tz5sy3 ай бұрын
How about running the tyres hard enough so they don’t make a noise and soft so they don’t buzz on the surface you are riding on.
@derek751163 ай бұрын
You’re right, Intuition isn’t a bad thing ma man.. sometimes science and analytics is only justification for a job..
@mgusty9493 ай бұрын
I'd love to see you modify pressure on the fly via a KAPS system. Great video Ollie!
@timtaylor95903 ай бұрын
dylan johnson was right mountain bike tires for cobble road races
@PhilAndersonOutside3 ай бұрын
Paul Sherwin used to say the same. If you're coming to Roubaix to ride the cobbles, bring a mountain bike!
@l.d.t.63273 ай бұрын
he's not right.
@thegearboxman3 ай бұрын
So in summary, for most of us plodding along at 25-30km/h on reasonable (but occasionally pot-holed) tarmac, tyre pressure makes precisely 2 parts of f**k all difference LOL. Besides, this test takes no account of the losses through the front tyre, nor does it consider what happens when you hit a pothole. I think I'll protect my carbon wheels by running the tyres a bit on the high side, plus I'll maintain some grip while cornering hard without the tyre rolling off the rim!
@LivandTrekGoCycling3 ай бұрын
Good science Dr Ollie. Enjoyed this. Can't subscribe as I'm already in but worth a thumbs up and a positive comment 🚴👍
@gcntech3 ай бұрын
Liking the video and leaving a comment also helps us a lot, thank you 🫶
@sirifail4499Ай бұрын
Don’t forget that the front wheel is seeing pretty close to the same loads etc. So a set of nice tires! Were the testers including the “load” of the front in their watt calculations.
@ericpmoss3 ай бұрын
I know everyone likes to think there is a chart they can refer to and not think about it any more, but jeeeeez. There is one easy way to get the right pressure for a road bike -- on the day of your ride, ride a bit on the route you are taking, starting with obviously too much pressure, and slowly reduce the pressure until just the road buzz goes away. It accounts for everything -- your bike, your body, your tires and tubes, the road, the weather, etc. If your route has wildly varying surfaces, either adjust as the terrain changes, or decide which section you want to accommodate.
@MikkoRantalainen3 ай бұрын
Interesting results. I would love to see more testing to understand the road surface, pressure and tyre width combination better. And I would love to see actual gravel testing instead of cobbles but that cannot be done on a drum.
@gurujoe753 ай бұрын
conti GP 5000 23/25c a regular clincher at 7.5/8 bar, front/back on a good asphalt.
@veloxime3 ай бұрын
So are the Silca recommendations reliable? How wide lower or higher can we try without risking puctures
@superyamagucci3 ай бұрын
Tyre pressure is easy - just get your thumb calibrated. My dad calibrated mine when I was about 10 and it’s been accurate ever since.
@hornetluca3 ай бұрын
#AskGCNTech I put two inner tube with sealant in my bike tires, each inner tube weigh 200 grams. I wonder, does the sealant inside of them gives me more momentum when I ride on a flat surface or is it just a wrong feeling I have? Thanks. Cheers!
@arnoldmonk63813 ай бұрын
I’ve done the same with some gravel tyres and it does seem to have a flywheel effect, the downside is the overall weight increase of heavier tyres and sealant in the tubes. Will be changing the tyres back to tubeless for winter conditions.
@johnnyloco113 ай бұрын
this is the content I live for.
@CraigCail2 ай бұрын
Great Video! Sounds like you definitely need to go back and do all the tests you need to, all the sizes, all the pressures etc. I have no idea what this would cost you but I'm sure all the viewers including yourselves would greatly benefit from a update video with all the intel you will discover.
@secureone223 ай бұрын
28 GP5000s at 80 psi for me.
@wilfriedjansen11253 ай бұрын
Hi, very interesting! But what about the given value on the tyre? How to prevent snakebites with low pressure?😉 Now, I‘m riding the Vittoria Corsa 25mm and my weight is 72 kg. What pressure do you suggest..?