A Comparison of the Captain Black Blends…Royal and Platinum

[@nathanwolfenbarger4472]

Lester, thank you for your very thoughtful review of these two blends. I found it informative, and interesting.

[@missworm]

Have fun in Italy. I shall expect a postcard…in lieu of sausage (ooer, matron!). I’ve been doing a tour of Italy in my living room, jogging on the spot whilst watching some of the wonderful YT walking videos. It’s not doing much for my carpet, but it’s keeping me fit!

[@RedcoatsReturn]

My dear Julie 😄😄 You always make me laugh in your comments…😉 In my tiny library room..I go all over time and the universe…with help of KZbin and my overactive and hungry imagination and…my Tardis…if course. It doesn’t keep me slim enough…as I like to eat 🥩 and drink 🍷 too much…I thought pipe smoking would be an appetite suppressant…but only after dinner unfortunately 😆 cheers 🥃 😉

[@missworm]

@@RedcoatsReturn what rot! You’re in fine fettle for a man of … 89 … A library? How wonderful. My house is full of books, so much so that we have had to implement a strict* ‘one in, one out’ policy for the last few years. Most of my recent fiction has now migrated to kindle, but I’m starting to worry that I’ve reached peak non-fiction capacity. It’s enough to give a minimalist ptsd. *I say strict, obviously this only applies to Mr Worm’s sci-fi collection 😉

[@RedcoatsReturn]

@@missworm Don’t worry my dear….you’re amongst friends in the pipe community…we all have acquisition disorders for pipes and tobacco…and traumatic stress when we can’t buy a new one 😄😉 Greetings to Mr. Worm….may his collection grow…there’s always another secret drawer…somewhere 😄😁

[@oldandintheway1955]

Hiyas Lester, I have an ancient history with Captain Black. Back in the mists of time, before the wheel; a former girlfriend did NOT like the aroma coming off my Rattray's Black Mallory tobacco. Well, i assessed the situation and decided to go with Captain Black. She liked the aroma and i disliked the flavor profile. But, one does what one must...... Eventually, she moved on and i sent what i had left of the Captain, to a watery grave 🚽!! I've not had any since. I thoroughly enjoyed your review regardless. KPO ✓ Gary

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Gary, …the funny thing…in pipe smoking…is you maybe try an old blend…that you hated…and…you suddenly…you like it 😲😲 the second time around. The taste on your tongue is…so dynamic…and…over time….we learn techniques to enjoy…almost any blend. Girlfriends come and go….but….pipe tobacco…is on your side 😄😊😉💨💨💨

[@oldandintheway1955]

@@RedcoatsReturn Very true my friend, very true indeed. I will pick up a pouch of CB Royal and give it a 2nd chance. I'd never do that with girlfriends, but I will do so with tobacco. 🤔👍

[@sandrofazzolari8833]

Lovely to see you dear Lester! Interesting blends and smoking them in different pipes will provide you with some additional insights. Enjoy your trip to Italy 🇮🇹 and keep us posted. If you pass by Milano and have some time, please let me know. Cheers 🍸S.

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Hi Sandro 😊😊 I enjoyed trying different pipes on this one, it taught me to think longer…which pipe for this blend 😄😄 We are traveling to Bolonga with our in laws…just 3 days..a lot to see…drink…and eat 😄😊 Next time in Milano…I’ll drop you an advanced note 😉

[@SouthAlabamaPiper]

Thanks for the reviews and good advice…. I have not tried either one of these two blends, but I have tried 1Q and CB White. I will try to find some and let you know how it goes..

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Thanks Keith😊😊…I’m interested what you think about these blends 😉💨💨💨

[@frogmorepipester7490]

I really enjoy the Platinum. Cheers from the South Carolina Lowcountry (U.S.)

[@wlsims85]

My wife is loving that pipe! She loves that color blue! I used to smoke Captain Black white and gold some years ago. Haven’t tried the new one.

[@RedcoatsReturn]

I appreciate your wife’s comment😊👍👍…I love this astronomical painted cob…I smoke it when I use my telescope🔭 😄 The new CB Platinum is very enjoyable at a gentle tempo…quite different from the old CBs 😉 💨💨💨

[@frenchyleboeuf]

What an interesting aromatic analysis! Enthralling to hear your take on the two blends. As Albert Einstein once said, “I believe that pipe smoking contributes to a somewhat calm and objective judgement in all human affairs.” Take care, Lester!

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Definitely…Einstein was right on Relativity…and…Pipe Smoking too 😄😊 Thanks for watching Frenchy my’ol mate 😉

[@pipe_appeal]

Your videos never cease to be wonderful. Thanks Lester! I’m going to enjoy this!

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Glad you enjoy it! Both blends are worth a try 😋😋 though very different in character 😊😉

[@challengerdart3731]

Good vid RR. Thanks a lot. Have a great week ahead.

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Thanks, you too for watching my friend 😊 I’m off to Bologna this week…viva Italia 🇮🇹😄😉

[@josegolfpiper8342]

Gorgeous Pipe!! I too enjoy the Royal Blend. Never had the Platinum Blend. Excellent tobacco review! Thanks, Lester, for sharing.......Jose from Texas

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Thanks Jose 😊👍👍 Quite different blends but…they both…have their own qualities too 😉💨💨💨

[@michaelcase8574]

Some in the TPC might say that you area brave man Lester Mills to review these blends,but not me. Glad you enjoyed them. Our good friend Bradley over at stuff and things is releasing his final review of Captain Black cherry today. He may not be as generous in his review as you have been. We shall see. Another great one my friend.

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Yes my’ol Mike😊😊..I realize some think Captn Black is chemical junk…but…a lot of people love it and rate it as decent tobacco. Certainly, the Platinum is a step away from heavy topping and maybe will win over some of the Captn Black critics…lets see 😄🤔😉

[@georgetiedemann1537]

Another great video I smoke royal as my everyday smoke. I really enjoy it and also love sir Walter Raleigh.

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Those old Lane Ltd blends were wonderful for me too 😄😊Though I like variety…I can be sometimes a codger too 😄😉💨💨💨

[@The-man-with-the-many-pipes]

Hello Lester! Very nice pipes and tabaco, thx for sharing greetings from Austria 🇦🇹 👋🔥💨💨💨

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Thank you Günther, thanks for looking in my friend 😊👍👍

[@oldmanthingspipes]

Hey thanks Lester! I do like the normal captain black white. I just took some on my camping trip.

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Can’t go wrong with CB….its still a best seller of Lane Ltd (STG) today 💨💨💨😊😉

[@codgerjim]

Enjoyed your review. Looking forward to trying the new platinum. The pouch is NOT yet in our drug stores here in Ga. Guess I’ll have to just mail order some. I normally smoke rlp6 which is the bulk of original Capt Black.

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Its worth a try Jim 😊…go real slow..and pack it tight…it will reveal its quirky floral vanilla that way 😉

[@EricBryan]

Great info, my friend! I just heard of an event called Photo Basel, which made me think of you. Looks like there is some great fine art work on display!Glad you are well, and as always, thank you for another wonderful video! 😃

[@RedcoatsReturn]

I will check it out Eric…sounds interesting 😊👍👍

[@timeintheuk]

So relaxing thanks 👍

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Glad you enjoyed it my’ol mate…pipe smoking is…relaxing therapy…indeed 😄😉💨💨💨

[@JC-rw3tb]

Sunny week of Switzerland, so relaxing! I haven't tried them yet. I'm going to try it. Thanks.

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Have fun my’ol mate 😄💨💨💨😉

[@TamperJim]

Good to see you again Lester. You've presented a very thorough and thoughtful review. Hope the weather is treating you well and you're able to enjoy some relaxing time with your pipes. - Jim

[@RedcoatsReturn]

The weather right now is sunny, temperate and perfect! I watered the garden…for my absence in Bologna…looking forward to seeing that city after 25 years 😄🇮🇹😊

[@FlatCapPiper]

I really enjoyed your review. Rather relaxing listening to the birds. Very well done! If you like CB Dark then you would love Peter Stokkebye Black Cavendish No. 201. To me one of the best Black Cavendish Vanilla blends.

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Thank you Rafael 😊 I’m a recent fan of Peter Stokkebye blends…like the Luxury Flake Twist 😋😋 So I’ll look out for some of that No. 201 😄 Thanks for the tip my’ol mate 😄😉

[@JMZ56]

Thanks for sharing this comparison/review. Haven't tried this one yet, but I will pick up a pouch, and give it a whirl. Always a pleasure watching your videos. Take care and stay well my friend.

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Thanks JMZ…CB Platinum us worth a try…I found it good at at a gentle tempo and after packing it tight 😊😉💨💨💨

[@chuckmoss7414]

You touched on something that I have observed, and others have commented on: the change over time with the tobacco blends by the producer (change of ownership). Always interesting how something that gives the impression of being timeless, is so much in flux over time.

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Thats very true Chuck 😊 …Even 50 year old blends have changed more than once...under their new manufacturer…in a way...it makes interesting to note these changes, sometime good…sometimes bad…depending on your individual tastes 😋😉

[@chuckmoss7414]

@@RedcoatsReturn I am now two-thirds through a pouch of Plat. And I am enjoying it very much. Just as much the shag cut, as the taste. Country Gentleman the tool of choice.

[@chillaxe9603]

Thanks for the review. Paladin liked this one also. I've royal and white sitting in the drawer and have recently turned 2oz of 1q to ash! I'll send word to Welsh Piper to check this video out, he's after strong tasting vanilla recommendations! Have a good trip!

[@RedcoatsReturn]

I can recommend Captn Black Dark…its the atomic vanilla blend…of all time 😄😄😉

[@chillaxe9603]

@Redcoat‘s Return that's just what he was after, i thought of him when you said it! I'm more into stronger, heavier blended stuff, I force myself to aro in the cobs... regret buying em mostly, as you say a bit light but some can bite with the best of em. The last of the smaller particles of Sutliff Revelation match burned with zero bite but it was in a system pipe...! Loved the taste no matter but I did feel the bite next day when the bag was fresh. Worth it!

[@Chriscyng50]

Hi Lester, just checking in. You always due excellent reviews. Have not had either blend. Take care now

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Thanks, you too Christopher 😊 Captn Black is worth a try my’ol mate 😄😉💨💨💨

[@CaptainBailey4007]

Great review! Like I said in my review it’s not for me , your right about it burning quickly , I was always getting a little tung bite. Cheers!

[@RedcoatsReturn]

I agree William, CB Platinum…is not an easy smoke…everyone has their tempo and style…and…some blends…are too much hard work…to feel comfortable…for me too 😄😉💨💨💨

[@The_Southland_Piper]

Thank You for the review. 👍🏻

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Thanks my’ol mate…it was fun to experience these very different blends 😄😉

[@TruckinPiperBob]

Evening Lester, quality in depth and inserting review, thank you for that. Glad you mentioned the water drops in the jar I did that today whilst jarring some tobacco up and wondered if I was doing the right thing have a great week 😊

[@RedcoatsReturn]

I use boiling water to sterilize may jars, pour it out and add the tobacco…but…some drops of water are in the jars…never had a problem. When I open the jar…I touch the tobacco to feel if it needs a dry…or…not before loading my pipe 😉

[@nathanwolfenbarger4472]

​@@RedcoatsReturn Simple but effective. Thank you for the tip, Lester.

[@s.m.r.1202]

Very good! Thanks so much for your thoughts on the blends, Lester. I've enjoyed listening in. I have been wondering about the new blend since it came to market. Now I know. 👍 Have a wonderful week ahead. 😊

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Glad you enjoyed it Randy 😊 CB Platinum is worth a try…quite different to the other CBs…but enjoyable in a slow gentle tempo too 😊😉

[@franksanto4815]

Hi Lester, Love the smell of Captain Black and the review. I watched it a few nights ago. May have to purchase Captain Black Royal just for the smell. Again, loved the video as I did Smokeless Measured Breathing with my Country Gentleman cob. It was all very relaxing. Smokeless Breathing and watching Redcoat Returns, a great combination to wind down in the evening. Elaine says thanks for keeping me entertained. Stay well old friend from across the pond. Blessings. review

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Its a pleasure my dear Frank…for me to entertain you…my friend…Some aromatic tobaccos are pure aromatherapy ☺️ Some are better than potpourris fragrances…they have a comforting…homely…and pleasant ambiance that they…exude 😊💨💨💨

[@franksanto4815]

Ah, aromatherapy from pipe tobacco. They definitely have the ability to comfort and relax with fond memories of potpourris fragrances around Christmas time. Blessings old friend!@@RedcoatsReturn

[@joseluismanzur1973]

Hello Lester very good video i love CB royal y never smoked CB platinum.Thank you for this rewieu and goods smokes.

[@RedcoatsReturn]

My pleasure Jose 😊😊 If you like vanilla…try CB Dark…its an atomic bomb of vanilla…very smoothed by black cavendish 😋😄😉

[@yusufsayed1583]

Beautiful pipe , lovely blue with good tobacco , captain Black 😊 awsome content 👏🏼 great review 👌🏽 Thanks for your time and sharing your thoughts with me😊 Greetings and cheers🍻 from south africa 🇿🇦

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Thank you Sayed 😊 It was fun to understand these blends and their differences and their characters 😄😉

[@TinFoilHatPipeDude]

Thanks for the reviews and comparison, Lester! I love codger blends, SWR is probably my favourite. I regret not buying a pouch of CB Royal in Greecd last year, I was a bit put off by my experience with CB Regular…a nice blend but not really my thing. I do agree about SWR Aromatic, shat a wonderful blend it is, maybe my favourite aro of all. Not sure which version I have tried though. Be well and enjoy those cob friendly blends my friend! Emil

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Thanks for watching m’ol mate😊 both of these blends are worth a try…very different in their qualities…but….both enjoyable too 😋😉

[@shearersmokes]

Excellent review Lester. I really enjoy what I have of SWR and CB both coming by way of Old and in the way 👍 I shall be trying to get hold of those two blends for sure. Great tasting notes. Enjoy the rest of the week 😎

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Those old classic codger pouch blends are very enjoyable and fun to try out. I was surprised how I liked the CB blends 😄😉💨💨💨

[@shearersmokes]

@@RedcoatsReturn I really like them plus the history involved when these blends would have been the staple choice of Grandad's & Uncles.. 💨💨

[@ParsimoniousPiper]

Haven’t tried either one, but CBs do burn well. I’ll have to try them and see what my wife thinks.

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Your Mrs will like Royal…as most ladies like royalty 🤴🏼😄😉💨💨💨😆

[@kaiserhog]

I always keep a jar of CB Royal. It is good and comforting. It is not 1Q, it is better.

[@RedcoatsReturn]

I totally agree Robert😊👍👍…the topping is more complex…not just vanilla like 1-Q…Royal has liqueur, vanilla, cocoa and chocolate on top. Its more flavourful than Carter Hall and SWRA too since they moved production to the Dominican Rep. I wonder if CB is made in Denmark rather than the DR 🤔

[@kaiserhog]

@@RedcoatsReturn I just read online that it is produced in Denmark. Take that for what it is worth.

[@andreyradchenko8200]

I like their Gold blend the most, it isn't bitey but still has a pleasant taste and aroma. What's your opinion on it?

[@RedcoatsReturn]

I’ll have to try CB Gold…sounds good…I’ll order a pouch 😉 If you love vanilla…try CB Dark…its the most powerful vanilla blend I know 😄😉

[@andreyradchenko8200]

@@RedcoatsReturn I've tried it once out of curiosity, it's a really solid blend, but nothing tops gold for me. Guess that's a personal taste of mine. On an unrelated note, it's been getting harder and harder to find any pipe tobacco at brick&mortar retail, over the last four or so years the amount of weak rolling blends and chemical-soaked hookah junk increased and supply of pipe tobacco of all sorts decreased, to the point I'm lucky if I find any for sale at all.

[@EDICKINSON-rv5im]

The following video (See 10:57) gives you info re JimInks with Wilke pipe shop. I've heard you comment on his reviews. Thought you might like to see this. Cheers, Ed.

[@EDICKINSON-rv5im]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/n3azg4lqm8eUpqs Sorry!

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Thanks for the info, I‘m certainly interested…but….the link to the video was missing.

[@Pfeifenraucher_der_Insel]

Hola Lester. This was a very interesting comparison about two tobaccos which are unknown for me. I think both of them are not my taste. I think I will have the same problems with the Platinum like you. Do you know form Vauen the "Grandpa's Blend"? If you like Caramel I think this will be a very good choice for you my friend. Hav a good trip in 🇮🇹! Best wishes from the 🌞🏝. Michael

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Thank you Michael 😊👍👍 I’ll look for that Vauen blend…as I love caramel 😋😋😄😉💨💨💨

[@Pfeifenraucher_der_Insel]

I hope you'll like it 😉

[@matthewmosley4325]

Great review! Thanks for your thoughts on these. I look forward to trying the platinum. That's a really nice pipe, very unique! I'm enjoying some 1Q while watching. So far, I'm with you on the Royal but will be giving the platinum a try. 👍

[@RedcoatsReturn]

Thanks for watching Matt😊👍👍 Pack the Platinum blend tight and go real gentle…then its subtle flavours will embrace your palate indeed 😋😋