A Heathers The Musical Movie Is Happening??

What do you think about this cast?
Oh how the internet gets us excited about these things.
Enjoy the video!
Instagram:
Ryan - @ mccarya
Samantha - @ Samantha_Fekete
@samandryan
Sam's Book, Nightstand Notes: a.co/d/4Wf31uW
We're Sam & Ryan! Samantha Fekete is a content creator/production manager who works full time at Spellbound Inc. Ryan McCartan is an actor who you may recognize as Diggie from Disney Channel's Liv and Maddie, JD from Heathers the Musical, Hans from Frozen on Broadway, and more! We create content to entertain and inform. Subscribe to take a deep dive into out content! If you subscribe, you officially become Daddy, a part of the best fan base out there

[@marcrisflores]

“liz gillies could play JD and i’d watch it” truer words have never been spoken

[@variablecheesecake]

if liz gillies played jd i would buy tickets to every showing of the movie ever

[@I-defeted-Europe-in-1346]

I would sell out every theater for the entire time it's showing.

[@TiredMoonRabbit]

Yes she fucken could, victorious would have totally referenced something like that.

[@artsyfartsy748]

OK one thing I see is a lot of people fan casting Ryan and Barrett as the two cops for a cameo, which I think would be iconic

[@rosie6707]

they'd become everyone's favourite role 😅

[@HEATHERStheMUSICALfan1]

Imagine JD as like a 7/11 cashier lol

[@gengar2439]

Nah Kurt and rams actors

[@leep.9808]

this is the GREATEST thing ever

[@freyadoesitall]

Please they would kill it as the cops

[@savannah4439]

Hey, if Ben Platt could be Evan Hansen then Ryan can pull off JD at a Riverdale-style high school 😂

[@charlieneedshelp989]

Yeah but the dear Evan Hansen movie was bad 😂

[@sabinajoh]

@@charlieneedshelp989the makeup did him dirty though

[@ashleyhedrick5635]

But I don't want everyone hating on him like they did Ben Platt....

[@Rognik]

Just because Ben Platt did do it does not mean he could pull it off.

[@your.local.theaterkid]

ok but hear me out: winona ryder as veronica’s mom and barrett wilbert weed as ms. fleming

[@Heatherslover127]

This !

[@veronicasawyerrrrr]

YES

[@alypritchett2883]

YES

[@user-kz9ip4wk9n]

PLEASE I NEED THAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@Sarahgacha4561]

YES OMG

[@your.local.theaterkid]

if a heathers the musical movie is eventually made and includes “you’re welcome,” i am going to have to find a very nice corner to cry in.

[@pili_chaves]

I'll find the corner with You 😭

[@OliviaWilson-ww9jr]

Me too😭

[@aldendomino3523]

lol just make a mashup of blue and you’re welcome to piss everyone off, or create a brand new song for the movie to replace both (or piss me off and change it to dialogue like the mean girls musical movie)

[@aldendomino3523]

Ryan could do it, he doesn’t look that old… but his humor does make him sound like an asshole

[@ROCKYHORRORHURRAH]

share the corner

[@FunkeMonke-ff3kz]

If it ever does turn into a movie I’m signing a petition for Barrett to have a cameo

[@katysikkema]

And Jessica, Alice and Elle!! ❤

[@FunkeMonke-ff3kz]

True

[@stranger_things_fan_1015]

Or for her to play Veronica again

[@nativenewyorker3144]

@@stranger_things_fan_1015 I love that girl to death but Heathers actually destroyed her voice. I wouldn't wish that demanding of a role upon her again.

[@ischristinaok]

came here from rachel zegler’s tweet just to let y’all know this was an April fools joke

[@lillycummins7243]

GOOD

[@aislinnhurtado8318]

@@lillycummins7243BAD

[@nuggetdoja871]

They say that in the video 🤔

[@Buttercup174]

OMG I AM SO THANKFUL 🙏

[@samandryan]

Hi super late to this comment but can you please share what she tweeted? I’m just now noticing some comments like this. We’re both Rachel fans and totally understand it was an April fools joke, just wanted to talk about the idea of a hypothetical movie! But I can’t find anything she said about this video online! Any clarity would be appreciated! - Sam

[@StevenWithAStench]

Ryan, most teenagers in the 80s look older than they are already, you’re fine. Younger men playing a movie-musicalized JD aren’t real they can’t hurt you

[@marcrisflores]

this!

[@kalebparolin3113]

Just want to put this out there but Ryan as Kurt or Ram's dads in the future would be amazing.

[@Maddi_xoxo]

I was thinking JD’s dad only because he was JD but yeah like Kurt or Ram’s dads as long as “My Dead Gay Son” is in there lol

[@luna-mo3ol]

For Chandler, I honestly could totally see Sabrina Carpenter as her. I know you guys don't necessarily care for her much based on a past ranking video😭 but I LOVE her and her voice, and she's just gorgeous. I could see her playing someone with that type of attitude too

[@paytonjoy13]

tbh she would be such a good heather mac

[@hc50820]

@@paytonjoy13that’s what I thought, I cant see her as Chandler

[@luna-mo3ol]

​@@paytonjoy13 idk I can't really see that honestly. I can see Duke or chandler way more than mac cuz sabrina herself just gives really sassy (in a good way) boss vibes and I think that would play well as the other two. I can't really hear her singing lifeboat either, her voice fits more with the others

[@koiloylo]

@@luna-mo3oli can see duke tbh, just because she’s blonde doesn’t mean she suits mac

[@luna-mo3ol]

​@@koiloylo exactlyyy

[@tomorobo4472]

5:38 you know what happened with evan hansen💀

[@Thatonekidwholikesmusicals]

Even hansen was a banger

[@koiloylo]

@@Thatonekidwholikesmusicalsthe movie??? 😭

[@Thatonekidwholikesmusicals]

@@koiloylo yes….

[@ZidaneKiano]

"he's a decade older to play the character" lmao

[@jeremyweitendorf6723]

can’t believe they didn’t cast james corden

[@phasemollasis6748]

He should be Heather Duke 😂

[@lorenbennington4952]

Honestly with the Mean Girls movie Musical coming out and the wicked film coming this year. I honestly see a world that this could happen in. Badass women in musicals are having their moment so this honestly could happen in my opinion... Also I believe in Renee Rapp supremacy.. Renee Rapp as Heather Chandler

[@KelilaBennet]

"how. Literal. Dare. You. I. Am. THIRTY Years. Old."

[@andreadunn6874]

How I would cast: JD: Joshua Colley Veronica: Solea pfeiffer Chandler: Renee Rapp Duke: Amaya Braganza McNamara: Rachel Zegler edit: i didn't know Renee and Antonio Cipariano dated 😨

[@FunkeMonke-ff3kz]

Renee Rapp would be amazing

[@florencelovesfantasy]

RENEE AS CHANDLER I WAS THINKING THAT

[@keithwilson2345]

Rachel as McNamara makes me happy :) if she was Veronica I would be so angry lol

[@verityharris8551]

Putting Antonio and Renee together is just cruel lmao

[@SafiyaFoster]

I thought they were gonna say Renee as chandler but they didn’t and I was surprised

[@persephonebby]

ryan mccartan as the super senior jd lmfao 😭

[@hellooo6751]

omg i’m dead stoppppp 🙈🙈

[@aro5739]

ay veronica where's my hug at

[@realdeadgirlwalking]

veronica where my hug at why you gotta be like that mamas

[@EmisStillAtLarge]

wait this better not be an april fools prank

[@EmisStillAtLarge]

god damn it

[@lunaisluckyyyyyy4955]

I’m so glad it is tbh. I don’t ever want them to ruin heathers

[@Zen-ft5fj]

Popular movie musical could mean finally getting a Broadway run. I'd be down

[@fifteendozenalleyroses]

@@Zen-ft5fjbut look at what was done to Mean Girls the Musical😭 i don’t want that to happen to Heathers

[@ammmmyyyy]

exactly😭 it got too modernized and and for me, that lost the charm​@@fifteendozenalleyroses

[@ThatOneTeen288]

All I hope is that they don't make it like Riverdale

[@RoryOdonnell-ex8fe]

Not 2018 again

[@bi11lietsuki]

it's probably gonna me like mean girls 2024

[@ThatOneTeen288]

@@bi11lietsuki they ruined a few songs, but it's was a decent movie?

[@elliexoxo9284]

Jim parsons as miss Fleming would be iconic

[@BunnyNuit]

POV IF GEN-Z MADE THIS MOVIE IN A FEW YEARS: September 1st, 2029!

[@BunnyNuit]

Okay… but I wanna be Veronica plz 😂

[@talentedfailuree]

Ha. ha.

[@pastelcloudz12]

i wanna be heather mac

[@lesbiannoyed]

The number of octaves Sam's voice jumped when lying about Ryan on Riverdale had me cackling (love you Ryan).

[@Moon_427]

He could still play JD I mean like lots of people would be happy

[@bripk9598]

I just want to see Barrett... in everything... always. I love her voice.

[@emmabobemma5]

Guys it was an April fools prank please🥲

[@jaydss]

Ryan please I’ve literally spent the past three hours trying to scoure for clips of you as JD, Jessica as Heather Chandler and Barrett as Veronica. CAN YALL PLEASE REPRISE YOUR ROLES IF THERES A FILM OR EVEN A REMAKE ILL CRY HAPPY TEARS

[@minimockingjay7719]

IF YOU FIND ACT 2 PLEASE LET ME KNOW IVE BEEN TRYING ALL DAY

[@jaydss]

@@minimockingjay7719 hate to break it to u but… there is none… theres only ever been one bootleg and only the original recorder and ryan have it and both said theyll never release it

[@minimockingjay7719]

@@jaydss people have said that the entire show used to be uploaded on KZbin, and that Act 2 used to be on a now deleted Google drive file. The chances of it ever coming out are slim, but not none. Additionally, there are multiple recordings of it that were given to the cast and crew, as well as made for historical/archival purposes. There is a chance that this will be released eventually as an anniversary/final performance thing in the future. There's still a chance, although slim that it comes out.

[@minimockingjay7719]

Either way, there is a small possibility that it will be released, and if it doesn't, that's ok as well. Whatever the cast/crew/production company chooses to release is up to them and I'm sure will be best for all involved :)

[@jaydss]

@@minimockingjay7719 im aware of that brother ur the one that asked me lol no need for an essay

[@tuba8923]

I would sign anything for Ryan plays JD again

[@colonyofrats4193]

It was an April fools joke Jesus

[@marcuspd7502]

James Corden as Kurt and Ram.

[@FTMdoom]

he plays both of them and just talks to himself

[@marcuspd7502]

@@FTMdoom Maybe he wears an eye patch he moves from one eye to the other depending of who is speaking. Also, I smell a new song.

[@Hourspookie]

AM NOT EVEN HALF WAY INTO THE VIDEO BUT I JUST HAVE TO SAY AM JUST SO SO SO HAPPY THAT SO MANY PEOPLE EVEN KNOW HEATERS AND REMEBER IT, I NEVER GOT TO SEE IT IN THE RIGHT TIME SO THE PAST YEAR IVE BEEN OBSESSED BUT LIKE ITS BEEN OVER 6 YEARS I THINK AND I COULNT FIND PEOPLE WHO ALSO LIKED IT. THE FACT THERES A MOVIE COMING I MEAN GEEZ❤❤(sry for bad grammar i was typing fast)

[@arubinojr5670]

Really looking forward to seeing Cole Sprouse in action as JD. He's gonna knock it out of the park and there's gonna be so much Logos about it.

[@astridholmhansen]

if they actually make a movie version of the musical and rachel zegler is playing veronica, i think i would literally pass away (in a good way, i love her and really think she would be an amazing veronica please)

[@emalaw1329]

I'd pass away if she were to play Eurydice in Hadestown, honestly. Since her performance as Lucy Gray in the Hunger Games could be seen as a perfectly valid audition for it, and Hadestown right now is kinda going through this phase of stunt/gimmick casting for several of the main roles, I don't see what stands in the way of a Zegler Eurydice (in actuality it's probably her filming schedule, she seems booked and busy at the moment). She gets a lot of hate from ugly, way too mainstream corners of the internet, but there's no way the Broadway community wouldn't welcome her with open arms.

[@iammary191995]

⁠@@emalaw1329before Sondheim passed away didn’t he describe Rachel’s voice as sounding like a nightingale? If that’s not a recommendation that Broadway should accept, I don’t know what is 😅

[@ROCKYHORRORHURRAH]

I’ve been refreshing my KZbin page for the past 3 hours because ive been waiting for this. (Not even joking I’ve been so excited) love you guys ❤❤❤

[@TheVendettaMcQueen]

If I got to direct a Heathers the Musical the Movie my casts would probably be “Could easily pass for highschool cast” Veronica - Hailey Kilgore JD - Antonio Cipriano H. Chandler - Reneé Rapp H. Duke - Rachel Zegler/Olivia Rodrigo H. McNamara - Eva Noblezada “Riverdale-esque cast” for Ryan of course Veronica - Demi Lovato??? JD - Ryan H. Chandler - Anna Camp H. Duke - Elizabeth Gillies H. McNamara- Anna Kendrick Martha - Alex Newell

[@MARVEL_FAN24]

If Barrett is up to it I think she could also pass as a Riverdale-ish high schooler

[@allthingsfandoms6833]

I can also see Antonio Cipriano as a JD and Maia Reficco as a Heather Duke or McNamara or even Veronica really

[@julian2grande]

YES MAIA AS MCNAMARA

[@Cloud9berries]

I was so confused at first because a heathers musical movie/proshot already happened 😂

[@queengeorgia8594]

whoa look at this rebrand

[@yee-raplantar-maximoff4318]

I've been thinking non-stop about a Heathers musical-movie ever since the Mean Girls musical-movie released, the timing of this video is borderline scary 😂

[@candicematheny6025]

Ryan played Tony in West Side Story last summer.

[@StevenWithAStench]

Tony’s age doesn’t really matter in WSS

[@packerjock]

And BRILLIANTLY, I might add!!!!

[@camxsst1nky]

if we ever got heathers the movke musical just cast ryan as every role he would eat that up

[@sopita2236]

I’ve thought about this so much I completely agree

[@leep.9808]

what the hell did i just watch? i loved every second.

[@scollaceyuri]

i'll still probably be watching it..idk i'm a movie musical apologist

[@OPIUMAxoloxi_-cl1de]

Ok, but like imagine this happens in three years because they did this with Wicked and Mean Girls and both times three years later we get the movie

[@theyadoreemadz]

ryan it’s okay! to let go you can let jd go

[@jaydss]

no he cannot

[@luna_elvenstar]

bro if i was in heathers off broadway even as an ensemble i wouldn’t let it go ever, he was *JD*

[@jaydss]

@@luna_elvenstar literally let alone being a mainnnn main character

[@multi3ditz]

As much as I’d believe Diablo Cody would and absolutely could remake a heather’s the musical movie it’s a little suspicious considering it was posted on April fools 😭😭 but that would actually be awesome especially considering Cody is great for dark, gritty, women focused films

[@SizzlingVibe]

*greetings and salutations fellow teenagers*

[@angelaribaudo2919]

Imagine Ryan playing Jd ‘s dad in a new adaptation

[@Sassievn]

I mean if Ben Platt can play Evan Hansen in the movie, Ryan can definitely play JD! I would watch it for sure!

[@mariapelzer8005]

What we learned from that though is that dear Evan Hansen movie TANKED and ben being so old for the role was one of the main reasons

[@sunshineeee]

If it’s not entirely an April Fools joke, it’s definitely intended to test the waters

[@charli_obss3sions]

The way he said timothee chalmet

[@funkyfrogcos]

lol my first thought was "Rachel's a sapranno, not a mezzo"

[@bobbyjayjohnson3460]

I’d like to see Ryan do covers of JD Heathers songs,

[@user-po3li8cu1t]

He doesn't need to do covers. he's the original cast recording

[@LittleBrainReallyEvilHeart]

Okay people idk if this is actually happening but lets just hope that the casting and characters are accurate to the og musical

[@SeaRavioli-TF2]

Kurt & Ram as Dwayne Johnson and Vin Diesel??

[@emalaw1329]

It would be the second "You're Welcome" number in which The Rock gets a solo

[@Brawl483]

This is a lot of energy for April Fools

[@pokemonbb4227]

I love how half way through it turned into 7 year olds playing family

[@karisarmstrong4567]

i would die if Rachel Zegler played veronica in the best way possible

[@therealVeronicaSawyer]

If it's the west end version I'm gonna scream. (315th like, here early, love yall!)

[@Heatherslover127]

Heyyy!

[@therealVeronicaSawyer]

@@Heatherslover127 Hii!

[@ultimateships]

Damn it, i was really thinking about all the possible actors i would want to see in the movie, and who i BETTER NOT see in such a classic, as well as a fundamental musical that i know got so many people into musicals in the first place. nice joke, definitely got a reaction from me😂

[@Icefrompacificocean]

ALERT ‼️🚨⚠️ SAM AND RYAN POSTED

[@lunaisluckyyyyyy4955]

I’m scared about this tbh 😭

[@sadieclark2015]

I’m excited!!!! but if they mess this up i’m going to hate whoever made the movie, Heathers is my favorite musical.

[@Stella.416]

Apparently it's an April Fool's Day prank

[@sadieclark2015]

@@Stella.416 yea i commented that before i watched the video

[@speakingofnblla]

so off topic from everything in this video but sam is GORGEOUS here wow, (she's always gorg but i love her fit/jewelry here) face card NEVER declines PERIODDD

[@starilyn]

i would love for ryan to be jd again if it happens i think i might explode

[@imhavingsomuchfun7464]

I mean we had the heathers proshot and I think that is enough.

[@ur.funnyy]

PLEASEEE

[@ayalakiviti6491]

Talia Ryder is Veronica!!!!!! She looks like her she's beautiful and she's perfect for the role (Plus Winona Ryder Talia Rider get what I mean)

[@suavefrog5029]

Omg she’s perfect

[@JackieWarner13]

2mins into the video seeing the screenshot & it saying April 1st made me realise it was an April fools post

[@keithwilson2345]

HEATHERS THE MUSICAL WAS NOT TEN YEARS AGO AGHHHH I FEEL OLD

[@katieantrim4600]

When I saw the title I instantly thought "wasn't the musical based off the heathers movie from the 1980s??" Like that doesn't make sense.

[@eesgaming7319]

they did it with mean girls

[@strwberiisoph]

I screamed out loud no you better be fucking joking

[@whatwhatwhatidkwhatstuff]

I love heathers and I can’t tell whether I need this or not

[@kokonafriedchicken9031]

damn i wish this wasn’t an april fools prank

[@tammyrock4500]

LOVE U GUYSSS

[@auspicious93]

Sam looking gorg

[@carlthegamernpc849]

People arguing if it should be you're welcome or blue but why not both first blue and in the end of blue Veronica tries to get away right well what if ram or Kurt stopped her and starts singing you're welcome

[@Belle-Rose-Choudhury09]

i actually like that, that sounds like a great idea! id love to see how that works!

[@lornatw]

Honestly I'm quite happy with the other movies that are out there. But whatever sure I'll eat up another one lol

[@JenniferMcMahonhawaii78]

Better music than Mean Girls.

[@disasterd0lls]

i think they should add the og cast for heathers in (the ones that are alive) but like AS THE OLDER CHARACTERS. SO LIKE CHRISTIAN SLATER AND WINONA RYDER AS MR AND MRS SAWYER ECT

[@Theestybestie30]

YESSS

[@disasterd0lls]

@@Theestybestie30 YESYES

[@aloidia222]

im so happy that they’re making one omg

[@aloidia222]

@@miaveale3751 yeah ik im playing along

[@miaveale3751]

@@aloidia222 okay lol sorry! ❤️

[@MummyPigsBoots]

The woman who played Heather Chandler was in my UK tour of wicked and I got her signature at stage door before even knowing about her being my favourite character in the film recording of my favourite musical 😭 😭 😭 I was so so so so sooooooo happy!!!

[@nataliewilson23]

NO WAY!!!! THATS AWESOME 🎉

[@phlegm_globber]

Honestly I don’t think I want this to happen. BUT if it ever did, it should be in the future so I can play Veronica 😁

[@luna_elvenstar]

pfft ur so real for that

[@v1zqx]

if heathers ever got turned into a movie i’d pray they don’t fuck it up as badly as they did with mean girls 😭

[@destinystarrr_]

Ok but considering the mean girls movie recently I would be interested to hear the agenda

[@lilavril3]

tbh seeing real teens or teen-passing ppl in heather’s would feel wrong due to the context. like adults playing teens feels more camp less real?

[@TLD033]

Antonio Cipriano as JD?

[@duane_f]

Can't wait for the red carpet premier! 🤣

[@katysikkema]

Why did they play with my feelings like that 😭 I would have LOVED a heathers musical movie as long as it’s good. Like please don’t mess it up 🫶🏼

[@beltingtokra]

There's a pro-shot of the London production, I genuinely dont think the world needs a movie of Heathers rn

[@SageAd0ptMe]

BRO I WISH!! RACHEL WOULD BE PERFECT FOR VERONICA

[@elijahravensy9859]

OK OK HEAR ME OUT.... Ryan and Barett as veronica's parents...😮

[@aarongilmore1254]

You guys realize that Heathers the musical the staged show was filmed for stage on the Roku Channel right?

[@defnot_alyssa]

WAIT IM SCARED WHATTT

[@supimreallytired]

if a new heathers movie comes out if chris evans, chris pratt, and chris hemsworth aren't the heathers im not watching it

[@lindsay1989]

Honestly Megan Rapp could be Chandler

[@evanbowers5299]

I want Joshua Cooley and Sophia ann Coroso to be JD and Veronica

[@federicopagesbergese1077]

Ryan listen to me you MUST produce Heathers the musical the movie, and obviously cast yourself :)

[@Phuboslive]

Simon Gordon better be JD 😛

[@persephonebby]

ELIZABETH TEETER AS VERONICA PLEASE AND THANK YOU