A Messy Tiktok "Dr" Exposed, Gisou PR Mailer Called Out, Rose INC Loses It's Rose - Ugly News

[@JamesWelsh]

Check out Dr Angelo Landriscina MD socials @ dermangelo on all socials. You can also check out My magic healer products for yourself here: mymagichealer.com/

[@arwen_2.0]

I saw you corrected the Loose/lose mistake :)

[@Mc-fe3qe]

While it’s good that you’ve credited them, maybe next time you/your editors could cut down their video instead of putting all of it in the video. It’s 6 minutes of someone else’s content and (imo) we didn’t need the entire video for context, we watch for you not for someone else /gen

[@AliceHunter-0827]

The products may be lovely, but personally, I would not be inclined to buy from a brand with a name like that - even without the messy "doctor" spokesperson. It just doesn't sit right. You got the gist of the joke at 17:25. (I left it in a comment on your video about the TikTok doc who kept insisting that water deactivates glycolic acid.) Thanks for another great video. I hope you have a wonderful weekend.

[@MarjaMariachi]

Dude looks like he's Alexandra Anele's brother! :P Just putting it out there... if the two of them ever meet and do a collab, I would watch the ever-living sh!# out of it! As someone with premature white hair, I love seeing people rock that look, whether dyed or natural.

[@MeganNoelRhea]

Ew. My sister’s name is Arwen. She’s just as obnoxious.

[@livesouthernable]

That med student critiquing the derm for wearing a funny shirt is so odd to me. What does fashion have to do with science? 😂

[@karaiakauma3179]

Home girl was reaching, straining even

[@linseylinsey]

People always try weird stuff like that with professionals trying to say female professionals can't post in bikinis and medical doctors can't wear a silly shirt. Meanwhile, anyone can buy scrubs or a lab coat. What you're wearing has nothing to do with your knowledge of a subject.

[@JamesWelsh]

Like dr’s have to live in scrubs their entire life and aren’t allowed a personality

[@linseylinsey]

@@JamesWelsh absolutely. There's a larger conversation about "professionalism" that's been taking place and this critique or attempt to discredit Dr. Angelo is an example of that

[@livesouthernable]

@@JamesWelsh exactly

[@samanthaabreu782]

Med student probably in the beginning or middle of the course, those are the worst, they see a cell under the microscope for the first time and voilà, a microbiologist is born. To be honest I think is urgent that EVERY university start giving an ethics course that's mandatory to any student, the lack of professionalism and ethics is mind-boggling

[@ellenkarlsson9490]

I hade to share my hostel with a group of "doctors" from Yale who were on a volunteer trip in Panama. Turns out they were first year pre-med, most of them only 18 years old. They took themselves *way* too seriously. I will never forget when one of them felt a bit ill and was laying on the couch surrounded by "doctors" trying to diagnose her. Their "medical" volunteering mostly consisted of them wheeling the old ladies from the senior home around town. (Also, the hostel never got paid for them staying there because the money Yale paid for the trip went straight up the nose of their coordinator.)

[@KayJoyy]

I agree whole heartedly

[@Dunika]

Totally agree with you. I once saw a comment of a “podologist student” on a video claiming the patient on said video had flat feet from being obese, that he has seen that countless times on “his patients”. Not only was the patient not obese (only overweight), but their arches were so high I could have fitted my whole fist under them and the voiceover from the video clearly stated the patient had a neuropathy (charcot tooth Marie syndrome) that made its arches so high they were walking only on the outer side of the foot and had completely destroyed the natural cushioning of their foot in that area.

[@3.toads.in.a.trenchcoat]

I dunno for the us, but ethics course are part of the cursus in Canada....

[@hinatamercury]

I dunno about other countries but there is actually an ethics subject for nursing, doctors, law, and even mass communication in my country (SEA) but its not taught during 1st year but around 3rd year or 4th year

[@Thecrowfens]

It always fascinates me when a med student goes viral for giving “advice.” Even if their school doesn’t have a social media policy, they’ve definitely had *several* discussions about this kind of improper conduct 😬

[@JustAFace_InTheCrowd]

As someone who went to didn’t finish their degree (for psych, not med school), whenever I share anything I learned from my studies, I always give a disclaimer. It’s possible to be well educated in something, but it’s important to let people know that so they at least have the opportunity to realize they should check to see what you’re saying is concrete. Second opinions are important, with anything. Especially anything involving health advice. I’m literally at the halfway point from a masters degree (I really just don’t want it anymore… not after what happened, long story), and I will always admit I don’t know everything. I personally don’t find anything wrong with sharing an educated opinion, however it’s just important to say you’re not currently in the field, where you actually witness things changing in real time. Because you’re not a professional with a license, you’re not there to learn the new things that happen- and that’s why it’s important to say you’re not, cause you might’ve not been taught something or missed something. I don’t understand why people want to pretend to be something they’re not so badly nowadays. I personally struggle to simply be myself, so I find it incredibly…. Odd. Like… these people would be so much better off trying to get into acting, the way they’re already pretending to be other people. Plus, having the title DOCTOR is actually a whole heck of a lot to live up to…. Like… why not pick something easier? Lmfao 😬

[@skinme2340]

Everybody gives advice these days.

[@BreakofDawn]

I highly doubt she even is a med student. I don’t think a real med student would spend their precious time, spend all that money on schooling, just to waste it on making up blatant lies on TikTok and basically damaging any chance they had in becoming a real doctor

[@when-do-we-get-a-block-button]

​@@BreakofDawnyoud be shocked, being in med school (be it anything from mental health to physical health, even surgeons) can give some people an insane sense of superiority. its not all, but a good handful end up with a huge ego because they get told "you're a doctor you are a hero" and forget to remember they are still a human with human flaws.

[@thesussexbunion]

You're not kidding. Asking for a consult on a brain bleed, and after a second year student leaves, a third year comes in and refers to him as his "subordinate."🙄 He then proceeded to ignore our concerns, and the man died unnecessarily of the condition we called them to assess.🤬🤬🤬

[@linseylinsey]

"POV: you wash your face with your hands." Yeah, I also wash my hands with my hands too! Mind. Blown! It's completely safe and works!

[@shortcake66]

When I first saw that I thought “What am I supposed to use? My feet?”

[@linseylinsey]

@@shortcake66 I think as long as you close the toilet, feet are a good option

[@pinkbubblesnake]

​@shortcake66 you need to use your elbows as we know from covid elbows are more hygienic than hands!

[@ellenkarlsson9490]

When you wash your face with your hands you also wash your hands with your face. 🧠

[@ellenkarlsson9490]

@@linseylinsey 😂😂😂

[@adafihj6439]

Oh she activated James's petty side. So long Dr Messy

[@JamesWelsh]

🤭

[@LunarEleven]

And bless her little heart for that! I love that she posted a picture of "this dermatologist" slaying in a crimson corset thinking she was discrediting HIM. 😆 That just tells me everything I need to know. She's an ignorant homophobe that thinks an outfit can be demonic and has a pathological fear of toilets. That's basically 3 phobias just at a glance. She proves that fear is the mind killer cause girly is braindead 💀 James makes me proud to watch his channel, I have so much respect for people who aren't afraid to use the voice their platform gave them 🫶🏻 (Edit: I'm not familiar with @dermangelo so I apologize if "him" was the incorrect pronoun!)

[@misshell2223]

Fkn love this!!!!!

[@justkiddin84]

Came to say this: not a doctor got James mad! Good job, though! She needed to be stopped.✌️♥️

[@MishaSims]

yasss 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@dobbsy22]

I’ve never understood why they don’t just send out mini sizes for PR. The person promoting is still going to use the product and review it but it’s not wasteful. Sending somebody full size foundations in every shade has never made sense anyway…

[@tsunfish9443]

I wish it was easier to find mini sizes to buy for trying too... Hopefully I just did it wrong, but I physically walked into Ulta the other day, could only find one product I was interested in, and it was still like 9 or 10 dollars for I guess a half sized La Roche Possay wash XD

[@celeste7987]

Dr Mehss reminds me of "psych majors" trying to diagnose people (actual people, not fictional characters) on the internet when all they've got are some undergrad credits, no clinical experience, and no patient history or interview. Stay in school, lol.

[@laurentoren]

i’m a psych grad student living with another psych grad student. even with a masters, we aren’t allowed to diagnose without either a phd or a license. she has neither. she has been going around with her DSM offering ACTUAL DIAGNOSES TO PEOPLE!!! huge ethical issue. we learn not to do that in the first few grad classes. it’s so annoying because people like her give psych students a bad rep.

[@bisexualantigone]

​@@laurentorenbet that girl is white and well off too lol

[@cs4849]

I’m a clinical psychologist and it drives me nuts that so many people think they are psychologist because they’ve taken a few courses. Even with a doctoral degree, I don’t diagnose people that I don’t actually work with in person.

[@kfkkfk7995]

​@@bisexualantigonewhy would that even matter though? Dr ramani is a big proponent of armchair diagnosing and shes definitely not white 💀💀

[@teddycinema]

right like u correct them n they say "it's giving dissociative identity disorder🤷‍♀️"

[@SeewahBeewah]

Wow. As a pharmacist the misinformation allowed on social media is mortifying. Thanks for bringing this misinformation to the surface James

[@missbubble44]

🇨🇦 PharmD student here, and I could not agree more

[@MamaMOB]

Who owns the internet? You say that stuff is allowed on the internet... so who owns it?

[@ReptilianTeaDrinker]

@@MamaMOB So, you're cool with people spreading misinformation that could be potentially harmful? You completely missed the point and got all defensive for absolutely no reason.

[@karaiakauma3179]

I think the med student was aiming for some tiktok clout and got mad an ACTUAL doctor was disproving her baseless claims Had to edit cause OMG I CANT BELIEVE SHE BLOCKED YOU

[@eiwansk]

I went to her page, I’m shocked she has so many followers asking for advice. WILD

[@girrl88]

OMG you actually read my comment about how if you graduate bottom of your class you are still called a doctor. You just made my day!!! I also really need to thank you for recommending COSRX snail mucin. I have incredibly dry skin which causes rough patches. I've tried soooo many moisturizers and none of them gave my skin what it needed. The snail mucin has made such a difference in only 2 weeks. You saved my skin.

[@RG.9970]

The COSRX line has been a staple for me for almost a decade. They always have something for someone.

[@girrl88]

@@RG.9970 I honestly feel a little silly for waiting so long to try it. It is a bit more than I want to spend but it's done wonders so far. What products would you recommend?

[@norahulsey7247]

I broke out severely to the snail mucin but gave it to someone who I thought could and would use it . I didn't go fear mongering about

[@wplants9793]

I tried Peach slices snail mucin but it didn’t really help! Maybe CosRx is where it’s at

[@girrl88]

@@wplants9793 If you want to give it a try it's on sale at YesStyle right now, $12 instead of $19. I don't know if I'd have bought it full price just to try it out but it's def worth the $$.

[@mei1568]

The "messy" doctor has always made my blood boil. She started popping up on my FYP with those fear mongering videos and I commented on a couple of her videos about "toxic beauty" that she is not a real doctor. She hasn't responded though, not that I expected her to either yk. Anyways, sooooo so glad she's getting the criticism she deserves, hope there are legal actions that can be filed for fake doctors like her too

[@James-z8u4f]

Dr Messy, how accurate

[@JamesWelsh]

🤭

[@coffee_2234]

Lol fr messy is accurate

[@KayJoyy]

When a brand responds in this type of way it makes me want to completely support them. I have so much respect for that

[@TheDevilChrno]

She gives MLM Hon vibes. 😂

[@Queenofmercuryretrograde]

Totally 😂

[@Wiingashkikwe]

“Dr” Mehraveh Sayyah (if that’s her real name) is based in Istanbul. I’m not sure what the rules are there. There’s also a Reddit thread from a person whose picture she stole for her social media. Claiming whatever condition they have was caused by them sleeping on the wrong side of their body. She needs to be deplatformed.

[@47missjane]

The Gisou PR is very interesting - I remember in 2020 there was a huge push from/for creators on KZbin specifically to stop taking as much PR and doing PR hauls. I think it was led by Sam Ravandahl talking about the packaging waste. It feels like now we're watching the second "wave" of that with Tik Tok creators who gained their popularity after that.

[@lexwithbub]

I must say that gisou package is BEAUTIFUL though. Whoever designed the whole package did an amazing job.

[@kairos-049]

“Dr” Mehss posing as a med student or physician while not putting her government name on her profile is already suspect. Like yes, privacy good, but if we can’t verify your credentials then you may as well not have any.

[@achocot]

Just for info: there are places like Germany where the title Dr. is reserved for those with a PhD (research degree). One can be an MD but not have the Dr title or, very often, they have both because they have also done enough research to earn them that.

[@404bug]

I'm from germany and this is absolutely true . Even dentists are not called Dr's until they do their research.

[@mitalichinmulgund8679]

​@@404bugwhile here in India, physiotherapists with a bachelor's degree fought to be called "dr". Crazy

[@LauraLVTGW]

As a Licenced Veterinary Technician since 1992 with extensive experience in specialty and emergency, I hate giving advice to friends and family, much less to the public. Only Doctors can diagnose, I may know what the condition is but would never discuss with the client unless the Doctor has spoken to them first. I truly hope people pretending to be doctors online are prosecuted, by licenced lawyers. Many blessings!!!💖💖💖

[@julsdemers4740]

The best advice to give a friend is to ask the correct professional for their problem 😊

[@katiastas3828]

Having a qualification/ dregree does not automatically make you an expert. In fact, real experts in science will never say YES/NO facts like that as science is very dynamic and it is a constant learning process. Trust only official approved sources and read several of them to make your own decision on topics of your interest 😎👍🏼 love u James xxxxxx

[@MamaMOB]

That's why the closest thing in science to a fact is a theory. Science does not deal in facts it deals in theories. Because any theory can be disproven at any time. Science is literally a process it is not a thing. People need to get over the idea that it's a thing.

[@satanyanko]

Agreed 👍 Like James said, it's authority bias... Even a doctor who graduated at the bottom of their class is a doctor... When I learned about the beef between Doctor Mike and Dr. Charles I was flabbergasted - the latter tried to discredit the former bc he didn't like being corrected after spreading potentially harmful medical advice. Dr. Charles blocked Dctor Mike and his dog on all platforms afterwards (you can't make stuff like this up 😂)

[@julsdemers4740]

there's a reason things are called "theories" in science, and its exactly because of this, scientists are always open to their findings being debunked, so they will never call something a fact, its a theory and always will be, and what we colloquially call "theories" are what scientists call "hypothesis"

[@KylaKupid]

I wish they would send customers PR like a raffle! Let people who love the brand win a PR package by entering their email on the website or something. People who could never imagine reciving such a lavish gift instead of some influencers who receive things like this on the daily, like you said will probably just go to waste.

[@upcloseonbeauty]

They could do like Dior and create a customer programme that, depending on how much you spend, you get a reward. I think all brands should do that. Customers should get PR too ☺️

[@goingferalluvs]

Bring back influencer raffles. Might remind a few influences why doing things for their fans and giving back is fulfilling instead of just hoarding it "in case" because so many things like to slap Limited Edition on the label to increase urgency

[@Arvak]

It's so important that we keep spreading the message that skincare is a very personal thing, and different products will work for different people. I have very dry and sensitive skin, it took me many years to find products that truly work for me and don't irritate my skin (despite trying many that claimed to be suitable for dry sensitive skin) and now I've been using the same products religiously for months. I'll never follow skincare trends, it's just not realistic to say that whatever products are trending are the best products for every skin type!

[@H.A.-zr2wc]

Friday doesnt start until the Welshes post 💜💜💜

[@TheWolfeDen]

Lmao I didn't see her name at first and definitely thought you were being shady by calling her "Dr. Mess"

[@nadiahassan5307]

It always makes me think about those extravagant gift bags for movie stars, where gifts are always given to the people who least need it. Honestly they should just buy it as a business expense and just raffle off all the PR.

[@2nicnag2]

Exactly!! I’ve never understood the point in giving wealthy people more items!

[@asum7213]

Because they're trying to go above and beyond to get in their good graces. I don't agree with it for the record.

[@2nicnag2]

@@asum7213 I totally agree, I’m glad some people end up giving their items to people in need

[@solabis]

Jordan Peterson is the best example why we shouldnt just trust healthcare professional because of what they do or used to do for a job lol

[@SwanTheQueen]

He was good, now he is unhinged 😂

[@maryeckel9682]

Good example

[@MamaMOB]

Why because he doesn't want to mutilate your 8-year-old? Sorry but your son will never be your daughter.

[@juliasantosmoura1298]

This vid reminds me of a lesson I teach at a foreign language school that focuses on decoding bulls*t language on news headlines related to science and health - but to contextualise the start of the lesson I asked them how they got science and health info and basically all students answered tktk. Oh dear, it instantly became a whole different lesson. Thanks for your content!! Always great!!

[@AKbaby89]

Ive had to explain to numerous drs and nurses that i cannot possibly be pregnant because i had to have a total hysterectomy and oophorectomy. So sadly, there are drs who are just not very bright. And most drs really only know anything about their specific field. A dermatologist isnt going to know anything about Endometriosis, and my Endometriosis specialist isnt going to know anything about my Cyclic vomiting syndrome. Which is why i have 5 different drs. So yeah, someone being a dr does NOT mean they know what theyre talking about😂

[@lettievanhemert]

I used to love PR hauls. Now, declutters are so much more satisfying.

[@Uncle_Smidge]

Ugh, medical scaremongering drives me BONKERS. I work in a hospital and some of the shit we hear is just... tragic. Also, coming after a board certified medical professional for their fabulousity off the clock is some insecure bigot shit. We see you, ma'am.

[@sumlem]

It worries me that someone pretending to be a doctor (allegedly) is comfortable being bigoted publicly. It makes you wonder if their ethics would be compromised in actual practice

[@whoahanant]

A toilet seat being up is perfectly fine EXCEPT when it's flushing. When you flush a toilet it sprays tons of miniscule droplets of water out into the air at some pretty high speeds depending on what kind of toilet you have of course. So a toilet being open while showering isn't an issue, flushing it while leaving it open can spread stuff across your bathroom though. Which of course all comes back to touching your skin. It's not really about skincare anyways, it's more about hygiene and the bacteria and germs that can be sitting on your countertops and even toothbrush. So reminder to close the toilet lid when flushing.

[@jwolfe1209]

We keep ours closed all the time, but that's more because our cats are clumsy idiots who like throwing things off counters. And having had to give post toilet-diving baths on TWO separate occasions I will firmly be in the "keep it closed" camp 😑

[@whoahanant]

​@@jwolfe1209 I also have cats and we have elected to just keep the bathroom door shut at all times lmfao

[@RachelBJ]

@@jwolfe1209 This is the same reason I have to keep the toilets in my house closed! My cat has been known to drink from the toilet (so gross), fall into the toilet, & knock things into the toilet. I swear he's worse than a human toddler sometimes!

[@gunshitknife]

Yes, if she sits there waiting to catch all the droplets on her face when flushing, she'll probably get acne.

[@tsunfish9443]

Thank you so much for this PSA, someone asked to close the lid for this reason when I was in college and I've stuck to it for almost 10 years. ......meanwhile inregards to the cat comments, it is kind of funny, I also started closing my bathroom door to stop having to deal with my budget roomba from getting stuck on the bath mat... Hahhahaa

[@iamnotaconcept]

imagine if Gissou gifted those fridges to small salons who could use them as gifts for new clients, etc.

[@will-o-the-wisp-witch]

That gissou fridge sure did pan out well in terms of promotion. Seems like any pr is good pr and theres no really losing for them. Aside from that, the fridge itself is super cute and retro looking. I love those old rounded design refrigerators.

[@asum7213]

I was thinking they didn't hit the mark with the design, just looks flimsy I guess. You should see Smeg's fridges, although if you're into retro rounded fridges you probably already heard of it. Only problem is the price point.

[@KayJoyy]

It would've been less wasteful and made a lot more sense if they did that with those cute retro cosmetics fridges.

[@SwanTheQueen]

Nah i was planning to get the hair oil but not after this! 😂 I’m not paying overpriced stuff to pay influencers get this packages is insanity. Consumers are paying for this. Anyways that’s the only product kinda worth it so won’t miss much but yeah this literally stop me to buy so I’m grateful I watched this! 😅 saved me the bucks!

[@lindsay419]

Dr (air quotes) messy 😂😂 Amazing

[@akiragalbreath4532]

I love your voice, and find it so calming! I’ve been so stressed lately, and so I’m making a routine out of saying a prayer, lighting a candle and listening to your lovely accent. You could read off your grocery list and I’d be transfixed! God bless you sir, I hope you have a wonderful day! ❤

[@LynnR10]

Don’t mehss with James! Love that you brought it to the company’s attention and they acted on it.

[@FaraGeso]

Unrelated but I absolutely love the gentle slow music you use when you speak it fits your calm gentle voice so beautifully

[@yvielou]

Go on James!! Love it when you get a bee in your bonnet and call out these "creators".... keep up the good work and the exquisite levels pettiness x

[@oliverwortley3822]

it’s not just wasteful - it’s insulting to the regular and normal people, and upsetting too. it just makes us jealous and bitter.

[@jeon_artemis]

Isn't your own emotions your own responsibility? Why should a brand be responsible that you feel jealous? 😅😅

[@oliverwortley3822]

@@jeon_artemis grow up

[@adafihj6439]

I am totally and completely burnt-out on tiktok and social media experts on everything. That's why i stick to my trusted few and i still google what they say

[@eveenala]

17:13 I completely agree with this sentiment. If there’s a symptom or a potential underlying non-disease related issue, a home remedy is fine. It can resolve an issue. When my hair starts shedding heavily, ginger and jojoba oil work for me personally. But that’s not going to help someone whose hair loss is the result of a deficiency or illness.

[@AKbaby89]

Michelle is coming out with a book all about beauty and the science behind how things work, and i ordered it and im so excited to read it. Michelle is by far one of my favorite professional whos also a creator, she just explains things in such an easy way to follow. I dont usually watch drs (outside a few that are specialists in one of my conditions) because all the real drs tend to not explain things dumb enough for me to understand, then theres the pretend drs like the guy who thinks filler and highlight are the same thing😂

[@AKbaby89]

@dizzieblonde same, it's great timing cuz I've been wanting to learn more about hair and how I can make my hair more healthy, and id much rather learn from Michelle. I love the way she explains things, she's not intimidating to learn from🫶

[@susanagomez955]

In Spain we have 2 different words: "Médico" all the students that finished the University plus all the practice and passed all exams are Médicos. Doctor is only a person that makes his/her PHD and is the highest academic level. And you have Doctors in Language, in Laws, etc. So if she finished her University and passed all her exams she's a Médico, what ypu usually call Doctor. And can be doing a residency or be intern to specialise on one specific field. In my country all the interns and residents are already doctors and finished their basic studies. Then they can stay like that and be a family doctor or go for an specific specialising such Dermatologist (3 years) Psychiatrist (5 years) and so on so forth.

[@will-o-the-wisp-witch]

Thats interesting to know. In the USA, there are "doctorate degrees" that also be any thing from law, archeology, education.

[@susanagomez955]

@@will-o-the-wisp-witch I think it maybe the same PHD degree but here is the highest level you can reach after finishing your career, so the basic studies in university + practice in hospital or as free lawyer or whatever practice your career may set as part of it. So even if people say. ..I have a Doctor appointment, most of the time, 99,9% of the times they DON’T have a doctor appointment, they have a medical appointment, no mater if your medical appointment is with a neurologist, traumatologist, gynecologist....etc. Most probably is they never ever got the Doctor degree (Doctorado) as is spending like 2 to 3 years of research to prepare a paper that you must defend in front of the most taught Doctors (real Doctors) of your specific career. So for the most, unless you're really really gifted, nobody goes for Doctorado. I, as nurse for 38 years only met 2 Doctors in medicine and one Doctor in English Language in my whole 60 years.

[@harrietxo2310]

@@will-o-the-wisp-witchyeah it’s a phd

[@will-o-the-wisp-witch]

@@susanagomez955 The only person that I have met with a doctorate degree was a science teacher of mine at college. I chose to go to that college just so I could learn from him. He was constantly doing research to the extent that he hardly had time to teach. Made me realize that I did not want to even consider that level of education.

[@00Rav3n00]

So, in the US, a doctorate is one of the highest degrees someone can earn in many different fields. For example, I am a political science study, I will be going to Law school and I will earn a JD (Juris Doctorate), so I will technically be a "doctor" because I will have a Doctorate degree. However, I can not call myself a medical doctor because I don't have a medical degree or a medical license; I also will not be able to call myself a lawyer because I will not be a practicing lawyer (meaning I have not take or passed the bar exam, and I have not be approved by the American Bar Association). It is actually illegal and punishable by jail time; lawsuit; or a fine to claim that you are a practicing medical doctor or a practicing lawyer, and provide someone with advice in either of those fields when it is not a factual statement. So the messy doctor was, in fact, committing a crime in the US (granted, I don't know where she is in the world, and it would have to be brought to the attention of law enforcement/government officials to be properly handled).

[@CaliforniaBabe0525]

There's a blush from Rose Inc. that I really love but it's no longer sold at Sephora. 😕maybe it will come back

[@seok-jin514]

This video was so necessary. Thanks for spreading the word about this !!

[@raenoway]

Gisous sending all of that to influencers is so damn wasteful. That’s money that could go to giving their employees raises that may be living paycheck to paycheck. That money could have been donated. So damn wasteful. Hate it.

[@SwanTheQueen]

The consumers are paying for that. They are not losing money. 😅

[@karmakiwi2155]

It’s not wasteful bc they’re getting brand promotion to make more money

[@lindagallaway-moore4158]

Well done James! You always have our backs. Thank-you!! Have a lovely evening. ❤😊

[@loveit7484]

I have a suggestion: why not have influencer raffle off PR gifts they can never use up to their fans. So many of us cannot afford so many of these. I love this one influencer is doing this. We need more of this. As fans like influencer, if we like it, we will buy. You just said what I wrote. Thank you!!!

[@JamesWelsh]

So there is a strict law surrounding holding a raffle because it’s classed as gambling! So most of us just use random name picking websites!

[@loveit7484]

@@JamesWelsh ohhhh. I didnt know that. Thanks for information & reply. You Rock!

[@jenniebeann]

Love seeing these videos more often, I think they are so interesting. Keep them coming please xxx

[@WinterGirl1969]

I love how you responded to Dr. I'm not an MD yet. As a student you're still learning, she needs to humble herself and stop presenting herself as a Doctor when she has not graduated. Basically, she needs to check herself before she wrecks herself 🤨

[@_.mxggxn._]

I really respect Rosie HW’s statement. I think it’s right for her and I hope she’s still able to channel her interests and passions into something else.

[@carolinaquiceno9737]

So glad you covered “dr” messy. I saw dermangelos clap back and had to go stalk her page, so infuriating. Would love follow ups on this!

[@itsthatlady]

That PR is insane 😂. But like you I get mortified by the amount of skincare I accumulate in PR, and I just refuse to keep it all. Even items I love I pass along to people that can use it. I just call it direct influencing 😂 I’ve reviewed it, I don’t need 30 toners open at once

[@jazwhoaskedforthis]

Lol bathe in it all

[@itsthatlady]

@@jazwhoaskedforthis I swear I literally could 😂 I won’t lie I do use some face moisturizers on my body just to feel a little bougie 🤣🤣

[@flyygurl18]

James, I love your proactivity in the beauty space and how you make it approachable thus less scary and digestible; your content always bridges that gap by cutting through the faf and information overload 🥰😍🖖

[@Basic6936]

That fake doctor girl is 100% a rage baiter. We are doing exactly what she’s wants us to do lol

[@lilissupafly]

'pov: you wash your face with your hands' what am I supposed to wash it with, my feet?

[@gothboithick]

a washcloth maybe

[@Chachixo]

Gosh the "doctor" lady is so frustrating. I genuinely appreciate you talking about medical professionals having the capacity to be wrong af and people fully being ready and willing to lie about their credentials. Yes, we should be able to trust people as an authority on their subject but people are still people at the end of the day.

[@movementevolutionsa]

James, you are the best kind of influencer... you get it, you understand and you're always so humble!

[@lesleytolley5033]

I really enjoyed this video James, interesting and informative as always, so thanks 🥰

[@KharonDeLune_vtb]

That's one hell of a way to call for engagement, bro! Well done!

[@debpalm8667]

Thank you for your service, James. Much appreciated.

[@Yuriy99]

The rose inc thing happened to REN beauty, Huda inadvertently exposed them in several clips that I pieced together. She was always obsessed with RENs rose oil and one day the company was secretly sold and an executive reached out to her and asked if she wanted to purchase a percentage of the company. She flew out to their headquarters because the rose oil completely changed her skin and she appreciated how they offered the most exquisite ingredients. Well, at the meeting they started talking and she mentioned how absolutely phenomenal this rose oil was and how she had never used anything like it - the exec cut her off and was like “well, effective immediately we will be reformulating the rose oil with MUCH much cheaper ingredients so that we can increase profit margins, isn’t that great?!!”. Needless to say, she changed her mind and ended the meeting. Before flying back she stopped at RENs store and purchased every single rose oil they had in stock with the original formulation. She flew it back to Dubai and had her team recreate it so that it could live on - today the closest renditions to RENs original rose oil is sold under her brand WISHFUL called Get Even Rose Oil and it’s amazing..

[@faunvocations]

my GOSH james you are positively GLOWING today!!!

[@kerriehardy2823]

Good for you James! Keep up the good work and keep them honest! This 61 years old grandmother loves your content, and the stuff you do with your brother is hysterical 😂

[@Campanella12]

wow James your skin is glowinggg

[@fri5kas]

Amazing commitment! Go James! I am here for it! 😂

[@anniealexander9911]

I hadn't heard of Rose, Inc but was this the same brand sold through M&S? I have her original rose perfume which is one of my fav's (rose has always been my fav scent), and some of her silk bras. Nice quality. I hadn't realised she was so involved with her companies - I wonder if that applies to all her companies.

[@michellecarr2556]

I’m sorry but I have to ask what products did you use on the morning of filming this video? Your skin is just glowing! ❤️ I mean it always is but it seems to be even more so in this video! Love your content!

[@2nicnag2]

I will be checking out Dr Angelo!! I have several skin conditions and am extremely allergic to most meds and super sensitive to most products. Basically my skin negatively reacts to the sun and I live on Benadryl at times. When my inflammatory bowel disease acts up so does my skin inflammation. I just tried a new make up brand product and my eye lines/waterlines were so inflamed/swollen I had to use an ice pack for relief

[@maryeckel9682]

Autoimmune disorders suck 😢

[@2nicnag2]

@@maryeckel9682 yep! I became a hospice social worker because it helped me maintain perspective of my life because I was working with people who were in worse health situations myself and because everyone deserves quality care when terminally ill

[@atxoatmeal]

Aaaaah ... Phlur Vanilla Skin is SO good. Yay you are getting them in the UK!

[@picahudsoniaunflocked5426]

I have a chronic illness & my wonderful top-of-class doctor makes a similar joke when I have a crappy specialist appt. He tells if "What do you call someone who graduates at the bottom of their medical school? Doctor."

[@amymarxer6559]

Love this content, James! Go get ‘em, Sherlock Welsh! I saw your unboxing vid with Monsta Gels. I fainted. 💜

[@katyredmond]

That's a good one!! In the u.s. I've always heard the saying, "half the doctors graduate in the bottom half of their class"😅

[@jennlife]

I give you high praise and respect for handling the situation with "doctor" in a calm and professional way. You got info on the product she was representing and then made them aware of a negative situation that they may not know their business (lively hood) were even involved in. 🌈 🌝

[@susanyamini]

Good for you to exposing her. We need more people like you. This could be very dangerous for young people listening and believing these scammers.

[@beverleytaylor5859]

I love this series. It's really informative xxx

[@LMBillingsley]

The natural product company had a really interesting story, and i think illustrates why some people use natural remedies. I see no issue with trying out alternative products and methods when you're frustrated by the medical industry, especially when you're buying from a company that can produce sterile products that won't go bad within a week. I'm also relieved to see a holistic company with a professional and measured response to valid criticism.

[@christamoore7461]

Omg you look amazing. Your skin is flawless ❤

[@Lemon_Lime_Lily]

I love your when beauty turns ugly series and the ugly news! Would you ever consider doing a video about treating bumpy facial skin? I have keratosis pilaris and would love some advice for bumpy and textured skin!

[@mattyboi8338]

Can I ask how you have such white skin? Do you wear any kinda tone corrector or anything it’s just I used to have perfectly white skin and now it’s all red and I want it to be white again like yours. Been told I’ve got a damaged skin barrier so I’ll just use a cleanser moisturiser and sun cream but it won’t cure my redness so wondering how you’ve gotten your skin so white? Thanks

[@kemhug2623]

James. JAMES. You just earned my sub This was great

[@ginag8723]

I love your due diligence, James.

[@livquin8557]

Aye James Petty Welsh can't believe she blocked you 😂 Your skin has looked amazing in the last few weeks what products/ routine are you using? I've unfortunately had my Rosacaea flare up recently & I'm looking for new products/routine.

[@calihhan4706]

"Dr. Messy" had me almost spilling my drink 😂

[@benjib0yyy]

as someone with HS and struggles with it since I was `17 years old, its so gross to prey on us like that. all we want is relie and for it to go away. its already so mortifying, and most people dont even get a [proper digasnosis or never go get it treated cause its so embarrassing.

[@zappa-happy]

Perfectly put James! Stay on Messys case!😁💖💖

[@VtheHAPPYLURKER]

There are plenty of reasons to keep the toilet lid closed when it's not in use, like trying not to have Skibidi Toilet: Live Action Kitty Edition. And waaay back in the day, Penn and Teller did a show called Bullsh*t, which had a segment all about whether toilet seats were as nasty as people presumed. Their conclusions? Nope! As long as you don't have broken skin or do something stupid like lick the seat, it's perfectly safe. You don't even need those paper seat covers. The millisecond I saw she was promoting a cure-all 'salve' , I had flashbacks to black salve (DO NOT looking up.). And, while this won't likely work for the products, there's nothing stopping the people who got that promo fridge from chopping up and freezing those fruits. Free smoothie fodder. I just hope they clean that bottom drawer super well.

[@maryeckel9682]

Why do I hear a strange voice singing "Skibidi meow meow meow yes yes?"

[@liviusss]

James, your skin looks amazing! ✨👏

[@RadBadJodster]

WOW! Great show! Well done James!!! 🫶🏻💜🖤

[@GLAMGENX]

Ugly news! I love it!!! James digs up the scoop, always!

[@enenenergp]

I can totally believe a propolis based salve could treat infected skin since propolis definitely is antibacterial. In my country we have wound salves based on things like honey or spruce resin, some of which have a ”medical device” registration meaning they fill requirements set by the EU for medical devices and do actually have an effect, even though they’re not registered as d rugs, so natural is sometimes effective!

[@maryeckel9682]

Honey for wound care is awesome.

[@JustAFace_InTheCrowd]

19:50 Strange that they would put something like Mogu Mogu’s in there….. They’re delicious but they’re incredibly sugary. A decent amount of juice, considering most brands now put almost none, but still… It feels like they’re trying to say they’re good for you…. And that’s weird. lol

[@gracied.3599]

WOW! James’ skin looks amazing

[@meizhou9279]

Med students giving medical advice reminds me of that scene in Harry Potter where Dobby uses magic in Harry’s home and the “magic court” was ready to punish Harry severely. We need that level of punishment. 😂😆

[@omarzayed6096]

When I started taking much more of an interest in skincare during COVID, little did I know I would open the door to a world of high DRAMA!

[@kamlin98]

How dare she come after Dr Angelo! I love their content. Thanks James for breaking down the whole situation for us and following up with that brand.

[@michellefrias6221]

I’m glad you’re going to investigate this woman!! And you seriously need to become a dermatologist already ❤️

[@Jacklynn_huckleberry]

I need an update on that "doctor" and the gel polishes!

[@alicetremea1798]

I looooved Rose Inc, her cream blush and face wash have been staples for me since they launched. I really loved the ethos and ingredients, I am not sure how it's going to be now with this new parent company...