A Perfect Circle - Magdalena (Reaction/Review) So there's no such thing as A Perfect Circle?

[@SoOutrageous]

One of the best sonically produced albums in my opinion.

[@blakemeads9225]

I wish I could go back in time and hear Mer De Nom for the first time again. That album is all killer, no filler.

[@metal.head.]

One of the greatest albums of all time. Perfect. Unique. Emotive!

[@tonymills818]

This entire album was a masterpiece. Orestes is my favorite, but I'm not sure I've ever loved an album more in my life. APC is pefection.

[@TxRn-xe3gm]

I LOVE Orestes as well!

[@JkersteJr]

100% THIS

[@joescott4778]

Mer des Noms was a perfect debut album 👌

[@chetthehoss]

Orestes was absolutely brilliant. My favourite song on the album too, bar none.

[@joescott4778]

@@chetthehoss Magdelena, The Hollow, Judith... much like Tool, my favorite APC song is the one I'm currently listening to

[@chadrat39]

I've said this since it came out on album, that solo guitar probably top 5 in rock history

[@dtpfeiffer]

Been a while since I listened to this one myself. Kind of amazing how hard a song can hit when listening to it after a long break, especially when you listen to it intently.

[@dmusiclife5727]

💯

[@johnhedglin4489]

Love the Danny Carey shirt! 😂

[@nicholasdsilva5273]

Maynard’s vocals are always on point and he is just crushing it with this one

[@thepooz7205]

Been a while since I really listened to this song. My reaction mirrored Dylans here. Thanks!

[@Yodavich]

Story time!!! I saw A Perfect Circle play on the day of my 21st birthday nearly 20 years ago now at Festival Hall in Melbourne AUS. It was by far the most crystal clear sparkly sounding gig I have ever been to, almost like you were listening to a CD (remember those kids?), stunning performance. A few songs in, Maynard says "I don't know if you know this but it's someones birthday today". I then proceeded to lose my mind! Then he goes on to explain that it was one of their roadies birthday. Then all of my mates around me throw me up into the air and I scream "IT'S MY BIRTHDAY TOO!" Then Billy Howerdell points right at me and walks over to Maynard and says something into his ear and pointed me out to him. Maynard then got the whole crowd to sing happy birthday for their roadie. I can't remember his name but let's just say it was Tom, so every time he sang his name, he followed it up with "and that guy too". So he finished it with "happy birthday dear Tom, happy birthday to you... and that guy too" It was around that point that the drugs began to take hold and I had really good time. Best 21st birthday you could ever ask for

[@anthonylanzano114]

love seeing people's reactions to one of the best songs on one of the best albums ever made!!

[@chadrat39]

U guys are the few that have reviewed this so I always come back. This song is just sent.

[@savitrisdisciple]

Paz on bass, with John Freese, what an engine room to drive the rest of this perfection

[@eggstu]

Josh Freese on drums. The dude can smash and I love his style.

[@nauseantrock532]

Awesome❤

[@davemarsh04]

First 2 perfect circle albums were brilliant, I personally haven't liked much since but first 2 brilliant!

[@pwph8361]

Top 2 A Perfect Circle song for me! So gooood.... wish it went for 10 minutes 😁

[@hermesdungeon]

Damn could you imagine. That would be awesome

[@sharpasattack]

Such a phenomenal track. Everything they do is good. Fuck, anything Maynard touches is gold 😂

[@jessietaylor790]

Except for Emotive and Eat The Elephant. Both are atrocious.

[@sharpasattack]

@@jessietaylor790 I generally agree with Emotive, not my favorite by any means but I appreciate the artistry involved in looking at songs in a new light like they did on that album. Live version of When The Levee Breaks at red rocks really hooked me to that song, brilliant performance. I think these guys actually did a review of it, check it out if you have time. As for Eat The Elephant, again certainly not my favorite but songs like Feathers, By and Down The River, Hourglass, even Disillusioned & So Long I really enjoy now after not liking so much on first release.

[@Awprod2000]

You HAVE TO! check out "A Perfect Circle - Orestes - Stone and Echo Live at Red Rocks" . One of the most incredible live performances ever, with an extended solo

[@theendistheend123]

add in "When the Levy breaks." FANTASTIC cover.

[@stephenroby8498]

A Perfect Circle was originally conceived by Billy Howerdel, a former guitar technician for Nine Inch Nails, The Smashing Pumpkins, Fishbone and Tool. Howerdel met singer Maynard James Keenan in 1992, when Tool was opening for Fishbone, and the two became friends. Three years later, Maynard offered Howerdel, who was looking for lodging, a room in his North Hollywood home. This provided Howerdel the opportunity to play demos of his music for Maynard. Pleased with what he heard, Maynard remarked, "I can hear myself singing those songs." Howerdel originally wanted Cocteau Twins lead singer Elizabeth Fraser to be A Perfect Circle's vocalist, but she was unavailable. Howerdel agreed Maynard would be a great fit and the rest is history.

[@norbertovelazquez7441]

Amazing song

[@BrokenToasterOvens]

Done 6:26 min in.

[@jeremeywilson2318]

By and Down is an amazing Perfect Circle song!!!!!

[@jesuschristpose896]

Paz, a female bass player, and badass, and classical trained in music, great band and the drummer is badass also

[@JkersteJr]

I am so stoked that you guys did this one, I haven't even watched the video yet lol Definitely definitely do this entire album, it's a masterpiece and among my favorites of all time!

[@rodgerhermes5995]

Fuckin a dude

[@Remedy462]

My black madonna...I agree *throws another dollar down*

[@rodgerhermes5995]

Lolol

[@chadrat39]

It's like riding westward

[@jeremeywilson2318]

We need some Pantera!!!! ~ Mouth for War ~ Domination “LIVE” ~ Walk ~ Slaughtered ~ Suicide Note 1&2 ~ Cemetery Gates ~ War Nerve ~ The Sleep

[@stabbyeinstein6731]

You have to check out Puscifer's V is for Versatile, Indigo Children.

[@aiwass84]

The band that smashed the pumpkins ....

[@rodgerhermes5995]

Vocals are just 🥜

[@nauseantrock532]

Of all of the so called supergroups that came out .yeah these guys are forewallyyo

[@munkeeBraynStoo]

D Music Life with Tool (and all music) you NEED to be looking at lyrics Thomas by a Perfect Circle is AWESOME!!! It's the only male name on the Mer de Noms (Book of Names) album

[@raulgallardo7195]

Pls react to the noose, you won t regret

[@rodgerhermes5995]

Or the package, awesome

[@spencermcCH]

You still gotta do the new Primus 3 song EP!🤪😂🤘🎧

[@Freddy_Confetti]

Killr song

[@chadrat39]

Deep Cuts version will send you

[@op1ate43]

@D Music Life Yeah, tool is great, APC and Puscifer too. But man, It's a shame that is almost end od 2022. and you two probably still didn't listen to some Isis band stuff. Let's start with Isis - Dulcinea, Garden of Light or In Fiction, Weight, So did we. This band is just fuckin' epic.

[@januszmynarczyk7108]

I second anything by Isis band but Grinning Mouths, Wills dissolve, Not on rivers but in drops, or Dulcinea will all make right by you.

[@castle07dw]

Man, can you pleease react to One Armed Scissor by At The Drive In? Would love to see you guys react to that especially in the odd chance you haven't heard it yet

[@edparr4670]

No such thing as a perfect circle? Riiiiight hold my sqare😮😮😮

[@tapsX3]

There isn’t a weak song on this whole album.

[@johnnyblue9120]

Come on Deftones fans. When are ya'll gonna so 'Crosses'? Start with the first track. 'Is This A Trick'.

[@Brotha_Teresa]

This is most “Tool-like” Maynard’s voice gets in any APC track.

[@rodgerhermes5995]

For sure

[@mrsleep0000]

Do yourself a favor get get an adblocker.

[@Useful-_-Idiot]

One of my favorite Maynard vocal performances. That guitar wailing, I’ve never heard anything like it before or since. The bass, everything just absolutely Game Over! ✌️🤘