A RDR1 Scene That Definitely Hits Different After Completing RDR2 - Red Dead Redemption

I say this because if you think about it, after John, in the epilogue, loses Abigail and Jack at pronghorn ranch and BUYS Beecher’s Hope and literally builds it with the help of former gang members, I most definitely feel something in me after John is forced to hunt down the remaining members and have his family held hostage and after all that time spent in the story to get back to them, it feels surreal to walk back into Beechers hope after building it and working it and remembering Charles and Sadie being there and finally going back to where the story in RDR 2 left off. Worth a replay. Such a damn shame rockstar had to cancel the remaster for freaking GTA 6 man

[@RedsDeadBaby]

Finally A 5 Year Old Mystery In RDR2 SOLVED! kzbin.info/www/bejne/fWOkaICvhsdmi5Y

[@AlaskanFrost98]

My favourite part of RDR1 was when Dutch said ‘It’s Dutchin’ time’ and then jumped off a cliff

[@thebat4763]

He jumped straight to Tahiti and replaced himself with a dead look alike. He had a plan all along

[@yearninganimal]

He always has a plan

[@christopherkinsella3912]

He said “Oh boy, looks like I’m in double Dutch for this one.”

[@thesausageman5388]

@@yearninganimal but he needs money

[@balabanasireti]

Cringe

[@tav095]

"Hold your excuses until you figure out which one to use" I love that line 😂

[@jaredallen1950]

I know right 😭😭😭

[@DmpstrPirate]

John had a magnificent way with words

[@damarradityo9285]

It’s Lumbago, John just never understand

[@MrFreakRite]

John knew the next one coming was his lumbago and didn't wanna hear it 😂

[@dadrip]

Same

[@_Cato_]

Damn. Honestly, these graphics hold up incredibly well for a game that’s over a decade old

[@popakuba6211]

fr it's impressive

[@agustinlyon8173]

Yeah , John's face here is much better than in RDR2

[@braydonblanton8218]

@@agustinlyon8173 probably bc he got older he looks more badass and talks more with a growl in this game bc of everything he’s gone through. Of course he wasn’t like this in RD2 bc he was young

[@pandersonnike]

I wish they would re-release it on PS5 with a slight touch on the resolution. Or somehow use the entire RDR2 engine and add some more strangers and random experiences with NPCs on the road. That would be amazing.

[@phalanx8437]

@@pandersonnike Yeah, keep dreaming.

[@Cheddarhead7]

R* did a great job casting a soundalike as Abigail for her RDR2 actress, it's very difficult to tell their voices apart

[@fankgaming7753]

I thought they were the same actresses tbh

[@moolahfornothing1650]

I think the voice actress from 2 (Cali Elizabeth Moore) was more shrilly while the voice actress from 1 (Sophia Mary Marzocchi) was much more soft spoken.

[@undeaddragon0977]

Do you know why they couldn’t cast the first actress?

[@moolahfornothing1650]

@@undeaddragon0977 No idea.

[@Moha_English]

Agree with that. The tone is perfectly matched.

[@crazyguy32100]

"I never thought I'd see this day again." The number of times John thought he'd never see Abigail and Jack again, either by the Pinkertons, the Goverment, Dutch or Abigail herself, "Again" really hits hard.

[@randomt800kiddo2]

it's almost the same amount of "one last hit"s dutch planned lmao

[@railenherman6482]

This reunion hits so damn hard after finishing both RDR1 and RDR2. With RDR1, it hits cause you worked so hard and it finally pays off, but it gets taken away when John’s killed. With RDR2, it hits because you’re seeing these characters again and actually seeing the very house you built with your family all welcoming you back.

[@ArcAngle1117]

It will become even more depressing if Jack Marsten is ever the protagonist of his own game. Just returning to the life his father and Arthur fought and died to keep him out of.

[@jameslakejunior8054]

Imagine dutch has a secret son who makes his own gang

[@ledoppler8524]

@@jameslakejunior8054 This would be the case if RDR was developed by Ubisoft

[@ronanhavern1980]

@@ledoppler8524 red dead redemption 10 would've been coming out at this point in that case

[@FrantzJunior]

@@ronanhavern1980 if it was an ubi production we would be in the 10th game and we would be controlling the horses instead by this point

[@manband20]

I love the outfit John is wearing in this scene. He looks like he just stumbled home after Coachella. No wonder Abigail was worried she's never see him again.

[@josephstalin2606]

@l It looked better for Jack imo. His hair isn’t receding like Johns is

[@thedevilissix]

Lmao

[@Donna-hk3oc]

I think it looks like sh** honestly 😂

[@M1A1.]

​@@undergoingstressFR

[@TheBasedUchiha]

John would never be caught dead in some smelly Coachella cess pit

[@andreivaldez2929]

My favorite part of the whole game was when John said, "It's time for my Red Dead Redemption".

[@Nativityin6lack]

my fav in the whole series was when arthur said “it’s time for my red dead redemption too”

[@ElPatron42069]

Lol I wish

[@conangaming2156]

The is along the same line as: “Patrick, it’s you, you’re the American psycho!”

[@KingoftheApes]

Not as good as the ending of GTA V. I still get chills when Michael says "I'm getting too old for this nonsense," and leaves Trevor behind. When Trevor strokes his chin and says, "well, I guess it's time to commit Grand Theft Auto" and the title card plays is easily my number one moment of any game ever.

[@jasonterry8719]

@@Nativityin6lack banger

[@deskbop]

Uncle: is sober for 0.1 seconds John’s entire farm:

[@mulletmayhem3812]

The Virgin jack martson: let's the cattle and chickens get eatin/escape The Chad uncle: says don't go blamin me when they haven't said his name

[@Imstillaround9x19]

** *let’s the cattle and chickens get eatin/escape* **eaten

[@daffodil815]

Virgin? Ha! Tell that to our kids

[@_laryssa]

@@Imstillaround9x19 eatin'

[@ShallBeMine]

Virgin lung cancer vs Chad Lumbago

[@hmmmm9174]

@@Imstillaround9x19 eatin/escype

[@SanAndreasModsVideos]

The prequel writing in the RDR series is perfectly done, just like Better Call Saul. Everything fits together so perfectly.

[@pascal2085]

It fits so well that I like to believe that RDR2 was written before RDR but was postponed due to technical limitations.

[@seamuswbiggerarmalite3379]

perfectly? what about john daughter???? javier meet her

[@kingofsinter8416]

@@seamuswbiggerarmalite3379 And how do we know Javier and John never met between 1899 and 1911? Answer: We don’t. There are certainly lots of inconsistencies between the games, but the vast majority of them can be explained away somehow.

[@seamuswbiggerarmalite3379]

@@kingofsinter8416 a wizard do it

[@anontwentytwo1380]

Red Dead redemption or Red Dead Revolver?

[@solowali10]

the mission in 2 where john just takes Abigail on a date and proposes had me crying like a baby. This series is a masterpiece.

[@avaracicot5063]

I played rdr1 when I was basically a kid. I only finished rdr2 last month as an adult, and my god that mission had be bawling, I love the Marston family so much.

[@Long-Horse]

Jesus Crist

[@nixn6412]

Come on man…

[@emiliamcgrath1799]

everyone else loves when other people have feelings

[@SneakyNinja837]

I was crying also knowing he was proposing to a h**e

[@Megaman54327]

yeah after you know how horrible her cooking is in the rdr2, knowing abigail learned to cook weeks before johns death hits *HARD*

[@Merip1214]

Oh that's so sad 😭

[@Ricardo-cl3vs]

Abigail is a horrible person altogether. Always nagging, never satisfied. I hate that b1tch with a passion.

[@sebastianmurphy7507]

Well, if you don't pursue the mission further, it will take more weeks, or if you let the game like that then John still be alive now. I know it cuz that is what I did. After John's death, I couldn't bear it.

[@Long-Horse]

@@sebastianmurphy7507 Lol why, its part of the game, it honestly suits the ending of him getting blasted 100s of times, John is a bad man with a bad past and you get your just desserts.

[@BRUH-nw9hh]

@@Long-Horse Both Arthur and John felt the hand of justice in the end

[@TheDemonicHorseman]

Abigail's first line never fails to crack me up.

[@luisfuentes3012]

The way she opens the door and walks up to John, that was womanly rage

[@averysillygal]

and the way he lightly runs away from her 😭

[@ArcAngle1117]

@@averysillygal Probably scared him more than facing a Gatling gun or almost getting eaten by wolves.

[@mrunderhooks4798]

@@ArcAngle1117 Or from water

[@EzraB123]

Once I finished RDR2 I just pretended the events of the first game never happened and John and his family lived happily ever after.

[@mcfall420]

Same, especially since I never played the first one so this whole thing is very confusing lol

[@Yarblocosifilitico]

yeah, man, it's kinda depressing seeing the 'happy ending', knowing it'll only last for a short while. But it's good storytelling too: you can redeem yourself, but you can't escape the past.

[@TheBuhrewnoShow]

@_sanguine.rose_ that's totally fine! there's lots of stupid ppl in the world who don't think they're stupid - but it doesn't make em any less stupid!

[@TheBuhrewnoShow]

@_sanguine.rose_ luckily, I never called you stupid :). was a simple analogy. but.. if the shoe fits - lace it up and wear it bud!

[@Long-Horse]

@_sanguine.rose_ He was calling you stupid and then took a 180 when you made him look more stupid than you and tried to play it off like he wasn't, actual cretin we have there.

[@spawnglance6720]

"You saw Dutch? ... And Bill? ... And you didn't go back to 'em?" *has an entire freaking highlight reel of the 2nd game flash through the mind* "I left that life. Just as you left yours."

[@user-mu8dm4rk7g]

My favorite quote of John's comes from this scene. Always puts a smile on myself at the same time as giving food for thought. Because what he says is true.

[@shawnsouth327]

“Hold your excuses until you’ve figured out which one to use”

[@trainknut]

Care to elaborate which quote that is?

[@johnbishop9621]

@@trainknut "I hope you've learned how to cook."

[@bayabooz4855]

@@trainknut I think 1:13 to 1:35 is what they mean

[@josephstalin2606]

@@trainknut “Some trees flourish while others die, some cattle grow strong while others get taken by wolves” that one. Life isn’t fair and being said by John is all the more ironic considering really nothing about Johns life is fair

[@bwalker77]

I always feel sorry for Abigail. She has no control over what is happening in her life, no matter how hard she tries, and she never gets the happiness she deserves.

[@Kyle-vg4wg]

Yeah, If im not mistaken she gets sick and dies shortly after John. I wonder if the sickness was heartbreak.

[@BeavisandBoobhead]

Naw, Abigail was a hypocritical, selfish jerk. I personally feel John could have done better.

[@TheChuffert]

​@BeavisandBoobhead Bonnie McFarlane was totally into him. Not saying John and Abigail don't suit each other and he should've abandoned her and Jack, but Bonnie totally would've smashed if the situation were different

[@kiriakai2842]

@@TheChuffertman who cares about some more pussy he’s got a boy and a wife. They ain’t perfect but so John is not. Damn I wish we were in those times, family meant something

[@static5919]

​​@@TheChuffertor take the boy and then get close to Bonnie. No matter what, Jack deserves his dad. Abigail can't substitue John's role. Or better yet, John avoids her when she joins the gang and then gets close with Bonnie at age 36 in 1911.

[@UNCHARTED2FANATIC]

John marston is too real. I think he is easily among the best character in gaming

[@Shadowfire204]

Glad some people still think so. As much as I love Arthur and feel just as strongly about him it feels like he's kind of completely overshadowed John as a character in many people's eyes

[@johnnybravo5969]

@@Shadowfire204 yes, I agree. Rdr 1 is old but gold.

[@shootymcshoot8515]

@@johnnybravo5969 RDR1 is like an aged fine wine

[@johnnybravo5969]

@@shootymcshoot8515 Thanks for catch phrase, I'll remember that. Thank you again.

[@knightr0685]

@@johnnybravo5969 red dead suck

[@TheFlamingPike]

I just realized something. Uncle was the most helpful of the whole gang. When people looked down at Uncle they were realizing they were very productive in comparison which made them feel better about themselves and when they still felt like shit but didn't feel like arguing or getting in a fight they could insult and threaten Uncle and be guaranteed he'd take it all without trying to fight it out. He was a walking ( or sleeping ) morale booster. This scene proves another thing. John kept Uncle because of Jack. John was aware that his relationship with Jack was tense. He wanted to preserve it. In this scene, Uncle was the perfect outlet for John because he could avoid blaming his son, putting the blame on Uncle instead!

[@Rubyofthedead]

The bullet that killed Uncle was laced with lumbago.

[@HelghastStalker]

And ultimately when it came down to it, for all of his faults and flaws, Uncle didn't try to flee the Ranch when John was away, or rat to the government when they came to kill John. Uncle did do his best to keep the Ranch going and Uncle died fighting for John, Abigail, and Jack, trying to make sure they got out alive.

[@stiffchris9720]

He was basically the last loyal member of Dutch's gang left. He never stopped caring.@@HelghastStalker

[@CoolSaver]

​​@@HelghastStalker"Be loyal to what matters". Uncle sure understand that like no one else.

[@vivanloslunes7493]

Something that breaks my heart is when Charles and John reunites and told Charles that Uncle still alive, and says that "maybe god has a reason to kept him alive" and sure he has one, to protect his family one last time...

[@MegasXRL]

Honestly after playing red dead 2 i think the overall concept about john and the gang from red dead 1 changed a lot.. from RDR1 perspective, it was a gang of thugs pretending to be robin hood sometimes but when you play RDR2 you see that the gang was overall formed by decent folk like arthur, hosea, lenny... and of course after the events of RDR2 abigail would never tell john something like that 'and didn't you went back to them'

[@joyyoboyyo]

Was thinking the same especially since she knows they betrayed him but ig u can also look at it as she knows how Dutch is nd his way with words after some time had passed maybe things could have been rectified it is weird tho too bcuz she speaks like she wasn't with the gang herself right there but u can't plan for everything lol

[@trainknut]

Personally I think it makes more sense now knowing how persuasive Dutch was and how close he was with Bill and especially Javier. She's worried for their life, him, and for her son, it makes sense she would be concerned and ask about it.

[@philfooshay]

@@trainknut agreed

[@tylersibanke9916]

I think the concept is still the same Dutch manipulated decent folks into committing horrible crimes in order to make him richer the gang killed thousands of people in rdr2 alone being led by Dutch who convinced them what they were doin was right

[@chandrakantkothari9694]

They were too scared to have morally grey characters.an outlaw like Charles being in the gang made no sense .

[@moolahfornothing1650]

Interesting to see here that John is about a head taller than Abigail, but in RDR2 John is only a few inches taller.

[@IDontPayMyTaxas]

Well... sometimes people actually grow smaller after some time, that what happend with my mom.

[@yisus7178]

@@IDontPayMyTaxas Or she has Lumbago

[@mirza_afaq295]

That is because Abigail is played by different actresses in both games.

[@moolahfornothing1650]

@@IDontPayMyTaxas Yeah, but that's at old age. Abigail's only 34 here. And it's only by an inch or two, not half a foot.

[@moolahfornothing1650]

@@mirza_afaq295 The actress who played Abigail in RDR 2 (Cali Elizabeth Moore) is 5'4". The actor who plays John in both games (Rob Wiethoff) is 6'2".

[@ShallBeMine]

John did not hug Uncle because of his lumbago, and hug would hurt. How watchful of him! This game has so many details!

[@Metaliconian]

A most observant insight on the benevolence of John!

[@user-qf4du7lc4z]

RDR2 Uncle seems so different than RDR1. I'm pretty sure if the second VA did both games, it'd feel the same.

[@shadrakistann6833]

@@user-qf4du7lc4z nah it was just John’s sour attitude finally wearing down the fun, playful (and omniscient) Uncle to a grumpy layabout.

[@lemoncoatedcenturion8297]

@@user-qf4du7lc4z If I remember correctly the va for RDR1 Uncle was supposed to do Uncle again in RDR2 but he died before the game could be finished. You can hear his voice sometimes because they used some of the lines the original VA was able to record before he died. Mostly his singing.

[@josephstalin2606]

@@lemoncoatedcenturion8297 Uncle had 3 VAs in total. This one who voiced for only the first game and then fell off the grid after the game was released, then the one that they got for the 2nd game but ended up dying (the one that voices Uncles singing voice in the 2nd game since that’s all that was recorded of his voice) and then finally the one we have now in the 2nd game that recorded the rest of Uncles lines and the one we all recognize the most

[@googlyeyes1497]

The interactions and dynamics between John and Uncle in both games are solid gold.

[@abelle621]

“Hold your excuses till you figure out which one to use!” DAMN!

[@christhefiend]

John has always been good at roasting.

[@hishkapish4817]

John really used antagonize on him

[@XTheTopHatStudiosX]

When she was slapping John I was dying laughing lmao 🤣 💀

[@moolahfornothing1650]

Lol domestic violence is funny if it's against men 🤣

[@mkultra2456]

Where is the second comment?

[@XTheTopHatStudiosX]

@@mkultra2456 idk KZbin glitch

[@Hotelsix]

@@XTheTopHatStudiosX the guy probably deleted it

[@ishdemon_]

Yeah well he will die soon too

[@batmanfan43]

1:05 "Like you. Like me." More than either of them will ever come to know

[@sveinnsigururolafsson8314]

"Some men are born rich enough and dumb enough to enjoy their life." What a line. Great writing and yeah, the graphics hold remarkably up.

[@ProperlyGaming]

Rdr 2 definitely made me appreciate rdr storyline even more. Getting to see for ourselves the downfall of the gang, see that john had himself a real true brother who gave his life to get him outta there, only for the past to still catch up with him.

[@bunathan2485]

when I was a kid I think this game changed my whole perspective on the power of stories. The ending scene just smacked me in the face, in a good way.

[@RedsDeadBaby]

Same here dude.

[@aboudhh]

@li remember as a kid turning off my ps3 and hoping i could stay alive and it didn't save. If only i had shot them all with the dead eye

[@tacthescribbler772]

Heck, I'm a writer and RDR (1 and 2) changed my perspective on a lot of storytelling. Especially in terms of writing characters. I've grown to like bitter and bittersweet endings. Not everything ties up neat in real life, so when a story ends that way, it's somehow more real.

[@Saberofthe87th]

Out of all quotes and things said by John in both games this one hit home for me, nothing resonates with me more then John said to Abigail "Now Abigail, I hope you've learned to cook"

[@Enzopapo126]

0:09 Rabbit cameo

[@Mahivitsit]

Blessed are those who played RDR1 and realising every movement of it while playing RDR2.

[@jakelakeyt]

I haven't played RDR since probably 2012 or so, recently replayed RDR2 and then RDR and damn it hits different. I suddenly felt the same as John. The line "You always have a plan, Dutch" made my eyes all watery. These are S tier games

[@SosaL432]

Yo man ikr, that scene felt like I was back at the end of rdr2, finally seeing the house you built and your family again.

[@imchase7796]

John’s voice actor is incredible, it’s like he’s actually there coaching his son

[@AnthonyProvenghi]

You really like the Reyes rebels outfit I can’t blame you it’s cool seeing John without his hat

[@fatman1288]

god damn even in RDR 1 Abigal is fucking smoking hot

[@meanmrmustard2803]

@@hiagain1 life

[@kensington1199]

No

[@andreivaldez2929]

Lol what

[@ang77l]

i like her design more in this game, she just looks odd to me in rdr2

[@Onurb2821]

Just don't try to get funny with her. We've seen what happened to the guard

[@jamesneylan7631]

Imagine not seeing somebody for years and they come back looking like that

[@billieaylysh8405]

i don't think they got kidnapped for years.

[@josephstalin2606]

More like a few months at most. Either way it’s still a dramatic change and can explain why Abigail is so shocked to see him and is wondering whether he reverted back to his old ways judging by his appearance

[@logancutler6267]

John Marston's got to be one of the best protagonists in a game. RIP to the GOAT

[@kapowchou.2kap288]

No

[@a.demifemiflapo5795]

Arthur Morgan first then John

[@H00dner]

Arthur Morgan is better and the true GOAT

[@Airfryer208]

@@H00dner you never played og rdr or you wouldn’t be saying that. their stories and characters are both goat tiers and both do things better than the other.

[@TheSeabassss]

@@Airfryer208 I played both, Arthur is the goat. Cry more

[@lunatictheater6901]

I swear hearing uncle's voice after playing RDR2 and not playing RDR1 for a while it's kind of a shock

[@georgelucas9699]

"Hold your excuses until you've figured out which one to use" might be my favorite line from these games.

[@swaaws]

They made uncle so much better for RDR2. Makes me kinda sad though, seeing him become even MORE old and grumpy

[@CheefChaos]

There are hints that Jack may actually be Arthur's Son.

[@billymays4376]

I absolutely love this game. I know RDR2 is a really good game with amazing details and beautiful story, but THIS... this game has always been and always will be my favorite. The story is so good in it's own right and I have soooo many memories of playing the online (both base and undead nightmare) with my friends until the sun came up irl. God, do I miss the early 2010's. I know I won't ever have a time like that for games again...

[@johnmarston3434]

RDR2 just made Uncle’s return that much funnier

[@nae1922]

This is especially incredible after RDR2 to me because you got to see just how intense the trials and tribulations John and Abigail went through to get to this point. You saw how a charismatic leader gets a bunch of broken and mislead people to band together and do his bidding and their realization of that fact. You get to see the violence and direction the gang started in and the way they just didn’t feel right about it. Just incredible they’re able to portray this and more in a video game that we get to be a part of.

[@FreeAimDog]

she looks so much like the mother from the waltons, if you never seen the show find it on some streaming pirate site, if you love red dead you will be addicted and bench watching the show once you get started on the first 3 episodes.

[@jzimmerman284]

I remember watching that show with my grandparents when I was a kid, my favorite episode was the one where Jim Bob got into racing harley davidsons

[@FreeAimDog]

@@jzimmerman284 have not got that far yet, still on season 4

[@sharkshady1876]

*Binge watching

[@greencreekranch]

Interesting detail how Abigail, when asked how jack is, says "like you, like me" Pretty sure John never actually got to experience jack being like him. Than again, probably better that way.

[@JacobVonRoker]

Angry, clever, persistent, that's jack

[@josephstalin2606]

It’s mentioned while John is at the ranch that Jack likes to sneak out on his own and do his own thing. He also fantasizes about the outlaw/gunslinger life too and obviously that’s worrying to Abigail because he grew up around that already and was trying to set him down a different path but like any other teenager he was acting out. And when the ranch got attacked and his father died you can only imagine his behavior only got worse and it seems like by the epilogue Jack had been out getting stronger and better with a gun because now he’s determined to be an outlaw to avenge John

[@NickC_222]

I'm in my 4th playthrough of RDR2 with over 750 hours in story mode (never touched online because story>online fight me irl) and for the very first time today, during very early chapter 3, I heard Bill Williamson sitting at the round table in camp talking about "Someday I'll run my own gang!" because Sean and I think John, we're making fun of him, laughing at him for being silly. Sean said "If I was in your gang, I'd never laugh again" and John said "It's no laughing matter" and it was all absolutely hilarious. Afterword I "greeted" Bill and Arthur said "So you're gonna run your own gang one day, huh?" and Bill said something like "Yes... One day..." That line hits different for an RDR1 original.

[@seamuswbiggerarmalite3379]

we all know you aint man enough to kill me bill

[@irzufzary]

Sean and Lenny

[@FuNati]

Beautifully written and acted. No other games even got CLOSE to this level.

[@thtguyplut002]

I love seeing how big Jack is in RDR

[@josephstalin2606]

He’s even better in the epilogue. I just wish a grown Jack could’ve rode alongside his father or any of the other gang members. He looks badass but was given no story potential besides avenging John

[@screamingcactus1753]

@@josephstalin2606 Would have been hilarious if he showed up in one of the Mafia games still toting his six shooter and cowboy hat

[@rodrikofharlaw6848]

@@screamingcactus1753 I could totally see low honor jack becoming a hitman for mobsters during prohibition.

[@user-vd6me7ox6c]

They modelled Arthur’s jacket after jacks, you can make shift Jack marston by wearing Arthur’s jacket as John

[@SrChr778]

Rockstar had plenty of backstory to work on after the first RDR. So yeah, when John reminisces about "old times", now we know.

[@arrowplaysyt8358]

I love how uncle hasn’t changed a bit 😂 this game is special

[@oijosuke9879]

It's the lumbago

[@jasonswitzer1748]

Yea. I REALLY wish Rockstar remade RDR1 with better graphics and improved play mechanics lifted from RDR2. I know GTA is popular, but wasn’t RDR2 rated one of the best games of all time? There’s a whole group of people who never got to experience RDR1. It’s a bummer.

[@k7cryptic]

They were developing remasters for RDR1 and GTA 4. Their parent company TakeTwo got frustrated with them remastering after the response to the GTA Trilogy remaster. So all effort and resources are on GTA 6 now. The remasters for RDR1 and GTA 4 have been shelved but will happen.

[@tsarbomba1]

@@k7cryptic Damn. Would have really loved a remastered GTA IV.

[@gabrielmartines3510]

@@M3TA763AR5071D GTA 4 and RDR 1 use RAGE, dummy, they'll never have DE level bugs and glitches, and the swing set is not even a glitch.

[@carlo14_]

@@M3TA763AR5071D they removed half the soundtrack??

[@ggknightz9597]

Really need RDR3, UNCLE the "one-shot kid".

[@piersjarvis100]

There’s actually theory that uncle is Red from red dead revolver back in the day

[@SosaL432]

I loved this scene because after you played rdr2 and play rdr1 you’re seeing your house you built in rdr2 and your family, and it feels like you’re back at the end of rdr2

[@punknomad7995]

John is such a sweetheart after his “shithead arc” in RDR2, and being a being a badass gunslinger in RDR, he gets lightly beaten up by Abigail and immediately folds. Then goes into dad mode when he see’s Jack. It’s a nice change of pace.

[@welon17]

Abigail asks for Dutch, but not for Javier. She even asks for Bill... But again, not for Javier. Javier is a lot of things, most of them bad. But a man on Abigail's mind? No.

[@Popcorn-ch7uy]

John said she always thought he was a creep

[@LordBlakeWhitehouse]

Javier was near the same moral level as Arthur. Only major difference was Javier was loyal to Dutch

[@mitiamed]

There's speculation that Jack is actually Javier's son

[@hugoferreira7992]

@@LordBlakeWhitehouse, that's a bold statement to make, considering we don't know of any good thing Javier for someone other than himself or his gang partners.

[@darkstars4695]

I amount of gang Ba**g we all did to your mother , Sure you can predict your own future

[@chandrakantkothari9694]

Why didn't they make John this articulate and intelligent in the second game ?

[@anthonyrivera2306]

Because RDR 2 is a prequel set in 1899. RDR is set in 1911.

[@brwhizz3060]

@@anthonyrivera2306 That’s not really an answer to his question.

[@boomshine87]

Rdr2 is set before this game. So in this game, rdr1, he's grown up experienced more things probably read some books etc

[@chandrakantkothari9694]

@@boomshine87 talking about epilogue John .it's set like 4 years before first Red dead.his vocabulary could have been better even if he wasn't as wise .

[@James-vk5ov]

@@chandrakantkothari9694 idk its a game so yeah.

[@1wolftank]

Such a good pair of games

[@305backup]

Its incredible the story they created whith such great space for a prequel that you wouldnt believe it wasnt all planned out. RDR is like the Star Wars of video games.

[@jairoaldus6085]

My favorite part is when John Marston shout "Sh*ts about to go down, Marstin Time"!

[@spurslegacy]

This is the ending to RDR1 in my head 🙂

[@PsychorGames]

John was too afraid to embrace Uncle because he knew Uncle could snap him like a tooth pick. Very few characters hide their power level as effectively as Uncle.

[@DraGon1229]

Only if game ended here it would have been a perfect ending

[@vslayer7403]

Damn This video has wanting to play rdr and idk if I could make myself not so emotional when uncle and John die

[@greencreekranch]

I will definitely use "Hold your excuses until you know which to use"

[@RDJ1997]

“Some men are born rich enough and dumb enough to enjoy their lives”

[@dalton5903]

what i loved about rdr2 is that it enhanced Rdr1

[@MrMorgan16]

"Some Cattle grow strong and others get taken wolfs" kinda reminds me of the time John got eaten by wolfs

[@JasonL77]

“Why don’t I gets a warm and tender embrace?” “Because I don’t want to aggravate your lumbago.”

[@Maxisamo1]

Definitely like Uncle's writing better in RDR2, way more lovable in that game

[@wesgunton238]

Makes me smile when Uncle complains about not getting a warm tender embrace.

[@MutedAggression]

Lol I love how John asks Abigail if she learned to cook like he's delivering bad news 😆

[@TheInfamousTRS]

"Abigail... I hope you learned to cook." That cracked me up

[@iian5830]

Im surprised uncle didn't blame lumbago

[@darkname122]

After i played rdr2 I played the original it made a lot more sense than playing the first one then the second

[@Cnw8701]

I still like Uncle's original voice a lot better, it suits him more.

[@DarkheartedMKGames]

Yeah but some things can't be helped sadly

[@gabrielmartines3510]

Well, you can't bring the dead back.

[@user-hx6gs9rq7u]

@@gabrielmartines3510 Uncles actor from rdr1 didn’t die he was just unavailable for rdr2. The actor they replaced him with passed away before rdr2 came out tho

[@austinmaruna1760]

my favorite part of the whole game is when Bill said, "Send me the bill" before getting loaded with bullets

[@ekathe85]

Mine is when Ross says John died because of the life he had and Jack replies "You don't give Jack shit" before blasting him to the North Pole with an RPG

[@dylanstankewicz850]

I love when John says "It's Redemtion Time" and Red Deads over everyone

[@12227UserName]

Wish there was a remake or remaster of this game for current consoles. The Red Dead Redemption games are my favorites of all time. The world feels alive, more so than any other game I've played, including the GTA series. The voice acting is superb in places. The story and narrative of redemption and the encroachment of civilization in the last days of the old west, while maybe over bloated sometimes, is really well done. The conclusion of each game along with how well they connect is also great. And of course the gameplay is great. Truly these games are a work of art, in my opinion. And I don't say that lightly. I'm pretty picky when it comes to videogames.

[@itsmj3103]

Hope they do, I'd really love to play it but sadly no backwards compatibility. :( I might look into the emulators for PC

[@laurenporter4649]

It’s on Xbox

[@L00d4cHa]

oh boy I bet you are dissapointed with recent events then lmao

[@12227UserName]

@@L00d4cHa Quite the opposite lol

[@onemoreturn]

"Some people are born rich enough and dumb enough to enjoy their lives. Ain't nothing fair. You know that." I know John, I know.

[@kylelangford9096]

My favorite line of the whole series is when Aurthur looks John in the eyes right before his last stand and says "You implore me?"

[@Donna-hk3oc]

You mean Dutch?

[@DonTooP]

I aspire to have a relationship like John and Abagails

[@jameshawkins6619]

I feel the same way about Breaking Bad and Better Call Saul too.

[@Yaxxer4]

And what's interesting that's breaking bad creator Vince Gilligan has describe the show as neo western, a modern day version of Western.

[@jameshawkins6619]

@@Yaxxer4 exactly.

[@kyle_crane]

@@Yaxxer4 And Arthur and Walter both have a lung disease, too. Not saying that it means anything, just thought it was a cool coincidence.

[@jameshawkins6619]

@@kyle_craneyep.

[@krashdown102]

Wish they’d do a remaster of this

[@robertparker6280]

Take the graphics from RDR2, and put it into this!

[@suhaibm5463]

@@robertparker6280 the game is already good

[@blakearmentrout7717]

Rockstar officially announced the remaster of this was canceled due to how poorly Red Dead Online did, which if you ask me is a bullshit excuse. Online sucked donkey dick and this game was a masterpiece of its day worthy of a remaster, I mean hell they already have most if not all the in game assets in RdR2 to recreate this game minus making the character models appear a bit older and weathered, they wouldn't even need to redo the voice casting, they could just use sound clips from the original game.

@@robertparker6280 and make it available for pc :))

[@expensivegranola]

Doesn’t the entire game kinda do that?

[@RedsDeadBaby]

Pretty much, but as far as RDR 2 epilogue this one feels entirely different after relaying

[@expensivegranola]

@@RedsDeadBaby Yeah fair enough

[@nahuelcutrera]

I wonder where will they go with the third one, and I feel a little worried about houser not being there anymore... I hope they don't go crappy like most of the games nowadays.

[@FelipeASaito]

They could go further back in the cronology to events before rdr2, culminating in the Blackwater fiasco. Maybe in that case we could play either John, Arthur, both, or an entirely different character, since it seems to be a tradition to kill the main protagonist in RDR

[@thomasfryer5706]

@@FelipeASaito I would guess you would either play as Mac or Davey Callendar in that case. What I personally would prefer is a game that takes place 20 years before RDR2 during the time when Dutch and Colin O’Driscoll were working together. I could see the player playing as Colm’s unnamed brother, and at the end Dutch kills him. The Epilogue would follow the player playing as Hosea deciding to leave the gang, and the epilogue ends with Hosea and Bessie leaving the gang to try to go straight, as mentioned in RDR2.

[@corvoyami3192]

I wanna play as young Arthur

[@TheMasterUnity]

I hope they dont make a 3rd. It doesn't need to be made

[@FelipeASaito]

@@TheMasterUnity well, I have bad news for you then, since RS basically confirmed they will keep making as many RDR games as they can

[@Sch0L_iM]

I love the part when Uncle says "Its Lumbago time"

[@dejoniko]

For me, thats the end to RDR :')

[@skyvolt2566]

If only Rockstar put work into the online part of RDR2. It could have been just as good if not better than GTA online. It was better imo

[@Chris-cj4ck]

Hopefully you read this comment but the RDR1 remaster is NOT cancelled! If you read exactly what Rockstar said, they said they are not going to do further development on RDR1 and GTA4 remasters until after GTA6 releases. This means it IS coming!!! Just be patient! :)

[@ednoresult4179]

COPIUMOD

[@elijah2658]

Man I hope... it would be nice

[@seamuswbiggerarmalite3379]

DAMN NAG

[@jura732]

Remake would be nice🤔

[@blax140]

after playing rdr2 and knowing the relationship between these characters really improves cutscenes like this where they talk about their old gang

[@ah-sf8kp]

It’s so hard to explain but the graphics and art style is so immersive and excellent for this game not only is it unique to the game but it gives it such a recognisable feel like it belongs, it’s like a movie and real life all blinded in one it’s so hard to explain but it’s one of the best

[@arthurmorgan7874]

It always bothered me how much grumpier uncle was in RD1 than 2. Like damn bro, who pissed in your cheerios

[@maddox2028]

Lumbago probably did

[@enxgmatxcofficial]

DONT YOU GO BLAMING ME BOAH!!

[@arthurmorgan7874]

@@maddox2028 True

[@aleemizcool3654]

He's still a comedic character, I think the main difference is the voice actors. The RDR2 voice actor for Uncle has a much jollier voice which is what we're more accustomed to now because Uncle has a lot more screentime in the second game. The dialogue is consistent for the character, it's just the way the lines are delivered

[@fkskyz]

I hope if they remake RD1 they change the ending so John doesn't die, I just wish he could be with his family

[@TheSpaceJockey91]

Or at least give us two optional endings where you can choose like RDR2 did.

[@Johnnysmithy24]

Would take away from the point of the game

[@user-hx6gs9rq7u]

Changing the ending would ruin the story

[@ZakEmber]

_"Take a gamble that love exists and do a loving act."_ - Sister, RDR2. What I love about the Sequel/Prequel is that we find out that some of the old gang may have been crooks, but they were also weren't all bad. Sean, Lenny, Mac, Charles, and of course, Arthur... we spent the first game hunting down the old gang without really knowing much about them. The sequel gave us a lot of time to see their best and worst, plus also showed us that most of John's best friends in that gang were already dead, including the man who was the closest he had to a brother. Giving your life so that someone else might live is a great theme of the series and shows how John and Arthur were trying to change, and had at least some principles in their hearts.

[@davidstronach3261]

After beating Red Dead 2 which was and still is a masterpiece of a game. Read Dead 1 still holds up after 14 years and its fun to go back and play it to fill out the blanks also Uncle and Abigail's actors sound much better in Red Dead 1 than in 2 I thought.