If Arthur is clean-shaven, the Gang will react to it

#rdr2 #reddeadredemption #arthurmorgan

[@k8x97]

I love Arthur just making rounds standing silently in front of people in the hopes they'll comment on his new look

[@i_love_gay_corn_69]

his like A happy dog Wagging his tail about the bone he want to show

[@TheOneShotKid]

​@@i_love_gay_corn_69 wow 🫠

[@maksymalnybul6145]

Did he asked for your opinion?

[@i_love_gay_corn_69]

@@maksymalnybul6145 Yes. i did ask for his opinion

[@Yourcreepyuncle]

@@i_love_gay_corn_69love your name

[@KinderJoys]

Charles: "You shaved, who's the lucky lady?" Arthur: "You okay?" XDD

[@deniskopcov2760]

You, okay?

[@SaulGoodman-ou1lv]

Ok I'll catch you later then

[@SewingMink160]

It's probably because Charles showed emotions for once and Arthur didn't know how to respond.

[@Sae.bae.GG08]

,,You, Charles it’s you. Your the lucky lady.’’ xD

[@SpaceCowboy260]

@@SewingMink160charles shows his emotions just only really around people he trusts like Arthur or John

[@UncleBztur]

May I... stand unshaven

[@t.7899]

amidst.... amidst a crash of hair

[@cardigunov]

Nooo I can't 😭😭😭

[@ARKHAMxMaverick]

You win

[@AcelJean]

I hate that I laughed at that

[@StrangeMan0-s2p]

@@t.7899 Did I hear a scissor? Did I hear you cutting?

[@hyouka_unforgiven]

Micah: "A shave. Mary must be sniffing around again." Arthur: "Did I ask for your opinion?"

[@Kop32353]

Arthur just gave him 'who asked' roast

[@aidanwow1593]

He isn't wrong, though.

[@AdrianValenciaYT]

I thought for a minute that it was an antagonize response. Glad to know it's just "natural". 😂

[@watulookinat]

​@@siranon yeah i hate people like this

[@lettucearsebiscuits8375]

​@@aidanwow1593 But did he ask?

[@lego_boba_fett_watch]

Clean shaven Arthur looks like a young Hosea

[@drysoup3017]

A much more muscular one at that.

[@canevas1017]

@@drysoup3017the guy is using a mod to make Arthur bigger

[@white_vargr1999]

@@canevas1017i just thought he had a weird coat xD

[@canevas1017]

@@white_vargr1999 I got ratiod so hard for pointing it out on another video when it was clear they used it on Arthur. Everyone swore Arthur naturally looked like then brick house in the video but I use the mod so I know

[@vengeance1450]

​@@canevas1017 Yeah I don't know why everyone thinks Arthur is some heavy weight that's 400 pounds of muscle, he's just an average guy. The only person in the gang that is truley buff is Charles.

[@soupiano]

Dutch: Why you shave Arthur?? I GOT A PLAN FOR THAT BEARD!!!!!!

[@sandradufke2324]

😂

[@Anythingidontreallycare]

SO WHAT ELSE YOU BEEN DOIN BEHIND MAAA BACK?

[@isaacfentom8684]

Faith Arthur!! Faith!!

[@poseidon7359]

LOL

[@YBGAMINGYT-ph4cl]

😅😅

[@hunterlovejoy7651]

Good on you for exclusively antagonizing Micah

[@watulookinat]

Bad on him acctually micahs the best

[@glassbovines]

​@@watulookinatwhat in gods name did you just say sir

[@watulookinat]

@@glassbovines i said the best thing micahs the best

[@joedwyer3297]

​@@watulookinat🤦🏻

[@watulookinat]

@@joedwyer3297 NO CATH NOT 🤦‍♂️ IM RIGHT!

[@brianbommarito3376]

Nobody likes Micah. But you got to admit, he nailed it with his reply!

[@vvgr409]

From him it's almost like a compliment.

[@yashuab.2979]

I love to hate him, makes the story more exciting!

[@watulookinat]

​@@yashuab.2979 I love to love him

[@sloppyphart7879]

I like him.

[@watulookinat]

@@sloppyphart7879 me too demented mickey

[@RHAK22]

0:30 Bill even had to get up because he couldn't believe what he was seeing 🤣🤣🤣

[@timetravelingtraveler]

Everyone: *Gives constructive critizism* Micah: You- Arthur: did I ask for your opinion?

[@volentastudios4673]

Other then bill the rest are nice but Micah isn’t smart enough to get an opinion

[@VladamirInhaler]

LMFAO, that double-take from Mary-Beth said more than all the words spoken in the entire clip!

[@deimosok2003]

The what?

[@VladamirInhaler]

@@deimosok2003 the double take? I assume you've never heard the term? Look at Mary-Beth's reaction - she looks up absent mindedly as Arthur approaches, goes back to reading and then snaps back to looking at Arthur like "wow!".

[@TheRock15793]

@@VladamirInhalerwhat does that mean? I don’t quite understand

[@sideways_chip_eater6420]

​@@TheRock15793 double take is where you look at a person or object and than back to what you were doing, only for the realization to hit you as you look at them again

[@mencobasukses97]

she's clearly thirsting over him lol

[@Veloziraptor111]

0:54 I don't know if that's a glitch or a genuine animation, but Mary Beth doing a double take is hilarious.

[@monikamorningstarshadlo4129]

Yeah it’s a glitch, but it’s still fun lmao

[@OrthurMorgan-]

it’s a glitch since he focused on her character then she naturally looked as he approached when he stopped focusing

[@Gyrbae]

It's not a glitch, it's a programmed response that all camp members do at random. If Arthur has changed significantly since previous encounter (long hair/long beard/bald/no beard/silly hat etc.) they sometimes do a double take and comment on it.

[@Luis-oy3et]

@@Gyrbaeno they dont🤦‍♂️

[@raredays2767]

@@Luis-oy3etnpc’s fucking do it so yes they do.

[@Momo-zi7sp]

Karen’s reaction tho

[@slumpchump1707]

Hey man

[@keizerfreeman3320]

ikr like no one’s stopping you ma’am 😭

[@maksymalnybul6145]

He's hispanicable now

[@eemr9572]

totally lost his head over it

[@gabrielarkangelo]

I'll catch you later then.

[@Fishpasta4]

Charles: "You shaved, who's the lucky lady?" Arthur: "You okay?" Charles: (⊙﹏⊙)

[@Yeet_Delete36]

Micah: *breathes* Arthur: Did I ask for your opinion?

[@davidle4936]

Micah: "A shave. Mary must be sniffing around again." Arthur: *So you have chosen death*

[@KieranDuffy1878]

I really wish Arthur could kill Micah

[@khalifabinhendi6107]

Bill taking his legs off the table just to have a proper look at Arthur is hilarious!!!!

[@mencobasukses97]

him and Mary-Beth doing the double take 😂

[@jonts7]

The gang also reacts when you're wearing the sheriff badge in Chapter 3, when you buy new customized pistols (yeah), when you're bloody, when you're dirty, when you're wearing fancy clothes... It's quite impressive how they thought of pretty much everything the player could do and went out of their way to record specific dialogues for that, from multiple characters, that most players wont even notice or even get to hear.

[@Reyfan601]

Customized pistol? Elaborate pls

[@jonwifebeaterjones6389]

They will also compliment you on your horse if it's a good one and you keep it clean or do the care package. Its crazy

[@jaredhiggins3746]

micah got the best reaction

[@masonmorley5065]

"Did I ask for your opinion?"

[@lucasabdou7130]

charles better

[@poweroffriendship2.0]

When Arthur Morgan get shaved, his appearance in the way he dressed looks like the character straight out of _Hamilton._

[@TicTacMoe-]

I like how Karen looked like she was approaching with an intention for kissing... 💀

[@Itslanny2dab]

Well she did mention it…

[@Ludovicus1769]

I like how he only responded to Micah, the hate is just too strong not to.

[@ArthurMorgan1947Boss]

The girls are all down bad for arthur but karen didn't try to hide it

[@BOOtyFiddler445]

Lenny is just the sweetest

[@guitartheherogamer]

0:38 smartest thing bills ever said

[@bearimpaler101]

Lenny: "you look 5 years younger" uncle: "that shaved knocked 20 years of that mug".... so uncle thinks that arthur looks 16?

[@zanderlucioperca]

@kenreeve9510 no he doesn't he looks like he's in his thirties or about to be.

[@SpaceCowboy260]

@@zanderluciopercaback then people aged realllly fast people looked 30 at 20 so Arthur does look around 25-30 clean shaven or with a goatee but with a beard he looks his age look at all the other random npcs it’s rare they look any younger than 35 or Micah for example he’s about Arthur’s age but looks older than Dutch

[@zanderlucioperca]

@@SpaceCowboy260 25-30 as you wrote is quite close to my estimation. I think the graphic settings may have some impact on our takes. I've played on some higher settings and wrinkles and condition of his skin makes me think he's 30.

[@xcobmi]

@@zanderlucioperca he looks 40 tbh

[@zanderlucioperca]

@@xcobmi you mean with or without facial hair?

[@1stwonder788]

Rizzed Tilly up right quick

[@SadClown418]

Love that he stays silent with everyone's reaction exept Micah

[@marifeavenida9824]

Did i ask for ur opinion?

[@boneheadedfellow]

Uncle said 20 years, Lenny said 5.

[@IllIllIllIllIII]

Lenny is being realistic, Uncle is overreacting again

[@terryhien6709]

@@IllIllIllIllIII well, he got Lumbego 🤣🤣

[@IllIllIllIllIII]

@@terryhien6709 that's physical, nice attempt tho

[@AppleOfThineEye]

​@@IllIllIllIllIIIThat hostility was uncalled for.

[@IllIllIllIllIII]

@@AppleOfThineEye stop being a ❄️

[@haydenvaughn00]

The amount details and literal thousands of lines of specific dialogue for very events just like this, that can be missed, is mind boggling.

[@thefaterix]

"You shaved, who's the lucky lady?" "You okay?" Me to literally everyone who implies I have a chance with anywho.

[@theoutsiderjess1869]

I love how charles notices immediately and I also agree with bill for once

[@Cam-im8io]

Clean shaven is best

[@1stadc836]

Bro these NPCs are more normal than the ones we get IRL.💀

[@edwardwilliamson6589]

You Gotta Admit: Mary Has A Thing For Arthur

[@kikithepupper6774]

How can she not, he’s such a cool dude

[@edwardwilliamson6589]

@@kikithepupper6774 Right

[@edwardwilliamson6589]

@@kikithepupper6774 And Obviously Karen Want's To Be All Over Him

[@watulookinat]

​@@edwardwilliamson6589 nah shes with sean and always would be thats how she died after all

[@edwardwilliamson6589]

@@watulookinat Yeah But Arthur's A Badass Son Of A Bitch

[@arthurmorgan2906]

stop modding my fkn torso

[@arthurmorgan2906]

@seren934 if she spent her good years on an outlaw then she definitely was a fool

[@canevas1017]

Funniest comment on here

[@mencobasukses97]

​@seren934I think he wanted to at some point, then TB happened 😔

[@codyhansen3117]

I love how Arthur only responds to Micah’s comment and ignores everyone else

[@bojangles4398]

More likely the video cuts early

[@seansgamingchannel4639]

Wonder why they programmed it to only happen with the mission instead of any time arthur shaves

[@diamondsingh_]

Wait Karen's reaction tho

[@Beer_Me]

I would have told her to plant one on me then

[@-Alena-irish-german19848]

I feel like lenny is the most polite man here 😭

[@ronnycollins9125]

I have literally NEVER heard those interactions. I try to keep Arthur clean shaven ALL THE TIME… or at most give him a small goatee on the chin… like myself.

[@yashuab.2979]

It's probably alternate dialogue for that one mission where you rob the boat. This option is for if you go clean shaven, then the other option is if you don't go clean shaven (Probably because Rockstar devs knew that a large portion of players would like to keep growing their beard that they may have spent so long growing.) The option where you don't go clean shaven has them talking about the hair on top of your head instead of the lack of hair on your chin.

[@ronnycollins9125]

@@yashuab.2979 That’s funny… I remember in one save file, I had Arthur Morgan growing his hair LONG… like a METALhead’s. I can’t remember what was said to him then… but once I got to Saint Denis, the goddamn kids sure treated me like an everyday redneck… like they were SUPPOSED TO, I imagine.

[@thechickenslittl1373]

​@@yashuab.2979 its probably deleted dialogue, like the one's about arthur's long beard and long hair

[@yashuab.2979]

@@thechickenslittl1373 Oh, I had no idea, I just keep avoiding going clean shaven since I usually like at least a long moustache.

[@xarvis9047]

Maybe it happens after you have worn a beard for a while

[@kaisermapping1910]

stopping kids from saying second

[@ThatOneRussianTank]

Arthur really said "Did I ask?" to Micah lmfao. I like that he only responds to him out of the gang.

[@justinbassit8336]

I swear, I’m the only one out of all my friends who prefers clean shaved Arthur during my play through

[@KinoJosh]

im always clean shaven as Arthur and I didn't get these interactions 😭

[@michaelharrisjr]

That's okay not everybody get complimented as much when clean shaven

[@bumblebeevision]

I'm not 100% sure (I may be wrong), but I think it only happens if you choose the "extra clean shaven" option at the barber that you unlock in Chapter 4. If that's what you're talking about though then idk

[@nerdtom4513]

I think you have to go to Saint Denis Barber and select "Extra clean shaven" for the camp member dialogues.

[@thebirdnerd]

I love how bill sits up straight when he sees arthur lmao

[@jimmymeridian5174]

Bill "A beard's good for a man." Arthur "I don't see why *you* got one then."

[@interactivegameplay]

This game never stop to amaze even years later ❤

[@Rtms22554]

All this turmoil one last score we just need some noise I have a plan then the Pinkertons and the army won't know were there

[@YBGAMINGYT-ph4cl]

Bill havin a point there

[@WARRIOR_2090]

is this just a video where Arthur try's rizzing up his fellow gang members Edit:MOM IM FAMOUS!!!!

[@outlaw4liife]

Charles is such an optimistic friend

[@kimbaldun]

I noticed all them quotes changed throughout the game, Wearing any hunting's garment sets will make the camp think like you're trying out a new outfit and it doesn't look good and in Chapter 6 they'll think that the TB has made you go mad to wear those outfits.

[@j-dawg4774]

Crazy how not once have i ever heard any of these interactions.

[@lunakemi]

Ofc bill loves a beard

[@Shhtick]

I love how he didn't respond to anyone except for Micah

[@mAtTdAmOn223]

I like how every little interaction with micah made you dislike him, he was an amazing antagonist

[@triops463]

I like how Hosea pauses, like he's remembering a younger Arthur

[@frezingcrazy]

And yet again, I'm assured over 100% that camp in RDR 2 is the most well detailed location you'll ever see

[@EndOfSmallSanctuary97]

It really is absolutely insane what Rockstar achieved with it. I've played like 150 hours of RDR2 and still felt like it'd never run out of unique content.

[@DementiaGamingDementiaGaming]

Bill was so shocked he had to put his feet on the ground

[@GoonBearPig]

Bill took a minute to process.

[@Blue-jy4rf]

Of course BILL knows whats good for a man.

[@zoeybarter3246]

Bill knows a thing or two about beards 👀

[@seanynosheep72000]

0:36 that’s the most chad thing I’ve ever heard And that’s coming from Marion The Pomade Soldier 😂

[@bobsnow6242]

Bill like bears confirmed

[@mencobasukses97]

Gotta love how Bill adjust his repositioning to get a good look at Arthur before giving his opinion

[@DeacTheone]

1:51 honour is now just an item that you gift someone😂

[@foldervtolvr]

I shaved clean exactly once, and that was for the ferry mission with Trelawny and Javier. That's because genuinely clean shaven Arthur actually looks really nice, and it fits well with the heist and it's requirements.

[@Dannymanny2005]

Bro I lost it when Arthur said that to micah

[@ENTERTAININGVIDEOS1]

0:35 Words of wisdom!!!

[@midori2280]

thanks! we love us the attention to detail of having the gang react to his change!

[@ДокторМом-н3р]

Bill knows a lot about mens beauty😂

[@zarif_chow]

Abigail: "My my, Arthur!" John: "Come on, this ain't funny!" *shoves Arthur out*

[@siamwse]

0:56 Abigail and Jack are so cute 🥹🥹🥹

[@unknown_apostate]

Damn, those shoulders. Arthur's just like Dr. Livesey's cousin in this outfit and posture

[@SaintDamain]

I’ve never agreed with Bill on anything until today. When I lived in West Virginia the locals used to tell me “Don’t trust a man afraid of his own biology. We’re men. Our faces grow hair.”.

[@Chuumbo]

Arthur hit Micah with the “didn’t ask” 😭

[@valentiapauwels]

Bill was speaking facts 🗣️

[@Frog-gloves]

I do this but with animals I hunted before I donate any animal to Pearson I walk around camp so they can compliment Arthur because he deserves it

[@Mango-bf1oj]

125 years later and I be getting the same reaction from my own family lol

[@Have_a_fabulous_day]

Karen WHAT 💀

[@lisvender]

I usually keep Arthur with a little stubble and long hair. I think it’s interesting that clean-shaven is more striking to the gals in this time period

[@Billy_the-cat]

Micah knows about mary, interesting

[@mencobasukses97]

The real reason why he turned Rat, women and jealousy are the true reason after all

[@Billy_the-cat]

@@mencobasukses97 well I hear that theory for the first time

[@leonkrzem1226]

I like how accurate Micah's prediction is.

[@andris404]

It's cool that the gang members react on your appearance, but it sucks that you can't react back. Except for Mika, for some reason

[@Catman43]

1:17 Did I ask for your opinion ? 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@hanajak]

I still remember the first time I saw Arthur clean shaven. I had the full-grown beard for the whole game, went clean shaven, and had the worst conflict in my life on whether to keep it or go back to the beard. I'll just say that Arthur has a handsome mug 😭

[@caseyguilfoyle4580]

Bill: *slowly takes legs off table* “My, my, what have we got here, Morgan?”

[@DevonLadd]

Of course micah is the only one being negative, even uncle gave a compliment

[@fandaklada609]

That was probably the only time he wasnt negative, cause he was actually right for once 😄

[@EndOfSmallSanctuary97]

Well he wasn't wrong, Arthur does go on a fancy date with Mary in that chapter.

[@angelparrilla2068]

Hosea: Clean shaven, you look... like a new man. I don't know why... but for some reason I thought he was gonna say "Like a Pansy". Why the pause? He's clean shaven too.

[@kimberlyh.1090]

Maybe Arthur usually keeps stubble/a beard? idk

[@DutchPlanDerLinde-se9fk]

Rare time when i agree with Bill

[@LedgerLegend-ns4ns]

i love how he only responds once, and it was an antagonize to micah

[@LiminalOutOfTheBox]

at 0:30 i was pretty sure he didn't recognize arthur at first and was about to kick the ass out of it till he get answers of why that strange fella was there, just to notice it was arthur who shaved his beard and got younger, just to go back to idle again~

[@marquviousgreen4674]

That compliment from hosea actually hits different

[@AngryBassist66623]

1:38 well hot dog Tilly!! 😘

[@deadhead2453]

Bill likes his men bearded

[@nkk313]

One time I came back to camp with a fully upgraded schofield and Tilly said "I like that new revolver of yours"

[@doomy330]

bro ur arthur LIFTS

[@Neko_Medic]

Arthur does rock the look. Very elegant.

[@hallowedgrimm5954]

I never shaved my Arthur past 2. He looks weird to me when Shaven.

[@watulookinat]

Yeah really goofy

[@RyanzinBR]

And here me still trying to find a gameplay where he is always shaven.

[@Frankie-f5c]

Mary Beth literally looked up once with a follow up second look with a quickness 😂.