aespa ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from Black Mamba to Supernova]

enjoy
~~~
contact: [e-mail]
tiktok: @kstat_yt
aespa ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from Black Mamba to Supernova]
Karina
Giselle
Winter
Ning Ning
#aespa #supernova #LineDistribution #AllSongs #karina #winter #ningning #giselle #album #kstat

[@philip0w0hoang]

Average Line Distribution per song Winter: 39.2 | 28.1% Ningning: 38.7 | 27.7% Karina: 32.9 | 23.6% Giselle: 28.7 | 20.6% Variation: 14.3% Color of Zone: Green

[@philip0w0hoang]

I decided to update the Key a tiny bit. Though, there may not be much differences. Gold (Very Fair): 0%-9.9% Green (Fair): 10%-30% Yellow (Normal): 30.1%-60% Orange (Unfair): 60.1%-94.9% Red (Very Unfair): 95%+

[@Roach_EntertainmentOFFICIAL]

Yet they still complain

[@philip0w0hoang]

@@Roach_EntertainmentOFFICIAL About what?

[@Roach_EntertainmentOFFICIAL]

@@philip0w0hoang the line distribution

[@kpopbroughtmehere]

isn't it funny that the gap between winter and ningning was higher when winter was still considered a lead vocalist? now that they're both main, finally ningning is starting to getting treated better edit: found out that winter is lead again.

[@udebrl]

Winter still a lead vocalist

[@ILLNES_S]

​@@udebrlshe is main vocalist confirmed on weverse

[@Teeeeooo]

@@udebrl she was announced as a main vocalist

[@udebrl]

@@Teeeeooo where

[@awayowayo]

weverse i think ​@@udebrl

[@joao.gu1lherme]

The main vocal NingNing, the original, soon takes the first place, which is yours by right

[@eksoelekso7277]

winter i love you

[@bestminijeongss]

I hope SOME ningning stans stop complaining about line distribution especially winters lines like ningning was first in drama album 4 out of 6 songs and is first at supernova aswell.Im not saying ningning doesnt deserve her lines she deserves but stop spreading hate comments towards winter its not her fault🩷

[@Cryforme-]

It's actually fair- but only Giselle deserves better

[@twicatcher]

no. giselle main rapper

[@anisaafsar4528]

As a rapper. The worst vocalist and dancer of the group. Doesn't have outstanding stage presence or charisma or popularity. No she doesn't "deserve" better. I love her and she's a great idol but be realistic lol. She's getting amazing lines compared to what she would get in any other group as her only good position is as a rapper

[@chapeaudeplumes]

​@@anisaafsar4528 erm why are you mad??

[@Cryforme-]

​@@anisaafsar4528 She got first place only 1 time & 2nd place only 2 times so she deserves better there Aespa everyone are nice vocalists anyways-

[@blackbird251]

@@anisaafsar4528but giselle and Karina are around the same level as vocalists

[@DuskLizares]

People arguing over whether Karina or Giselle is the better vocalist when the difference is completely negligible do be kinda funny

[@NoixDeCocoSplit]

True They are Both like D/D+ in vocal tier

[@rosiesarered7433]

You’re so quick!! I love supernova by the way, where did you get the line distribution from?

[@winnerloserww]

I think it's from Random-K

[@_lukaz_silva_]

Giselle merecia pelo menos mais umas 2 ou 3 músicas onde ela fosse a primeira em questão de linhas. Até hoje só Lucid Dream

[@JIHYO.Y.Y.]

really not too bad but with some lines for giselle 💚💚💚

[@PererecaSuicida1]

You wasn't in hiatus?

[@bestminijeongss]

​@@PererecaSuicida1Lol

[@iroseqn3438]

We need more Giselle lines please

[@akslx11]

its a 4 member group she gets a lot of lines lol someone has to be last

[@iroseqn3438]

@@akslx11 what is your problem?? I’m just saying as MY we want more Giselle lines, what does that mean wt

[@H0PEFHVLL]

@@akslx11she’s the main rapper and somehow Karina gets more rap lines

[@nicolasmagalhaeslussim2711]

Winter is last in supernova actually

[@opinionisopinion]

Giselle the best rapper of the group and 3rd best vocalist The line distribution she get "a short rap and few vocal parts" really like how SME is not bias

[@hirano5725]

Nah Karina>Giselle

[@opinionisopinion]

@@hirano5725 Giselle>Karina

[@douaedouae3451]

No Karina is the 3rd best vocalist

[@Blinkmoon711]

Vocal Karina>Giselle Rap Giselle>Karina

[@opinionisopinion]

@@douaedouae3451 Giselle high D+ vs Karina Mid to High D+

[@k-multifan]

I feel like Winter was treated similar Nayeon from TWICE. They're both lead vocalists, but they get more lines than their main vocalists. I even thought main vocalists from SM groups are treated well by having more lines in songs. I was really suprised that NingNing is the main vocal of aespa, but she isn't 1st place in the overall line distributions like Wendy from Red Velvet.

[@alxndrsreyes]

just wanted to say both winter and ningning are the MAIN VOCAL OF AESPA

[@aeri_taylors-version]

i mean skill wise i’d argue wendy is far above the other RV ladies so she’ll almost always get the final chorus ad libs / high note.

[@XccZ9]

The reason why SM is treating Winter like a Main Vocal is because that she is a Korean and she has the visual ability, if Ningning was a korean, SM would have treated her better like a princess but sadly she’s not. Plus she had the longest training period than other members, she has the potential of being a well treated member like Seulgi or Jihyo idk. Now SM is acquired by Kakao, they now have different staffs and pds, and finally see Ningning’s ability as an all rounder 🎉🩵💜 (vocal 100%, dance 80%, rap 60-70%) (and of course being an ace doesn’t mean that you have to know how to compose or write, many official aces they don’t know too) Why Winter is half considered as a “Main Vocal” in aespa too? Because people only see the lines she’s getting, the higher note she sings or how sweet she sings. But that’s not only what the Main Vocal is, SKILLS is the most important thing to have as a main, she’s a lead and of course she has good technique and voice, but not highly skilled like Ningning. (Some of Winter’s high notes are so “annoying” to listen, too sharp and sometimes out of tune) BOTH GIRLS ARE SUPER TALENTED AND VERY PRETTY, I HOPE EVERYBODY GETS WHAT THEY TRULY DESERVE❤

[@sushi672]

This backhanded ass comment…

[@ara9755]

People like you are so pathetic because you can't hide your hypocrisy. Saying Winter's voice is sometimes annoying to listen to but then saying NN and W are both so talented. Pick an argument. Regardless, Winter stays on top!

[@jisongprak882]

now ningning might be first bc of armageddon, she really shone there.

[@royertorresrazo7784]

Yo juraba que Karina tenía más líneas, pero bueno

[@comedistas]

Black Mamba Forever Next Level aenergy Savage I'll Make You Cry Yeppi Yeppi Iconic Lucid Dream Dreams Come True Illusion Life's Too Short Girls Lingo ICU Beautiful Christmas (ft. Red Velvet) Hold On Tight Welcome to MY World Spicy Salty & Sweet Thristy I'm Unhappy Till We Meet Again Better Things We Go ZOOM ZOOM Drama Trick or Trick Don't Blink Hot Air Balloon YOLO You Jingle Bell Rock Over You Regret of the Times Die Trying Supernova TOTAL: 윈터 Winter: 1448.9s 닝닝 NingNing: 1431.5s 카리나 Karina: 1215.7s 지젤 Giselle: 1063.3s BLACK MAMBA ~ SUPERNOVA aespa (에스파)

[@Sapphire_Ace]

By the way, to any annoying person who clearly hates winter, THEY ARE BOTH MAIN VOCALISTS. Their weverse accounts says it....

[@sushi672]

winter gets treated like a main vocal because she sings like one (and now officially is one). this doesn’t take away ningning’s title whatsoever. mys really need to understand that.

[@jisongprak882]

weverse profile is not in anyway official lmao their staff be putting random descriptions for their artists. mark having a totally different description in dream vs 127, calling jeno a freaking samoyed like ??? what's that gotta do with anything, it's ridiculous. aside from the leader position, all sm artists' positions were never OFFICIALLY and CLEARLY stated nor announced anywhere.

[@sushi672]

@@jisongprak882 it has been confirmed and stated on many different occasions, aside from weverse, that winter is a main vocal. not sure what nct has to do with this or why they’re being mentioned

[@karolinaservilha2842]

for a SM artist her technique is still weak for a main vocal tho. She's young, and can improve, but Ningning studies hard vocal tecnique since early childhood and can actually belt and has suport notes more easily than Winter. She is improving a lot , tho.

[@djdjsjskjdnnxsjns]

you're missing "get goin'"

[@Land070696]

Ningning should be the first. I believe, it's a question of time

[@spookyems]

Makes sense that the main rapper has the least lines since aespa is more of a vocal group but Giselle has a nice singing voice too

[@jgilly02]

i thought giselle wasn’t last in supernova?….

[@jotambor6360]

You forgot Get Goin 🙈

[@Grizzisnothome]

although my bias is karina, giselle deserves more first places cause the gap between the two is too large especially for a group with only 4 members and not 19

[@O-O-vc5gx]

BRO MISSED GET GOING

[@alicjanizio7051]

Where is song get goin by aespa

[@Tutworzynicia]

3:54 yayyy im so happy winter is first i love all the members thow

[@Tutworzynicia]

@Co-hostjihoon why

[@GabrielAlves-jc4rg]

​@@TutworzyniciaNingning has been receiving lines these last few days and it seems like she is being treated like a main vocalist and well there is a chance that she could spend the winter

[@Tutworzynicia]

@@GabrielAlves-jc4rg but winter deserves she still had the most lines lolll

[@joao.gu1lherme]

NingNing is much better than Winter, so it deserves to be first. The group’s original main vocal

[@Tutworzynicia]

@@joao.gu1lherme u are so rude such a toxic my

[@bestminijeongss]

We need giselles vocals in title tracks too not only in bsides also sm give her more lines especially full rap parts!!

[@H0PEFHVLL]

This line distribution is so unfair, Karina is lead rapper sub vocals , Giselle is main rapper sub vocals too, but somehow Karina gets more lines and more rap lines, and ning2 is main vocal and winter is lead vocal, and somehow winter is the first?

[@ara9755]

WINTER'S profile literally says "main vocalist" on weverse what are most of you arguing about? She will always be 1st or 2nd with most lines.

[@jisongprak882]

weverse profile doesn't prove anything lmao their staff be putting random descriptions for their artists. mark having a totally different description in dream vs 127, calling jeno a freaking samoyed like ?? what's that gotta do with anything. weverse profile is ridiculous.

[@ara9755]

@jisongprak882 weverse is an official website linked to the artist. now, tell me your credible source, where it clearly states an up to date of Winter's position. Also, don't bring NCT in an argument of Aespa. They may be in the same company, but they have a different team managing them. There are different.

[@mypearlb5208]

​@@ara9755 The centers for each SM artists aren't included in managing Weverse by the way. Remember that H*be owns it so SM does not have direct control on who manages each artists' page. They mainly put creative descriptions for all the artists, even based on fans' trend for the members. If you take them seriously, I don't know what to tell you honestly.

[@mypearlb5208]

​@@jisongprak882 No one takes Weverse profile as legitimate source because of this lol

[@ara9755]

@mypearlb5208 Thanks for your info. However, my point still stands, where does it say WINTER is not a main vocalist. I would accept your disagreeing views, but there is nothing backing up your arguments other than assumptions. Ppl in the comments discredit her merits and vocal ability. Why go about hating on her for having the most line distribution. She has the voice of a main vocal, she sings like a main vocal, she has the lines of a main vocal, yet it is saddening ppl treat her harshly in the comments. I came here to comment she is a main vocal and that ticks so-called fans. i wonder what's the underlying issue for this.

[@arthunbransd3618]

Winter is also the main vocal so yall can stop crying now

[@lcid.cookiee]

Nop, is Ningning, only NingNing, Winter is the lead

[@arthunbransd3618]

@@lcid.cookiee incorrect Winter is now also a main

[@mariqilieva6650]

❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@winchanpen]

あれGet Goin'は？

[@Juaozinho-i9m]

Can You do tutorial?

[@carolynhoo5756]

Your profile ♥️

[@ViolettaVevoTV]

You forgot Get Goin'

[@nuzhatkhan2761]

Justice for Giselle!!!!! Istg she is the main rapper but literally didn't got any rap lines in their 1st album's both the track songs.

[@izzathirah]

Ningning fans can't accept that winter is a main vocalist too 😂😂

[@Crystaaaalize]

AESPA DISTRIBUTION IS NOT UNFAIR AS IT SEEMED.

[@mariqilieva6650]

5 seconds ago ❤😊

[@lcid.cookiee]

You're forgotten "Get Goin'"

[@helana2203]

what song giselle number one lines in

[@SusyNurasnah]

Lucid Dream

[@patrickyu6732]

Actually, Winter is not least line in Don't Blink.

[@clearlyblurry508]

Giselle is goated af.

[@anacatalinamaringenez7392]

Aespa not all songs Black Mamba Forever Next Level Next Level (Habstrakt Remix) Next Level (IMLAY Remix) Next Level (Licoland Remix) Aenergy Savage I'll Make You Cry YEPPI YEPPI ICONIC Lucid Dream Dreams Come True Dreams Come True Intrumental Illusion Life's Too Short Life's Too Short (English ver.) Life's Too Short Instrumental Girls Lingo ICU Girls (Minit Remix) Girls (BRILLNT Remix) Beautiful Christmas with Red Velvet Hold On Tight Welcome To MY World (feat. Nævis Spicy Salty & Sweet Thirty I'm Unhappy 'Til We Meet Again Spicy (Nitepunk Remix) Better Things We Go Better Things (RAYE Remix) Better Things (Sped Up Version) Better Things (Slowed Version) Better Things (Snack Version) Better Things (Tropkillaz Remix) Better Things (Dance Remix) ZOOM ZOOM Drama Trick or Trick Don't Blink Hot Air Ballon YOLO You NOBODY Jeon Soyeon (g)i-dle Liz Ive Winter Aespa Jingle Bell Rock Drama (Sped Up Version) Jingle Bell Rock (Sped Up Version) Regret Of Tge Times (2024) Regret Of The Times (2024) Instrumental Die Trying with TOKiMONSTA Get Goin'

[@GabrielAlves-jc4rg]

I think the remix and speed up version of the songs is not included

[@averyatwell95]

Is this a joke? 😂

[@Ashwanimittal9]

Actually Giselle is second in black mamba Proof : kzbin.info/www/bejne/bKTSZnl9obt2jassi=P6FFsXQFH2E-RJ7q

[@redloona1085]

she's not, not only is that hidden vocals but she's also not first in the video you showed

[@bestminijeongss]

She is 2nd in the video tho🤓🥲

[@KYTISKE]

1. Lead vocalist 2. Main vocalist 3. Vocalist 4. Sub-vocalist Fair enough 👍

[@m0ogurt]

1. Main vocal 2. Main vocal 3. Vocalist 4. Sub-Vocal

[@TurkaneAdgozelova]

Nah Giselle is 3rd best vocal

[@mimi_imfat]

1. 2nd best vocalist 2. The best vocalist in the group 3. 4th best vocalist 4. 3rd best vocalist