aespa ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from BLACK MAMBA to WHIPLASH]

[@philip0w0hoang]

Average Line Distribution per song #1 Ningning: 43.3 | 28.4% #2 Winter: 41.5 | 27.2% #3 Karina: 35.8 | 23.5% #4 Giselle: 31.7 | 20.8% Variation: 13.9% Color of Zone: Green

[@Hello-fi7od]

ningnings voice is so heavenly 😍 so glad she gets the most nowadays

[@MummanLego]

Giselle deserves more lines and a full rap verse ,my pinkselle💗

[@Amandine___]

She got a full rap verse in Savage already!

[@itsraimehangg]

​@@Amandine___ yeah but that was three years ago it's already been long overdue

[@Amandine___]

@@itsraimehangg yeah for real

[@Caspian_Xx]

@Amandine___ that's the bare minimum ? she's the main rapper ? Who else was supposed to get a full rap part ? Like y'all be coming up with some extra pathetic excuses . It's like saying "she got the most adlibs so be grateful" about a group's main vocalist....it's like their job, so because she had a rap in a song means she doesn't need lines ? In a group where their skills aren't that far apart , the lines shouldn't be either.

[@Amandine___]

@@Caspian_Xx I’m not saying that. In every Aespa song I’m waiting and hoping to see a new Giselle rap. They definitely should give her more rap I only want that. I was just saying that it’s not like she never rapped but I really want to see her get the kind of raps Soyeon gets for instance. And I agree for the main vocalist thingy.

[@meu-valsk]

Uk the group has good singers when fans keep arguing on who should be the main vocalist😂 as a ning2 biased i love both ningning and winter’s voice so im not gna complain😁

[@cherryentertainmentggk-ran7369]

I mean it’s pretty obvious Ningning should be / is the main vocalist since she is the most technically capable. Winter is a better belter however.

[@shreybaee]

I just want a full giselle rap verse, like all of it is hers and its not split with anyone else. it's just her. like that's it. thank you for coming to my TED talk

[@veronica_hill]

Why is everyone complaining when it’s literally fair, someone needs to be first and someone needs to be last, there are groups out there that have way worse distributions, aespa have pretty fair distributions over all compared to other groups, Ningning and Winter are main vocals and Karina is an all rounder and she has a very unique voice that’s why the distribution is like that, also every single one of them have shined in both singing and rapping so I don’t get the complaints

[@ednaedna9601]

ALL ACE

[@kittypawser2512]

Exactly!!! It's so annoying these Giselle solo stans driving me crazy the distributions make sense and are always pretty fair. If let's just say winter got 100 sec and Giselle got 20 that's different but what they have RN is actually very fair based on their skills and positions. Please stop crying. Like imagine it was like Everglow distributions, then I'd understand but this is really fair. Also no one stops to think that maybe she asked for less lines. That can happen like Sakura has opened up about wanting less lines so honestly we never know but anyway I wish you a great day ❤

[@veronica_hill]

@@kittypawser2512 You get it! They indeed have fair distribution unlike Everglow and other groups. I hope toxic Giselle stans will stop acting up. You too have a great day~

[@_Seph_]

Honestly it's pretty fair distribution of lines overall. Giselle almost has 21% and Ningning 28,4%? That's REALLY fair. Perfectly equal would be if everyone had 25%. And 21-28 is REALLY close around it. You have groups like Blackpink or 2NE1, where some members have way above 30% (close to 40 even) and others don't even reach 20% (sometimes closer to 15 lol) You may be yapping, but aespa is one of fairest groups when it comes to line distrubutions. And the overall graph shows it really well.

[@H0PEFHVLL]

Bro Karina has more rap lines than Giselle

[@_Seph_]

@@H0PEFHVLL So? That means Giselle must have A LOT of singing lines to reach 21%. Good for her, singing a lot! I said it's a fair distribution. It is. Case closed. 😉

[@H0PEFHVLL]

@@_Seph_ nope she must have more rap lines than Karina and more lines than her!

[@mathhenri-xy5fh]

They wouldn't last a day in 2nd Gen. If Sistar fans weren't throwing a fit with their line distributions, no other group fans should.

[@_Seph_]

@@H0PEFHVLL She MUST have? Interesting 🤔 She doesn't though. How come she doesn't if she MUST have 👁️👄👁️ Glitch in Matrix! Universe is broken!!! Grow up, pls. Aespa is a music group, the members are artists. They don't care about their fans petty arguments. They are FRIENDS. And what you are doing is putting friends against each other because of HOW MUCH THEY SING 💀 Pls grow up really.

[@AJ-nu9cn]

Winter deserves a massive apology from aespa's fans for the hate and harrasment she got and still contiues to get for lines

[@rleywntr]

Wbk that they're racist towards the Korean members. If another person is first in line distribution, it is a fair one but if it's Winter, it's called a "mistreatment" to their bias XD

[@AJ-nu9cn]

@@rleywntr they hate them and harass them just cause they’re popular and Koreans. Never seen this with any other group I stanned

[@rleywntr]

@@AJ-nu9cn agree! The harassment from those subfandoms is insane

[@yoonaddict2527]

They are never gonna do that. For them in this group any member can get a lot of spotlight and successes except for Winter

[@AJ-nu9cn]

@@yoonaddict2527 I still remember the harassment, sl*t shaming, and even death threats she got in 2022 after Girls. Same thing happened after Spicy. They treated her like she committed a crime

[@fad9582]

Main Vocalist NingNing 1st.. ❤😊

[@Dirrie_e]

Winter is also the main vocalist, my Ning2 and winter is the main vocalist of 4°gen 😍

[@paws8403]

​@@Dirrie_e winter is lead from the profile. But being 2 of vocalists is still fair for their parts

[@ShaunMonteFalco]

sorry but winter is now a Main Vocalist got really changed it back​@@paws8403

[@chaewoners]

@@paws8403winter was confirmed their other main vocalist recently

[@Miloticygon]

Winter is actually also main vocalist now

[@Aes_1dle]

NINGNING !!! QUEEN

[@rexxder]

yall need to accept that winter is also the main vocal and, rankings always have no.1 and no.2, it really doesn't matter who tops the rank. they're both good singers

[@clyde4306]

winter isn't the main vocal

[@cvntywinter]

​@@clyde4306 she's been a main for a long time now

[@alejo_oq]

Soon Giselle will have the double of lines than Jisoo

[@nakuraitomi21]

Aespa has double the songs of bp. Not comparable

[@AadiCartoonGeek]

How can you just depreve jisoo

[@彡Love.Until彡]

Jisoo is lead vocalist but Giselle is sub vocalist so it is normal for her to get less parts.

[@ednaedna9601]

​@@彡Love.Until彡😂😂😂😂JISOO COCKS ES SU VOCALISTA... ROSÉ MAIN VOCALIST Y JENNIE VOCALISTA LÍDER JISOO SOLO VOCALISTA

[@ednaedna9601]

​@@AadiCartoonGeekNO JISOO COCKS NADA QUE VER ESA SOLO ES VISUAL NO SABE CANTAR

[@cutebunnyhops]

Winter is main vocalist too and her voice is a base for most aespa titles, especially chorus and pre-chorus. You can clearly hear her voice among others cause she's leading most of the time. Her vocal tone is the most fitting to aespa's unique style of music: in next level, savage, girls, illusion, spicy, better things, drama, supernova

[@ednaedna9601]

NINGNING 👑👑👑👑👑👑

[@GreySky27]

​@@ednaedna9601shut the fuck up you're under every winter comment

[@danidr2]

I agree I love Winters vocal tone. It's one of my favorite in aespa and kpop overall

[@dareenabuhmeidan2286]

Winter ate 🔥

[@까미대박유튜브]

On other channels, Kill It and Pink Hoodie are the top winter hits.

[@ednaedna9601]

YO CHEQUE BIEN LAS CANCIONES Y EN KILL IT ES NINGNING SOLO WINTER GANA EN PINK HOODY

[@atne3484]

Wtf is wrong with the comments?

[@ohitz_mocha]

Right? It sucks that such an amazing group has such stupid fans

[@sammielim7040]

Everyone being protective of their own biases 🤷🏻‍♀️ Back when ningning line distribution is lesser than winter, we was protective (i mean main vocal supposed to get more lines or whatever and that was bef sm announced winter is main vocal as well) and some stans went crazy now ningning finally overtake after whiplash, winter stan telling ningning stan to f off 😂 and ning stan obv not happy as ning is still being mistreated by the company Giselle stan is unhappy cos she got last in line distribution and didnt get any full rap verse Karina stan is unhappy cos she gotten last in whiplash and idk 😂😂😂😂

[@nikkivy123]

Ah more like Ning is number 1 now, so can they leave Winter alone now? Since they had bullied her half of aespa career already ​@@sammielim7040

[@MdRajo-n7n]

​@@sammielim7040where is the mistreatment for ningning? The only sub fandom that have full right to complain is giselle stan ( saying this as a non giselle biased)

[@sammielim7040]

@@MdRajo-n7n geez “back when” learn to read

[@yoonaddict2527]

Winter being 2nd and you will still see Ning Ning akgaes calling her lines stealer

[@Ttx20]

you’ll be fine 😂

[@likelyoolikemetoo]

Ning Ning being a Chinese member and you see Korean fans being sinophobic

[@argxoxo7326]

@@likelyoolikemetoo ning why come to korea🤣? cause she useless in china ,yawwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww

[@argxoxo7326]

@@likelyoolikemetoo becoz chinese are not good neighbors,look at the trouble with most nation😝sm just use her for market🤣,if kpop totally banned in China then she's out🤣🤣

[@argxoxo7326]

@@likelyoolikemetoo proof???😂😂don't play victim card lol

[@БориславАмов-ю8е]

WINTER AND GISELLE 🤍🩶🖤🤎💜🩵💙💚💛🧡🩷❤️❤️‍🩹❤️‍🔥❣️💟💕💞💓💗💖💝💘💌

[@callmeMEILING]

Wth w the comments..I'm really happy for Ning because she's the first in the lineup distribution ❤ As she shows her vocal performance very well just like Winter, but these people fight over such absurd things and they're in the same fandom?? Instead of throwing hate at the members of the group, be happy for them and shut your big mouths pls..

[@sushi672]

In one of the past videos, I commented on how ning and winter alternate 1st places and fans were in my replies crying about how ning gets mistreated in regards to line distribution. I said just give it time. Now where is this so called mistreatment lol

[@wntrcore]

ning2 fans just LOVE to play victim card so hard. They act like she hasn't sung almost whole titles since drama era. and even in bsides, more than half of the album has her parts the most. drama, armageddon and now whiplash album. looks like she is favorited these days🤣

[@yoonaddict2527]

They are the most hypocritical subfandom of aespa

[@rosie5816]

@@wntrcoreshe’s the favorite bc she’s finally getting pushed as the main vocalist-? In spicy she was basically forgetten she got 1 full verse and the a bunch of short lines and adlibs, most of lines come from adlibs and she’s never pushed for vocally killing parts. It’s been a long time since she’s gotten the killing highnotes in their title track.

[@cutebunnyhops]

​@@rosie5816Winter is main vocalist as well, her voice is essential to aespa discography. Her vocal tone and colour is most fitting for the aespa concept and singing style

[@rosie5816]

@@cutebunnyhops do it look like I give a damn-? Ningning is aespa’s MAIN vocalist. They will never be able to take that position unless she’s out of aespa. Sm has a bias towards winter and Karina and makes it obvious.

[@hihi_0906]

Giselle has only gotten ONE time to shine and it was in a bside 3 years ago... she deserves better.

[@joao.gu1lherme]

Main vocal NingNing in first 🎉❤

[@Dirrie_e]

Winter is also the main vocalist, my Ning2 and winter is the main vocalist of 4°gen 😍

[@aabbcc099]

​@@Dirrie_e Ningning >>

[@BecaOmena]

Winter >>>>>>>​@@aabbcc099

[@Dirrie_e]

@@aabbcc099SM's vocal princesses Ning2 and Winter, just like Wendy and Taeyeon I love my queens ;)

[@Fairy_ld]

​@@aabbcc099 Solo stans don't deserve to stan any group, I understand biases but js not like that

[@asya_sanu]

Столько песен за 4 года карьеры🤯 В я шоке

[@Gagan__L1485]

For those who are barking over high notes, note who got notes since debut Black mamba ning Next_Level winter Savage ning Girls winter Spicy mid notes both Drama winter Supernova ning Armageddon ning Now tell me where is discrimination

[@Harelewy]

I really loathe ningning toxic stans (unfortunately they’re are A LOT) who just scream discrimination whenever she’s not on top 😭

[@duaoelfkejdksjafkdkd]

ウィンターもニンニンも上手くねぇじゃねえか雑魚がよ。わざわざ挑発的なコメントしてんじゃねえよカスが

[@francoportillo4659]

From those 1700 seconds, how many are actual rap verses? It would be a good line distribution if SM give Giselle actual rap verses, the only good female rapper in SM history, and she has like 2 "good" verses in 4 years.

[@Mah_K-sky]

The giselle😢

[@GatoFeliz-cd4zk]

For everyone aespa doesn't really have "official" positions, but if they had, most likely would be: Ningning and Winter main vocalist, Giselle main rapper, Katina lead rapper, main dancer, fotg, lead vocal, Winter lead dancer, Mingzmingz sub-rappers. But I would like to add, Ningning as a lead dancer, and Giselle as a lead vocalist, and leave the center position unofficial. Just admitt it, aespa is a really taltented group, literally every member could have any position

[@skittle2821]

they do have positions though? Karina is sub vocal, lead rapper, main dancer, fotg, leader and visual; Gigi is sub vocal and main rapper; winter is sub rapper, lead dancer, main vocalist, and visual; ningning is main vocalist and maknae

[@GatoFeliz-cd4zk]

​​@@skittle2821They have said they don't have positions, but a lot of sources, like weverse say that positions you've mentioned, that's why I said "official", 'cause some say they have but don't always agree

[@skittle2821]

@@GatoFeliz-cd4zk oh ok 👍 how do you feel about whiplash?

[@GatoFeliz-cd4zk]

@@skittle2821 I'm obsessed, with all the songs

[@oliver74231]

You and sunmook_k will need to set this straight cause you guys have different countings.

[@Michifiedddd]

Now I don’t want to see any Ningning yappers yap at any Winter stan in the future.

[@cielphevans]

One of them say it's Ning revenge😂

[@omni-verse01]

It's the opposite most times I see winter solo stans go absolutely mad when they see winter getting least lines😭

[@banningtonreese8186]

Fucking weirdo

[@AJ-nu9cn]

@@omni-verse01 go to the comment section of any song Ningning is last in… Edit: heck, go to any song Winter is first in even if Ningning isn’t last… people would be attacking her in the comments and accusing her of favoritism

[@Ttx20]

@@AJ-nu9cn doing the same thing that you bitter ass winter stans are doing now despite her still being SECOND in line their most recent tt. you and all her other stans are a joke.

[@희-v1d]

난 그냥 각자 솔로 활동을 했음 좋겠다 서로 원하는 가수 보컬 실컷 들을수 있잖아

[@maomao8950]

if karina last place everyone think it is fair

[@ednaedna9601]

AMO A KARINA PERO GISELLE MERECE MAS LÍNEAS QUE ELLA, RAPEA Y CANTA MEJOR SU VOZ ES MÁS LIGERA QUE LA DE KARINA

[@Dred0n]

She's a lead rapper it would definitely be fair

[@gandashaa3564]

Karina is the Face and Visual of the group so expect her to be more on center, first in line and lots of line cause she carry the promotion of the group, and she has the cool tone that could balance the others and she is the most stable so I think this is already fair. And their gap with Giselle is not that big.

[@taomi1]

​@@Dred0ngiselle is the rapper

[@Dred0n]

@taomi1 Giselle is the Main rapper and Karina is the lead rapper

[@emma-vp6os]

Well giselle seems to be last in every single aespa songs 😮

[@ShaunMonteFalco]

i still don't understand why giselle is still remain at the 4th place 😢

[@kimsehyeon3606]

Sm hates her tbh

[@jackson.624]

Someone gotta be last bro

[@taomi1]

someone has to be last bro😭

[@aestxt7034]

we love you winter

[@Land070696]

Ниннин вновь первая, на своём месте❤

[@kim_liz]

That's fair!

[@TEAPOP_thereal]

Giselle Is the best member of Aespa

[@cutebunnyhops]

I've realised how winter is leading most of choruses, her vocal tone and colours is foundation of most songs

[@fearnotbemydododo]

Giselle desveres more lines my bias and actually i love all of aespa

[@jsj9907]

this comment is ridiculous, stop downplaying winter's main vocalist position +++ also everyone thinking karina has the most lines lmao, just shows how charismatic she is. "she's a lead rapper and giselle's a main rapper why cant giselle get the lines" well you see... you can literally answer your question by looking at karina's positions lmao. she's the all rounder, the FOTG and center, she's meant to take center stage that's just business. aespa was never meant to be a rap centered group like NCT and when was the last time her main dancer position was utilized? i cant even remember since it's been so long

[@duaoelfkejdksjafkdkd]

お前は黙れよ

[@ednaedna9601]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@cherryentertainmentggk-ran7369]

Maybe because it doesn’t make sense. It’s a 4 membered group not a 14. Having two main vocalists make no sense and Ningning as the best singer will always be seen as the main vocalist 🤷‍♀️

[@jyo4986]

Just like how in SNSD TY and JS are both main vocalist but TY is the main main one. The same with aespa. NN is the main main but both her and wntr are main vocalists.

[@perezoso29622]

This thing about demanding that SM make Giselle shine more is getting out of control. One thing is that they ask for more lines for themselves and another very different thing is using Giselle as an excuse to throw hate at Winter. It is not her fault that Giselle is not treated well. Fans must want Giselle to be a soloist. 😂😂 I am a multifandom and I have to say that it is the most fair distribution that I have seen in a group, apart from that there is not much difference between Winter and her.

[@twicatcher]

ningning stans now leave winter alone

[@likelyoolikemetoo]

same way the opposite

[@twicatcher]

@@likelyoolikemetoo not the opposite. ningning stans always cursing winter just because of 10 seconds

[@hothotth]

​@@twicatcher I see the opposite on Twitter lol

[@AJ-nu9cn]

@@hothotth are you new to aespa? Cause Winter has been harassed for years and she hasn’t been first in more than a year. She was still harassed the last time she was first which was Regret of the Times

[@hothotth]

@@AJ-nu9cn winter hate is not worst than ningning hate in 2022 and Olympic thing lol the fact I stan ningning since her rookie day 2016, her fan was harassing her for be main vocal especially than she is Chinese bfr

[@БориславАмов-ю8е]

20 minutes ago ❤😊

[@luxnova2467]

My Ningning finally first ❤ my favorite main vocalist slayer ❤🎉 the other one is so good too so get off my back Winter yappers 😂

[@Shreyisdelulu]

Winter ❤❤

[@luxnova2467]

@@Shreyisdelulugo home

[@dareenabuhmeidan2286]

U are so obsessed with winter lmao seek help

[@eirensh]

are u obsessed with winter or smth?

[@GreySky27]

My ningning finally first 🤡

[@lyn5717]

you forgot some song - get'goin , count on me , onece again , with you , SOLO first concert

[@jotambor6360]

You always forgot Get Goin 😭

[@shivabehvandi]

I love ningning so much❤️❤️❤️

[@pearlsintheskymotivation5638]

I know ning is main vocal of group so she deserve this lines but i really like winter's vocals over ningning

[@cynthia-mendez]

Winter is also a main vocal

[@pearlsintheskymotivation5638]

@@cynthia-mendez how there is two main vocal in one group winter is lead vocals and main visual I think as their position in the group

[@cynthia-mendez]

@@pearlsintheskymotivation5638 it’s stated by SM on their weverse that Winter is main vocal with Ning

[@Shreyisdelulu]

Both winter AND nin2 r main vocalists. Tho I like winter's vocals wayy more

[@pearlsintheskymotivation5638]

@@Shreyisdelulu same here I like winter's vocals most in the group

[@dareenabuhmeidan2286]

Winter is my favorite vocalist in this group she is the best in my opinion ❤

[@ednaedna9601]

NINGNING 👑👑👑

[@danidr2]

She's my favorite too I love her vocal tone

[@NVRJOSH123]

What happened in salty & sweet to thirsty

[@fl00ryn.x]

Poor Giselle 😕

[@AdamHumaidhaan]

6:10. What a lucky number she has.

[@aron_2727]

ningning is the MAKNAE 💜

[@julesfoury9240]

In Kill It the correct ranking is : 1- Karina 2- Giselle 3- Winter 4- Ningning

[@Shreyisdelulu]

Finally nin2 is last lol

[@Lovewinter19]

yes❤

[@rosie5816]

@@Shreyisdeluluhush

[@antoncutie]

​@@Shreyisdelulu Ningning in line distribution for that song but always first in vocal skill 💋 stay mad

[@hrk_nkn213]

My Ningning❤❤❤

[@tsukuli_offc]

karina last in whiplash???

[@omarzahalka8985]

Yes, It's obvious when you watch the MV 😢

[@panconleche_uwu]

Giselle deserved those lines

[@luxfindings]

@@panconleche_uwu & so much more!!

[@erikovokada3458]

​@@panconleche_uwuno one mentioned giselle here the comment is asking about karina karina stans only focus on supporting her instead of obssessing over another member unlike you guys ..

[@panconleche_uwu]

@@erikovokada3458 Bruh Karina always gets lots of lines, even more than Giselle in rap parts. In fact, my bias is Ningning hahah but I want all of them to be respected and treated equally, and with this comeback Giselle has shined a lot so I'm happy about that. Stay away with your toxic behaviour solo stan!!

[@andre4419]

Ok, but aespa girls are working a lot this year. I didn't remember Hot mess was released after Armageddon. It's just three or four months of difference to Whiplash but there's a Japanese comeback in the middle. SM don't overwork aespa

[@antoncutie]

SM made Winter and her botched nose a main vocalist because Flopning stans wont stop coming for her. Queenrina has the best voice clearly 💋

[@danidr2]

You're not doing a good job at being a troll

[@antoncutie]

@danidr2 i tried my best, please get off my case

[@danidr2]

@@antoncutie well stop trying. You're not funny or convincing anyone

[@antoncutie]

@@danidr2 not until i see karina on the top 1.

[@antoncutie]

@@no4528 gurl who is yew

[@adeherlina-t6j]

ayo karina ningning cepat aku suka sama karina ningning

[@duaoelfkejdksjafkdkd]

黙れ

[@moonlightsunshine6]

finally Ningning stans can stop yapping and being crybabies, guys we were waiting for this moment, finally winter can have a comeback without being bullied

[@guilhermesoares8005]

In 2020 Karina - 20 years Giselle - 20 years Winter - 19 years Ningning - 18 years In 2021 Karina - 21 years Giselle - 21 years Winter - 20 years Ningning - 19 years In 2022 Karina - 22 years Giselle - 22 years Winter - 21 years Ningning - 20 years In 2023 Karina - 23 years Giselle - 23 years Winter - 22 years Ningning - 21 years In 2024 Karina - 24 years Giselle - 24 years Winter - 23 years Ningning - 22 years

[@いちきん-s8h]

what is the last chart? 最後のチャートなに？

[@zyotagram]

OUT NINGNING MAIN VOCALIST ❤❤❤

[@sunnosunno-h7q]

Why is ning ning still have the lots of lines in hot mess album even Giselle is the Japanese...

[@lesserafimmakesmypocketsdry]

still patiently waiting for a giselle 1st place in a title track

[@venupsa]

fr...

[@sussexmyzennie]

Hell, still waiting for her to get 1st place on another b-side...

[@sunflowersyeppi]

It will never be possible because her position is not the main vocal. If it is on bside maybe it can, but for the title track it will never be. Because so far I have never seen Irene and Yeri's line exceeds Wendy, Seulgi, and Joy's line. In addition, it can be seen that Sehun and Chanyeol's line will never be able to exceed Chen, Kyungsoo,and Baekhyun's line

[@lesserafimmakesmypocketsdry]

@sunflowersyeppi but karina has got first place

[@rosie5816]

@@sunflowersyeppibut karina has been close to first place and she’s the lead rapper so why can’t main rapper Gigi get up there-?

[@Margaretteameidaveroski]

Ningnign is having her revenge

[@cielphevans]

Why tho?

[@cielphevans]

She got many line from the three comeback already

[@Sapphire_Ace]

it's just music.... y'all make it sound like it's war or something😐

[@cassiesays]

Lol she always had a lot of lines since debut, stop being dramatic

[@Margaretteameidaveroski]

@@cassiesays in girls and spicy era winter killed her legd

[@luffyd.aceroger8254]

idk what yall on are about their is no such thing called "fair" it would be unfair not to give the lines to the best among them in the particular song. so for an instance if they have a song that is better suited for giselle voice it would be unfair to then give to winter who arent capable enough and the "favour" her over giselle.

[@tayektamut]

karina deaserve more line ❤

[@maomao8950]

SM and aespa fandom hate karina that much

[@djdjsjskjdnnxsjns]

you're missing get goin'

[@omarzahalka8985]

Winter second!!?!?!?!?!😮

[@AnyGamerfofis]

1st

[@jaichar]

this album was boring. they need to bring back crazy winter lines

[@vitoriaapolinario4830]

I agree

[@까미대박유튜브]

pink hoodie Is Ningning 1st? In other channels, Winter is 1st and Ningning is 2nd.

[@GazaAriana]

Yeah cause the difference is so so so small that it ppl think winter or ningning it might be winter by a 1 nanosecond

[@까미대박유튜브]

It's the same song on every channel, but the parts are all different. On some channels, Winter is first, and on other channels, Winter is last. What's the reason?

[@Harelewy]

@@까미대박유튜브they prolly can’t distinguish all the ad libs correctly

[@antoncutie]

Winter and her nose left the first place? I wish Queenrina would surpass her soon

[@INmendigo]

finally ningning 1st 💗

[@mxhcxl]

girl she has been first for 80% of the past 3 albums what are you talking about

[@INmendigo]

@@mxhcxl i stan aespa since debut when winter was first, if you get mad just go to other comment

[@wntrcore]

yes, until drama she wasn't treated as the main vocal in the titles. but since drama this has changed. and since the last three albums she has been in the first place most of the time in both the bsides and the titles isnt it? so wdym by "FINALLY"

[@AJ-nu9cn]

@@INmendigo if you stan aespa since debut, you should know Ningning was first until Girls and has been first since Drama. Winter was only first for a year of their 4 year career

[@aerisellexcel]

ridiculous ngl

[@khaioberlin]

what is going on with these comments

[@imNanhha]

Some winter stans keep yapping ningning stans can't stop complaining. Can we realize the fact that winter's lines were more than ningning's before aespa recognized winter as main vocal?!! Thats what ningning stans r saying! And rn ningning got the first, then u guys jumped out of nowhere saying that ningning stans should stop arguing. Every ningning stan just feel happy for ningning being the first. So whats ur guys point?😅 keep emphasizing something like "ningning stans can leave winter alone". Just stop arguing!!! we all know ningning deserves more line before winter is a main vocal AND winter is a main vocal rn, so winter and ningning deserve singing lines!!! It is quite fair for ning and winter to have more lines❤

[@Harelewy]

girl before winter was ‘recognised’ as a main vocal by SM they literally didn’t have positions so what’s your point? Ningning might be the best vocalist but she was never called Main vocalist because they have NO POSITIONS, fans just started saying she is the main (and that’s fair because she’s the best) because SM implied it with line distribution. but you can’t really complain when she is literally first every other title (also since drama she’s been first in EVERY title track). Also being a Main vocalist is about singing parts other members can’t sing which isn’t really a problem in aespa is it? they just give line based on the most suited vocal tone and in next level where karina is first (for example), Karina’s tone is more suited for the song than ningning. I personally love both Winter and NingNing (with winter being my bias) and I don’t get mad when Ningning is first in a song? it is not that deep, MYs are just so obsessed with line distribution

[@SumairaRiyasat]

My bias winter but I'm happy that Ningning got the place that she deserves

[@NVRJOSH123]

Why can’t Giselle get more lubrs

[@paws8403]

It's not a problem tho. Winter is lead vocalist and Ningning is main vocalist, tho the gap is not that big for 2 out of 4 official vocal line in a quartet group.

[@yoonaddict2527]

Winter is a main vocalist. It’s written on their Weverse profile

[@Miloticygon]

Winter is also main vocalist now

[@z_hange]

Winter is a confirmed main vocalist on multiple sources. Can MYs respect this fact already

[@sammielim7040]

@@z_hangecasual listeners may not know about this as most group tend to only have 1 unless the group have many members. Usually in intro, ningning is known as the main vocal and maknae while winter is introduced as a black horse, all rounder so not many people will look into their profile 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@z_hange]

@@sammielim7040 Yes though I'm talking about MYs

[@felixgurapee1]

唱功不好争了主唱有啥用？

[@구구-s7y]

It's NINGNING vs WINTER 😂

[@patrickyu6732]

😮😮 winter is 2nd

[@lachainedestrucsnulle1211]

She's 2nd since a long time now 😭

[@dramatic_sooji]

@@lachainedestrucsnulle1211 really ,

[@paws8403]

It's not a problem tho. She's lead vocalist and Ningning is main, tho the gap is not that big

[@AJ-nu9cn]

@@paws8403 Winter is a main vocalist. She’s not a lead vocalist

[@Miloticygon]

​@@paws8403winter is main vocalist too

[@antoncutie]

Winter stans are fighting everyone who were proud of the other members especially Ningning in the comment 💀

[@opinionisopinion]

Ningning the real and only Main Vocalist of the group is on top 🎉 but so sad for third best vocalist and best rapper of the group seems she's mistreated so much 🙄

[@AJ-nu9cn]

@@opinionisopinion Winter is a main vocalist too. Cry about it. The company decides positions and Winter confirmed to be a main vocalist too

[@Miloticygon]

Winter is also main vocalist and much better than ningning

[@z_hange]

Why are you all so childish and disgusting

[@thatoneperson731]

@@Miloticygonning2 is better

[@opinionisopinion]

@@AJ-nu9cn Ningning C+ vs Winter C lol still ningning main and best vocalist of the group

[@YatoKpop]

Winter where she should be 😂

[@Dirrie_e]

Winter is also the main vocalist, my Ning2 and winter is the main vocalist of 4°gen. Be quiet you b1tch 😘

[@хто-х4э]

that's why i hate ning2 fans

[@Shreyisdelulu]

Gurl yall nin2 stans r so annoying yappers lmao. Winter is also main vocalist not only that weird nin2. She's wayyyy better than that nin2 lol (IK its ning2 but im not gonna waste my time writing that extra "g")

[@physicslawss]

​@Shreyisdelulu all the time you saved by taking out the gs you wasted by explaining why you took the gs out

[@no4528]

@@YatoKpop you saying this ab Winter but not having the same energy for Chaeryeong when Winter is Main Vocalist while Chaeryeong is Sub 💀 dont be a hypocrite