AI 5 Finale - Carrie, Kat & Taylor - Made it Through the rai

[@mollysouth3987]

Such a a great season on Idol. Taylors voice stood out. One of the best'

[@tutorgirl082594]

i love this performance so much. carrie was amazing, everyone was. i love carrie's hair though.

[@luvhicks]

Taylor was the total package. The unique voice, the moves and stage presence and his musicality. It made him the best.

[@JenniJaco]

@row759 Good singing comes in many different styles. Carrie had the pure tone, while Taylor clearly displayed the most emotion and connection with the audience, which brings me back to my original point: Carrie and Taylor would complement each other well in a duet. Silk and Whisky

[@newflava89AGAIN]

two best idol ever!!! Carrie Underwood and Katharine McPhee.... both of them my fav singer now!!!!!!!! Kat in pop and Carrie in country :)

[@Cherylbuckeye1968]

This was the best season!!!!!!

[@Rebereyes]

carrie is so beautifullllllllllllll

[@yesitsme9]

Taylos is HOT!!! I love that man!

[@MrASOfficial]

Love U McPhee!!!

[@kidtaouk]

I agree!

[@jannegan]

I agree with you!

[@yesitsme9]

@mermaidofsuburbia Totally agree. Soul Patrol for-evah!

[@chilidog5693]

Katharine has the most beautiful voice!

[@15joel22]

carrie is the best!!!!!!!!!!

[@SteelAVic18]

This was the best season ever of American Idol. Katherine should have won. I wish the Finale would have been between Katherine and Mandisa!

[@gabrielsierra4019]

Carrie & Katharine together

[@JenniJaco]

Carrie and Taylor sound great together..they should do a duet like Joe Cocker and Jennifer Warnes did together

[@cevichexconxpescado]

May 24, 2006

[@JenniJaco]

@row759 I prefer a voice with a little more soulful character, like Taylor's. Everyone has their own preferences.

[@qg6ff]

I think Katharine's pretty damn close up there.

[@ajamaicanparadox1]

Ohh wow.. i love this song, howeber.. i do believe Jennifer Hudson, Fantasia, and Latoya in the Top 12 Medley was better.. considering Kat is off the melody in the 1st verse. However, i must say that this is the first time I've recognized Taylor as a real singer thought

[@lilmisfit23]

I still think Carrie blew them all out of the water

[@Rebereyes]

he won because people liked him, because the people voted for him, not for kat

[@carlos312]

katharine and carrie are amazingly gorgeous. i think kat is hotter though

[@TVDmaniac]

@bigbilly2006 just a lil bit. but of course Katharine is a thousand times prettier...

[@TVDmaniac]

Taylor won just because people liked him for his humor and craziness. I mean, he can sing, but has no strength or anything special about his voice and vocals. I liked him too, but, argh! Why didn't people get real and realize that American Idol is a singing competition! The best singer must win! Not the most likeable one!

[@mollysouth3987]

He was the best singer, by far.