Aircrete is great, but watch this before you build with it!

[@domegaia]

Thanks for the great video! We have also build 8' walls that are poured horizontally on a frame that then tilts them up into place. We should have some information and a video on this coming out soon. We also have found that fiberglass stucco mesh offers great strength for the exterior layers. I would also like to offer one clarification on R-Value. There is one article out there that claims the 5-6 per inch but the information source for this is miss leading. There is an experimental commercial product that is similar to Aircrete that can achieve this r-value but it offers no structural integrity at all. Aircrete as we use it has an R-vaule of 1.8 to 2.3 per inch depending on the mix. this is still very good for the cost and lack of thermal bridging and air infiltration you get in a traditional wall. A normal 2 x 6 wall with R19 in it will actually perform around R-13 when the whole wall is factored in. I hope this information helps.

[@radicalgastronomy]

Outstanding. Thank you guys for innovating with this material. I’m looking forward to this new information!

[@beartankoperator7950]

Dome Gaia out here promoting correct info, Awesome! The mistake happened so early into the aircrete hype it became super widespread it doesn't help that Google still provides this incorrect information preferentially

[@noellwilson1273]

I was wondering about that super R value also. Is Aircrete that much different from Aerated Autoclaved Concrete (AAC)? A friend of mine moved from a high mass solar house near Oak Ridge, TN that had a wood stove for cloudy winter days to an “ideal” AAC house in Northeastern TN. The R value of AAC was low but the ads preached thermal mass. Thermal mass is fine in New Mexico but not so good when you have week long spells of cold cloudy weather. My friends now depend a lot on their wood burning stove and found that the AAC loses heat in accordance with its stated, low, r value.

[@radicalgastronomy]

@@noellwilson1273 interesting. I had thought the big problems with AAC were cost and embedded energy. Seemed cool, otherwise. Good to know!

[@nc3826]

AAC, R value.varies depending on if it is loaded bearing or non-loaded bearing .AAC.. Plus it tends to have a relatively high levelized cost in the US, since the supply is limited.... much like Hempcrete, ....

[@onecompass7290]

Enjoying your videos, thanks. I built a straw bale in 2000 and used the bales as the lath inside and out to apply three coats of clay-sand/lime/chopped straw plaster in different recipes as you have done. I worked great, no chicken wire etc. The result was gorgeous, non-toxic, cured hard and sound, no cracks etc. Final coat was sand/water/lime with lime wash over all for a stunning bright light reflective structure. I sold it in 2022 for 10 time what it cost to build. I had a gorgeous home that never needed cooling and very little heat in the VT winters. I love watching all the innovative notions people are putting into practice. Good on ya mate!

[@Biggles-x73]

I'm looking at building a straw bale home Love to pick your brains on the things you learnt before and after building. And a bit more info on the rendor 🍻

[@chrisashdown1484]

In the UK we used Aircrete on building many new hospitals 30 years ago, after about 25 years they started to fail and now are being knocked down and replaced, so whilst it had advantages in build it does not have the expected lifespan

[@SCrEenNaMe-i9h]

It’s was built incorrectly that’s why

[@normbograham]

perhaps 30 years ago, I was working on a hotel, where they put rigid foam board insulation, then skinned it with a stucco finish. The walls were not painted before a child slamed his bike handle against the walls, and broke thru to the insulation. Then damage kept happening. So, what looked like it should last 50 years, did not last 2. Hard to believe how many times exterior walls get hit with something. Within two years, all foam board was removed up to 6', and replaced with solid durarock like stuff.

[@ХозяинПолянки]

@@normbograham You are residents of a backward country :) Masons, sorcerers, horoscopes, etc. (The country's forces are dedicated to this! ) This problem was solved in the 70s in the USSR. It was enough to steal the monograph. England is stuck in the 50s in the 90s (!). Buildings are falling apart due to corrosion of the reinforcement in the slabs. Aerated concrete is a type of artificial shell rock. You might as well cut in the quarry :) (It’s hard down there, and fluffy at the top of the quarry) Styrofoam is poison

[@robertweekley5926]

@@normbograham - In the 1950's, My Father worked in California on Tract Housing. After Occupancy - The Low Cost Housing Tenants often knocked holes in the Sheetrock. Many trips back for repairing the sheetrock. Next set of houses, they put 1/4" Plywood on the studs first, then the sheetrock: No More Calls back to fix busted sheetrock! Styrofoam can be bonded to Aspenite, Plywood, or other standard sheet materials with good strength, to give it greater durability. Same with Aircrete, though it might require mechanical attachment (Screws, or Bolts).

[@Luming-di9rf]

@@ХозяинПолянки Is no country as backward as yours.

[@boltholeonabudget6526]

I was gifted a 16' diameter geodesic dome made from 3/4-inch conduit. I lined the inside with metal lath and ferrocemented the inside. Then I built a 18' dome over the smaller dome and metal lathed and ferrocemented the outside as I poured lifts of aircrete.

[@lenturtle7954]

Ive sprayed shotcrete and supervised a large shotcreting crew for 18 years in the mining contractor industry . we use robots and also spray by hand . I never believed in the fibrecrete until we tried to demolish tunnel rings that were fibre crete . Its next to impossible I now totally believe in it the strength and durability is amazingly robust . As far as vertical construction with aircrete -you need to do less than 1 meter per hour with high strength concrete without stopping if you stop you need to greencut the surface to get a proper bond with the next pours . i would think air crete could be done similarly if you poured slower or used an accelerator Like meco 160 to harden the mixes faster so u could increase the vertical rate. If you build a house that lasts longer than the glue and sawdust ones we build in todays time your footprint get smaller as each year passes . GREAT VIDEO

[@radicalgastronomy]

Thanks for the good info!

[@DrMatthewHudson]

What is meco 160? I can't find it online

[@aischaparker9471]

here in New Zealand there is a type called Foamcrete, its 20mpa and has fiber glass strands about 1.5 inches long but can spay out if pulled from each side resembling 2 'W's persay. ive seen it used as block fill in high rise buildings, on the uppermost floors , which also has steel rods within. And it has been used to form garden pool structures and then a final over lay is sprayed on at great force about 2 inches thick which is then troweled and sculptured and either sealed with a paint or tiled over. yes its been around for about 20 years now , Very light and easy to work even vertically which is alll in the batching success so its not wet enough to slump off the walls.great video thanks for sharing.

[@elizabethpears307]

Great video! Thanks very much for not having distracting background music👍

[@kerrywynn1949]

I just love you tube University it’s the best!

[@Pww642]

I know this is beside the point, but this dude has the most transfixing eyes. It's like looking into the sea.

[@oakld]

My house is built with "Aircrete" (-like product, Ytong blocks). Such products are available in Europe for many decades and are now, at least in this part of Europe, number one material. The aircrete blocks material is ranging from pure cement to ones with high gypsum (and some other stuff) additives, that drastically increase R value. Unlike those DIY alternatives, those are "baked". Blocks are precisely polished to fantastic precision of 0.5mm, so they can be joined with super thin film of mortar or (approved) mounting foam. Typical wall thickness is 300mm (10 something inches), but Today often up to 0.5m. Even with 300mm you don't necessarily need any more insulation to suffice the code, but it is typically added. I have 300mm Ytong wall + 160mm EPS insulaiton and together with tripple pane windows the house performs about at about 2.5x of passive house limit. There's no point in doing aircrete DIY in Europe, but to those overseas, if they got all the way to building an aircrete foam machine, I'd recommend to also make also a very simple polishing machine and polish the blocks to precise shape - it will sure make the structure much more sound, will drastically reduce need for mortar (or mounting foam could be used) and make assembling super easy.

[@RRaucina]

Yes, I have seen those systems in Europe and it is maddening that you can't buy those blocks in California or most of the USA.

[@John-vz5un]

Styrofoam pellets!

[@dlorien7306]

Foam crete, what is being called Aircrete here, IS NOT equivalent to Ytong AAC. There is a brand name Aircrete that is AAC but that is not foamcrete. AAC is an industrial precision material made to ASTM standards, not a DIY hack like foamcrete

[@oakld]

@@dlorien7306 While there are differences for sure, like Ytong makes cavities using aluminum particles as opposed to foam, the end product is very similar and the goal is the same. I'm quite sure, no one in the US would bother to make DIY foamcrete, if they had a cheap procreate blocks available at the nearest home depo type store. There's a video on KZbin showing DIY type foamcrete process used in industrial scale somewhere in a small republic in Asia. The precise blocks are basically indistinguishable from Ytong products (which I'm sure was the point). In Europe, there are many porocrete/aircrete products, some of them much more different from Ytong, than those DIY foamcrete. I'm also quite sure Ytong AAC is not made to ASTM standards, it was based on old standards like DIN or CSN many decades ago, which were harmonized to EN and ISO. Most likely no changes to the product were needed to meet ASTM standards, just complete documentation for US market.

[@oakld]

@@dlorien7306 @dlorien7306 While there are differences for sure, like Ytong makes cavities using aluminum particles as opposed to foam, the end product is very similar and the goal is the same. I'm quite sure, no one in the US would bother to make DIY foamcrete, if they had a cheap procreate blocks available at the nearest home depo type store. There's a video on KZbin showing DIY type foamcrete process used in industrial scale somewhere in a small republic in Asia. The precise blocks are basically indistinguishable from Ytong products (which I'm sure was the point). In Europe, there are many porocrete/aircrete products, some of them much more different from Ytong, than those DIY foamcrete. But of course, everyone is entitled to his own opinion, about proximity of the products 🙂

[@DennisKenneybees]

I have watched thousands of videos on various topics and yours is one of the best. Thanks

[@Kadranos]

If you added in a lightweight fiber reinforcement like chopped fiberglass or basalt fiber, you might see enough increase in tensile strength to have moveable panels. Even some of the more natural fibers might be sufficient. Another possibility is your dustcrete studwork wall section built then stood up. One idea I've had in my mind since I learned about earthbag homes, rammed earth, and aircrete is using a metal sprayer to put a thin aluminum shell over it to weatherize it. Apparently this kind of process has been used over 100 years.

[@ldnelso2]

Basalt fiber is a great idea for this application

[@Stuffandfangs]

They make hemp bricks, they are naturally sticky and can form hard resin as well, hemp fiber might be an extremely affordable way.

[@B30pt87]

Wow! I have been following the same You Tube channels, and came to about the same place (minus making my own foam generator.) I am a fan of domes, but your drywall-type slabs sound like a very good idea for stick frame houses. Overall, this video was excellent in a number of ways! Also, I had no idea that grain bags were fireproof. That changed my thinking because fire safety is huge for me & I didn't want to incorporate anything in my aircrete that would melt (like AH's styrofoam mix) or offgas with intense heat. I subscribed immediately, because you are the kind of person I want to hear from. Thank you for sharing!

[@radicalgastronomy]

Thank you! Glad to be of service.

[@fabonline9389]

I think domes are the best option for this material because they are self-supporting. If you build flat walls you still have to build a roof out of conventional materials. Then the question of load becomes an issue. They make materials for covering concrete roofs (fabrics) that are designed to adhere to concrete. I agree with you to keep toxic products out of a home construction. I believe the foam balls will weaken the finished product as well. You only need the fabric below the equator of the dome as the pressure is outward. Once you are above that line the structure is self-supporting. You could also make u-shaped blocks on the lower layers and add rebar "rings" to provide tension strength.

[@paperburn]

@@fabonline9389 In asia the use post and beam construction and wall panels are not load bearing

[@NoCantsAllowed]

Nice synopsis of your findings and your efforts. Best of luck with your goal. I do hope you reach it.

[@quintondavid7023]

Hey I really appreciate the analysis and multiple applications/uses. I had not personally stumbled upon many videos demonstrating floor slab assemblies. Keep crushing

[@radicalgastronomy]

Right on. Will do!

[@eileenmcloughlin4778]

I have been searching and searching everywhere for how to make sawdust and lime insulation. I can't afford regular insulation as I'm moving into a shed to live. I'm 70 and have a fractured vertebrae but have heard that you can do this with little effort. However, I don't know the ratios for each. Your video's are so inspiring. Thank you for your ingenious inventions on building with local materials. I can obtain $1.00 bags of sawdust but am not sure where to go from here. Do you have any ideas for me. Thank you very much. Intelligent people always come up with using local things for building.

[@jonisolis9645]

Wishing you the best and hope you find the help you need to build a nice home.

[@DanielinLaTuna]

“KZbin University”! Thanks for sharing

[@radicalgastronomy]

You bet!

[@echoeversky]

Thank you for the summation of the various folks solving the aircrete!

[@richardjones2767]

Great video! I've done some work with papercrete and a hempcrete-like substance using other vegitative substrates, but now that I've retired, I have time to delve into this exciting material. Thanks for your insights!

[@radicalgastronomy]

Right on. Enjoy yourself!

[@magapefarmshomestead6453]

Also if you want insulation I'd recommend styro aircrete (eps). As I can't remember everyone you mentioned that you had looked at I'll recommend the channel of "Stephen Williams"

[@foodmonsterweightloss5886]

Stephen's channel is: Abundance Building Concepts. He has a great system. It's worth noting, Aircrete Harry also uses styro aircrete.

[@evennorthug2585]

Great video. Gives us a more balanced approached to aircrete, a quite fascinating and promising material.

[@wittoist]

Do you know what the surfactant in Drexel is? I want to avoid fluorosurfactants as i dont want to contaminate the groundwater. Fluorosurfactants are commonly known as forever chemicals. I dont wabt to build a house that eill be toxic easte in 100years. Unfortunately fluorosurfactants are still incredibly common as they foam extremely well.

[@RichCampbell-p2d]

Great video. Captures all the basics, including all the concerns. I'm particularly interested in the slab walls poured vertically and then stood up. Need to be able to produce interlocking panels without the cost metal framing. Also looking to include exterior design in the pour (board and batten) to further cut down on cost. Would be willing to invest in facility to manufacture panels in the US. While DIY is fun for small projects, the potential for quality control failures is a concern. If the remaining concerns can be resolved we will have an answer to affordable housing!

[@dirttdude]

way back when, i was desperate, there was no aircrete, i developed styrocrete, made it into 3X3 blocks 4 inches thick and insulated our entire root cellar, that was 35 years ago and it still looks and smells like new in there.

[@brokenrecord3523]

😳 What does it smell like?

[@jamesmatheson5115]

Did you use bean bag type pellets?, I personally think they are better than Aerated Concrete.

[@dirttdude]

@@jamesmatheson5115 i did, i think i mixed it to three buckets full of beans for one bag of portland cement

[@jamesmatheson5115]

@@dirttdude With some shredded pvc fibre mixed in would make it strong, make your own fibre out of old bags that people throw away.

[@t9358]

Thank you very much for your time well spent, excellent work, saved me a couple hrs.

[@radicalgastronomy]

That’s what I like to hear!

[@Enoch1970]

Jamey Mantzel has used something like dustcrete. He used a Styrofoam grinder, to take styrofoam products into the cells, and then using the cells as a basis for styrocrete. It is pretty interesting. Used this stuff to make several domes on his homestead down in South America.

[@JosephMiller-nd8om]

I used this by mulching styrofoam and mixing mortar to make a vegetable grow box. I made the outer form surface to mimic a stone by squirting trails of silicone as the joints, and roughed the plywood surface. It turned out quite authentic. I threw brown and black concrete dye on it and it reminded me of a railroad bridge stone.

[@francoisbouvier7861]

Thank you. I'm watching closely and hope to integrate some of your principles into my projects.

[@radicalgastronomy]

Wonderful!

[@HolisticHealthEducation]

Very interesting and informative. Respect.

[@annmarieschantz9724]

I was curious about arecrete myself. Thanks for the video. Never tried it.

[@sketchesinsand8593]

I enjoy your channel. Thanks for reporting on all of your experimentation. Also, thanks for supporting your local farmers in their fight against the new County Dude. Anyway, in my county I have codes to deal with (I envy your "lack" in that respect), but I'm thinking I might be able to use some kind of aircrete system for insulating a timber frame structure. I like your idea of making a SIP-like material. Thinking out loud, James Hardie makes a 4x8 fiber cement panel product for board and batten look siding. I wonder about fastening one of those cement panels to a dimensional lumber frame, then pouring aircrete or dustcrete into the panelized frame. Maybe drive some nails through the panel to add something for the aircrete to grab onto. If the aircrete bonded well to the siding panel, with the added rigidity of the lumber, that might make a nice SIP replacement. Finish off the inside with plaster applied directly to the aircrete panel. Again, just thinking out loud for now. Won't have time or space to experiment with it for a while. I know that you would balk at the cost and all the commercial products, but for me, it would be a way to avoid all the outgassing foam as well as being very fire resistant. And cheaper than SIPs, especially since they would not need an additional layer of siding. I think I might be talking myself into this...

[@JarrodJordan-gf3ul]

Have you looked at the Styrofoam AirCrete (Stephen Williams) I am wondering if you could use the Sawdust in place of Styrofoam, and get a substance that is wetter like his, and more readily available in your area.

[@radicalgastronomy]

I have not, but will, now.

[@Faithful_Tribe]

Mr. Williams seems like a neat inventor.

[@tanjirokatoichi7425]

@@radicalgastronomy Sir, i 2nd with Mr. Jarnod Jordan on Mr. Stephen Williams styrocrete. I watched many videos on Aircretes (aircrete Hairy, Honeydocarpenter, styrocrete etc. Your Dustacrete seem to be the simpliest and easiest to work with and create. Glad i found your channel and videos..

[@radicalgastronomy]

@@tanjirokatoichi7425 I have watch some of the styrocrete info, and agree that there is potential. Personally, I like to avoid materials that have the potential to “off-gas”. I find styrofoam to be kind of gross. The dustcrete is performing quite well, and avoids the use of petroleum based synthetic materials. Glad you like my info!

[@tanjirokatoichi7425]

@@radicalgastronomy i love it!

[@mikescudder4621]

Here in Brazil theres a movement (who say they´re green but they´re not) where they use sheets of polystyrene stood up and held by short sections of rebar coming out of the concrete slab. They then put up metal slab reinforcing either side, tie it all together, give the polystyrene a light coat of water cement mix, then a fairly thick stucco layer. Its a pretty fast construction technique by our standards and they build multiple story buildings with it. But is metal and polystyrene intensive which have doubled in price the last few years. I always figured that aircrete panels without metal frames like ac harry honey (whatever is his name is!) would make a good substitute for the polystyrene sheets. But from what you´re saying, you were unsuccessful in making an aircrete panel that would make it out of the form?? Or were you solely focused on the drywall concept?? Cheers.

[@crawkn]

Aircrete has been in practical use for many years. My first notice of it was its use as the primary wall surfaces of a warehouse-type building in which my workplace was housed in SHAPE, Belgium, a NATO installation, in the '80s. I'm uncertain of the superstructure design, although I assume it was steel beam supported, but the walls themselves were probably at least six meters high, and supported their own weight. They were very large blocks, probably each half a meter in height and approximate thickness, and quite long. They appeared to be bonded using some synthetic caulking-type material, although that could have been only an exterior sealant rather than the primary bonding. My only critique, which would apply for some uses and not others, was that it was easily scratched and dented, but that could be addressed when desirable with some over-coating. On the benefits side, it doesn't transmit impact forces efficiently, so it is resistant to cracking and shattering.

[@SpiderF27]

Those blocks are self-sustaining but you can't build a second floor on top of it. In many countries, in Estern Europe for example, you won't get building permit to build more then one floor without reinforced concrete encasing, columns. Another issue will be, if you want to apply insulated boards on the façade using drilled fixxings. It may crack or crumble. That being said, those blocks are brilliant for indoor partitions, separations walls etc.

[@crawkn]

@@SpiderF27 I saw one video of a couple who wasn't able to get consistent enough results and gave up on the material but if it is pre-cast by an experienced manufacturer I'm sure it's fine. No I wouldn't think you should use it under a more compressive load than maybe a small roof.

[@SpiderF27]

@@crawkn For a single storey building will be no problem. Now there are plenty of manufacturers, big enterprises all over Europe that make those blocks in all sizes. Ytong is one of them. You can build a house in no time with those blocks.

[@allwaysbetter552]

Could you use your lime plaster with the foam? instead of using cement?

[@sonicx059]

I have not tried it, but it has popped up in some of the videos that I watched. Also I do not have experience with building homes, or anything of the sort. Just like learning about it all, and such. Eartships, tiny homes, and just anything that seems... unique.

[@Shaboynga]

It’s definitely an intriguing product. It just seems so tough to get the mix right for what a person needs.

[@jeremiahshine]

Put a stick under the 98 pound portland mix and cut the three exposed sides. Lift the stick and stand the bag up leaving you with half of the portland on each side. Slice the remaining side. Now there's two 49 pound loads.

[@CodyStegeman]

Or just pick up the 100 pound bag?

[@JosephMiller-nd8om]

Thank you for that. - my back

[@suburbanbiology]

Great summary. I'm planning a greenhouse build. Thinking of insulating the north wall with aircrete. I envisioned building a steel frame, then using r-panel or ag panel as an outside and inside skin; similar to how sheetrock and siding would be used in standard construction. The space between the r-panel I thought I would fill with aircrete to act as rigid insulation that rats cannot eat or nest in. Hopefully the expansion of steel and aircrete would be similar during temperature swings. Any thoughts or advice? I thought I saw that you subscribed to my channel around a year ago so I figured I would pick your brain. Thanks!

[@TheMysticBohemian]

Amazing video thank you. Your conditions, with holds and requirements mirror my own.

[@clintyou1]

Just subscribed to your channel. I think my goals are closely aligned to yours. I like persons who are not closed minded to one system but willing to shop around for ideas and combine concepts if necessary for their specific needs and projects. With that said, take a look at Tiny Giant Lifestyle. He is my favorite "explainer" of aircrete. I love his channel because he goes beyond simply sharing his passions and experiments with others but, against the backdrop of a very analytical mind and years of building experience, he walks his viewers through very logical and well presented reasons for his building decisions as they pertain to aircrete. In my opinion, he presents the most logical arguments as to why aircrete is perhaps the most practical alternative building option for our modern society. (p.s. I have zero affiliation with him - in fact, I don't even know the name of the gentleman, only his channel)

[@radicalgastronomy]

Cool! I’ll check him out.

[@jimmymcgee4101]

Just discovered aircrete, like the light weight, good to see pure honesty, we went to u-tube university and are in the process of building a cabin at the age of 70 and 66. Are we crazy, yes.

[@John-vz5un]

No use Styrofoam pellets

[@TimberTrainer]

Thank you for sharing your thoughts. Have you tried styroaircrete? It's basically shredded styrofoam mixed into aircrete. It seems to overcome a lot of problems typically associated with aircrete.

[@50shanks]

I love the idea of styrocrete and have made my own, but unfortunately it has been banned due to 2 hour fire resistance requirement, and toxic gases emitted in a fire. Interested to know if anyone has overcome this issue.

[@ShivaTD420]

Use perlite instead

[@geoffreydebrito7934]

@@ShivaTD420 Perlite does appear to have the potential for a successful natural alternative to petroleum based Styrofoam beads.

[@ShivaTD420]

@@geoffreydebrito7934 just don't mix it too hard when the perlite is in, over mixing will crush it into a powder loosing the insulation benefits. It will also make the concrete a bit more water permeable than the styrofoam mixes. So make sure you get decent vapor barriers. The perlite mixes are not too far behind the Styrofoam in weight, but they are usually much stronger. For perimeter walls or multi nozzle concrete printers I usually lay down three layers. A conventional structural mix for the outside envelope, a perlite insulating mix for the core and a fine particle white sand mix with high latex for the interior layer. This gives the walls a nice shiny white finish that looks like it's painted. This white layer is impermeable, so it can act as a vapor barrier by itself.

[@JosephMiller-nd8om]

One attraction of using Styrofoam is that it's an environmental disaster, and encapsulating it with mortar seems like a good solution. There's plenty of it that people want to freely be rid of; the mix results are consistent. I've made a grow box with it. Turned out very nice. I'm thinking that timbers may be a viable option. A 6"x6"x 8'or 12' stacked like a log cabin with spacers to create mortar joints, filled with touch n foam (painted)

[@marstedt]

Check your audio settings, I'm getting a crackling sound. Could be clipping or maybe a bad connection?

[@MaskMasterEsquire]

Very well done Sir, great job at accurately explaining AC pros and cons. It's early days and smart people are busily playing with AC and coming up with innovations. I'm sure you will be one of those.

[@radicalgastronomy]

It’s so close to amazing. I bet we see an industrially produced wall system in the near future. A DIY alternative would be epic, though.

[@MaskMasterEsquire]

@@radicalgastronomy I'm certain the 'powers' will do their best to suppress aircrete innovation. It's just to easy for the average Joe to replicate. Imagine all the insulation products etc that might be superseded if aircrete became mainstream. Here in Latin America that's not an issue so we might see some exciting developments from here. I agree with you though, a mass produced, cost effective aircrete system is achievable. I've got a few things in mind. I'll let you know how I get on. Best of luck with your project...I've subscribed👍

[@radicalgastronomy]

@@MaskMasterEsquire right on. I look forward to hearing of your progress!

[@ursulagallucci5749]

I'm on a similar hunt for the "best" infill material for timberframe walls. Considerations for an ideal infill/wall material: 1. Insulative and thermal mass value 2. Strength and durability 3. Anti-Pest 4. Ease of installation (a one step, al in one process would be ideal) 5. Environmentally and human healthy- Low embodied energy, natural renewable material, non toxic. 6. Aesthetic value 7. Low cost. So far, old ways and new ways still haven't produced a "best" way. Thanks for having boots on the ground with your experiments.

[@radicalgastronomy]

This is the quest. I’m really liking the dustcrete. I plan to test a lime/clay binder, in leu of the portland/lime mix I’ve been using. I think it will be the closest to meeting these specs.

[@gingebrien2408]

Thanks for the input. It is good to hear about problems. We generally hear only the positive. It is in my future to build an AIRCRETE dome. Subscribed. 😁

[@Boscovius]

I've played with creating my own foam generator but have yet to actually make the foamcrete for the project I'm working on. I love your idea for a foamcrete composite sandwich material. I imagine applying a water based starch glue like wall paper paste to the cured foamcrete slab while still in the form. Then cover it in a paper product like newsprint. No plastic, you want it breathable. When dry, flip the planel and apply the glue and paper to the other side. Paper should be overlapped to avoid seams.

[@WhatDadIsUpTo]

I have long been an aircrete fan. I built my own foamer, like you, etc. I think most of my aircrete-building future will center about two words: Tilt Up Nuf sed

[@radicalgastronomy]

Yup

[@ParadoxPerspective]

Greetings! Great, sober analysis of aircrete as a building material! There are two things that I would like to see done with aircrete that I think would compliment the material very well. 1) Continuous flow with in-line agitation for large pours. This should be feasible with a hopper for the portland cement, a screw pump/agitator to move/mix it, and the foam inlet behind the screw to ensure you don't make a clogged cylinder in your screw pump. 2) tilt-up single form cast walls with cast-in fastening joints, mesh reinforcements, etc. Aircrete should lend itself very well to the tilt-up method, as a substantial logistical burden for tilt-up is the weight and then insulation of large pours of reinforced concrete; aircrete minimizes the weight so you may get away with smaller cranes or no crane at all to erect the casts, and your insulation is integral to the material itself, and the logistics of laying your mesh saves a lot of labor as the cast-in aircrete will give you the best chance of adhesion. Also the problem with adhesion and aircrete is the foaming agent acting as a separator as well. Most surfactants have long polymer lipophilic tails which are good at forming mono-layers when they're not bunched up in micelles. I'll have to think up some ways to modify the foaming mixes chemically to avoid this. Probably rheology modifiers like CMC or maybe just table salt can promote micelle formation and swelling, which should make for good adhesion to synthetic fabrics. If anyone knows why Drexel foam is commonly used instead of bulk Sodium Lauryl Sulfate for aircrete please let me know.

[@fabonline9389]

The foaming agent is one of the keys to making a successful product. The longer the bubbles remain intact during the curing process the higher the quality with less shrinkage. SLS does not last long enough to make good products. Drexel is better. It is an agricultural foam used on spray rigs to mark the edge of where you spray. It has to remain intact so when the tractor comes around the operator can follow it for the next pass. I have contacted many producers and some claim up to 3 meters of pours at once. Even better is Alpha Olefin Sulfonate also a product used in common products. The bubbles are extremely tiny and resilient. I also like the mixtures containing Gypsum which cure in 15 minutes as apposed to hours for straight Portland.

[@corba197]

Curious... I'm seeing Gypsum as a retardant of Portland Cement's otherwise very rapid set time. Did you perhaps mean a different additive?

[@mori8424]

Commercial airkrete (spelled with a k) does have an r value of 5 or more and is used as an insulation but it isn’t made with Portland cement so it doesn’t doesn’t have much strength. DIY aircrete spelled with a c is a lightweight concrete with some structural strength but the r value is only 2 per inch thick not 5 (with the density most commonly used on KZbin- 94 lbs cement, 6 gallons water and 43 gallons of foam) denser mixes will have more strength but less than 2 r value. Aircrete with little pieces of EPS foam added to the mix will have close to a 3 r value but strength is very compromised.

[@meredithheath5272]

Thanks for your information!

[@lenturtle7954]

Have you looked into using poly fibre in the aircrete like shotcrete . No rebar or mesh required increases strength and resistance to cracking . Amazing strength increase in concrete

[@radicalgastronomy]

I haven't tried it, but it sounds viable.

[@rushrumble1699]

Your voice is very nice. I've watched other videos where the person's voice made me just change channels altogether. 😅 Thank you for the information!

[@markpennella]

Great video! I have experimented with Aircrete insulation blocks. They get more ridge with time...months.

[@patriotjoe3110]

I have been interested in aircrete for a while and plan to build a shed with it this year. Aircrete has been around for decades and is widely used in Asia. It is referred to as cellular concrete, or air entrained concrete. One method of manufacture involves curing it in an autoclave. One method I have seen is to make panels and connect them with spikes. When the wall is up cover both sides with chicken wire & stucco for strength.

[@radicalgastronomy]

I believe there is an autoclaved block available, as well.

[@MaryAnnNytowl]

@8:09 being a penny-pinching miser myself, I support your position. 😊😂 I'm looking for cheap material for a few projects I need to get done with a coin-screaming budget, and i think aircrete would be perfect for one of them. On a side (but very important) note, please, please take time to tell your loved ones you love them EVERY chance you get. Tomorrow is not a given; you're never promised the next sunrise. ~ ~ ~ ~ "And don't let it break your heart. I know it feels hopeless sometimes. But they're never really gone as long as there's a memory in your mind." _Hold On To Memories_ Dave Draiman, Disturbed

[@lenturtle7954]

Ive experimented with a 50% shredded recycled styrofoam mixed into concrete with reduced heavy aggs also used fibreglass fibre for rebar replacement and had great success light - recycles guarbage stro foam strong fire resistant easy to put fasteners into or stucco or parge . 🎉 You can haul larger loads in a concrete truck as half the concrete is very light (foam and cement, water ) 🎉

[@radicalgastronomy]

Cool!

[@brianburnssailorslife5383]

Good commentary on the matter. Aircrete has my attention and I've heard from other sources that it is a file product with a lot of possibility.

[@rongray4118]

I fully agree with your final statement in regard to the use of portland in ANY project and the LONGEVITY of the project usefulness. If the statement were not absolutely true - we would not be witnessing Roman architecture still standing to this day. The same can be said of Meso-American structures that stand COMPLETE in this day and age as well!

[@radicalgastronomy]

Here here

[@AlwaysCensored-xp1be]

Romans had access to a particular pumice that helped them make lightweight domes. Had many types of concrete including underwater setting types.

[@gregorymhouston]

I've made thousands of aircrew bricks for equipment sheds. We live in an arid desert regen, so extremely hot days and cold at night. Curing aircrete in extreme heat is a huge challenge. However, it works well, is cost effective, and has awesome insulation properties.

[@ХозяинПолянки]

In American scientific literature, engineers complained that the builders of the 50s and 60s were crazy and lived in the 19th century or did not work well. And now Americans remember “how good it was in the 60s.” Naturally, wild lameness. There is a super construction crisis in the country and the banking and construction lobby. They cannot make cubes from free concrete (the price is only for cement and air - waste). (1 plant per country) So that lonely homeless people build 150 m2 houses in 3 months. Soviet panel houses are divided in 1-3 days into a House (Foundation month or from ready-made elements = week.) And the first floor itself in 3 days. 7 days = 2 floors. The city mafia seems to steal 20,000 per homeless person per month. And this is the price of the apartment :) 5 floors without elevator. 60 apartments. 200 people with housing.

[@clarksouthoff3840]

Hi there nice video. In Canada. they have been making cementitous foam for the last 20 years. A continuous process by injecting air into a slurry containing blowing agent, water reducers. The bubble size is important as well as its consistent distribution in the mix. a cement mix density of 0.375 has an R value of 1. Tested and verified. Less dense mixes have been use a insulation on Heavy oil tanks @ 100 degrees C. The lighter mixes used for insulation under basement slabs. It is Canada, -40 C is possible. Take care I hope this puts bit of information in the mix. Cheers Clark Alberta Canada

[@markheffernan7016]

Have you looked at MgO cement to adhere to the row cover material? It sets up fast and will stick to lots of things that Portland cement will not bond to.

[@markheffernan7016]

MgO cement is also not conductive of heat, electric, or water. It is not cheap....but...

[@bobosun9741]

Thanks for sharing!

[@snowballsvlogs621]

Just a thought have you thought of using dust Crete with polystyrene balls in it, say 25% to combine both materials without the bother of foam.

[@Scott-su1wj]

Great video. Very informative. Thanks

[@jram7047]

Very good video. I live out on a small homestead. I built a metal shop about 6000 square foot and I also have a home here already. I'm interested in building some out buildings with this method. I've got a few questions if you've got time and are comfortable discussing them. I don't know why but I had the impression that people also use brown up Styrofoam waste to create air pockets. I also am curious about the addition of fiber into the Portland mix . When the engineered plans came for my metal building I was kind of disappointed with how lax they where with concrete thickness and strength requirements. I went to a far higher strength concrete but I also had them add fiber to it for more strength. The fiber just came out of a bag and didn't add much cost at all. It was mixed in the trucks before they poured the concrete. My location has one thing, very dry and hard ground. My current idea is to use my small tractor with backhoe to make forms in the dirt itself. To tamp it down with sand and to then make panels and let them cure for a few weeks before anything happens. I would like them to be structurally sound and insulating. Inside I plan on sewing plastic materials and making a dome roof inside a rectangular building. The walls would be these pre formed pieces and the roof would be a first pressurized dome, using chicken wire, rebar and whatever else may add structure I would spray the outside first with thin layers, next would be a layer inside to lock the shape in. From there I would use bonding agent or whatever is necessary to make a roof strong enough for the high winds and such in my area. I would like to be as environmentally considerate with materials as possible but not to the point of loosing strength, adding excessive cost or time to the build. My hope is for 8 foot walls, with a 20x30 outside footprint. For the floors I've seen a few dirtcrete jobs that I would like to do with a lot of compression and then a good coating over the top. The eventual goal for me is to have this as an efficiency. I have years of hvac experience professionally and I've developed a small geothermal / underground storage tank cooling system from small pumps lines and a converted inverter style window 12000 btu window ac, that I currently use in my bedroom in my home. 1 ton is typically good for 500 square feet in a typical home in my area so I'm sure with highly insulated walls and roof the 600 square feet plus added air space of the dome will be well within reasonable use.

[@ottodidakt3069]

Have you thought of lime as a basis instead of cement ? what would be the limitations in your opinion ?

[@grim6980]

I am going to be looking for land to homestead in about 4 months. Videos like yours have my imagination going with possibilities.

[@radicalgastronomy]

That’s super exciting! Good luck with your search.

[@blackwolfspace-cowboy121]

Have you considered using a form of reinforced rapid cure mortar that the foam/aircrete then fills in around to add compressive strength while still remaining relatively light?

[@radicalgastronomy]

I have not. Interesting idea.

[@kevinhornbuckle]

I am working on such a demonstration project.

[@radicalgastronomy]

@@kevinhornbuckle nice!

[@corba197]

​@kevinhornbuckle: Do you have any drawings, photos or videos detailing your project?

[@OblioArrowgood]

I'm wondering how this would hold up in an underground application? What else would one do in order to do this properly?

[@ljg5511]

From what I understand the R6 may in fact be wrong as it was achieved by using non ASTM testing techniques that have not been verified. R 3.5 - 3.7 seem more likely. 3.5 is still not too shabby. I also wonder if skinning the panels with hempcrete or straw reinforced concrete would do the trick of making a sip that can be moved without cracking

[@radicalgastronomy]

You are correct. R 6 is not accurate. I doubt hempcrete would not crack, but straw concrete could work.

[@SixPackDan]

I would love to see you find a successful way of making an aircrete wall. The R value per inch is amazing. Can you imagine a 6 inch thick wall and or floor!

[@radicalgastronomy]

It still intrigues me, but other commenters have pointed out that that r6/inch number is inaccurate.

[@wildernesshermit]

Excellent presentation. Many thanks.

[@radicalgastronomy]

You bet.

[@bohannon9339]

Awesome video but why didn't you do an epoxy layer over the top to give it a hard durable surface?

[@bryansovich2]

Great research, and well done video's!

[@bonedust68]

I was thinking why not dry lay cinder blocks.. while keeping them plumb with mortar as needed, then surface bond instead of joint bonding them.. And with rebar pre installed, you could fill the walls with air-crete, 100%.. thereby having the best of both worlds, viable load bear ability and insulative qualities combined together?

[@underourrock]

Thank you for the video. Some really good trade off analysis there and consideration given to alternatives. Ignoring for a moment the material source and looking at it more from a long term goal perspective: truck bed liner both as a reinforcement itself and as a bonding agent with a stiff backer in a manner similar to drywall is intriguing. I really like the SIF concept for if a panel is sturdy enough to survive handling, shipping, and more, then it is likely a lot less fragile once installed as well. Paper is pretty high density... When paper is rolled up tightly, it is stiff. When paper is pulled tight and bonded to the gypsum, the taut paper is a key part of its overall sturdiness. That coupled with the fact that trying to bend drywall: one side of the paper is under tension regardless of which direction you're bending, the key here is having that tension on both sides. A high strength material bonded to the aircrete with a bonding agent itself that exhibits high strength properties could be key. Have you seen how truck bed liner has been used to reinforce cinderblock walls or allows something else survive catastrophic impact? Where it might fall down is cost per square foot? Not sure. That seems like something that is solved with economies of scale and labor savings. Rolling out or spraying a bed liner is pretty quick. If the physics and bonding hold up, then other substitutions may be worth experimenting.

[@radicalgastronomy]

That’s an interesting thought. 🤔

[@ericensley2427]

I appreciate the fact you pointed out that concrete is very energy intensive. And the fact we have to pick the lesser of evils. We will never go back to "neutral" lives... I think we all like AC, cheap items, and cheap energy too much. Building items will probably never be "sustainable" but we do need to pick the MOST LONG TERM EFFICIENT designs. Great video!

[@radicalgastronomy]

Thanks!

[@Athoughtfulcitizen]

Very useful information. Thank you.

[@radicalgastronomy]

My pleasure.

[@B30pt87]

If you put a piece of plywood over the poured aircrete floor, wouldn't it distribute the weight evenly enough to prevent the aircrete from compressing, at least in the size you showed?

[@radicalgastronomy]

It would, but that would not be a suitable next course. I would worry about mold between the wood and the aircrete, and there is no good way to anchor plywood to aircrete. As my plan was to tile, I could have laid cement backer board onto the wet aircrete, perhaps. In the end, the deck mud was the best, lowest cost solution for me.

[@B30pt87]

@@radicalgastronomy Thank you for that explanation. I had thought of doing that, with a moisture barrier between the aircrete and plywood, but I had hesitations too. In the end I just poured a layer of self-leveling concrete over the aircrete. I think I'll still get the insulation from the ground, from the aircrete. (It was a shed, not a house.)

[@radicalgastronomy]

@@B30pt87 Self-leveling cement and diamond lathe make a superior underlayment to backer board, for tile setting, if one can afford it. In my application, the deck mud was an acceptable cost, and allowed me to slope the shower floor for a curb-less shower. You made the right move.

[@BlackjackArmyCaptain]

Fantastic advice! Thank you so much for sharing your knowledge.

[@wendydevereux4375]

Dustcrete using mining waste was used post war in the UK. Results are Mundic blocks which disintegrate to dust if they get wet.

[@jonathanseagraves8140]

Feel free to ignore this, I don't know if you have had other people point this out or not. This is in regards to the foam generator, specifically the ad hoc eductor (were you in the Navy?) . This may be way off, since I can't see a cross section of the T joint, but it appears that the constraint in the flow of air is BEFORE the foaming agent. If you google "venturi" there should be a image that appears on the right hand side of the page. Apparently, the reduction of pressure happens along the length of the constraint (the drop in pressure is a direct result of the increase in velocity of the fluid). So if you want that thing to suck more (in a good way) you have to 1. Make the constrained section longer (not just an orifice/aperture, possibly the whole T joint long) and 2. make sure the soap input falls within that constrained section. Anyway, you got a great beard, wear it with pride.

[@radicalgastronomy]

Ha! Yeah, the science of that prototype was weak. Great tips. I did not join the Navy, but have a brother, sister, and son who did.

[@jonathanseagraves8140]

For some reason this aircrete thing has been hard to stop thinking about. Specifically generating extremely high density foams. I have been comparing every result I have seen with Barbasol shaving creme as the go-to default. I think shaving cremes use isobutane or something as the propellent/foamer. The reason I'm pestering you again is I was wondering if you have ever seen anyone take a big air flask and fill it full of the water/surfactant mixture and carbonate it like a giant soda can. The interesting part, is not that it may generate a good foam, but that the foam is composed of CO2, which portland cement needs to cure. It would be interesting to see if the properties of a test block change in any way if this was done. @@radicalgastronomy

[@radicalgastronomy]

@@jonathanseagraves8140 that would be a great experiment!

[@georgeegerog4175]

wonder if you can make and aircrete with geopolymer concrete

[@gordonauld5945]

I have not used or tryd ether yet although your dustcreet looks very good and I will be testing it and probably building with it in the nere futcher.

[@trakeespree]

I found out by accident that 0.125mm metal window screen mesh sticks to aircrete really well. Maybe you could give that a try.

[@spamman007]

That might also work as a Faraday cage to outside EMF. One possible problem would be cell phone reception inside.

[@Mike-hr6jz]

You should consider buying 50 pound bags of milled fiber it comes in different lengths. It is fiberglass in almost a powder form, but it can come as long as a quarter of an inch down to a 60/4th of an inch when you mix this with your air Crete it acts like microscopic rebar. It adds an immense amount of strength. You just have to get the right ratio. And then, of course, I would go back to the hardware cloth galvanized for more reinforcement. There are also other Paula burners that can be added for more Elastomeric benefits, making this thinner, stronger and lighter

[@ryanjamesloyd6733]

I have not yet attempted aircrete, but it is something I am pondering on. I have wondered if the addition of graphine (which should be getting cheaper as a concrete additive if it's not already) would make up some strength. I've not seen anybody attempt that with aircrete yet. I have also wondered, if there was a way to foam "water glass" or a water resistant resin so the bubbles would be hollow, but would cure like a hollow glass bead. No idea if such a thing is possible (I mean, if you heat the water glass, it bubbles up and gets hard- like honey-do carpenter's aircrete rocket stove. But firing a whole panel seems less than optimal. I know that if you got a thick water glass solution, you could probably aerrate the hell out of it and make it foam up, to an extent, I just don't know if it would mix with the cement and reinforce the bubble voids or not.

[@radicalgastronomy]

I’m sure there are many ways a low cost, no toxic panel could be achieved. My interest is in low tech DIY solutions, but I encourage manufactured materials that are superior in cost, performance, and ecological considerations. The water glass thing is fascinating, for sure!

[@TanVer-z3e]

Which materials included in this foam.

[@rocktech7144]

I have built structural panels 2 inches thick with no reinforcing materials that are still in use outdoors as table tops with no coating either 4 years old. Used gypsum and latex additives. It can be done.

[@radicalgastronomy]

Groovy. In what form was the gypsum?

[@matthewmccartney3926]

Do you think dust create would be strong enough to make 12in raised beds?

[@beartankoperator7950]

I was about to correct the r-value info but the legit Dome Gaia already corrected thats awesome

[@radicalgastronomy]

The hive mind is on the case. 😁👍

[@beartankoperator7950]

@@radicalgastronomy Haha

[@brianclark8821]

I am curious how you get R6 per inch? Of course, it depends on your density in the mix. Must stable mixes seem to come up with roughly R2 per inch. I've played around a little with it. I look at it as filler/ insulation, not structural. I think it can be utilized however.

[@ashleewhitbrook8992]

could you use the aircrete method but use like a plaster of paris instead of cement to build the boards you were talking about

[@radicalgastronomy]

Worth playing with.

[@MadRat70]

Cement bonds to expanded bead foam, so there is that option. Maybe your dustcrete in a honeydobagger form would be a good strategy?

[@radicalgastronomy]

Perhaps

[@bradholland6074]

Why put the feed sack material on the outside?

[@BrianSEPT11]

I am curious about aircrete but not confident in the structural integrity of aircrete. I believe that the integrity would be improve with hemp fibre's. Still, what will be the long term durability of Aircrete? Experimental right now, but hope it can be a long life system with great structural integrity at a low cost. 🤔

[@penguinistas]

Interesting discussion, thank you.

[@radicalgastronomy]

You bet. Thanks for watching.

[@project-unifiedfreepeoples]

That's amazing, just curious if the addition of carbon black to the mixture, would make a significant difference to the structurial integrity. If not, the use of regular concerte and addition of carbon black, makes block or foundations that are super capacitors that would hold enough energy that could power a nice, one story , 2 bedroom 1.5 bathroom house. If you use copper rods instead of steel rebar, you will maximize the total output of each block.

[@radicalgastronomy]

Interesting 🤔

[@project-unifiedfreepeoples]

@radicalgastronomy if you get a chance, check out MIT website, they go into a bit further detail. I just use aluminum drinking vessels and zinc rods as cathode and anode with concrete and Epsom salt mix for crystal batteries that last forever. Just add water when the medium oor. Concrete dries up.

[@project-unifiedfreepeoples]

If you find success with the carbon black admixture, you can add self sustaining energy to your pitch. I truly hope you make it big. This building material is not only the future here, but when we go to colonize the moon or Mars, with a self sustainable foundation or building itself, will endure your prosperity. Blessings brother.

[@EIndependent_Life]

@@radicalgastronomy Regarding the vermiculite, pumice is 10X cheaper and is ligh weight.

[@SethLunchquest]

I just watched your dustcrete video, then this one. I was wondering, how rigid is the dustcrete compared to aircrete? I have been planning to use aircrete poured in a slip-form of an arch structure. I know aircrete can support itself in an arch, but dustcrete looks so much easier to work with. Do you think it could support itself overhead?

[@radicalgastronomy]

I think it would, provided the form was left for 48 hours of longer.

[@robertscotton5882]

Has anyone considered using the fibreglass loose fibres as reinforcement? I believe you can substitute the steel required in walls and floors?

[@radicalgastronomy]

We have been kicking that around.