Alfa Romeo Giulia QV vs BMW M3 Competition vs Mercedes-AMG C63 S comparison review | MOTOR

[@charlesclement383]

No matter what you say,I'll pick the Alfa. Thanks though.

[@curtisnash4476]

pro trick : watch series on flixzone. Been using it for watching a lot of movies these days.

[@johncreedon7847]

3 time m3 owner here. Just bought a Guilia qv, very different to the na m cars. But it’s a joy..hugely fast , very comfortable but just razor sharp at the same time. My first Italian car, and loving it so far.

[@DullaTakesYouToSchool]

how quick is it?

[@johncreedon7847]

@@DullaTakesYouToSchool 190 mph quick and gets there fast

[@jamesjannell8706]

I choose the passion and went with Guilia Q. A pure joy to drive even as a daily driver.

[@Nick-GR]

Wise choice.

[@CallMeAK]

Did you actually purchase the car? If yes how long have you had it and did you face any issues with it?

[@jamesjannell8706]

@CallMeAK yes I've had mine for about 4 years now. Still very happy. No real issues at 33,000 miles. Other than a dash light once or twice. Just had to be reset. Cheers good luck.

[@CallMeAK]

@jamesjannell8706 Alright thanks man, good to hear that the Alfa is reliable 👍

[@chrisc2184]

Why does everyone think the Alfa has to be the best, the Alfa has to be competitive which it is, it's up there with the best. Then when you consider a 2.9 v6 against a 4.0 v8 the Alfa is a much better engineering achievement. Long live Alfa Romeo!

[@redarmy1778]

is it reliable

[@stevebright8583]

Yes. I own one. I can vouch for its reliability.

[@pgivno4241]

definedly not worst reliability that bmw or rust problems having mercedes@@redarmy1778

[@pgivno4241]

exactly.

[@c0zzar0ner0]

Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio Verde is definitely the best sport sedan in the world. World record on the Nurburgring. This is the choice of power and passion. Both of them. Alfa Romeo sports that classy "civilized" appeal that german cars won't ever have... simply this...

[@harryaustin9223]

Hahaha everyone saying the driver is crap and that’s why the Alfa lost.. he said the Alfa is the easiest to drive and the m3 is the hardest.. and m3 still wins by a second

[@lorenzobarili8623]

Harry Austin (Nurburgring)

[@sasalolic999]

@@lorenzobarili8623 lets use nurburgring times where manufacturers get an hour to set the time and neither the drivers nor the conditions are the same - every deluded alfa fanboy that wants to twist facts to suit them

[@95regShamil]

Lorenzo Barili bmw also faster in Nurburgring

[@arsiongowrang2447]

Bmw kicked the other two's ass

[@avishkarsingh744]

That's the power of ///M

[@andrewyts82z]

I have an M3 and will work on my driving skills to extract the max out of it.

[@pedrosousa8512]

I have 3 bmw, and even a fan, my powerful e60 v10 m5 is my babe and i drive the other day this alfa, sorry bimmers but i have to admit and say this, Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio 2.9 V6 is definitely the best sport sedan in the worls in this moment!!! Best look, best driving, best steering and the motor is a best!!

[@GKAMOULAK1]

Ok but M5 is another class and philosophy from other two M3 and GIOULIA

[@clutched77]

Bro wtf hahaaha I'm dying you are just too much bro haha, you are so dumb as well bro you're killing mehahah

[@MrF-ly2bb]

Shut the f****** you do not own no BMW M5 with a V10 and saying that the alpha is better you're full of s***

[@lorsamadey2435]

All u own is a renault twingo if u day gulia is better then m5 e60 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️ what a noob!

[@georgiosioakeimidis8465]

BULLSCHIT BULLSCHIT you are m5 e60 driver, mayby Fiat FUCKED MORON

[@diegodiegito7248]

Alfa Romeo Giulia QV the best !!!!!!

[@swarupkj8420]

Yup, the M3 CS is actually the best of all worlds

[@scook2003]

It’s titled “track battle” and BMW is 1 second faster. At the end “and who is the winner, not the BMW”. Lol maybe you didn’t like the result which was the only objective thing in this video!? 1 second - Wow that’s a massive gap on a track. BMW is sports the other are GT.

[@syd_jzx100]

scook2003 the Guilia is a Grand Tourer? What shrooms you on?

[@aamvoor]

The guilia trashes the beamer on te nurnburgring

[@edrod4266]

Nurburgring record for a Faster sedan car,! Must Faster than a bmw m4

[@theopot5798]

the Giulia is not a GT...that M3 is faster BUT it is tuned with wider wheel and stiffer supension ''competition package'' in which you pay more to the M division , beacuse the standart M3 is not M3 enough ?

[@solaimanelaissaoui4842]

Theo Pot the M3 Comp is like the C63 S. The standard version (the normal C63) has 476 hp, but the S version has 510.

[@bercavlad8560]

BMW is the clear winner. Aren't we talking about a Track Battle?Who cares about that bla - bla - bla? It's the lightest, it has the best chassis and it's still not the ultimate card played by BMW. M3 CS is around the corner!

[@edrod4266]

Clear winner: alfa

[@fernandofragoso4118]

The time and winner will depend on track configuration. Nurburgring Nordschleife is a good track for that purpose because its long and combines better different types of road surfaces and layouts which represent better real world performance. Other than that M3 would be faster on tracks with shorter straights because it could brake pretty good and has a lot of grip and it wont lose on the straight because they're short, Giulia would be faster on combined roads, medium straights and high speed corners, and AMG will only be faster on tracks with long straights.

[@steve-k.91]

I'm big fan of m power,but that alfa is the winner(But Alfa is not available in my country😐

[@mickyquiroga3517]

En España, en la misma prueba hicieron mejor tiempo con el alfa. En Inglaterra igual. Están los videos en KZbin

[@dexter2312986]

Alfa Romeo 😁❤️❤️❤️

[@giannislymperopoylos5574]

ITS A GREAT TEST AND A GREAT CHANNEL THAT I DID NOT KNOW OF..!!!YOU DESERVE MUCH MUCH MORE VIEWS!!

[@danielrico3006]

7'32"

[@davissilvestrs1996]

Eat shit M3 is faster

[@dimitarchardakliev5351]

not where it counts ;)

[@theopot5798]

@@davissilvestrs1996 nope...the fastest M is the M4 the GTS version with no rear seats , and super light cinfiguration and engine tweaks

[@davissilvestrs1996]

@@theopot5798 Nope, M3 Competition, M3 CS, M4 Competition, M4 CS, M2 Competition, M5, M8 Competition is faster.

[@avishkarsingh744]

The M3 is just legendary 🙌. Never disappoints.

[@tcathunder]

Alfa blows both away...

[@Ruido-rosa]

Alfa Top

[@Emdcrp]

Alfa giulia QV number 1

[@edrod4266]

What s The dúvida? Giulia of course is The best of this 3. By far? Your profissional driver dont make it at their limite.! If he does, it beat The other 2 all day.

[@Gazza-zg2tr]

Alfa has the record at the Nurenburg.I bought the Alfa its the nuts.

[@lorsamadey2435]

Even f80 is the oldest of them 3 it still a WHOLE SECOND faster! I would go for the m3 any day! Best handling car in the segment!

[@joe3nips]

drove the Alfa and the BMW, got to agree the Alpha was best to drive but the gear box on the M3, better interior quality, rear folding seats (these are still meant to be practical cars at the end of the day) and price meant i got the M3.

[@palefaced1]

I did the exact opposite. I drove them both and preferred the Alfa. It was the one I bought. There's something special about it. Can't explain it. It just makes me happy, and I thought the bmw was a bit too serious. It was a nice car, and I liked it, but I loved the Alfa.

[@RagingBad]

joe giles it's called ALFA

[@GKAMOULAK1]

yes but BMW is the winner

[@begaalbi7788]

italian spaghettis being jealous about german cars lol, shit alfa , i would even choose a VW instead of alfa

[@alexeifree]

HaZeM ZooMa haha you own a bicycle idiot kid

[@Katievandaalenwetters]

the answer is quite simple. Italian cars are special. therefore Alfa. And would everyone quit spelling "alfa" like "alpha" it's triggering me. :D

[@jackblack5124]

Alfa wins. Allways

[@zaq9339]

It's worth pointing out that the M3 was the pre 2017 facelift model which was available at the time this year came out. It's been said a lot has changed in terms of overall manageability of the car.

[@progames70]

I wonder where everyone complaining Alfas are unreliable get their information, because all Alfas since the GT/159 era have been fine, this has been proven in the Europe reliability score where Alfa Romeo scored the best out of any European brand in terms of reliability. Besides it been proven on numerous reviews that the STOCK giulia QV is faster than the M3 competition pack and is the better car to drive both daily and on the track. I'd take the Alfa over the bland Germans any day, gorgeous car.

[@stevebright8583]

I own one. I can vouch for its reliability. It never steps out of line.

[@massimo4973]

The Alfa is the king !! No Questions

[@NNooshaAlfa]

The Alfa for me all day long.

[@wahidjavid51]

He is right the c63s is a beast and the winner in this segment. I just bought one and its the best money ive ever spent.

[@pikende]

Check the nurburgring results. Alfa is the fastest of them.

[@tsnaha]

I disagree I have a c63 and it's lived in the garage for 4 months because I bought the alfa romeo quadrifoglio

[@charlesclement383]

I'll take the Alfa Romeo.No questions asked.

[@Michael_00001]

I looked at and considered the Guilia Quadrafolio at one time but something will eventually break. The Merc is just plain ugly and a victim of mediocrity. I have a 2017 F80 M3 Competition pack and I'll take the build quality, performance and looks of it all day every day over the other two.

[@hereandthere4763]

Except Mercedes build quality is much better than BMW.

[@brunostudley2191]

Michael Kirst All of BMW M cars are renowned for serious engine problems and everyone’s got a C63 or an M3, I’ll take the Alfa for Italian style and exclusivity.

[@bmorlok1]

Bruno Studley not the S55

[@Schaufelor]

Look at the current BMWs. Who is plain ugly now? xD

[@Michael_00001]

@@Schaufelor Oh they are god awful hideous now!!! Haha good thing I'm in a GT350 today ;)

[@MorenoArtStudio]

I chose the passion and design as well and went for the Giulia

[@zb0430]

It’s really interesting how personal preference plays such a huge role in these reviews. It’s commonly accepted that the steering feel of the Alfa is superior to both of these competitors, yet it’s cited as an issue in this review. Likewise, the BMW is often knocked as having disconnected steering feel and too stiff a ride, yet pretty handily beats both other cars in most lap time shootouts like these. And while the sound of the AMG V8 is really head and shoulders above these twin turbo 6’s, its added weight and more difficult power application hinders it a bit. Each has their own niche, for sure.

[@johncreedon7847]

The qv is like driving a supercar. The amg is like driving a sedan with the power of a supercar.

[@APaulO96]

Wait that Alfa doesn’t have the carbon ceramic option equipped...

[@jasonibrahim4701]

M3 performance is not too hard to access. Just need to understand the car. Best driving machine out of the 3

[@arpadattilatilla6358]

I love Mercedes and i love Alfa, and tbh no other car ever gave me the same feeling like when i had my Alfa 147 GTA..They feel special and the leather interior was amazing. And I have waited for along time for another special Alfa.. Definitely having the Quadrifoglio now and having a proper LSD fitted.. Both my 147GTA's had Q2 diffs fitted, transformed the car.

[@jorgeg162]

Maybe a Giulia with a sport competition pack would be a better deal...

[@mansees]

Giulia can be an everyday car. M3 is not too comfortable. Plus to derive M3 performance you better be a race car caliber driver. Otherwise you are not seeing those speeds.

[@24HourRealtySanDiego]

Couldn’t agree more about the M3. On the streets especially, I have to focus on my driving or it could all end badly in a split second.

[@jasonibrahim4701]

That’s what makes it fun! I drove all 3 but bought the M3. Amazing driving experience

[@catstory1986]

I really want the c63s. But i might get m3. Its cheaper.....in used market.

[@tigerpjm]

I've got a C63S and a Giulia. Much prefer the Giulia. As you can probably tell by my name and avatar. That's how much I love it.

[@Antony-18]

The Alfa all day no questions ask....and I’m sure you held the Giulia back to benefit the M3 it’s written all over your face , your a M3 fanboy.

[@redarmy1778]

he choose the c63 so how is he a m3 fan boy lol

[@DiscoveryLegend]

Ferrari vs the others really…❤ - after watching the Ferrari Movie you can see the camaraderie each Italian manufacturer has for one another. Passion is why we drive.

[@Aina-wj5uv]

Vous aurez du faire la vidéo avec une E63s Amg 😕

[@jw6188]

Even on its off days, BMW still kicks anyone's ass

[@MrF-ly2bb]

RIGHT !!! but lost hmmmm I smell a bias and this post was ran by a Giulia fanboyz !

[@ravenblackops]

That's why the needed to comeback with a special Competition Pack ? :)))

[@PrettyBird23]

Their all great. Personally I'd like a car with the v8 engine from the merc. The dct transmission from the bmw. And the exoticness of the alpha.

[@tokberkel]

To help you all in your discussion... watch Chris Harris drive the Alfa, at the end he asks him self, is the Alfa as good as an M3... NO is the simple and straight answer. So, there it is, the Alfa is not as good an an M3! The BMW is the more focused, connected car that demands the driver to be on his toes. That is what makes it so good and fun. I own a M4 and had a day of driving all audi S and RS cars (not the R8). And fuck how boring that was comparing to the hyper responsive and aggressive M4. You can say what you want about the Alfa or MB, but they can not compete whith the M3/M4 when it comes to responsiveness, gearbox, and foucus.

[@redarmy1778]

i’m a beamer guy last 15 years been in one and looking to upgrade my 15 m135i looking at m3/4 but i’ve had my head turned by that 4.0 v8 c63s, from what i can see is bmw track car first road second as the MB is road first track second, as a daily i think the c63s wins

[@rwac07]

@@redarmy1778 I've got an F82 M4, and when the settings are the most conservative it basically drives like a standard 4 series, you get the best of both worlds

[@arsiongowrang2447]

Totally agree

[@messiboss7940]

M3❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@mitchellschwartz2148]

Not for nothing, but Alfa is so new that there is not much data on reliability...I'll take my BMW Z4 with Dinan install over them anytime.

[@duffydon1741]

The alfa is a great car, but it took decades of studying the M3 for it to be competent, nomatter how good it maybe, it will never be like the M3, the M3 is the original idea of the track in this segment...

[@thomasferrarojr.9772]

Lol. You're kidding right?! Alfa copied BMW driving dynamics?!!

[@FutureGameLight]

just saying that the giulia also comes with the normal alfa problems where some people cant drive their new car more than half of the time of owning one. look up the forums i never had heard of a worse handled car befor.

[@rogerpreece7762]

Not sure how on Earth you reckon BMW quicker than an Alfa???.... No chance... I had an M4 with a Comp pack on it and actually swapped it for an Alfa. Alfa is way quicker than both the other two. And Merc is the SLOWEST !!!!

[@alleviate9546]

The Alfa lost and BMW is better on the track perhaps in a straight line too. To me, the BMW wins!

[@LeandroMoyaRuiz]

Alfa Romeo is the best! I have a MiTo QV, Amazing.

[@jacobusstefanusvandervyver4211]

Dont think the stats of the merc is correct...

[@tahag2107]

Alfa on semi slicks and still slower ?

[@Dps640]

Is Only Q (Quadrifoglio) not Qv

[@TWHISPERER]

Is Alfa reliable this time around? Not that the other two cars are but Alfa was terrible at one point weren't they?

[@722stirlingmoss]

C63 for me

[@histriamagna1014]

I choose passion...

[@waqarghulam2653]

Put this engine in the 4c

[@corneliusscipio777]

Better in the next 8c 😎

[@jrgensenbo2999]

Cornelius Scipio; it's a 6c then 😉👍just what we need

[@reonbarrett5546]

any one pls thankyou

[@beaubatchelor]

I would pick out of the Alfa and BMW.

[@bjmckay3]

M3 best sports sedan period!!

[@mushy1983123]

How can u say the amg is the fastest in a straight line with the Alfa's quater mile time is quicker then the amg and the m3 times a identical to the amg

[@kdog18ful]

It’s the best. It’s Alfa.

[@teamlava6283]

After watching this I’ve noticed this dude does not understand the driving physics of the giulia

[@rwac07]

You guys dismiss the M3 because the performance is 'too hard to access'... but fanboy over cars that are a whole second slower, in a track test.

[@AR-tc9kf]

ALFA ROMEO NUMBER 1 Germans, boring.

[@dor1tomcswagger69]

A R yeah it's not fun buying a 100k car and it being more reliable, right?

[@rab7991]

he's saying the alfa is easiest to drive and the bimmer the hardest. that makes the alfa the boring choice the bmw the fun choice with benz being the balanced choice

[@solaimanelaissaoui4842]

BMW M3 Competition all day, every day!

[@GianzSSD]

Il go Alfa ♥️🏁

[@liamhorn1150]

I call that bullshit time Alfa quicker than the M3 and M4

[@Unicoseti]

Mediocre and joke test!Real life Alfa QV=N°1

[@AlsAllAussieAdventures]

Better off just getting a HSV W1, will be faster around the track and down the 1/4.. Has much bigger brakes and sounds insane! Plus a real stick shift manual.

[@tsnaha]

Yet on the nurburgring it killed both

[@greengrass9572]

R. I. P M3, You've had your day.

[@ardijankovaci]

sponsor by Mercedes

[@mariuslesan2311]

BMW 450 HP.....1'33"9 - GIULIA and MERC 510 HP......1'34" 9.......for me is "M" all the way!!!

[@alessio.123]

Why only Alfa Romeo can take 540ps, from a 2.9engine?🤟🏼🌶️

[@mpowerm.760]

Bmw is always always the best❤❤❤❤☝☝☝☝

[@MrSirnick74]

Yeah!! What!!??? M3 is not the winner!!?? LOL so what is the video tying to tell the world here? Don't buy it cause it has beaten the Merc and Alfa on the track and its a much better car! Well done people from MOTOR MAGAZINE !! Bravo!! You have convinced me !!! Well done!! LOL . What BUNCH Clowns!!!!

[@pgivno4241]

alfa has 3.0 engine -mercedes 4.0 and arrive in same time,to be fear alfa better enginering to achieve same result whit 2cylinder smaller engine.

[@MrF-ly2bb]

This was a track battle and the BMW M3 CS was the cheapest and the fastest around the track and it lost ??? I am surprised that the Alfa even last threw the whole testing due to a LOT of issues owners are having with their cars. Alfa are known for problems that is why you never really hear about then for the pass 10 years in the USA ! And yet there are still NO teams that used them in ISMA racing or any other racing organization .

[@nassermohd2317]

This not m3 cs its compt 2017

[@chrismorris3726]

Sauber. At least until very recently in F1.

[@mushy1983123]

How is the amg fastest in a straight when the alfa runs a 11.7sec or 11.9sec and bmw best quarter mile time matches the amg which is a 12 flat.. I've driven the alfa and own a m3 both very good cars only reason why I have m3 over the alfa is cause the bmw have a bigger aftermarket performance parts then the alfa which is alfas only downfall

[@llanbabogibo756]

The BMW is king

[@alexbarrios875]

M3 is the track king.

[@zemolo1]

can I contradict you ..? I have the giulia since April 2017, made 55k km and 4 track day at Mugello (time 2.03), is a fantastic car, with a steering precision that even the GT3 has .. when you drive it .. (few have the balls to drive it seriously) gives you emotion that only the various ferrari, porsche, lambo etc. I can give you, believe me and another story of m3 .. at least for now .. you will see with the new .. another positive note the giulia to the mugello the brakes hold .. the m3 no .. the only problem of the giulia that to go strong you have to be able to drive .. where often those who do these comparatives are not really pilots .. to go strong and do not work hard there is the GTR .. I apologize for the errors but I'm Italian and I do not know English ..

[@arsiongowrang2447]

Don't care what he says I'll take the m3 over the other 2

[@jaymyers6452]

There is no way that crappy bmw beat the gulia, has beaten the same m3 in many other reviews including top gear, just look at the nurbergring lap time

[@sideswipeproductions]

Soooo, you didn't actually watch the video then.

[@kunalmore5212]

Quit your bulshitting bitch. M3 is hands down the ultimate sports sedan!

[@X3R0CAST1]

I have also watched numerous other reviews of the Giulia and in only one of about 7 reviews have the m3 won (saying that it was the comp pack m3) and it was only by .1 seconds faster. I think overall it depends on the track. Each of these cars have their strengths and weaknesses and they show on different tracks. But with that said, i applaud Alfa. After a couple decades of not producing rear wheel drive dream machines they come back and basically meet the best of the best in it's class with the Giulia. I personally think they have made the impossible possible. Well done Alfa!

[@marune1975]

Hilka Nander Absolutely not for me

[@sal1988]

Lets not forget,the only way the M3 is faster is with the Comp pack. Lets also remember, that this is the first Giulia Q model and they've climbed the ladder with one car. I cannot wait for an update with all the small glitches having been refined. The car will be, if its possible, even better.

[@erikalvarez4516]

KZbin: "Someone has de-throned the 5 year-old F30 M3!" BMW M-Division: "Cool." *returns to creating G20 M3/4

[@alexandrinakrylova7029]

the M3 is the oldest car of the 3. however is the fastest on the track ! sorry merc C63 all that power cant beat the bimmer, sorry alpha giula all that new tech from alpha, chrysler, and ferrari cant beat the old Bimmer M3 F80. By the way in less than a year from now the M3 will be updated and then ... and then... ohhh boy ... merc c63 and alpha giulia will be not just beat it but humiliated

[@nickcramer4783]

1 sec on track is a lot. I have seen other track results showing the Alfa 2 seconds faster than the MB. M3 is also beaten by Alfa in many other track comparisons. Maybe a lousy racing car driver or the times taken at different tack conditions. They never tell you that. I still have to meet the first M3/4 that is faster than me on track in my QV . Well whatever both Germany and Italy lost WW 2 so maybe the Cadillac is the winner LMAO

[@farewelnsomnia7128]

the Australians are always against the BMW. BMW the best !!!

[@pikende]

Better than a Quadrofoglio? Hahahaha. You fool. You ve eaten the german marketing.

[@EE-hk8iu]

I think the presenter is a bmw hater , how come they didn’t take bmw although it was a second faster ???

[@pikende]

Again a fake video lieing about the Alfa? The Alfa Romeo made world record on the Nurburgring. Beating the shit BMW. That is all...

[@Gandalf606]

Sorry but why the hell are you measuring petrol engines with this 'kilo doodah' nonsense? It's brake horse power. Full Stop. Just BHP. Stop your idiocy right now.