🇨🇳 🇺🇸 Why is Huawei so controversial? | Inside Story

[@alphaheat8331]

Prism prism on the wall, who is the most trustworthy of them all? If you don't know the answer, ask Edward Snowden

[@RedRider1600]

That was a different king of spying, you moron.

[@netprowlerp]

A American honors the constitution and tells all and the US is not to be trusted. China hides behind a wall of human rights violations and pushing propaganda that would make Hitler warm and fuzzy and you love them. Wow, how stupid.

[@binyumaronald8047]

Huawei is stealing what we don't have lol 😂 ridiculous.

[@kholomokolo]

It's like saying Usain Bolt is holding up his competitors by being in front.

[@netprowlerp]

@Papyrus Okagbue Hahahaha, China steal, pirates and copies everything they have. Go Taiwan.

[@zackofpersia5086]

They stole* the information then poured billions of dollars from the communist party to upgrade it. Do your research on the business tactics of china(in Shenzhen there is no patent or copyright law. So they use whatever publicly disclosed patent a company or individual makes and then pours money into development and research. what is very important when talking about a Chinese country is to consider its not just a country but rather its a whole government. Research how the CEO of Huawei was in the military then retired and got promoted to the high division of the Chinese Communist party(witch basically run everything in china) that was in charge of business and then magically his company appeared out of no where(it was actually huge amounts of money poured by the communist party to gain more influence and reach in Emerging technologies. Arm yourself with knowledge before you start serving the Chinese food and clean their houses. they look down on other races as if they are inferior and consider their country to be the greatest in the world. I lived in china for 5 years, i have a great understanding of how their Huge business works, how the government controls the businesses and their people and the psychology of their actually people. This message is a warning to find truth, Justice and to guard yourself to how china has been robbing the world for year's whilst we get nothing back but cheep goods from their horrindisly used working class.

[@osmanjerry3272]

You all seem to forget China also rape America, ask Trump.

[@mpph6102]

@@zackofpersia5086 you are so stupid there are more pattents regarding 5g in china than any part of the world stupid!!

[@repairman2540]

Huawei does not use Apple out dated Technology. I have a Huawei Phone it is completely different then my iPhone and works much better.

[@PhoenlxA]

it IS apples technology!!!!!!!!!! its completly the same as iphone 15!!!!!!!!!!

[@peterphan3524]

Hi Greg, I'm thinking getting one but don't know US carrier be able to activate it and which one would you advise to get. Thanks

[@repairman2540]

@@peterphan3524 AT&T Prepaid. Very easy to setup

[@erichoe7802]

now u know

[@nurulkarim6525]

What is the price of each?

[@kenrie20022]

I just bought the Huawei mediapd T5 after I heard this incident but I must tell the tab is better than ipad and Samsung. Thanks US for making Huawei known worldwide.

[@SepsRoll]

Us is jealous of China 🇨🇳. Huawei is the best. We love huawei..

[@davidhynes]

Hauwei is a spy for the CCP 1000%.

[@amoslukyaa5792]

@@davidhynes Rubbish.

[@FF-hy4ro]

@@davidhynesAfter bothering learning about CCP's ideals you will side with them.

[@robstammers7149]

When Richard was asked "where is the evidence against Huawei..." he couldn't answer!! Why... Because there isn't any so called evidence!!

[@xing288]

to Al Jazeera: Huawei is a good company, but it is a "pride" to the Chinese no more than GE or Google is a "pride" to the Americans, if at all. Still, if Google's CFO was abducted by a foreign country, I am sure most Americans would not feel good about it, especially when it is coupled with accusations laced with arrogant presumptions. It's that simple.

[@snowwyify]

Hahaha it wasn't China that was caught tapping into Angela Merkels phone...

[@milkybar06]

your right so America can spot when others are doing it to.

[@RedRider1600]

But China has been caught for many other things.

[@ianofliverpool7701]

Every country spies on every country , but you seam to think the CCP should be trusted??

[@kahsiongchow8040]

if the US were to provide 5G to another country, can US also control the communication/defense of the country ?

[@dawnyraikhan3043]

Love Huawei from Nagalim US is just jealous

[@hochungkwang4562]

4G belongs to United States’ AT&T, Verizon, T-Mobile and Sprint. The world's countries pay more than 10,000 trillion yuan in copyright fees to the four companies in the United States. China's 4G pays US$100 million in annual copyright fees to US companies. If the countries around the world switch to Huawei 5G, the United States will lose more than 10,000 billion yuan of foreign exchange each year, which is set at 20% of the annual GDP of the United States. Therefore, the United States will not allow 5G in the world. the United States will destroy Huawei to protect the interests of the United States; i.e. stopping the loss of at least 20% of USA's GDP. What a big bully !!!. Let the world know the true & ulterior reason for USA's insistence on bringing down Huawei.

[@satshiva2105]

All ways huawei😘 America trying their political games, jealous of Huawei growth. Switching from iPhone to huawei today😤

[@archiebunker4108]

No political games from China?

[@jeffganlk]

@@archiebunker4108 China not stopping anybody from doing better. Let's compete. US like "I am the boss, there is no competition". Do whatever it takes to stop others from growing.

[@davelumsden4228]

If the US spent more money on research and development and less on fighting wars for you know who, they probably wouldn’t be in this position.

[@henrychuah9658]

Agree.

[@rbb.828]

LOL almost all of the modern eras major technological advances are thanks to the American defense budget 🙂 fact check me

[@jones1351]

The old National Security two step: 'Hey, this person/country is threatening our NS!' 'Okay, so where's your evidence?' 'Um, I can't show it because of NS concerns, but take my word - they are a threat!'

[@howard49]

Time to confront the bully. Huge respect to Huawei. World get behind them. 👏👏👏

[@RichardVrong876]

Its controversial because Americans couldnt come up with its own functional 5G network and commericalise it.

[@Spaceballz123]

Ok so will China let American companies build infrastructure in china if the situation was reversed?

[@proudtobewhiteprivileged9530]

@@Spaceballz123 you mean like google and youtube

[@RichardVrong876]

Spaceballz No, China won't need to do that because they have huawei and dont need US utterly worthless 5Ge phony rubbish! What would US have done if China pressured all her allies to boycott USA products?

[@wubinfan603]

@@Spaceballz123 worry abt yourself 1st, Americunts need more infrastructure than China.

[@RichardVrong876]

Wally WallyAmericans always accuse China of faking things lol. Out of sheer desperation and heavy pressure, you guys faked a 5G and you call it 5Ge just so you don't look so pathetic and sad and was caught red handed, you're truly beneath contempt, pathetic and sad! I will offer you Americans a tremendous deal that you simply can't refuse. I currently do not have 5G and Huawei is very tempting but I will wait for "made in the USA 5G" and pay a whole lot more for you NSA agents spy on me.... The question I have to you is this, when can I buy American 5G???? Or are you going to sell me 5Ge? Do you have the sophistication, capability, knowhow and talent and to finally figure out and make a breakthrough in 5G tech? I promise to be your first customer and pay top dollar for it!

[@seahippies]

After I bought a Huawei phone my wife wants to ditch her iPhone to get one also - Amazing technology and ease of use - That's why the fear of the yanks...

[@morimoto5768]

@VICtorian071 all I see is the future man. And we have to make new laws regarding 5g to prevent stuff like that happen.

[@jerrygeniusjacks1102]

Darryl Hetherington lovely

[@sdfssdfsdfsdf]

Huawei handphone is not warming and not hanging like Samsung. I am very satisfied with it. I threw away Samsung since I used Huawei and wowed that I will stick to this brand for next phone purchase.

[@joebrister4159]

como gain let's see how good Huawei will be in the future without the support of America loser

[@earuption]

China, if you're listening, could you please help us get rid of Trump for the good of the world?

[@chloe-jw6nt]

I am starting to worry out about my Alexa at home, every word I speak at home could be logged into Amazon's D/B.....

[@NangongReng1973]

Why are u afraid if u didn’t did bad things?

[@MrKrishnadevotee]

5G will be everywhere except in the US and then the entire world will develop at an exponential rate while the US stays far behind. 5G is part of the tech age a huge gamechanger in Tech

[@vishnuchinnasamy]

Do you think All US brands are truly transparency .......no ...only it is pretend to be

[@teoliansengify]

Hi Lady, invite Edward Snowden for the open discussion and I am sure he will have all the correct answers.

[@benghui1988]

It's not about security. It's about american jealousy of Huawei more advanced than american.

[@AERoVALKYRiE]

lol when the anchor asked: "first how right is the US to be suspicious about huawei? secondly, where is the evidence?" That dude represent US can't even give a straight answer.

[@ReajoanMashfik]

Ban selling rare earth materials to US 😂😂😂

[@passby8070]

USA vs Huawei... If that's not bullying, then I don't know what is...

[@RedRider1600]

China has been spying and stealing and getting away with unfair trade practices for decades. China bans most US and foreign tech companies from China. Canada arrests Huawei's CFO, Meng Wanzhou for breaking US-Iranian sanctions and selling US technology. China demands that she be released, or else . . . China is also making territorial claims against all their neighbors. If that's not bullying, I don't know what is.

[@darrellkmalone]

"If you're suspicious of Huawei, why not Apple, Facebook, Amazon, etc?" "Ooh, that's tough... Let's talk about 5G instead."

[@paulmylo]

hello cave dweller. come outside

[@TheJohnwingkayip]

We support Huawei 👍

[@tzutran3181]

How come the top Huawei engineer that mysteriously died from apparent suicide right before mengs arrest never got broadcasted?

[@jasonyan1782]

Anon Wibble proof??? Or did your handler at the CIA forget?

[@jasonyan1782]

Cmon vietdog. Where is the proof?

[@kotnakerry3819]

Anyone noticed that Huawei spokesman was holding the latest Huawei foldable phone while reading the announcement?

[@danh_dang7912]

Controversy is trumpet not huawei

[@davidjacobson3529]

This discussion seems very short on facts. The actual facts seem relatively simple to state. Huawei's chief financial officer is accused of violating sanctions selling telephones to Iran during the initial period of sanctions against Iran's development of nuclear weapons. Huawei is accused and in legal proceedings about the theft of a robot arm used in testing from T Mobile. There is also litigation more than a decade in the past of Huawei stealing some Cisco router source code. Huawei appears to be guilty in both cases. But, neither changes the reality that the bulk of Huawei's success is the result of Huawei's own intellectual property. There don't appear to be any allegations of Huawei theft of property related to its 5g networks or any real possibility of stealing intellectual property that nobody else has. Computer technology of all kinds plays many different critical roles in global economies. There is a legitimate concern about the possibility of computer hardware or software containing malicious functions installed during the manufacturing of distribution process. To date, there appears to be no specific evidence of any history of Huawei carrying out this kind of activity or acting as an espionage agent of the Chinese government. There also is no question that the law passed by the United States Congress specifically applies only to Huawei. More facts would be useful. But endless repetition of the American government's smear campaign don't add any value.

[@RDL_Jamaican]

Jamaica loves Huawei. The most used phones in Jamaica.

[@gregzeng]

Not sure why foreigners do not understand USA's military & para-military (lawyers, legislators, "corrections", homeland security). Every bully needs a target. For centuries now China & the Chinese people have been good targets. Historians will show you the evidence: Mongols, Japan, Europe, England, ... and now the USA. Back to western psychology 101. My own personal legal history here in white Australia shows the importance & needs for bullying targets. Obviously colored people are discriminated, more so at the talented & senior levels. Bully personality means stopping good communications of every kind.

[@abdultikasdalandas6703]

All this controversial about Huawei is an about 5G connection as none of the western technology providers achieved it, until now other than Huawei. So they want to hold back Huawei 5G technology to not allowing it to their countries until they achieve their version and fully functional which is for the western tech company is far from achieving it. It's a matter of pride being smashed and not accepting the fact that Huawei, in fact, defeated all of them.

[@Owleyes2019]

Huawei is not controversy the USA is...

[@sihartobing9570]

This 5.G Market Compatition, How If Huawei To Lounch 7.G 2020, What More Reason To Throw Acuse To Huawei, ...... Bravo.

[@godprincessrealty]

I'm with huawei ❤️

[@rickbarrington]

“Andrew” Leung .. “independent” analyst, what a joke. Doesn’t sound very independent, more a mouthpiece of Huawei. For him to say “the US is acting as judge, jury and executioner” is ridiculous coming from a citizen of China with its authoritarian rulers

[@DMV_L3GO]

I honestly hope they are an ethical company and wouldn't do such a travesty

[@winstonchurchill8300]

Why is Huawei so controversial? Easy! No NSA backdoors. However, I am looking forward to the new HuaweiOS. Well done Mr. Ren.

[@edding4204]

The world still follows the rule of jungle at this stage. However, justice will arrive a bit late, but not be absent. Today's difficulties can not stop the solid steps with which China is moving forwards, but make it more determined and confident. Time will tell who is the winner and who is right later on, no matter communists or capitalists. There is no need to argue here.

[@deanofthetower663]

That's the rules of the jungle. Kill or be killed. No action means death.

[@crtordoes]

There are also many successful American business men who jump - start into business from their military careers. So their business also linked to their government? Puzzled. 🤔

[@BegurKailash]

Earlier it was cold war. Now, it is war of technology. One thing is certain, in this game, only the nation with brain will survive and control. Not like olden days.

[@Predestinated1]

Huawei isn't controversial. Trump made Huawei "controversial".

[@deanofthetower663]

I guess Trump made Huawei "controversial" before and during the Obama administration. Duhhhhhh!

[@FF-hy4ro]

@@deanofthetower663 It took two presidents to barely tint the name of a company. Side effect: the world sides with the company :p

[@KMuse99]

Because Huawei makes better tech.

[@airportcarlimousine3941]

US IS FIGHTING LOST COMPETITION

[@cecilmcintosh864]

This is a mixed bag in MO. I can appreciate both sides of the reality, and let it stand where it stands. Its too complex to write off as right or wrong. I can't judge US and I cant judge China. I commend China for things that some would deem evil, simply because we are living in an evil world. America is also evil, and we are guilty though we never admit to it. We are not on top of the world because we are great, it is because we were willing to do what others either were not willing to do, or did not have the opportunity to do. White supremacy has painted all Western nations as good and righteous while painting everyone else, ex. Venezuela, Cuba, Africa, China, as wrong or evil . Even Russia enjoys free trade and respect from our president even after meddling with our elections. when China try to make the same human sacrifice and use the same bullying to secure a position of security in an evil world, then white nations demonize them and expose what they do. When we are exposed for what we do, the people who expose us are punished, and the white nations agree to ignore the wrong doing, and do not punish one another. That being said, I am proud of China, for the sole reason that they managed to rise up from under white national hegemony and colonialization. They did what they had to in order to take hold of their own destiny, and humbled themselves to below being the dirt under westerners shoes, doing all the things no white nation was willing to do to gain economic foothold. Their people are better off for that I think, and I don't know of a better way they could have risen as quickly as they did. I don't care what people think about communism espionage and the 'ethics' of all that. Before you sit on a capitalist white horse, tell me with all honesty whether capitalism would be in the position of power that it is without slavery, without colonialism, and without unbalanced globalization built upon those unethical practices. China hurt their own people to build themselves up, and the US and Europe raped, pillaged and destabilized other people. Who is better? No one is perfect enough to judge between them. All hypocrites. Now that being said, I am not going to judge US or the rest of the world for banning Huawei should they decide to. China cannot expect me to believe with a straight face, that Huawei is a completely legitimate company. China is in a position where they should not need to cheat as much as they do anymore, but they may have gotten too used to using underhanded practices. The US is still cheating, but it is the government doing it, and not really our capitalist companies. China needs to get their government less and less involved with commerce, since they do not need to have as strong a grip on things as they used to. The future of China depends on the Ego of the government. They need to recognize when it is time to let go of control, and let their nation be free enough to be trusted and respected by other free nations. If you don't care about being trusted and respected then don't try to defend a company like Huawei and continue on the same path. Huawei is their mission to the moon, in comparison. I don't believe they actually want to spy on people, but they do want to dominate and show China's strength, even though it is a false show of strength. US, and the west are guilty of the same things. China just wants to use Huawei to show the world that China is capable of legitimate domination in Tech and manufacturing, to give status and pride to Asian nations, in order to lift the white supremist perception that plagues the world. However, China does not have the credibility to convince the world of this yet, and they continue to use practices that make it hard to trust them. Like making it illegal to compete with a home grown company in their borders. That is not fair play. Why should the world marvel at Huawei capitalist power, when they don't play by capitalist rules? Makes no sense, and China knows this. Their support of Huawei is solely a Government supported and funded propaganda campaign. I don't fault China ethically for trying this, but I simply don't think it is a good idea in 2019 and beyond. Keep in mind the US has done this same kind of thing with some of our own companies but it was during a time when such things were overlooked or deemed acceptable. Companies are too global now to ignore the underhanded things China has done with Huawei. Communism is not a modern system. I think it is necessary to incubate your nation until your nation is strong enough to fend for itself in the global setting, but if it lingers too long you end up like Russia. And this white world is not ready to accept a non-white nation like Russia, where the mafia runs the government and has their finger on nuke buttons. They self appoint billionaires and self appoint the poor, yet the US does business freely with their dirty money and fake wealth. That is not right and it is very....very evil, yet Trump loves these people, while he demonizes China for doing much less.

[@FF-hy4ro]

* They can compete: Cisco is everywhere in China, and isn't Apple already there too? * Let the grip of giant tech bulls go and still be a country? China can learn from the US and how now it has become a lobbyist system without any consideration for the environment or the welfare of its own people. * History can only move forward, communism also does, if a decent amount of Americans learned a little about it instead of watching TV there would be a socialist revolution there tomorrow.

[@cecilmcintosh864]

@@FF-hy4ro I agree for the most part I think. I don't think communism is inherently wrong, neither do I think capitalism is completely wrong. I believe in a balance, based on common sense. I think culture, past, present, and future should always guide politics. That's why I don't like rigid boxes like 'communist' or 'capitalist', The times are complex and call for more robust solutions to societal goals and problems. China needs to be more transparent and clean up their economic practices if they want the respect they are looking for. Granted the US government is and has been evil, but I don't see Apple and Microsoft, or Samsung that way. They are governed by rules that are for the most part commonly shared across capitalist countries, so that competition is relatively fair. This is why Huawei is not being accepted. They are too closely tied to government to be trusted and respected.

[@christopherashford4194]

Chinese gov't taking US gov't to court in the US ... LMAO

[@gargon009]

Whomever dominates AI will rule the world. The Americans understand what is at stake. Can they beat the Chinese, kr even the Indians? No...! Too many people, and too large of a talent pool to draw from.

[@joremtechnologysolutions6745]

Oh America. One day, the chicken is going to come home to roost

[@christopherashford4194]

Already has ... started on 9/11/01

[@MS-ce8nr]

Can Apple, AT&T, Google, Amazon, Facebook and ...... other American companies sue Chinese government? Also there is a Chinese law to require private companies to engage in espionage activities in foreign countries. So USA has to be concerned.

[@topoli201]

He said the Huawei has to prove there innocent that is dumbest think I ever heard before.

[@netgiant2592]

Richard needs to go do his research. Foreign companies actually have around 80% success rate in the Chinese domestic court system.

[@justmanuel2000]

That is totally BS. ZTE is the competitor and also others small companies which not know to the world in China.

[@complicatedjason]

Economists: Data is the new oil USA: did you say oil?

[@growthmindset6951]

Watching this with Huawei 😎

[@yunye1]

Ban HUAWEI ? It’s you who are losing .

[@mitriada]

In which way?

[@taiwee0404]

LOL! 760 countries world wide uses Huawei. Andrew Leung gotta be the best of the best China Analyst.

[@cn-yg6vf]

Why complain?, Huawei got the biggest advertisement by this fiasco. The phones are affordable and sleek and good battery usage.

[@eddieschneider8294]

Huawei should hire edward snowden

[@cholakuany5989]

Huawei is a great company who makes great wireless products. Politics plus human-greed based on 5-G network is fuelling the fight.

[@Gigastorz]

i would not call "jumping to conclusion without evidence" count as transparent legal system, on top of assumption of guilty and demand the defendant to prove themselves innocent.

[@peggy_tan]

the host really likes to cut the chinese speaker off.

[@jobabaran4484]

so using Huawei's "lawsuit" as precedent which is being considered "valid", i could sue anyone who will not buy anything I sell, any company who will not hire me, and just about anyone who will not let me do what i want. WTF is wrong with the world

[@smileg3871]

May be Trump using Huawei now bcos he knows no one spy on him...so secure...🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@bummers]

I pity the US lawyer ... he went to the table with absolutely no chips.

[@davidwang552]

Cisco is everywhere in China

[@zhengzhaomao9904]

How could huawei steal a technology that Cisco doesn't have at all

[@edwinchoy5774]

THAT AMERICAN GUY SAID THAT CHINA DOES NOT ALLOW FOREIGN COMPETITION IN CHINA AGAINST HUAWEI. ONE SIMPLE ANSWER IS THAT THE USA HAS NOTHING, TOTALLY NOTHING TO OFFER IN THIS FIELD. UNTIL USA IS ON PAR WITH CHINESE STANDARD, THEN BEGIN TO WORRY ABOUT OTHER THINGS.

[@tommyjohn1064]

Smart phone Competition Again Another Smart phone is good News for the Consumers !

[@EmpressAA]

THE BACK DOOR ARE IN ALL AMERICAN PRODUCTS...NON WA FOUND IN THE ´HUAWEI...

[@SuperGreatSphinx]

Repentance

[@dao.y4460]

the number of Chinese is larger than islamic people.and don't say no to a Panda

[@gavin8535]

yeah, clone everything and make a better one. we all steal knowledge from our ancestors. right?

[@KubaSobecki]

20:55 - 360 degree pushback lmao

[@robo7921]

Cheating and stealing.. That is rich coming from the American.

[@DiosdeAlcázar]

They was my reaction when I heard that. They are such big hypocrites.

[@harmindersinghthandi8000]

Huawei, even if you win your case against USA, USA never pay any fines and they never will, so it will be a waste of time talking them to court, especially in USA.

[@songking2010]

legal fees? advertising money well spent

[@ravithapa3022]

Good Luck Huawei.

[@morimoto5768]

I'm still buying that phone

[@stevencorbo1220]

This is Apple's fault in the first place for going to change and produce their product

[@igor-yp1xv]

The Chinese analyst didn't answer the question about the Canadian citizens that were arrested in retaliation.

[@doloressverko9887]

Richard Goldstein is uninformed about tech security. Military runs on entirely separate Internet. Even embassies of small Central European countries have such high security for inter communications between their offices.

[@sihartobing9570]

I thing 2020 Not Suport Them, Huawei must Lounch 10.G Smart Phone In 2020, every world market, this good Business much profit, .... Bravo.

[@jasminewindfield6838]

You don't need any inside story to conclude that Huawei is better, anything that can make US govt panic must be something better and stronger, or they won't even care about it right? so, my next phone is Huawei.

[@wallylee8470]

Huawei 5G technology is so advance there is no competition.

[@mitriada]

Can you give one example?

[@sihartobing9570]

Every Knowlage As I.T ithis very universal, now every country build 5.G. they're have capable to build It, than why be Huawei get trouble from US Country this not fair, ... Bravo.

[@tonyatgoogle6076]

I think it's why USA so controversial.

[@nhlanhlasithole6363]

I do not understand why she is deliberately passing on wrong information. Huawei won a government contract, not a communist party contract as she puts it.

[@jomolololo4398]

Maybe cause the CCP law in China is that all companies must provide any info the govt asks for , that is a FACT

[@WiseSloth1978]

Apple and Google are not used for networking technology involved in military activity which obviously seems to be the major concern of the USA

[@prakashhegde8918]

We are not intrested in Huawei products, due to security issues.

[@davidhynes]

Lock her up send her to the US for trial.

[@shaf3006]

The courts system in the two countries argument have an interesting matter to reconsider 🤔

[@KimJakab]

At 20:04 the sign says "Boycoot(t) Huawei". Shouldn't it be boycott?

[@tabishkhan7721]

7:00 - Did he say 760 countries worldwide ?

[@KimJakab]

160 countries?

[@chrisginger4454]

It’s so hilarious to see the US govt accuse others of spying!

[@Hope-kb3lf]

Doesn't Cisco hardware run Linux firmware if so, then everyone can view and modify source code🙊