American Beauty - What it all Meant

[@roarblast7332]

The idea of "joy in small things" is really a reference to the joy of being. In other words, joy isn't derived from anything at all. It comes from a state of acceptance, of being at peace.

[@WhatitallMeant]

I can agree with that.

[@koomba0]

Thank you. I could phrase it a dozen different ways, but this is the essence. Whatever you want to call it, it's as Lester says at the end, letting it flow. If you try to hold onto it, beauty, you'll never have it. Just be.

[@user-rl2rw3tp6s]

That’s so true very wise

[@cecilwhinter]

You're right. And even though joy can come from outside of yourself, from moments that show themselves to you, you have to be in a state of acceptance & peace like you said to not just receive it but welcome it.

[@QuietlyCurious]

Which if anything, goes AGAINST the American ideal. That's the brilliance. We're always told to strive, compete, & never settle.

[@florencetj]

I believe this is the kind of movie that's just getting better and better to you as you get older.

[@WhatitallMeant]

Yeah, it hit me really hard in high school, but now I know more people that are like these character

[@florencetj]

Thank you for sharing your insight, Mate :")

[@kasskapis]

Floren Nakajima exactly what I thought! when i first saw it, I was 12 years old and thought it's boring. I'm 18 now (i know i'm still very young) and i've watched it at least 5 times at different age and every time it's so cool to think back how I used to think about that film. absolutely fell in love with it at 17.

[@gj3042]

So right. I just rewatched it at 24. I remember watching it in my teens and sneak watching it when I was really young. It’s such a great movie.

[@Jaydee011]

Like wine.

[@Winchester-xw8uy]

People always think they want stuff but they actually want happiness. They spend their entire lives chasing after it but fail to ever grasp it fully

[@some_randomninja]

Pure happiness is when you're a child i reckon. As you get older you just have snippets of fun.

[@Jack-rk7jc]

@@some_randomninja Pure happiness as a concept doesn't exist, I don't think. Ups and downs are inevitable in life, no matter how healthy, wealthy, and full of love your life is. The idea that you all you have to do is obtain this one thing, then you'll be happy forever, is just impossible. Happiness is a feeling, an emotion, not a lifestyle. The way I see it, happiness comes in waves, and you really have to be present in the moment to accept the opportunity to ride that wave when it comes by. That's how you fully appreciate the ups, now as for the downs... I think it helps if you find a way to enjoy the times in between those waves happiness, or atleast come to terms with them instead of letting yourself feel stuck or worse, actually causing yourself to be stuck by giving up and settling into the cesspool instead of continuing to try climbing out of it. The "bad times" we go through don't have to be the "worst times." Finding a way to still enjoy things and letting yourself love the people in your life as well as seeking comfort in them, is the best way to use the downtime. But a lot of people just say to themselves "well this fucking sucks" and they sit in that shitty attitude, and that only makes it worse, and last longer. What's worse is when they fully give up. Then... you could lose years of your life, or for some people, they never find a way out of that, and are lost forever from that point. Long story short, try and find new things in life to love, and appreciate the things and people you already love, because surrounding yourself with good people is really more important than you'll probably ever be aware of.

[@Meisterling]

Happiness is a byproduct

[@Mayu1505]

@@Meisterling calmness is an inate quality of the mind and its often mistaken as a hole that needs to be filled with stuff like phones, cars,etc

[@paoloromano3759]

​@@Jack-rk7jc The great misstep of evolution occurred once homo sapiens gained consciousness. Before, we acted on instincts of hunger, sexual reproduction, and survival. However, with the addition of consciousness, humans now spend the entirety of their brief existence searching for the elusive feelings of "happiness" and "love". Although some may feel they have obtained these imagined emotional states, in reality, they have merely released certain chemicals in their brain. Despite the darkness and nihilistic nature of our futile existence, we somehow manage to get out of bed everyday.

[@rocker5202]

American Beauty is a true masterpiece. One of my favorite films of all time.

[@HaythamThorn]

Martin Dean He's probably American, we don't use the "u" in such a way.

[@theoneandonlyspook1312]

You know shit is good when you say film instead of movie

[@olegdepapa]

why? it's not really a feel good film. by the end of it you feel like there's no point to life. what's good about that?

[@DDTSik]

@@olegdepapa the fact that this film was able to evoke that particular emotion for you is skillful in itself.

[@spderman123]

i slept on this film and been watching clips definitely watching soon

[@AlchemicalForge91]

as a kid in the nineties we didn't have much money and I was jealous of the families in this movie.. Then I got older and pitied them. The beauty is anywhere and everywhere though in truth.

[@bruce4303]

Hell yeah....

[@peteowen5860]

i hear that!

[@roastedturkey2484]

Amen brother

[@MrAns786]

Joe Urban I feel you bro. Peace

[@elizabethbennet4791]

MWAH me too

[@stuartevans1351]

American Beauty and Fight Club gave such good representations of the corporate 90's

[@holyholyzeddd]

Office Space and the Matrix are also good ones.

[@SolusBatty]

What about Glengarry Glen Ross. Loved that one too.

[@222browneyes]

And American Psycho

[@LexCreeps]

+Sue Donym isn't american psycho about a bunch of 80's yuppies

[@222browneyes]

Genuine//Imitations It was a perfect, graphic and somewhat comedic critique of corporate (mostly Wall St workers) in the 90s. A beautiful portrayal of the superficiality and meaninglessness of that lifestyle.

[@CinephiliacProdction]

The symbol isn't just of a "rose", and while your words on that make sense, it's not what was intended. The "American Beauty" is a breed of roses, so the title refers to this breed of roses that while being pretty and appealing in appearance, is often prone to rot underneath at the roots and branches of the plant. Thus, the tagline "...look closer" tells the viewer that when they look beyond the "perfect suburban life," they will find something rancid at the root.

[@williamchristie2921]

It's not only the rose it's also the color red like when the camera focuses on the red door near the end

[@nppappapaannnnp]

Thanks, I didn't know this but it makes a lot of sense!

[@333br]

Everyone has a different perspective.

[@seminole17910]

@ Yummy Sounds. I would agree with this. This movie is what you choose to make of it IMHO. I tried to articulate to someone why "American Beauty" is one of my favorite movies of all-time and I just couldn't put my finger on it. Of course, it's a scathing indictment of modern American life at the surface, but it's more of a philosophical movie to me. As Sam Mendes (the director) said "It was amazing that a movie where the pivotal scene is a dancing plastic bag, was embraced and understood so greatly." The "Plastic Bag Scene" and Spacey's monologue at the end, make that movie for me personally. Just pure beauty. No pun intended. Beauty and happiness are fleeting in life and not even Rickey's video camera could hold on to either.

[@blacjackdaniels200]

CinephiliacProdction Excellent

[@xruraldustx]

Lester is the focus. He's finally found beauty (the little things) but he's been enlightened too late in his life spent here on earth. Ricky shows insight into what the rest of the characters and the audience have the capability to become, enthralled with seeing the beauty in everything. This film is a great lesson in life.

[@williamdon3442]

That’s pretty good. Never thought about it that way.

[@morganmmontz]

This is probably my favorite film of all time. It really is the ride, the roller coaster, that makes this movie for me. The highs and lows are just...amazing. Along with the music, it really makes a viewing experience I have never matched.

[@jasonantigua6825]

Check out Revolutionary Road !

[@morganmmontz]

jason antigua I will!

[@JackNapi3r]

Even though Revolutionary road is a great film, it doesn't match the greatness of American Beauty

[@danifunk6687]

I totally agree. This is my alltime favorite drama and I've been watching it at least once a year since I had seen it in the cinema when it first came out.

[@jellyt4967]

One of my all time favorites too. It cannot be matched. The soundtrack is so thought provoking along with the great drama and filming. I love questioning the image of beauty and how people present themselves in society. This movie is definitely one that can be watched over and over again, as it provokes new thoughts each time.

[@riggamorrischan]

I think you could possibly even add on to the symbolism. Not only are the roses a primary symbol, but in a more broader sense, the color red is represented throughout the entire film. The red roses, the front door, the red behind buddy kane's advertisements, the red car, the sweater with red flowers worn by jane, and even the red oven pan, etc. And red represents so many different things like sexuality, love, rebellion, life force, and the soul.

[@AlexTheCrayChick]

Daniel Miller also anger and hate

[@DDDSSDDDSSDDDSS]

You forgot the blood at the end.

[@mgdkns6678]

The soul is represented by red?! In what philosophy?

[@EM38101]

Of course, Tyler Durden when he is introduced wears white because the narrator is still sort of processing the very being of Tyler, when he realizes he wears red, the aforementioned colour. But in the end he wears black, the color of project Mayham to show his true self

[@ct6852]

Red usually means passion.

[@johnellizz]

People make fun of that thing with the dancing bag...but IT'S REAL. I was walking down the street one day when a plastic bag jump right in front of me and did a miraculous dance. It was like ballet but with a bag! Then, this bag followed me for two blocks as I walked down the street! I'll never forget the look on this cat's face as he watched this bag trailing behind me as we passed by his front lawn. Hollywood isn't always full of crap (just most of the time).

[@blacjackdaniels200]

PROVEN FACT VIDEOS you were probably smoking that same stuff Ricky Fitts was

[@YogiBearTruthbetold]

There is a whole life behind things, Search "Truth Contest" and read the top entry called The Present. The truth will set you free

[@blacjackdaniels200]

Grace Ful if it was so true no one would need a book to know it

[@aliasjon8320]

User name checks out

[@coreyhebert5139]

I thought it was cool

[@santoroy2120]

When it's late I get all philosophical and shit and watch videos like these

[@Datheavyispootis]

Good! Keep at it

[@LightXplosion]

I know right? It's 3 AM on a Friday morning and here I am pondering the meaning of beauty.

[@pastelhotmess9299]

Roy Boy that's me every night join the club dude

[@fredmorris7743]

r/iamverysmart

[@scottwall3095]

Same, when my mind is too tired to keep up the facade of controlling everything I tend to turn toward this sort of stuff.

[@willrueb9573]

American Beauty was detailing the end of the nuclear family, the end of the conventional American dream, and the innocence of the American youth being replaced by a jaded pessism directed at their parents and elders.

[@mikekaroules2820]

I know I'm late with this reply but you sure said alot there. You're on to something. I absolutely respect the narrator's analysis but in my lowly opinion he is too detailed. I think he may have gone off on a couple tangents. What I got out of the movie is seeing a family 👪 who have lost their way and , believe it or not , they actually still love eachother. They just don't have the tools to be reconciled to eachother. I believe deep down they don't want to fracture or split up. They want to be a family but they are searching in every wrong place to find happiness , but happiness alludes them. They basically have the American dream but what good is it. The American dream deceived them and has basically destroyed them. This accurately reflects thousands of American families right now. Look at all our material success and it robbed us of our heart and soul. Families are wealthy but lost. They're lost.

[@sean.furlong1989]

Couldn't the same be said for the hippies of the late 1960s/early 1970s?

[@mikekaroules2820]

@@sean.furlong1989 not sure . The hippies back in the late 60s were not trying to overthrow or degrade the traditional family unit nor traditional marriage.

[@ct6852]

I did kind of have that feeling when this came out. Like 'does it mean everything gets worse from here'?

[@wiizxx]

The soundtrack is a masterpiece

[@paperchasindude6578]

Thomas newman should've won the Oscar

[@airikkalerofficial]

@@paperchasindude6578 FACTS

[@TheProphegy]

Who knew such simple keys could evoke so much emotion. One of my favorite movie soundtracks ever. So much peace and calmness it brings me.

[@BrotherMalMusic]

Had to get that mf on vinyl

[@DeepVerma728]

Lester Burnam reached self actualization which means he had to die.

[@mgdkns6678]

Why “he had to”? Nevertheless it made me think also of the movie “A single man”, when Colin Firth’s character reaches the same catharsis and ends up the same...dead...

[@waynepayne9875]

True. He was complete.

[@BigSmoke-bu6ib]

Wake up, Donnie

[@BrotherMalMusic]

Wild, a similar thing happens in _Panic_ with William H. Macy

[@gabbar51ngh]

Reminds me of Vanilla Sky a bit. He wakes up the moment he realises he's experiencing a manufactured dream.

[@walterkronkitesleftshoe6684]

Thomas Newman's "American Beauty" theme music has ALWAYS touched my soul, and makes me ACHE for something I cannot define (And I'm normally not the most "spiritual" of people) but this soundtrack just DOES this to me. So much so that driving to my mother's funeral 9 years ago, I purposely listened to it, just to reinforce its power on me. The single piano with string accompaniment is such a DEEPLY moving motif.

[@ct6852]

Thomas Newman has some really great scores. This might be the best. But White Oleander, Meet Joe Black, Road to Perdition, Finding Nemo, Shawshank, Cinderella Man, and The Iron Lady are all fantastic.

[@waynepayne9875]

When I was a teenager I thought this was just a cool movie, but as a grown man I think it's a masterpiece.

[@sashinshine5818]

1: Cruel Intentions 2: American Beauty 3: Fight Club In this order, for the message behind the movie. All great movies, all have a deep thoughtful reality of people trying to cope with their life.

[@jimmycrackcorn1603]

Donnie Darko and the Matrix will round the list off... late 90s they were opening the veil for us.

[@sashinshine5818]

@@jimmycrackcorn1603 The Matrix? How and why?

[@jimmycrackcorn1603]

The aesthetic of the real world...the crappie clothes and shitty food. The cast seems to yearn to go back in to save others. But they are always dress very autrutrisric, as if they are most posh, for a mission. It seems they have to "dress up" their egos, never manifesting the same things they see daily in the real world.

[@RottenDoctorGonzo]

All 3 came out in 1999! Along with Office Space.

[@THEOvERSiZEDMeATBALL]

dont forget office space

[@ChubakaSteven]

I just watched your analysis of American Beauty, and in going through the comments, I saw a month ago you said that you had been feeling down on yourself. Knock that crap off, buddy. Your analysis of American Beauty was MIND BLOWING. Tonight, I've been doing a lot of thinking about my relationships, life and death, notions of "God", the universe, beauty, peace, meaning... and to cap the evening off with your analysis of American Beauty was fantastic. "Taking control of a shadow or mirror self seems great, but... it involves so much turmoil. Yet there are those who live inside that state constantly, which is another way to try and escape these identity crises, but as stated, it creates a person that can be happy and sees the things other people take for granted, while on the other hand keeps them from experiencing full joy due to their split." In that one paragraph, you were able to accurately summarize my entire 'existential crisis' that I've been analyzing for the last several years of my life. You are an incredibly bright, intelligent person. You have an incredible way with words, that is "substantive" as someone else put it, and is so succinct and poignant that even I, who consider myself a word-smith, find myself envious :). Keep up the fantastic work!

[@WhatitallMeant]

All I can really say is thanks. Not to diminish what you said in the slightest, but every once and a while I'll get a comment or email or what have you like yours that helps to alleviate the sort of petty depression I fall into. I appreciate it so much.

[@CallMeNumber8]

+What it all Meant there is no depth without pain my bro. I'm in the same boat as you! Thanks for video my man 📹 peace ✌

[@aerialpenn8849]

@@WhatitallMeant just wanted to say thanks for this video. This was a great review for a classic film

[@loudrockacdc]

No way, I saw this movie for the first time 2 nights ago and you post it NOW!!! That's awesome. I love coincidences so much.

[@bobpolo2964]

There are no coincidences

[@blooduhz]

Where were you for the past 17 years? this movie was released back in 1999 lol.

[@loudrockacdc]

blooduhz Just never got around to seeing it! I actually hadn't even heard much about it until some friends suggested it to me.

[@paulatreides0777]

Synchronicity is the word you are searching for

[@LeBovarysme]

you're so enticing in a way i can't describe, i'm so amazed with the way you talk and the things you say, so poetic yet precise, i could listen to your analysis for hours and i wouldn't feel bored at all, it's sad being surrounded by people that just don't get it, movies are so beautiful and full of messages waiting to be deciphered, it's truly breathtaking seeing that people like you have such passion when talking about movies, sorry for the long comment, props to you sir❤️

[@WhatitallMeant]

Well thank you! Glad I can be that for you.

[@beat.1546]

bro, you just got an admirer.

[@fkxstyle]

IKR! people don't care about the meaning of the movie anymore these days..

[@Ares_gaming_117]

a rich analysis for a film rich in meaning. cant get any better

[@HazelFaith]

I love what you're doing and find it very enlightening and educational. Please keep going!

[@ChanelROETV]

This movie profoundly hit me in a way I can’t even explain

[@jerrygil1965]

Same

[@RottenDoctorGonzo]

Yeah, I feel you there.

[@freddiesawyer]

Same here…

[@GamingBusterOneAndOnly]

Same for.. I'm looking for other movies which give same feel

[@Malikj661]

Man frfr it’s like the feeling of the fall

[@Nonni655321]

Thank you for doing justice to this movie, it's a pretty special film for me. I also want to mention as a professional classical musician, that the soundtrack of this movie was groundbreaking, we can hear the minimalist score influence in many films and trailers that we see even today.

[@WhatitallMeant]

Oh yeah, if these were reviews/retrospectives rather than thematic analysis, you better believe that section would have been much longer

[@bobpolo2964]

What it all Meant I want this to be straight to the point. This was a clear step up, literally. I got to about 7 minutes and had to pause the video because of so much essential information being tossed my way, I mean that in a good way. Your critical writing has evolved and the dead pan delivery was in full effect. Perfect balance of objective analysis combined with subjective observation. One: too many titles, way too many. Your potential for tight structures really showed in this video, so I would suggest dividing your analysis into 3 parts and a conclusion. This will allow you to have the title, Part one: whatever, Part two: whatever, conclusion etc. Movies have 3 acts and a conclusion, why not film essays? Having so many titles is unnecessary. You begin with an opening statement about how the film is about identity and beauty. Just keep talking like normal, giving us context and then... Part one. I saw a title for tone, cinematography, music, and your normal sentences on screen all before 2 minutes of video😬 By dividing the essay into parts, this will allow you to discuss all of those elements in between and still be able to thread the character arcs, buzz words, etc. And you can place those titles into different parts, more organization. That allows the viewer to say, "I think I'll study part 2 for now before moving on." Imagine that. Two: you really kept it consistent with your examination of the themes of identity and beauty. There was also this nuance where you showed a character talking about seeing a dead homeless woman and how sad she looked. Then you cut to a dead Lester with a smile. You allowed me to catch that on my own without beating me over the head. Perfect. Be careful with your wording. "Subtext is apparent through the lens of everything else thus far." By not saying what type of lens (spiritual, existential, identity) this sentence becomes abstract. Always be conscious of appropriate modifiers. You're a writer. "Trying to force an identity is as problematic as having none at all." Perfect!!!! Three: you're almost there, super sayain level 1000. Just keep grinding. This was your best format thus far, so happy to see you experimenting even though you have to deal with your other life, independent from critical work. Seriously consider the division of parts. It's gonna let you expand on textual threads and visual continuities in whatever film you're examining and thread those different elements within your overall essay. I'm about to rewatch this bro because it's so good. Take care

[@WhatitallMeant]

bob polo I'll keep ALL this in mind for my next video. Especially the bit on the subtext phrasing. Structure is key to clarity, so if I can continue to improve on that, I'll take any suggestion. Sorry I can't reply to everything specifically. Just know I'm taking it to heart, appreciate the time taken to type it up, and have no time at the moment.

[@anautumnforcrippledchildre8369]

Thomas Newman "Any Other Name".. The track suits the film perfectly.

[@deniseg812]

I love Thomas Newman. My favorite is The Orchard from Phenom

[@WhatitallMeant]

Trying a new format, any feedback is greatly appreciated. Hopefully you like it!

[@theogaccount3791]

Love this movie love your channel

[@the_famous_reply_guy]

It works well! another great deconstruction, it seems i missed out a few things from this classic. Much appreciated.

[@vincentbyas6186]

Very straightforward while still keep in the unique way in which you deconstruct something. Feels very specific and clear. Great job!

[@WhatitallMeant]

+Donte Newmy Hopefully, I'm going to try to have A Clockwork Orange out by next week

[@Hamletshandle]

Brilliant mate, no BS just straight to the point with using the perfect clips to back up your points. There was nothing wrong with the previous format however this seems a lot better

[@coma3550]

I knew this movie was a master piece the first time I saw it in my twenties. Twenty years later I'm still trying to wrap my head around its complexity.

[@Lone432345]

ITs about a guy trying to bone a underage girl. There nothing complex about it.

[@johnadams-wp2yb]

A rare thing these days... a truly great American film.

[@kasdfg776]

Yeah, but look when it was made. They sure aren't making any good movies any more.

[@olegdepapa]

whats so great about it?

[@sirpizo555]

Made by a Brit though

[@dreamthedream8929]

@@kasdfg776 what do you mean? Parasite came out and won oscars. Your name came out and received praise

[@HarleyQuinn_93]

This movie talks to me in a different way. The movie says there's so much beauty that you can't take it but relax and it flows through you. It speaks to me through love rather than something as common as beauty. I've wanted to be married and be with my soulmate since I started liking girls, which was literally in Kindergarten. I saw the beauty of love through the relationship of my parents. August 15, 2017 they will have been together for 25 years. I saw the best parts, worst parts, hardest parts and easiest parts of love through them. I knew the meaning of love at 15 and only knew more of it as I grew older. I talk to my soulmate in spirit on a regular basis. I talk to her like I would pray to God. Her name is Lexie. I've wanted love like my parents have for so long. They never really taught me how to show someone I love them. So, I always just threw it all on the table and scared them away. My heart to this day is so full of love that it has become a burden that ways me down. It constantly weighs me down because I have no woman to give this love. I have no woman because women don't want the love I have to offer. The love I have is true love. The love I witness in my parents marriage everyday. Women that want that love don't exist. Not in my world anyway... Is this Lexie I told you of even real? Am I crazy because my own love has weighed me down to rock bottom? Then I watched this movie and everything just felt okay. That being said, I haven't found a way to let go of my love so it can flow through me rather than weigh me down. I'd really like some help with that one. I was born in 93, so I understand the end of history thing. We appreciate that all the hardships from world wars, racism, diseases, and other things are gone but we have no direction now. We're just a bunch of half alive misguided ghosts. We're half alive because we have no direction. We're misguided because we listen to the unwise(Hollywood, the media)trying to tell us what to do. This and Shawshank Redemption are my favorite movies of all time.

[@porakanasa2006]

Can I ask you, IF you don't mind of course, and you are still using this account, given that this comment was written 6 years ago.....has your opinion changed? Did you find Lexie....in all her glory? You must be around your 30's now... I don't even know why I went through this rabbit hole on YT watching a video about the movie, then scrolling down the comments. Your comment related to me in a way that I was holding my breath and watching the screen for 20 minutes before I pressed reply. I'm just curious. I'm a female, with sort of completely different experience than yours in regards to my parents life, but the sentiment is the same still...

[@panaramix4835]

Thank you, dude. You have no idea how much I enjoy listening to/watching your perspective on some of the finest films I've seen. Lately I've been struggling with deconstructing how my own life unraveled and became derelict and meaningless, so I started rewatching films and browsing youtube for essays, deconstructions and perspectives to keep my mind occupied and "stay in the light". It's refreshing to listen to other people's standpoints on these masterpieces and you're doing a fine job at keeping depression away. You're awesome!

[@WhatitallMeant]

Thanks! I'm glad I could do something actually meaningful for you.

[@adamflores402]

I have been really wanting this for a long time. the soothing voice, as well as easy to disgust break down of the Emotion behind the film. you really out done yourself. Great Job!

[@Jim90117]

I'm 34 and I'm amazed I had never actually come across this as I lived and grew up during this era of time and obviously can relate to it. I was absolutely blown away by this movie and felt it hit so many deep sentiments of the time it was filmed and even modern day.

[@Malikj661]

omg did you love this movie ? i’m 24 watch it last winter and omg it was the most perfect time of the year to watch this movie

[@hoppergrasa]

My favorite movie. It's an absolute masterpiece

[@Mindzinsuk]

Background music has been my wake up alarm for years. That piano is the most gentle sound to wake up to.

[@paperchasindude6578]

Same it's so brilliant

[@eadams1057]

Whats the name of the track?

[@Mindzinsuk]

@@eadams1057 The track is called "Any other name" by Thomas Newman

[@eadams1057]

@@Mindzinsuk thanks

[@jasonmaclean719]

I've always loved the movie, still one of my favorites. Lester to me was the focus and gave the message. However, years later and the allegations against Spacey came to light. Now? The parts with Angela are REALLY tough to watch

[@user-ep9fu2be4z]

I rarely bother to comment on anything. You are incredibly good at breaking things apart. Please keep making videos. "She's just waiting in other people's quicksand." Dude.

[@WhatitallMeant]

Glad you decided to! And I will, A Clockwork Orange is next

[@dylanfriese-greene174]

Spot on. Upon first watching this film did I realise how much it was a work of art. The characters literally unfold before you so vividly. Thanks for shedding some new light on stuff I didn't pick up.

[@DAEAJ1]

Watched this again today and I’ve watched a lot. I always enjoy it and I always fill up at the end. When I’m at work or anywhere else and movies come up I always say that this is one of my favourites and tell them it’s great. It’s annoying that people I know haven’t heard of it let alone watch it. It really is a great smovie

[@VJ4rawr2]

This was an incredibly well done analysis. You've put into words the meaning that I felt.

[@tetsuan25]

I remember lying on my friend's bed as he surfed the net, and the haunting American beauty theme music played in the back ground, when my friend said out of the blue. " The problem with you is you won't allow anyone to love you" My expression changed I felt my soul for a brief moment escaped my body, as that truth speared my heart. That has always stuck with me. We no longer have contact. That music always reminds me of that moment.

[@lea9977]

This is a film if I see it is on Netflix, I will play it going to sleep. Easily watched it 40 times. I find it very touching. Who isn’t trying to put on a face like they’re living a dream but all of us are struggling.

[@jakethelifter3824]

Just watched this movie last night, and It lives up to its name. It's one of the most beautiful films I've ever seen. And no matter how sad the ending is for many reasons, it still has major payoff.

[@cb_2887]

I love movies and watched American Beauty when I was 13. From the writing, performances, cinematography, and score it was THE movie that opened my eyes to what filmmaking was. Still is one of my favourite films! A True Masterpiece.

[@lucyk2371]

I thought it was symbolic. The young girl that he is obsessed with is his youth. He believes that by sleeping with her that he can recapture some of that freedom. He comes to the realization just like when he starts to get intimate with her that it is wrong. His time has past and he sbould take joy in his life now. Maybe help his family recapture some of that spark. It's just when he realizes his life is perfect the way it is that he is shot. I believe that is why the photographer boyfriend smiles at the look on the father's face because it is complete bliss. However like many great movies, it can mean different things to different people.

[@grey6545]

Thank you so much for your work. I watched this video when I was going through rough times, and through it, I managed to understand certain aspects of life which helped me overcome the issues I was facing back then. I always come back to this video, this is a timeless video. Thank you!

[@raalaa121]

The haunting music score. And Kevin Spacey and the pothead did it for me.

[@eddiethatch5060]

This is an excellent documentary. I was blown away by American beauty when it came out and still love it to this day.

[@arturkarpinski164]

I saw this movie back when it was brand new, I was around 20 and I thought that it was stupid. Now at 42 I saw it again and it's one of the best movies I've ever seen. Very good review!!!

[@jacktrim796]

I found 'American Beauty' an almost perfect movie. Still enjoy it today. Great review and analysis. Thank you.

[@davidegiacon9371]

Definitely the best video I've seen in a long time, brings so many emotions. Thanks for uploading

[@WhatitallMeant]

+Davide Giacon Thanks! I'm glad it affected you.

[@HarleySB]

Thank you. American Beauty has been one of the most meaningful movies for me since it's release, and it's nice to see it broken down respectfully. Then ending still rings through my bones.

[@carlgrau5910]

Probably the best movie i have ever seen. Watched it when I was 17 loved it. Now at 37 still a great movie. Probably one of the best movies I have ever seen

[@Lone432345]

You might want to watch more movies.

[@GabithWhyborn]

A true spiritual movie ! I understand it better than before because I had an awakening and some profound experiences with meditation. Reality is perfect as it is, it's infinite beauty. The ego project his judgements and fear on reality and this is why we think Reality's harsh or not perfect at all. Ego isn't truth, being is. Reality is pure beingness, there is no moral, no judgement, no language, it only is. And we're not separate from it, we are it. Now you don't have to believe me, if you want to know learn to be and within years you'll see by direct experiences.

[@noloveforthehaters]

This movie means just as much to me as a 40 year old man, as it did to me as an 18 year old teenager, but in two totally different ways. A phenomenal piece of art which only some people will truly appreciate.

[@lpr5269]

And Another thing. From now on we're going to alternate our dinner music because frankly, and I don't think I'm alone here, I 'm getting a little tired of this Lawrence Welk Shit.

[@xTruncz]

Paul y Lol!

[@hyperborean72]

I never before really noticed how beautifully Angela showed that she truly cares for Lester (11:10) and with that she literally saved Lester overwhelmed with solitude from crying. Such a fantastically played scene. And it is may be the only scene of the movie where people really care about each other and understand each other

[@CS-fw7ze]

The morning after I saw this movie I asked my husband for a divorce. I identified so strongly with Spacey's character and being a middle aged poor woman with zero attraction for teen girls I never really understood why I felt that way. I just knew I didn't want to die living unhappy but secure. Your explanation makes sense to me. I understand now why I identified with him. :)

[@elizabethbennet4791]

too late in life lol...but you're still alive, so there's that.

[@olegdepapa]

that's terrible.

[@westkanye4005]

How's The Single Life

[@MrSkarbek36]

@@westkanye4005 lmfaooooo

[@waynepayne9875]

That's awful you abandoned your marriage because you saw a movie? Did you make it to the end? He realized his life wasn't that bad.

[@edwardnygma1887]

The most revolutionary thing someone can do is be happy

[@mathematics5040]

Happiness do not remain constant throughout the life span but vary from one stage of life to another. ;)

[@sirbarksalot9139]

It's all about enjoying the small things in life​@@mathematics5040

[@sura3638]

This is the most beautifully written and articulated analysis of the film. The way you explained everything was so well done, especially with the audio behind and the perfect editing. Can't wait to watch more, I'd love to see some more in depth analysis of films like this, perhaps Requiem for a Dream

[@mkeeble1989]

That was awesome! Your analysis is so substantive that it is impossible to take it all in with one viewing. How are you able to analyze this movie the way you do and talk that way you do in your analysis? The way you phrase a sentence is incredible to me. I can't really describe what it is you're doing but I just know that it's simple but encapsulating the way you speak. I would love to be able to speak like that. Please keep the videos coming.

[@WhatitallMeant]

Well thank you very much! I've been kinda down about my work recently, so it's great to have such nice words sent my way. I've been thinking about doing some "teaching" videos to show how I analyze or break down any given piece of media. Just stay tuned.

[@sprutch11]

Please do so! I have just recently come across your channel, and, while I enjoy your videos tremendously, there are only a limited amount of films one man can analyse. I always feel like I am missing out on half the fun due to my limited ability to break down films and discover its (hidden) messages and themes. Teaching your viewers a tool set to do so themselves would be perfect.

[@RawandCookedVegan]

I agree, very insightful break down.

[@SyskoTheCat]

The new format is really nice. I enjoy how you thank the viewer(s) at the end of your videos. keep up the good work

[@maze2512]

So death is the penultimate freedom.

[@Pickle-Rick365]

Death is imprisoned by life, just as life is imprisoned by death. Freedom only comes from being at peace with the state in which you are already in.

[@nottletottle]

no, acceptance is

[@xzaviermalibu6276]

Lol this movie is stupid the blonde was the only normal one

[@igorcesar5574]

@@xzaviermalibu6276 you sound like the blonde lol

I believe this movie is about finding beauty in life. To not take for granted what we do have but to also to see beyond it and see that beauty is all around us all the time. We just have to slow down and pay attention. Something as simple as a first kiss, or the senior year in high school where it might seem just like days gone by its relative moments to the person that's experiencing them but those moments as inane as they might seem. Those moments will eventually be simple, beautiful memories but they will stand out like a sore thumb because we could only wish to go back in time to those times and tell ourselves that those moments will forever live with you til the day you die not in regret of course but to appreciate all the beauty around you in that perfect scene.

[@ronwalker403]

An absolutely brilliant movie. Probably my favourite cinematic creation of all time. I say this as a Canadian, too. Love this movie.

[@michaelhogard3394]

One of my all time favorite movies and this is a great analysis!! Nice job!

[@AllenChildress]

9:00 Identity is used as a synonym for "meaningful life" in some circles Trying to force an identity is as problematic as having none at all. It makes us narrow minded and withholds Joy. Even living within an established life, where you'd think one can build on themselves, it still can keep people in a depressive state. So how do we avoid this? Perhaps shedding off that past obsession with the image being chased. Maybe it's just relaxing. It feels good to indulge in nostalgia, and have the things at one point that you only dreamed of. ... even the things that made you feel guilty. Obsession often leads to new obsession, unfortunately, which can get out of hand - or inappropriate. Taking control of a shadow or mirror self seems great, but it involves so much turmoil. Yet there are those who live inside that state constantly, which is another way to try and escape these identity crises. But as stated, it creates a person that CAN be happy, and sees the things that other people take for granted, while on the other hand keeps them from experiencing full joy, due to their split. So if "too much understanding" at one time, has us getting obsessed with the new vision. Then only having it half the time, still has the person miserable, then wouldn't embracing it throughout life mean that's the way to live? Sure! But who's like that?? I mean there are going to be those who haven't taken that first step into their mold yet. But who would understand how to subvert this longing for meaning and identify, from the beginning of life? Actually, what even is this understanding that these "partially enlightened" are seeing? Joy from Beauty in the small things? What does that entail? Why is it important? Is there beauty in what's behind things? Enough to create meaning? Probably not. But ISN'T there joy in those things? Those small things, if they are meaningless ... only great to the individual. Simply, generically beautiful. Express forces beyond our control. Things we failed at. Are objectively sad, or just ... are. Isn't that something?? At least more than presenting ourselves for other people, in hopes that it exudes purpose.

[@AllenChildress]

Really impressive work, Sir! I am looking forward to listening to more!

[@Amyti]

Thank you for transcription :) I am French and I had difficulty distinguishing certain words!

[@AhFuhgettaboutit]

This is incredibly good and insightful. Anyone who really appreciates this movie like I do, should appreciate this video and commentary.

[@LBOOGIEDAMANN]

I loved this movie as a teenager. Watched it at least half a dozen times.

[@nelsondashner7758]

My favorite symbol in the movie is one that I never hear anyone discuss. It's not just the blood on the counter reflecting Lester's smiling face, it's the blood on the floor. It's an exclamation point. It's the punchline. Life seems important, but it slips away into a small puddle of liquid. TADA!

[@leahdorothy]

american beauty and american psycho are my two favourite movies so the fall out boy album is great haha

[@rheat9932]

Leah M cray cray! Nearly exact same as me and exact same top favourite movies 😂

[@staceyxtra1631]

May I request a movie, Lolita. It's one of my favorite movies, it's a bit of an odd movie. Glad to have found your channel.. (:

[@sksksk2940]

Stacey Xtra yasss just watched it and i'm so confused

[@lucynx1511]

This film reminds me of Lolita too!

[@RottenDoctorGonzo]

Which version? Irons?

[@robertpoole9786]

I think there is something red in almost every scene..

[@heyjonnyparke]

Your style is wonderfully unique. Please don't stop doing what you do so well

[@lalaland9069]

i just finished this movie and im crying an ocean 😭😭😭😭😭 i really feel so much for every characters. especially right now that im alone in quarantine and doing my best to be grateful everyday. omg i love this movie 😭

[@billwill7383]

Well this is late. But hope things are better for you these days.

[@kevinmalone29]

the way lester describes angela as “not ordinary if you tried” and the way angela fears being ordinary and boring reminds me of the rose from The Little Prince

[@kreep182]

The best moments for me is my morning cigarrete right after I eat breakfast. Sad but its true. All kidding aside, the video was amazing. The first time I wathced the movie, I was 15 and it blew my fucking teenage mind. Still is one of my favourite movies. And now that I am much older, it even has more meaning than ever.

[@josegamino5677]

Dude do eternal sunshine for the spotless mind

[@WhatitallMeant]

Maybe soon

[@josegamino5677]

you seen it trippy movie

[@andyquinones1762]

Great analysis - fun little detail: at 4:54 Jane is wearing a rose-patterned sweater.

[@JonPanDrum]

I love your videos. Some of the best videos on youtube. I learn so much about myself when reflecting on your words and these stories. Thanks

[@Boneidol82]

A wonderful movie. Explores the human frailty. Dysfunctional families and miss guided fantasies.

[@inmatejason]

Never enjoyed a movie as much as this one.

[@PrincessSquig]

My favourite film of all time

[@milkmedia1657]

Just watched for the first time , absolutely mind blown . Every shot and line just so perfect

[@Kedar4real]

this movie is a true work of art. really great acting by the cast

[@SimonVanliew26]

I dig the format. But man I have to watch these so many times to really get all the information I can out of them. You're really smart brother keep it up ✌

[@charlesderosas5577]

As a teenager watching American beauty got me through tough times. As a teenager I finally understood what this film meant. Initially when this first released I didn't understand anything.

[@bluemoo7611]

What does it mean

[@applescruff1969]

​@@bluemoo7611To put it into Layman's terms: Modern Life is Rubbish.

[@lukephillips7239]

This movie is such a pieve of art. There is hardly anything like it.

[@jerrygil1965]

This film was an AMAZING rollercoaster💜

[@weeeeoooow]

One of my favourite films! Lifting the lid on suburban lives and unleashing repression, insecurity and simmering anger. A masterpiece!

[@mandeloo9404]

This came out when I was 17 so the 90's were my "day" At the time all we wanted to do was be back in the 80's or 70's but I look back somewhat fondly at it. (I say somewhat because life as a minority back then was still a horror show) Life had more meaning, more purpose compared to today where everything is uncovered and it's mostly awful. We see the world as it is today, and it's hard to look.

[@hayseman]

You are the first KZbinr to take my suggestion. Thank you so much for that. This video was mindblowing! You hit all the points of this movie right on the head. The one thing that I didn't pick up on that you pointed out was how individuals are preceived by different people as in the case of Ricky. Perception also plays a major role in this film. It is clear how these characters define the world around them just on what they think about or want. I am so happy you took the time to research and make this video. Is this your longest? And also thank you.

[@mets23232]

My favorite movie ever. As I get older this film means more to me; I saw it in theaters in '99 when it was released. I was in my 20's. I'm now in my 40's and Lester seems more relatable to me, as does his relationship with his wife. This film is a classic. It has drama, comedy and makes the audience "look closer"...we all have issues and problems and are trying to navigate through life, relationships, parenthood, school life, work life, misunderstandings, etc. In the end life is beautiful, even with it's ugliness at times. This film has it all. An American clasic that is still relavent in 2018 and beyond. A must watch again and again and forever. An American Beauty of a film.

[@michaeljackson7732]

yes indeed

[@AAC4808]

Thanks for doing this. I always look forward to your videos. They're so insightful!

[@mdjones4]

I like the editing in this one, i know this movie had alot of stuff to break down, you did great

[@guillermogarcia6658]

i love your videos man ,seriously this channel is gold!

[@raalaa121]

The American western lifestyle portrayed in this film is completely different to the east / Asia.

[@fkcamry88]

Routine, searching for goals to make you happy and the plans for where you think you’ll be when you’re finally happy will keep you from living in joy.

[@NatalieD1]

I really liked your interpretation of this movie. I watched this movie many times, but it never occurred to me that it's about people's identity & life meaning. I thought it was about life in the American Suburbs. If you do 'a what it all meant video' on 'In the heart of the sea' or 'Life of Pi', it will be awesome.

[@WhatitallMeant]

I'm saving Life of Pi for a special time.

[@NatalieD1]

Can't wait! Who knows your channel will be so popular then, and Yann Martel might do an interpretation for your channel (like fight mediocrity channel). That will be awesome!

[@MARQ247]

Please do vanilla sky.

[@luciens7713]

Fantastic analysis! Great structure covering all bases in detail👍 Watched this movie for the first time the other day honestly blew my mind that a movie could explore so many themes so beautifully Cheers!

[@SviraSvi]

What an absolutely amazingly beautiful and meaningful film, thanks for the analysis :)

[@aurorerich]

The music works so well because it sounds so tribal. They use sounds of rain, birds, drums, moaning, steam, crystal. It's the opposite of the dull, planned, OCD structure of modern western life.