American Giant vs Flint and Tinder: Which Is The World's Best Hoodie?

* SHOP AMERICAN GIANT'S HOODIE: fave.co/3r6tYTs
* SHOP FLINT & TINDER'S HOODIE: fave.co/3r47l2f
* FULL ARTICLE: stridewise.com/american-giant...
So you've decided you're going to finally spend Real Money on quality - no more disposable, $30 Champion hoodies for you, you're going for the big time! You want the Best Hoodie and if you've been Googling terms like "best hoodie" you've almost certainly come across these two names: American Giant and Flint and Tinder. It's a battle of the over-one-hundred-dollars hoodies, which one comes out on top? Watch this and make the right decision for you.
00:00 Intro
00:47 American Giant vs Flint and Tinder's Fit
02:17 American Giant vs Flint and Tinder Materials
04:03 American Giant vs Flint and Tinder Price
04:39 Wrapping Up
#americangiant #flintandtinder #10yearhoodie #americangianthoodie #besthoodies

[@DancingSpacePotato]

The editing format with you switching hoodies when you talk about them is really great. But to be honest all this video did was tell me I should buy two more hoodies

[@Stridewise]

Hahaha this is a terrific comment

[@allsport916]

Truth.

[@philipbeadle6446]

I've been debating buying one of these Flint and Tinder hoodies for a while now, and I think this sold me on it. I'm an average height guy with a build more on the stocky side, so I'm a big fan of the straight up and down fit.

[@Camronlaz]

Another important note about them to consider is the styling beyond the fit. I chose the more traditional fit of the F&T but liked that it had a non-traditional styling with the raglan sleeves. It has sort of an instant classic feel for a piece of clothing, like you can have this hoodie for 15 years and it will always look good.

[@yabbadabbajr]

I admire how AG has revolutionized and upscaled expectations on what makes a high quality hoodie, but I have to say I much prefer the raglan cut of the F&T - IMO the raglan stitching flatters the athletic torso so much more. Thanks for the review, Nick…F&T added to my fall shopping list.

[@pherble]

Thank you for the review. I've got a few Carhartt but if one ever wears out, I'll look to American Giant.

[@gingebrien2408]

Great review. Appreciate the info. I haven’t decided which way to go as yet but I’m leaning towards American Giant. Cheers

[@aarondeancurtis2199]

Nice review! Thanks.

[@djswany85]

This is best picture and sound editing you've done.

[@dahak972]

I love the American Giant hoodie and I’m a big guy, like 30-40 lbs. overweight, lol. These are totally worth the price and look great as well. Great video!

[@joebuffaloe5418]

I just got the American Giant in iron grey. I like how big the hood is and the tight feel around the forearms and waist, kind of Assassins Creed. The tight feel is good under my motorcycle jacket, thick but it doesn't feel too bulky or bunch up. I would have liked the warranty of the other brand though. I was initially looking for brands made in the U.S. to spend my stimulus on so I went with the AG hoodie, Red Wing Iron Rangers (thanks to the Rose Anvil cut in half video) and a Benchmade Griptilian pocket knife and I have been thoroughly impressed with all of it. Honestly I wasn't expecting the hoodie to be as nice as it was.

[@Cemmos]

I lift/work out and I generally love when companies do athletic cuts. It's always a shame to have tightness in the chest/shoulders but then have a billowy looking midsection. In this case, though, that Flint & Tinder hoodie looks great. Maybe it's mostly because of the color, but I think it looks really good on you. Not that the American Giant one doesn't, but I guess they nailed that "classic" fit. Looks classic indeed. Love that warranty too, companies that back their products like that usually get my money. And I pretty much never need to utilize the warranty anyway, so good for them.

[@Tecton420]

Both are worth purchasing in my opinion if you can. I spent 2 weeks trying to decide which to get and ended up saying fuck it and got both. My Flint & Tinder basically lives underneath my Bravestar Ironside jacket, I found it was much better suited for layering than the American Giant due to the torso length difference. The American Giant is my go to when I don't feel like wearing 10 pounds of jacket lol.

[@frankb5693]

Damn, Nick, you look great in both! Sure makes it hard to decide which one to get!

[@sssnrrr]

I’ve had the Uniqlo cotton Pullover hoodie for three years - it’s bomb! Staple for sure

[@SpartanFarron]

Well, since you made the video, I dug out my AG again. I've been wearing my Uniqlo pile lined hoodie the past two months. I definitely miss the weight of the fabric.

[@parryhooper]

damn, I found your old video on AG comparison which didn't have the disclaimer that Black is not 100% cotton. I didn't even realize it even though it says it on the website too. I ordered already, oh well! I am sure it will be great.

[@jamesmontoban1338]

I love your black shades, i wonder if you would be open to doing a review on the best sunglasses at some point in the future, one love!

[@dahak972]

The best are the cheapest. 99% of all designer shades are all made by one company.

[@Stridewise]

Oh thanks, those are just Warby Parker ones haha. I just got some Oliver Peoples sunglasses too though which I like a lot: instagram.com/p/CMNSXHKFq1Z/

[@Stridewise]

True, SunLux dominates all.

[@treygreenleaf7878]

Very slick filming/editing with the seamless switching between Hoodies but using the same dialogue. Very cool

[@KT-cz7rm]

American Giants fit is fantastic. I bought a tentree for warmer weather and indoors. That's the most comfortable hoodie I've ever had.

[@littlebill1138]

Regarding American Giant's warranty: I'm an N of 1 so take this with a grain of salt, but I bought their Ultimate Hoodie five or six years ago. The cuff started to fray and even had a hole in it -- which is definitely NOT a manufacturing defect. But I gave them a call and asked about their warranty even though I had the frayed cuffs and they were so kind and said not to worry about it. -- they asked me what color and size I wanted for a free replacement and suggested that I either donate my frayed hoodie or to enjoy it and keep it. They just stressed to not throw it in the garbage. Your miles may vary on that but that's my personal experience. Full disclosure: I was a repeat customer (I also own their now-discontinued Mechanic's Jacket) and so maybe they knew that because I was in their system and were more inclined to be nice to me. But that situation made me a lifetime customer. Also, I donated the older hoodie to the Red Cross. And now I've bought two of their lightweight hoodies which are also incredible for very different reasons.

[@phrayzar]

I have noticed that most designs now have longer torso and looser waist band. It's very hard to find a classic cut hoodie. I have resorted to buying vintage hanes and fruit of the loom from the 70's.

[@jaeff4]

Really appreciate your videos. I've been considering both of these, but also hoping Brave Star releases a full zip version of their 20oz. Japan sure is making some interesting hoodies these days too. Cheers!

[@miguelsoliz772]

Which Japanese brands make good hoodies? Thanks

[@jaeff4]

@@miguelsoliz772 Neighborhood, Visvim, Bape, mostly streetwear and streetwear adjacent luxury brands.

[@jasonkelsey3441]

I have owned 4 AG Hoodies. I love the weight and feel. The big hood is amazing. However, every one blew out in the cuffs within a year. The main body of the hoodie wears very very well, but the cuffs are the weakest point. Two of my hoodies also had zippers fall off- but AG replaced with no hassle. I might go with the flint and tinder this time just out of AG cuff frustration.

[@BlaineD]

Me: Middle-aged guy. NOT into fashion. Pretty much a minimalist when it comes to clothing, in that I simply wear a rotation of a couple different outfits that work for the specific environment. Basically live in two different cheap box store hoodies. Decided to up my selection secondary to a zipper blowout. Found your video..... and it is perfect! Comparison, combined w/ nice editing, and factual data and experience. Great review - and now I'm going to pull the trigger on the F&T hoodie.

[@davepaek5014]

I'd love to see a review of brave star's hoodie

[@american_giant]

Thanks for the feature!

[@Stridewise]

Great hoodie guys!

[@jonuiuc]

I got the original ten year hoodie as a kickstarter backer in 2013, its two years away from making it the whole ten. Now the fabric is a little different from what flint and tinder are using now (it was 100% cotton) and the new cut seems a little tighter (looking at the flat measurements), the old one had a double raglan sleeves. But as long as the seems and material is comparably tough on the newer model, I don't doubt it can go 10 years too. I'd try the american giant moto jacket, but seems I'm the wrong shape for it (barrel shaped lol).

[@hookedonfishing2095]

So they are using cheaper materials…Easy PASS

[@Christopher_Stead]

Very smooth transition at 1:19!

[@Lgirtfhdzxfft]

Do a review on Carhartt heavyweight hoodie

[@serialseb2841]

Bit of a French Terry nerd and own about a dozen zip hoodies. As such I would Recommend Reigning Champion for your consideration. A runner up would be Naked and Famous.

[@Stridewise]

Thanks Seb! I'm planning on trying out Reigning Champ as well, maybe doing an ultimate comparison video. Hadn't thought of Naked and Famous, thanks for the rec!

[@robjackson606]

Hey man. You look good in a Large, how tall are you? I’m 5 9” 190 so a bit thicker, wide shoulders so M or L be a better choice in your opinion? Thanks!

[@k.1873]

Good video. I have American giant and you describe it well

[@HBeretta]

is the flint and tinder hoodie in this vid navy or black?...i can't tell, but like the color.

[@JerichoTheCity]

Did you record this video twice and just edit between the two takes? Neat editing 👌

[@Stridewise]

I did! One of my favorites :)

[@prod.deathwish]

the warranty for flint a tinder is what made my mind for me thanks for the video would've thought American giant lifetime would mean it covers tears but it doesn't lol

[@kevinleyva3003]

Been eyeballing the American Giant but ended up purchasing the Brave Star Glory Days hoodie instead

[@Pharto_Stinkus]

It is extremely disappointing that AG changed their warranty from "Anytime for Any Reason" to "within 30 days, if in like new condition" (effectively no warranty at all). I've switched to F&T 10Y hoodies for this reason. I like a good warranty.

[@The1Boone]

I'd love to see your opinion on Reigning Champ's hoodie too man! Great video as always!

[@Stridewise]

Thanks Wesley! Yes, Reigning Champ is next on my list. I also want to compare their sweatpants to Rhone and Ten Thousand, not sure if that's going too far in a different direction to the rest of the channel though haha

[@The1Boone]

@@Stridewise Sweet! I'd totally watch and support that too!

[@damancookedit]

I have both. If you're looking to stay warm outside and inside get the Flint & Tinder hoodie. It's soft warm and comfortable. American Giant is a rugged hard cotton inside & outside the jacket, it will not keep you warm in the lower 60s.

[@Stridewise]

Good tip re: temperature! I hadn't noticed much of a difference

[@damancookedit]

@@Stridewise being that I owned both it's definitely something I noticed. The Flint & Tinder is definitely warmer. I can throw a North Face jacket over it and I'm good in 40 something degree weather.

[@johno1104]

Hi Nick, great review. What colour is your AG? Looks light grey to me but i can't see it on their website. Not even in the special colours.

[@Stridewise]

Yeah I put it onscreen in the video: they don't make this color anymore/right now. Which is weird given it's the archetypal hoodie color! Bummer.

[@thedailyp00per]

What are your dimensions for reference?

[@IvanSergio1984]

I bought 3 American Giant size M and they all fit different.

[@mrchrisroden]

Ok, so I’ve tried both of these now and can confidently say: the Reigning Champ midweight is the grail and blows both out the water.

[@mrchrisroden]

Though, tbh, the heavyweight is quickly growing on me too.

[@regjarrett]

I have a new, unwashed F&T hoodie in size medium. It fits me perfectly out of the box. I sized down for a slimmer fit. I am concerned that it will shrink when I wash it and become too tight. How much can I expect it to shrink and should I send it back to get a large? Thanks. Enjoy your videos. Even the older videos like this, which I use as a reference.

[@Stridewise]

Thanks man! I didn't find this shrunk much at all, that's the pro of polyester it helps the garment retain its shape.

[@terry7441]

I have the American Giant storm hoodie. It's great but 100% sucks for lounging at home; therefore I really haven't worn since pandemic

[@brianh4625]

Agreed. And the plastic zipper sucks. Makes me wonder why it costs more than the classic, given that the classic is heavier and more over engineered (but crappy fraying cuffs)

[@ColinRichards1]

Where as i just checked flint and tinder they only habe S M and L. No XL No XXL No XXXL, No Xs

[@creepr524]

Do you ride motocycle?

[@billygowhoop]

I have both hoodies and I like the American Giant one better. I like the fit on the AG hoodie much better and I think the quality is a bit better. The Flint and Tinder hoodie feels a bit more pedestrian to me in terms of fleece quality and I wish it was a bit longer. It has a more relaxed, classic look. If you're a tall and thin guy like me, then I'd definitely recommend the AG hoodie. I'm 6'0" and about 130 pounds and went with a medium in both hoodies.

[@Stridewise]

Yeah I totally agree. The only thing is I tend to wear F&T when I'm just lying in bed because AG is so burly

[@charlesbronson240]

Bravestar 20oz hoodie

[@JohnEZang]

American giant is the bomb. Got one over the holiday and ended up with 3 now. The pullovers are my favorite. Have a feeling these are going to the grave with me.

[@burritosupreme333]

American Giant has won me over. My Flint and Tinder hoodie sits in the closet. Was not a fan, and it shrunk like crazy! I have 3 American Giant hoodies that I rotate and wear daily.

[@jessa.3857]

I hate to say this but I now prefer hoodies with mock necks. Much warmer especially when working out.

[@dismasjoseph7313]

Good video 👍👌😎

[@Stridewise]

Thanks for the visit Dismas

[@davidmcgowan1756]

Where do you get your henleys?

[@Stridewise]

Most of them are Buck Mason!

[@dcthomas2826]

I'm in the UK and bought a hoodie by Champion. It's fly.

[@watso014]

Don’t y’all call them jumpers?

[@dcthomas2826]

@@watso014 Hi. Lol. No a jumper would most likely be made out of wool like a cardigan but without buttons. ( Hope that makes sense.)

[@cesarsanchez9697]

My dude, Are there any quality hoodies made of wool? I would think those would last much longer and be more breathable.

[@davidlandrum]

Dehen 1920.

[@zman8340]

What I’m looking for as well

[@richardmckrell4899]

Carhartt

[@edtollway3730]

Do more stuff on watches, please.

[@Stridewise]

I've got a Vaer watches video filming but to be honest the watches space is super competitive so it's not really worth it lol, people don't see them

[@kalonaastepad6401]

Where in New York is a good place to get the Flint and Tinder hoodies?

[@Stridewise]

Just online I'm afraid!

[@kalonaastepad6401]

@@Stridewise shame. Thanks!

[@nlibby.268]

I only have the American giant and at first I really didn’t like it. I grew to like it though… I think… Or maybe I want to because of the price. I kinda felt like a flying squirrel in it at first, that v shape is weird in a hoodie, and the hood is crazy wide and oversized. My Carhartt and Dickies hoodies I enjoy more. Only thing I can say I absolutely love is the made in USA piece when it comes to these AG and 10 Year. Wonder if I’m the only one who thinks the hood is huuuge???

[@youngmc5040]

Does your American Giant zipper get really wild and squirrelly looking after you wash it? Mine doesn’t sit flat at all.

[@Stridewise]

No mine is fine!

[@youngmc5040]

@@Stridewise I wonder if it is because mine is the "mid weight" version and they used a different zipper?

[@stevemendez3535]

I do not like the fact that if you order something from American giant, you will not speak to a customer service agent and if you have problems, you cannot speak to a customer service agent.

[@aznlemonboy]

Review for reigning champ?

[@Stridewise]

In the works! Might be too warm out now though...

[@matt72543]

All I needed to hear was the torso comment, longer than normal torso here as well.

[@Stridewise]

corgi boys unite!

[@mrchrisroden]

Almost a year to the day I went down the Great Hoodie Rabbit Hole.

[@brianagee2790]

Lol. Those Google search results are fixed to favor sponsors. Love my 3sixteen hoodie.

[@Stridewise]

Haha as someone who works in SEO, results are not fixed. But you can put an ad up top of the page! But it's labeled as sponsored.

[@brianagee2790]

@@Stridewise There are SEO freelancers and experts available to hire to give companies a leg up on these search results and improve their ranking. That alone is a factor based largely on marketing budget and not primarily on quality of product. The search engine is not able to remain neutral because it's a system that can be understand and manipulated to benefit a company with higher resources. Those are my thoughts. Not sure if this matters. Guess I just have to jump in when I hear someone declaring something as the definitive best in the world. At least proud you found American brands as part of your reviews. Thank you for that.

[@matgougeon3087]

How tall are you?

[@Stridewise]

6ft

[@AAmtb]

"10 years"....they should clarify they probably mean "10 years on Mercury." This sweatshirt has torn cuffs, holes, and faded as F after 2 years. None of my clothes have holes/tears, not even my mountain bike and snowboard clothes which get abused on a weekly basis. 10 years at $100...please.

[@banker2787]

After wearing flint n tinder for a month, American giant wins. It's just warmer and more comfortable. Flint and Tinder gets bad over time. Color wears down and looks bad. The American giant I've had for over a year still looks intact and in good form. American giant doesn't get bad when you pull up the sleeve to the elbow area and doesn't fall down like the Flint & Tinder does. I'm a banker at a casino and the American giant one allows me to keep the sleeves up a bit so I can clear my hands. The Flint & Tinder kept falling down which was annoying.

[@watso014]

At these prices, I’ll stick with Champion

[@CASTRO45ACP]

The ten year is a good deal, if you're going to use it a lot that is.

[@MetalsForBrunch]

Flint and tinder all the way

[@mattceccotti]

pleaskeepbothstringsequallenght I am going nuts

[@marcdellorusso180]

It bothers me that Flint and Tinder use polyester in their hoodies. Especially when it's made with cotton grown in America... Keep it 100% cotton all the way.

[@darkodjogo96]

Hoodie is a hoodie, really I dont care which one it is. Unlike your boots and bags videos, where quality difference really does matter, this one, for me, makes no sense.

[@russianbeginner643]

I tend to spend more money on shoes, boots, and jeans because of quality but on hoodies budget friendly ones is enough for me.

[@RJRigs]

@@russianbeginner643 Liked your comment just because of the name.

[@TriniDaChief]

Thanks for the video but for God’s sake man even out the drawstrings PLEASE.

[@gamebred26]

I bought the American Giant hoodie and returned it immediately. No real value there above a standard made in China Kohl's hoodie. Ridiculous price for it. I buy American made boots...jackets...etc. but for a hoodie....I expected more. Meh..

[@c0r8d877]

1620 is better than these two. Made in America as well.

[@jameskaravias3148]

American giant are under sized and they have the worst customer service

[@Stridewise]

hm mine fits pretty welll, i think maybe they're just less baggy and more fitted than most hoodies, which lean slouchy

[@hookedonfishing2095]

Both hoodies are garbage! I only wear 100% cotton

[@Stridewise]

but American Giant is 100% cotton

[@Coldgecko]

What about sizing for a woman -- short and trim? Will either work?

[@Stridewise]

American Giant make women's hoodies!

[@pygmalioninvenus6057]

This video made me want to get a vaccine and vote for Joe Biden because love is love