American Political Scientist John J. Mearsheimer At Rising Bharat Summit 2024 | N18V | News18

American Political Scientist John J. Mearsheimer At Rising Bharat Summit 2024 | N18V | News18
American political scientist John J. Mearsheimer on Tuesday described India as an “aspiring great power” that is growing strength to strength in the geopolitical rivalry involving the United States, China, and Russia. Speaking during a session at CNN News18’s Rising Bharat Summit 2024 in New Delhi, Mearsheimer said that the United States was the most powerful country on the planet during the unipolar phase, which started with the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991 and lasted roughly till the mid-2010s.
#risingbharatsummit #news18 #cnnnews18
n18oc_news

[@UnitedAfrica-uw9ct]

I think INDIA will have to do a lot more than talk on forums , when the Chinese had a GDP as India is now they did not spend their time trying to get validation from anybody , they knew they were not there , NOW EVERYBODY in the WORLD ,Including the USA KNOWS THEY ARE There....when you reach a super power status the world will know even if you do not recognize it yourself.

[@user-bp3b5jt5z]

太对了，当你过早暴露自己的上进心，西方会找上你的麻烦。

[@realnapster1522]

India doesn’t seek validation. India seeks its rightful place 🎉

[@douglaswong6975]

Well said

[@SR-mj3hk]

There is nothing called superpower for an average citizen, all this show is to increase invester confidence for the markets

[@burung81]

They didnt even brag on their military or start any aircraft carrier which is a big toy for politician. Spent the money for infrastructure and school. Alleviate the extreme poverty in society, push everyone to middle class. Huge middle class is the key to superpower beside having large population..

[@joellu3645]

US fighting for Taiwan ? Don't make me laugh. It may use Taiwan to fight a proxy war in just the same way the West has exploited the Ukraianian situation, but the US and the West will surely not fight a real war themselves.

[@abhijits.g.6037]

Palki Sharma failed to secure an answer from Prof. Mearsheimer about India🇮🇳's prowess in geopolitics, but unfortunately have to bite the harsh reality. India has miles to go before becoming a VISHWAGURU. 😂😅

[@dr.ramurangila5344]

everybody is saying india WILL become vishwaguru..nobody is saying it IS vishwaguru So what's your point again?

[@read7641]

Cuz there isn’t any prowess. It’s a fantasy. Thats what he is saying but in a very nice and kind manner so Indian sentiments don’t get butt hurt.

[@biggpicture2930]

Vishyguru? , while pratising apartheid at home. You cannot have it both way.. The world will never accept india. It is complete fantasy.

[@user-vp6vf8wm2s]

India power? Great power? Get a reality check One day, not now

[@biggpicture2930]

Impossible for vishwaguru. Why? Hinduvta is being promoted inside India. It is a complete opposite to basis for a vishwaguru. It is an absolute incompatibility- watch the wire.

[@Jkl62200]

China rose quietly for 40 years. Indian is 'rising' noisily even at the learning how to walk stage. 😂

[@anunrealproduction1438]

It is claiming it's rightful place.

[@Jkl62200]

@@anunrealproduction1438 do first, claim after

[@user-if1vh8po2f]

@@anunrealproduction1438 Yes . . . At the BOTTOM of the Pit . . .

[@anunrealproduction1438]

@@user-if1vh8po2f we will judge from data.. India is on it's way up.. Presently your China is sliding into a pit of used cooking grease recovered from a sewer.

[@opedsk]

Not very quiet when you are bullying all your neighbours 😂

[@liewkinglim]

India is already talking like they are a hegemon power. ….Wonder how they will behave if they ever become a great power.

[@raysplam]

No worry...they never will.

[@SDFNI3894YR]

@@raysplam you really think a with 1500 million people who have education n democracy will not become world power?

[@burung81]

@@SDFNI3894YR yes, IF all are educated and united. that is big IF. More likely scenario, the more educated, the more division as each start to ask and demand more, no?

[@blahblah-yx7bl]

@@SDFNI3894YR what democracy??

[@aniruddhrajendran7570]

​@@raysplamDream on brother. Musk wants to build Electric Vehicle factory in India, we became a IT hub a few decades ago and Apple is building houses for workers in India. Your dream will be that just a dream.

[@wutangmuslin]

Mearsheimer is an offensive realist, not a defensive realist.

[@yeejlilys9742]

He just says what India does not want to hear.

[@ANGRYBIRD-8]

John Mearsheimer is speaking truth and of course he is a great scholar!!

[@darthvadeth6290]

India's GDP is slightly higher than the total combined GDP of sub-Saharan Africa. GDP per capita wise is is ranked 138 out of 191 countries. The bottom 30%. Even with India's GDP growing at 10% a year for the next 35 years in 2060, it 's GDP will still be the same level as China's in 2023, or the US's in 2015. India has never achieved a 10% annual GDP growth. The closes it got was in 1975, 1988, 1999 and 2021. Its average annual GDP growth historically had been between 3-6%. Let's say India's GDP growth averages 6% moving forward, it will take India close to 60 years to achieve China's 2023 GDP, or the US's in 2015. India is lacking behind in all technological indicators. I am talking about way behind. Today, China leads globally in 37 out of 44 crucial technologies. USA leads in the other 7. India leads in none. If sub-Saharan countries decide to consolidate into one union, will it be considered a superpower just by mere size?

[@wutangmuslin]

@@darthvadeth6290 definitely, India is going to shine, but that shouldn't distract us from the African dawn.

[@yeejlilys9742]

@@darthvadeth6290 India can reach whatever it sets for its goal of GDP growth simply by changing GDP calculation methodology. It has done this multiple times and surely it will do this again. Outside India, this smart move is called cheating.

[@kelanzhi7269]

can't this lady leave china alone?

[@xae1229]

you are watching too much this lady

[@johntong4453]

what mearsheimer is saying, put in simple words: India is growing, but far from being counted as a power, let alone a polar in this world.

[@FdvsHgerhh]

I don't know what nonsense you are talking about. As we all know, India's GDP exceeds that of developed countries such as Britain, which means that India is a developed country or a developed country.

[@johntong4453]

@@FdvsHgerhh gdp per capita at 2k+ USD, u r free to call urself a developed economy. bet u dont mind the world laughing.

[@LeoLeo-dn5fy]

Hahaha, Indians believe that India is a developed country, while Chinese believe that China is a developing country

[@realnapster1522]

He is an old fool. India is already a world power. Ukrainians, Russians, Americans everyone is courting India cause India is most important swing state in world. 🎉

[@realnapster1522]

@@LeoLeo-dn5fynice trolling. Insecure Chinese trolls 😅

[@photonics1]

very interesting how many times china is being mentioned in the talk 😂😂😂 and the backdrop is “rising Bharat summit “

[@aniruddhrajendran7570]

That is because he is discussing geo-politics for heck's sake 😠. The world doesn't work in a vacuum. What happens in China affects us. This is no longer the 1980s when we were closed economy. We live in an open world.

[@4tress300zx]

@@aniruddhrajendran7570 The Chinese Media doesn't talk about India. Meanwhile the Indian Media is obsessed with China, no matter what the topic maybe. Ridiculous considering the problems that the Indians themselves are facing within their own borders!

[@aniruddhrajendran7570]

@@4tress300zx The Chinese Media is not taking about its issues because it is a media controlled by a single political party that doesn't want to talk about its issues. Otherwise how is it that inspite of their property market being in near collapse such a thing isn't even being discussed. The issue with us Indians is looking for causes to belittle our own country just because we arent like others. Stop looking outside for inspiration. We are a 10,000 year old culture ourselves.

[@sachair2701]

this should have been a much longer conversation

[@user-if1vh8po2f]

"What about India?" 😅😂🤣 Yes . . . What about India? 😂😂😂😢😢😢

[@CarpsterKing]

To compare India with China is an insult to China..India is comparable with Zimbabwe.. Nigeria or Philippines.. China is on another level by itself..no other country can compare with China in manufacturing infrastructures..ports and highways, etc

[@user27455]

Hello bot. Say hi to xi. Heard he is not keeping well

[@jishe8957]

@@user27455 He was in good health, after all, he had never drank Ganges water.

[@user27455]

@@jishe8957 did he go to wuhan??

[@fengying-haoyunllianlian]

​@@user27455 Go eat steak 🥩

[@user27455]

@@fengying-haoyunllianlian bat steak?

[@mdrashid9882]

She is stuttering infront of professor like a child beacause it's not the studio where she just reading the script.

[@4tress300zx]

Exactly! She's just a mouth piece for Modi's Gov.

[@morningstararun6278]

That Shawarma lady got owned 😂😂

[@ABC-bangkok]

Indian superpower has just been shot down by Mr Mearsheimer.

[@saagnikpaul]

Mearsheimer's argument misses a very big point here. The US didn't abandon cooperation with China for containment because they saw China didn't convert to a "democracy". The best example is Japan. When japan in the 80s was rivalling US economically, they did the same to Japan and Japan hasn't been able to recover since. So this argument of democracies is a hogwash. Dont challenge america's economic hegemony is the only message out there. hence India should be very weary of getting too cozy to the US.

[@nagamanjunath2102]

I think Japan was past its prime and could never compete with the US economically apart from competing in specific sectors like automobile. Regarding India, what we are doing to the US is promising them to be a good partner in containing china. This is actually helping us get a lot of cutting edge tech from the US, jet engine deal a shining case in point, apart from the FDI and American / European business. We need to play this game until we are fully sufficient in crucial tech.

[@saagnikpaul]

@@nagamanjunath2102 read up about the plaza accords of 1985 and it's impact on Japan. And it will be quite foolhardy to believe that the Americans will give us any of the key technologies, be it in jet engines, or semiconductors. While I do not like the US, I also don't consider them to be stupid.

[@nagamanjunath2102]

@@saagnikpaul of course they aren’t stupid, that’s the whole point why they would want us to stand up to china. Because they see us as a “gun for hire” should things go kinetic for them with china. We need to ensure they keep believing the same. The jet engine deal definitely won’t be 100% ToT but it would be as much that would significantly shorten our own R&D and time spent in catch up to that tech. We can develop that tech on our own but time isn’t on our side. Semiconductor technology is currently a multi nation effort and will remain the same in the near future. Even the US is dependent on components that the Japanese and the Europeans make for the lithographic machinery.

[@saagnikpaul]

@@nagamanjunath2102 also while you read about the plaza accords, read up about the US domestic politics which took a similar hawkish turn towards Japan, where there was a very similar upheaval that they must decouple from Japan. Japanese electronics, Japanese cars, were burnt on the streets. So it wasn't a matter of Japan going past its prime. It was a very coordinated effort to pull down the japanese.

[@biggpicture2930]

Japan still have innovation capabilityy. Its education system is sound. India has minmal capability. Just no right foundaation even of now, so it is a fantasy in thinking india is on the way up. When you are on fantasy ground, you can only go on with fantasy. If you can drag yourself down back to the ground, then things will change. India is on a cloud.

[@Jkl62200]

Ms Palki 'China, China, China' Sharma is at it again. Obsessed with China. Lol

[@ChinaRedMan]

superpower india 2023 #111 in Hunger index #161 in Freedom Press index #126 in Happy index #139 in GDP per capita #134 in HDI index #148 in Women, Peace And Security Index #1 pollution 10% earn

[@user27455]

Bots are here? Say my regards to xi

[@irenechan7193]

China red man is an Endian !😂😂😂​@@user27455

[@yanfeizhu7953]

@@user27455India is number one . Are you satisfied?😂

[@clipwat1511]

Yeah, india numba one supa powa!

[@zhiyu1778]

India Super Poor 😅😂

[@KMuse99]

Sorry, the host is clueless. If this is the best India has to inform it's people, you guys are in big trouble.

[@nolita2011]

Almost as bad as the so-called anchors/reporters on US tv leading presidential debates.

[@lv9657]

Looks like India can't live without China but unfortunately China is 50 years ahead of india in all fields, economically, militarily, Politically.

[@gigimathew4031]

They had a 50 year head start.

[@user-if1vh8po2f]

@gigimathew4031 Both started on equal footing . . . But one had leaders too busy lining their own pockets, and it does not look like there's stopping anytime in the FAR future!

[@rogeryang18]

@@gigimathew4031 Not true. China was even poorer than India at 1970s.

[@jakew5987]

@@gigimathew4031 India had a head start than China, it was richer than China from the end of WW2 to 1980s.

[@gigimathew4031]

@@jakew5987 India was dirt poor after British Royals and East India Company stole everything from them and left them dry.

[@ankan1627]

They should have had a more intelligent host to talk with a person of the calibre of Prof Mearsheimer.

[@thecomment9489]

Yep but then that's perhaps the best they could bring to interview the Professor.

[@deepachakravarthy9619]

I cant agree more- no offence to Palki, I like her; but she is too soft.

[@prajithr2202]

There are numerous foreign policy experts in India. Palki is nowhere near them.

[@tylerpham1106]

I think she is the best for endia

[@Jkl62200]

India controls the opening of the Malacca straits!? Is that an Indian dream? 😂

[@kanubana8910]

That's a reality dummy 😂😂

[@user27455]

Xi dreams😂

[@rajnishkumar7084]

Meirshiemer is amazing social scientist

[@kannanmavila4093]

A shining voice of reason, Dr. Mearsheimer is IMHO

[@photonics1]

😂😂😂 what about India? people just care about china usa and russia again

[@michaelpattison8543]

Mearsheimer is absolutely right about Ukraine and Palestine but I think he’s totally wrong about China

[@fatdoi003]

mearsheimer still an american, he needs to protect his country's interest from china

[@tariqsyed9640]

Horrible interviewer ,

[@greentraveler4114]

The Inidians are not happy to hear American master didn't take it as great power. But certainly nationalist inidians still will make comment proud of being inidia while sitting slums searching for food scraps among trash piles. Here in Japan, most people believe America Russia China are the dominant great powers, Japan and Europe are playing important roles as well in shaping global order.

[@venkataramansubramanian9288]

American Political Scientist John Mearsheimer on Tuesday described India as an "aspiring great power" that is growing strength to strength in the geopolitical rivalry involving United States, China, Russia. Speaking during a session at CNN News 18's Rising Bharat Summit 2024 in New Delhi, Mearsheimer said that the United States was the most powerful country on the planet during the unipolar phase, which started with the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991 and issued roughly till the mid 2010s. Arguing from a realist perspective, he said the world today was a multipolar one where great powers are vying for dominance. "By 2017, Vladimir Putin had rescued Russia from the dead and Russia was back as the great power -- and China (too) because of all the economic growth that had taken place, during the 1990s and the first 17 years of the 21st century," said Mearsheimer during the session titled ;Geo Calculus' cracking code, the US expert said the world is now in a system where there are three great powers, namely, China, Russia, and the United States.

[@Samuel-ts5dh]

Palki Sharma, You didn't prepared well for this interview with Prof John Joseph Mearsheimer, the eminent political scientist.

[@henli-rw5dw]

@@scpython1 Well, those are her opinions. Not like she will change her views for him. He made her views seem shallow.

[@demonridera]

Palki Sharma is a mouthpiece who is somewhat pleasing to the eye. She has little wisdom, not much expected, not disappointed

[@thecomment9489]

She is never prepared. Doing too much of propaganda requires low IQ which she has.

[@SavarkarManeTikhapan]

So what if she is a mouth piece. She is a pretty mouthpiece😂. Long live BJP🚩​@@demonridera

[@Liboch]

Palki is good in glorifying the current government, everything in India is good.

[@nagamanjunath2102]

Really appreciate the honesty of John and the amazing clarity of thought he has got. This sort of pragmatism is seldom seen in Indian policy makers. Big lesson for India is to put this rubbish called “Vasudaiva kutumbakam” in the garbage where it belongs and start becoming a hegemon in the south east Asia first. Everyone respects hard power and that alone.

[@darthvadeth6290]

India isn't a South East Asian nation. It's not a great superpower either. It does not have the capability to become a "hegemon" in anywhere except within India itself. India's GDP is slightly higher than the total combined GDP of sub-Saharan Africa. GDP per capita wise is is ranked 138 out of 191 countries. The bottom 30%. Even with India's GDP growing at 10% a year for the next 35 years in 2060, it 's GDP will still be the same level as China's in 2023, or the US's in 2015. India has never achieved a 10% annual GDP growth. The closes it got was in 1975, 1988, 1999 and 2021. Its average annual GDP growth historically had been between 3-6%. Let's say India's GDP growth averages 6% moving forward, it will take India close to 60 years to achieve China's 2023 GDP, or the US's in 2015. India is lacking behind in all technological indicators. I am talking about way behind. Today, China leads globally in 37 out of 44 crucial technologies. USA leads in the other 7. India leads in none. If sub-Saharan countries decide to consolidate into one union, will it be considered a superpower just by mere size?

[@nagamanjunath2102]

@@darthvadeth6290 😂 I see your desperation to find a narrative that suits your bias. At least try doing a better job in fooling people by making your arguments more convincing even if you can’t back it up by facts.

[@darthvadeth6290]

@@nagamanjunath2102 you really couldn't counter a single point I made uh? LMAO good to know 👍🏿😂

[@nagamanjunath2102]

@@darthvadeth6290 Your points are so lame and so conspicuously misleading that even a person who is unaware of Indian polity can’t buy it. Only source of your info is “trust me bro” and backed up by nothing else 😂 Even to try to make a person like you understand, let alone counter with facts, is a not just a waste of time but also disrespectful for anyone. I don’t wish to drag myself down to your level just like how you’ve done with yourself.

[@darthvadeth6290]

@@nagamanjunath2102 the statistics I used in my points are public data published by each country itself and accepted internationally 🤣

[@vedprakashmevada6741]

Typical Americanism. Power power power and power. America will not last long.

[@Vp27364]

That's how the real world works

[@thecomment9489]

​@@Vp27364 You mean that's how the real world works in the West? Like colonialism, imperialism, slavery etc..

[@biggpicture2930]

America won't last long India won't last long China won't last long

[@RasvonKoo]

Well isn't that what India is crying about every day even it doesn't have it? No offense to my indian friends 😂

[@biggpicture2930]

India is more obsessed with power that India can only dream of

[@SurinderNagi-yw6qn]

Sir, WELCOME TO OUR COUNTRY!

[@user-vp6vf8wm2s]

The QUAD? sounds like a QUAKE QUAKE 🦆🦆🦆🦆🦆🦆🦆 One difference, it's a sinking one

[@wongjerry520]

🤣🤣🤣

[@jameswong07]

India gdp was 2.1 trillions in 2014 , 3.5 trillions in 2023 , an increase of 1.4 trillions over the past 10 yesrs . Whereas china achived 9.65 trillion in 2014 and 18 trillions in 2023 , a 8.35 trillions increased over the past 10 years . India should humblely learn from its neighbor China .

[@yashkumar3196]

U never heard of compounding??

[@max-cs9ko]

He has literally predicted Ukraine's war and west is responsible for this situation long time before start of Russia Ukraine war in a college lecture, that video literally went viral after start of war, it's really great to hear from such a knowledgeable person

[@prasad5621]

Very Great Man..👍 🎉🎉🙏🙏

[@shevashevasheva777]

Palki Sharma is useless lol

[@Monkey341]

India only aspiring but can never be! Oops!

[@sinalbertckwong6406]

...is this a RISING BHARAT SUMMIT or a WANT-TO-RISE BHARAT SUMMIT? 😮😮😮😮😮 John:'....although I'm visited here and you paid me a fee and all my expenses, but I have to disappoint you, my bad.

[@vichua1052]

Mearsheimer does not want to offend his host. So he said India is a aspiring power although he knows it is still a long way off.

[@TheLargeoldshoe]

mearsheimer burst the bubble on the “india superpower” playbook of almost all ruling parties in india. India will never be considered a superpower unless 1. Technologically self sufficient 2. GDP exceeds $10000.00 (or whatever the equivalent is when you measure) 3. Currency widely used to settle (atleast 10-15% of world wide transactions excluding india).

[@dr.ramurangila5344]

nobody is saying india IS a superpower lol

[@RasvonKoo]

You forgot about industrialization. No country can become a great power when it needs to import the majority of its weapons

[@aadilansari5997]

Hello Idiot it is GDP per capita of $10000 .

[@realnapster1522]

It’s already a superpower. India doesn’t need certificates from anyone. 😅 China is afraid of rising India. Russians, Americans, Europeans all of them want India on their side. What does that tell you?

[@hongqi5734]

India is an aspiring great power but will it ever become a great power is quite different. 😂

[@probasket8159]

Amazing

[@Hypocrites-507]

Palki is piss when John Mearsheimer say India is not a rising superpower ?? According to the world expert India is ranked like Japan Germany Canada n etc Indian going cry over 20+ years until India ranks to become superpower ??

[@fatdoi003]

india is like those honorary oscar award recipient.... never good enough to win a real one but still craves for recognition

[@earthtothe9791]

I don’t understand India so desperate for recognition, it is not there, majority of India military are still imported, don’t be fooled by India military spending , then you think India is 4th most Powerful, a lot of it weapon are overpriced, UK,France,Germany, and Japan these four can edge out India any time they want.

[@yanfeizhu7953]

The glass heart of the Indian host is broken.

[@JIANGTG]

Wait and see. Truths and facts always speak louder than words ....

[@systemspro1239]

Great perspective offered by Mr J Mearsheimer

[@mohamadazamabdullah4191]

Professor was kind to say 'aspiring' when it is far from it. 4 things will confirm this: lack of water resources, climatic change, over population, garbage generated. Can this country survive using a copy and paste davalapment of other countries.

[@padmakumarvadhyar7656]

First learn to spell development correctly.

[@sureshchandra-wd2bv]

And who is responsible for uncontrollable rising population?? Ans is peaceful community......They Cannot grow in any field except population to please Allah 😮

[@mohamadazamabdullah4191]

@@sureshchandra-wd2bv All are marrying without thinking of the consequences. There is no legislation. Can't blame the peaceful community solely. Do some introspections.

[@mohamadazamabdullah4191]

@@padmakumarvadhyar7656 Never try to correct somebody's language which is not English. This is a foreign idiotic language imposed on others. That is why Dravidians fully oppose any foreign language.

[@realnapster1522]

Chinese trolls are desperate. Using Muslims names here. 😅

[@h79guf]

No open q&a? Wow!

[@h79guf]

They got him as a filler to add value to their speaker lineup but wasted away. Seems like they were not interested, just checking the mark.

[@hugodiazgarcia1266]

Congratulations for your video with American Politica Scientist John Mearsheimer, expert on international affairs and the increasing importance of India, mainly in the Indo-Pacific Region!!

[@desiputtar89]

Don't trust whatever the Americans say.

[@pubguc6771]

What is in world rules regulations law not available ?

[@shubhamdhali9473]

Good initiative by news 18👏

[@shuklaz]

The no of ads on this channel is horrible

[@kaushalpakhrin9131]

Host should be neutral not propagandaist like palki

[@DineshTwanabasu]

Absolutely right. Palki is a $$ paid propagandist to spread anti china propaganda.

[@redline5003]

Acha bhai ravish kumar ko bol de vo kr dega host

[@Jodoe243]

Palki asked WHAT ABOUT INDIA????

[@directorofficer8565]

What about India what do you want to hear what do you expect to know? Just walk outside of your home and see it for yourself!

[@Jodoe243]

WhaT?????????@@directorofficer8565

[@johnabuchi5830]

Palki my number 1 news caster in the world is this your new platform?

[@kz0927]

赞 from wforum

[@dennyli9339]

Palki has a market positioning: Indian patriot... Hence, she can't have in-depth question... That is : "Elevated view".... same to USA host and chinese host....

[@swamivas2089]

It is wrong to consider as special India being special as a QUAD member! On the contrary, it has had hardly any positive impact!

[@CarpsterKing]

India is a.junior follower.in Quads ..US (.leader ) UK..Japan.( Ally ) .India ( junior follower)

[@tedchandran]

Jai Hinduja. We Indians are the Risen power.

[@user_uif_ghg_wer_das]

It's so funny during the first question when the Professor was talking the background screen flashes several times "Rising Bharat**". It's like yelling "India, India, India is the superpower".

[@msomayya2828]

We don't want to be a great power we want to have a good life for our people

[@blahblah-yx7bl]

your indian host does not think so

[@larryhongkham694]

Palki: HOW ABOUT INDIA

[@paulmatters2641]

LOL

[@deepachakravarthy9619]

The background is too loud and distracting; could have opted for something more subtle

[@ansa336]

Exactly!

[@user_uif_ghg_wer_das]

It reminds people constantly "Bharat is rising".

[@swamivas2089]

in America the election process is in a super mess with the current president, also referred to as a lame duck, apparently facing impeachment!

[@bashayk8170]

This rime with all due respect the professor was excessively controversial. He even forgot the BRICS role and future internal and external developments that will affect the present situation. But my thanks goes to courageous people like him even though today for some reason was not his day❤.

[@sudiptasamaddar8149]

There is no science in politics so the term political scientist is absurd. And India doesn't need western validation. The people and the government know very well what they are doing.

[@IndianArma]

Brainlet comment

[@rahuladduri6562]

Palki sharma got belt treatment 😂

[@menghuakin8574]

India is rising, and will become world power in the coming years. Let's be Humber, not noisy, rise in style, be good nearbor to Asian countries and not be double headed snake to the West.😅

[@paulmatters2641]

I completely understand India's position. I am an aspiring billionaire. Lets go.

[@kmich7660]

Aspiring?? Shouldn't it be already?

[@nmew6926]

26:50 John Mearschimer : "... If China collapse like Soviet Union rest assured US will point its guns to India..." Palki reaction : ".... Pakistan...." 🤣🤣🤣

[@bluewaters2231]

altho a palki fan, didnot feel this was her best. anyine agree ?

[@fahadali-kk2bs]

isn't it the anchor and india both looked a bit screwed...

[@user-jm4td9le2f]

BARAT RISING IS AMBARAST THEMSELVE WITH BARAT RISING.//

[@choisamwon2344]

Aspiring great power ! India should support America and cut its interest from Russia.

[@catinbootsnow4267]

Like what Ukraine has done? 😅

[@yestomor7673]

And act as Ukraine?🤡

[@blahblah-yx7bl]

it is a polite way to say indian is nothing

[@Qiushishuo]

When India, US promise one China policy, there is always no credit. What a ridiculous world.

[@tylerpham1106]

Where are the proud to be ENDIAN now

[@rickzeng1882]

I am deeply puzzled by John Mearsheimer's logics. He claims himself as a realist, and then he has his opinion on how the US establishment should handle Russia and Ukraine, and he is well aware that his opinion is not adopted by the US establishment; on the other hand, he has his opinion on how US should deal with China and Taiwan, in particular, fight for Taiwan if China adopts a military approach for the unification, and he is still 100% confident that the US establishment will act as he wishes...not to mention he has ignored all the facts that the US pulled out from Afghanistan and did not send troops to fight for Ukraine. As a realist, can he tell wishes from reality? LOL...

[@hrduan7674]

I think John's logic is highly consistent. The question is not whether the U.S. government is willing to adopt his opinions, or even the opinions of a large group of people, but how strong the government's willingness to go to war is. Obviously the U.S. government’s willingness for war is quite strong. Since it is willing to encourage and sponsor Ukraine, which is not so important to its strategic interests, to go to war with Russia, it is very likely that it will directly participate in the war in the Taiwan Strait, which is extremely important to its strategic interests. Yes, I think this is John's thinking logic.

[@user_uif_ghg_wer_das]

John, this is your last time to appear at "Bharat is rising", "Bharat is rising", "Bharat is rising", understand?

[@ahmadbhatti4875]

It is a shame to have such an erudite guest and sort of a propagandist IDF spokesperson type host whose only reputation is talking points. Before india becomes a major power it should have some nice TV hosts:)

[@pubguc6771]

Social media group of general scientific globally peace

[@MJTUEN]

India's aspiring great power = LOL LOL LOL

[@oki_0074]

Your opinion is = LOL LOL LOL 😂😂😂

[@biggpicture2930]

Aspiring middling power, but guest tried to please delusionals

[@Rav01508]

A superpower is defined as a country that has the ability to project power and influence around the world. USA's 800 military bases and China's 151 BRI member countries are some of the examples. Not to mention having veto powers at the United Nation. Indians are of the opinion that india is today a global superpower, which is ironic since india can't even influence its neighbours Sri Lanka with regards to visits by chinese vessels. Worse, Maldives want india and indians OUT ! A WANNABE SUPERPOWER WITH NOTHING TO SHOW FOR.

[@jorgarb]

@@biggpicture2930 We will see.

[@biggpicture2930]

​ @jorgarb I am seeing India down in turmoil.

[@shakeelfaisalkakkayzaimali1335]

Palki tried hard to put her tongue in John's mouth but could not succeed. But succeeded in getting the historical dishonoured 

[@kocheng176]

This must be another big joke of the year !!! Ha ha ha

[@aadilansari5997]

After Ghazwa e Hind Hindistaan will be the superpower. Muslim are great soljer and Hindu can work for muslim to produce food, build house produce car ..

[@techystt]

93k great soldiers. 😂😂😂

[@StraightTalkMaverick]

They are so scared of the opposition alliance I.N.D.I.A , they had to name the show Rising Bharat instead of Rising India. Godi Media at it's best... 😂😂😂

[@scorpiorules]

Yeah, very scared of an alliance that broke apart before it took off 🤣🤣 Must be hard coping with reality when the real Godi media has filled your head with so much propaganda 😃😃😃😃

[@realnapster1522]

Nobody cares about this alliance. They have no chance of winning 😅

[@StraightTalkMaverick]

@@realnapster1522 That's true because the Fascist BJP government has media in its back pocket.

[@user27455]

Nice to see so many Chinese here. We play cricket with bats here😂

[@Qiushishuo]

Too silly

[@jishe8957]

The Chinese are also very happy that Indians can temporarily stop participating in rape, stop drinking the chemical-filled Ganges water, open their eyes to see the world, and listen to the voice of civilization.

[@DULENSHK]

Now, let welcome this boy from “rising Bharat”👏👏👏, is India a super power 🥹? Nah😬

[@user27455]

@@DULENSHK 1000 social credit from Hong Kong ccp govt for that insightful comment

[@DULENSHK]

@@user27455 we don’t need that, boy, face the reality, hear the wise man saying about what your country is. Mouthwatering won’t made your country a super power.

[@birkaransingh6392]

The russia ukraine war

[@lingeng2659]

At the end, John Mearsheimer is arrogant also.

[@harry-zm2vi]

John is speaking the truth. America always take out any near number 2s. India will face the same challenge when it surpasses China.

[@biggpicture2930]

But India wants to be NO 1

[@AnAn___]

I think there is a difference between liberal free democracies and other countries. The USA needs India with respect to the global commons, global organized crime, islamism, Xi, fighting global wokeness. This won't change any time soon.

[@weimingfeng2284]

@@biggpicture2930India already the NO.1 in their imaginary world 😂

[@bz6626]

never mind, India will never surpass China

[@morningstararun6278]

@@AnAn___ 😂😂😂😂 Amoorikkans and most definitely Indians, never give two focks about democracy. If Amoorikka really cared about Democracy, then why did it overthrow the democratically elected Socialist leader Salvador AIIande? Why did Amoorikka support radical Islamists against Gaddafi? Remember, Libya during Gaddafi was the richest in all of Africa. Take a good look at Libya now. And Amoorikka needs India to fight global wokeness? 😂😂 Idiot, Amoorikka and India are the hotspot of global wokeness. I live here in India, and I have seen the woke crazyness. As a matter of fact, Amoorikka supports India and Israel for promoting wokeness. You don't see such a stupid, meaningless woke movements anywhere in China and Russia.

[@gourighosh4167]

Since my childhoog I heard India is growing. Now, soon I will die but India did not develope . What real India is we still have exactly same colonial. state machine . India never had freedom .it had transfer of power from Brits to its collaborators. No country can develope with colonial exploiting system. Only politicians and few rich people are benificiary. Our consolation is we are better than Pakistan. None of the Government here really did much to address basics . China good or bad you like it or not does not take orders from others ,do not talk much , work hard.Above all mobilised their masses.

[@tedt5588]

India is so poor that i dont know if they will ever be a great power.

[@elihazaelgarciatoledo5912]

Mearsheimer is a neorealist by the way

[@jonathankwo1658]

Indio is already a super power

[@saugatalahiri7287]

He is big shit, the world’s best Universities study him

[@DK-ev9dg]

Only in the west. I don't agree with him on China at all. He is clueless about power and greatness of China

[@karnatheempire6789]

Palki 🎉

[@paulmatters2641]

Poor Palki. No India is not a great power. Bwaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah

[@vedprakashmevada6741]

Please dont call these overrated scholars to your programs.

[@askeladd60]

underrated

[@devasharma5478]

yes you are right….he failed go recognize that ancient aliens are with india and only india has access to the gaumutra technology🤓

[@dr.ramurangila5344]

​@@devasharma5478 no bro you're right this 20th century relic is neo jesus 😂 zelensky definitely gonna stop fighting after listening to him 🎉🎉

[@biggpicture2930]

Call pravin Sawhney

[@biggpicture2930]

@SatpalVer8000 That is why the Pravin Sawhney's book is titled "The last war". @SatpalVer8000 2 hours ago (edited) @biggpicture2930 India would di-sintegrate in war with China just like Pakistan d-isintegrated in war with India. We Sikhs Kashmiris and north east nations been waiting for that war and jump in, like Mukiti Vahini of East Pakistan (Now Bangladesh)

[@sk61186]

Nepal, Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Bangla desh should listen to the professor. India will have to do a Ukraine if pushed to a corner.

[@breezeanonymous6034]

Name a country in South Asia that was created by a British trading company. That country is hated by all the countries mentioned in your comment.

[@MuhammadRidwan-pe7ny]

no maldives ?

[@dr.ramurangila5344]

​@@breezeanonymous6034its pakistan you po rki 😂

[@Rav01508]

A superpower is defined as a country that has the ability to project power and influence around the world. USA's 800 military bases and China's 151 BRI member countries are some of the examples. Not to mention having veto powers at the United Nation. Indians are of the opinion that india is today a global superpower, which is ironic since india can't even influence its neighbours Sri Lanka with regards to visits by chinese vessels. Worse, Maldives want india and indians OUT ! A WANNABE SUPERPOWER WITH NOTHING TO SHOW FOR.

[@Rav01508]

Countries With Highest Prevalance of Child Wasting 2023 (percentage of children below the ages of 5): 1. India🇮🇳- 39% 2. Yemen🇾🇪 - 24% 3. Sudan🇸🇩 - 23% 4. Mauritania🇲🇷 - 17% 5. Sri Lanka🇱🇰 - 13% 6. Mauritius🇲🇺 - 12% 7. Bangladesh🇧🇩 - 11% 8. Niger🇳🇪 - 10% 9. Syria🇸🇾 - 10% 10. Djibouti🇩🇯 - 10% 11. Mali🇲🇱 - 10% 12. Indonesia🇮🇩 - 10% 13. Burkina Faso🇧🇫 - 10% 14. Comoros🇰🇲 - 10% 15. Malaysia🇲🇾 - 9% 16. Cambodia🇰🇭 - 9% 17. Maldives🇲🇻 - 9% Source: WHO World Nutrition Report 2023