American Questions Muslim On Free Will In Islam! Muhammed Ali

Support Me and The Channel:
www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted...
/ themuslimlantern
Follow me on Social Media:
/ chainless_slave
/ chainless_slave
/ themuslimlantern
00:00 - James Joins
02:33 - Problem of Evil
07:01 - Evolution and Islam
11:49 - Doubts vs. Questions

[@TheMuslimLantern]

Brothers and Sisters! Don't forget to Like, Comment and Share the video to help us reach more people so you can share in the reward in sha Allah! Support Me and The Channel: www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=9NUGVQNWSZHEY www.patreon.com/TheMuslimLantern

[@AdrianMuslim]

💗

[@nashbash_]

Maybe it can help, Al maidah 5:48

[@draconainlady]

Jazaaka'allahu khair for your great content. I came back to Islam after 15 years of absence alhamdulillah. Your videos are really helping strenghtening my faith, as I also have a very scientific mind.. Is there any video where you talk about your backround and how you came to be the person you are today? I'm really curious!

[@ahmd05208]

the brother could have given a more convincing answer/explanation of free will. so let's start .. Allah(the one and only true god ) is all knowing I.e he knows the past, present ,future, every conditions etc . everything is under Allahs control. literally everything is decreed by Allah. for example Allah may decree I pass my exam based on my action/conditions. for example if I study I pass the exam if I don't study I fail the exam , this is the general rule , but sometimes what happens is even though I give my 100% I still fail , why? because Allah decreed so. Allah is all knowing all wise ,he is the best of planner so I don't get sad because I gave my 100% and it was the decision of Allah the almighty all wise all knowing . Allah knows the future he knows if I will study or not , but I don't know the future ,I don't know if I will pass or fail so I have to study and give my 100% then if I pass, alhamdulillah all praise is due to Allah , I don't give credit to myself because nothing happens generally or usually it happens by the will of Allah . if I know the future that I will be failed then of course I will not study. the concept of free will is that allah knows and we humans don't know . so if we don't know the future then we take action by our own free will and we are responsible for it . hope it helps

[@thebesttruth4659]

..Pray for innocent Muslim Brothers😔Sisters all innocent family😔😔😔😔in PakistaN Pakistan stop kidnapped and killed innocent😔😔😔family May Allah protect innocent 😔family in Pakistan,,, 😔😔Free BalochistaN😔😔

[@KHABIB-TIME]

*“Take advantage of five before five: your youth before your old age, your health before your sickness, your wealth before your poverty, your free time before your busyness, and your life before your death.” - Prophet Muhammad ﷺ*

[@Daynite786]

Hmmm pretty interesting concept

[@flamecsm4679]

⁠@@Daynite786then you should read more about the Hadith of the prophet Muhammad pbuh. You will be amazed 👍🏻

[@rimesherif5775]

Read the Quran as well​@@Daynite786

[@pearlsof5534]

@@Daynite786 this is what the teachings of prophet Mohammed peace be upon him are- please read his Hadith but most of all read the Quran where the greatest miracles can be found

[@Cbari92]

Salaam. Can you recommend me a hadith?​@@flamecsm4679

[@fahadshaikh9099]

Muslim lantern should be posting more of these vids. His content is simply amazing with his calm demeanour

[@abdouahamada8122]

I can not agree more 🙌

[@Laleeeeeee271]

I agree but he also has a private life

[@sosoma32]

dude knows how to keep us in suspense

[@arcader54tdbank55]

@@Laleeeeeee271 true

[@chains84]

quality over quantity my bros

[@abdouahamada8122]

I’m always so excited when people are sincere and come up with questions like this. They are beneficial for all of us inchaAllah

[@Abd-al-Qadr]

"nO iTs NoT mY mAnHaJ iS ThE MaNhAj" too much of this going on. Your comment is the energy we need. Eager to learn. Thirsty for correction and critique

[@Bodrul1]

*inshaAllah

[@hamzanabeel8347]

If you read this say alhamdullilah

[@7625e]

Alhamdulilah

[@farhaanidrees13]

Alhamdulillah

[@MohamedAhmed-lc6ch]

Alhamdulilah

[@lovelyday6500]

Alhamdulilah

[@-NWJNS-]

alhamdulillah for islam

[@faisalwho]

I have so much respect for people like this individual. Humility and genuineness are very admirable qualities

[@crongo4284]

A merciful God needed a sacrifice to forgive? A sacrifice to forgive a sin that we didnt do which is unjust on us? I will stay in islam the true religion that doesnt need atonement for forgiveness, but sincere repentance to a merciful creator. Alhamdulillah

[@crongo4284]

So youre telling me that God cant forgive anyone directly but he needs to sacrifice his innocent 'son' to do so? Thats limited forgiveness + thats atonement even not forgiveness. The 'son' did not even know he was gonna be 'sacrificed'. How is that merciful? Why cant you repent directly to God and be forgiven? Isnt that fit for the most merciful? May Allah guide you.

[@crongo4284]

im telling you thats not forgiveness thats atonement

[@crongo4284]

So the Most Merciful, the Most Forgiving, cannot forgive without blood? Alhamdulillah for islam, where Allah, the truly most forgiving and merciful can forgive without blood of an innocent human being, letalone one of the most noble messengers (Isa عليه السلام). ۚ إِنَّ ٱللَّهَ يَغْفِرُ ٱلذُّنُوبَ جَمِيعًا ۚ إِنَّهُۥ هُوَ ٱلْغَفُورُ ٱلرَّحِيمُ Indeed, Allah forgives all sins. Indeed He is the most Forgiving, the Merciful (Quran 39:53).

[@crongo4284]

So taking an innocent person, and forcing all sins on him is "just", and not being able to forgive without punishment is "Most Forgiving" Ezekiel 18:19-20 “Yet you say, ‘Why should the son not bear the punishment for the father’s iniquity?’ When the son has practiced justice and righteousness and has observed all My statutes and done them, he shall surely live. The person who sins will die. The son will not bear the punishment for the father’s iniquity, nor will the father bear the punishment for the son’s iniquity; the righteousness of the righteous will be upon himself, and the wickedness of the wicked will be upon himself. How can God contradict himself?

[@muksumularafin7798]

may Allah guide this brother to Islam. Very beautiful brother. Watching from Bangladesh.

[@safwanshahriar4108]

আসসালামু আলাইকুম ভাই

[@fightingdreamer8681]

Ameen

[@HxH-to1xh]

May Allah bless him and guide him to Islam

[@Kuschiwawa00]

@@lord.jesus.christ.followerno

[@halim997]

I'm addicted now to Muslim lantern videos, upload more bro 😂

[@Hiba.07]

Same alhamdulillah 😂

[@Yousmine]

Me too

[@tuberoses..]

Idk why but I am binge watching it..better than watching fitna😅😅

[@rosidssoy]

same bro 😀😀

[@_ibnmuhammad]

@@tuberoses..Same! May Allah make us benefit from the brother, and may Allah make us witnesses for him on the day of judgment that he may benefit from us at that time.

[@arditqerasaj2897]

The American guy seem sincere and thats a good sign . In Shaa Allah he get guided. Our brother Muhammad Ali jazakhallah khair and Allah SWT rewards you on highly scale. Keep up the good works

[@RightSauce]

My excitement everytime he drops new vid. 🥰

[@wiamcyrine]

I was born muslim, but still, i listen to these kinda videos only bc I'm learning a lot !thank you, brother ali

[@kitetsu77]

May ALLAH guide him to the truth and remove all his doubts.

[@mohamedhanad339]

Assalamu Alaikum to my fellow Muslim brothers and sisters, and hello to everyone else watching this video. I've just finished watching the video and I wanted to share a summary of the key points discussed. The video discusses free will, evolution, and doubt in the context of Islamic beliefs. The brother explains the Islamic perspective on these topics and emphasizes the importance of certainty in essential beliefs. The conversation provides insight into Islamic teachings and addresses common questions and misconceptions. 00:00: Journey to Islam and Grappling with Free Will 00:14: James shares his journey, including receiving a Quran unexpectedly. 02:36: James discusses his struggle with understanding free will and God's responsibility for evil acts. 04:03: Understanding Free Will and Determinism in Islam 04:03: Determinist, libertarian, and compatibilist perspectives exist in Islam. 04:26: In Islam, there is one true idea of free will, but heretic beliefs also exist. 05:53: The concept of free will and determinism is fundamental and applies to all, regardless of religious beliefs. 08:05: Differences in Evolution Theories and Islamic Perspective 08:06: Different theories of evolution are not universally agreed upon in the scientific field. 08:43: Islamic perspective rejects the idea of humans evolving from a single cell organism. 11:29: Rejects the concept of randomness and doubts in Islamic belief. 12:09: Understanding Doubt and Certainty in Islam 12:23: Doubt in Islam is different from having questions. 13:05: Certainty in essential beliefs is crucial in Islam. 13:30: Levels of certainty in Islam: belief, seeing, and experiencing.

[@Lololololhhhh]

Thank you

[@Assyaroni]

Masya Allah Barakallaahu feek brother

[@not_mybrother7705]

Walaikum salaam brother. Jazakallah for taking the time to do this.

[@vgmms]

most people don't like to listen to long conversation even if it's only 15 minutes but this helps anyone who likes to skip some. thanks

[@abdirahmanessa7406]

Jazaka Allah khayran Akhi

[@jamesash461]

I really look forward to these videos Please keep posting brother.. May Allah Bless u

[@monotheistmedy]

Very sincere brother who came to discover listen reflect instead of arguing for the sake of arguing ❤. May Allah bless him , guide him , and lead him to his mercy.

[@Truth_Seeker-79]

Please come back as we would love to have you as a brother in Islam! 🌺

[@ZackCali]

Bois wake up! Muslim lantern posted a new video!

[@halaali8547]

Peace and blessings be upon the prophet Muhammad.

[@user-hy9it5dx6q]

عليه افضل الصلاة والسلام

[@klaas2597]

I can tell this young man is sincere and has a open mind. May Allah guide us all to the straight path.

[@amine_dubs]

Brother reached 300k Alhamdulilah. 1M إن شاء الله

[@chouaibkharassi4254]

I would love to be in contact with brother James. He seems sincere and very passionate in his curiosity. I love when conversation goes with this level of respect. BarakAllahu fik brother Mohammad for your videos. I’ve discovered your page few weeks ago and you really get me to feel like I want to do Dawah as well in a close future. May Allah guide us all, fill our hearts with faith and good intentions, our mouths with good words and our hands with good deeds. May Allah protect our brothers in Palestine, and the oppressed all over the world. 🇵🇸

[@itzmewaleed]

Assalam o Alikum Allah Bless You Brother Ali ❤

[@nadjibe]

What a nice dude, you can tell his sooo genuine and asks questions with confidence without an agenda behind it except learning. Amazing my Allah guid him, and my self too

[@mennasoliman4438]

جزاك الله خيرا

[@cond.oriano9533]

i get very happy when i see your notification

[@Lonewold.]

May the One who Created Everything Guide brother James to Islam, May we meet in Jannat Al Firdaus Aameen Ya Rabbul Alameen

[@chinesecovidanalswabs4752]

Ameen

[@AbuOmarP]

Jazak Allaah khair brother. Keep up the good work

[@hero4963]

Bless him hes so sweet ma sha Allah may Allah guide him to Islam

[@elizarehan2309]

I really enjoy conversations like this☺️Alhamdulillah

[@djemba]

Thank you!!!!!! I needed to hear this today!

[@7625e]

Mashallah. Love to see this. May Allah (God) guide James to Islam AMEEN!!

[@Hiba.07]

Ameen

[@leedswindowtintsjay7995]

One of the best knowledgeable person in islam to date mohammed ali may Allah reward you brother such a nice person how you explain everything

[@nailafarzana9038]

May Allah guide him

[@Invisible_man4]

Amin

[@SaadMuslim20]

Thank you Brother mohamed for dawah May Allah bless

[@osamak123]

JazakAllahu khairan @ Muhammad Ali

[@sadiajahan6712]

I watch one message Islam. Its also quit good. MashaAllah. May Allah bless you all. Keep up the good work!!!

[@Daynite786]

Alhamdulillah I admire our brothers knowledge and wisdom, very excellent,I as a Muslim learn a lot from all his vid. May Allah swt keep u blessed bro.

[@NervDisturb]

This could be one of the greatest episodes!! God bless you both

[@jackryder6732]

This man said it right, the way how things are made and how complex, they are that itself is an evidence of one creator. Allah May Allah bless him and guide him

[@NՓԵhing]

JazakAllahu khair

[@user-jh8re2yj4k]

Ramadan ✨ is coming ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@EXHINDU_PRO_INDIA]

Your from brother

[@NՓԵhing]

May Allah guide us all to Islam Ameen

[@Invisible_man4]

Ameen

[@Invisible_man4]

Alhamdulillah

[@Invisible_man4]

❤❤

[@Invisible_man4]

🎉🎉

[@Invisible_man4]

JazakAllahu khair

[@kamui8663]

As selam aleykum

[@2jz99]

: للمعلومية اذا قرأت اية الكرسي بعد كل صلاة الفرق بينك وبين الجنة الموت

[@user-hg9gh5fo6e]

عقيدتك كعقيدة النصارى

[@Fortheshows]

May Allah reward you and grant you the highest level of Jannah , I have forgotten yet you’ve reminded me

[@user-cb5md6lx9g]

جزاكم الله خيراً

[@HemsK-zl7xm]

Amazing keep on bro. Much truth to be found.

[@Invisible_man4]

Alhamdulillah

[@user-yp3gi7cy3n]

جزاك الله خيرا وبارك الله فيك

[@Invisible_man4]

MashaAllah tabarakAllah

[@sutil5078]

Also many people assume evil has no side benefit, 1. without evil no goodness to compare to, so we would not know what is goodness 2. even in economy sometimes little short correction (depression) is necessary to correct itself.. 3.. even in natural disaster, it may unify the survivors and make them help others, for the humans who did not make it, it raises their ranks in the next world (if they are believers) and change the heart of evil doers because some of them may return to God seeking help!! for oppr/ essors they face justice, etc etc etc May Allah protect all of us. Amin

[@hid4768]

Destiny is the secret of Allah in His creation. Whatever Allah has revealed to us in His Book or on the tongue of His Messenger, we know and believe in it, and whatever Allah is silent about, we believe in it, in His perfect justice, and in His profound wisdom, and" He is not questioned about what He does, but they will be questioned"

[@env0x]

it is so interesting hearing the different ways people get guided to Islam. everyone has such a unique and interesting story. yet i can still somehow relate to all of them on some level.

[@vortexvampire]

بارك الله فيكم... اللهم اغفر لوالدينا و ارحمهما و اجمعنا معهما في الفردوس الأعلى مع الأنبياء و الشهداء و الصالحين و جميع موتى المسلمين.. اللهم احقن دماء المسلمين و انصرهم على من عاداهم.. رب إني مسني الضر و أنت أرحم الراحمين... لا إله إلا أنت سبحانك إني كنت من الظالمين..... . ..................... .

[@omarhaider7885]

Honestly Out of all the people who spread Dawah on the internet Muhammad is the best man his manners, Etiquette, Logic everything Subhanallah

[@ahmedadawy1238]

May Allah bless you brother Muhammad Ali

[@user-wx6zr3tz9y]

These questions and answers benefit me a lot as I learn each time more and strengthen my beliefs.

[@MichaelMezger-dx6bc]

Masallah the nour on the Brother Muhammad Ali s face !!!! Love from Turkey and Germany ❤

[@idrissbenabbes1284]

May Allah reward you and us with the highest Firdaous with no judgement.

[@Invisible_man4]

Alhamdulillah for Islam

[@muneermalay1]

Assalamualaikum. Alhamdulillah. What a beautiful discussion. May Allah SWT continue to guide you so that you my soon be a muslim brother. InsyaAllah

[@xxghl]

Congratulations 300k subs 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉 شاهدين لك لا عليك 🫡

[@historian3290]

MA. Always cool, calm and collective.

[@freeman7983]

Baraka ALLAHU fik

[@nailafarzana9038]

Alhamdulilah

[@AdrianMuslim]

Good discussion.

[@truthseeker2306]

Assalamualaikum Jazakallah Khair

[@AnsafHussain01]

❤ Great Useful

[@jonese9854]

Hi Muhammed Ali, I’ve been following your vlogs for a months now. And I admire the clarity of teachings you shared about the quran also I’m a christian, also I try a lot of religion, searching for the right religion, thirsty for learning about the word of God and starting again to read bible also I read quran. It is a gift from my friend and I don’t know if it’s a good version. It is english translation by Abdullah Yusuf Ali. I wanted also the one that you’re giving maybe it’s a good version. because some english word is not in good translation. Also someone share it to me that in the bible in revelation 22:17 that Jesus and his bride. Another one that I don’t remember they share that we know we have father, they say we also have a mother? Just want to know about your thoughts about this. And I want to gain knowledge about it. I respect any religion. I love also the teachings of the muslim. I also believe in 1 God. It is very helpful for me if you can answer this. I hope you can notice my comment. Thank you for the lesson as well! 😊

[@sounku7147]

''Saheeh International '' is the most recommended translation by brother Mohammed Ali👍

[@jonese9854]

@@sounku7147 I don’t know where I can buy Quran. before I was living in UAE now I’m back in PH. I’am starting to read quran since the english translation is not good I can’t understand some part.

[@Rhim96]

You are welcome to come when ever he is doing the stream bro, you can ask any questions to him to learn about our religion,

[@jonese9854]

@@Rhim96 I’m a sister. I put already notification alert on my phone. The problem is the time zone different.

[@sounku7147]

It is available online sister, and for understanding reading the translation isn't enough, u need to read tafseer (explanation book) and the one recommended by MA is "Tafseer al-Saadi" as it is simple and can help u as a beginner❤️

[@zzzxxx7294]

بارك الله فيك

[@AspiringGuitarist100]

Thank you for these amazing videos. Inshallah Allah SWT gives you health, and the ability to continue dawah and receive reward for it.

[@rizkyramaputra6962]

brother Muhammad i really love your content it has peaceful in it make me feel like relax listening to it

[@bee2373]

First word revealed to The Prophet (pbuh) was ‘Read’. A call to action. Allah wants us to read, study, and learn! It helps to cast doubt, ignorance, etc. Read the entire Qu’ran as the first step. Blind faith is not good, but neither is excessive questioning. Secondly, I’ve been looking into quantum computing and physics. It’s a way of solving complex problems faster. I think of how incredible Allah is, The Originator of the Heavens and Earth , to know everything at all times, the past, present, future, and He Knows what decisions we will make. Allah has the ability, unlike us, but we continue to make advancements in science, computers, technology that people of the past would think it was magic being used.

[@ayanokojisenpaionce3092]

جزاك الله خير

[@zahidmuslim6560]

Subhanallah....Alhamdulillah....Allahuakbar

[@mohamedshahin3316]

May Allah guide him ❤ and all true seeker ❤

[@tamarabrown6347]

Amin ! Keeps on teaching us !

[@hasan3step570]

Wow the free will determinism question has been one of my biggest struggles in my journey and he is 100% right i never thought that this problem is not unique to islam at all and id have to grapple with it no matter what creed i follow. I may have to do more research on determinism in islam for my mind to rest on the issue but this information was like a sigh of relief for me. The problem didnt go away in my mind but i honestly can not blame it on islamic doctrine. I just never could get past the idea that if god its truly all knowing then even if he gave me a "choice" the fact that he knows what i will chose would essentially mean that IF i chose the path of hell, well then it would stand that he created knowing i was heading for the hellfire with my choices. So why create me in the first place if he KNOWS im going to make the bad choices? This is the only real problem i ever had with islam but in reality it is a problem that exists under every creed.

[@Yaas90]

Great questions from James!

[@NՓԵhing]

Alhamdulillah for Islam☪️️☪️️

[@Invisible_man4]

Alhamdulillah

[@Invisible_man4]

SubhanAllah

[@Invisible_man4]

MashaAllah tabarakAllah

[@Invisible_man4]

JazakAllahu khair

[@Invisible_man4]

BarakAllah feek

[@FarhanaFaruq]

Masha'Allah

[@nahid2281]

Amazing Allahumma Barik.

[@s.a.9600]

Leave that which is Doubtful and act upon Certainty, and the doubt will eventually become clear, Insha 'Allah.

[@seriously235]

So essentially pick and choose the religion?

[@shagg9204]

​@@seriously235he never said that 🤦🏾‍♂️

[@FarhanMehmood]

@@seriously235 Where did he say that?

[@say_aashnaa9302]

He was one of the nicest people on the streams i really hope he becomes Muslim ❤may Allah guide him❤

[@Rhim96]

This is old video, we wanna see video that recently 4 new shahadah take on the stream, please upload it brother Muhammad Ali,

[@sgyoldman9582]

Thanks

[@fardosaabdi1960]

300k Mashaallah ❤❤❤❤

[@truckdriver5979]

This is a genuine brother may Allah guide him.

[@taufiqrl]

Very sincere brother, may Allah ﷻ guide him to the straight path

[@myxos]

Brother James if you're around, feel free to get connected with me. I'm in Minnesota and I'd be happy to speak with you.

[@tugbabulut2106]

Man! Allah literally knocked your door not once, not twice but tree times. How lucky you are ❤

[@yavuzsabuncuoglu]

Great video 😊

[@SoothingNasheeds]

jazakallah khair

[@ahmadazfar968]

James, we cannot fathom Allah’s wisdom. however i read a concept before, in order for you to recognise good, you have to recognise evil first. not always the case for everyone. just like when we want to recognise happy, we must know what is sad first or to know fragrant we must know pungent first. the hot cold phenomena. cold is just the absence of heat(hot). hope this helps my brother

[@TH-oo9ww]

"why did God throw us straight into the hell fire, he didnt give us a chance. I would have been real good"

[@nisahmed9121]

Watch The Purpose of Life - Jeffrey Lang. He struggled with your same thoughts before converting to Islam !

[@GG-09]

Keep up your work brother Muhammad ❤. May Allah grant you Jannat al Firdaus.

[@pioneer5555]

Great questions and great answers

[@AlaaAhmed-on2rh]

May Allah Keep us affirm on the truth!

[@diligoscientia]

May Allah put certainty in your heart, Ameen.