Ammar Nakshawani FAILS to Prove 12 Imams from Shia Sources

  Рет қаралды 20,884

Farid Responds

Farid Responds

Ай бұрын

Пікірлер: 775
@FaridResponds
@FaridResponds Ай бұрын
Shias watching this video should set a time limit for themselves depending on how much time they have. Do you think it is reasonable to find evidence for each of the Twelve Imams in a week? Two weeks? A month? Set a reasonable limit and force yourself to find an answer within that time. If you are unable to find sufficient proof, then I invite you to the path of the Prophet (peace be upon him).
@bishaarsabtow
@bishaarsabtow Ай бұрын
الله اكبر
@HA-td3uw
@HA-td3uw Ай бұрын
Spoilers: You won't find any credible/sahih narration at all with the names of all imams. There I saved you all the trouble imposed on you by Farid. Follow Mohammed ﷺ and his companions as you were ordered in the Quran. :)
@bishaarsabtow
@bishaarsabtow Ай бұрын
@@HA-td3uw 🤝
@A.A471
@A.A471 Ай бұрын
You may have made some good points that I can’t question, since I don’t much about the narrators. However, all 11 Imams were murdered. Some were imprisoned, most were poisoned and one of them was massacred at Karbala. Can you explain why they were murdered? Because the way I see it to that question is there are two logical answers, either: a passionate hate for the Ahlulbayt, due to association with the Prophet SAW or because those 11 men were important and there is a deeper reason as to why Ummayd and Abbasid caliphs would spy on them until they’d have them poisoned. Also if it’s not these specific 12 men, then it must be another 12 men, according to Sunnis Hadiths as well.
@IbnSalama-ok2os
@IbnSalama-ok2os Ай бұрын
Farid: Avoid these self-appointments, where the Imam is appointing himself. And if the Imam is asking for one-fifth of your stuff, then that is sus. Mohammed (pbuh): I have been appointed as Prophet. And btw, the war booty is for Allah and me (Quran 8:1). One-fifth is for Allah and me.
@IrfanAhmad-uv4ul
@IrfanAhmad-uv4ul Ай бұрын
Ammar nakjawani cheerleade incoming.......😰 3......2......1.......
@TheFaro2011
@TheFaro2011 Ай бұрын
Shocking, can't even take him to someone's house for a marriage proposal
@Umar2O00
@Umar2O00 Ай бұрын
Inb4 "I am a sunni muslim but........"
@RoofingConnecticut
@RoofingConnecticut Ай бұрын
If the imams have knowledge of everything up to the hour then they must know when the hour is since the hour would be as soon as they no longer possess knowledge
@IrfanAhmad-uv4ul
@IrfanAhmad-uv4ul Ай бұрын
Allah(swt) said in the Qur'an that he alone have the knowledge of the hour
@RoofingConnecticut
@RoofingConnecticut Ай бұрын
@@IrfanAhmad-uv4ul yes of course but I’m saying if the Shia position is the 12 imams have knowledge of the future right up until the hour then it stands to reason they know the hour is right as soon as their knowledge of the future ends, they’re making the assertion that they know the hour by default
@SkillsFx
@SkillsFx Ай бұрын
This in itself is shirk and no longer is Islam since ALLAH ALONE has all the knowledge (past, present, future) because if these so called imams also have the same knowledge Allah no longer remains a necessary being
@ghul8158
@ghul8158 Ай бұрын
According to quran, a man bought the Palace of sheehah before Prophet Sulaman blinked his eyes. He outshone the strongest jins. Please explain how an ordinary man not a prophet can do this? are you saying tis man wassuperman?
@RoofingConnecticut
@RoofingConnecticut Ай бұрын
@@ghul8158 which verse are you talking about
@darkdr1fter
@darkdr1fter Ай бұрын
Islamic "scholar" with his whole body full of tattoos 🙄 This is why I don't take Shi'ism seriously 😑
@justsomeone8899
@justsomeone8899 Ай бұрын
Maybe he had them when he wasn't religious
@JohnJohn-tn3lc
@JohnJohn-tn3lc Ай бұрын
​@@justsomeone8899apparently it's makrooh in shiism
@Abd_Allah_1445
@Abd_Allah_1445 Ай бұрын
@@JohnJohn-tn3lcno they consider it halal, Sistani said it. But I think the tattoes got more while he got more religious
@Deeneda
@Deeneda Ай бұрын
And when people can't prove you wrong they target your appearance. 😂 where's your evidence of tattoos being haram?
@Abd_Allah_1445
@Abd_Allah_1445 Ай бұрын
@@Deeneda Islam
@IrfanAhmad-uv4ul
@IrfanAhmad-uv4ul Ай бұрын
Timestamps- Some superpowers of "imams" • 2:10 imams have knowledge about past and present •2:29 imams have access to angels •2:43 imams know when the previous imam dies •4:28 imp. 6:50 1st "proof" by nakshawani problems- •isnad problem(ibrahim bin hashim being weak narrator) •muhammad jawad is appointing his son as the imam but the problem is jawad's imamah is unproved So if he appoint his son as an imam it means nothing 9:54 second "proof" by nakjawani Problems- •al barqi's books predates al kulayni's book al kafi by 50 years and it gives the same report but it only mentions 3 people instead of 12 It seems like al-kulayni fabricated everything.i.e the report is fabricated Most probably,Al barqi has the original report with only 3 imams and al kulayni just filled the gaps •this report has been reported by Al Jawad himself (at 15:41 )
@Spined1234
@Spined1234 Ай бұрын
What's funny is that we have multiple Shiee hadiths in which people would come up to the Imams and ask them who the next Imam is or if there even will be another Imam. If they already had access to a hadith which states the 12 imams by name then it makes no sense why they would ask the Imams these questions.
@gr3en_jamfatima295
@gr3en_jamfatima295 Ай бұрын
I think you forgot to use a brain when you wrote this.
@Spined1234
@Spined1234 Ай бұрын
@@gr3en_jamfatima295 Nah but you evidently forgot to use yours when typing out your rebuttal. Ja’afar Al-Sadiq, in two separate narrations, says that the Imam does not pass away until Allah tells him who the next Imam will be. (Al-Kulayni 1/166) Why would he need Allah to tell him who the next Imam is if there already was an authentic hadith with all 12 imams mentioned in it?
@gr3en_jamfatima295
@gr3en_jamfatima295 Ай бұрын
@@Spined1234 bro what are you talking about? Are you saying there was an authetic hadith existing during the time of the Rasulullah SAW where all 12 imams are listed by name? Prophet muhmmad already said Ali is your maula, then from Ali (as) he said who the next maula will be and so on. And only Allah appoints his leaders
@Spined1234
@Spined1234 Ай бұрын
@@gr3en_jamfatima295 Maula is not Imam. Nobody at the time of the Prophet peace be upon him understood "Maula" to mean divinely appointed infallible imam. And no, there is no authentic hadith from the Prophet peace be upon him in which he states there will be 12 divinely appointed infallible imams starting with Ali.
@gr3en_jamfatima295
@gr3en_jamfatima295 Ай бұрын
@@Spined1234 yeah maula means friend because Prophet Muhammad saw stopped everyone at khums in the heat just to say Ali is my friend, and Ali is your friend. Everything the Prophet SAW says is by the wishes of Allah and Allah SWT had commanded him to say infront of everyone that Imam Ali (as) is your leader. You guys think anyone can be a religious guidance of the ummah. No sunni can consistently tell me how a leader is appointed. Some say it's because abu bakr lead prayers, others say the ummah decide amongst themselves like a democracy and others argue that Prophet Muhammad SAW told abu bakr directly.
@seamus4055
@seamus4055 Ай бұрын
Why does he speak like that lol
@LayLoow
@LayLoow Ай бұрын
He drank a redbull can 🤷🏽‍♂️
@agp4580
@agp4580 Ай бұрын
You should hear him speaking about george floyd, look it up and have a laugh
@anime_joy
@anime_joy Ай бұрын
He turned off the comment section on his video :D
@shaks1903
@shaks1903 Ай бұрын
The you ask me "excellent excellent question" always gets me😂
@ashifhassan1148
@ashifhassan1148 Ай бұрын
Why do these Shi'a guys have a same way of speaking? I don't like the way they speak.
@ManhaJSalafee
@ManhaJSalafee Ай бұрын
They speak with nose
@babahadjimohamed9339
@babahadjimohamed9339 Ай бұрын
​​@@ManhaJSalafeeSalam alaikum when someone clicking on your channel, Un-Islamic things appear, especially with the name of your channel that does not match it. Advice, remove it for known reasons. If I could advise you secretly, I would do so, but this is not available to me at all.( subscriptions)
@abasinnazimshah4598
@abasinnazimshah4598 Ай бұрын
they speak with tajweed or something
@babahadjimohamed9339
@babahadjimohamed9339 Ай бұрын
@@abasinnazimshah4598 probably the Iraqi Accent
@Last2LP
@Last2LP Ай бұрын
I don’t like the way you speak either
@user-op8fg3ny3j
@user-op8fg3ny3j Ай бұрын
Infallible leaders sounds is how Christians ended up worshipping Esah as. Even rasoolullah made mistakes ('he frowned') etc.
@ponderingspirit1475
@ponderingspirit1475 Ай бұрын
Frowned?
@alhomsiyyah
@alhomsiyyah Ай бұрын
​@@ponderingspirit1475 see tafsir of Surah Abasa
@robasuca645
@robasuca645 Ай бұрын
@@ponderingspirit1475hes referring to surah abasa Number 80
@tam3133
@tam3133 Ай бұрын
That was uthman who frowned not the prophet stop the lies
@alhomsiyyah
@alhomsiyyah Ай бұрын
@@tam3133 why are you lying?
@bishaarsabtow
@bishaarsabtow Ай бұрын
May Allah keep you sincere. Great work once again. I have to download this video because it feels like it could be taken down for how truthful it is 😂
@mohammedowais6682
@mohammedowais6682 Ай бұрын
I think it's high time someone focused on Nakhshwani, please continue this brother Farid
@malaminekamara4079
@malaminekamara4079 Ай бұрын
@sunnah_discourse also has great videos on Nakshawnies "Islamic" series which is him lying for hours
@IrfanAhmad-uv4ul
@IrfanAhmad-uv4ul Ай бұрын
Honestly,He doesn't worth time
@mustafaal-dabagh9155
@mustafaal-dabagh9155 Ай бұрын
@@malaminekamara4079 everything he brings is truth alhamdullalh and all the sunnis are becoming shia
@safiyayuichi6553
@safiyayuichi6553 Ай бұрын
April fools is in a few weeks ​@@mustafaal-dabagh9155
@MegaAcoustic
@MegaAcoustic Ай бұрын
​@@mustafaal-dabagh9155 congratulations on your victory 😂😂😂
@JohnDelVentomusic
@JohnDelVentomusic Ай бұрын
I crossed paths with him during his time in Hartford. He was the “cool Imam” during the height of the interfaith dialogue era. He used to do a lot of “well, these terrorists are actually Sunnis, let me tell you about Shi’ism” routine”. He has gotten very popular
@Last2LP
@Last2LP Ай бұрын
He’s not wrong about that
@mustafaal-dabagh9155
@mustafaal-dabagh9155 Ай бұрын
wait are the terrorists not sunnis? did he lie or smth?
@sania6
@sania6 Ай бұрын
​@@mustafaal-dabagh9155 terrorists are not sunnis they're wahhabis, hence out of the fold of islam
@heromahdi
@heromahdi Ай бұрын
@@mustafaal-dabagh9155 yea they arent sunnis, they are wahhabis.
@mustafaal-dabagh9155
@mustafaal-dabagh9155 Ай бұрын
@@heromahdi bro he keeps deleting my comments it’s funny 😭😭
@gongkong-oi7qx
@gongkong-oi7qx Ай бұрын
Shia pagans are coping very hard on this one.
@amjadqureshi4622
@amjadqureshi4622 Ай бұрын
The 12er Shia concept of Imamah is similar to the Sikh concept of Guru.
@HR-313
@HR-313 Ай бұрын
Yeah not even close
@amjadqureshi4622
@amjadqureshi4622 Ай бұрын
@@HR-313 I acknowledge there are differences. However here are the similarities: Both schools faced persecution against Sunni imperialism. Both schools have a divine appointment concept which is unique and cannot be traced in history. Imam is a term used but historically there are no Imams like the 12. Likewise Guru is a term used before but there are no Gurus like the 10. In additions there were some other Ahlul Bayt who claimed Imamate and declared kaffirs by the Imamis. Likewise within the Sikhs members of Guru line always claimed there they are the Gurus. They too are condemned by Sikhs. In the 5th Guru's time the oldest son of the 4th Guru claimed he was the Guru. For 12er Shia Imam Jafar disowned his son Abdullah for Imamate. The strange part it some Sikhs believe in Guru Gobind Singh will return. Likewise the 12ers are waiting for the Mahdi' s return. Lastly Sikhs have a Guru that became Guru before baligh. This is the 8th Guru. Likewise the same case with 12er Shias where some Imams became Imams before baligh. Likewise one of the Gurus also disowned his son for claiming to be a Guru.
@isafcb312
@isafcb312 Ай бұрын
Nice to see you and a few brothers teaming up to disprove the nonsense these Shia spread, nothing but speculation, conjecture and conspiracy, of course the bots will defend them regardless but may Allah reward the Muslims fighting to defend the truth
@Girly1026
@Girly1026 Ай бұрын
“Nothing but speculation, conjecture, and conspiracy” while he’s using the Sahih books lmaoooo so you’re saying your own Hadiths are nothing but conjecture, conspiracy, and speculation? Got it
@unbornfoetus8166
@unbornfoetus8166 Ай бұрын
May Allah bless you!
@respectthemanthatchangesfo760
@respectthemanthatchangesfo760 Ай бұрын
Thank you Jazak Allah ghair 👊
@user-gt3oo1qg3h
@user-gt3oo1qg3h Ай бұрын
Umar ibn al-Khattab (ra) reported: The Messenger of Allah (saw) said, “Verily, among what I fear most for my nation is every hypocrite with a knowledgeable tongue.” (Musnad Ahmad)
@adammalik196
@adammalik196 Ай бұрын
May Allah bless you Farid, an excellent concise video that should get all Shias thinking. May Allah guide the sincere shias to the truth
@ZainAli-st6sh
@ZainAli-st6sh Ай бұрын
Bro is waffling on a regular basis now. SAN has him so rattled he’s not even making sense anymore
@JamieDelour
@JamieDelour Ай бұрын
Looks to me Shia's are rattled, multiple comments on this video but no answers? he kindly asked you to reflect on your own books, your own evidences, instead your focus is here on the comment section.
@syed2194
@syed2194 Ай бұрын
“Waffling” lmao 😂 that’s all Nakhshwani does
@great87
@great87 Ай бұрын
May Allah guide to see, speak and accept the truth. Bring evidence or accept Islam upon Sunnah.
@salmanfarook5133
@salmanfarook5133 Ай бұрын
Why do I see the comment session watered with Shiai tears?
@anascalligraphy
@anascalligraphy Ай бұрын
Salam, Can you make a video on 33:33 and that um salama hadith and wether this ayah speaks including the wives or not? Ive seen sunni interpretations saying both. Or point me to a video that does. Jazakallah khair, i appreciate all the work you do
@gehadqaki
@gehadqaki Ай бұрын
Incredible work Masha'Allah brother. This knowledge is paramount for us to know.
@thecriterion-718
@thecriterion-718 Ай бұрын
Well Well Well, the supposed hadith about 12 imams is a clear rip off of Hadith Jibril , word to word event to event albeit with Shia taste 😂
@achraf9946
@achraf9946 Ай бұрын
Verse 1:5 of the Quran is more than enough to disprove those Mushreqen
@sammirzad
@sammirzad Ай бұрын
And surah tahrim is more than enough to tell you aisha and hafsa were mushreqen 😃 66:4
@achraf9946
@achraf9946 Ай бұрын
That Verse don't justify the Shirk of Shiasm@@sammirzad
@HR-313
@HR-313 Ай бұрын
​@achraf9946 but you follow whom Allah condemns. How cute. Infact you take your whole faith from her ❤
@shinmonbenimaru91
@shinmonbenimaru91 Ай бұрын
Is your mother available for mutah? I heard she takes 15$ for 3 Days lol.
@anonymous.1238
@anonymous.1238 Ай бұрын
First prove that umar Abubakar n Usman where not mushrikeen then come n tell us....the one who said quran is enough for us went to saqifa to elect a Khalifa if quran is enough y the hell u went to get selected
@adenmir5852
@adenmir5852 Ай бұрын
In the original Hadith it also says Islam will triumph under the caliphs (notice how it’s caliphs and not “spiritual leaders”) and even according to them their “imams” did taqiyya which was mainly practiced under the oppression of Quraysh.
@samy7013
@samy7013 Ай бұрын
Ask Twelver Shi’is the following: 1) Were Abu Bakr (RAA), Umar (RAA), and Uthman (RAA) legitimate Caliphs after the death of Rasool Allah Muhammad ﷺ? (They’ll probably say “No!”) 2) Was Islam triumphant during the tenures of Abu Bakr (RAA), Umar (RAA), and Uthman (RAA)? (They’ll probably say “No!” yet again.) 3) So was Ali (RAA) the true Caliph from the moment that Rasool Allah ﷺ died? (They’ll probably say “Yes!”) 4) So was Ali (RAA) the true Caliph during the combined 25-year tenure of Abu Bakr (RAA), Umar (RAA), and Uthman (RAA)? (They’ll probably say “Yes!” yet again.) 5) So if Islam was not triumphant for 25 years during the tenures of Abu Bakr (RAA), Umar (RAA), and Uthman (RAA), doesn’t that mean that Ali (RAA) also was not the legitimate caliph during those 25 years, since his legitimacy requires Islam to be triumphant during his tenure? (They’ll probably start sweating, and will try to walk back their previous answers, and will now claim that Islam _was_ triumphant during those 25 years.) 6) So if you’re now saying that Islam _was_ triumphant during the 25-year tenure of Abu Bakr (RAA), Umar (RAA), and Uthman (RAA), doesn’t that mean that they were the legitimate Caliphs? (At this point, they will have no clue what to say, since there’s no good way out of this dilemma for their dogmas, other than for them to admit that the original Sunni hadith, does nothing to help prove their so-called “infallible imamah with wilayah taqweeniyyah”.)
@shadsz1444
@shadsz1444 Ай бұрын
Our prophet SA told us cleary on many occasions who is his successor, if you dont even accept the 1st imam Ali AS . Your questions end there.
@samy7013
@samy7013 Ай бұрын
Evidence?
@saracenii
@saracenii Ай бұрын
Yes Abu Bakr was the first caliph and thats why Ali (RA) gave Bayyah and accepted it so.
@shadsz1444
@shadsz1444 Ай бұрын
@@saracenii so going against the prophet is someone who you revere
@saracenii
@saracenii Ай бұрын
@@shadsz1444 Why did Ali (RA) go against the prophet in that case and give bayyah to Abu Bakr. Lol it doesn't make sense. Nobody went against the prophet saw much less Abu Bakr RA when he was given Caliphship. Because everyone knew it should go to him. Also Allah said Abu Bakes in Jannah, so anyone who insults him will have insulted Allah for given Abu Bakr Jannah, After the Prophet named Abu Bakr, Uthman, Ali, Umar as people who will be going Jannah. So who are you to Insult them.
@shadsz1444
@shadsz1444 Ай бұрын
@@saracenii here we go playing the insult card. Where have i insulted any1
@mustafaal-dabagh9155
@mustafaal-dabagh9155 Ай бұрын
about the kitab almahassan argument kakashi already proved that the earliest manuscripts include all the imams by name all 12 of them.
@FaridResponds
@FaridResponds Ай бұрын
Uhh where is this proof?
@-------....___
@-------....___ Ай бұрын
Kakashi of the Sharingan?
@mustafaal-dabagh9155
@mustafaal-dabagh9155 Ай бұрын
@@FaridResponds keep deleting my comments farid you coward.
@mustafaal-dabagh9155
@mustafaal-dabagh9155 Ай бұрын
@@-------....___ kakashi of the shariah^
@Moody.Smiruai
@Moody.Smiruai 19 күн бұрын
Proof? Evidence?
@hasnainjivraj1923
@hasnainjivraj1923 Ай бұрын
May Allah show you the right part brother farid second don't put half video please put the full video and he has proof you from your books
@TheFaro2011
@TheFaro2011 Ай бұрын
So who knows our books, a Shia who lies or sunnis? You don't even have books of our equivalent! You don't have any idea of the standard they are and how they are to be used with context of actual history, NOT your emotional non provable history
@great87
@great87 Ай бұрын
The full video is a waste of time. 😂 Especially in Ramadan
@hassanmsangi4149
@hassanmsangi4149 Ай бұрын
fareed you have to tell where did prophet mention four khurafaa rashiduun
@Dante-kx7mw
@Dante-kx7mw Ай бұрын
Prove us imamah, go.
@SK-eg6dp
@SK-eg6dp Ай бұрын
its so interesting how sunnis are using sunni hadith to refute sunni hadith
@Last2LP
@Last2LP Ай бұрын
@@rcmysm9123 the pagans of mecca used to pray with their hands on their chests 👀
@darklink7105
@darklink7105 Ай бұрын
Using Hadith to criticize a Hadith for scrutiny is a part of Hadith science, something Shias lack much of.
@TheFaro2011
@TheFaro2011 Ай бұрын
​@@rcmysm9123you can't accept the Quran saying hold 5 prayers in their prescribed times. You lot seem to be "travelling" all the time.
@user-pb9nc4by2k
@user-pb9nc4by2k Ай бұрын
Wow buddy. Looks like a Shia might finally understand at least one aspect of Hadith. Congratulations. You're officially better than most of the people compiling and studying Shia hadith.
@abhmd4481
@abhmd4481 Ай бұрын
I wonder why all shia comments sound like bots, not one single coherent comment whatsoever 😂
@MOMO-iq3bi
@MOMO-iq3bi 16 күн бұрын
The names of the 12 imams is written in Masjid Nabawi
@maryamdw
@maryamdw 21 күн бұрын
Wait so in 14:33 in the Sunni book, Al khithr literally says to Hassan (as) that your father (Ali) is the successor of the prophet!
@harunkelly4530
@harunkelly4530 Ай бұрын
31. From Muhammad son of Wahban from Abi Huraira about the saying of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم):"Whoever wants to live my life and die my death, let him follow Ali son of Abi Taleb and follow the way of the Imams after him, the number of Asbaat(grandsons of Jacob are 12)." The Imams are 12 from the children of Ali (عليه السلام). so their count in total are 13. Sirat AlMustaqeem-AlBayaathi v.2 p.114
@tatsuyakuragi3578
@tatsuyakuragi3578 2 күн бұрын
16:00 "I would like a fifth of your income btw" 😂😂😂😂😂
@samy7013
@samy7013 Ай бұрын
One only needs to read Nawabakhti’s “Book of Shi’a Sects” and read about how the Shi’a fragmented and split into multiple groups after every “imam”, to realize that even the Shi’a had no clue who their “imams” were most of the time! 🤣😂😁
@abiabi9353
@abiabi9353 Ай бұрын
Oh my God.this guy farid is really crazy.He wants to judge the shia hadith but he knows nothing about mustahul of shia hadith. He just through words and useless opinions.He ask about imam jawadi to prove his imama ,really? Just go an read the history of imams and you will never ask such question again
@arabianknight0000
@arabianknight0000 Ай бұрын
Stop embarrassing yourself. Shites are not Muslims
@FaridResponds
@FaridResponds Ай бұрын
Mustalah*
@BigAck
@BigAck Ай бұрын
@@FaridResponds wow Farid you're that petty? spell check miss the point 😂
@TheFaro2011
@TheFaro2011 Ай бұрын
​@@BigAckI think you're missing the point. Shia "Hadith" doesn't hold a candle to the sunni science of Hadith. Not even close. And so much is fabricated. You guys actively do shirk, mins boggles how you will absolutely do anything to uphold it.
@Barlas511
@Barlas511 18 күн бұрын
Strange first they do away with eldest son Hasan's progeny from Imamat and start it from the mixed blood of Yazd Gerd, then almost all so called Imams had issues with their brothers over Imamat like Baqir. Even they weren't sure 😃
@ghul8158
@ghul8158 Ай бұрын
Alot of people talking about imams having superpowers. According to quran, a man bought the Palace of sheehah before Prophet Sulaman blinked his eyes. He outshone the strongest jins. Please explain how an ordinary man not a prophet can do this?
@fluidlessanimations8689
@fluidlessanimations8689 Ай бұрын
it was a jinn, a powerful among the jinns who is called an ifrit, not a man. do you mean these verses in the quran? 27:38 [Solomon] said, "O assembly [of jinn], which of you will bring me her throne before they come to me in submission?" 27:39 A powerful one from among the jinn said, "I will bring it to you before you rise from your place, and indeed, I am for this [task] strong and trustworthy." please explain to me how did you figure that it was a man when it clearly states that a powerful jinn brought the throne to him huh?
@MalikL3
@MalikL3 Ай бұрын
So your imams are jins 😂😂😂😂
@MalikL3
@MalikL3 Ай бұрын
@@fluidlessanimations8689his masoomi imams are jins
@Capt.RedBeard
@Capt.RedBeard Ай бұрын
imagine picking Ramadan time to enhance and broaden up your shirk...... wow
@TheFaro2011
@TheFaro2011 Ай бұрын
But it's a directly represents their faith oddly enough. Let's pick on organized praying and label Umar RA a "mushrik" astagfurullah, but he will do videos literally leading his flock astray. The irony is off the charts
@TheIntrepid-tz4zo
@TheIntrepid-tz4zo Ай бұрын
My point exactly.
@ibrahimamine2803
@ibrahimamine2803 Ай бұрын
So you mean to tell me our Prophet (sawa) whi taught is everyrhing frpm salat to how to eat etc. Left out who woild lead the WHOLE UMMA? Seriously, whoever believes that is lost.
@samy7013
@samy7013 Ай бұрын
Exactly… These Shi’is are absolutely lost.
@tahirmahmood9687
@tahirmahmood9687 Ай бұрын
Well, Syedna Abu Bakr was asked to lead the prayer when Rasoolullah ‎ﷺ was ill. He was his ‎ﷺ companion during Hijra which is also mentioned in the Quran. And verse of the Quran ‘Allah is with us’ includes Syedna Abu Bakr with Rasoolullah ‎ﷺ which elevates his status. May Allah be pleased with him.
@See773
@See773 26 күн бұрын
​@@tahirmahmood9687 is that your proof that Abubakr is the chosen one? 😅
@RexArdent
@RexArdent 7 күн бұрын
Please make a more detailed video on this one more
@BloodReversal
@BloodReversal 29 күн бұрын
This “evidence” is what they teeter their entire akhira on? I’d laugh if it wasn’t so sad.
@josephbarnabas3568
@josephbarnabas3568 Ай бұрын
Why you followed the ummayad caliphs or the 4 imams of fiqh. Of course they claimed they are caliphs and Imams, but how did you know they were true caliphs and Imams? How do you know they were not usurpers and fake imams? Actually the names of the 12 Imams are already mentioned in the earliest shia Hadith collection known as kitab of sulaym.
@zohairs.5038
@zohairs.5038 Ай бұрын
I will also note that the original version of the hadith at 14:02 also is narrated by Imam Ja'far as Sadiq (6th imam) while in the al-Kafi version it is Muhammad al Jawad (9th imam). The original chain is marfu' in al Mahaasin, so it definitely isn't strong evidence anymore!
@abdullahsaifee3775
@abdullahsaifee3775 Ай бұрын
Holy moly, this Shia guy talks like a super annoying person
@whitedragon7436
@whitedragon7436 Ай бұрын
I swear
@BigAck
@BigAck Ай бұрын
have you visited speakers' corner and heard people like Mohammad hijab and the other Sunni shouters speak? DETROYING CHRISTIANS, DESTORYING SHIA, DESTOYING JEWS, is the title of all their videos haha and they just shout. Bet you all love mo hijab the professional shouter.
@kingpiye7060
@kingpiye7060 Ай бұрын
Atleast hijab doesn't have a lisp he's actually masculine
@BigAck
@BigAck Ай бұрын
@@kingpiye7060 I see someone’s character never matters to you. Just their lisp. Their looks. Their clothes. You have a thing for hijab? Think he’s cute or something? I’m confused? Guys a paid activist that yells at everyone.
@abdullahsaifee3775
@abdullahsaifee3775 Ай бұрын
@@BigAck while I don't much like those titles, I'm yet to see any of their arguments being refuted, in general at least. Also do you have any proof of hijab being a paid activist? If not and I'm assuming you don't, then what does it say about you (if you call yourself a Muslim)
@Dontcallmeapusok
@Dontcallmeapusok Ай бұрын
After this video Amat read the yellow shoe Hadith to know what do to next
@captainrtf
@captainrtf Ай бұрын
Wallahi you’re a liar. Can you just encourage your viewers to watch SAN’s videos themselves and come back to comment on your videos? I bet you won’t like their comments after watching SAN😅
@samy7013
@samy7013 Ай бұрын
But when your so-called “infallible imams” say that taqiyyah is 9/10ths of the Twelver Imamiyyah Shi’a religion, and that he who doesn’t practice taqiyyah is devoid of religion, how can anyone believe anything that any of you say? The only Twelver Imamis today who seem to have set aside their taqiyyah are some of the akhbaris. Unfortunately however, the latter still use _buhtaan_ (slander) against their adversaries as a standard practice, so even they can’t be trusted to tell the truth either.
@captainrtf
@captainrtf Ай бұрын
@@samy7013 😂😂😂 see another liar. When your authentic books are being used to disprove your salafi-wahabeast-umari-sunni religion, you’re here spewing lies and falsehood like farid himself. It’s no news to us that you guys are very closeminded and have little to no knowledge when it comes to Islam. Your arguments have always been based on hearsay and no evidence. Come back again broh!
@mrbergula3536
@mrbergula3536 Ай бұрын
Screaming "Ya Aowli, Ya Aowli,"..asking everything from Ali radhiyallahu anhu.. Eating mud at Najaf.... Slapping with sword and knifes at their own back like Christian... And they not even realize or rather too stupid that even Ali radhiyallahu anhu unable to defend himself from Ibn Muljam..
@flag_bearertruth6257
@flag_bearertruth6257 Ай бұрын
you have shown from your comments and they are --- due to your sheer perfect ignorance, super scarece little knowledfe & a super mumbi jumbo weak minds and to weak faith and lack of certainty... the religion you follow is from abu bakr & umar (read saqifa incident). read quran 5;67.. which makes it clear about who you should follow after PBUH. Umar ^ abu bakr made 1st sect in islam, the people who stayed with Ali (as) remained in islam. also read tabari sunni book clearly states the propaganda at saqifa and these thug had gone at amximum klength to defend that. lol about Ibn Muljam. Imam Ali knew Ibn Muljam had a sword and he will struck, i finkk mrnergula was born in wahabi famil since u dont know Qadr, eschatology, premonition, & miraj. Imam Ali could ave sliced up all these hypcrites sahabas but the bigger picture was to protect islam and the last words of PBUH to him about patience, actually Fatmia (as) got angry at abu bakr and the GOd's wrath was about to hit abu bakr & umar but Imam ali tried to calm down Fatima (as) during those days after saqifa. Firstly, PBUH and his family are not normal human beings, they were speical creations whom by default know the secret of the universerve. PLus u meed to worry about yourself as how u deny Quran 5;67 and became an abu bakr & umar follower? and you agree , follow and take side of them who were materialistic, corrupted. super hypocrotes (incuded in 12 hypcrites bty abu hudaifah in sunni books), evildoers, dislloyall to the pBUH, misled people, deceivers and upgradedto new islam to islam 1.0 (caliphate islam).
@Hanbali437
@Hanbali437 Ай бұрын
Sunnis should be on offensive side now. Farid make a video about the shia concept of bada and show how reactionary this sect actually is.
@Last2LP
@Last2LP Ай бұрын
Sunnis have always been oppressors. The fk you mean „Sunnis should be on the offensive side now“ 😂
@babahadjimohamed9339
@babahadjimohamed9339 Ай бұрын
@@Last2LP yeah Iran in Ahwaz Vu and in Syria Vu
@abubakarbalghari8344
@abubakarbalghari8344 Ай бұрын
Sheikh please if you have an aproch to sheikh Adan Rasheed then please make him ready to respond allayari rafidi in Urdu language!! Jazakumullah khaiir
@lemoncake8398
@lemoncake8398 Ай бұрын
Alhamdulilah, finally a response to this man Nakshwami, every single night of Ramadan spewing nonsense to his audience. Pls keep up the good work brother Farid.
@hi-mq3gb
@hi-mq3gb 12 күн бұрын
12 imam proved already by Hassan Allahyari with sahi hadess, watch it 🤣
@Burna1009
@Burna1009 Ай бұрын
It’s like listening to a Harry Potter novel
@IrfanAhmad-uv4ul
@IrfanAhmad-uv4ul Ай бұрын
Yes listening to nakjawani is like listening to fairy tale I agree
@gongkong-oi7qx
@gongkong-oi7qx Ай бұрын
Nothing beats abiogenesis as the best fairytale.When is the next addition mate😂?
@ADF366
@ADF366 29 күн бұрын
The evidence for imams is as strong as evidence for the trinity. Nothing of substance in clear words anywhere, all unicorns. Unless you're born w it hard to convert ppl to unicornism
@amania9254
@amania9254 Ай бұрын
Thanks for the clarifications of his claims, great work, brother ❤
@Deeneda
@Deeneda Ай бұрын
Can you prove that Abubakar was chosen by Prophet Muhammad PBUH AND ALLAH SWT
@samy7013
@samy7013 Ай бұрын
Are you Shi’is for real? We Sunnis aren’t the ones who consider “infallible imamah and wilayah taqweeniyyah” to be usul of the deen. You’re the ones making these wild claims about your so-called “infallible imams”, so you bring your evidence. It’s the central pillar of _YOUR_ religion, not ours.
@saracenii
@saracenii Ай бұрын
If Allah and the prophet (PBUH) decided no, Abu Bakr wouldn't have been given bayyah from everyone including Ali (RA).
@Mehmet_Fateh
@Mehmet_Fateh 26 күн бұрын
Prove that this is necessary.
@realitybeckons4120
@realitybeckons4120 Ай бұрын
Allahumma barik
@aktharulhaqueshopon9251
@aktharulhaqueshopon9251 Ай бұрын
This guy talks like a clown
@IrfanAhmad-uv4ul
@IrfanAhmad-uv4ul Ай бұрын
Yes,nakjawani is a clown He just don't talk like a clown His videos proves that he is a clown
@habibanathani3747
@habibanathani3747 Ай бұрын
Where is Farid from
@samy7013
@samy7013 Ай бұрын
Bahrain
@dogface814
@dogface814 Ай бұрын
Your book shelf is about to break. You need something more sturdy
@gamingexpert7115
@gamingexpert7115 Ай бұрын
PhD holding Shia can’t defend his unislmic beliefs is not surprising
@szuvibes9474
@szuvibes9474 Ай бұрын
Not done with clowns ? Come on bro , at this time we could have refuted some other clowns.
@j400wel
@j400wel Ай бұрын
Elephant Airways 😂
@elprofesor8571
@elprofesor8571 Ай бұрын
Great
@AW-ty8ol
@AW-ty8ol Ай бұрын
God Bless you Farid.
@A-KDJ
@A-KDJ 23 күн бұрын
Is it just me or are (some) Twelver 'hadiths' just cut, edited, and pasted with a Shi'a flavor to suit their needs? Anyone who knows anything about ahadeeth knows that the Shi'a 'hadith' quoted sounds awfully a lot like when Jibra'eel (AS) visited Rasul ﷺ and asked him questions about the Deen in the presence of the Sahaba (RA).
@FaridResponds
@FaridResponds 23 күн бұрын
No doubt.
@doncorleone8733
@doncorleone8733 Ай бұрын
@farid you’ve not done well either. I have been following your responses trying to find out the truth but you’re not doing a good job either. Nakshwani said he doesn’t want to convert anyone. He is telling you to stick to yours and he to his and don’t call each other infidels. You Muslims are a funny bunch. Sometimes I think, you’re in awe of Mr. Nakshwani and maybe just trying to respond to all his lectures, weakly I must add, so you can gain fame and prestige perhaps? I hope you’re not doing it for the clicks.
@arabianknight0000
@arabianknight0000 Ай бұрын
Stop embarrassing yourself
@syed2194
@syed2194 Ай бұрын
Oh no I’m sure you’re such a legitimate knowledge seeker just trying to find out the truth. Get out of here you kadhab. Nakhshwani presents extremely weak evidence and then extrapolates an unsubstantiated conclusion to support his views.
@doncorleone8733
@doncorleone8733 Ай бұрын
@@arabianknight0000😂😂😂
@abhmd4481
@abhmd4481 Ай бұрын
You haven't responded to any of Farid's arguments
@doncorleone8733
@doncorleone8733 Ай бұрын
@@abhmd4481I can see no arguments 🤷‍♂️
@studentofknowledge6431
@studentofknowledge6431 Ай бұрын
Farid - would you not say the same happens in our literature of hadith. An earlier report is shorter but a later report gives more details. But we accept both.
@MichaelJDV
@MichaelJDV Ай бұрын
It's the same sanad and the same narration with a different matn. It shows that stuff was tampered with. If you read our literature there is a difference in isnad usually regarding the same report
@Spined1234
@Spined1234 Ай бұрын
Why would the earlier report not mention the 12 imams? What reason would they have for Shias to remove the 12 imams?
@MichaelJDV
@MichaelJDV Ай бұрын
@@Spined1234 Because Al Kulayni needed to fabricate evidence to support his theological beliefs, so he took the same sanad and just added the rest of the names and graded it sahih.
@Mehmet_Fateh
@Mehmet_Fateh 26 күн бұрын
Why do the Ismailis and Zaydis have a different list of Imams if it is all so obvious?
@MichaelJDV
@MichaelJDV 26 күн бұрын
@@Mehmet_Fateh We as Sunnis believe that their 4th imam Ali ibn Hussayn r.a was asked about Abu bakr r.a and Umar r.a and he defended them so a group of the Shia declared someone else the imam
@user-zx6xi3jp2g
@user-zx6xi3jp2g 17 күн бұрын
Less sound
@aliiqbali6384
@aliiqbali6384 29 күн бұрын
If I were a sunni, I would look into my own literature as Sayed mentions, look in those references that he gives and be the judge, don’t listen to this guy, judge by your own. In the end it’s you who are responsible for you actions not others. Stop being ignorant and look into you own books and then judge the behavior of Abu Bakr and Omar generally. what they did to the house of Fatima(AS) should be enough, there a few incidents that should make it easy for you to see that those two wanted something else from the whole beginning. As sayed says, how do I expect Sunni Muslim to have anything mentioned in their books when they rejected the first one, it was clearly 2 groups back then, the house of Fatima (AS) and then Abu Bakr and Umar. As for some that says Ali (AS) gave Bayyah to Abu Bakr, he gave it after Fatima (AS) died according to Sunni literature. How come that it was an election with Abu Bakr, not with Omar, but with Othman? How can Abu Bakr pass the khilafa to Omar but Omar won’t do the same? How can we follow people that are capable of doing mistake? Omar changed the some rules in the religion because he thought it was good for the religion, how can he do that? Everything that the prophet (SAW) said should be the same.
@HH-pv9ex
@HH-pv9ex Ай бұрын
The funny thing is that twelvers claim that Ali may Allah be pleased with him is the first Imam, when Ali himself pledged allegiance to Abu-Bakr and Umar and Uthman....if they claim to follow Ali, then they would be expected to do "exactly" what Ali did. But obviously they don't follow his example. Besides, even they splintered amongst them selves concerning the 7th Imam, which proved there is no divine appointment or infallibility. Then the severs splintered over Nizar and Al-Musaali and so on. But they can't stop pontificating to the Sunnah 😅
@abhmd4481
@abhmd4481 Ай бұрын
This is a big problem.
@Burna1009
@Burna1009 Ай бұрын
So Ammar started his series by trying to refute taraweeh in attempts to then try and convince Ahlus sunnah about imamah??
@fatninja6847
@fatninja6847 Ай бұрын
No, the video Farid was watching Ammar said that his focus was to inform Shia more about the imams with Shia Hadith. He wasn’t trying to convince sunnis about imamah.
@Burna1009
@Burna1009 Ай бұрын
@@fatninja6847 isn’t his 30 part Ramadan series about proving ithna ashariya but extension refuting ahlus sunnah?
@ababa40
@ababa40 Ай бұрын
If we know that Islam is a perfect religion, what is Sunnah wal Jamaah's plan after the Prophet (pbuh) passes away?
@mhmd1854
@mhmd1854 Ай бұрын
as always, farid clowning around, the prophet said Ali is the caliph after me, you don't accept the first which that clear how you will accept others
@Meezan12
@Meezan12 Ай бұрын
In the terminological sense, the Sahabah (R.A.) refers to those fortunate people who were blessed with the sight of the Messenger of God (PBUH) in the state of faith and became dear to Allah in the state of faith.... According to hadiths, whoever recites the word la ilaha illallah Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah is a Muslim. Is everyone who has seen Einstein a professor of physics today? If not, then how can anyone who has seen the Messenger of Allah become a religious scholar? Below we will see the types of Companions of the Holy Prophet from the Holy Quran The Holy Qur'an has divided the Companions of the Messenger into different categories, and it does not matter whether a person is a Badri or a non-Badri, believed before Hudaybiyyah or after Hudaybiyyah, before the conquest of Makkah came among the Muslims or the conquest. After Mecca. Therefore, the real faces of these groups have been mentioned in the Holy Quran as follows: 1. The famous hypocrites (Surah Al-Munafiqun, verse 1). 2. A deceiver and a cunning hypocrite (Surah Towbah, verse 101). 3. Patients with hearts (Surah Ahzab, verse 12). 4. Those who listen to the words of the enemies who spread fitnah (Surah Towbah, verse 45-47). 5. Those who do good and bad deeds (Surat al-Tawbah, verse 102). 6. Apostates (Surah Al-Imran, verse 154). 7. Except for the believers, those who have been accepted (Surah Hujarat, verse 14). 8. Mawulfah al-Qulub (Surah Towbah, verse 60). 9. Fasiq (Surah Hujarat, verse 6). 10. At the time of war, those who turn their backs on the disbelievers and run away (Surah Anfal, verse 15, 16). Where the Holy Qur'an has promised paradise for following the Companions of the Prophet, the same Qur'an has forbidden following the hypocrites. Surah Towa 100. And among the emigrants and the Ansar, those who excelled first, and those who followed them in good conduct, Allah was pleased with them, and they were pleased with Allah, and Allah has prepared for them gardens beneath which rivers flow. They will flow in them forever and this is the great achievement. Surah Ahzab 1. O Prophet, fear Allah and do not obey the disbelievers and the hypocrites. Indeed, Allah is All-Knowing, All-Wise. Note: ___ When the hypocrites come to you, they say: We bear witness that you are indeed the Messenger of Allah, and Allah knows that you are indeed His Messenger, and Allah bears witness that these hypocrites are indeed liars. ) If there were hypocrites among the Companions of the Prophet, there were some who came to him and testified that he was the Prophet of God. God has forbidden to obey the hypocrites, then how can the consensus of the Companions of the Prophet be a proof? [Surah Maida verse 10:10. And those who disbelieved and denied Our revelations are the people of Hell.]_________________ 1. Surah Al-Imran: 144. Result____:@ "It is wrong to call the Sahaba RA wrong and it is also wrong to call the wrong Sahaba" __@ Only those who disbelieve dispute in the Ayat of Allah, so let them be troubled by their confusion in the land. (4) Translation: Kanzalaiman They do not dispute in the verses of Allah, but the disbelievers, so do not be deceived by their wandering in the cities, O listener. "Read carefully again" The Sunni sect is over❤
@1001011011010
@1001011011010 Ай бұрын
It is not proved that al-Kulayni is just filling in names; al-Barqi seems to imply his list is not exhaustive. So perhaps al-Kulayni is simply giving the full account accurately. But this doesn't prove he is in fact relaying a genuine account, either.
@Spined1234
@Spined1234 Ай бұрын
It's still tampering with the hadith. And it makes no sense why the Shia muhadetheen would randomly remove the names of the 12 imams of highly important hadith.
@1001011011010
@1001011011010 Ай бұрын
@@Spined1234 No, it doesn't have to be tampering. What was written was implied to not be exhaustive: it is not random removal. Oftentimes people don't reference all the hadith they know or don't list the isnad if they already have it somewhere, etc. Hadith have an oral life, not just a written one, so a fuller hadith later written down doesn't mean an earlier, truncated hadith that was written was then tampered with by the later source, especially if the earlier one explicitly says the tradition they are relating is truncated and incomplete. Once again, this isn't to say it is authentic. But it doesn't prove inauthenticity
@Spined1234
@Spined1234 Ай бұрын
@@1001011011010 It makes absolutely no sense why the Shia would randomly remove the names of the 12 imams in a highly important hadith considering that Imamah is one of, if not the most important tenet in their faith. The only explanation that makes sense is that this hadith originally did not mention the 12 imams and later Shiee authors came along and inserted their own list into it. This is strong evidence that the hadith was tampered by the Shia, which is common with a lot of their hadiths.
@1001011011010
@1001011011010 Ай бұрын
@@Spined1234 It wasn't randomly removed, listen to the hadith again. It just doesn't list them all out; the list of people is not listed out itemized, but it is described.
@Spined1234
@Spined1234 Ай бұрын
@@1001011011010 Again, why would the Shia NOT list the names of the 12 imams when that is the most single important aspect of this hadith? So the shiee muhadith receives this amazing hadith listing all the 12 imams and then just decides to exclude all of them for some reason. Yeah sorry I'm having a lot of trouble buying this story especially when the Shia often use this hadith as evidence for their imamah. I need a better explanation as to why the earlier Shia hadith did not mention the names of the 12 imams. This isn't even mentioning the issue that the Imams themselves did not use this hadith as proof of their Imamah.
@stuffsummedup22
@stuffsummedup22 Ай бұрын
If the imams can communicate with angels, what exactly is the difference between them and prophets from a shi'i viewpoint?
@samy7013
@samy7013 Ай бұрын
No difference, except the name. Shi’is actually believe that their “infallible imams” are superior to all of the Prophets, except Muhammad ﷺ, and even the latter deference to Rasool Allah ﷺ is just lip-service. They ascribe alleged virtues to their “infallible imams” far higher than what they ascribe to Rasool Allah Muhammad ﷺ.
@thesociallyradicalguitaris9589
@thesociallyradicalguitaris9589 Ай бұрын
As an added point, Ammar Nakshawani studied Islamic Studies but did not go through formal Hawza training. A lot of those graduates of Hawza training perform Taqiyah, and make a judgement on when it's appropriate to reveal what they were taught about the true history of Islam as taught in the Hawza. Each of the named Imams performed miracles, particularly in front of each major Caliph of their time, so they would have no excuse before Allah SWT when asked why they didn't turn over the caliphate to the Imam, the rightful leader of the Islamic Ummah.
@FaridResponds
@FaridResponds Ай бұрын
Prove that al-Hadi performed a miracle.
@sammirzad
@sammirzad Ай бұрын
Farid, respectfully, you failed to disprove nakshawani's video about the twelve imams 😂 anyone who watches the full lecture without any bias will understand where the twelve imams from the shia theology comes from
@everythingandroidois
@everythingandroidois Ай бұрын
Not falling for these "insufficient response" when this is what Nakshawani presented throughout the whole. At first, I thought you guys were sincere in this but I can see through the coping without refuting.
@sammirzad
@sammirzad Ай бұрын
@@everythingandroidois it’s ok no one’s forcing you to watch the lecture, if you trust everything in this video to be 100% correct then that’s your choice.
@FollowtheSunnah632
@FollowtheSunnah632 Ай бұрын
yes it comes from majloosi enemies of Islam
@j400wel
@j400wel Ай бұрын
They come from Ibn Sabaah, the Jew.
@arabianknight0000
@arabianknight0000 Ай бұрын
It comes from the @55
@mustafashariff8024
@mustafashariff8024 Ай бұрын
Ya Farid ...وَمَثَلُ الَّذِيۡنَ کَفَرُوۡا كَمَثَلِ الَّذِىۡ يَنۡعِقُ بِمَا لَا يَسۡمَعُ اِلَّا دُعَآءً وَّنِدَآءً ؕ صُمٌّۢ بُكۡمٌ عُمۡـىٌ فَهُمۡ لَا يَعۡقِلُوۡنَ‏
@saracenii
@saracenii Ай бұрын
By shouting and doing acts of worship i.e. praying to Ali by yelling Ya Ali instead of praying to Allah, is enough for me to not be Shia.
@-------....___
@-------....___ Ай бұрын
Good Farid that you are not calling this man 'Sayed'. Sayed in the old times meant someone related to the Prophet PBUH's family by blood, or is a descendent. Current Shias rather use the title Sayed (or Syed) as a rank in knowledge instead.
@A.A471
@A.A471 Ай бұрын
But Ammar is related to the Prophet SAW. They just keep the title of Sayed even if they become a scholar.
@HR-313
@HR-313 Ай бұрын
You sound soo intelligent mashallah .....
@-------....___
@-------....___ Ай бұрын
@@A.A471 How do you know he is related? And how do you distinguish between those who are just calling themselves Sayed because they are a scholar? If Shia are giving themselves titles based on how much they have studied their literature, why do other people have to use those titles, especially when those titles pertain to a false religion? As a muslim, would you meet a christian priest and call him Father?
@-------....___
@-------....___ Ай бұрын
@@HR-313 weird comment, but okay
@HR-313
@HR-313 Ай бұрын
@@-------....___ aww dont be like that I was just saying mashallah you sooooooo smart like wow
@saliksayyar9793
@saliksayyar9793 Ай бұрын
Concocted . Circular reasoning. Begging the question. Ali (rta) in the presence of Abu Bakr (rta) and umar(rta). So he invokes Khidr, why not just a random person. Confabulations!
@haniel-zein8123
@haniel-zein8123 Ай бұрын
Why would he use shia sources 😂
@harunkelly4530
@harunkelly4530 Ай бұрын
From Muhammad son of Wahban from Abi Huraira about the saying of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم):"Whoever wants to live my life and die my death, let him follow Ali son of Abi Taleb and follow the way of the Imams after him, the number of Asbaat(grandsons of Jacob are 12)." The Imams are 12 from the children of Ali (عليه السلام). so their count in total are 13. Sirat AlMustaqeem-AlBayaathi v.2 p.114
@Mehmet_Fateh
@Mehmet_Fateh 26 күн бұрын
So why do Zaydis and Ismailis exist?
@harunkelly4530
@harunkelly4530 26 күн бұрын
@Mehmet_Fateh You should probably those sect members.
@Mehmet_Fateh
@Mehmet_Fateh 26 күн бұрын
@@harunkelly4530 Who did Jafar al-Sadiq name as his successor?
@harunkelly4530
@harunkelly4530 26 күн бұрын
@@Mehmet_Fateh He's son Musa al Kazim a.s.
@Mehmet_Fateh
@Mehmet_Fateh 26 күн бұрын
@@harunkelly4530 I mean originally...
@waqaswani2994
@waqaswani2994 Ай бұрын
Isn't Nakshawani the same guy who gave a challenge and when Ustad Adnan Rashid accepted. He went underground 😂😂😂
@ammaarrizvi6212
@ammaarrizvi6212 19 күн бұрын
Why don't you try to refute the videos he made on Abu bakr you only tried to refute those you thought you were able to do. Also change your tittles to "trying to refute" instead of saying you have refuted because you should let your viewers decide that.
@FaridResponds
@FaridResponds 19 күн бұрын
What is the name of the video about Abu Bakr?
@HK-vl3cp
@HK-vl3cp Ай бұрын
The names of the 12 Imams (a.s) are even seen inside of the Prophet's (Sawa) mosque in Medina. Go and check it up yourselves.
@MalikL3
@MalikL3 Ай бұрын
Yes we know this what does this prove do u know who point them there in the first place your brothers the Qadbrooni Sufi 😂😂😂 what a strawman
@user-sh8yv7rn7y
@user-sh8yv7rn7y Ай бұрын
"Islamic Scholar" with tattoos on whole body. And on top of that he is "Ph.D"
@samy7013
@samy7013 Ай бұрын
Ammar Nakhshwani seems to be deliberately trying to imitate the delivery style of Kamal Haydari, except that he’s using a weird English accent instead of Arabic. 😂🤣😁
@joejr.cocker9997
@joejr.cocker9997 Ай бұрын
Phd given by whom.. christian pastors, i guess! Hahaa😤
@HR-313
@HR-313 Ай бұрын
Ohhhh ahahhahahahhqhqhhqhahqhqhhqhqhqhqhqhhw that was so funny omg you must be a comedian
@TheFaro2011
@TheFaro2011 Ай бұрын
​@@HR-313but he has a point PhD of western uni doesn't equate to classical Islamic studies. Completely different, that's why he avoids actual debates with learned.
@HR-313
@HR-313 Ай бұрын
@TheFaro2011 does Mohammad Hijab have his phd from al.azhar? Lol
@haqqulyakeen4661
@haqqulyakeen4661 Ай бұрын
Lol, these wahabi gang members cannot all together handle an orator syed ammar, syed ammar made these salafi guys forget taraweeh and kept them busy trying hard to refute 😂😂 this came from a man who is not even a debator but just a shia orator, whats gonna happen if an actual shia debator starts making vidoes
@aafanusmani9180
@aafanusmani9180 Ай бұрын
Then actual ahle sunnah (all movements in jamaat)debator will start making video's
@haqqulyakeen4661
@haqqulyakeen4661 Ай бұрын
@@aafanusmani9180 Yeah, we saw that with Shiekh Hassan Allahyari
@haqqulyakeen4661
@haqqulyakeen4661 Ай бұрын
@@aafanusmani9180 Adnan rashid running by saying he is an akhbari
@haqqulyakeen4661
@haqqulyakeen4661 Ай бұрын
@@aafanusmani9180 And Asrar Rashid cannot be still found
@haqqulyakeen4661
@haqqulyakeen4661 Ай бұрын
@@aafanusmani9180 As for the ummah tv umari scholars, they are still busy digging deep in books to find something to refute the videos of shiekh
@Beardkatt
@Beardkatt Ай бұрын
Lets face it... Sayed Ammar might not have provided strong evidence on his claims but AT LEAST it holds more truths than the lists of the 12 that Sunni scholars come with. I'm not saying that Ammar showed strong evidence.. that's hard especially when you take into fact that Umar BANNED the writing of hadiths for many years. I'd like to see you analyze and counter the claims of Ammar's Ramadan series WITH your own facts using your literature.
@Last2LP
@Last2LP Ай бұрын
Come on now. That wouldn’t support his narrative
@mustafaal-dabagh9155
@mustafaal-dabagh9155 Ай бұрын
sunnis can’t name the 12 also farid lied the whole video in the latest manuscripts of shia books the 12 imams are mentioned.
@heromahdi
@heromahdi Ай бұрын
@@mustafaal-dabagh9155 Honestly this guy's channel is just to hate on shias and praise umar 💀💀 He doesnt provide anyone with useful information at all.
@samy7013
@samy7013 Ай бұрын
Are you Shi’is for real? We Sunnis aren’t the ones who consider “infallible imamah and wilayah taqweeniyyah” to be usul of the deen. You’re the ones making these wild claims about your so-called “infallible imams”, so you bring your evidence. It’s the central pillar of _YOUR_ religion, not ours.
@mustafaal-dabagh9155
@mustafaal-dabagh9155 Ай бұрын
@@samy7013 we have our evidence and it can be found in our earliest manuscripts of our books.
@jackripper3429
@jackripper3429 27 күн бұрын
Okay now putting all those Hadiths aside, why should I believe a random kinda knowledble muslim on KZbin over a well eloquent, PHD Muslim scholar who has more authority over his words then any of those guys out there?
@Mehmet_Fateh
@Mehmet_Fateh 26 күн бұрын
A PhD from a kafir university means nothing in Islam.
@Meezan12
@Meezan12 Ай бұрын
This article destroy Sunnite/suffite islam In the terminological sense, the Sahabah (R.A.) refers to those fortunate people who were blessed with the sight of the Messenger of God (PBUH) in the state of faith and became dear to Allah in the state of faith.... According to hadiths, whoever recites the word la ilaha illallah Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah is a Muslim. Is everyone who has seen Einstein a professor of physics today? If not, then how can anyone who has seen the Messenger of Allah become a religious scholar? Below we will see the types of Companions of the Holy Prophet from the Holy Quran The Holy Qur'an has divided the Companions of the Messenger into different categories, and it does not matter whether a person is a Badri or a non-Badri, believed before Hudaybiyyah or after Hudaybiyyah, before the conquest of Makkah came among the Muslims or the conquest. After Mecca. Therefore, the real faces of these groups have been mentioned in the Holy Quran as follows: 1. The famous hypocrites (Surah Al-Munafiqun, verse 1). 2. A deceiver and a cunning hypocrite (Surah Towbah, verse 101). 3. Patients with hearts (Surah Ahzab, verse 12). 4. Those who listen to the words of the enemies who spread fitnah (Surah Towbah, verse 45-47). 5. Those who do good and bad deeds (Surat al-Tawbah, verse 102). 6. Apostates (Surah Al-Imran, verse 154). 7. Except for the believers, those who have been accepted (Surah Hujarat, verse 14). 8. Mawulfah al-Qulub (Surah Towbah, verse 60). 9. Fasiq (Surah Hujarat, verse 6). 10. At the time of war, those who turn their backs on the disbelievers and run away (Surah Anfal, verse 15, 16). Where the Holy Qur'an has promised paradise for following the Companions of the Prophet, the same Qur'an has forbidden following the hypocrites. Surah Towa 100. And among the emigrants and the Ansar, those who excelled first, and those who followed them in good conduct, Allah was pleased with them, and they were pleased with Allah, and Allah has prepared for them gardens beneath which rivers flow. They will flow in them forever and this is the great achievement. Surah Ahzab 1. O Prophet, fear Allah and do not obey the disbelievers and the hypocrites. Indeed, Allah is All-Knowing, All-Wise. Note: ___ When the hypocrites come to you, they say: We bear witness that you are indeed the Messenger of Allah, and Allah knows that you are indeed His Messenger, and Allah bears witness that these hypocrites are indeed liars. ) If there were hypocrites among the Companions of the Prophet, there were some who came to him and testified that he was the Prophet of God. God has forbidden to obey the hypocrites, then how can the consensus of the Companions of the Prophet be a proof? [Surah Maida verse 10:10. And those who disbelieved and denied Our revelations are the people of Hell.]_________________ 1. Surah Al-Imran: 144. Result____:@ "It is wrong to call the Sahaba RA wrong and it is also wrong to call the wrong Sahaba" __@ Only those who disbelieve dispute in the Ayat of Allah, so let them be troubled by their confusion in the land. (4) Translation: Kanzalaiman They do not dispute in the verses of Allah, but the disbelievers, so do not be deceived by their wandering in the cities, O listener. "Read carefully again" The Sunni sect is over
Why are Sunnis and Shia Different? Full Breakdown (AIM Conference)
37:07
Shia Debater attempts to prove 12 Imams
1:20:14
Farid Responds
Рет қаралды 29 М.
Surprise Gifts #couplegoals
00:21
Jay & Sharon
Рет қаралды 26 МЛН
Are the Qiraat mistakes?
12:49
Farid Responds
Рет қаралды 98 М.
The Muslim Lantern Says It's Permissible to Say Christ is King
10:01
Maktabah As-Sunnah
Рет қаралды 1,1 М.
Three Common Claims about Hadith
8:23
Farid Responds
Рет қаралды 13 М.
How Bible Scholars Challenged my Christian Faith
25:54
Blogging Theology
Рет қаралды 196 М.
‘How did Fatima Zahra (as) die?’ | Night 1 | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Fatimiyah 2023/1445
1:04:17
The Return of the Islamic Dilemma
20:23
Farid Responds
Рет қаралды 23 М.
القطة المسكينة 😭😭🐱 #shorts
0:30
7amoda Gaming
Рет қаралды 10 МЛН
100 lvl🧠⛓️‍💥
0:32
Kan Andrey
Рет қаралды 17 МЛН
ОБЫЧНЫЙ ДЕНЬ РОЖДЕНИЯ 😅 |  #mellstroy #shorts
0:18
Мұсаның анасы Розаны қалай қабылдады?😍 Бір Болайық! 06.05.24
25:53
Бір болайық / Бир Болайык / Bir Bolayiq
Рет қаралды 217 М.