An Hour on That Planet is 7 Years in our Time - Interstellar (2014) - Movie Clip 4K HD Scene

If you are a 🎥 movie lover - you're gonna love our channel 👌
Get your popcorn 🍿 & 🥤soda and enjoy legendary scenes from
your favorite movies. You might also find some great clips🎬 you completely forgot about or even find something completely new to spend your afternoon on. Don't worry, we all do it sometimes 😉
SUBSCRIBE & CLICK THE BELL BUTTON:
______________________________________________________________
All material belongs to their respective owners.
Any and all ads that may appear during this video are set by video material owners and/or their associates.
This channel never has nor will ever in the future be monetized.
No business of any kind is possible so please don't contact us about it. The only reason email is provided in 'About' section is for owners of the movies to be able to contact us.
Fair use.
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended.

[@legendarymoviescenes1926]

I started making movie reviews, check it out: kzbin.info/www/bejne/mqu0nnWFgc-kpM0

[@Bhuvan2403]

Its 2024 and when you realize this movie got released just 1 and a half hour ago in Miller's planet😮

[@SammyChabert]

What's crazy is seeing comments from years ago saying "45 minutes ago". Regardless of time dilation all our lives are passing by. Time takes no prisoners.

[@DevilishmanThe]

The covid lockdown gives the time dilation a new perspective really.

[@Mr_Dancy_Pants]

What's crazy is the dude who literally stood around for days staring at the wave instead of climbing into the hatch.

[@superdoublekapowzler2383]

@ 7 years per hour, it'd be weeks. Weeks looking at a wave. In 2021, human deaths were 184,065/day, while this a-hole watched a wave.

[@macfurrywong8108]

This was my exact thoughts!

[@notidentified9667]

He's a dvmb 4ss

[@johjoh9270]

Shock I guess, some people and animals freeze when extremely frightened, can't expect to be rational when a more than 1KM high wave is advancing towarss you

[@Mr_Dancy_Pants]

@@johjoh9270 He was doing just fine until he got to safety. Then he decided not to climb to safety.

[@Kragatar]

They were awfully optimistic to think they could descend down to an alien planet, find a person, get all the stuff they needed, and launch back to the mothership in under an hour.

[@manasgrover112]

Well they kinda executed it lol

[@dwaynedevera1488]

Well they would’ve executed their plan perfectly if Doyle wasn’t acting like a damn deer caught in headlights when the wave was approaching 😂

[@dakotawolf5155]

Yeah my wife and I rewatched this and thought the same. Poor writing, no one is that naive to sit their and watch. He had ample opportunity to get back in the ship, but by the time he stared at the wave, and casually watch tars get Brand, he lost his chance

[@kennedyxd8614]

@@dakotawolf5155 well, its not like they were prepared for that, and if you didnt notice doyle was in love with brand and thats why he made sure she was safe before getting in

[@dakotawolf5155]

​@@kennedyxd8614oh didn't know that had a thing for each other. I just have that "keep moving" mindset. I can't stand when people are slow lol

[@kaister901]

It's even more insane to learn that this is actual science and not BS. The math is real.

[@tarbabyluvr2272]

Have we actually been on a planet like this?

[@kaister901]

@@tarbabyluvr2272 What? That's not how science works. Also the scientific principle applied here has been already observed and documented. The depiction in the movie is the extreme end of it based on the sound math already proven along with empirical evidence. That is the time dilation astronauts in space experience vs people on land. It is minute but definitely present. You may not know this and most probably won't but your GPS in your car, in your phone all are programmed to account for this difference in time. The satellites in orbit experience time ever so slightly different from people on earth. Yet, still significant enough to give wrong directions if it isn't accounted for.

[@victorholmes5225]

@@tarbabyluvr2272 the math is real. Not the experience

[@tarbabyluvr2272]

@@victorholmes5225 thank you sm

[@NaveedKhan-tn4un]

Its not a movie. Its a class of physics.

[@jackbyrne4635]

You HAVE to think Wes Bentley’s character knew that Brand never intended for anyone on Earth to survive the way he reacts when Cooper mentions plan A

[@brandondaniels9471]

_"We are the future"_ - Dr. Mann

[@thedarkknight9153]

"There is a moment-"

[@HomeDefender30]

Yeah it feels like plan b was plan a all along, but the only way to convince a team to do it was under the premise that they were simply finding a planet that all their family and friends could live on happily ever after. Cooper would have never left if it was always plan b.

[@captaincrunch8432]

Wow you’re right. I never thought of that

[@kylehaney4124]

@@HomeDefender30it was definitely plan A all along and your right how do you convince the team to do the job? Make them think their was any sort of salvation for their loved ones. Saving mankind was the goal all along by any means necessary.

[@sixela3455]

1:33 what a sad and eery foreshadow. He knew

[@douglarsen4801]

This movie truly changed how I think about life. It’s amazing.

[@Haigen.R.Hawkins]

if you need a movie to change how you think about life, i feel sorry for you.

[@douglarsen4801]

Sick Burn

[@douglarsen4801]

Sick Burn

[@douglarsen4801]

Sick Burn

[@douglarsen4801]

Sick Burn

[@elitewolfzz567]

It’s crazy that Miller literally died like 30 min beofre they got there

[@kb4903]

Correct strange they never thought that her pings were from ages ago. Never understood why it was just a thumbs up to.

[@tombucannon]

@@kb4903how blinds sometimes

[@stevelarry3870]

@@kb4903 They obviously knew her pings were from ages ago, because they knew about the time dilation. The pings being from ages ago isn't a red flag.

[@drg8687]

@@stevelarry3870 it is if it's the only thing she is transmitting for years and years... nothing else cause she died right away

[@stevelarry3870]

@@drg8687 You don't understand. She would be transmitting the same thing for years and years regardless of if the planet was inhabitable or not. She was down there for like an hour, the initial readings are all that they would expect her to have time to broadcast.

[@thomasconstructionco6579]

love how casually matthew was when he said he can swing by a neutron star

[@cloroc]

I picked that up

[@therearenoshortcuts9868]

looking for a habitable planet around a Black Hole AND a Neutron star.... rofl... what else does this system got? strange stars and unstable red dwarves?

[@ceIIardoor]

@@therearenoshortcuts9868 don't forget countless meteors within atmospheric range! BEST PLANET GUISE

[@JUNIORK1974]

Right?! "I'll jump in old melba toast here are drive around it." LOL

[@thatcornfedrx8guy372]

@@therearenoshortcuts9868the neutron star he was referring to was the black hole

[@DngrDan]

It's so strange to think you age FASTER on earth than you do in space. But there is absolutely no difference from your perspective either way. You don't actually live a longer life. But technically you do. Crazy concept.

[@DngrDan]

@user-qu7qh7qj2t I think you and the movie both explain this perfectly. It's just hard to wrap your head around.

[@Charzhino]

You dont age faster, from your perspective you are aging normally. Its only to the distant viewer that you appear to age slowly because each second of light thats reaching their eyes is taking longer to travel to them

[@nickieb9656]

time doesn’t exist

[@DngrDan]

@@nickieb9656 It's all relative. Just another way of us humans trying to understand the world around us.

[@Qichar]

It made ZERO sense to visit the water planet first. At that time they thought Plan A was still a realistic possibility. As such, time was their most valuable resource. They should have visited one of the other planets first, even if the journey was going to take months. At a rate of 7 years to one hour, they had to plan on the round trip down to the planet taking at least a decade. Also, they should have been able to see that the planet was almost entirely water when they got closer. Such a planet would be unlikely to be habitable by humans without advanced and extensive construction equipment, which would not have been possible for their technology level. One of other two prospects just made more sense. In the end, we know they visited the water planet because the film makers thought mile high waves would look cool. They did.

[@TW0man4RMY]

Not to mention inhabiting a planet with that drastic of a time dilation puts you at the mercy of the rest of the galaxy that DOESNT have a drastic time dilation...

[@khaliquet1]

Right. Edmunds was easily the safest choice, if time is truly a resource. I rather lose months of space travel than lose decades for a few hours…

[@osamaz2780]

it's actually crazy to imagine what exactly they would see inside the planet orbiting outside of the time cusp. Mile high water waves moving at dead slow speed perhaps? or Seeing Miller team landing just now at slow-mo speed etc

[@TheYamsinacan]

Did you even pay attention to the movie bro? They are traveling through space. They did this on a secret NASA budget that isn't supposed to exist politically in their world with limited resources. There are no pitstops--they have limited fuel, food, and oxygen. Miller's planet is FIRST UP ON THEIR ROUTE (0:24)--they only realized the blackhole issue after they started getting close (0:28). They have to conserve resources, and since the other planets are super far away, it's not as simple as just coming back to Miller's planet (2:03). Also, if Miller's planet was good, they can call the mission a wrap and just go back to Earth. There mission was to save humanity, not the lazurus missions. It's the closest one and has promising data (seems to be the best given the characters' reactions). Second of all, they didn't have three choices. Edmund's planet stopped sending signals (0:09) . Why would they have ever gone to it before Miller's when it was still multiple months away? Third, another reason for the time loss was because the water logging made them stay on the planet for longer. They doubled their time on the planet because of the engines getting water logged. The editing is confusing, but Case tells Cooper that they need 45-60 min for the engines to be clear. Fourth, given Prof. Brand's knowledge that Plan A was a lie and Doyle's behavior, it is very likely that Dolye knew Plan A was a lie as well and was focused on finding something suitable for Plan B. His argumentation makes more sense if Plan B was the only plan. The time dilation means that fuel and oxygen aren't a big deal since they would experience time as 1 hour and the 1hours worth of fuel vs the months of time experience in the journey to Mann's and Edmund's planet and the accompanying fuel. Yes, they think decide to start thinking of time as a resource, but it was still far below fuel and oxygen in their resource tier list. Yes, one of the reasons they went to this planet is because it would make for an interesting story. That's how story telling works. This is not based off of real events. But don't just say things don't make sense just because you didn't even bother trying to pay attention to the details of the movie.

[@Qichar]

@@TheYamsinacan When they discovered the proximity of Miller's planet to the black hole, they had an opportunity to skip it. They knew that going down would take at least a decade given the gravity issue. I watched the movie yes. I would have a skipped a planet completely covered in water, orbiting a black hole, with other serious issues. Somehow, they had the ability to visit the other 2 destinations in the movie, yes? So they had enough fuel and supplies to somehow not only get to the other 2 places, but also maintain orbit and feed a guy who wasn't sleeping the whole time for 23 years. I'm thinking maybe you only paid attention to the unrealistic details of the movie that you wanted to. Given the proximity of the black hole, they ALREADY knew from the discussion SHOWN IN THE MOVIE, that this one destination was going to take at least a decade due to the time dilation. The Earth was dying, they thought plan A was an option, spending 10 years (minimum) on one destination was a good way to doom everybody they had left behind.

[@woodrobin]

I like that the robot companion species that he wouldn't leave *one* of them behind. Robot humor. 🙂

[@Simtak147]

And then he actually didn’t leave her behind lol

[@brandstradamus]

If you stood at the event horizon of Sagittarius A for one hour, 700 years would have passed on earth 🌎

[@ordenax]

That is mind boggling!

[@dannyhernandez265]

What? Unbelievable

[@brandstradamus]

@dannyhernandez265 so amazing when you actually try to comprehend everything.

[@dannyhernandez265]

@@brandstradamus absolutely. Space is just insane.

[@gregordrizzlewing7339]

Not a space dude thought I’d look this up out of curiosity and bruhh space is just scary man

[@Box-yg8qm]

Did no one really think how long miller has been on that planet? I mean 7 years is an hour. Someone had to figure out that she hasn’t been on that planet for long, maybe she just arrived.

[@reddotsxul8166]

True, I saw someone say from another comments section that she could’ve been hit by that exact same wave that this group was hit by a few minutes before.

[@Iagoingsoc]

yeah I think the idea is they just forget to think of this until they're down there (then they realise and talk about it) - easy to do with relativity, even for experts!

[@TheOpinionGuyy]

They only figured that one out when they were about to make a choice.

[@ItsChevnotJeff]

@@reddotsxul8166 Its also thought that the wave she was struck by was the same one that they saw was already past them

[@chudzij]

they literally say in the movie that "Miller landed here minutes ago"

[@MrMarkus987]

An experiment was conducted where an atomic clock was placed at ground level and another placed on the highest point on our planet (Mt Everest) there was a slight difference in time. The experiment concluded that object closer to a gravtional pull as opposed to object further away from the same gravitional pull will experience a small difference in the change of time. (Time Dilation)

[@mw5213]

Didn’t they also do this with two planes flying in opposite directions around the world and also found differences ?

[@Minimeister317]

There's also that of NASA astronaut Scott Kelly who spent a year in space, whom happens to have a twin brother, so when he came back to Earth, doctors made a comparison between them and noticed a difference between them

[@jenniferspears7074]

Amazing science❤

[@chinaman1]

if that's the case then the movie Core, the guys that went into the core should've been younger when they come back up.

[@XAVR_]

@@mw5213 one was stationary at the airbase, the other travelled around the earth at >Mach 2, the one in the plane was a few microseconds slower when it returned. Same theory (time/space relativity), but using velocity instead of gravitational forces

[@AMB33ZY]

I like how the robot was offended by being told it talk to much and it bullshit to much.🤣

[@RRRRobbbb]

"Gargantua?" "It's what we're calling the black hole." The crew has never talked about it, and no one on earth knew about the black hole until these 4 arrived. So Doyle literally just decided that's what they were going to call it lol.

[@Bzirk]

I think they already knew about it because they say Miller's planet is "much closer to gargantua than we thought"- Implying they knew about the black hole, just didn't know the planet was that close to it.

[@Minimeister317]

In real life, there has been done several experiments in time dilatation, one of the more prominent ones is that of the NASA astronaut Scott Kelly who spent a year in space. Scott has a twin brother, so after one year of being in space, they made several comparisons between them when Scott came back to Earth, and found that Scott's biological clock was different to that of his twin brother.

[@olplainface1299]

No one has been past low earth orbit, grow up.

[@flamingkillermc2806]

@@olplainface1299How about the moon landing, flat earther?

[@Whales1992]

@@olplainface1299 ? And what? You think the International space station which u can see with a telescope is fake?

[@saintcrx6567]

These the mfs that believe the election is fake tho lol

[@Jafmanz]

@@Whales1992 he thinks it is a 6 foot long dome cleaning device that scrubs the dome shell for him.

[@rickymartin9458]

TARS foreshadowing the ending lol

[@rowangoswell]

Somewhere between 1:00 and 1:47, they decided Miller's world was a better first-stop than Mann's world, and I just cannot fathom where it is. I'm not convinced they actually made a choice. they just saw the technical challenge of Miller's world and tried to solve it. And if that ain't scientist/engineers and hot-shot pilots in a nutshell, what is?

[@sadas3190]

The idea was that Miller's planet was transmitting FAR better data than the other two. Sure they could have visited the other two first, but that increases risk drastically. If something goes wrong and they have to abort, they may never get to visit Miller's planet. In terms of risk vs reward then it makes sense to go for your best shot first.

[@rowangoswell]

@@sadas3190 Yeah, but follow the conversation again: They had a bit of debate over what they should do, had a digression about time-dilation, and then Anne Hathaway's character just took over the choice and decided they were going to Miller's world. At no stage did they actually justify the choice, they just lost direction in the conversation and she made the choice for them.

[@sadas3190]

@@rowangoswell that's just an artistic choice then. Most movie dialogue don't follow actual science/work discussions as it would extremely boring to the casual viewer. As long as the viewer u derstands why they made their choice it's fine.

[@circa1890]

Having worked in the sciences for 20 years .. this kind of conversation has taken place in the lab plenty of times .. like it organically comes into play with each person speaking their own logic puzzle.

[@softy8088]

1:50-2:07 is the discussion which presents Miller's planet as the best choice and they all (silently) agree with that. If they go visit their other choices first and they don't work they'll have to go back to Miller's at great cost in resources. The optimal search pattern is to go to Miller's planet first, only the time-dilation is a dealbreaker. Everyone agrees.

[@canadiantesladventure]

"I wouldn't leave you behind Dr. Brand" *Proceeds to leave Doyle behind*

[@whatsgoingon07]

Doyle wouldn’t haul ass

[@marcelotapia3970]

He didn’t say he wouldn’t leave Doyle stupid

[@EL-ISS]

The amount of magical things in this movie that are theoretically possible is baffling ... Always loved space and the universe, this movie only reinforced that love. Also gave me a great appreciation for the arts that are filmaking and writing. The fact that there's no soundtrack playing in the background and the scene just allows you to sink into the immersion and science is lovely.

[@SWyrick366]

So basically, this planet is the hyperbolic time chamber, only reversed, where inside time moved insanely fast, and outside slow as fuck, that's insane.

[@DankMemez69]

"Hypersonic lion tamer"

[@user-ol9ck7ig2f]

@@DankMemez69 Popo: You get one more..

[@italianodblaugrana3842]

​@@user-ol9ck7ig2fhyperglycemic crime chamber

[@RetroRob420]

"No, it doesn't. That's why there's a plan B." That was cold as ice. (Must've been channeling his inner gamemaker there😄) And as always, Brand to the rescue with the misdirection of the conversation.

[@youtubehub8190]

"you're right, that's why there's a plan B" "now hold on a minute you fk"

[@trevorjensen2706]

Thank you so much for this, sir.

[@aaaaaa-hh8cq]

Way ahead of its time.

[@PK01234]

17 hours for every second on millers planet.

[@victormuhia750]

Coop's plan was so solid. I was immediately in.

[@Rydonittelo]

This was the best cinematic experience I had as an adult. Me and a close friend who were both physics geeks and Nolan fans and before we went into the theatre we took a hand full of Dehidracodine 30mgs , got our hotdogs and popcorn and it just blew our minds. we talking about movie all night afterward. It was amazing.

[@ParkerBG]

If you needed drugs to fully enjoy this movie, you couldn’t be that much of a physics geek…

[@Rydonittelo]

@@ParkerBG I didn't need them to enjoy it, I enjoy it without drugs numerous times without . I just enjoyed it way more than you did on my first screening in a cinema . What you are suggesting is like saying someone who went to a music event high on ecstasy must not really like the music which is silly. The ecstasy makes it incredible

[@rebelchcrik]

thats the reason american society is as it is now, 1/3 of people below the age of 18 has at least slept in prison at least one day, almost everyone is on some kind of opioid everyday....@@ParkerBG

[@VOIP4ME]

​@Rydonittelo Ecstasy makes everything incredible though. If you want someone to believe your review of an experience then don't mention you were on drugs.

[@eduardoleonlotero]

3:07 Wait but, that explanation makes no sense… if they know being close to Gargantua like being in the Millers planet, the time is way much less than being away from Gargantua, if they stay away and outside of the black hole, that wouldnt save them fuel, its literally the opposite. As they go to Miller and spend like a couple minutes in there, when they come back, the spaceship was waiting for years, they spent MUCH more fuel and MUCH more time by being away of Miller, instead of being close so that time passes similarly in both in the planet and in its orbit, as they have a very similar distance from the black hole. When they came back after their mission at Miller, the other person had been waiting for like 23 years, just waiting for them, while if they had been close to the planet, they would’ve both spend the same time, idk how to explain it

[@krishnamali6102]

For me that guy spending 23 yrs waiting makes no sens, I mean who tf waits that much in a spaceship for so long. He would've been dead a long ago due to depression.

[@cineman7936]

@@krishnamali6102 he tried to Hibernate as much as he could but I think the mission as well as how he said he spent a lot of time studying the black hole along with the robots kept him from offing himself

[@BrowncoatGofAZ]

I think the idea was to minimize how much time they spent in the time dilation zone. If they hadn’t been hit by that wave, they would’ve been in an out with hopefully a year at most of a difference. Instead they were stranded for over 3 hours.

[@tonybradford678]

I'm so glad you mentioned this. I was thinking the same thing.

[@dumpsterplayer2700]

I think you're saying that although they save fuel getting to the planet, they needed to use fuel to keep the spaceship running for the 7 years+ the ship would be running, so go to a planet that didnt have such a dilating effect first?

[@Foxhound3857]

Why is Doyle acting as if he knows something that Brand and Romily don't? Almost feels as if he's challenging Cooper on his ideas and analysis here because he already knows Plan A doesn't work.

[@ceIIardoor]

Can someone give me a good reason why they didn't just send the robot by itself? They would still experience the passage of a lot of time, but they could be together on the ship working on new ideas, and they could also decide to leave the robot behind if they change their mind. Couldn't they just leave the robot and then go explore the other planets, and come back to the robot if the other planets weren't viable? (Although that might be a fuel issue)

[@cj2smooth._.]

Robot would of been destoryed by those mountain waves

[@vinbones]

i feel like there's plenty of malfunction that could happen if they sent robots to control everything, and they have to actually experience what the planet is like (future living space for humans) there was a quote in the movie somewhere mentioned by matt damon that said robots not having the capability to feel fear or survival instinct were weak points

[@entropy8429]

I think it's because there's key parts of the ship's operating procedures that require the split millisecond precision of the robots, and losing one would be a huge loss for the mission as a whole. It's easier to think about in hindsight I guess, but without both robots they wouldn't have been able to pull off the maneuvers needed to redock and slingshot the black hole at the end of the movie.

[@freewiremedia215]

They shouldn’t have gone at all as a planet orbiting a black hole isn’t a long term solution.

[@ceIIardoor]

@@vinbones interesting point!

[@derivative3805]

ITS MORBIN TIME

[@jkman10]

I dont know why they thought this would be a good idea. Not even seeing what's on the planet, it's next to a giant black hole with a huge gravitational force. If they want to prolong humanity, doesn't seem like a good planet to do it on.

[@kevinwaag9976]

humanity has one generation at best. a black hole near a livable planet is still livable for a few thousands years. time enough to get out of earth and then later on to live this one too. they're on survival right now not proper

[@Karboooo]

hmm i just noticed during this plan, they stayed in the planet 3x more than was planned, by then the endurance wouldve probably been out of range with the orbit they had

[@ceIIardoor]

Romley or the robots may have corrected the range, or maybe were supposed to assume this ship just automatically corrected itself from some pre setting, but good point.

[@izsan9070]

TARS : Am I a joke to you?

[@bigbubu75]

Imagine since the movie came out it is just a hour on Millers planet

[@davidlorang7697]

That’s cool!

[@leonconnelly5303]

Lmao

[@abinmathew9851]

"Thats Relativity folks"... 💯

[@lieing619]

The team was talking about plan A then all of a sudden at 1:37 the guy informs everyone there is a plan B and they slowly look at each other and say along the lines of "this can't be real".

[@sidneyrodrigues728]

Psychological horror thinking about those long dwell times travelling through high gravity fields. That jaunt cost them like 28 years!

[@jeremylee6352]

Everytime I look at Doyle ... he's like aged so much since being Blackheart...

[@thlee3]

the robots were So important to movie … i immediately became attached to them

[@DarkWingDuck703]

Doyle always crying in space and the ranch

[@awkwardgaming9865]

The next scene was it was just an equation 🫡☹️

[@elvancor]

Yes, going to Miller's planet was a very dumb idea. But let's be honest, how many of us thought about that right when wacthing this scene for the first time?

[@largol33t12]

The altitude of the International Space Station is carefully tracked at all times. It already suffers from very light time dilation where time passes differently on two places. If you have an identical twin who is a few minutes younger than you, spend a few months on the ISS and come back to eaeth. You will be younger than your twin because time passes more slowly on the ISS than on earth.

[@taka-taktak]

This is the theory of Einstein's annus mirabilis, when he discovered STR.

[@wootle]

Fantastic intro clsssn on Relativity which is very very real. In fact our own bodies age at different rates becuse of it. GPS signals are corrected for relativistic effects or they'd send us to the wrong places!

[@Ubermensch9240]

Well as long as we don't end up traveling BACK in time I think I might be able to keep up.

[@anikasuraiyasura9158]

The timing thing is real is really amazingly creepy

[@ruychii]

It was actually very weird decision pushed by Doyle. He said it will took months to go to Mann's planet, or even longer for Edmund's planet. But his colleagues just said, 1 hour = 7 years in Miller's planet. So he concerned several months more than 7 years ? Even if they tried to descend into the Miller's planet as fast as possible, let's say they only required tenth of 1 hour = 6 minutes, it was still the same as 8 months in their spaceship's time. And there's no way they could do that in seconds. Clearly he never learned time management, and even as the scientist, looked like he wasn't too bright either, cause most of the scientist will figure out they will have to visit Mann or Edmund's planet first before even considering Miller's planet.

[@willrose5424]

Wait... they don't have hair spray in space

[@karlstriepe8050]

Jesus that little boy is so attractive!

[@zachsutton6195]

😕😕😕

[@NoNo-kf2ys]

They're all just figuring out that time is kind of a big deal after already making an expensive mission with people that should at least have an idea of how space works from youtube videos or something?

[@ashdonsimmons01]

if they would have just landed slow instead of trying to save time they might have seen the wreckage from the cockpit instead of getting caught by the wave

[@JustSomeCanadianGuy]

It was SO stupid to even think about landing on that planet. Just try one of the planets that doesn't have as great a relativity factor!

[@Usa12333]

My first time

[@KK-wc9wi]

So ddnt they know any data from Millers would not be up to date due to time dialation ?

[@DarkR8N]

Nice

[@vladpoluektov2217]

So does time dilation work while your stationery?

[@Jobsz1]

getting ur character into another server is hard

[@NeverDoubtTheWorm]

Can’t believe dude lied about the readings just to get picked up lol

[@caperoot]

Well hell, no matter how many times I watch this here flick I still can't reckon what the hell it's all about🤔 and what they keep'on talkin about that big ol' sammich from Jimmy John's for?...

[@googleuser5663]

On earth how do you explain this issue I am 52 so if I waste a year wasted of my life is like 5 years wasted to a 18 year old for example or is it like 4 years?

[@unknownfromkashmir]

I couldn’t understand one part - how did the black hole remain after the tesseract closed inside the black hole ( once coop finished transmitting data to his watch). I mean millers planet loses the gravity and it’s time dilational effect of warped space. Tf happened there ?

[@kevinwaag9976]

first: time is relative, that warmhole exist outside of normal space and time, so when you're in it you're basically in everytime. second they closed the tesseract, meaning that Fourth highest dimension so that coop can travel back and send messages, but they didn't close that warmhole. it's there. and at the end coop is going through it again to go back to the colony

[@unknownmangafreak]

I’m a bit confused. Knowing that time is a lot slower on that planet compared to earth, why didn’t they consider that that woman might only have just arrived? Seems odd to only click it after the fact

[@kp6007]

Your head ages faster than your feet 😊

[@mrpepre]

Astronauts having a conversation like this is goofy but guess you gotta explain it for the audience 😂. It’s not like they haven’t been training for this mission in years

[@Aname-hk4bu]

Tons of surprises. Surprising heroes with their abandoned children they decided were my responsibility while they stole my vehicle. Lovely movie tho.

[@1stKills]

If we were too inhabit a planet like that one day imagine the amount of time manipulation that could be pulled off

[@haydenwilliams1577]

They should've sent the robot down to the surface; emitting a steady pulse beacon for telemetry markers. If the pulses began to get farther apart, they'd know time was dilated and they could abandon the effort-saving many lost years.

[@defjunai]

that's relativity folks!

[@corinth492]

Universe you scary

[@adhilk5977]

the real life application of time dilation are GPS & satallites.

[@conmaxanhle123]

And they go to that place first when time is a problem. Smart peoples are send out of space

[@mihaelk1938]

How would a direct radio link look in this case? Would the person on ship wait for voice for 7 years???

[@kevinwaag9976]

not possible. no radio wave would get out because of the gravity field. even if you could somehow with technology advanced enough, the voices would be slowed so much that you wouldn't understand it, we're talking about tech so advanced that we can't fathom it yet

[@mihaelk1938]

@@kevinwaag9976 let say we have a wire connecting them that can sustain all the forces. I find it really strange but than again i have low iq

[@brandonflorida1092]

I think they were picking up radio waves that went through the worm hole.

[@gaayyak]

How could they miss that wave when they were landing 😅 It's like Daenerys missing the Greyjoy fleet just for the plot to progress

[@m.hernandez1404]

Yeah. That was my solution. Sure.

[@Tjd1982]

I will never understand how an hour on that planet is 23 years to Romilly who is orbiting above.

[@e.leohassanmodeste756]

I think the math is off cause in the movie, TARS said it’ll take about an hour for the engines to come back live after being flooded. 1 hour = 7 years as they stated. But when they get back, Romilly says he’s been waiting 23 (Earth) years for their return. So they had to have been on Millers planet for about 3.5 hours either upon arrival, including the descent plus 2 for how long they were there researching. That’s my take on it.

[@ebincd2362]

Romilly wasn't orbiting the planet, he was orbiting the black hole itself farther away

[@MrGilRoland]

I have a question: what would happen if the ship in orbit but outside the gravitational pull try to communicate with the team on Millers planet?

[@MrGilRoland]

Interestingly enough, I asked chatgpt, and it gave me the reply: if the team on the planet has the right communication tools, they should receive the transmission. But they can’t reply back, because nothing can travel faster then light, hence the radio transmission can’t escape the gravitational pull beyond the event horizon.

[@thegp2008]

@@MrGilRoland but Miller's planet ISN'T beyond the event horizon, it's just a bit closer than the ship. So eventually they'd receive the transmission, it would "only" take huge amount of time.

[@damedash261]

Is it safe to say then that everything that has and is going to happen has already happened??? 🙇🏽🧐🧐🧐

[@kevinwong8693]

365 * 7 = 2555 / 60 = 42.58 days on Earth passed for each minute on the planet.

[@720zone]

This is my all time favorite movie, but this small piece never made sense. Every hour on the planet is 7 years elsewhere. When they return they're told 23 years have passed, meaning they spent over 3 hours on the planet. They rush down as fast as Cooper can land. He rushes them to get to the beacon in minutes. The wave floods the engines and we're told they need "45 to an hour" to drain. They leave earlier than that because another wave comes. It seems like less than an hour on the planet; how was it 3+ hours???

[@knowpassword]

Is that the runner guy from Seinfeld?

[@kp6007]

I love this film, but there is no way you would even consider Millers planet as a viable option. It’s far too close to the black hole.

[@Alex233xx]

It’s a rotating blackhole so it’s not as bad

[@user-gn5nm2ij4o]

When i go to miller planet before , my pizza still fresh and hot from the oven . So , if you dont understand what im sayin , im sayin that i dont too .

[@RetroRob420]

It's a shame, since they would have been able to get a better look at the surface and its swells if they had chose to orbit like the initial plan (and then they could have possibly aborted with time to save instead of the opposite, and went straight for Mann's planet. Or.... maybe Edmund's would've been their choice instead, hopefully, cause ya know how that ended up. Who knows, maybe a 23-year younger Romily would have voted differently and sided with love though🤣).

[@keiramcgill9515]

Would you age and get older or stay the same age on this

[@clarke7703]

They should have just sent TARS alone

[@ceIIardoor]

Right. WHY DIDN'T THEY? HUGE plot hole.

[@manfedmedviq]

What a bad idea. Instead of collecting the data they hoped to find, they ended up loosing some precios time and a idiot crew member who couldn't move faster to literally save his life.

[@Foxhound3857]

Gravity on Miller's planet was 130% that of Earth. You try moving in gravity that heavy with water up to your ankles.

[@manfedmedviq]

@@Foxhound3857 I just watched the scene again. First, Dr. Amelia looses too much time trying to collect the data even after being told that a freaking giant wave is coming, and second, Doyle had way too much time to enter the ship, and at the last moment he wasted valuable minutes in admiring the giant wave, instead of getting in.

[@chinmayaparida5135]

@@manfedmedviq yeah rather than wasting fuel and time on searching of that stupid scientist who betrayed should collect data and get the way out

[@wiseogjc370]

Soooo... after all this conversation, is it possible that everyone on earth is dead while they execute the plan to go to Miller's planet? It's a grim realization that they did all that for nothing. Humanity goes extinct in the movie.

[@matana4567]

And much time they stayed on the Miller planet?

[@lolwhatidk]

going to that planet was so damn dumb in the first place lol

[@leszekhalama1173]

Romilly should also be in this range of action of this "powerful" gravity. So that the perception of time is the same for him as for the rest...But okay, Cooper mentioned something about fuel reserves there. Maybe that would have some bad effect on the fate of the mission or something? I assume I could be wrong. More powerful minds than mine were working on the script hehe. With Christ.

[@leszekhalama1173]

Okay I already know. Flying the main ship into the range of the black hole and then entering the small ship would be minutes, maybe a dozen minutes. Five minutes is half a year or so. Not knowing that there would be such problems, they actually might have wanted to save even one minute.

[@user-pc8wm1kb4f]

Science is the second best thing I have married other than my wife, cheers to the creator and it's creation ❤

[@ftrunks2k]

Whatever time in your life you watched this film. No-one cares. Enjoy it. Like we all did.

[@Al-cynic]

The bigger the blackhole, the weaker the gravity at the event horizon, so despite Kip Thorne's input, they could help but hollywoodize the science.

[@ceIIardoor]

Can you explain why? I don't understand this.

[@jackbyrne4635]

The lesson as always is f*** Wes Bentley

[@andrewjoseph5923]

Can someone do the conversion for me, how is 7 years only 1 hour. And if they spent 3 hours how did 23 years pass?

[@anticorncob6]

3 hours turns to 21 years, so it was probably slightly more than 3 hours.