Anathema - Comfortably Numb (A Moment In Time)

[@dcavfactory]

Anathema's "We're Here Because We're Here" CD is probably one of the most spiritual and riveting pieces of music I have ever heard. So sad that not many will hear its brilliance and acknowledge Anathema's passion. They have grown so much. Powerful. It is a total listening experience and beautiful. Sad, Sad state of music.

[@papantlaflyer68]

THE SPIRIT OF THE SONG IS completely honored, performed with soul and blood and they never tried to outshine PINK FLOYD,but to "ride" the feelings inside the song and embrace the pain... great cover in my opinion.. thanks for sharing it, man ...

[@andreascala2663]

as a HUGE PF fan i'm totally agre with you….great job!

[@BrendaMachuca]

Woooww!! any band that can cover comfortably numb like that deserves my respect. Just WOW!!

[@noeldnz]

PINK FLOYD AND ANATHEMA ! MY FAVOURITE BANDS !

[@ana021085]

The solo at the end it's absolutely fantastic, it really adds another dimension to this song, it makes it more powerful and meaningful . I might be the only one, but I clearly prefer this solo over the original. It seems to have more depth

[@fernandofigueredo9946]

😂 You're so crazy, girl

[@manuelaschuster5217]

This Band is so graet i cant find the right words, to Cover pink Floyd ..gaet i never Heard so a fantastic Cover, Anathema thank you all for your g graet Music 😎✌️

[@henrygonzalez5478]

it`s a totally anathema song. the sound and the style. they`ll never tried to be equal to PF. they`re the best Rock band ever... after Pink Floyd :)

[@Jorgitox619]

awesome! the best cover of comfortably numb i've ever heard. You can feel the passion the lead guitarrist while he's playing the solo (both of them)

[@gulceuysal1380]

Hmm, what I really think about covers.. I like the covers which was made because the band likes the original song. And this cover looks like it. The song actually fits them, maybe not musically but emotionally. I don't think Anathema covered it because they think they play better, but because they feel the song. And as long as they feel, they are perfect.

[@colinpartridge6423]

I

[@aoeuable]

Anathema, starting out as doom/goth, ever so slowly but surely evolved into a sound that is pretty much Pink Floyd without the LSD. As such they're one of the few, if not even only, bands on the world who can take a Pink Floyd song and neither copy it verbatim as a tribute, or change it beyond musical recognition to cover it, but just... play it: The way they're playing it could very well be an Anathema song on a random newer Anathema album, and yet you have to pay attention to hear how it's different from the original, how the only difference is the roadie failing to dunk the strings into LSD before the show.

[@txopito]

Only Anathema can make a live cover of "Comfortably Numb" with dignity... ¡BRAVO!

[@Eskarmory]

Não consigo acreditar que tem gente falando mal de um cover magnífico como esse... Feeling verdadeiro e a reprodução é quase genuína, não fosse por esses grandes músicos terem suas próprias e marcantes qualidades musicais. Como pode ter tanta gente à toa e hater pra ficar desqualificando algo tão maravilhoso...

[@vanderluis17]

Senti falta do solo final, mas ficou um belo cover, sem ser "plastificado " como outros

[@edwardspencer-small7021]

People bitching about the final solo not being as technically good as the original. Yes, that's true, but I feel like Danny's interpretation more accurately reflects the insular feeling of addiction. It's unsettling, and this solo reflects that. This entire cover is a mood piece, and that final solo fits in perfectly with that. The whole thing is far darker than the original, and I can't help but respect that.

[@TerribleTomy]

Just wow, this is the best cover I've ever heard.. love Anathema.

[@lucianav7606]

TBH, one of the best covers of Comfortably Numb I ever heard, it has a lot of feeling. And great guitar solos, the two of them.

[@digitalbladeca]

2019 - 40th year anniversary of The Wall.. Wow!

[@Burnyoursins]

Dude Pink Floyd is awesome, making Anathema the only band that doesn't suck at covering Pink Floyd songs

[@adriandinu5953]

They've also played Shine on, in their concerts. It's just a tribute to a great band. From another great band. As long as the message is sent with passion, why do we need to be "specialist"? Listen, feel, keep searching!

[@felozai]

Nobody will EVER come up with a guitar solo like this, EVER!!... It's unbelievably epic!!

[@octoberrust85]

Fucking hell. I didn't think it was possible to adore this band even more, but there they go and turn my brain on its head again. This is second only to the original song itself. Absolutely mind-blowing!

[@ericmorrison4446]

Gilmour's signature strat sound covered with a Les Paul leaves a little to be desired but Anathema totally killed it! Love this band and this song choice for them.

[@OmerC2]

Incredible distortion and solo.

[@williamcecil5280]

Cheers!!!!!I heard this cover into a live performance, it was in 2007 - Artmania Festival, Sibiu, Romania......Every now and then, I remain speechless

[@andrea-v2s]

one of the best covers of CN ever

[@khatatonia]

i love anathema and i love pink floyd even more, and vince's voice still gave me goosebumps. no one's as good as gilmour with this song, but they did a great job anyway! :)

[@digitalbladeca]

Just saw the chaps in Toronto... Not quite like this, but wow, absolutely stellar performance nonetheless! You all beautiful people, keep the real music alive!!!

[@foreverafter2000]

no one beat pink Floyd ever but i love the way anathema play it really

[@sagzzn872]

Best of the best cover of Pink Floyd!

[@moonchild5000]

really nice cover!!!they perform this mind-blowing song in an amazing way!!!

[@Tehchapster]

Love the scream at 3:20, this is so good!

[@OmerC2]

3:20 anathema: we’d like to remind u that we r a metal band.

[@luccakareem]

I'm know that you're going to give a lot of negative votes when I'll say that this is better than the original plus you have to listen for your possible pasts and better of dead performed by anathema I'm sure you're gonna love em

[@curieux35]

Danny plays well.... voiced i tell and guitar too

[@anathemadeathopeth]

the best cover ever made.

[@lauanathema]

I just love them!

[@metaljoe9088]

Been my favorite album since i was in grade school in the 80s. The wall that is

[@lacrimamosa]

the best cover of the best song!!

[@AlexisGolnas]

Anathema is truly amazing

[@Nutera1]

This song deserves only the best performance!!!

[@Chronomorte]

I think this is a great version - the goal isn't to 'reproduce' the original, but to respect it and give it your band's unique signature. I thought his solo was fine - it's not like anyone thinks they are going to make a 'better' solo than the original masterpiece, so nothing wrong with playing your own take on it.

[@flaviaangelica2358]

Fantastic version!!!Amazing...!!;;!!

[@geryfisherbg]

I stay in silence every time after I watch this cover- unique performance is the only thing i could say!

[@Sabin41]

@deftnes28 That is a very narrow viewpoint. Basically you can't accept that any band would want to play another bands songs for whatever reason, whether to pay it tribute, because it has the same kind of emotional meaning to them, or because it is just an awesome song that deserves to be heard another time. Johnny Cash covered Nine Inch Nails, bringing a lyrical masterpiece to a whole new audience. How is that wrong? The bands fans still love the original, they don't have to hate the cover.

[@ErickMaciasJuarez]

very nice, to be honest!! Anathema sounds so good live.

[@rooftrelen]

i love it when danny sings.

[@Thebigoted]

the song touches the guitarist's heart

[@ssmmeeaarrggllee]

one of my favorite songs ever, played by one of my favorite bands ever kewl

[@chadwick111fields]

Other than a genuine Floyd tribute band Anathema are the only ones who can convincingly pull this off. And they did here! Gives a pretty big clue about the bands' progressive heart!

[@keijox]

OMG! Love this song, love anathema... What a great video! ^^

[@PATBLACKIE]

ohhh i never heard some cover so beautiful! just perfect!

[@speedymice]

I love his songs... very great band

[@PrincessKagayaki]

Omfg... This is the best guitar cover I've heard. Certainly not better than Gilmour. I'm THE pickiest so if I'm saying this is the best cover of the guitar solo; I'm not lying. I usually dislike almost everyone who attempts it but this is GREAT! :D

[@digitalbladeca]

i respect Anathema's take on my favourite song of all time with the warmest feeling. Of course they did not hope to out-do one of the greatest musical prodigies in music history, but Anathema (and Antimatter for that matter) have created entire soundscapes of their own and changed the scene for those who care to look beyond mainstream. What is the big problem for a great band to show respect for their predecessors in a legendary fashion?

[@Killeroffloggers]

wuau.. 16 años de subido! realmente eso era "un momento en el tiempo"...que ya se fue. H E R M O S O ANATHEMA, ojalá se juntaran otra vez.

[@nocticiachannel1535]

Great as always !!!

[@dimitaregumenovski5619]

why you don't just stop arguing about the solo. for Christ's sake: THIS IS ANATHEMA, NOT PINK FLOYD!! you cannot compare them... both are best in what they do, and what they sing... and for once PLEASE STOP pointing so much attention to those who still do those shit like comparing.. if they can do it better, why they don'd just do it and leave us alone?

[@GSimenon]

I see no problem with the solo. Anathema played their loud, dark and deep music as usual, and they got no reason to imitate the solo of Pink Floyd however brilliant it is.

[@LeberCi]

dudes, this cover is great. it doesn't mean you have to play the song exactly like the band who sang it for the first time or like the band which owns the song. it means to play it your own way, to express feelings i a little different way. so, shut up and feel music, don't just listen ;)

[@monique3540]

very good cover nice suprise Anathema got such of lot of talent

[@hawaslianas]

WHY DID HE BREAK THE MARSHALL !!!!

[@tireoghain82]

Probably wished it was a Layney.

[@ivlackx]

cover.. its the best.. **

[@isolationav]

when i was talking to the band about this show they said they hated playing that gig they said it just felt like a shit night for some reason and things kept going wrong but i said it was an amazing show they put on but what can you do eh! they played this cover at one of the many times iv been to see them and when they played it in Glasgow i was a month away from going seeing roger waters in Amsterdam and it set me up perfectly anathema are the best band to come out of the uk in years

[@Lozanka34]

I love the song so much.......And I'm so glad that *Anathema* play it too...They are my last addiction!I'm musical *explorer* from few years..It's joke...Just love the music so much...And right now I feel *Anathema* so close to me.....

[@YBVANDEADPOET]

wooooow I got to say man, being a huge Floyd fan, Igrew up listening to them, I like this version so fucking much, I'm also an anathema fan, wooooow this is so beautiful, you don't have to decide wich one is better, floyd's or this, just enjoy this, and enjoy Pink Floyd as well...

[@ercan.kucukaslan]

bi de sorsan onlara; "zevkler renkler tartışılmaz abi" derler. evet bunun zaten tartışılıcak bi yanı yok: enfes! :)

[@AzaharSpain]

The Jadis cover of comfortably numb is the best I heard on youtube !!!

[@patrickrock666]

TREMENDO TEMAZO TOKADO POR UNA TREMENDA BANDA K ESPERO KON ANCIAS AKA EN CHILE PARA VERLOS NUEVAMENTE EN VIVO GRANDE ANATHEMA......................

[@Anathemer]

Anathema plays Pink Floyd = Priceless!

[@feiti635ceira]

yes, it feels a bit dirty to me as well, i suppose it's not the most easiest thing to do - to cover Pink Floy :) but the ending solo and stuff is damn insane in my opinion, you can just feel Danny drowning in it! Fucking powerful.

[@ephesian666]

GREAT ANATHEMA GREAT COVER ! LI AMO!!

[@Valkoisen]

im speechless, breathless, brainless.. anathema, pink floyd: perfect combination

[@coheed987]

i love anathema so much. but some things just cant be re-created.

[@borislozano]

i actually like this one better than the original its indeed a very different cover, but it has a big deal of anathema's feel to it, i like it a lot.

[@Pink000Floyd]

Wow what a nice cover!

[@Afterdark68]

Epic cover !

[@fernandofigueredo9946]

6:57 the epic moment 😏

[@tbarrettl]

In my opinion this is as good if not better than Dream Theater's good cover of this, I am digging that scream.

[@Silber7]

a great cover, worthy of some giants as PinkFloyd

[@metalballs666]

amazing cover..that ending solo was amazing.

[@PendulumEffect]

I think this is a great cover,it's not Pink Floyd,so what? Get over it!!!!! Anathema are a brilliant band paying tribute to one of their favourite bands and a fine tribute at that. I love Anathema,to me they are one of the only bands in the world that mesmerise me with their music and i listen to all types of genre. Good,honest music played by great, honest and hard working musicians. This band has been through alot but have kept together and made brilliant music.

[@jegermajster]

They hailed Pink Floyd and this is what matters. It was a perfect idea. They did not "desecrate" the original track.

[@Jared-Flynn]

youve never heard Pink Floyd's The Wall album? my friend you have not yet lived

[@diosanoli9035]

Esse solo é um orgasmo!

[@maurobilotti]

Nobody can sings better than him... you just said it!

[@Ensorcelled1913]

@deftnes28 I stopped taking you seriously when I realised that you're most likely a fan of Deftones. Anathema are an amazing band, and they put on one of the most spellbinding performances I've ever seen in Liverpool on Tuesday.

[@BesorgterAnwohner]

a force of nature

[@Жендосфера]

Братан не смог вытащить ) слился . но они другое могут , и очень гениально)

[@DelhySK]

The Best Cover for me... Softly and Strong; Sorry DM, Queensryche, Mostly Autumn... ... Anathema I miss the doom metal, But now it's... I don't understand it. I just like !!! Delfrego What are you do ? When I'm away... I'm close to you with music (Edya)

[@brujopanitos]

the greatest solo guitar ever

[@BLOEDVLEK]

that ginger guy sounds just like roger waters!!! this is a great cover

[@sajadzand]

Pink Floyd by Anathema .... great....

[@Kilzer60]

The música of my life

[@KarinaSotoS]

Wow.. pretty awesome..

[@josephduggan3215]

live at Liverpool cathedral.anyone.awsome DVD

[@L10161649]

Have to watch this from time to time to remind myself how to feel that "knot" in the throat whilst the eyes get wet...

[@alecsandervassalodearaujo2754]

Simplesmente LINDO!!!!!

[@patrickrock666]

@takisent si todo el mundo sabe que pink floyd es una tremenda banda pero anathema no se queda atras son muy buenos lo digo por que los he visto en vivo tocando este tema y ahora 31 de julio sera mi sengunda vez para verlos aqui en CHILE ....

[@unicornucopia1]

😳WOW🤩

[@TheMoonanique]

love this

[@abhikoolblue]

this is a Fckn gorgeous cover... not like dream theater's lame copy .... its different and Hands Down to danny for that Solo ... blows my mind !!!

[@antonioalejandroespinola]

Que buen cover !!!!!!.....muy logrado!!!!