Ancient Egyptian Cosmogony - The Origins of the Egyptians

[@Crecganford]

Are there any gods or myths in Egyptian mythology you would like to know more about?

[@pendragon2012]

Thoth might be one of my favorite gods in any mythology. I'm always down to hear more about him. And since seeing Moon Knight, I am curious about Khonshu and Taweret as well.

[@N1ghthavvk]

I'd like to know more about Nephthys. She's often skipped over in popular stories, and wikipedia doesn't tell us too much about her either (apart from her assumed general roles).

[@adambuss654]

I like the idea of the world and sky being made, and then split. It leaves open the idea of a time in between the split, where the world was in a godly state

[@MrTryAnotherOne]

Could you cover the egyptian golden age: the creation and the decimation of mankind? There are so many similar myths about this in ancient Sumer, India, Greece and Egypt that IMHO there is probably a common origin (indoeuropean?) - despite the many differences within each mythology. Not sure if these originated at about the same time, though.

[@janeslater8004]

Minoan snake Goddess

[@miketacos9034]

This channel has covered so many mythologies I didn’t even know about, so this video makes Egypt feel totally new.

[@wireless849]

I would love more material on Mesopotamia. I have heard so little about it, but it seems so important.

[@Crecganford]

It is incredibly important to much of the mythology, and so religion, in the "Western world". And I will talk about it more in the coming months.

[@roddo1955]

​@@Crecganfordtell us about the city of Uruk!

[@mellie4174]

​@@Crecganfordcan't wait!

[@AClaiderman]

While I don’t have direct links right now. There are so many KZbin videos about Mesopotamia. Like so many. Just learn how to use your search bar. It’s so fascinating.

[@Lobo-Lobo]

Hey type in Mesopotamia 5 times in your yt search......you'll c the volume of Mesopotamian stuff

[@adamhoward7277]

Really been enjoying this series! Would you ever consider covering Uralic or Basque mythologies? I’m guessing they probably also have really old substrata that also show up in other mythologies (for example Asko Parpola’s suggestion that “asura” comes from a Uralic word meaning “lord”) that I’d be really fascinated to learn more about

[@Crecganford]

Yes, I am slowly researching Uralic mythology, and so maybe in the coming months I can do something.

[@henridelagardere264]

Only a week or so ago, we were listening to Alice Coltrane's _Ptah, the El Daoud,_ a soothingly beautiful, spiritual album, and here you come today. Thanks for *your* inspiring work!

[@JonnoPlays]

Love your channel! Thanks for putting in the work so we can finally get the straight story.

[@markwrede8878]

Annual flooding of the Nile would drive denizens to primordial hills. The Nile had likely been inhabited by hominid ancestors for a million years.

[@teyanuputorti7927]

I been fascinated with Egypt since I was 7 but ever really heard their creation story thanks for telling it. The reason being everything I read and watched didn’t cover it.

[@megasupreme9985]

There's been a lot of focus on Proto-Indo-European mythology in academia, and to an extent on this channel. I love the work you do, especially with your resources in the mythology database. It would be rather lovely if you could do something regarding the Proto-Afroasiatic mythology. They gave rise to the renowned ancient egyptians and the various semitic peoples, as well as a whole plethora of lesser known groups in northern africa... it deserves much more attention than it has gotten.

[@Crecganford]

I would love to, the trouble is finding good evidence to support these. But I'll do some more research and see what I can find.

[@TheLastAxeman]

John I really love your videos, thank you for bringing actual scholarship to people who cannot actively study it via academia and work in the field. You're a hero!

[@Crecganford]

Thank you.

[@MatthewCaunsfield]

So many creation myths in Egypt! Love it 👍

[@nils8584]

So good! What I enjoy about these myths is that you get an idea of the collective human mind and imagination, and I think it can help aproximate a kind of truth about the meaning of it all. Thanks so much for this content!

[@andrewcutler4599]

Another vote for Basque. Mal'ta Buret culture and dogs would be nice, and any of their contacts with the Gravettians.

[@axebearer]

I'd love a video discussing the role of Apep in Egyptian mythology, and any possible provenance shared with chaos serpents in other mythologies. Are we apes just naturally afraid of snakes and that's why they keep appearing in these roles, or is there maybe some older tradition they all stem from?

[@aanchaallllllll]

0:20: ! The secrets of ancient Egypt hold the key to the creation of life, the universe, and everything. 4:45: 🌍 The Egyptian creation myth begins with the reunion of Shu and Tefnout, leading to the birth of Geb and Nout, and the subsequent separation of earth and sky. 9:35: 🌅 The myth of the creation of Memphis involves Ptah, the first artisan, emerging from the primordial waters of chaos. 14:20: 🌞 The Heliopolitan myth describes the creation of the universe and the importance of solar theology. 19:09: 🔑 The myth of Thoth and the tradition of Ptah in ancient Egypt. 23:29: 🌊 The Enuma Elish and the Heliopolitan creation myth have similarities in the motif of the primordial waters and the formation of land. 28:22: 🌍 Ancient Egyptian beliefs about creation and the cosmos. Recap by Tammy AI

[@dcmurray6466]

The way you started, I thought you would find the answer would be 42!! Still, I enjoy your videos, they are very well researched and presented - shows good scholarship. Thank you. Looking forward to the next one!

[@Crecganford]

I'm glad you got the reference.

[@Mortismors]

The sacred number of Hermes was 4 so that's halfway there. All the secrets of reality are contained in the number 4... The biggest epiphany I've had with this is that heaven or the spirit world is the fourth dimension.

[@kylemacarthur9863]

Crecganford videos are the ONLY videos i save for the weekend like a reward. Your videos are amazing! I do a little jig when one comes out!

[@Crecganford]

Thank you.

[@-zorkaz-5493]

The separation of Earth and Sky is also pretty prevalent in Maori mythology with Rangi and Papa. How the myth made it all the way there must be quite the story ...

[@starryeye6511]

I really enjoy your research and work, thank you for sharing with us

[@lbr88x30]

Hope you will do more on Egyptian mythology. This was wonderful.

[@jaredjordan9863]

Excellent video, although there was one very common oversight. Upper and Lower Egypt were two very distinct cultures. They became more homogenized after The First Intermediate Period, but understanding the roots of these cultures is important to understanding differences in their mythology. The Upper Egyptians were most likely Africans moving due to the desertification of The Sahara. They were moving East and then traveled North along The Nile until they ran into The Lower Egyptians. As such, their roots were distinctly African and share the same roots as The Serer culture and religion. The Lower Egyptians came to the Nile Delta from The Levant. It's also likely that there was migration from Anatolia. So The Lower Egyptians would have had heavy Proto-Indo-European influences. These two groups would have also been genetically distinct. We see this in The Papyrus on Ani. His wife Tutu is depicted with light skin while Ani is depicted with dark skin. His funeral is depicted with both light and dark skinned mourners. So when talking about the genetics of The Ancient Egyptians, it's important to know which part of Egypt genetic samples were taken from.

[@NiejakiDD]

Mesopotamia influencing culture of Egypt, including creation myth and pyramids - it's most revealing to me in this video. 🤷‍♂ Thank you, Crecganford.

[@upsidedown4734]

I'm sharing this with Jordan Peterson. Your narration is superb.

[@davidfigueroa6351]

This channel is excellent!

[@Crecganford]

Thank you so much!

[@davidfigueroa6351]

@@Crecganford Without a doubt brother. Thank you for your educational videos. Pure gold !

[@chinmaychandraunshuh]

thank you for this video, It's awesome to learn about myths from around the world.

[@PlanetDeLaTourette]

Consider the depth of thought. The ogdoad is quantum foam. An abstract space of forces. Four male/female pairs. I think these pairs are also structured as opposition/complement. A sort of yin yang. Animating principles are anthropomorphized. Depictions use patterns in those, which might be significant. The raise of the Amun pair created a new pair: void. The raise of the Amun is a big bang. Physical reality unfolds. Then it's more problem solving. It must be a dung beetle that pushes the sun forward. Mechanism. They saw it happening; these creatures pushed balls (crap) (from which new life emerged (eggs in dung)). It should be noticed that humans could think of an empty space as an absolute beginning. Then they tried to formulate forces that created reality. It's physics. Sort of. It is not a crazy idea from far in the past. It is how we think today. At the moment of establishment of civilization the philosophy was quite advanced. Humans are apes and had deconstructed the universal principles back to zero, nothingness. Then a logic of continuation was applied: male/female pairs. Then it takes a lot of leaps. These fundamental constructions are interesting and funny. They worked with what they had. On top of a pyramid stands a benben stone. It refers to the first land on which the light rays are cast. At sunrise these peaks lit up first. That's why these pyramids are so big and precise. The creation of the universe. Every day.

[@GarOfTheField]

What a way to wake up!! This was great as always! Thank you, Jon!! You’re the man!!

[@erikthalman]

"... one that doesn't come from a fantasy world." 😂 Dr. White, could you do a video about the Pharoah Akhenaten? I've read articles in big magazines about him, with claims ranging from his monumental but short-lived influence on Egyptian culture, religion, and art, to readings of him as the first genuine monotheist, and wild claims of him as a historical inspiration for Moses or Abraham! Would you be interested in tracing the Pharoah's influences in myth and his revolution for Aten the One God? Would love to hear your perspective!!!

[@sarahtoshiparsons9388]

Absolutely awesome…. I have had a thing about Thoth and Ra and eyes for such a long time and you are confirming my belief of who we are/were/can be as beings of love in alignment with nature and allowing for all possibilities that we work as a whole and that beauty and peace in action is possible whilst living in chaos and madness ❤ thank you

[@JB-jkhb1972]

You are doing an excellent job. Really enjoy all your videos a lot 👏👏👏👌

[@Crecganford]

Thank you so very much for your support, it is so appreciated. This will be used to buy a book, and maybe more tea bags. Thank you.

[@JB-jkhb1972]

@@Crecganford 👍🫖☕️

[@duivelgeen]

EXTREMELY BEAUTYFULL COSMOGONIC MYTHS FROM ANCIENT-EGYPT INDEED .THE LAST FROM PTAH-ONE ARE MOST FAVORITE TO ME!THANKS FOR THIS INFO, IT WAS VERY INTERESTING AGAIN.

[@supEnoc]

This is my new fav channel for falling asleep

[@aariley2]

It's so interesting to see how similar these myths are in disparate regions. Isn't it time we all adopted the religion of love? We are all the same. These myths prove it.

[@Arnsteel634]

I named a place on a hexmap for a dnd setting Crecganford. It is a place people go to commune with spirits in search of truth and understanding. Many spells of divination can be cast there more easily and it is easier to commune with the spirits of forgotten lore. I know it may be silly. But I have used your videos as inspiration for creating mysterious lore for quite a while now and your work is far more important than that. But I enjoy your videos for many other reasons too

[@MaximusOfTheMeadow]

Anciant Egypt, possibly my First love If a five year old can feel such a feeling

[@Lucien_75]

Grateful for your endeavors sir. This is the best I can do for now.

[@Crecganford]

I really do appreciate your support and kind words. They are very much appreciated.

[@pieternoordenbos]

Finally you are talking about the Ptah in the room!!! I have been wondering about that strange coincidence for some time now.

[@JM-hr4xp]

Thanks!

[@Crecganford]

Thank you so much for your support, it is appreciated.

[@flamencoprof]

E-books I have read, free from Project Gutenberg: - Creation Stories: - Sir E. A. Wallis Budge - Legends of the Gods Chapter I (Seems close to the Heliopolitan relatef here.) Sir E. A. Wallis Budge - The Literature of the Ancient Egyptians Chapter VI General Stories: - W. M. Flinders Petrie - Egyptian Tales, Translated from the Papyri First series, IVth to XIIth dynasty W. M. Flinders Petrie - Egyptian Tales, Translated from the Papyri Second series, XVIIIth to XIXth dynasty

[@conorhenderson8537]

Egypt also had influence on mesopotamia too. Creation tales with Gods is egyptian too and brought to near east as well. 6000 years ago.

[@dlmiller7873]

Fascinating and excellent. Thank you.

[@adempc]

Beautiful stories, they feel true in some weird way.

[@joesantos7085]

Hopefully you will cover Anubis he has always been my favorite Egyptian god if you haven't already. Keep up the good work.

[@RichardChave-xl9yw]

You mentioned Ra rising from the lotus. Is this what is actually depicted in the famous 'Dendera Lightbulb' bass relief?

[@customsongmaker]

The earth and sky embraced each other closely, husband and wife, but were separated. Indonesia has a similar story, but adds that rain began as the tears of the sky, sad that she was separated from her husband. In some African myths they say the sky was low to the ground, so that men could reach up and take pieces of it. But it was taken away out of reach. The Bible says that rain did not exist at first. Then it rained for 40 days and 40 nights, and only after that did rainbows appear. Presumably the sky would have seemed much closer to the ground, if there had been a permanent layer of clouds that had never before been dissipated. The Flood was also the point at which the human lifespan was drastically decreased. Modern science says that the primary cause of aging is cellular damage from the sun's free radical radiation, which may have been filtered by the layer of clouds. Egyptian stories agree that those who lived before did not age and die like us. Where else could those gods continue to survive, and have longer lifespans, without direct sunlight and its radiation? In the underworld, the vast system of underground tunnels and chambers beneath the ancient cities. But maybe some people began to worship the sun, since the old gods were afraid of it.

[@henchy3rd]

Apparently the Dogon tribe of Mali,west Africa were of Egyptian decent & for some reason they left. Now a truly unique pagan people who knew all about the Sirius star system & Jupiter’s moons thousands of years ago & strange stories of pre-historic earthworks linked to all mankind.

[@francisfischer7620]

Oh my goodness!! I'd never heard this creation myth - but the way you tell it makes it feel personal! Like it must surely be my own! My old Scottish ancestors must have turned over in their graves! Thank you!! So magnificent! Dr. Fischer

[@gregvondare]

What strikes me first is the similarity to the Grecian myths detailing the generations of gods: Ouranos to Kronos to Zeus. And their various sub-gods and goddesses. I read somewhere that the importance of Gobekli Tepe is that it represents the moment in time when humanity first shifted from animal gods to human figures. The Egyptians carried a part of that ancient tradition with them in putting animal heads on human figures -- although this may have been an echo of the shamanic practice of wearing an animal skin or head during a ritual of penetrating the other world to receive visions or premonitions.

[@richardmixon8177]

Need info on Thoth, everything about space & time. Might of discovered something.

[@oscodains]

I think that these creation motifs are under-used in tracing human history. I had no idea about this area of study until this channel. Combined with archeology and genetics, it provides even more evidence in tracing humans throughout history.

[@hihatter2784]

Been watching since the day, well done on you silver KZbin button 💪

[@Crecganford]

Thank you so much.

[@Arnsteel634]

On lunch break. Off this weekend and will catch up on all the videos I have missed with English Breakfast Tea

[@TioDeive]

Thank you for one more fantastic video.

[@Vgn1701]

My second semester of studying Egyptology (and Latin) starts tomorrow so it's perfect that I found this, really curious who this turns out. But judging from the other videos I watched, I'm sure it's gonna be great. :)

[@SuperRobinjames]

Thanks

[@debbiepatch3135]

Awesome job thank you for all your information

[@sakuanallah7]

If you don't mind.. Nun doesn't mean 'Nothing'. It means Formless. Atem sitting on the Hill produces Air and Moisture. This is the Atom forming the Formless into Solids, Gases and Liquids. Ptah 'PTH' means The Path. The mathematical course inherent in all things.

[@erinaltstadt4234]

Thank you

[@tommytomasita1599]

Awesomeness!!

[@initiatesoflight1723]

Thanks!

[@Crecganford]

Thank you so much for your support, it is appreciated.

[@the_lotharingian]

When i studied mythology the egyptian creation myth in the text book was the one where creation is done through "self love" Where is that one from?

[@LokiSilverFlame]

One version of the story says that before Atum coughed or spat up Shu and Tefnut he first ejaculated in his own mouth.

[@laurac8659]

I absolutely love your channel ❤

[@Crecganford]

Thank you.

[@PlanetDeLaTourette]

Bennu (Earth diver) is an aspect not mentioned (in the myth of Heliopolis). This bird flies over the primordial waters and its call manifests the first phenomena. The benben (first land). We can see a relation in these names. Ben means manifest or placement. Bennu seems to mean repeatingly manifesting. Benben (double = emphasis) seems to mean very manifested. The later phoenix myth seems to have its root here (returning bird). We can find traces of Ptah being the creator of aspects of the ogdoad and ennead. Interesting aspect. I suspect that there was an attempt to fuse the several myths. Egypt seems to be a Mediterranean culture. There is a lot of fuzz about the blackness of Egypt. Recent DNA research seems to indicate that today's Egyptians have a stronger relation with sub Saharan Africa than the old Egyptians. Though Egyptians may have been African a.f., the cultural influences are dominated by the Levant, as is the DNA connection, which might have come from Egypt in a deep past. River deltas have always been the soil for cultural powerhouses. I think that the Nile was colonized from there after the Sahara became a desert, millennia before the development of Egypt. Where do myths come from? Certainly the deep ancient stories are being carried forward for a very long time. But Egypt is also a translation of that landscape. The life giving water cutting through the desert, from south to north. Egypt is great for study because of its weird isolation (though trade and connections of the ancients is generally underestimated). It brings an interesting clarity. Though this situation has also been a death trap. The drought in the first intermediate period was truly hell on earth. Complete decimation. This brutal suffering was an ultimate shock and disillusion. This too has shaped the ideas of forces and the perspectives on evil. In this sense Egypt was created several times.

[@augustusprincepsvictoria77]

ty for the info.

[@kassraamidi9283]

thank you for always addressing Graham Hancock as a joke

[@SamtheIrishexan]

I wish they would go deeper. There has to be a way to get past the water levels at the Osirion for example. There is more down there I know it.

[@PlanetDeLaTourette]

I dropped some earlier comments. Amun and Bennu (phoenix) can be seen as one thing. It's a chicken or egg thing. That's the fundamental problem here. Something has to create the cosmic egg. The bird shrieks and Amun is the shrieker. The first sound. Then the egg in the ogdoad with its four m/f pairs, with Amun/Amunet. Then the egg breaks and a new reality emerges. It is the past, a golden age, but Amun/Amunet are at work, hidden in the background. Bennu has the quality of returning.

[@MichaelYoder1961]

Always love your content, Jon! Would love to hear you talk about why cats were so important to Egyptian religion. I saw a post about the first known named cat as "Nedjeh" (sweetie). Curious, me being a cat person. And I suppose conversely, were dogs revered?

[@Loooppp]

You study the writings, but there is full off graphic descriptions in tombs and monuments. Its a hard work i know ...! Im trying but its my first video, it would be nice watch your version ! 👍

[@SimonkaShow]

When I hear the beginning description of non I can't help but think of the universe before the Big Bang if you take the rest of the story imagery and not take it literally but more as a metaphor it sounded pretty much like the current mainstream theory of the Big Bang

[@smillstill]

The frustrating thing about mythology is that realization that you have started watching it 75% of the way through the movie, is some ways, and 99% of the way through in others. We see Mesopotamia and Egypt interacting before 4000 BC, but have almost no idea what their mythologies were before 2500 BC. We see evidence of a few gods, like An, Ninlil and Inanna pictograms existing in 3100 BC, but no idea what they represent or their mythologies. We have no creation stories from Mesopotamia before about 1100 BC. These Egyptian stories and their prehistoric interaction with Mesopotamia make me wonder if, like the Egyptian creation stories, An was originally a lone creator formed out of the formed from the waters of chaos and Ki, his consort, came later, or Ki, Ninlil and Ninmah all diverged from a single unknown mother goddess who came about later after An.

[@Sarke2]

And we get to the question who influenced Mesopotamians and their myths?

[@Crecganford]

Now that is a very interesting question, and something I am very deep into researching.

[@sedwillful]

Africans, since "egyptian" lore predates Mesopotamians.

[@raycosmic9019]

The actualization of potential is Infinite and the potential for actualization is Infinite, because only Eternity can fully embrace Infinity. That which is, that is nothing in particular (actual), is by definition everything in general (potential).

[@dukelake7412]

Jon, to understand what you're saying. Atum is, "Adam". Nun is, "Night", as well as the word, "nothing", at the same time. Coughed is spoken, sneezed is like a bull, angry. I know over 100K words from Egyptian to coniform, the hieroglyphs are like baby writing. The wheat and barley are people, not food. Silver is a word that means, "good word of mouth", to have been/or be spoken highly of. So, like you said, he sneezed, I said which is like a bull, angry, which is to say that the Lion was created which caused moisture which is tears. The description of the divine deities are seasons of types of people, which the 1 created 2, the 2 created 4, the 4 created 8, and only doubles to 8. The main 4 are the 4 rivers, Lion, Lamb, Man and Eagle, sometimes known also as Lion, Unicorn, Man, and Serpent. These when combined are 12, 12 Elders, or 12 Seats, or 12 Cosmoses, or 12 Universes, or 12 thrones.

[@dukelake7412]

@@Ekmanto That was written to Jon White, he knows all these stories, just was pointing out a couple things, "HE", would understand. Question? If what I say can be backed up, and you said, " information that can’t be backed up", sounds like you don't know it, not that it can't be backed up. So, sounds like again, you're saying it's not true without knowing. A bit of advice, don't do that, you give no one incentive to help you to know. In the bible it says, “And the four angels were loosed, which were prepared for an hour, and a day, and a month, and a year, for to slay the third part of men.” The word, "Month", means them of astrology. Now learn what, "an hour", and "a Day", and "A year" means.

[@nuclearmaga9694]

really good

[@real-timelabel-freeimaging4653]

Splendid...many thanks... already with the first three creations, it become obvious for me,how much was transferred into the bible... "GOD over the waters of NUN, speaking and making the sun..."... didnt know this, thanks for the wisdom you brought to me...thx

[@evan_james]

Sounds like Early Egyptians origin story is a major volcanic eruption. I've always speculated the pyramids were made to represent mountains or volcanos. Kilimanjaro, Maru, and Monduli share similar spacing, but Kilimanjaro would have erupted 360,000 years ago so that seems unlikely.

[@loveiskey7833]

Everyone went there to learn the esoteric knowledge of the universe

[@redwaldcuthberting7195]

In the beginning there was watery chaos and then the first land appeared called Punt in the shape of a pyramid.

[@j.g.4942]

It's interesting the interactions of mythologies; The Ten plagues of the Torah's Exodus reflects the Ennead (9+Horus/Pharoah), effectively it's a tale of YHWH's defeat of the gods of Egypt. I wonder how other mythologies spoke of their conflict/interactions? I know the Greeks and Romans often just said that the other gods were simply other manefestations, yet Assyria seems to have seen them as figures to force into submission (although perhaps we don't have myths from there as the empire didn't last long?)

[@shanegooding4839]

Ptah was also associated with fire and metal, something he appears to have in common Yahweh.

[@jenifehlberg3189]

I would like to know who the Anunnaki were/are and what’s the book of Enki. Do you have anything on that topic?

[@pallasashta9129]

The hermopolitan myth is the more atlantic one ;)

[@jakeaurod]

I've read that the story of Marduk and Tiamat was relatively recent, to promote the dynasty in Babylon, which postdated Akkad and Sumer in Mesopotamia, and would have been written much later than Egyptian myths. Is there earlier evidence of Tiamat in earlier Mesopotamian traditions? I've read that Tiamat can refer to the sea but also a monster, so might it be related to serpent stories from Africa or India instead?

[@Crecganford]

The video I recommend at the end of this video is a mythological comparison between Tiamat and the Vedic Vitra, and so you may want to watch that as what I found out surprised me.

[@shanegooding4839]

The Marduk version is a later form of earlier myths but is more complete.

[@TheManCone]

The Egyptian gods were the angles that fell. The description of angels having heads of animals and how they had powers like God but not as awesome (Moses battling that wizard) frankly their day bringer was lucifer, then they got found out and ousted.

[@brentoniverson1020]

🔥 🔥 🔥

[@pattiwicksteed3731]

The separation of the sky and earth is also part of the Maori creation myths.

[@biomuseum6645]

I appreciate very much the reduction of ai images 🙏

[@KipIngram]

Jon: What's your opinion of the theories that the Pyramids (well, the Sphynx, at least) were built much earlier, at a time when the region still experienced a lot of rainfall? I kind hate that the Graham Hancock types have grabbed hold of that idea so hard, because at its core the arguments about the erosion patterns on the Sphynx seem to have some real merit, and I haven't heard any real rebuttal yet - mostly just experts waving the idea away and saying "No, you're wrong because we're authorities." Poor Graham - I've watched a few of his videos, and he can start out making a semi-convincing case, but then he just can't seem to help stumbling off into the weeds.

[@Crecganford]

Graham is a very good story teller, but alas his embellishments and occasional nonsense mean all his work is considered a no-go for academia. The pyramids I've discussed in a short video, and there is a very clear evolution of them, as for the sphinx, I think this is much harder to date. A shaped rock, reshaped, possibly a number of times, over time. I certainly don't think it can be any older than 7kya.

[@KipIngram]

@@Crecganford Yes, that doesn't surprise me at all. He seems like a kind-hearted enough sort of guy, and I think he actually means well, but he does get "lost in the wilderness." He shows up now and again with Randall Carlson, who I tend to feel similar about. Carlson does seem to have some fairly good data, and I think he may be right about the Younger Dryas being connected with asteroid/comet fragment impacts. But watch him enough and he also gets into some strange places. I think he even got involved with some sort of "free energy" nonsense in the last few years, which is one of my biggest pet peeves. Anyway, I just want to say that I have tremendously enjoyed your channel since I found it a week ago or so - I'm on Christmas vacation right now, through next week, and you are supplying the bulk of my leisure activity these last days. Thanks so much for all the energy you've invested in this work - I've learned a ton. I've subscribed. 🙂 I haven't checked out your Patrion yet, but I likely will - I do like to try to give a little back to the people that I think I've truly learned from.

[@gruboniell4189]

Ball lightening. You gotta look up Martin fleischmann memorial project

[@mediakings9401]

it's strange how you went off about the middleastern influence on Egypt yet mention nothing about Nubia (Ta-Seti) ....very strange specially due to the fact the only 1 out of the 4 creation myths on your chart was comparable to Mesopotamian myths. I think it's beneficial to put aside this idea of superiority. The main reason the Nile Valley and Mesopotamia were so developed is because of the locations. Also, according to the Bible Noah's son Ham founded Egypt, The Levant and Nubia (Kush) . And Nimrod (son of Kush) Founded All the Cites of Lower Mesopotamia. Cheers !

[@dejanzmaric5735]

my personal believe is that COSTUME OF NIRVANA (to achieve by denial of pleasure and mummification process holiness with one, origin) have both bases of wester belief systems, first achieving after life with process of mummification than later achieving same with denial of pleasure.? So origin of both systems should be practice of both in one costume. And most interesting thing to me is that, "gods" worshiped people who achieved status of nirvana lived on Tallest MOUNTAINS so they fit in middle phase systems, in between, roughly speaking?

[@ernestschroeder9762]

It's strange because we're in a time of technical change and the world changes fast. Has it always been thus?

[@eightness888]

you bring up the term "At" for order really got me thinking of the Buddhist term Atman, like the word Buddha or enlightened ones something like that. Basically I'm just asking if you've seen any connections between the Egyptian and Buddhist histories?

[@eightness888]

I also wanted to ask if you had any knowledge on Charles piazzi Smythe, he was the royal astronomer of Scotland in the 1800s that literally took a ruler and measured every square inch of the pyramids and his book The Great pyramid documents that.

[@skynet5828]

Tefnut being moisture is an outdated belief. In modern egyptology she is more commonly associated with fire.

[@Mortismors]

I always thought it was Amun-Ra who cleaved the heavens from the earth. First time I'm hearing it was Atum-Ra.

[@francisfischer7620]

I bet your kids absolutely adore your bedtime stories!!

[@Crecganford]

Maybe 17 years ago… but now, not so much.

[@MaximusOfTheMeadow]

You said Atum the Son?? How very insetting.. A single Son born from a (at that moment in "time") single creator God

[@evanstential]

For all that stuff in them sands, Id expect this subject to be a bit longer

[@KipIngram]

These Egyptian creation myths seem... "simpler" than the Proto Indo European derived myths you've talked about.