Andrew Tate Thinks British Colonialism was Good for India

Check out our recently published book ‘Reading the Classical Texts of Marxism’ by Dr. Thomas Riggins: www.midwesternmarx.com/books....
If you enjoyed our video please consider checking our website out :
www.midwesternmarx.com/
Also, if you are interested in helping us fund our project become a Patron :
/ midwesternmarx
Check out our online library for FREE books on Socialism, Philosophy, History, and more:
www.midwesternmarx.com/online...
Listen to our Podcast on Spotify:
open.spotify.com/show/3Dv6Dvc...
Follow us on Instagram: @midwesternmarx
Follow us on Twitter: @MarxMidwest
Like us on Facebook: @Midwestern Marx

[@almightypush2251]

Imagine stealing someone's money and then calling them poor.🥴🏴‍☠️🏴‍☠️🏴‍☠️

[@OnlyPixelOne]

True, ikr

[@mohammedsiyam3544]

They dominated

[@Rockstarmade224]

@@mohammedsiyam3544 exactly so it wasn’t good for India u bozo 🤡

[@HebrewJerusalemBoy]

Ikr the same way the did Africa

[@jamesswindley9599]

UK shouldn’t have to repay anything though, we should be 100% giving India help to industrialise and improve their economy to help all! ❤

[@MuskanKumari-st8up]

Looting 45 trillion.... what a development

[@ARCWIZARD]

A little railway structure and some old buildings for 45 trillion....what a deal 💀

[@rollinslab9659]

​@@ARCWIZARD building Railway not for indians but for carrying 45 trillion dollar wealth to Europe. 🫣

[@Ali920a]

​@@ARCWIZARD Are your leaders sharing as much wealth now ? Do you even have roads

[@mudra5114]

Looting 45 trillion is a myth.

[@mudra5114]

​@@rollinslab9659 Railways was built to fight famines.

[@MiserableMuon]

Not to mention, the horrible atrocities done by the British against the Indian subcontinent.

[@halthegoat]

Fucking cry about it. Weird how the only thing throughout all of human history that people cry about is British colonialism. Not the billions of other horrific acts throughout tens of thousands of years commited by every country.

[@baileygregory9192]

was it any different to what other conquering powers did prior to britian?

[@prikipriki30]

​@@baileygregory9192It's not, so what?

[@baileygregory9192]

@prikipriki30 so if every one else doing it at the time them why we holding historical individuals and empires up to modern standards especially whilst ignoring other empires, its just being selective and dishonest to do so. Britian was no different than the Mugals

[@jojo.s_bekaar_adventures]

​@@baileygregory9192difference is, they were indian, so at least wealth stayed in India British exploited india and took the wealth with them

[@borkingborker5567]

It's funny how it's only Westerners think that India benefited from British colonial rule meanwhile the whole of India vehemently disagrees.

[@hirenahir76200]

Because it's not true India was richest at that time and also from Pakistan,Nepal,Bhutan, Bangladesh was part of indian empires like Mughal and than Marathas but British looted and divided us

[@ashishpanwar6129]

Summary of Indian GDP (1-1947 AD) From the 1st century AD to the start of British colonisation in India in the 17th century, India's GDP was between about 25 and 35% of the world's total GDP, which dropped to 2% by Independence of India in 1947. these motherfuckers robbers should pay our debts

[@sylver1146]

@@hirenahir76200 factual

[@Unknown35-_67]

Says who? Not and indian. U can say words that easy, u dont know how much the leader and the citizens of here suffered.

[@Unknown35-_67]

Im not against andrew tate im his fan myself.

[@jacky64]

India's literacy rate when they got freedom from colonialism was literally 13% now it's nearing 80%. That alone somewhat tells how the British did nothing that benefits people, just did things that benefitted themselves

[@TheSm1thers]

That's just because it was a policy to not get too involved in a conquered nation's political governance to avoid rebellion, so it was left up to local rulers. The higher literacy rate is a result of Indian rulers using British systems and democracy.

[@harieeshrakhavandaran]

​@@TheSm1thers after independance the British policy was changed heavily by Indian government

[@harieeshrakhavandaran]

​@@TheSm1thers the democracy is not given by British it was fought by indians against the british

[@harieeshrakhavandaran]

​@@TheSm1thersthe British men are not capable of ruling a country like India because when you don't care about the local population you can rule the country by force and genocide

[@harieeshrakhavandaran]

​@@TheSm1thers on the other hands the indian rulers ruled for the country and they are partially successful

[@borkingborker5567]

India would be a better place today if the British treated them with respect and traded fairly with them instead of subjugating them, brutalizing them, and siphoning their wealth and resources for decades.

[@kingtejas_]

Decades? Bro centuries

[@lolxdbruh]

@Nirbhay Mane india aur superpower 🤣 bruhh moment

[@graytoby1]

Don't the Indians do that to themselves with the caste system

[@tn9974]

@@graytoby1 ironically enough, there is no history of caste system before british and mughals arrived.

[@graytoby1]

@@tn9974 I did not know that. Most if not all the Indian people I have met had a large respect for Britain and British people in general. Maybe I'm meeting the wrong ones or likely the ones who live in Europe who have seen the benefits of colonialism. I guess if you live in a slum in Bombay gotta blame someone right?

[@johnphillips5993]

Not underdeveloped, overexploited.

[@_Bees]

yellow parenti

[@hirenahir76200]

Make a richest country poorest and divided an united subcontinent into literally more than three countries is good for India😆

[@aerosmith7217]

India was the farthest thing from "united" before Britishers its was broken in different Kingdoms

[@hirenahir76200]

@@aerosmith7217 it was under a maratha empire

[@jerobyarts5654]

@@hirenahir76200 it still failed nonetheless as marathas were weak when the Brits came.

[@hirenahir76200]

@@jerobyarts5654 because of constant conflict between mughals and Marathas they just need a little bit time to make entire continent stronger but they didn't get that's sad

[@TheSm1thers]

​@KING OF TYRANNY Hence being weak

[@TritiumCupcakes]

Lol imagine thinking British Colonialism made India better after attempting to destroy the deep history and culture of one of the most ancient civilizations.

[@cat_city2009]

They actually encouraged parts of their culture, like the Caste System.

[@Curry_Communist]

@@cat_city2009 only the parts that were convenient for them

[@cat_city2009]

@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 citation needed

[@Noone-gz8li]

@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 who told you british invented caste system ? Stop living in lala land

[@Noone-gz8li]

@Ex atheist khushal and what is your jaat ? 😂

[@Argon369]

He should stick to Masculinity and Life in general not Geopolitics

[@arbsan8366]

Exactly!

[@hobbithallows]

Even in masculinity, he lacks How will he generate quick money if he doesn’t give hate speeches now and then

[@hirenahir76200]

😂😂

[@oneup3]

He's correct

[@silvesta5027]

Even in that field he’s utterly hopeless. The fact anyone listens to a man so out of touch with reality genuinely baffles me. Media literacy is dead

[@uddisa]

He was taught this way in his schools.

[@hanmaharashi8422]

You literally says " i don't learn shit from school i learn from my personal experiences "

[@Shootingbloodfromyourc0ck]

Lmao he is uneducated, never even attempted school

[@stargirl8444]

It’s true, british education system is biased af. In history class (recently) we got taught that britain civilised india and india was portrayed as a savage nation pre raj

[@uddisa]

@@stargirl8444 If u got time read the book "Despoliation & Defamation of India".The early nineteenth century British Crusade. We dont hate the present British citizens but saying that Britishers civilized Indians is like putting salt on wound.

[@finlayD853]

no not at all. I go to a British school and if you take on you learn about the empire and how it started what the impacts on other nations were and the impacts on Britain. and they don't hold back on telling you about all the horrible stuff the empire did in countries like India, Australia, New Zealand, and Canada

[@svcby]

as an indian im not offended. its not tate its western schooling 😌

[@finlayD853]

no not at all. I go to a British school and if you take on you learn about the empire and how it started what the impacts on other nations were and the impacts on Britain. and they don't hold back on telling you about all the horrible stuff the empire did in countries like India, Australia, New Zealand, and Canada

[@svcby]

@@finlayD853 glad to know if true

[@halthegoat]

Yeah im sure indian schools teach you well💀

[@bruler7264]

@@halthegoat mate, weren’t there literal protests in the uk over making maths compulsory cause kids were finding it way too difficult to comprehend💀, how tf ain’t math a compulsory subject already lmao.

[@halthegoat]

@@bruler7264 never heard of this in my life, maths has never not been compulsory in school in uk

[@choirpractice5847]

He’s just doing a shittier variety of wokeism and doesn’t even know it.

[@DraGon1229]

thats not woke but conservative

[@choirpractice5847]

@@DraGon1229 its all liberalism

[@sylver1146]

@@choirpractice5847 do u even know what.wings are my guy ? Bro said liberalism, u prolly don't even know what it means , Andrew tate is Antithesis of liberals my guy he's hard right wing

[@its_sandy286]

@@choirpractice5847 liberalism doesn't support half cooked knowledge tho.. 🙏

[@Guru-mb4mh]

@@choirpractice5847 Bruhh how's this liberalism in any way?

[@arianhamidullah1908]

Tate needs to Acknowledge that he is not well educated but a hustler who might be street smart 😂

[@aaryameena]

Tate is tattu A ghochu

[@adropovskidney]

street smart enough to dox himself by showing off who’s boss to an autistic teenager over twitter

[@Silverwind87]

Judging by how he got arrested, he is definitely not street smart either. He was just lucky.

[@dragondanyar9508]

@@Silverwind87 this didnt age well

[@dragondanyar9508]

@Jerry Louis with The Thickness NO WAY. HE IS NOT INNOCENT! I mean he was in jail for 3 months with no evidence. Also he got released. BUT HE IS GUILTY!

[@ashishpanwar6129]

Summary of Indian GDP (1-1947 AD) From the 1st century AD to the start of British colonisation in India in the 17th century, India's GDP was between about 25 and 35% of the world's total GDP, which dropped to 2% by Independence of India in 1947.

[@gajahsimha2848]

Thats because world GDP increased, not bcoz India's GDP decreased.

[@ashishpanwar6129]

@@gajahsimha2848 a r u stupid or what they stole 45 trillion dollar of wealth literally double of usa GDP😩

[@gajahsimha2848]

@@ashishpanwar6129 They didn't steal shit. They simply exported revenue to other part of the empire... just like local empires would distribute wealth from one province/state to another. In gross figures, India's GDP increased in British colonization.

[@ashishpanwar6129]

@@gajahsimha2848 instead of paying for Indian goods out of their own pocket, British traders acquired them for free, “buying” from peasants and weavers using money that had just been taken from them. It was a scam - theft on a grand scale it's still a loot understand in your stupid colonized mindset

[@gajahsimha2848]

@@ashishpanwar6129 That's literally what all empires of the age did. But one can say with a great deal of certainty that their loot was more benevolent or less parasitic than the Marathas or Mughals. If you get out of the patriotism kool aid, you'll see that the British enhanced our culture and quality of life.

[@enigmaticbloke1129]

They killed millions during that 200 years which nobody will talk about. They used to open fire at any sort of protest by Indians. They even passed laws which allowed Britain to arrest anybody they want without any reasons. Britain built the railway in India but not for the people. It was built to transport loot to sea ports. People were denied education, food, or any sort of development. Obviously there were few viceroys who wanted to rule India for Indians but those guys were removed from the power very soon by the queen. The manufactured famines during world wars killed a lot a of people in india because britain decided to take all the supplies from India to the soldiers. So ya, If anybody thinks Colonialism was good any country, that means you are sick and still secretly proud of what your ancestors did to millions of people around the globe.

[@JulieStardoll]

It's Britain that's in a better place now because of colonising India.

[@elomial724]

Sure and it's great. Why would it not benefit them if they succeded?

[@JulieStardoll]

​@@elomial724 then how about ppl like andrew tate acknowledge it and stop pretending like british rule was not detrimental to india? indians paid a very costly price in terms of human power, wealth and resources for the british to flourish and survive the world wars. colonialism was absolutely NOT good for india in case you the point went over your head.

[@elomial724]

@@JulieStardoll Even if colonialism was not beneficial to India I would still support it beacuse India's interests are not my interests. I am not British but what I care about more are British interests over the Indian one. Another thing is that the UK undeniably united India as a country. Which you all Indians are proud of which btw is garbage beacuse it's too diverse and people from different regions aren't the same. Another thing is that ethnic Indians don't exist. Inside of India there are different people which are ethnicities themselves. From what I know different Indian states looted and murdered themselves for the whole of history but when Britain came and did that you all start complaining how bad they are. Also law and order was established since Europeans came which was very beneficial too and I actually won't change my opinion about colonialism beacuse I don't care about colonised people's interests. Btw Glory to the British Empire🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧 Rule Britannia

[@XXXTENTAClON227]

@@JulieStardollIndia is not the English Channel. Iceland survived both world wars too, was it their colonial empire? Why does everyone think armies can magically float across water without facing the hardest resistance? The Roman Empire couldn’t even settle by force, resorting to installing a Roman king south of Celtic Britain, even though they were facing naked people with paint and spears. Britain built the Indian navy, not the other way around…

[@JulieStardoll]

@XXXTENTAClON227 not sure what your point is. India was bled dry by the British. Billions and Billions if not trillions of dollars worth of wealth and resources were illegally extracted out of India to Britain and indians paid a very dear price for it.

[@absxyz8714]

As an Indian person, thank you bro from the bottom the heart!! Can’t believe how you saw his whole video I mean Andrew shat has an iq less than a room temperature

[@TysonEmmy]

As an Indian , I completely agree with you

[@user-jg9wd2oc7c]

You are not Indina

[@nofacerainbow1693]

​​@@user-jg9wd2oc7cyeah he's not Indina, he's Indian 😊

[@jagathidirectioner9095]

Bro

[@KM-up4xz]

No wonder why these kind of people are being promoted on social media they represent interests groups directly or indirectly. As soon as they bring politics, religion or ethnicity you know there’s an agenda never trust anyone brings that up in a casual way

[@minhducnguyen9276]

Andrew Tate also thinks that not covering your head in a fight is a good idea that's why he's still stuck at the immediate level as a fighter while claiming he's on elite level. So I wouldn't put much faith in his word.

[@mateenabbasi9856]

4time world kickboxing champ 😑 lets not slander him. even tho he is completely and utterly wrong about this one.

[@minhducnguyen9276]

@@mateenabbasi9856 Not on K1 or Glory. Yes, ISKA is the basic requirement to get into international level but to call yourself world class elites in kickboxing, you have to win in K1 or Glory. That's where you see elite level fighters. Tate has never won a fight there. Just because he won on one fighting organisation doesn't make him elite.

[@nischaynalamada9109]

Can you fight.... shush

[@minhducnguyen9276]

@@nischaynalamada9109 Ah yes, if I don't fight on his level I don't get to talk. Classic moronic take. First, I actually train in MMA and the first thing everyone who step into the gym will always be taught is to keep the hand covering the head. Second, Tate is only good at fighting people shorter than him exactly because he never cover his head the moment he fought someone at the same height he got smacked. Maybe if Tate actually cover his head he wouldn't get his retina detached. Make no mistake I'm not saying Tate can't fight as he reached international stage but he clearly overhyped himself. Not to mention, there are plenty of more accomplished kickboxers who already criticized Tate for that statement so maybe you should shut up and learn instead of using that piss poor argument. But looking from that kind of passive aggressive attitude over a matter that has been settled you seem like the one who never fight here. But feel free to follow his advice and see how long you'll last in a real fight.

[@minhducnguyen9276]

@@nischaynalamada9109 Tell me you don't know shit about fighting without telling me you don't know shit about fighting.

[@kostaborojevic498]

What exactly did they steal??.....

[@Aryaputra_Rajanya]

They stole our resources, gold, diamond,silk,jute, land ,crops,etc. They supplied all food to world war 2 and they bought famines in Bengal which took 6 million lives.

[@Sneakyyyyyyyyyyyyyy]

What not?

[@Ajgsydodkdlclcjjs]

43 Trillion dollars and millions and millions of lives. Read up

[@rakeshkrishnan1099]

Tate discussing english colonization of india resembles a dentist attempting to teach nuclear physics🤣🤣

[@NC-zu7mm]

TO ALL WESTERN PEOPLE 1)JANTAR MANTAR 2)KAILASH TEMPLE 3)STUPAS 4)AJANTA ELORA CAVES BUDHIST ART 5)KAJARAO TEMPLE 6)HAMPI RUINS IF YOU JUST SEARCH THESE YOU WILL KNOW WHAT INDIANS BUILD IN THOSE TIME WHERE ENGLISH KILLING EACH OTHER ANCIENT ARCHITECTURE BEFORE BRITISH INDIA WAS BIGGEST ECONOMY AFTER BRITISH INDIA BECOME SOME OF THE POOREST NATION AFTER BRITISH - INDIA IS 5TH BIGGEST ECONOMY OF THE WORLD UK IS 6TH (STOLEN MONEY ) INDIANS ARE RUNNING UK'S ECONOMY SEARCH IT HOW

[@dewaldt8104]

Except India wasn't even considered to be a profitable colony.

[@user-uj2tk2tv3z]

@@dewaldt8104 then what were they doing in india for 200 years ? You seriously need education and come out of your mom's basement

[@vatsal7640]

" INDIANS ARE RUNNING THE UK ECONOMY ". LMAO sure buddy🤣🤣🤣 Keep coping

[@sarcasm_hard..5767]

If Andrew tate comes India in future that was his last day

[@cat_city2009]

Another reason to hate Tater? That's not new.

[@insfiresmannn4201]

Welcome to the Andrew hater club 😇.

[@muhammadwilliams8034]

Neo-colonialism: the last stage of imperialism Kwame Nkrumah

[@bernard8793]

That's my president

[@Aditya__ze]

This is first time seeing a westerner talking about reality of British Colonization of India, need more people like you

[@Drizxander]

I dare him talk like this in front of our freedom fighters

[@pooroldman5089]

What freedom fighters, there no war?

[@AmitGupta-cu7qk]

@@pooroldman5089 you didn't get it , he was talking about a scenario

[@hustlers5682]

bro he could probs beat them in a fight even a gunfight

[@idkwhy77]

​@@hustlers5682 I doubt it.

[@tuhinastark8793]

Gandhiji be like : I am gonna follow violence for some minutes

[@pravin3870]

Andrew surprises me every time with his half knowledge😂

[@reddragon2k6]

A good book to read about this is "An Era of Darkness" by a very knowledgable man named Shashi Tharoor. He basically destroys any argument that British colonisation brought any form of good to India or Indians in it

[@vatsal7640]

I have some other recommendations. Watch dr zareer masani debating tharoor or Rafe mankoo on British empire and reparations

[@DragonboltBlastter]

Andrew tate knowledge? *Source: Andrew tate's hair*

[@korsensei5891]

As an Indian , i thank your very much for standing with truth. 🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@FrankTheMackem]

As a Brit, I thought Indians were cooler when British Raj was around.

[@multiverseofchadness1167]

​@@FrankTheMackems my d

[@cantkickmyleaderlikeadoor-2037]

@@FrankTheMackem no

[@FrankTheMackem]

@@cantkickmyleaderlikeadoor-2037 yes

[@cantkickmyleaderlikeadoor-2037]

@@FrankTheMackem no not at all

[@Tetragrammaton22]

We ought not place much regard unto Tate.

[@TheEmperorsSidekick]

Well... Tate's a freak. He's juvenile, so are his fans. He only gets more popular when someone attacks him. He's popular among folk who enjoy being edgy countering popular opinion, right or wrong. He's not countering Wokeism at all. In fact, his thinking is just the other side of the coin.

[@borkingborker5567]

He would be an example of a mirror of wokeism.

[@sylver1146]

He says outlandish stuff which are part of why he gained popularity, u prolly don't get his satire not would I blame u , rather seem naive for it Edgy is what left wing is truly

[@inthestarstommyluke6788]

It's usually jealous people that don't like tate because he's done nothing but speak truth and we all know people hate to face facts

[@dontlookspins]

@@inthestarstommyluke6788 pure delusion to believe someone so woefully ignorant of the world around them could ever speak truth, how does it feel to be so duped by KZbin grifters that you publicly simp for people so demonstrably dumb?

[@inthestarstommyluke6788]

@@dontlookspins what has A.Tate lied about? I bet anything you can't name one thing.

[@kontankarite]

Dude... No one should be listening to Andrew Tate. The only knowledge I would trust from Tate is how to roundhouse someone's head off. 🤦‍♂️

[@KeshavBaheti-wv7dq]

Even in some indian history books there is a page called benefits of british colonialism it is the colonial mindset which is propagated by the liberandus because of which we use english as our first language We were the oldest greatest richest bravest and best civilisation since the ancient times

[@pervertedstoner69reborn70]

At least India and Pakistan weren’t childishly fighting over Kashmir and Myanmar didn’t ban the colors red and yellow from TV!

[@kishlayverma6622]

india lost over 45 trillion dollars after british rule which lasted for 200 years, for comparison world gdp 2018 (before covid era) was 20 trillion dollars. fun fact:- currently 1 dollar is around 80 indian rupees , if everyone in India stopped buying foriegn products just for 90-100 days, 1 dollar would be equal to just 2 Indian rupees and India will jump from 5th to 2nd largest economy in the world.

[@andrewwilliams3137]

The 'drain' increased by almost $20 trillion in just FOUR years as calculated by the Marxist economist Utsa Patnaik. She estimated $45 trillion up to 2016 and then $64.82 trillion up to 2020 both at a 5% compound interest rate. Also 5% is more than twice the average annual rate of inflation of the GB £ from 1765 to 2023

[@vatsal7640]

Lmao the drain was calculated by a marxist economist. She did the same method in 2020 and the number came around 60 trillion dollars. See??? The whole thiing is flowed

[@martinjugolin2087]

Would've the USA exist without colonialism?

[@sarthakofficial1115]

I hate those people who think that British made India better, like bro India was a lot better than Britain, and is better now than Britain

[@talhanizami5400]

But not in terms of economy and developement

[@treeismyusernamewhyjustwhy]

Then tell indians to stop moving here if britain is so bad

[@vatsal7640]

Listen man nobody says Britain was better than india or anything like. But plz don't act as if it was a paradise before British came

[@sanalkumar62]

Britishers destroyed indian economy which contributes 35% of world gdp in 17th century to 2% in 1947. But thank god they built railway tracks... Wow

[@andrewwilliams3137]

"The statistic that India produced 25 per cent of world output in 1800 and 2 to 4 per cent of it in 1900 does not prove that India was once rich and became poor. It only tells us that industrial productivity in the West increased four to six times during this period...National income statistics do not show that during British rule the Indian economy became steadily poorer". Source: Tirthankar Roy, Professor of Economic History, born and educated in India. There was an industrial revolution and the total GDP of the world grew faster than the GDP of India. India's GDP increased under the British but not as much as in the West.

[@UtkarshSingh-hd5yn]

​@@andrewwilliams3137yes that's the point, it didn't grew under the british

[@vatsal7640]

@@UtkarshSingh-hd5yn it did grew. It's global share declined, but nominal gdp was still growing The US has the largest global share of gdp today ,doesn't mean US took 30 percent gdp from other countries This is literally given on Wikipedia

[@shagunjaiswal7206]

Jaliyawanla bagh massacre

[@lolalee6256]

I'm Chinese and my history teacher in high school said that China owes its development to western imperialism because the west opened up China and made it part of the free market. He also blames the fact that he can't afford to eat beef on the Chinese government.

[@Raydaruckuz]

Mind boggling the anti-China mindset permeating all throughout the West, from academia and on down..it's bad enough when it comes from Neo-Cons, mass media, etc, but to see it from schools/universities historians, not to mention the overwhelming majority of liberals, as well as so called leftists, and progressives. It's truly insane how the group-think takes ahold on certain foreign policy viewpoints, when people that normally disagree on every single issue on all things domestic, become lockstep on thier imperialist viewpoint of China. The Overton window is skewed so far towards a neo-connish hawkish view, that any "moderate" view ( i.e anything not viewing China with the utmost hatred) is seen as some extreme stance, to be instantly shunned, and discredited as some China sympathizing traitor. This animosity comes from liberals, conservatives, and even so-called Western "Maoists".

[@syedafeefahmed7756]

Yah but brother Indians own more land in UK than the British native itself’ isn’t it like what goes around comes around?

[@mjgaming7603]

True, no one ever gets away with anything Traps of karma is beyond your awareness as you get more aware you will realize all you did in this life and previous life

[@agressivepandit]

let him think whatever he wants to, what can we do.

[@AbhiIrani]

Anyone who is mad I just want to let them this is what happens when a child is uneducated and this is clearly tells that he failed in his history exam and also other subjects too.

[@anantbhardwaj2239]

It feels like THEIF blaming POLICE 😂😂

[@xeschire706]

Andrew Tate triggers me TBH. He's making everyone more stupid more than anything which is the big reason why

[@scottsaxton1819]

Wrong. You are part of how we got here.

[@BASED525]

I agree

[@aasthadwivedi6792]

If British were so good and helping colonizing then they can still help us by giving the remuneration they owe. Give all back to us🤷🙂 simple

[@sgxavier2000]

Bro is smarter than Tate 😂 If he had all the money of Tate He will be richer than Tate 😂

[@rinkiakepapa5625]

Actually Andrew is right . I am from Bengal and to be honest most of the infrastructure was completed by British. The British did commit atrocities and we must not forget them ,but still it is not possible to ignore the infrastructure built and benefits reaped. The pre British era saw some Turkish Warlords ruling Bengal and it was a mess .

[@0xakash7]

Bro infrastructure was built so that they could carry the goods to Britain.

[@archiem654]

To tum bengali logo me khud kuch karne ka dum kabhi nhi tha?

[@donquixotedoflamingo5455]

Yeah the British also got rid of many disgusting traditions like the one where a wife has to kill herself when her husband dies.

[@AtheistNationalist]

@@archiem654 abey zyada bolega tu? Subhash bose ke log hai hum. Tu joh national anthem gaata hai woh bengali ne likha hai. Khud toh saala bihari hai. Tere state ke suyar hamare state me rehte hai

[@AnmlPeeweeIsHere]

🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡

[@fourhorsemen8277]

Andrew Tate was absolutely correct here. 1) India was already under an imperialist rule. 2) it wasn’t just the incredible infrastructure which allowed India’s economy to boom; training of civil servants, governance, banning barbaric practices such as witch burning, providing medicine meaning that the population boomed, cartography; the list goes on and on.

[@Iamsus_dude]

Medicines literally

[@user-ym3wq1ei1i]

India had its own governance witch burning happened in britain these medicines were useless britain made civil servants not because they tried to develope india but because of their own gain

[@sahiltamuli1753]

What kind of brain washing did you westerners go through? You were only taught from their perspective so don't come and act like you know it all. The genocide that the Brits committed here was far greater than what Hitler did.

[@sahiltamuli1753]

​@@Iamsus_dude you serious? We had medicine before westerners came to India. Colonization did nothing but create destruction here.

[@varadbendale6210]

Thanks someone from Britain Took this stand

[@morningstararun6278]

Yes. Brits developed some infrastructure in India, but the amount they looted would be at least a billion times worse.

[@dear_setsune]

5sec clip I don't even know what he is talking about and you are calling him dumm, i need at least The 6 min of context

[@Cyallaire]

350 years of British domination of India resulted in their economy stagnating for that duration, and recurring famines killing millions where the British aristocracy used that railroad system they built to export grain from regions hit by famine, along with using their telegraphs and speculation to bid up the price of grain to make it unaffordable for millions. Mike Davis covers this in his book, *Late Victorian Holocausts*. Your shirt video responding to Tate is really well done. Thank you!

[@telfordexotics167]

Hey man, im british, im not proud of the hell the empire brought to the land of india, but i am proud to call an indian an ally, neighbour and friend,

[@saicharan.durusetti]

I just want kohinoor diamond back to my country

[@phenomenal8196]

Indian victims in the comment 😂

[@TacticalGaming_]

Dr Zareer would destroy this bloke

[@suhazareer200]

Suha Zareer speaking 😂

[@mangahead1987]

Imagine being an American and lecturing about colonialism....

[@RiazAhmad-uk9cc]

I think he's right to an extent but India benefited heavily. The British had connected all of India with a railway systems and created thousands of schools allowing them to advance. If you compare the Indian subcontinent, they're much better off in terms of development and education. I live in the US, and indian/pakistani/bengali are at the top of the educational hierarchy. Yes, people did suffer, but from a macroscopic point of view, there were great benefits. Also india's second language became english. Due to that, its is now the world's top freelancer as there's no language barrier to making money.

[@J_A_c_K_K]

What benefits u talking about ? The railway network was built for their sake only ...to take away the Indian wealth which is around 45 trillion dollar . And u pakistani shut the f up ...u guys need to beg all over the world for everything...

[@originalsoundtrack7379]

Side effects of learning history from KZbin university

[@finlayD853]

you do realise that the Winston Churchill caused a famine on purposen and as I quote him " I hate Indians, they are beastly people with a savage religion" this was the leader at the time

[@jeanettewee8805]

@@originalsoundtrack7379 same to you.45 trillion is a joke.

[@user-ym3wq1ei1i]

These railways were made by indian money india had their own school before britishers came

[@adamwallace7638]

If India was never colonized they would probably be in the state that Africa is now. Brazil wouldn’t exist without colonization. These places would be behind a 100years right now, they would barely have electricity infrastructure

[@jake_dev1046]

W

[@user-oq6ck1bh7q]

Source trust me bro

[@Bikramjit-kl7ug]

there are so many resources looted by british like gold silver cotten even indian masala as well, if you search on youtube london mausum there are many things are find loot from india.

[@papiezpp]

Nazis also build infrastructure in ocupied countries.

[@TheSm1thers]

Andrew Tate is correct. British colonisation was better for the whole world.

[@cow1959]

it ruined the world

[@TheSm1thers]

@@cow1959 There would still be slavery everywhere if not for the British Empire. Also brought new medicines, tech, infrastructure and superior culture.

[@cow1959]

​@@TheSm1thers they ended slavery by creating a new kind lawlz

[@TheSm1thers]

@@cow1959 Wage slavery?

[@andrewwilliams3137]

@@cow1959 An industrial revolution created the modern world, trade and colonialism spread it around the globe. Britain came to trade and then invested huge sums. In his book Empire, Niall Ferguson says that by the 1880's the British had invested £279 million in India, not much less than one fifth of their entire investment overseas. By 1914 the figure had reached £400 million

[@FM-dm8xj]

Democracy? Christianity and escape from the caste system? Learning English and applying it? British Judicial laws?

[@tacocatpoopracecarpooptacocat]

“democracy”

[@FM-dm8xj]

@@tacocatpoopracecarpooptacocat ?

[@sm24572]

So why does colonial mentality people whine “Democracy is in threat in India”?

[@Iamsus_dude]

Democracy 😂

[@MonEsperance]

The infrastructure the British built over the years still stand strong, as compared to the New Parliament building at a humongous amount of money that needed repairs in months. English knits the nation, dude!

[@nepzel42069]

Even though it didn't benefit a lot. Our politicians built a giant statue from the tax money. So Idc how much they looted decades before. Now it's problematic without them.

[@Ishant007]

You forget de industrialization of india

[@HOENUMAN]

No de industrialization happened the British Empire just built infrastructure in india subcontinent so they could extract or loot resources easily

[@crossedcs6542]

Yes it gained nothing, other than industrialisation, western education and globalisation. All of which are the only reason India succeeds today 😮

[@shiohara4613]

This education system sucks in India because of the developing obedience mindset towards the people who have authority in western education system . Fun fact , people who introduce this in India have already realized what shit they are teaching and making changes, you are the living proof of it my guy.

[@crossedcs6542]

@@shiohara4613 Seems like your education system being shit is the responsibility of India. Britain left a long time ago and showed you education when you had none, after Britain left a series of terrible decisions made India an extremely poor country when it easily could have been a rich one... Communist command economy what a fantastic idea hahaha Ghandi really saved you guys lmao

[@serboslav1389]

India's GDP before colonisation constituted about 25-30 % of the entire world, that same number after colonisation was brought down to 4%. India was one of the richest countries during the Rennesaince period, this is why Europeans like Vasco de Gama and Columbus wanted to find a quicker way of reaching India.

[@crossedcs6542]

@@serboslav1389 All of the GDP was selling spices to Europe. You didn't invent anything or create something, you sold flavour to people who had the money to pay for it. One day we got sick of paying and took it from people so elapsed in technology they could do nothing to stop it.

[@user-oq6ck1bh7q]

Source trust me bro. You need to learn history

[@afnanchowdhury946]

If India was strong how they cannot destroy Britain then if they had resources

[@jesse_pinkman_yo]

Ok kid look The human body is stronger than a virus than how can a virus kill a person

[@abhisheksingh-on3cl]

@@customgaming6185 that is with white they have so many husband

[@nivyashaji6737]

​@@abhisheksingh-on3clnow they had fucker charles and side chick kamila as king and queen . The Brits are bowing to them make more funnier

[@BEAST-45]

​@@customgaming6185 now it is opposite I fucking British women 😂😂😂

[@wonderdog776]

Ah, I’m sure they could destroy Britain with the resources of spices, sugar cane and tea

[@hells_paradise_]

and thats how andrew tate lost his all indian fans

[@desi_anarch]

Nit just tate but lot of upper class and upper caste indians think the same.

[@jimhalpert0]

Even I believe this way before Andrew Tate. India would've been way better if it was ruled by the British rn.

[@hanmaharashi8422]

Looting $45 trillion out of India would make India better ?

[@davidthompson4383]

You should probably look at the actual economic data. Though it's true the British absolutely should have done more for India there is no dispute among legitimate academics and historians that the Indian economy grew and developed during British rule.

[@user-ym3wq1ei1i]

No it did not india did not developed during british rule it just colonial mentality of Britishers they destroy Indian economy

[@blazefn8941]

The amount of wealth britain stole with that we could purchase them more than a dozen times😂😂😂

[@dino25842]

Man whenever I see colonization benefited india my hearts broke down 💔 forget about money stollen racist British killed million of india because they didn't like us 💔

[@edmundlubega9647]

As an African and Andrew Tate fan, I absolutely agree with you

[@Gypsygeekfreak17]

Yes the British did good for India

[@princegobi5992]

Wtf do you know about literally anything

[@wonderdog776]

Yes they did but it was mainly negative

[@Gypsygeekfreak17]

@@wonderdog776 and you treat minorities like crap

[@Gypsygeekfreak17]

@@wonderdog776 india is no better

[@wonderdog776]

@@Gypsygeekfreak17 I am literally from the uk

[@omgjacob]

I mean this guy should go to the Calcutta train station tbf and picture the Indian people’s reaction to it when it was made

[@freeranger2125]

45 trillion dollars, that was the amount that was stolen from India byt the Brits

[@andrewwilliams3137]

The 'drain' increased by almost $20 trillion in just FOUR years as calculated by the Marxist economist Utsa Patnaik. She estimated $45 trillion up to 2016 and then $64.82 trillion up to 2020 both at a 5% compound interest rate. Also 5% is more than twice the average annual rate of inflation of the GB £ from 1765 to 2023.

[@treeismyusernamewhyjustwhy]

If I see this 45 trillion lie on the internet one more time I'm gonna traumatise someone

[@freeranger2125]

@@treeismyusernamewhyjustwhy hey kid just because in your history textbook you didn't learn the truth it doesn't mean it's not the reality. Do you think that Britain did very nice things in the countries they captured. Maybe that is what they teach there

[@treeismyusernamewhyjustwhy]

@@freeranger2125 or maybe just don't believe the 45 trillion myth that was calculated by the same clown lady who estimated that 1.8 billion indians died in the british raj

[@Justinian43]

I recently watched a video about how Spain helped the Americas by also giving us religion, technology and infrastructures. Feels insulting to me, who's from south américa. It's crazy to think that there are people that believe in this bs euro-centric view of Colonialism, britain stole millions upon millions from India, Spain also stole millions upon millions from the Americas, native Indians and native americans had civilization and lived well before the colonial powers arrived to destroy everything.

[@arjunchaudhuri9227]

happy to see an american being educated

[@waltershumer4211]

Don't hate the player hate the game

[@LeYoKo0]

In 1AD to 17th century India 🇮🇳 and china 🇨🇳 are the richest country in the world they both of them share about 50% of global GDP

[@dewaldt8104]

China accounts for about 18 % and India under 10%. That adds up to 28%

[@LeYoKo0]

@@dewaldt8104 which year ?

[@LeYoKo0]

@@dewaldt8104 in 5 century India 🇮🇳 share 38% of global GDP

[@fr0xk]

Andrew Tate sometimes go full liberal mode

[@arnavpandey3823]

Colonialism maybe civilised Africans but not India. We had a flourishing civilisation before the Brits were even civilised. What were the Brits doing during the ivc era? Mauryan era? Gupta era?

[@sammilun3932]

Honesty as a indian i will say yes...

[@princegobi5992]

Yes what?

[@AtheistNationalist]

Thanks mate 👍 for pointing the truth. But I have one more thing, China opened up their economy in 1970s whereas india did so in the 1990s. And still quite a lot of those protectionist laws are present in india whereas China has turned almost fully capitalist. But still, we're improving. IMF has projected our growth rate in GDP at 6.5% which is among the highest in the world. Also our recession chances are 0% (Source: bloomberg). We don't have any enmity with today's UK or with any country for the matter (except Pakistan). So let's be friends. The world is one family(except Pakistan). Peace and blessings 🙌 🙏

[@ahindribanerjee7612]

This dumb: Ensure the pizza box is not recycled. Romania police: You better had it recycled.

[@MrWhitmen1981]

If wasn’t the British it was always going to be someone else. The idea of morals is flawed when looking back in hindsight. The only lesson is how not to be conquered is the one we must all learn from history on why certain civilisations where so easily conquered and why. Indias problem was it was so fractured with lots of different kingdoms to play against one another, it was never a unified concept, which ironically was something the British brought along as to run the empire to its eventual collapse.

[@Erockarmy]

Lol Tate is 100% right.

[@nicholas_x7732]

Tate is correct; just not fully expressing how good it was.

[@shamsulhussain1593]

He didn’t say it is. He asked the question lol

[@ADONOI]

That's not wt he said🤣🤣🤣... He said Britishers were surprised to see India architecture.. But Indians were fighting among themselves..

[@user-on8ji6tf2b]

they stole approx 43 trillion dollars ...India was called a gold bird sone ki chidhiya for some reason

[@AbdullahSajid-tz3sh]

What was name of the book? Also what did he say in the clip

[@theperson4yearsago565]

I had an aneurysm while watching this video