This tuning = Automatically beautiful songs

[@kattakid9884]

i kinda feel like you need to write two songs separate from eachother but with the same lyrics and see what the differents results are

[@andrewhuang]

Looove this idea

[@ABCD27814]

Yeah and same chords too! Just like 4 producers flip the same sample but instead it's the same song with different production

[@better.better]

probably better not to limit to the same chords. and the lyrics should be sort of ambiguous so that each person might take it in a different direction. this sort of happened with a melody that Cevin Key wrote, used it for both Skinny Puppy and Tear Garden (The Center Bullet) the melody was actually about his mother who had just died, the title refers to have devastated he was to lose her. but he doesn't write lyrics, so for Skinny Puppy I think it was recorded as an instrumental, but for the Tear Garden Edward Ka-spel's interpretation was about a revenge shot to the head

[@gitsurfer27]

@@andrewhuang Maybe you could give the lyrics to 4 songwriters and don't give them any rules or notes and see what they create

[@bardistass]

And the same set of random instruments

[@Packbat]

Rob Scallon around 6:19 saying "I can't take it anywhere except places I've already been" is such a good line.

[@hectichive889]

Seriously though

[@GuyManley]

Can't wait for the open tuning math rock album, Canadian Football.

[@thisgoestoeleven]

scrolled down to see how many people independently arrived at this exact joke lol

[@Mr_O]

Canadian Hockey

[@TheJumboBurrito]

canadian bacon

[@fr.davideynon6984]

In order to circle the joke back into also being something layered and profound, I would propose the album title Argonauts.

[@IHateMyAccountName]

Mexican Hockey

[@nistarok123]

"Forgot about the C-section. So I guess we need another punch" - things you can say in a recording studio, but not in a delivery suite

[@LordCargena]

This has such a first of october vibe. I think they are probably a major influence for them.

[@scottvogel8477]

People should check them out. They release an album pretty much every year.

[@better.better]

... literally every October... no "pretty-much" about it... well hopefully they keep doing it, right?

[@enricosonvezzo]

@@better.betternot 2020 tho😢

[@Ticktok_of_Oz]

@@enricosonvezzo that year didn't exist, so they didn't miss it.

[@xisotopex]

were they inspired by the Swirlies?

[@elicraig7367]

Have to say that it is so so heartwarming to see Rob realize what Andrew is doing and decide to step out of the way and let him explore. Giving space for his intuition over Rob's knowledge of the genre. The song is so special and unique and I love it! Just discovered the show, can't wait to tune in every week!

[@Lennard222]

Can someone tell me the genre? I wanna hear more like this :D

[@ThatMattGoodMusic]

​@Lennard222 math rock/emo so bands like American Football, TTNG, Chon, Toe, Covet, tricot...

[@donnymcjonny6531]

​@@Lennard222want to add Title Fight, And Balance & Composure to the list. They're a little heavier side of the genre. Joyce Manor and Camping in Alaska are closer to what's shown in the video. And if you've never heard Nevermeant, that's a quintessential song to the genre

[@Lennard222]

@@donnymcjonny6531Thanks :) I appreciate it

[@dragonsrus93]

midwest emo was def what rob was itching for here. Agree it's impressive (a skill in the industry no doubt) Rob let Andrew do his thing. Still sounds sick af, and if you added distortion and sped it up 20 bpm it would be emo af anyways @@Lennard222

[@UncleRJ]

This is just an excuse for Rob to say "so beautiful" while staring deeply into Andrew's eyes.

[@jwest879]

😭💀

[@fgrey-]

He doesn't need an excuse

[@ScorobeSlavinpoop]

Well, Andrew has pretty eyes. Who can blame him? 🤣

[@paperfoe]

he literally doesn't even hide this anymore 12:54

[@bolillo5013]

So true

[@virtualnuke-bl5ym]

Here's a tuning I've been experimenting with recently: 1. Restring your guitar to be like a left handed, but play it right handed anyway. So the high e is closest to you, while the low E is furthest from you. 2. Retune the strings so that they are eadgbE like a normal guitar... but because all the strings are backwards, they descend in pitch instead of increasing in pitch. So high e and low E stay the same, while b -> a, d -> g, g -> d, and a -> b. 3. After not snapping your a string because you tunes it up 2 semitones, you now have this very familiar setup that is completely foreign at the same time. All your 5ths become 4ths, 3rds become 6ths, and so on. playing usual chord voicings can sometimes oddly sound like cluster chords, forcing you to come up with different shapes you otherwise would never use or think of.

[@drown_n]

Lotta work, but yeah this is fun as shit. Try this out yall

[@milkjug7800]

this

[@giakobbo]

Rob being flabbergasted by everything Andrew did was heartwarming

[@Alkatross]

His face at 9:55 ...

[@giakobbo]

hahaha

[@aaroncottam]

The producer is as much a character as Andrew and rob when it comes to how amazing the song sounds, I’m in love with this track!

[@andrewhuang]

We write and record everything in the studio but post production and mix is done by me :)

[@meticulouslytender8921]

As a song writer myself this got me all excited. The idea that one simple idea can form a whole song. It is what dreams are made of. Touche gents, TOUCHE!

[@andrewhuang]

Yah just pick some kinda starting point and go!

[@-jank-willson]

Tune your guitar DDDDDD, put a capo on the 2nd fret, and only play the diatonic frets (do, re, mi - don't play the sharp/flat frets). Thank me later

[@ViktorSarge]

I was so happy to see Rob take an executive decision to stop the timer and just see where this ended up. It was like a First of October song reaching it's full potential. Awesome track.

[@justinjones4199]

By far one of the best pieces of art either of you have made. It's awesome when creative people get to do creative things together. Never stop being human.

[@rodriguezelfeliz4623]

That's funny because Rob did very little hahaha

[@RKWDBMX]

Never stop being human

[@bjornsundin5820]

So you're saying you wouldn't love them if they were worms? 😢

[@justinjones4199]

@@bjornsundin5820 I don't know what worms you know that make music like that. So I guess my answer would be absolutely l o l

[@demzionmain]

@@justinjones4199 Next test: Stick a worm on a piano and see what it plays.

[@Pr0fess0rSasquatch]

I love the level of self awareness to realize that this was more than just a song for content. This was one of those moments where the right call was to throw the script completely out the window and go along for the adventure, you guys nailed it!

[@Yuki-rh1ie]

i could spend my whole life watching a 24/7 stream of you two being absolute fucking geniuses and experimenting left to your devices.

[@jamesarmstrong6095]

Watching this video I put my guitar in the same tuning and ended up writing one of the best songs I’ve ever written for my band, debuting the song tonight in Glasgow ! Thank you guys

[@connorgriffin6671]

whats your band name

[@GregJonson]

I really want to hear this now!

[@indie1138]

Way to go, hope it worked out.

[@COhlen]

whats your band name?!!!

[@WhiteCranK]

Obviously he doesn't have a band

[@Pumpkinhead9092]

I'm still surprised you haven't launched this as a different channel. You guys are awesome and could grow this into something bigger than either of your channels easily.

[@andrewhuang]

That’s the long term plan if the videos do well enough here 🙌

[@Androxx6]

@@andrewhuangsiiiiiiiiick

[@jcnash02]

With guests

[@Alp0082]

And then you could invite other guests to jam with the two of you. Beardyman, Harry Mack, etc.

[@Srcsqwrn]

@@andrewhuang Yes! Excellent!

[@t3hjnz]

This is a really gorgeous track, but Rob and Andrew's friendship is the most beautiful part of music KZbin right now.

[@myceliummobb]

Never seen friends look at eachother like these two...

[@WhiteCranK]

​@@myceliummobbonly gay friends lol

[@lolickypeepee23xdd6]

@@WhiteCranK you arent true bros if people dont question yalls sexuality, the people that act the gayest are 2 straight best friends

[@WhiteCranK]

@@lolickypeepee23xdd6 Naah i'm not sure about that 😅

[@Nitrus5]

This is genuinely one of the most beautiful songs you guys have done, I’m blown away

[@jordantaylor4390]

I really appreciate Rob just admitting: "I'm giving Andrew a really beautiful tuning, because I selfishly wanna hear an Andrew Huang song in this style!"

[@nickshillito1170]

I hear FACGCE strummed open and I’m just immediately thrown into American Football vibes. It’s magical

[@ellielovesbands]

Haha, me too

[@nerdykidnick]

they kinda made the tuning popular lol

[@mrlost470]

math rock!!!

[@BriLikesSynths]

Huge props to Rob for being able to step back and let Andrew cook. Sometimes that’s the most important contribution you can make to a piece of art when working with other people.

[@lucster6]

I had chills the whole song. Both Andrew and Rob know when they're writing something unique and beautiful and they have such a deep trust to let the inspiration follow through. Again, just so much fun seeing these two guys having fun writing music.

[@alexscampone9601]

this song is so incredbly beautiful and i still am coming back to this video months later. the process of rob stepping back from his leadership role and really letting andrew create his vision is so beautiful. i want to hear an intire andrew huang midwest emo album now

[@PickPig]

obsessed over the synth solo that chord movement is so so good after stalling on one chord for so long plus the synth itself reminds me a lot of lena raines signature sound so instant plus

[@Shmicah1235]

Oh it's totally Lena Raine

[@Jademalo]

6:49 - "I can't take it anywhere than the places I've already been" is one hell of an explosions in the sky title lol

[@jayphilpot2909]

Sonic Boom has got me very excited for First of October this year. Songs like Que Pasa and the two shown today sound fantastic and the chemistry between you two continues to grow each year. So much love to the both of you 💕💕

[@cherrycoke106]

Que Pasa is an unironic banger!

[@zentair]

Watching Rob gently asking for instructions in his supportive servant voice is so funny after watching part one where everything is in his head and he is commanding the entire studio to make that thing. both lovely videos to watch

[@relsqui]

get you a collaborator who can do both

[@robertgarcia5519]

This show is the best thing to happen to music on the internet

[@andrewappel2970]

I was going to say "it's like they were made for each other" but it is more like they are "made OF each other". So cool to see creative collaboration that yields so much more than the sum of its parts

[@scottvogel8477]

This went from "Hehe I am going to trick Andrew into making a Midwest Emo song" to "ANDREW IS GIVING ME FEELS"

[@fernandoperdomomusic]

my song "Everything Leads to Now" on my album self was written in this tuning .. the album just got a 9/10 review in Music Connection Magazine.. THANK YOU

[@FatalExit]

Been a fan of yours for over 8 years of my own music making journey, and I will always take any opportunity to watch your videos and hear you create. This one was really something special, absolutely haunting and chilling song. Props to Rob for letting you go your own way with this, I'd love an album of this kinda music NGL. 💛

[@andrewhuang]

Thanks so much!!

[@lianju]

check out american football (lp1), these guys made FACGCE tuning as popular as it is. amazing band

[@schuepbachr]

First of all: amazing track. Hard to believe it was written in, line, 2 hours. Second: it's so cool to see the song writing process. Sections, developing a sound, production, philosophy, and methodology. So. Rad. Love you guys.

[@MilesKvndra]

This Andrew + Rob combo = Automatically beautiful videos

[@beepst]

Next First of October album should be all midwest emo / math rocky. I really love how you make it sound original by bringing other instruments.

[@joeltrout]

I love that Rob recognized how genuinely nice this song was turning out and nixed the timer in order to let it develop. Rob's a real one

[@BonesWasHere]

Andrew's vocal break in the high note sounds awesome in the song. Super raspy, and it somehow works. (See 15:55)

[@jayhu2296]

This series needs to never end

[@scottflora]

Agree strongly

[@GizzyDillespee]

...it just goes on and on my friend, some people started making it not knowing what it was, but then they kept on doing it forever just because this series needs to never end

[@brianwendt2520]

I love this song and I love the teamwork of these two. I honestly would watch a whole series of them making whatever song ideas come to mind. I don't need any of the challenges or whatever. Just pure creativity. I'll watch whatever they make tho!

[@yendanjin]

that song is hauntingly beautiful! Thank you for this amazing video and this song. the world is better with it in it

[@andrewhuang]

Thank you so much!

[@chandraiyer1710]

Man im addicted to this series, wow… goals for musical ability and friendship 😊

[@krouchingtigerr]

Although this was in many ways Andrew’s creation, so many interesting choices by Rob made this song happen…! Not only did he choose the tuning, but he had the wisdom to sit this one out, AND turn off the timer…? Beautiful!!

[@clarkcant4818]

His drumming is so perfectly placed in the final song too, it escalates in all the right spots and really captures the feeling of the song in a way drums usually don’t.

[@commissariorex]

2:07 I was listening to this progression and I thought "damn, this is so Cap 'n Jazz" and then Rob said that and I felt validated.

[@StonyATGmetal9]

Would like to start by acknowledging Rob's growth on drums. I see you Rob, nice work! I could not stop listening to the final product here. It put me in a different place that was lovely, and I just love you Andrew and Rob, thank you for the continued amazing content. Music = LIFE

[@mikemakesmusic7]

After seeing both videos I’m blown away at how talented and intuitive you guys both are, even on drums! Nice to see how supportive you each are of each others strengths. Cool how Andrew jumped in on the lyrics of his song while Rob was focused on other details knowing how he was racing the clock, then how Rob stepped back and even killed the timer for Andrew, maybe because he knew he would perform better without the pressure. Great partnership guys.

[@GarrettMusic1]

2 talented musicians coming together in a professional studio having fun

[@kaikai203]

you two remain one of the greatest musicians and influences in my life. both of you are the reason i keep making sound and part of the reason i sound the way i do. i love you guys, and adlib skill, and beautiful appreciation for music and the people and things around you. please, for us, keep up your amazing work! :)

[@stysner4580]

The vocal harmonies, so damn good.

[@Blutzen]

I have been a fan of yours and Rob's for so many years at this point, and I just need to say how damn cool Sonic Boom is and how much I appreciate what you two are doing here.

[@cleaningthepipes]

that was so fucken unexpectedly gorgeous coming from last vid, chorus is so punchy and catchy

[@Nyitemare]

This goes SO HARD. Maybe my favourite song by Andrew. Rob absolutely killed the drum part too

[@Relyx]

Just want to throw out that I only discovered Covet recently because of Rob mentioning them in a video, and loving what they do, it also got me into the whole wider math rock and midwest emo scenes. Andrew's song absolutely fits in with the vibe, and is absolutely beautiful. Hats off to Rob too for having absolutely no ego and stepping back.

[@blakedanielson733]

yvette young has a yt channel as well! some awesome short pieces

[@Thisworldislost]

Andrew! Oh my gosh dude. The best song you've ever done. I started to tear up before the synth solo. Well done Andrew and Rob.

[@brnktv]

This is easily my favorite thing Andrews ever written. And I normally don't like his vocals, but these were super different. Much lower, or harmonized. Really loved this.

[@danielclifton13]

Hey hey, I posted this on Rob's channel too... I love both of your channels independently and you two are supper rad together! Thanks for keeping music making fun. Love it! And super cool to have a production team to play with they're super cool too. You're all great! This makes me think of the video Andrew posted about branding and it's limitations. I love the metal guitars on Rob's challenge too!!! Love to see you both trying lost of different things. Please keep it up.

[@FrankenSteinsGate]

I would immediately buy an entire album of songs like this

[@PrototheDodo]

American Football LP1!

[@PrototheDodo]

but also yeah I would love to hear a midwest emo/math rock album from rob + andrew. Rob actually does have a midwest emo album though! It’s great it’s called the winter months. Fairly old though

[@lookforthegood1]

Turnover - peripheral vision

[@ehhhhhhhhhh]

American Football + Owen. Mike Kinsella!

[@sione_etc]

@@PrototheDodo I'd actually recommend LP3 as closest to the vibe of what Andrew and Rob made here

[@lionhearttx7156]

I used to write songs in this tuning in the 2000s, and a variation of it FACGCF and FACGBE. I was/am a huge SDRE fan and the sound of this tuning always reminded me of their prettier stuff.

[@ssslawz]

Yvette Young+Rob+Andrew collab. Someone make it happen, would break the universe

[@BrianOfAteionas]

I love this. What a generous genius move to pick that tuning and know when to completely step back. Amazing natural teamwork.

[@campfire2953]

This is genuinely so beautiful. Amazing work, Andrew

[@julienmgastonmercier]

As a fan of math rock, I can tell you it’s so hard to find this kind of amazing open mindedness and to see such an amazing musician really appreciate it really warms my heart ❤️

[@rustyshackellferd5842]

Seeing the two of you in a studio together is like pure magic. Always makes my day better. Please never stop being so beautiful.❤

[@XtraBees]

This song reminds me a TON of this awesome mathrock/jazz outfit Monody from Chicago! Very few bands mixing midwest emo/mathrock with straight up jazz.

[@evenzeroescanbeheroes6875]

I love how the songs are basically polar opposites of each other. Fantastic work

[@NatalieDemary]

It’s cool seeing other EDM producers with an acoustic instrument + music theory background!

[@erwinc.9117]

It's one of my favourite tunings of all time! Learnt it from Never Meant and now about 1/3 of my songs are in it.

[@sarniaguitarguy9405]

Another incredible achievement! Andrew's vocals never disappoint! Always inspiring to explore a new genre or tuning.

[@bricelory9534]

I absolutely love that you and Rob's collab has come from semi-serious but mostly memey content creation to a semi-memey but mostly serious artistic band - you both challenge one another so well and collaborate harmoniously. Absolutely lovely!

[@crystalsoulslayer]

Absolutely beautiful. Every bit of this, from the performance to the mixing to the editing of the video, is such an amazing display of skill and care. What a time to be alive.

[@naiden02]

I saw FACGCE in the thumbnail and instantly clicked, it's always a blast to see how people experiment with mathy/emo tunnings. By far my favorite song by u guys, great vid ♥

[@Landeville]

Breaking out of genre like this is where real magic happens IMO. Beautiful song and great video!

[@Kumquat_Lord]

Do it with a 7 string and make it C-A-B-B-A-G-E

[@gitsurfer27]

Your singing's sounding fantastic, sounds like you're experimenting with different timbres and tones, the end result is beautiful...especially that mellow verse!

[@IPGuitars]

Funny how I actually got a very Devin Townsend "Ocean Machine" era vibe from the verses. Man... I got completely lost into that song when it was played in full... beautiful❤

[@DerpLeSqueege]

that was a banger of a tune, been watching rob for a long time and recently seen some of your modular synth collabs and now I've been binging all the stuff he has done with you and your channel, you both have immense talent and its awesome to see you both bounce ideas off each other and make magic

[@TheRealLingrush]

Two of the most hard working and talented musicians of our era, and they put everything online for us to share in. Such a gift 🙏

[@DasOmen02]

I love the dynamic that Rob and Andrew has with all of their shenanigans!! Just friends hanging out with an INTENSE passion for music. Love it!! Great song and great video :D

[@Kevin-me2dz]

I love how this just started as a "hey play this tuning" and became something that made the hair on my neck stand up. Beautiful!

[@fatcyclops6025]

I love y’all’s musical and personal chemistry, it’s intoxicating watching and listening to what the two of you come up with your team together. Seems like a great atmosphere where music couldn’t help but flow ❤ love both y’all

[@jono6379]

Another fantastic song from you two. Anyone else getting serious 90s vibes? Also i find it funny how one tuning was so nice and one was horrible but they were both so happy with what they were given.

[@ScorobeSlavinpoop]

Crash by Dave Matthew's band has some similar things going on to what Andrew was playing at first.

[@jonny555ive]

Fantastic work guys. My guitarist and I we do this every Saturday, it is quite fun. And that's the end result really is having fun creating music with your friends. Take care, ~Jonny5🥁

[@lookforthegood1]

Yeah, I deff dig this one more. Rob had to work with a hard tuning and his riff was great when it came in, but my god this one feels so refreshing. Like a midwest emo song but with a slightly different flair which makes it even better.

[@DrSnap23]

I discovered this show today and I gotta say, not only is it awesome, it's just *perfect*. Like, this is a perfect embodiment of you guys and I'm in awe seeing so much talent in such a silly setting, with that tremendous editing. It's like it's the first of october every day !! The crew totally fits the vibe, too... it's a masterpiece, for real. Thank you for doing this Andrew and Rob, love you guys =)

[@jeffd.3883]

The main root chord is the same one (I think) that's in the video game Fez, you guys remember that game? The tone is similar to. ...this is really really good

[@ethanbrink3346]

My guitarist buddy is back in town and I was just messaging him today about setting up a jam sesh soon. Thank you Rob and Andrew for spotlighting this beautiful tuning! It will be a highlight of our upcoming jam for sure. Keep up the good work!

[@MarcasLancaster]

Snare sounds incredible.

[@fernandovidanacastillo6731]

This video (and the one in Rob's channel) just feel like a little 1st of October... And im all about it ❤❤❤

[@123Ir0nman]

I need a whole math rock album from Rob and Andrew now!!!!

[@transcendedsounds4713]

truly beatiful song and video. the lve between yall is real and thank you for sharing your lights with us and making the videos yall do. Got me all teary eyed and goosebumpy in the morning watching Rob see what was happening before him and saying screw the challenge let Andrew take all the time to cook up this beautiful master piece.

[@up4open763]

"Were you born in Champaign..." Heeh, I got that! Fantastic song, if you hadn't shown us, I would have presumed that song took much longer to make. Great sounds.

[@autumnbrookesings]

Y'all's friendship and musicality are so so lovely. I love the chaos and goofy fun, as well as seeing y'all genuinely love and support each other in your creativity

[@Caelum_Solaris]

There is nothing on the entirety of the internet that is more wholesome, creative, funny, and inspiring than the two of you working together to create music. 🥰

[@brianceefh8917]

I don't know about yall, but that last 'unresolved' note is so god damn beautiful!

[@Rodrifuuu]

To my amateur year it doesn't sound unresolved at all, I don't know what Rob was expecting.

[@JoshMIW]

@@Rodrifuuuhe’s expecting it to go down to resolve. Andrew is holding the 6th note in the key, which in a major key, is also the “home” note of the relative minor key, which may be why it sounds kind of resolved to you. But in the key of F major, which is what this song is written in, that note wants to resolve down to a C which is the 5th in the key of F, which is the most stable interval other than an octave. I hope this makes sense to you, I realize it is kind of wordy haha

[@Benzy670]

I always knew you two collabing would be incredible and Sonic Boom has lived up to every expectation. I LOVE this series so much

[@Arithryka]

Rob was really having some Feelings™ this episode ❤

[@XyamacaFly]

what a fantastic and tasteful track you guys put together, love it

[@jeg4011]

This is such an inspired take on math rock, and the synth solo just sent me straight past heaven into outer space!

[@JokeDindonChannel]

I'm always amazed at the talent throughput of these two gentlemen. What an incredible musical duo! Truly inspiring, good job!

[@LetsTalkAboutMathRock]

Alternate title: "Andrew Accidentally Writes an American Football Song" 😂

[@cheesist6998]

Hi man

[@briguy_fieri1689]

The one with the American football tuning

[@isaacthecorncob]

Never Meant to write an American Football song, but i guess I did