This Song Made us Tear Up - Jim Croce | College Students' FIRST TIME REACTION!

[@adriennepender673]

If you want to talk classic singer/songwriters, Croce is definitely S-tier. 'Time in a Bottle,' and 'I've Got a Name' are amazing as well.

[@ralphdyer4471]

If he didn't go so young he'd have been on the same tier as Paul Simon.

[@berniemargolis4288]

I love 'I've Got a Name.' I was so excited to hear it playing during Guardians of the Galaxy 2.

[@NakAlienEd]

I had heard songs by him before, but once I heard "I've Got a Name" that's when I fell in love with Croce

[@sjd5750]

@@ralphdyer4471 I believe that same thing, Ralph...Special talent.

[@dcook22]

Spot on @Adrienne Pender...

[@cindyspangler3982]

"Time in a Bottle" and "I've got a name" for more stories, and "Bad, Bad Leroy Brown" for something upbeat ..

[@centuryrox]

And for something fun "You Don't Mess Around With Jim"

[@IllumeEltanin]

These four are exactly what I was going to suggest.

[@sandrad9695]

@@centuryrox You don’t spit into the wind, you don’t tug on Superman’s cape, you don’t pull the mask off the ole Lone Ranger, and you don’t mess around with Jim.

[@cindyspangler3982]

@@centuryrox actually, "and you don't mess around with Jim" are just part of the lyrics from "Bad, Bad, Leroy Brown".

[@stevedem76]

Rapid Roy the Stock Car Boy, great upbeat Croce song.

[@vinnygi]

“She’s living in LA, with my best old ex-friend Ray…” Absolutely brilliant line. Tells you the whole story in 10 words.

[@jasonremy1627]

"Who she said she knew and sometimes hated"... Damn, you feel that.

[@kentclark6420]

@@jasonremy1627 But it makes you wonder why she would leave him, to be with a guy she sort of hated?

[@scottscholtes4530]

@@kentclark6420 My take is she always told him that to keep him at ease, while secretly having a crush on Ray

[@tommathews3964]

Bingo! First time I ever heard the song, it was like "that's all I need to know!" Jim was a fine songsmith!

[@mrheem44]

tells a LOT of guys stories its got to be true for him too, right? what a line

[@daveenyart]

Thank you. In September of 1973, I was a freshman in college and my roommate was/is an exceptional guitar player. After classes he rushed into our dorm room and grabbed his Yamaha acoustic guitar and played and sang two or three Jim Croce songs. When he was done he told me that Jim Croce had died. That was a very sad time but sublime as well because my roommate helped me through the tragedy. Music is powerful. I'm crying as I am typing this.

[@talltulip]

"Time in a Bottle" must be next; a love song that he wrote for his baby boy. Sadly, I think he was only 2 when Jim died, but at least he had that beautiful song from his daddy. After that, something upbeat, of which the best one is (IMO) "You Don't Mess Around With Jim."

[@MsKrystal57]

Jim and the Leroy Brown song.

[@debbie7505]

Agreed & I looked up his son & his son is a musician now. So sad he died so young. I remember when he died.

[@terrimobley6067]

☝️

[@chab1rd155]

Yesss!

[@tracysnow349]

His two best songs in my opinion.

[@marcribe6483]

Croce's story is an interesting one because he held various jobs while he'd play nights because he wanted to marry his girlfriend, who at a certain point began singing with him at places. They married and as a marriage gift, the bride's father gave him money to make an album, hoping that the son-in-law would, once he realized he doesn't sell, focus his life to "regular" jobs and raise a family. However, to their surprise, the Croce couple sold well at their shows. So much so, they made another one (Facets [1966] and Jim & Ingrid Croce [1969]). She got pregnant of their first (and only) child and left the duo; almost at the same time Croce met his future musical partner Maury Muehleisen. Next thing you know Croce's next single "You Don't Mess Around With Jim" is a local, than national success. He's appearing on TV everywhere, he played on the Sony & Cher Show, which was perceived a hip show for its time. And then for the next two years it was one hit after the other. "Time In A Bottle", "Photographs And Memories", "Bad Bad Leroy Brown", "I'll Have To Say I Love You In A Song". And in the middle of all this success, just like that his plane crashed and he's dead. And about two and a half months later comes out the title track of his new album he had just begun touring for "I Got A Name". A few months after that the compilation album "Photographs & Memories: His Greatest Hits" that would bring all these great songs back to daily/weekly radio play for the following three or four years; "Time In A Bottle" and "Photographs And Memories" the two most played amongst them. Wow! I've just relived the whole experience writing about it. Croce is a gem that shouldn't be forgotten. You two will probably get why he's so fondly remembered the more songs of his you hear.

[@kenkencat]

Excellent run down, thank you. I lived in Louisiana not far from where his plane crashed in Natchitoches after a concert at Northwestern State university. For years afterwards locals would brag about picking through the wreckage and finding some souvenir. “Hey man my cousin has the curtains from Jim Croce’s plane.” Such a tragedy.

[@cherinoelke]

I was gonna do a full run down like you did, thank you by the way. But the more I typed the sadder I got because I was a huge Croce fan, of him and the story of his wife not just the music. Him and Maury had such great harmonies, I actually got married to a friend singing and playing Tme in a Bottle on guitar. What a great talent and human being taken way too f-n young. I agree "You Don't mess Around With Jim" should be next, polar opposite of "Operator" but that's the point :)

[@mariefc8504]

This is beautifully written. 💕

[@jimreadey2743]

Yes, to what others have said, thank you for this beautiful summary. ♥

[@yutubetom]

Here is an excellent video of Jim and Maury performing this song. Two guys, two guitars: kzbin.info/www/bejne/mITCd51qbJJ3ppY

[@denizinan6253]

This song has not lost it's musical, poetic quality for over decades. It's so easy to get caught up in the story; still touches me. Thanks for playing it.

[@David-iv6je]

Worth noting that Croce also had a banger: Bad Bad Leroy Brown is a heckuva lot of fun.

[@marcribe6483]

Teaser: He got a 32 gun in his pocket full a fun He got a razor in his shoe And he's bad, bad Leroy Brown The song has great descriptive lyrics helping listeners mold this character into life in their minds. Note: 'He has a 32 gun (...) full of fun' as to say full of bullets always within reach of a man who enjoys killing. Very smart choices preferring unsophisticated language in all of his story telling. That's an art.

[@LadyIarConnacht]

Back in the day, telephone operators saved many lives, just by being someone to talk to, for a minute.

[@PWatts-ff2fd]

​@@marcribe6483"...got a 32 gun in his pocket for fun..."

[@lisamorrison2149]

"Time In A Bottle" is the tune I keep going back to after all these years...it's cathartic.⏳

[@vincentschmitt7597]

Time in a bottle is his most haunting tune imo.

[@sharipetkovsek5502]

Haunting! Perhaps prophetically written

[@lindab1945]

How many brides walked down the aisle to this poignant song? My college BF did!

[@genedoss664]

I still can't hear that one without getting emotional. In 1980, at the farewell assembly for the seniors at my high school, a beautiful young senior sat in her wheelchair as she knew she was dying from cancer and sang that song for all of us. Absolutely none of us could keep it together by the time she finished.

[@sherry091756]

@@lindab1945 I did too

[@LSBBD]

"I can't imagine a better way for that song to be written". It's this quote that makes me respect you guys and has me keep coming back. That is so prophetic and mature to respect a song for what it is, regardless of style.

[@poppyssnoopy5835]

My husband and I grew up in the 70s and 80s. We absolutely love Jim Croce. We had his song "Time in a Bottle" as our wedding song.

[@evalehde3869]

Beautiful song!

[@tjj300]

"Time In A Bottle" and "I've Got A Name" are two great "serious" songs from Jim. "Roller Derby Queen" is a really fun one of his.

[@shannonp1656]

I love Roller Derby Queen! It us so very much fun. His album cuts are hidden gems.

[@jamesfoster2238]

Roller Derby Queen, built like a refrigerator with a head!! That line just gets me every time!

[@volo1826]

"New Yorks not my home" was always my favorite.

[@cdfreester]

Totally agree

[@jdw5678]

Another fun one is "Rapid Roy (That Stock Car Boy)". Croce had so many musical gems.

[@arthurgoerner488]

The grin on Andy's face when the song ended is why people watch this channel. Then, the look on Alex's face when he is talking about not being able to read the number cause something's in my eyes.... Priceless.

[@scottdehart7716]

And we were all waiting for it, because we knew what was coming, that’s the beauty of this channel.

[@angier5775]

One of the best things about the 70’s - the Singer / Songwriter. Croce, Harry Chapin, Carole King, Carly Simon, James Taylor, Jackson Browne, Cat Steven’s etc….. The feelings always come out of their songs when they perform 🎵🎶

[@jgsrhythm100]

Hands down Cat Stevens

[@scottingram7634]

And speaking of Cat Stevens, it's about time A&A hit him. Put up another artist poll like they did for Croce.

[@aileenburke4667]

No doubt. Check out Laurel Canyon. I believe it’s on Amazon,. Such a creative time.

[@MrDeadstu]

A&A should do everyone of these artist listed, all of them are stellar. (Except Carly, her mouth is really huge and it scares me....jk)

[@anthonysalomone9225]

Agreed... greatest singer/songwriter time ever. Carole King "It's Too Late" James Taylor "Fire and Rain" or Cat Stevens "Peace Train". If you want to hear a fun Croce song, "Bad Bad Leroy Brown" would suffice, but "Time in a Bottle" has a similar feel to Operator.

[@jimreadey2743]

Others have already said it, but I will, too: This song sounds as hauntingly beautiful today as it did the first time I heard it 49 yrs. ago. Yes to "S"!

[@bjspeck4337]

For me too and just about that length of time.

[@paulettemaximun2505]

Yes

[@pamelagabert4709]

He has been gone 45 years and still amazes new and old listeners. Used to go see him live. He pulled at your heart and made you laugh. He was a delightful human. I cried like a baby when he died.

[@vectortonto1]

You saw him live? How many times?

[@PWatts-ff2fd]

I wish I had been able to see him live. He was a great story teller.

[@dianedavies8291]

Huge loss when he died, he was already a legend locally here in Philly. This song was written about his time in the National Guard. He saw guys who were lined up at the pay phones, who had just received Dear John letters, trying to call their girls. Check out Time in a Bottle next by Croce. ✌️♥️🎶

[@mikek5958]

Hey Diane, Philly boy here too yo! I can still remember as a kid driving to the Jersey shore or the Poconos sitting in the back seat of my parents 1976 Buick LeSabre with the great stereo and speakers, cassette player AND eight-track it had with my older brother (no seat belts just pillows and blankets!) listening to Jim Croce and all the great music of this era yelling at my Dad to "turn it up please" and singing along to all these great songs.

[@dianedavies8291]

@@mikek5958 I forget what type of car my Dad drove in the 70’s but definitely remember the rides down the shore with the radio playing. I remember trips with all of us, a dog, the grandparents all crammed in the car with no seat belts lol.

[@mikek5958]

@@dianedavies8291 Haha Holy cow dog AND grandparents! I'd just be yelling the whole time "ARE WE THERE YET!?"

[@yc919]

"Time in a bottle" is a must. Powerful lyrics.

[@jog8483]

My pick too! I think the lyric "there never seems to be enough time to do the things you want to do.." is so prophetic, since his life ended so young.

[@thomasmeadowcroft5421]

If Operator is an archetypal breakup song, "Time in a Bottle" is an archetypal love song, and "I've Got a Name" is an archetypal anthem in the folk/rock genre.

[@aerynoftalyn1307]

Great comment!

[@rmweidner7596]

"Time in a Bottle" will pretty much level you, because it's both a love and a love-lost song. ...and "Bad, Bad, Leroy Brown" is just a good time when you're listening to it...as is "You Don't Mess Around with Jim".

[@FFVison]

Time in a Bottle was also somewhat prophetic since he died very shortly after.

[@idalily3810]

My favorite. Everybody else says Time in a Bottle, but not for me. It's this one. When he says, "There's something in my eyes," I just tear up. Even all these years later. Because we've all been there.

[@jamiehanna45]

The guitarist with him is Maury Muehleisen. He died in the same crash and did " A song I heard" Amazing song, amazing guitar work, amazing voice.

[@bry3921]

Lived down the block from us in Trenton

[@mycapslockisbrokennvmifixe7518]

What an incredible talent. I can only imagine how successful him and Croce would’ve been if they were still with us

[@MarkLindsayCNC]

He wasn't all ballads and love songs. "You Don't Mess Around with Jim" and "Workin' at the Car Wash Blues" are real thumpers. "I Got a Name" is my absolute favorite Jim Croce song, and it's more than well worth listening to. Edited to add "One Less Set of Footsteps" is one of the world's best "forget this, I'm out of here" tunes you'll ever listen to.

[@kensroswell]

"One Less Set of Footsteps"..... brilliant.

[@BClarke]

Agreed on all counts.

[@kimrivera5302]

Absolutely "I've Got a Name"

[@kens32052]

I Got a Name is my favorite too.

[@mikemilne]

My thoughts exactly. For some reason I never much cared for Bad Bad Leroy Brown, which seemed to be an imperfe t clo e of "...Jim"

[@mkg59]

You two break down songs, no matter how simplistic, better than anyone else reacting to songs out there today. Terrific.

[@fredinaz]

You guys are so fun to listen to. I was a little worried because sometimes people who love Rush or The Who wouldn’t like someone like Croce. But you lived up to high expectations, again, by appreciating good music regardless of the genre. Nice work A&A!

[@cesarnarro6013]

Growing up in the early 70's I always listened to the harder rock band's of the time but I would also listen to the singer song writer's of that time, as most of my friends did as well. Just so much good music back then !!!

[@sgtBelson]

@@cesarnarro6013 It was a great time for music, as there were no real ‘specialty’ AM radio stations; they all played everything. In any given time frame, you could hear the singer/songwriters, Motown, country, soft and hard rock, the beginnings of prog, etc. I’m thankful for the exposure.

[@sandrad9695]

@@sgtBelson Yes! I loved that! I try to explain this to younger people and they can’t appreciate it. I’m thankful for the exposure to all that music too.

[@gerhardbraatz6305]

@@sandrad9695 and they always want to put every single song into a category. We just called it good music.

[@fredinaz]

@@sgtBelson Agree! I also love having an excuse to go back and listen to these great songs with good headphones!

[@raytull3922]

If you create a poll that contains "Time In A Bottle", it will most likely win. With that said, my personal favorite Jim Croce song is "I'll Have To Say I Love You In A Song".

[@mariannec6825]

finally someone mentions I'll have to say i love you in a song, got to say i think this is my favorite too

[@ethank4820]

That’s my favorite

[@thechomiji]

Agree 100%

[@MrPrice2U]

nah...

[@MartinEB72]

My favorite Croce is 'Kings Song'. About an overworked king that his queen left him for not being there. That song probably hits the hardest for me. It's a pity that it isn't on the big streaming services. You can find it on youtube though.

[@shauner1108]

Jim Croce is legendary in my book. I can only begin to imagine the amount of legendary songs he would have given to this world had his life been not cut short in such a tragic way. Hope he makes the RRHOF soon.

[@brianmasinelli9694]

It's criminal that he isn't in the hall.

[@kel9591]

Time in a bottle is one of the saddest songs imo his best. It's about not being able to spend time with loved ones. Croce then sadly died in a plane crash leaving his wife and young son behind.

[@DawnSuttonfabfour]

I read recently that he wrote it for his little boy. Tragic loss. Beautiful song.

[@AaronHunter]

Croce's one of the best American songwriters ever - he was Guthrie-tier before dying way too young. "Don't Mess Around with Jim" is one of his great "this is a light-hearted, fun song that's actually saying a lot if you listen." "I got a Name" is like, America in 3 minutes, and as southern boys you really ought to check out "New York's Not my Home"

[@kimberly2310]

This album was the first album I ever bought as a teenager. I was 13. I played it until the vinyl turned white.

[@MrDarkMagnus]

Jim was the real deal. Another guy who fits that category is Harry Chapin. "Taxi" is a masterpiece of lyric storytelling. I'm dying to see A & A's reaction to that. I'm proud you guys aren't too cool to get choked up. A couple of menches.

[@margaretanscombe730]

Yasssssss…’Taxi’ was a masterpiece by another guy who left us way, way too soon…

[@donges87]

Taxi would be a great review!

[@creynolds0216]

Dude, I totally get the chills when he hit's the line, "I've overcome the blow, learned to take it well, only wish my words could convince myself." WHOOOOWEEEEE. So GOOD!!!

[@jorgelopez-pr6dr]

Remember that losing your lover and your best friend at the same time isn't a betrayal that you don't go over so easily, it's just don't. He want to speak about his misery to someone.

[@roncypert8255]

I remember being totally frustrated trying to learn the guitar part on his songs…… Then I caught him on The Midnight Special and realized he had another guitarist accompanying him!🤣 Maury Muehliesen played amazing acoustic lead to Croce’s rhythm. It’s so tragic they both died in the same plane crash! Maury was only 24 to Jim’s 30. I found out then that Maury and I share the same birthday.

[@jhamptonjr]

He was So good! I love watching the handful of live songs we have from them.

[@jimallen8679]

Jim Croce has many S tier (IMO) songs. “Time in a Bottle” “I Got a Name” “I’ll Have to Say I Love You In a Song”

[@allisonreed7682]

Exactly! This is definitely not his only S-tier song. His entire body was work was breathtakingly good.

[@leonardoglesby1730]

The often forgotten half of the Jim Croce's music is his accompanying guitarist, and collaborator, Maury Meuhleisen who delivers the amazing guitar work. It is sad that both of them were killed together in the same plane crash. One of the musical tragedies of the 1970's.

[@targhee159]

Maury’s playing is astounding. Especially on this song. Such a huge loss.

[@williamlucero1349]

I was 9 years old when Jim Croce died. I’m 57 now and still grieve his passing. He was and is an American Icon!

[@PWatts-ff2fd]

Me too! I was 11 in 1973.

[@Martin.Wilson]

This song resonates with any guy who's ever had his heart broke......which is all of us.

[@lourenzi8820]

Two artist's that make me tear up with sadness when I hear them, Jim Croce and Karen Carpenter.

[@davidschmidbauer3930]

Add Keith Whitley

[@dunhill1]

Same here. I'm going really lose it when Gordon Lightfoot leaves this earth.

[@DavidDFairhurst]

Jim Croce’s Greatest Hits was one of the first albums I ever bought. It came out the year after he died. I was about 12 years old and knew every one of those songs by heart. What an amazing writer. Incredibly, the 14 songs on that album were all written within a span of two or three years. One of music’s most tragic losses. To get an idea of his range, next you should try one of his character songs, like “Bad, Bad Leroy Brown,” “You Don’t Mess Around With Jim,” or (my personal favorite) “Workin’ at the Car Wash Blues.” Or really, just pick any Jim Croce song at random. They’re all so damn good.

[@anthonytice3028]

Rapid Roy is another character song that just paints a totally complete image in your mind

[@Cheryl_Haydon]

Photographs And Memories is one of my favorite albums of all time. Each and every song on that album is absolutely amazing in it's own way, IMO.

[@fakenewsmindcontrol1508]

Me too,Columbia record club 8 track.

[@schrodingerszombie2401]

His evocation of characters is so good, he's the Charles Dickens of rock music.

[@thefoss5387]

Time in a Bottle was his most overtly romantic, as is I'll Have to Say I love You In a Song. One Less Set of Footsteps, Lover's Cross, Photographs and Memories and These Dreams, are all in the vein of Operator, end of the relationship songs, and each has a different emotional emphasis. Rapid Roy, Workin' at the Car Wash Blues and Roller Derby Queen are more light hearted bops. Don't Mess Around With Jim, and Bad Leroy Brown, were a couple of his more popular urban tales. I Got a Name is his most notable cover. As he died, truly, before his career could develop, he doesn't have a deep catalog, but, it is all great. Also, it should be noted that he performed as a duet, and the lead lines were mostly played by Maury Muehleisen , also a singer-songwriter who also perished in the crash.

[@cyndybensema7189]

I did not know that about his co-singer. Thanks for that info. His songs almost seemed like he had a premonition he's die early. Such a great artist.

[@mikek5958]

"Time In A Bottle" was written for his son.

[@thefoss5387]

@@mikek5958 That is true, but, the song also works wonderfully as a romantic tune, and has been used in countless wedding sets through the years.

[@mikek5958]

@@thefoss5387 It does yes, you are absolutely right. One of the wonderful things about art and music: The interpretation is always subjective and personal.

[@rollon863]

All great JC choices. Just decide what vibe you want. RIP

[@jeffdetmer4681]

Jim Croce was a genius. He got started after the army playing guitar and doing back-up vocals for Maury Muehleisen. Maury's band didn't have much success, but Jim got a chance through his writing to get a record deal. Though he used a fuller band to record, most of his appearances were just him and Maury (who was now Jim's lead guitar and harmony vocalist). Occasionally with a piano player or bass etc. Sadly Jim and Maury and a few other people were all killed in that crash. He was a very prolific writer and I believe would have been held in the kind of esteem as people like James Taylor and Bob Dylan for his writing. He did some really amusing songs but also some of the most beautiful love songs. He was a great story teller through his songs as well. Well worth a deeper dive guys. Really good reaction on this by the way!!

[@PWatts-ff2fd]

I agree 100%.

[@minkgraver]

His incredible voice and the absolute poetry that are his lyrics. Such a fantastic artist. One of the giants of the singer songwriter genre

[@richardsmith5477]

“Bad Bad Leroy Brown” was really good by him. And "Cats in the cradle" by Harry Chapin

[@themoviedealers]

Chapin also gone far too soon.

[@reddwarf3069]

Those two guitar parts are perfect together. Like Simon and Garfunkel’s voices.

[@cazgerald9471]

Maury Muehleisen - he also died in the crash

[@scottking9234]

Wow, that's an insightful comparison!

[@Cavie1974]

@@cazgerald9471 Murray was an integral part of Jim's music especially on live gigs. Too bad he never gets remembered much.

[@minkhollow]

"I've Got a Name," "Bad, Bad Leroy Brown" and "Don't Mess Around with Slim" are all excellent (and "Slim" in particular is hilarious).

[@DaughterofDarkness]

It's Don't Mess Around with Jim .... Slim comes later in the song ... and you're right, hilarious!

[@Martin.Wilson]

Time in a Bottle.

[@dwanemarsh4378]

Back then, there was NO ONE better than Jim! I grew up on all his songs. His voice, rhythm, and writing, were FAR above average. I'm 66, and about heard it all in my time. From country, to blues, to rock, to rap, etc...And STILL, he's on another level! Good reaction....

[@thekpmckay]

Loved this guy... He was a story teller w/ a beautiful gift. There were a few around that time that always come to mind. Harry Chapin, Cat Stevens...

[@rickwebermusic]

Don't forget Gordon Lightfoot either!

[@knightngail1]

Jim Croce could really hit you in the feels with his words...

[@anthonyboucher7077]

"Lover's Cross" is by far my favorite Jim Croce song. Hits all the feels.

[@leezabel181]

Came here to put in my vote for “Lover’s Cross”. Super underrated and amazingly well written.

[@StevesFunhouse]

Wow, what a great suggestion but sadly, you beat me to it (damn, damn, damn ... I don't get to do ANYTHING 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣)

[@1234dahu]

"You can keep the dime". For the younger folks, you used to have to pay for a phone call with change. A standard phone call was 10 cents.

[@tomloft2000]

until the inflationery 70s came-then it went to a quarter.

[@cazgerald9471]

You got your dime back if you just talked with the operator, hence giving it to her as a thank you - I doubt an operator had the mechanism to actually get the money, but it's a great line.

[@GaryHighFruit]

I was wondering if they would understand that line(and others) in this song. But they did.

[@CorePathway]

Hence the phrase “drop a dime”(as in make a phone call to rat someone out) also shortened to “dime” for basketball assists

[@1nelsondj]

You guys nailed this one, phenomenal song that has stood the test of time. I can't hear it without tearing up, had to wipe my face twice this time. Alex was right about the extra layer of meaning beneath the lyrics, that's not easy to do which is why you seldom hear it. And it's sung in such an understated manner it would be easy to miss if the listener wasn't paying attention. This was the love he thought would save him, so he's lost, he thanks the Operator as if this might be his last human contact. Real heart-breaker.

[@natebrown6879]

last human contact - love that I thought would save me. I hadn't fully put that together before. Thank you! And the absence of a line to end the verse is perfect. Jim is my favorite artist, I think. I typically don't even like lyrics, because it's tough to right a song that resonates.

[@Dano_in_Texas]

Another artist who has been a little overlooked...who fits right in, in this category... Harry Chapin. "Taxi" and "Cat's In the Cradle" Like Jim Croce, he's a great songwriter and storyteller.

[@dunhill1]

agreed, but Cat's in the Cradle hits too close to home and I can't listen to it anymore. Too painful, but an amazing classic that will surely live forever.

[@kayelle8005]

A must

[@Otokichi786]

"Greatest Stories Live": kzbin.info/www/bejne/n33EfYCBbNNseLs

[@michaelmalone6425]

Right on.. But do not forget the classic “WOLD”.

[@aldon1100]

@@michaelmalone6425 yep! what a brilliant but devastating song.

[@RicoBurghFan]

All of Croce's songs are sadder given the fact that he died in a plane crash at 30 just when he was achieving peak popularity, leaving behind his beloved wife and a newborn. Yes we do have his wonderful songs as a legacy, this, Time In A Bottle, I Got A Name, I Have To Say I Love You In A Song, etc, but God only knows what he could have done if he had lived.

[@joeterp5615]

Yes, “I Have to Say I Love You in a Song” is great! I’d forgotten about that one, haven’t heard it in years.

[@stevedem76]

I'd put " I'll have to say I love you" up as one of the greatest love songs of all time, and Jim performed it with such great feeling.

[@tashakomaroff2982]

I’m so happy you loved this song. I haven’t seen any suggestions of his song “Photographs and Memories.” It’s gorgeous and will also bring a tear or two.

[@Smootman1]

Got to hit "I've Got A Name" and "Roller Derby Queen" at some point. Time In A Bottle is a personal fav

[@kevinlogozzo3952]

My faves as well!!!

[@BoomerMcBoom]

"All her friends just called her 'Spike' ". I like me some "Rapid Roy" .

[@vincentschmitt7597]

I've got a name is a nice one.

[@anthonytice3028]

Rapid Roy that stock car boy!

[@spicy321]

All I can say is pick any random song by him and you'll be sure to rate it S tier. He was that good and had so much more to offer before his life was cut short.

[@12thDecember]

Jim Croce, no pitch correction, the emotional content comes through so clearly. When he died, a little piece of America's heart died when we heard the news.

[@catleeper]

As I sang along with Jim Croce, I was reminded of singing this song along with the radio as a young woman. It feels the same in my heart now, as it did then. Man, I’m one of the lucky ones to have witnessed these great songs at the time they were released.

[@roncypert8255]

@Catherine, I totally get where you’re coming from. His songs got me in my feels in my youth and they do the same now. Ultimate timeless classics!❤️

[@surlechapeau]

Recommend "I've Got A Name" next. Props to Maury Muehleisen backing vocals and co-guitar on many of Jim's songs and performances

[@themoviedealers]

Used by Tarantino in Django Unchained.

[@johnf7683]

"Time in a Bottle" is a great song by Croce, but he has several more. My personal favorite is "Lover's Cross". It's one of the best breakup songs ever, and show's off Croce's musical genius. Oh, and the amazing thing about Jim is when you check out him singing live...you'd swear he was at the studio!

[@wayne_twentyfive]

Spot on, John ! .. "Time In A Bottle" is a great song, and is usually the one most people regard as his best ( along with this one ) .. But like you, "Lovers Cross" is my favourite .. Such a memorable break up song, with brilliant lyrics and melody .. I think Andy and Alex would love it too .. Wayne

[@amandajames5068]

Lover’s Cross is one of my favourites too but so often overlooked

[@thomasmarthinussen8978]

Such a masterful song, melodically superb and lyrically utterly profound.

[@micheleparker3780]

This song is my favorite of his...kills me everytime.

[@jordan390a]

If this made you tear up, then Sylvia's Mother by Dr. Hook and the Medicine Show will make you cry...!

[@HamiltonRb]

Tears in Heaven by Clapton was as real as it gets

[@drew.168]

I would love some dr hook up on the channel

[@doobernow]

@@drew.168 yes some Dr Hook!!

[@steveschellenberg7485]

Do the version where they're recording live at Shel Silverstein's house.

[@doobernow]

@@steveschellenberg7485 yes please!! I love Shel Silverstein I've never heard it

[@StatsJedi]

So many are so good, but "Time in a Bottle" is THE big one. You have some idea what to expect!

[@scottdehart7716]

Yeah, you think Operator is sad, just wait, and bring a box of Kleenex

[@AdamMcGahan]

Next: "Time in a Bottle" - a soft, slow, heartbreakingly moving song

[@toddperry9860]

You young guys missed out on the 70’s, the best decade of music this country will ever know!

[@CorePathway]

70s/80s. Peak musicianship. Fight me.

[@scubashooter]

For me “The Day The Music Died” was the day Jim Croce died. “Workin’ At The Carwash Blues” and “Roller Derby Queen” are extremely well written songs by Croce.

[@robny1461]

A very special artist who left us waaaaay too young, just as his star was shining brightly - tragically, for all of about 1-1/2 years. I remember exactly where I was when they announced on the car radio that he died in the plane crash.

[@bodiedog1743]

Cat Stevens! Such a GREAT catalog of songs! Wild WORLD, Morning Has Broken, Peace Train and , my favorite, Sitting!

[@troilusand]

Yes, a great catalog to be sure, but for my money, as a long time huge fan, I'd suggest some of his songs that are not necessarily on the front of everyone's brains/lots of other first time reactions to. Sitting is a good example, and Where Do The Children Play, Can't Keep It In, On The Road To Find Out.

[@bafalan]

Longer Boats

[@jeffreyclaypool3103]

The whole Tea for the Tillerman album is great!

[@mattiefee]

I was introduced to Jim Croce at 13 years old from the Columbia House CD buying program. Got his greatest hits for under $0.10

[@mikewoodrow5878]

Bringing you all the very best in entertainment!

[@jameshill2450]

There is no possible way to tell the story more succinctly than Jim did. This song takes the idea that "less is more" to heart and makes you feel huge emotions from a very small song. He has the ability to tell so much story in such a short line of dialogue that the ending of "You can keep the dime" being only half a line actually conveys extra feeling because he's NOT saying more. You KNOW that he could have filled that if he wanted to, so it's clear that he is making a point with that intentional emptiness. How many artists have you ever heard of before that can make an impact by NOT saying something?

[@lauriebath9477]

🎶 There's something in my eye, you know it happens every time, I think about the love that I thought would save me....

[@OrangeRed1234]

The part right after Jim Croce says "you can keep the dime" and stops singing and doesn't finish the line is genius.

[@wayne_twentyfive]

Yep.. It's like he's confirming, what else is there left to say ? .. Nothing .. Genius for sure.

[@BrianBell7]

either Time in a Bottle or I've Got A Name probably next. both excellent in different ways. Operator is the first Croce tune I ever heard and is still my favorite. I had the original 45 when it came out. The "B" side was "One Less Set of Footsteps", also good.

[@okpainter9700]

"Ill have to say I love you in a song " and " One less set of footsteps " are my Favs ☮️❤️

[@ChicoEscuela]

Masterpiece

[@lowellfay2469]

As Terri suggested "Time in A Bottle" His bigger radio hits were Don't mess around with Jim, and Bad Bad Le Roy Brown, and had a moderate hit with Roller Derby Queen

[@mlbmba9546]

Awesome watching you guys instantly turn into mesmerized bobble head dolls at Jim Croce’s brilliance. Welcome to the club.

[@suzannesheridan9535]

The catalogue he was able to build in the very short time he was with us is phenomenal. We can only imagine what he would have created if he had lived. So poetic, beautiful and timeless. You must check out 'Time in a Bottle' and 'I've Got a Name'. Thanks guys!

[@johnlarsen2766]

These suggestions will obviously be repeated, but here it goes. “Time in a bottle”, “Leroy Brown”, “I’ve got a name”, “You don’t mess around with Jim”. One of the timeless singer/song writers from the 70’s. A friend of mine got married in the 80’s, and had “Time in a bottle” played at the wedding which was a perfect song for the occasion. Have a great weekend guys! 🎸

[@sallyphillips9175]

"Time in a Bottle" is a beautiful, timeless love song. Exquisite choice for a wedding.

[@roserollins9800]

WORKING AT THE CAR WASH BLUES

[@brushstroke3733]

I'm at an age and stage of life where every song makes me cry. 😢😂😢

[@michlkwitz]

But that's the true meaning of music, isn't it? There's a song for every emotion, event, life-changing moment, etc. And it's different songs for all of us but we all understand when someone says something like "this song saved me life."

[@luther1546]

What a legend he was. I'm glad younger people are learning about this wonderful musician.

[@ruelsmith]

What a songwriter! Some of the best lyrics ever written by a singer/songwriter.

[@jonathanlocke6404]

My kids couldn't understand songs like this, because: A)Why does he have to have the assistance of a third party (the operator) just to place a phone call? And, B)Why is he paying someone cash money, in coins, for a phone call? Telephone songs are a lost art...

[@jonniiinferno9098]

right !! When Croce' sang the words - "keep the dime if you want" - i thought - my g-kids wont know what the heck that is all about - "g-pa what the heck is a phone booth ?"

[@greggw.brevoort]

lol. Twenty years ago, when we'd hear this song, the usual reaction was "Remember when it was a dime?" (it jumped to a quarter sometime in the 80's). Now, it's like, "Remember pay phones?"

[@classicrocklady6288]

Time in a Bottle, for sure. He was such a great story teller. Such a loss.😞

[@marge3626]

I grew up listening to the singer/songwriters in the 70’s. Their music still stands the test of time. Every time I hear a Jim Croce song, I can’t help but wonder what more he had to give us.

[@comet52]

Hadn't heard this in a long time... could still sing along with every lyric and feel it all. Was a huge song back in the day.

[@denisedinwiddie9543]

Any of this mans tunes are a plus. He is the original campfire king! Love his music. Miss him.

[@cazgerald9471]

Look at the track listing of Jim Croce "Photographs & Memories: His Greatest Hits" - you can't miss with any one of those songs.

[@janegl48]

His songs came from his soul. Highly recommend Time in a Bottle and I've Got a Name.

[@jasonremy1627]

"Time in a Bottle" is gorgeous. He had such a range.

[@chrisdurham6517]

I asked for three Jim Croce albums when I was eight. Through all the crazy changes over the last 45-plus years, I still know every word of each song. He's one of the greatest.

[@pinkfreud62]

I still have this 45. Bought it when it came out and I was only 9. I had a pretty mature taste in music as a young girl.

[@karenbautista9236]

He’s another great storyteller through his music.

[@Marcus-Oh-really-yes]

Jim Croce's song "Time in a Bottle," which reached No. 1 after his death, is especially poignant. He wrote it about his 2-year-old son A.J., whom he didn't get to see grow up after all, but it's also a love song to his wife.

[@marian.jablonski54]

Here's something that might make you tear up again. At the age of four AJ Croce was blinded due to horrific abuse by a boyfriend of his mother. He was hospitalized for months - when he was around 10 he regained some sight on one eye. He's a musician now himself.

[@TheDivayenta]

@@marian.jablonski54 how could someone who was with such a gentle soul as Jim pick a child abuser next? That poor kid.

[@georgeperkins4171]

You guys can analyze a song I've heard a thousand times, and make me choke-up by really listening to the meaning. I hope you never stop doing this.

[@Joshuadgog]

One of the best songs of all time. Jim is a great songwriter.

[@liamg2271]

The brilliance of this song cannot be overstated. It's masterclass starting with Maury's sublime guitar, Jim's voice, the poignant and beautiful lyrics, the melody and complex composition, and the virtuoso performance by two phenomenal artists.

[@rebeccamunoz2948]

Great reaction guys, thanks for delving into older ballads. Jim Croce is pronounced “Crow-chee”. Time in a bottle is just timeless. Give it a listen🎶🎶💕💕🦋

[@ruthparker9756]

I read through a ton of comments for the pronunciation lol. I always thought that was how it's pronounced, but was unsure after Alex mentioned it.

[@barriekelley2241]

I saw a clip on KZbin of Jim on a TV show hosted by Helen Reddy and she pronounced his name as crow chee, so I guess that’s what it is.

[@tgtrout]

Couldn't agree more gentlemen! "Time in a Bottle" and "I Got a Name" are also excellent. "Roller Derby Queen" and "Bad, Bad, LeRoy Brown" were hits and fun, but I have always preferred the more serious Jim Croce.

[@rmyAddison]

Croce wrote this song about a soldier in a phone booth. He was waiting to use the phone and overheard the soldier getting dumped by his girlfriend, the song grew out of the hurt of losing someone.............Martin Guitars had a Jim Croce artist model, it had a real dime at the 12th fret.

[@danielmchenry1000]

Not only am moved by how you took the stomach punch of the spirit of this song but impressed by the fact you knew what an operator was and what "keep the dime", meant. good 1. S tier reaction.

[@marseneau7]

One of the best songwriters ever. Lost way too soon. I was very young when he died but still play his songs all the time. Love "I've got a name" as well.