Anti-Zionist Jew Vs. Rudy Rochman

At Berkeley University we came across a group of Jewish students active in movements against Jewish liberation and empowerment. It may not make much sense on a surface level that Jewish students stand so firmly against the interest of their own people, but there are many factors which play a role in leading them to their conclusions.
1) Misinformation - Today in intellectual and politically active spaces there is a large amount of misinformation that demonizes, delegitimizes, and holds double standards to the Jewish people and Israel. Blood libels, false information, information taken out of context, or manipulation of information has become the norm in such spaces which causes many individuals to come to false conclusions.
2) Disconnected identity - There are around 5.4 million Jews in America and studies show that assimilation rates are around 60-80%. Most Jews living in America do not have a proper understanding of their own identity, history, narrative, or a deep enough connection to their collective and homeland. If one does not know or value who they are, then why would they feel the need to stand up for their identity or collective’s aspirations when under attack?
3) Never learning about Palestinians - Although Jewish education does not teach their youth to hate Palestinians, it fails to educate them about the nuances in the conflict and transmitting a valid comprehension of what Palestinian identity is, what suffering they go through, or what aspirations they have. When they discover those nuances it causes many to feel betrayed or lied to, and as a reaction turn against their own community.
4) Pro-Palestinians students are forced to be anti-Israel - Many Jewish students who are aware of the struggles Palestinians go through truly want to help their cousins and become activists for their cause. However, the only outlet that exists on campuses that offers a way for one to fight for Palestinians are those that are obsessed with delegitimization, demonization, and the destruction of Israel/Jewish self-determination. Why are there no groups on campuses that are pro both peoples and seek to bring these populations together, rather than investing time and energy in dividing and using suffering to attack the other.
5) Social pressure - Judaism is based on helping others and making the world a better place. Jewish students who hold these values seek to be involved in movements which help minorities and create a world that is more just. When they show up they are told that if they don’t take an anti-Israel position, they will be rejected from their social circles.
6) Reaction to trauma - There are always consequences to traumatic experiences. One can fight back, one can pretend the problem doesn’t exist, or one can even subconsciously blame themselves and side with their oppressors. Jews have dealt with their fair share of trauma. Some Jews fight back, some Jews make excuses, and some Jews side with movements who seek to pursue their collective’s destruction.
Jews who fall prey to any of the six causes are not evil nor self-hating. There is a reason for their conclusions and we must focus on educating and empowering them rather than ostracizing and insulting them.
This video was made in collaboration with the Berkeley Tikvah student group.
If you like our work and would like to see more projects like this please support us at / rudyrochman or www.paypal.me/....
Edited by: Leibman Productions

[@celestialyuki3383]

It’s amazing how these kids are so arrogant that they aren’t even willing to show the littlest respect by listening to someone who clearly has more background and education about the subject than they ever will. Instead of shutting up for one second and letting him speak, all they do is laugh and mock him. I salute you Rudy for the patience you have time and time again.

[@ronimatalon6825]

That’s no arrogance, it’s cowardly. If they had confidence in their knowledge of the situation they would have been happy to debate. Just a bunch of bored teenagers that create damage for fun.

[@CreamCheesePepperJelly]

They are simply children. Rudy may be close in age. However, he is light-years beyond their intellect.

[@katinmazniv4714]

They wouldn’t even listen to a Palestinian if he said he doesn’t want all Jews dead

[@J7pat7]

@@ronimatalon6825 They just want to be part of the crowd .

[@gal2659]

They are clueless spoiled brats who live in an ivory tower but think they know it all. I mean, the main guy is acting like an edgy 14 year old at best.. is this the college material in the states ? oh boy.. I'm not pro-Israel much or pro Zionist, but have to understand why do so many "educated" college kids in US and Europe are indoctrinated with this concept: 10:44 ""Jews immigrated from Europe" - yes, and Asia, and Africa, and some were already living there, even before many of the "indigenous" Palestinian population, which came also as work immigrants throughout empires, or before that as Arab conquerors.. Why do they always try to emphasise it as "THE WHITE COLONIALISM".. who made Colonialism and being white, the number one enemy in colleges in Western society ?

[@Fatimah-rj4fn]

I’m an Iraqi Arab and I consider Palestinians as sibling but as Rudy said people are suffering and these kids are laughing and actually think they are helping, how stupid 🤦🏻‍♀️

[@muhammadjordanpratama5008]

To be precise, they just don't want to be called racist or suppressed.

[@edog101]

Best comment on this thread. 100%

[@Dave-nh2kj]

🇮🇱✌🏻🇮🇱

[@twistedyogert]

Yeah, they aren't too bright. But to be fair Rudy is kind of intimidating. He's built like a tank or a battleship.

[@thedude9941]

I couldn't take these people serious for that reason.

[@skrilly321]

Guy claims Rudy is a meme and becomes instant meme

[@indranildutta2961]

😂😂😂😂

[@Nottherealguyfieri]

honestly anyone who uses the term "you're such a meme" instantly becomes a meme

[@leojanjgava1714]

insert emperor palpatine "ironic" meme here lol

[@ibrahramadhan5147]

That was true

[@ibrahramadhan5147]

That was the fact on the ground

[@TheNotehead]

I think one of the primary reasons the kid kept saying "I'm not going to debate with you" is because he knew he was outmatched, and because deep down he knew that he was much more emotionally invested in his own personal engagement rather than in justice itself. And also he may have suspected that he would come across as an utter douche, in which case he would have been absolutely right.

[@ejl74]

Outmatched? You have to actually know what you’re talking about in order to be outmatched. That clown had no idea what he’s talking about. He just repeats what he hears on TikTok and has his stupid little laugh and thinks that it’s all about regurgitating stupid little comments. He learned how to socialize with other people on Fortnite.

[@russellgrosser-7677]

The kid struck me as emotionally and socially awkward. Even if this wasn't within an Israel-Palestine context, my guess is he'd behave the same way in almost any other situation. He's clearly uncomfortable looking ANYONE in the face, not just Rudy. My guess is that it's because most people are psychologically more comfortable texting and staring at their phone screens. For some, it's a literal addiction.

[@death-aura]

10:45 "Jews immigrated from Europe", that's how I know she has no clue about the conflict. Literally none of my grandparents immigrated from Europe.

[@gheller2261]

Sure, but here's the thing - when did it become bad for people to emigrate to Israel or anywhere else? Ah, only when the immigrants are Jewish.

[@tecumseh821]

She ignores the half the pop if israel that's not from europe

[@koen7-77]

@@tecumseh821 Right.. Also all the three main diasporic groups originate from the Levant and Mediterranean, with Sepahridcs and Mizrahis remaining in parts of North Africa and the Middle East.

[@burjanbarnabas5368]

These pro palestinian jews are always askenazi jews..The problem that they doesnt feel connected to the middle easy and think that israelis like him..but most of israeli jews from the middle east and also there are many other including sskenszi jews who's family was there even before modern zionust movemrnt..like family(mother side) of thr israeli president Herzog or family of former israeli oresident reuven livlin, family of sara netanyahu etc

[@alexanderbarlow3264]

I used to be like this young man. I was staunchly anti-zionist, called for the destruction of the state of Israel. It's so frustrating to see him just dismiss Rudy as a 'centrist' - seeing this as left vs right is the problem. There are left-wing zionists, myself included. There are right wing Palestinians. This isn't about left wing vs right wing, this is about a conflict that needs to stop. Rudy's patience is amazing.

[@a_paris3082]

As a left wing Zionist I absolutely agree

[@liorbur]

Rudy is a left wing zionist. That's pretty nice

[@TurinTurambar98]

The Left is absolutely the problem. They are subverted fools and a tleast the Right can actually have a conversation, the Left are so quick to label others as "racist" that it makes the conversation toxic. I am a Right Wing Zionist, whilst I got respect for all Zionists including Rudy, after reading a lot of Leftist literature and philosophy, no, this is absolutely the characteristics of the Left. They literally live in a pseudo-reality, which is why you cannot have a conversation with them.

[@indianmonk3380]

I think he was calling the other guy as centrist

[@Rockandrollgeerage]

The left today is much different than a classic Liberal. The far left that breeds in places like Berkley is very dangerous to our Democracy and free speech.

[@לאה-ב2ע]

These students simply radiate second-hand embarrassment. It's cringeworthy and painful to watch.

[@0phex]

I think that those student struggle to be popular in their campus so they go around with Palestine flag because it's a trend now...

[@marcusisaiahx]

@@0phex #FREEPALESTINE!

[@leonardogurney5488]

@@marcusisaiahx #AidIsrael 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱

[@marcusisaiahx]

@@leonardogurney5488 #freepalestine. people with EurAsian ancestry are not true descendants of Jews mentioned in the Torah.

[@Lebronwski]

@@marcusisaiahx can you give a reference

[@Yzjoshuwave]

This level of willingness to stay centered when someone’s being so personally antagonistic is pretty incredible. I’m not sure I understand why some of those people think Israel isn’t native to the region.

[@xStickStockx]

Because Jews are white and are European agents in Colonization.. That was the thought of the Arabs since 1882 till this day and is now shared by the "educated" graduates who base their world views on race. A nugget of useful information, Israel is about half Arabic Jews (from many Arab nations) and I believe around 7% of all Jews in Israel are Ethiopian.. Like you literally have the most diverse country aside the US perhaps, A democracy (even now, what dictatorship allows protests? and so many), The "Gayest" city in the world is Tel Aviv.. Israel respects all religions and you can find all of them living in peace.. (There are many Muslim and Christian Arabs that are citizens of Israel and live in peace with their Jewish neighbors).. yet progressive people call it basically N4z! Germany..

[@xStickStockx]

@@ibeenstephcurrywiththeglock that's the opposite of what I'm saying 😂 That's the claim made by anti-Israelis to claim Israel is a white colonial power or something stupid like that~

[@segurall1]

@@xStickStockx to your point, even Ashkenazi Jews can trace their lineage to the Levant.

[@DSN007]

coz they dont know what indigenous means. just bcoz a lot of jews got displaced n came back makes them settlers for these pos cl owns

[@AmandaMerkel]

​@@xStickStockxArabs are actually legally considered white in the US and both white people and arabs are caucasoid so they don't see a difference. A lot of Arabs look like they were plucked straight out of southern Europe. So to them it's all the same.

[@VayreenaVulpera]

"You have any evidence or even basic arguments? " "I have a flag!"

[@talginat4958]

The disrespect they showed just breaks my heart, how can you create a real future with people like that. You can agree or disagree with him, but to show respect costs you nothing and makes you a better human to continue with

[@MrMoo272]

what makes it worse is these are uni students. They are supposed to be completely open to learning new ideas yet they have completely closed themselves off from learning anything about what they're protesting, from a man who has experienced it first-hand and does work in this field, Rudy probably knows more about this than any of their professors. It's would be like a physics student meeting einstein or hawking and denying everything they have to say because their professor said something different. I get the feeling, the students there who are just rude and trying to shut down the conversation are the type of students who just study for years because they dont know what else to do with their lives and when then have finished their education, they end up working in walmart or someshit.

[@ndr_32]

Well, no good human being would agree with antisemitism. Even when it comes from a disrespectful, delusional and self-hating human being

[@DSN007]

break ur heart lol. it saddens me that dmmies like these can't b educated by a bit of sp anking.

[@antonknaus3075]

You can, they are just still children in grown up bodies, sarcasm is the only threat you have left if your arguments are based in your own developing journey, unfortunately still no original thought.

[@philiprufus4427]

The same disrespect was shown to World War 11 veterans fifty years ago by similar ignorent studients who new nothing ! I bet they are quiet now.

[@trs8696]

"is someone here actually palestinian?" AWKWARD SILENCE

[@XXXant1]

so true

[@wardog7512]

The anti israel jew must be such a shame to his family and parents especially

[@paulinbrooklyn]

@@wardog7512 The kid comes across as very young, intellectually weak and a bit of a douche, but he will likely mature at some point.

[@aladdinarbab2164]

That's the problem. People who know nothing about the situation judge us as Israeli. My family are Afghanistan and Iran Jews, so these people get give me hate

[@captainbossman1016]

@@XXXant1 *insert cricket sounds here*

[@blakecyclops7231]

"The masculine Rudy Rochman, strong, big arms" Yes.

[@eldesconocido5734]

FACTS.

[@Luigi_NDLN]

Well that guy really demonstrated to have little brain

[@AnonYmous-bc3jt]

Says the self hating beta male lol 😂

[@catharticchills_]

Their whole interaction gave me average fan vs average enjoyer vibes lmao

[@VAHZGEN]

More like chubby puppet

[@karnuna7]

Do they not understand that what they are doing is hurting the Palestinian cause? They genuinely believe that what they are doing is considered activism and it’s so sad. Rudy, your patience is impeccable, I genuinely salute you.

[@HigherVideos]

for real

[@SigalDa]

@Bungle Bear what genucide?

[@yosefplotkin5926]

@Bungle Bear no need to be rude your wasting your on time. Be educational not irrational

[@karnuna7]

@Bungle Bear are you aware that there are also Palestinian Christians? Stop making this a Muslim issue when it’s not.

[@SaintCharbelMiracleworker]

@@karnuna7 My sister married a Palestinian Catholic who is an Israeli citizen. He wanted to join the IDF when he was younger but the muslim Palestinians in his town in Northern Israel made his life hell when they heard. He even got threats and they threatened his parents. When they go to the local schools they don't learn about christian history or jewish history or even the Jewish roots of christianity they only learn about Arab islamic history, religion and culture. The hatred for anything Jewish runs deep, some even accuse Jesus of not being Jewish. My bother in law discovered during this experience via his grandfather that he is actually Aramean not Arab and his family have been there since the 6th century, they were lumped in with Arabs and so ended up identifying with Arab history, culture and food etc. a cultural genocide. Thankfully another Aramean Catholic Shadi Khalloul who served in the IDF as a paratrooper petitioned the government and recently the Israeli government legally recognized Arameans as a separate and distinct ethnic group with their own culture, history and language. My nieces and nephew have "Aramean" listed as their ethnic group on their birth certificates.

[@tyw2675]

It really encapsulates this conflict - one side wants peace, and wants to talk. The other just responds with rage and hatred.

[@dorbacal]

These people absolutely HATE getting their views challenged and they silence every opportunity someone gives you to challenge their view, disgraceful

[@nancikuba42]

It shows how little they know, so best to mock & ridicule as the way to go. Best definition of a moron.

[@NarnianLady]

The young fella says he is against 'ethno-states'.. while waving the Palestinian flag... the irony..

[@26Toshiro]

Why is that ironic?

[@26Toshiro]

@@GC-yw1mn Ah you’re right that is ironic - Abbas is a hypocrite for saying that. But in the same light, powerful countries like the US and Israel who are so vehemently against terrorism are amongst the world’s largest and most powerful terrorist states. That, I think, is quite ironic as well.

[@kaprimat7031]

@@26Toshiro theyre not terrorist states.

[@26Toshiro]

@@patriotsforisrael3610 Invading and supporting military coups, killing a top general, killing a nuclear scientist, killing hundreds of Palestinians without impunity. These aren’t in Wikipedia because they’re not acts of terrorism in the perspectives “western” and “developed” countries. Nonetheless, they are acts of terrorism per the official US State’s definition of terrorism. Are you a supporter of terrorism? 🤔

[@26Toshiro]

@@kaprimat7031 They are considered terrorist states per the academic definition of the term.

[@Kennychoco22]

He’s so scared to talk to Rudy because he’s scared of facing facts head on. Instead he keeps looking around trying to get support from his peers while attempting to turn Rudy into a caricature and failing miserably.

[@soldier6173]

@@trafficmonsoonacademy562 did you see other debates he had? Pre orginated with someone who he discussed meeting with and having this pre set debate? Just because he didnt debate your specific commentator so he is a coward? If you want to see it suggsest it to him in the comments and he may see it and attempt such debate.

[@trafficmonsoonacademy562]

@GM 97 would it be allright to ask you a question?

[@trafficmonsoonacademy562]

@@soldier6173 Do you believe in a God and Judgement day?

[@soldier6173]

@@trafficmonsoonacademy562 yes

[@chaimoberman752]

@@trafficmonsoonacademy562 שטויות. המטרה של רודי היא לעורר את האנשים בגיל הזה בחיים שלהם, שהם בדרך כלל הפעילים בנושא לחשוב קצת על הפתרון. אין לו עניין להתווכח. כואב לראות יהודי שמזלזל במולדת... אני חושב שזה כואב גם לרודי.

[@noamlurie1963]

If someone isn’t interested in a friendly debate or conversation then they either enjoy putting fuel in a conflict or they can’t back up their beliefs with actual logic

[@chanarottenstein9368]

Well said

[@JohnC-iv8jo]

most true,

[@bertbrett3764]

The same feeling I have when talking to religous people

[@deedee.nithaidgh9168]

Why would anyone want a nice conversation with people who support this? imeu.org/article/the-prawer-plan-ethnic-cleansing-in-the-negev1

[@ameenalsubee8900]

@@bertbrett3764 Exactly. I am a Muslim and I will get into any debate with anyone defending my religion and rights of everyone oppressed in the world including Palestinians. Having said that, if you have any questions about I’m stance on Palestine or Islam in general you are welcome to reply to this and I will have a thorough conversation with you.

[@knoxvilletz]

גודל הסבלנות שלך היא הגדולה האמתית שלך. עלה והצלח ותודה על הכל.

[@orangechickengorl]

There’s no way Rudy’s first job wasn’t in retail because the patience that former retail workers have is immense

[@ophirbactrius8285]

Doh skalik mung nim natang anok harang zoineh kapiak loknak sapa mampuh pung mung nim baso kopiak loknak bongsak pah ke sudoh.

[@DianeMonahan]

These types of so-called students are insufferable

[@leohasson9270]

“Jews immigrated from Europe”, “I don’t think this is like worth my time” smh, keep going Rudy!

[@kittenpawsbb]

She was rude. Nobody called her over. They can’t respect themselves or even each other, that’s why the other put the flag over her face. 😑

[@viadharmawheel]

Jews left Israel. It was not like last year or 10 years ago. The DNA of Jews has mixed even though they try to keep to themselves. Any claim based upon 2k years ago is just not valid for anyone but nationalistic Jews (Zionists).

[@davidtrak2679]

@@viadharmawheel *Forcibly exiled. How come Palestinians are considered refugees even if only their one grandfather left Israel as a child? Where do we draw the line? How can people in Israel, Egypt, Iraq call themselves Arabs, while they've never live anywhere near the Arab peninsula? Identities are much more complex than that, the same way the Palestinian identity is so new, but can still be valid.

[@viadharmawheel]

@@davidtrak2679 I believe you need to take a snapshot of who is living at a location at a given time. It is construct created by man to create artificial borders which is causing a lot of the problems.

[@davidtrak2679]

@@viadharmawheel That way you can justify pretty much any injustice and conquest along the way, but sure, even so, both Israelis and Palestinians live there now, not one group is gonna pack up and move.

[@user-pi5tt3nq8u]

Him: "I'm against ethno states in general" Also him: *waving palestinian flag

[@liorbur]

He probably supports kicking jews from the Levant lmao

[@partydave1067]

He is a troll.... or just a jackass, Maybe both?

[@user-sb4hr2gd3p]

It's worse than that, the proposed Palestinian state would not only be an ethnostate, but an authoritarian theocracy at that.

[@XiangnuKhaan]

Palestine isn't really an ethnostste simce non pali muslims would be allowed to live there as it contains the third holiest site in islam

[@marangibraltar4045]

@@XiangnuKhaan It's ridiculous and hypocritical. The State of Israel gives full equality of rights to minorities within it, and you still call it an ethnostate. The fact that the state of Palestine will allow some 'Muslims' to live in it does not make it a multinational state. The hypocrisy in this context is extremely outrageous. All those who work for human rights, LGBT rights, women's rights, are working to destroy a state that upholds these values, and wants to establish a state that will trample all these values, and be ethnostate and racist. By the way, today the situation is that there is a ban on Jews entering the territories under the control of the Palestinian Authority (it is true that the signs say 'no entry for Israelis' but in practice entry of Israeli Arabs is allowed and the ban is enforced only on Jews) There is no parallel prohibition in the territories of the State of Israel, and in all its territory non-Jews can roam freely.

[@alxbkers]

It's horrible to see what is happening in US colleges when it comes to difficult issues like this conflict. The students are almost always stuck in a terrible infinite loop created by their professors and teachers and are literally unable to have any decent conversation or debate. It's terrible and it's going to create more issues in the world in the near future than we have now. I really believe this close mindedness is what is going to destroy our world in the near future.

[@theliminallens]

I agree. I find this very concerning. University life is supposed to be all about discourse and learning. How can these people be students of one of America’s elite universities and behave like that? I don’t get it. I’m truly baffled. It’s a case study in the coddling of the American mind.

[@theliminallens]

@@ibeenstephcurrywiththeglock I hope you are right about that. It’s been a long time since I was a university student. I did see very concerning polling numbers showing a massive generational divide on this issue in the US (and probably Western Europe too, based on events there).

[@Magani79]

They are acting like 12 year olds and think they are cool... incredible

[@nancikuba42]

Reminds me actually of the kids in 6th grade.

[@dantchoums5089]

Even that is an insult to 12 yr olds.... They're like primates..

[@poorsam9173]

These immature little narcissists need to sort their lives out.

[@HelloYiddy]

They’re being coddled by their professors, university administrators, as well as at home. So, sorting is being very delayed.

[@ProfessorZoom2140]

OMG.. These guys are unbelievable! The way they constantly laugh and refuse to debate clearly shows that they have NOTHING to back there argument. Also, I find it hilarious how that guy constantly brings up Rudy's masculinity as if it's something bad.. yeah, Rudy is very masculine.. jealous much? 😂

[@viadharmawheel]

The biggest problem is the indigenous aspect. Rudy knows his logic is not iron clad and always moves on to getting along. Rudy's backend is commendable/right, but the frontend argument is just biased.

[@Magani79]

Masculinity in banned in America by the modern left, don't you know?

[@justforviewing2]

@@viadharmawheel You may be right, but why can't these student argue that? They have no skills or knowledge in formal logic because if they did, they would be able to better articulate their thoughts. They may even be able to challenge their own opinions and adjust accordingly.

[@viadharmawheel]

They need to learn and articulate. Problem today is everything gets on Social Media and can be cut and pasted to skew one way or the other. I am 100% for freedom of speech, the moment we dismiss people we go down the slippery slope to '1984' ...@@justforviewing2

[@josiahramos4943]

@@viadharmawheel How is that a weak point in his argument? There are enormous amounts of archaeological evidence from both inside and outside of Israel that confirm this claim.

[@kronosDking]

Wow, the level of patience from Rudy here is truly impressive.

[@gheller2261]

It actually can be maddening because in trying to find "common ground" he makes "admissions" about Israel that just aren't true. There are no injustices on "both sides." Every problem that "Palestinians" have is 100% self inflicted.

[@MatthewNouriel]

I've said it a million times literally when ever I watch your videos and I'll keep saying it. You have the patience of a saint. I don't know how you maintain your composure with people behaving this way. Bless you.

[@astrahcat1212]

Well because he's not acting out of hate

[@omax-sy8xp]

I went to this school. These idiots laughing while Rudy is being respectful shows the character of these kids

[@RailBuffRob]

Every one of these students is going to have to explain themselves out of this video at every job interview for the rest of their lives.

[@youtubedeletestomanyaccoun4247]

He put so many words into Rudy’s mouth so fast it was like a machine

[@thelastgeneration1926]

😂😂

[@vi8on855]

thats what they do , fake informaton , you just got to watch it live action lol

[@royty2353]

Even a Machine has more intelligence than this gawky flag waving airhead.

[@maimonmmiller]

It’s so sad to see those kids are so brainwashed

[@NA-gg7uy]

Yh and Israelis arent?

[@paprikaman1124]

@@NA-gg7uy no we aren't cus mind washed is when someone tells u lies and convinces u to believe it But we know the truth 🤣

[@alfeshzuber8043]

@@paprikaman1124 I know the truth words of arrogant who doesn't know anything 😂😂😂 over confident idiots

[@pebbles92able]

I can say the same about Rudy

[@eyalcohen175]

@@pebbles92able one is willing to have their ideas challenged and one isn't. There is no equivalency

[@maxruth1129]

"Oh so it's about common ground isn't it?" Rudy: "...yes..."

[@Balagoola]

This is why I much prefer and find it far more productive to have dialogue with Palestinians than to try to engage with anti-Zionist Jews who don't know a thing about Israel.

[@esthersteier6840]

I agree. Even your typical gen z kid Jewish or not Jewish. They don’t usually know what they are talking about

[@jhanig958]

Rudy, you have incredible patience and EQ. I don’t know how you kept so calm, but it’s beyond impressive to see how you conducted yourself, even in the face of such blatant antagonism. Good going, achi.

[@lvdon380]

"Jews immigrated from Europe" Omg... these ppl know absolutely nothing. Debate should've ended there.

[@AnonYmous-bc3jt]

@@יהונתןדובנו and the irony is that she doesn’t even know that her ancestors the Phlistines were not indigenous to Israel and came from modern day Greece smh 🤦🏻‍♀️ it’s impossible to debate with such ignorant, uneducated people

[@worldgripe]

What about Khazars a turkic tribe that converted to Judaism , they were not native to Israel. Could they be considered the ancestors of Ashkenazi Jews?

[@worldgripe]

@@יהונתןדובנו gotcha, but why in all the DNA test that widely spread right now like 23nme, myheritage ect... ashkenazi DNA all pointing out to Eastern Europe? Are they lying?

[@amenibouraoui815]

Yes that is what they did. They were scattered all over the world in africa, australia, europe , america

[@thetruth8542]

No they are actually right. You know absolutely nothing lol

[@donaldsaw]

Rudy - appreciate your patience with that guys in the hat. He's clearly wanting to engage but has no substance to debate you as he has no facts to back his claim. As you clearly pointed out, people are suffering (on both sides) and them taking the piss out of you achieves nothing! Keep doing what you do Rudy.

[@HigherVideos]

Those guys were immature and don't understand that their pig-headedness contribute to ongoing violence

[@HigherVideos]

@@89pok for real 😂very weird

[@thetasteoflimes]

The suffering is disproportionate. Ofc you must put that behind you to move forward. But I think it’s more difficult for one side than the other.

[@hadar5422]

@@thetasteoflimes as an Israeli i can agree with that

[@trafficmonsoonacademy562]

I dont understand how Israel is a legitimate country when they are slowly stealing Palestinian lands. Anyone up for a dialogue?

[@danaholtzman8426]

When they tried to bully the Pete guy, these kids maturity level is literally like the whole world is a college campus and giggling and yelling mean things is their form of social justice.

[@HelloYiddy]

They’re ultimately self-involved and immature. This is something to do, and to be “cool”.

[@lmeadows8276]

Thanks!

[@Dan_L1209]

This guy “anti-Zionist Jew,” is illustrating strong “hate my Dad” vibes

[@Love-eg2vf]

They’re always either very effeminate or screechy. I’ve known that for a long time, but what’s interesting is this specific one acknowledges it by saying “you’re so masculine” to Rudy. I’ve had this long standing theory that leftist men are channeling their suppressed humiliation at being “lesser” males (I personally DONT buy into the idea that a man’s worth is defined by his masculinity) by being catty and hateful and trying to “take down” their supposed competitors via stealth means. In this case, it would be through siding with their competitor’s enemy.

[@MonitoBandito]

Your patience here is so commendable, Rudy. A lesser man would have started launching uppercuts.

[@nirvicos]

haha totally!

[@thunderhawk358]

I've never seen so many blockheads in one video.

[@ahmadnangarhari1823]

Just look to the coward IDF. You'll see the real blockheads

[@iduy9219]

Minecraft head more like

[@flx2525]

That guy was annoying as hell... I could never

[@hueyfreeman1983]

Im a hardcore anti-zionist but that guy was annoying as hell

[@davidpoho]

@@hueyfreeman1983 You do know that the exact definition of zionism is just the right of jews to self determinate as a nation? So by being anti-that What do you really stand for? The death of all jews? Or to deny all jews from being a nation and a state?

[@hueyfreeman1983]

@@davidpoho You Zionists need to get over yourselves, your not that important. There are more Jews living outside of the "holy land" than there are there and they seem pretty safe, as long as you lot don't go around telling people you are Gods special people then no one is going to treat you any different

[@MrDlama]

@@hueyfreeman1983 and I'm anti whatever you are.

[@segevsemail29]

@@hueyfreeman1983 we don’t tell people wee are gods special people. We never do that, we never did, it’s a Stigma. Only the hardcore religious ones say that

[@redrazr6269]

“Do you think I’m a self-hating token jew?” Yes, I do.

[@russellgrosser-7677]

He needs to lay off the Norman Finkelstein literature, IMHO.

[@leslymarshmallows]

“I’m not gonna engage in a dialogue with you…” (meanwhile disrupting and heckling, waving a giant flag in your face.) 😂 laughable

[@MaccabiHaifaVideos]

"Dont talk to me , free Palestine" I really wonder if they think they could change things like that or it's just a fashion for them

[@youtubedeletestomanyaccoun4247]

Haifa gonna win the league

[@MaccabiHaifaVideos]

@Starhopper Right! The Exact definition

[@MaccabiHaifaVideos]

@@youtubedeletestomanyaccoun4247 We are wish 🙏

[@HigherVideos]

The typical fake, performative activism from wannabes

[@elonaackerman4163]

This guy was thinking he was cool he was just awkward

[@liorbur]

Rudy: "are you willing to engage in a conversation with me? Some idiot:" free palestine" These people have no arguments

[@mrt7333]

*debate 100*

[@patriotsforisrael3610]

The Jews are the ones who said "Free Palestine". Because they wanted to liberate the Holy Land (Eretz Israel) from the Ottoman occupation and then from the British occupation. "Free Palestine" is a Jewish Zionist saying. Here: instagram.com/p/CByQ4w-gM9b/?igshid=4lq7nhfmn0ym

[@mrt7333]

@@patriotsforisrael3610 BRUH

[@liorbur]

@@patriotsforisrael3610 very true. My grandma lived in mandatory palestine

[@sambillian1024]

*Palestine is suddenly freed because tons of people scream over Israeli and Jewish voices*

[@rachelloo2455]

I mean, the guy has a point... Rudy does have nice arms. 😂

[@aggghgaabk]

Fax

[@Seanonyoutube]

That skinny boy was totally into Rudy

[@rachelloo2455]

@@Seanonyoutube again, I can't blame him.

[@pinkteddybear6360]

@@Seanonyoutube LMAOOO

[@HomerSika1]

he do be like that

[@Trottellumme123]

“Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the universe.” (Albert Einstein) 😪

[@salter434]

You are a saint, Rudy. Admirable patience.

[@devilslayeroo]

Half knowledge is very dangerous...more dangerous is that people made lies as a truth and don't want listen when truth are being told..... keep doing the work Rudy we are with you..love from India

[@raven86]

"This is wrong but I don't want to lose my time" She doesn't know anything about Jewish history and she acts like she know the truth this is so annoying!

[@Judahrandom]

Regardless of ones political beliefs, everyone can learn a lesson from Rudy’s straight headed, calm, and well thought out approach to engaging in conversation with disrespectful people that oppose him.

[@jasonmason1000]

I wonder what he thinks would have happened to him if he was at that concert on October 7th. I don’t think Hamas would ask him before they shoot if he’s pro Israel or Anti Zionist

[@toxiczion4635]

You can’t debate gen z, they just lack the moral values, the intellect and the knowledge

[@BartenderW]

hey that's not fair, some of us actually have a brain

[@marianomarin6324]

And i thought the girl from the last video was bad

[@kittenpawsbb]

But she wasn’t disrespectful and act like she’s better than Rudy. Agree with pp, she had the conversation, and that’s the important part to having an understanding.

[@johanna3523]

the people who are against you arent even doing anything for Palestinians but talking about them struggling. you are physically helping Palestinian and Israeli familes bless your heart ❤️.

[@JessicaPerez-lk5rr]

These kids are so ignorant they laugh and do not take things seriously.

[@OCaptainMercaptan]

lmfao the dude has trouble even looking Rudy in the eyes

[@Rahab111222]

Cowardly femboy energy. Probably has issues with his father.

[@marioluigi9599]

That's because he knows once he looks into his eyes, he'll be lost for words. He'll be locked in and his position would be steadily yet gently taken apart by the man. That's why he keeps saying "I'm not interested in a debate". He wouldn't be able to handle it at all and he'd feel stupid afterwards. So he wants to stay away from being locked in, face to face with him. All he can do is just hover around and spout random insults and unfactual information

[@sarakay9149]

"I'm against ethno-states" says the person who protests for a Palestinian state

[@youkinder1837]

It's very very very weird, that people say, Jews are not indigenous to Israeli, when the truth is only a mouseclick away. Jews are indigenous to this land, Arabs are not, end of discussion!

[@ericmwai1149]

It’s like a dog chasing its tail while barking. 🤦🏽‍♂️ Rudy, you’re a class, and full of patience. Keep up the good work!

[@nifnom]

Those guys are so scared to speak with you. You are amazing Rudy, keep doing what you do, you are my hero!

[@pebbles92able]

I don't think they are scared lol...just know what a staunch and brainwashed Zionist he is and nothing can change his mind.

[@iduy9219]

@@pebbles92able ofc a Brianwashed pro Palestineian rudy all he saying is right your just delusional you can’t take the fact🥱

[@AllanLimosin]

The guy who was proposed to make a debate about Zionism who didn't stop replying “Free Palestine.” knew that he would lost the debate and go off-topic, this kind of people are loosers that talk about a theme without be able to defend his thesis and point of view, that how you can see how high they don't understand what they are fighting for. 🇹🇷🇮🇱🇵🇸

[@russellgrosser-7677]

Poor Rudy. He was interacting with downright emotional eight-year-olds in young adult bodies.

[@NetanelWorthy]

“ I don’t want to debate you.” But yet, he wants to stand in front of him, and fly a flag? This is what you call in the dictionary instigation. Those who have no argument, use this line constantly.

[@TheJncool]

"You're such a centrist man" he says like it's bad to not take an extremist ideology

[@daniel_kryz]

Exactly. I'm a centrist, too, and I believe people confuse extremism as authenticity. I think people should realize that there's often good and bad on both the right and left. We should learn from people with diverging opinions, not stay within our own bubbles.

[@esther.revival9054]

They are so disrespectful young generation who don’t have any patience 🤦🏽‍♀️🤦🏽‍♀️🤦🏽‍♀️

[@Net_Willis]

Rudi, you a Saint for being so patient with this clown

[@nettaboyar9870]

This guy is like the perfect example for the stereotype of a an American kid who’s whole life is in tik tok.

[@russellgrosser-7677]

Good observation. I noticed he kept circling back to "likes" and "views" in his conversation, and kept checking his phone. (My guess is he's a clout chaser.) This young kid had zero interest in any legit dialogue with Rudy...and, methinks, zero interest in any meaningful education at a VERY expensive public school like Berkeley. He'll either transfer at best or drop out at worst.

[@abelashes2676]

He won't debate because he doesn't understand the issue. Its as simple as that.

[@elonaackerman4163]

What a shame for him to go against his own people just to be accepted by others.

[@asherlevy1951]

@Jean Reinhardt visit Israel and see for yourself the so called war criminal activities ..afterwards you'll realize you over reacted ..and maybe you'll realize if you don't have actual proof within a court of law then all you doing is playing slander to what ppl show you through narratives and social media..I'm serious come to Israel for yourself to where they say there are such acts ..if you ain't there then you're receiving broken communication..think bout how someone believing negative pictures about you and not giving you the sec to show it's all lies ..this is what most ppl do today with almost every story in the networks ..they get emotional and then based not on proof but certain emotion that they've "sided' w the "right" side

[@elonaackerman4163]

@@asherlevy1951 I wouldn’t have responded better. You all are just following the move, learning that Zionism is Colonism when it’s actually the exact contrary. I suppose you are not interested about Palestinians when they suffer in Jordania/Egypt and all, but when it’s Israel, it’s apparently different. The double standard doesn’t fool anyone except the ones who sadly internalized antisemitism. If you want to know the truth, you can search for it. Otherwise you can continue on the path of lies forever not realizing you are slowly falling. Goodbye

[@TrueHitch]

Facts!

[@shayzombiex3851]

The amount of patients Rudy have for him is mind blowing, keep up the love🇮🇱❤️

[@matthewgrech7131]

This is genuinely so sad to see. 💔 When we stop even recognising the healing potential for dialogue and reconciliation, that is when you know that humanity has lost.

[@russellgrosser-7677]

Rudy was literally the only emotionally mature person in that crowd milling around him.

[@kevingutierrez9273]

Respect for Mr. Rochman from the Philippines.

[@arnavthescientist1149]

A white American against a colonialist ethno state. The irony there is of the charts.😂

[@shlomitabrahamoff4504]

This pro palestinian guy does not have one coherent word to say

[@APeculiarDiaryVideos]

"So basically you like indigenous people until they are on the ground" BOOM POW!!!! Rudy slayed this kid with high fever TRUTH by pointing out the kids hypocricy.

[@chenF122]

Wow, how much confidence and explaining in such a calm way in front of such annoying people, I appreciate it

[@rosdavid8626]

These kids are just a bunch of clowns but unfortunately because of such clowns the most of the people don't see a clear picture of the situation and not even thinking to open themselves for a real solution, instead of that they are just spreading hate ... Rudy your the man and thank you for your patience, a big respect for you. כל הכבוד לך אחי

[@ryandavidsmeehuijzen36]

Strong ending btw. Respect for him for helping Rudy out and genuinely listening and understanding!👌

[@liorbur]

"you are getting no views" Rudy is literally one of the most influential jewish activists and he gets subscribers and also has videos with quite a few jews. This guy doesn't understand what he's talking about

[@User9681e]

He should get more views but the youtube algorithm prefer more left or right videos as recommendation because that's what people look for unfortunately

[@jameskampro929]

That's how the Donkey act! I remember when I was on high school at the muslim city, one of my friends act like that. He is actually a minority too, he forgets to be him self and tried to reject his identity, mocking me and my friends like he did a cool thing. In front of our muslim friends he said want to convert to be a muslim. When we asking him to hangout together he refused. I know being jews is not easy especially when you are young and need friends! That's how the donkey act like I said before!

[@akivaragen]

The guy with the flag is obsessed with Rudy's masculinity. Basically, he is projecting his self hate against his own masculinity against Israel or something like that.

[@alig064]

Very large portion of the “pro palestinian” crowd don’t give a damn about either Israelis or Palestinians. We have to live here together while they use the conflict to follow their own goal of either inciting violence internationally or by not understanding enough. Real civilians want to live in peace , prosper and make the world better for ours and future generations. As an Israeli trying to help mitigate the madness which is currently ongoing the most understanding responses are actually from Palestinians , Iranians and Arabs from different countries while the people from western cultures blindly supporting hate, terror and genocide from the safety of their countries are usually much harder to have a conversation with.

[@williamkeane9088]

Poor kids are clueless. Props to the student that listened to Rudy. Keep doing your thing Rudy. Love his mindset

[@leszas872]

"I want you to explain your views." Rudy: (explains how Jews are indigenous to the land) "This isn't worth my time." Okay, then.

[@lmeadows8276]

This American Christian supports Israel 🇮🇱 & Rudy. God bless you , Rudy. Its amazing how you can deal with such ignorance & arrogance with love & kindness. 💛

[@Cleetus-VR]

It’s sad this kid is so brainwashed and can’t even recognize when someone is trying to show him respect and kindness and give him truth. It’s truly 💔

[@chandar1244]

Him: rudy, now you're making generalizations Ironic much huh

[@maidahari]

he doesn’t want to debate with you, because he knows he’s wrong 😭😭😭😭

[@moishefilip1005]

These people are acting so childish, Rudy you are a legend.

[@DanielA-jp1hu]

They cannot complete a sentence without giggling like little school girls.

[@JesseSmtns]

I’m trying to remember what it was like to be a 20 year old who thinks they know everything but this kid is making it REALLY HARD with his absolute lack of any desire to have a conversation of any kind.

[@Julia36D]

This generation is different. All kids this age think they know more than they do, but we’ve never had a generation like Gen Z who are arrogant while being dismissive, speak in internet slang and jargon instead of constructing full sentences with complete thoughts, but mainly being immature know-it-all’s.

[@lad7436]

This guy is the perfect example of the "Good Jew".

[@larakorik5016]

The amounts of patience you have Rudy is unspeakable and admirable. Wow. 😳👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@barbara-1]

Thanks for your great work, Rudy. Love and big hug from Ireland.

[@northernlight1000]

Unbelievable patience!

[@brianschneide0]

this guy is so smug and petty in confrontation. It's kind of sad to see American education in this state.

[@yehldyehld]

People like that flag guy are too easily emotionally triggered to engage in any genuine conversation. Why is he trembling with rage just seeing you? I notice he can't seem to look at you when speaking. He also constantly deflects then throws insults and sarcastic comments.

[@katej392]

Wow... he's so calm and collected like hats off to this guy. He really gives them the benefit of the doubt, even though they dont deserve it.