Prophet Moses and The Wise Guy

[@pranishsangraula4703]

Muslims who says these videos strengthen their faith, they should fund these creators and share these videos to their friends and families so that their faith can be stronger as well.

[@pikapi6993]

I love this idea :) we should apply to Qatar or Saudi Arabia for funding

[@Mujisu5102]

Yea, that would be so good, muhahahahaha😈

[@thecritiquer9407]

for not all muslims it may strengthen

[@arafatmarius331]

Some of us can refute those and that's why I watch guys like AP and AA...AP kinda got boring couse his content is 100% anti Islam he don't even do research or stuff he just stay ten minutes repeating "Islam Bad" "World better without Islam".And I like a bit more AA he is respectful and cool and I like to refute points.

[@Niggexp38]

@@arafatmarius331 Islam has been debunked and exposed countless times, you coping and acting like everyone who speaks against the faith knows nothing about the faith is goofy ahh

[@akhterhassan6670]

The Imam of our mosque once brought up this story during a sermon. When he came to the part of Khidr murdering the child his voice and body language changed for a split second. He lowered his voice and slightly turned away from the microphone for like a 10th of a second. His body folded in on itself and you can tell he was really uncomfortable. Even more funny, he referred to the boy as a "young man" and not a child. This moment is forever ingrained in my mind because of how revealing it is.

[@ApostateAladdin]

I thought I was the only one to pick up on such subtleties, but thankfully I'm not

[@rizwanasabreenahoss]

I came here from skeptic youtuber and the whole alzazeera show too. It takes a lot of courage to deconstruct! Take love Aladdin

[@ApostateAladdin]

Thank you so much. Welcome :)

[@aminububa851]

There is an even better channel Darkmatter2525.

[@HassanRadwan133]

Brilliant video!! The story of Khidr & the child, is quite simply a terrible, terrible story!! Apart from its bloodthirsty nature it exposes the complete incoherence of freewill. Plus the message of “Don’t question things that seem bad,” is arguably one of the most dangerous aspects of religion and has led to terrible crimes committed in the name of God. It’s also easy to see how such a mentality could be used to justify honour killing. I realise the author wanted to convey the message: “Don’t judge a book by its cover,” but it’s done in such a crude and flawed manner. For a book whose main claim to fame is Divine eloquence, many ‘mere humans’ have expressed this message far more eloquently - and without innocent kids being murdered.

[@SyrianApostate]

Very well put

[@Roxan926]

What would you say to someone who says the story was a vision or a dream?

[@locococo7362]

@@Roxan926 The way the story is told suggest it's more a fable than something that truely happened (list most of the stories in the abrahamic religion, but there are still people to take them litterally. anyways.) But the main problem of this fable is that it has a terrible morality. Doesn't matter if it's a vision, or a dream. The morality is terrible.

[@generalali7609]

I didn’t know you had a KZbin channel until a few days ago. I binged watched almost every video you put out. I definitely like your and Aladdin’s approach to such a difficult topic. I really appreciate the insight your videos provide.

[@polokucoch8112]

@@locococo7362 islam and mahamed (POLICE BE UPON HIM) are morally corrupt.

[@MalekMagicianPR]

This is a very detailed and insightful video full of critical thinking, which is important for every religion.

[@authenticallysuperficial9874]

Thanks for making great content, showing sources on screen, and keeping a kind tone while sharing the truth.

[@SaiyaraLBS]

Thanks for supporting AA monetarily and with encouraging words. Supporting him means supporting all ex muslims ❤

[@ApostateAladdin]

Thank you so much :) i appreciate it

[@zahraexshiatruthseeker1]

Exquisite and Perfect! You are a genius! Thanks so much for this hard work in helping Muslims leave Islam and think for themselves!

[@imdadood5705]

Alhamdullillah. After watching this video, my confirmation bias and cognitive dissonance got stronger.

[@arusirham3761]

Alhamdulillah indeed brother

[@xxursolovelyxxX]

Is this a joke lol

[@frog_230_lover7]

​@@xxursolovelyxxXYeah, isn't it obvious?

[@xxursolovelyxxX]

@@frog_230_lover7 lol I'm sorry I could not tell

[@Mortelle.0]

Alhamdulillah brother, let your confirmation bias get stronger!

[@Den-jp4yu]

I remember being so impressed by the story when I was 10 years old... that certainly changed after I grew up and, you know, developed critical thinking.

[@brotherben4357]

Fantastic work, Apostate Aladdin and Jasmine! Your hard work really shows in the quality.

[@Lina_92_]

The idea that all of this was written to happen before creation is laughable. Every now and then my disbelief gets shaken, but then i see a video like this and i realise disbelief is the right path. Thanks Aladdin

[@greyngreyer5]

I just hope you're in a safe environment

[@arusirham3761]

Be firm on your disbelief ya ukhti

[@j.mtherandomguy8701]

You should also try to think of the Abrahamic narrative of creation as a whole to better increase your disbelief, it is one of the most illogical, contradictory and stupid narratives to ever exist.

[@thenun1846]

Dude this is some top quality stuff! Please make more videos like this! It's a great supplement to your live streams

[@Killa_3]

I love the animated videos, theres something about the way its drawn, dry humour , and little things to spot that you might not see on first viewing, fun and learning yay lol , that aside the topic is one im shocked about, honestly the amount of conversations ive had with dawah gangs , and how they love to talk about everything but the stories found in the Quran, and now i see why , keep up the good work bro, cant wait for the next one

[@renticat]

This is one of my very earliest question when i brought up as a moslem because ofc my parents are moslem and my dad is religious man who loves to justify abuse to kids like it's okay to mocking and hitting kids because they're the parents and always knows better. I always have this question in mind while crying but never dare to ask cause i know i will get beaten i can read qur'an when i was just 4 and pray 5 times read the translation even though i am not arabic but from islam majority country because i kid you not people who hold religion tightly to their heart esp islam can just justify horrible things because the ideology itself is just so abusive to women and man couldn't see it ofc they're in the privileged position. I love dancing, traditional dancing and even though i was just 4 i can't do it like it's haram and attract attention like no wonder even prophet marry 5 yo my life was so messed up like who in the right mind kid just want to die if they don't have abusive parents i mean some kids are submissive and i am i tried to be good girl and religious but i somewhat also have this critical thinking that's they hate esp i am just a girl and consider as stupid and cry baby. I lost all my dreams. Heck even my father beating me up for just using sleeveless cloth inside home said it's kafir clothing like don't be a slut it's his true words when i was kindergarten. I still hate my life. Physical scars is fading away but not emotional ones and they're sometimes wondering why i have low self esteem like parents can be so stupid they certainly don't know nothing better .. But it's too late my brain is already fucker up. I was crying for crayons and drawing is haram who do you think you are talking back it filled with grotesque memories. If anything maybe this kid who've been killed is living better life though as they think innocent kids will go to the heaven i was so indoctrinated like that that's why i wish i just die like i believe but also question at the same time because it's what they shoved to my brain mostly. Well beating children is not abusive here culturally and it's not frown upon in religion even though my father is the one who has anger issues but he's already degrading me as human since i was just kid i know this hatred because he wanted a son as woman is liability. Fuck this religion i hate it it cause harm but people still defend it.. Like it's your father not anyone yeah you don't know you're unlucky if you get parents who practice it to the core. Everything i do is never good enough even some parents from my friend wished that theybhave children like me because i was smart and behaved mature, not crying not clingy like well enough ofc cause i can't even ve kids on my home like somewhat i am the mature one and my dad keeps yelling for his incompetence in life. I guess he actually don't want any kids but his religion forces him too and the cost is my life. I don't even wanna be here. And he didn't want me either. They believe that the prayer of the parents to the kids can be easily granted from god then why thefuck they talk to me like that, they just wish me suffer i wish i could end this but i was never succeed and just too coward. It's all because i always have question on mind and they don't try to listen and just see that as disobedience. Religion kills critical thought. Believe believe believe i know better you're nothing and needs to saved you're filthy.

[@juliusbattens2563]

Do not give up questions do not give up hope. Islam truly sucks No doubt.But we must examine the phenomenon of religions and their belief systems,history and cultural impact and ask the questions 1. Why do they exist 2 . What influence has religion on the personal and public domains. 3. What is God ? Why do we need God ? Or. Do we really need a God? Is there a true religion and a true God? If so what should I do? Keep studying. Examine all. Hold fast to what's good. Let Truth set you free.

[@hmao4466]

Get an education if you can. May God bless you in the future.

[@HassanRadwan133]

*hugs*

[@joyoyoy]

hey, Tifa! you and me both are in such similar situations, so if u ever feel like venting about everyday bothers, you got me! just letting you know you’re never alone :D💗

[@Vhlathanosh]

@@juliusbattens2563 "1. Why do they exist" Because they wanted answers to life's basic questions and they used the knowledge of their time? "2 . What influence has religion on the personal and public domains." Depends. For Muslim women, it's a different story. "What is God ?" Made up stories. "Why do we need God ?" Do we now? "Or. Do we really need a God?" No, we don't. "Is there a true religion and a true God?" If there is a god, he would know and he would communicate that clearly instead of depending on falliable humans. "If so what should I do?" I don't know, do good and let the rest take care of itself?

[@Taha632RMF]

Despite all the plot holes, inconsistencies, and bad choice of words, this is still one of the better quranic stories in terms of order as it doesn't jump into different topics midway through the story. Which only says a lot about this "linguistic miracle" lol

[@zambisabianus8245]

Because the words were rhyming together,the reason they maintained the mythical story to the end ...the goal is to put words to create poetic rhyme,,,the entire book is mythical stories

[@Taha632RMF]

@@zambisabianus8245 To be fair the entirety of quran rhymes, even for stories with incosistent ordering

[@zambisabianus8245]

@@Taha632RMF yes, it's poetry, even preislamic poetry is same,they were sung just like the Qur'an is read today ,, the only thing is that it's a stupid book,,when you read the translation of the rhymes, you will see they don't make sense,,, to make it rhyme they can just put at the end of the statement like"allah is the most gracious,the most merciful" even when you don't see that correlation

[@Taha632RMF]

@@zambisabianus8245 The lazy description enders are mostly used for medinan surahs, and al-kahf is a meccan one that uses different words to rhyme. But for the most part, you're right.

[@givemeyourpath]

Wdym by jumping into different topics midway? The book isn't linear? I haven't read it so I don't know much about it

[@grnzrn]

Allah be like: "I know, I know, this was supposed to be a really clear guidance, very coherent and whatnot, which is kinda important because misinterpreting it could end y'all in hell. And the morals were supposed to be really good, too. Well, it didn't quite turn out this way... But look at those *RHYMES* bro!"

[@ReasononFaith]

An excellent video. These are the foundational, evergreen videos which people will continue to reference for years, helping bring forth with clarity, just how garbled the Qur'anic message is. The narrative with many holes, the moral failings, it's all here, and you've explained it beautifully. For most of my life, I didn't realize most Muslims read this as it is plainly written. In the Ahmadiyya sect I grew up, they spend a dozen pages of tafsir to try to convince the reader that this was a spiritual _isra_ of Moses, and that it didn't physically take place, in order to escape the very damning moral implications of reading it as it is written.

[@hmao4466]

Love your work. Thank you.

[@huios974]

Mr Muhammad was an amazing story teller with a pinch or a lump of stupidity. And thanks to you for wisdom to that story.

[@greyngreyer5]

The leader isn't stupid. The people are. Islam is all about exploiting either ignorance or stupidity

[@stephanielasnoski606]

Your humor is my absolute favorite humor! You are an absolute true comedian! The kind of comedians that have always been needed during history! The genius is to get people to accept hard truths while laughing as laughing is a natural trigger to make us feel that we can accept it! I saw you on colts to consciousness and watched all the videos you guys did together! Those were my favorite episodes ever and that is saying a lot because every episode is absolutely amazing! Her guests are highly intellectual and grounded individuals! That being said please keep up this channel and especially these cartoons as I believe they are absolutely needed! Maybe do it in a way that depressed people from all religions?

[@racheljohara91]

I just became aware of this story recently. When I brought up the kid who was killed, a friend told me that the moral of the story is to not make snap judgements against people because you don't have all the information. First of all.....no. You have enough info seeing a kid being killed. Second, didn't the wise man do exactly that? He made a judgement on this kid and how he will be the rest of his life, and then carried out the most extreme punishment giving him no chance for redemption.

[@Quirkydope]

Were you a convert ?

[@bhavikjain280]

One of the best videos I watched. Great storytelling, great animation, great logic, I need more of these videos please.

[@Pancakegr8]

It’s too bad Muslims will not engage with this argument in good faith.

[@nazone7527]

Great video as always, well worth the wait.

[@SpaghettiBolognese99]

I love these animated series… absolutely fantastic

[@juliusbattens2563]

Great commentary! 👍 Keep it up.waiting for more.

[@MarshallMathers-m7e]

And the worst part is, chapter 18 is one of the best chapters in the Quran! It was the only chapter I was able to read in English without getting bored. As horribly written as the stories in it are, at least they stay on a single topic and make vague amounts of sense. The rest of the Quran doesn't even have that much.

[@HassanRadwan133]

And it is one of the most pleasant sounding Surahs. I used to love reciting it. I often recited the last two verses in prayers - they are quite beautiful in sound and meaning.

[@momo19991]

There is too much emphasis on the sound of the Arabic Quran in Islam and not enough on meaning.

[@HassanRadwan133]

​​@@momo19991 that's true, at least amongst ordinary Muslims

[@greylonewolf8750]

Aladdin,you are at your best,when you deconstruct. I truly appreciate your skills and your results in the videos.❤ Stay awesome like this,bro.

[@braveheart8515]

Yup tides are turning, internet is making it happen. Anywhere there is internet connection, there are apostates!

[@minhazhimu136]

It only made my faith stronger (in Islam being false)

[@raihanmuri5407]

Nice one brother🤣🤣🤣

[@raihanmuri5407]

At first i was like "here we go again"🤣🤣

[@munashemanamike4217]

​@@raihanmuri5407I feel you bro cause arguing with some of them is tiring

[@ChickenArad1]

@@munashemanamike4217 Don't call me bro. People laugh at you.

[@ChickenArad1]

@@raihanmuri5407 I am not your brother. People laugh at you. 😂

[@mernelbeqaraj2365]

Great Content as always. Respect from Albania

[@kald360]

14:00 There are plenty occurrences in the Quran that indicate the writer views Allah as a glorified human being. Such verses project Allah having feelings (love, hate, fear, anger) and committing emotion-driven acts (revenge, deception, mockery). Examples being: Surah 8 Ayah 30 (والله خير الماكرين) "And Allah is the best of the cunnings" Surah 9 Ayah 46 (ولكن كره الله انبعاثهم) "But Allah (hated/disliked) that they should go" Surah 4 Ayah 142 (يخادعون الله وهو خادعهم) "They deceive Allah but he is deceiving them" Surah 2 Ayah 15 (الله يستهزئ بهم) "Allah is mocking them" Surah 11 Ayah 34 (إن كان الله يريد أن يغويكم) "If Allah wants to lead you astray" Let alone the dozens ayahs where Quran uses vulgar language when addressing both believers and disbelievers. A language that would be viewed as shameful coming off a human king, much less the king of kings! These verses and many others were the reasons some scholars thought the Quran is not the exact words of Allah but instead, is the prophets attempt to articulate the revelations into a spoken language.

[@able763]

Allah Says the Smartest Things: 1. “The sun sets in a muddy spring” (Surah 18:86) 2. “He followed a way until he reached the rising place of the sun” (Surah 18-89) 3. “Allah holds the sky so as it cannot fall on the Earth” (Surah 22:65) 4. “And after that, He spread the Earth” (Surah 79:30) 5. “He (Allah) made for you the Earth like a carpet spread out” (Surah 20:53) 6. “Semen is made between the backbone and the ribs” (Surah 86:5-7) 7. “Cow’s milk is made between the dung and the blood” (Surah 16:66) 8. “The sun runs on unto a resting place for him” (Surah 36:38) 9. “We made the sperm-drop into a clinging clot, and We made the clot into a lump, and We made the lump bones, and We covered the bones with flesh. (Surah 23:13-14) 10. “We have adorned the lowest heaven with lamps and made them [missiles] for stoning devils for whom We have also prepared the torment of a blazing fire.” (Surah 67:5) 11. Fun bonus: “O you who believe, do not enter the houses of the Prophet, unless you are permitted for a meal, not (so early as) to wait for its preparation. But when you are invited, go inside. Then, once you have had the meal, just disperse, and (do) not (sit for long) being keen for a chat. This (conduct of yours) hurts the Prophet, but he feels shy of (telling) you (about it), but Allah is not shy of the truth.” (Surah 33:53) Remember, Allah is claimed to be the “all-knowing” “all-powerful” “creator of the universe” and he is quoted verbatim, word-for-word, in Allah’s “clear book” the eternal, uncreated Quran which has existed in Heaven before the beginning of time and creation. But as you can see, all-knowing Allah says things no different from a 7th century Bedouin. As the all-knowing creator of the universe, you would expect Allah to state scientific truths (in perfect, indisputable detail, requiring no jihadi-bearded dawah boys to help interpret) like the Theory of Relativity, the Double Helix Structure of DNA, Quantum Mechanics, Particle Physics, etc. But no. It's simple to prove Allah does not exist. We just need to prove Allah’s CLAIMS don’t exist. As the Quran is the “kalamullah” i.e. all-knowing Allah's verbatim word, the Quran must be 100% accurate. But it is not. The Quran makes many ignorant 7th-century statements. And since Allah’s claims don’t exist, Allah doesn’t exist. Stay away from Islam. Nothing good comes out of Islam.

[@MD10559]

As a matter Of fact no good comes out of any religion...

[@able763]

@@MD10559 Yes, but only Islam is going to tralala your head off if you disagree

[@MD10559]

@@able763 yes pretty much the case

[@Ibn_battouta]

Just because prophets and religions are lies does not mean that God does not exist. Perhaps God created us and did not send messengers or religions. Remember, we have not discovered a universe, and there is not a single piece of evidence that definitively denies the existence of a God or Creator. It has been proven that the God of all religions is wrong, yes. But I am talking about the real God. No one can confirm the existence of a God or deny it.

[@able763]

@@Ibn_battouta Ah, the "pure" God. Sure, not proven to not exist. But also completely unnecessary and incomprehensible to us. In fact, so incomprehensible that we can't even begin to talk about such a thing. So don't bother.

[@jkmutaike]

I respect your DEEP insights - you leave nothing unturned!!

[@AbdurRahman-cf8xd]

Wonderful Video!

[@polokucoch8112]

The number of stories that the quran copied from the Holy Bible or elsewhere is just stunning.

[@frog_230_lover7]

And the number of stories that the Bible copied from the Torah and other religious books is also insane, thos3 all are man-made religions with manmade books that have manmade/stolen stories

[@divvvyyyaaa2843]

Amazing video...keep going 🙏

[@nolife8209]

I remember dad was telling me this story one day. It made my skin crawl. How could he justify killing A CHILD? It was Allah's will? What if it was not? Well, not possible cuz Allah is the one true god, right? I really wanted to ask all these. Why is he not doing to same with other kafir kids? They could all go to heaven, right? Well, apparently, Allah is giving them a chance, but then some people who die as a kafir anyways? And this reasoning could be used by ANYONE to justify killing kids. They are following the prophet, so they are not "sinning". This whole story is just mindboggling, and I wish there were people who i could discuss these stuffs with, which i unfortunately can't. This is all just too frustrating.

[@huios974]

Interesting story which we never would know till you spilled the beans. My conclusion: 1. Mr Muhammad is sending signals to the Muslim not to questions things that he did even though it may be bad. 2. Islam is a religion that creates a grey area for bad deeds. It gives Muslims a justification for their bad deeds. Because the king would confiscate the boats, that unwise man had to damage it with holes. Because the boy would turned out to be bad, the unwise man had to behead him. Looks like Allah forgot to behead many evil people today when they were still a child.

[@locococo7362]

" Mr Muhammad is sending signals to the Muslim not to questions things that he did even though it may be bad." My thought exacly. Moreover, it reminds me of the stories we still hear nowadays about honor killing.

[@HamzaDesigns1]

love your videos aladdin

[@adama4656]

Finally someone exposes this ! Love you aladdin❤

[@AJ-et3vf]

Awesome video! Thank you for doing this! Very informative

[@Ugg_Son_Of_Thogg]

I need to sleep, but I MUST watch this masterpiece.

[@marc3dartist601]

Of course it never happened. Like most stupid stories in the Quran: Jews morphed to monkeys, yellow cows to resurrect a dead guy, army of birds, talking ants...

[@abdulrahmanalhamali1707]

excellent video bro

[@joerdim]

Schrödinger's fish 😅

[@katarinatibai8396]

😂😂😂❤love it😊

[@able763]

Fun fact: When you see the sun in the sky, take note that it is in a muddy spring for the time zones before you and under Allah's bum in other time zones. True story.

[@momo19991]

Brilliant commentary! Islam means submission not peace. The key is to ask questions as you help us do.

[@lesinema1893]

Great video, take care ❤️

[@generalali7609]

How to get away with murder is the perfect title. This is the exact story sheikhs use to do just that. This story keeps every follower’s mouth shut. I can’t tell you how many times people have brought this story up to shut me up😂. But I reverse it on them. I say that the story shows exactly why we don’t follow sheikh khider and why all the laws that came were given to prophet musa. I tell them prophet musa was mentioned over 100x in the Quran so that probably who we should follow 😂😂😂. Not the guy killings kids😂

[@kkk-xx]

Didn't mohammad kill,rape,loot, Is that the person you follow

[@ahadianto9632]

Apostate Aladdin, I really like your channel. As an apostate myself (I deconverted from Christianity a few years ago), I am amazed how the religions and the deities we both left behind are so similar in their violence. Keep up the good work. I hope someday you will be free enough to show your face as freely as I am as a Christian apostate. The time will come when there will be less ignorance in your part of the world too. It takes more people like you to turn the tide. I am rooting for you!

[@kajtek1953]

I love the way you strip the nonsense away with pure rationality- keep going😊

[@Aquastan-de2iq]

wow man !!! @0:31 TO @1:00 - I LOVE YOUR CAT !!!!! He's so Chill😻😻😻😻 I'd bet He would have made a Better Prophet .....

[@ryandruff5066]

What's interesting about this story is this is literally just a retelling of the story of the rabbi Joshua Ben Levi and Elijah but they replaced Joshua with Moses and Elijah with Khidr. Like it's almost exactly the same of course with some additions. Of course, the story of Joshua Ben Levi is completely legendary but it's fascinating how so many narratives within the Quran and also hadith literature is almost identical to Jewish Midrashic stories. Of course, they are all somewhat different and I think this speaks volumes about the memory, origins, and rhetorical goals of either Muhammad or early Muslims relating these stories

[@oishikhasan8500]

Does Elijah in that story murder a child like Khidr did?

[@ryandruff5066]

@@oishikhasan8500 Not to my knowledge but the lesson of the story, mentioned first in the quranic version with bird dipping its beak into the ocean is the same, basically saying "gods ways are not ours therefore just believe", but the story about traveling to a man's house while he is eating and being turned away is literally the same in both narratives. The story about child killing though... i have no idea, it might have been an original retelling or maybe there was a version of the Midrashic story that had that element in the arabia. But if you want to see the parallels yourself you can google the story of Joshua Ben Levi and Elijah and look at the commonalities for yourself

[@oishikhasan8500]

@@ryandruff5066 Maybe the story of the slain boy was woven into the original narrative by the Arabs of the time to make the "do not try to understand God's methods" point in a more intense manner. Or it could have been imported in from some Persian narrative through Arab retelling. The Persian influence on the formation of Islam is not trivial. All those cultures were mixing with each other for centuries. There are so many possibilities. Very difficult if not impossible to pinpoint where it all came from given how long it was ago and all the transmissions were oral.

[@oishikhasan8500]

@Tubba That is another possibility. We could speculate all day on the origin of the story, makes for an interesting conversation. More interesting if one is an academic doing research into this topic. But at the end of the day I find the Khidr story to be a grim reminder of how barbarism can masquerade as wisdom. Stories like these hinder our moral development, traps us in the prison of dogma.

[@amaarquadri]

At 31:12, I think the guy in the quote is trying to say that the whole story is a metaphor for killing your unlawful desires (aka the kid in the metaphor). Still, I think it's a very weird interpretation.

[@AJansenNL]

It's desperate apologetics, that's what it is. The guy know it's wrong and immoral, but can't admit that.

[@saimraja2119]

@Ammad Quadri Lol you're a Christian troll, hiding behind a fake account. Since you are upset that Christians are leaving Christianity.

[@rebaz7256]

Hi Aladin. I am a huge fan of your channel

[@polokucoch8112]

islam has nothing to stand on after Apostate Aladdin is done talking. Without LIES, islam DIES.

[@locococo7362]

I'm glad someone finally speak about that story. I think this is the part that shocked me the most when I read the Quran. Not only because of the murder of the child, but because of the "morality" that story is supposed to teach to the reader. It's just horrible. Especially from a book supposed to come from god.

[@OnlyJesus-Saves]

Written by God 😂 Allah himself wrote and sent it down with his angel Gabriel, it's really funny.

[@locococo7362]

@@OnlyJesus-Saves Funny details. Seems like people like Mosis had no problemt to talk with God directly. By Mohammed could only speak to an Angel. And go this revelation through ceizures. God works in mysterious ways... If god can speak to prophets, why did simply speak to a scribe prophets to write the Quran ? This makes no sense.

[@Aksarallah]

Who said it's a child? Most muslims agree that it was a young man and not a prepubescent child.

[@Aksarallah]

@@locococo7362 god has 3 methods of sending messages to man. Voice behind a veil, through messenger, or through angel. Each method fit for time and place and allah knows best

[@locococo7362]

@@Aksarallah "Who said it's a child? Most muslims agree that it was a young man and not a prepubescent child." Ouf, ok then. It was only a young man. Everything is fine then. "god has 3 methods of sending messages to man. Voice behind a veil, through messenger, or through angel". Each methods having flaws and making his religion indistinguishable from sects. Well, if at least everyone could see angels... Funny thing is, to delivery his final message, he still choose one of the worse way to do it. "allah knows best" I always hated this kind of sentence. It basically means to blindly trust something or someone even when nothing make sense. Why on earth anyone would like to do that.

[@imnotawake99]

You are so intelligent i love the way you speak, you are teaching me so much. Im so happy ive found you.

[@zambisabianus8245]

This is a mythical story that existed over centuries,I was shocked when I first saw the story ,but how Islam managed to link it to some Musa guy ,I wonder

[@Vhlathanosh]

What's more baffling is the beheading in the story that's glossed over like some horrific act didn't just happen within the chapters.

[@joshuadelacruz6617]

This is a great video. You're very thoughtful and seemingly honest. I'm impressed by you not being a native English speaker---probably another sign of your intelligence. This format of video is right up my alley. Thanks for sharing your point of view, despite how volatile the landscape can be. Please keep it up, I really enjoy your content.

[@Handycan-x8m]

Good to see you Back I hope you are doing well 😊

[@mamdhata1614]

You sink the boat - fisherman lose their means of their livelihood permanently. King confiscates their boat - they lose their livelihood with the hope of them receiving back boat in near future. I do not know which was a worse option. Did the little Green Man remedy the situation?

[@grnzrn]

Could also have helped hide the boat somewhere.

[@able763]

This is a masterpiece. Not a well-known plot hole in the Quran. Thanks.

[@drziggyabdelmalak1439]

Pause and watch something else! Brilliant, Aladdin!

[@srfrg9707]

Al Kihdr did not foresaw the future of the child because his real future was to be murdered by a false prophet. He never grew up. He never was a burden to his parents. He never was an apostate. So Al Khidr is not only a child molester, a murderer but also a liar and a fool. The kid died innocent. lsIam presents al Kidhr as a wise Muslim. A wise man who's worried by the future of a kid will teach him from his wisdom. This chapter in the Quran achieves 3 things : 1) It traumatizes the young Muslims because they are told that a random dude could kiII them for a thought crime they didn't even commit. 2) It defines innocence and guild not on reality and one's behavior but on imaginary crimes that exist only in the head of those who pretend that Allah talks to them in their crazy mind. 3) It ruins rational thinking by inverting causes and effects. The cause precedes the effect. The cause of an action can't be some potential event in the future and even less if the action prevents that cause to exist. lsIam makes people stupid.

[@ahmedazmy2014]

Beautifully stated 👍 This should simply kill Islam in minutes for anyone who can think for themselves!

[@wastingtimejustwaiting]

I just secured an infinite amount of nitro in heaven, Alfuckduillah

[@phun1901]

I expected you to frame the point about predestination as: why are the trials of life called a "test" if Allah already knows your test results?

[@laplacesdemon43]

Statement 1: "You exist only because of Allah and That's why any atrocities demanded from you justified" Statement 2: "Allah doesn't get tired, he didn't even break a sweat creating the universe." We become grateful to someone for the favors that sacrifices their own comforts. Nobody clap to billionaires who donated 1 dollar in their whole life. Why should I be grateful to Allah for the actions that cost him nothing. Any Tibetan Monk has more control over their anger than allah.

[@fromkentobaka]

even if that wasnt a kid and a young man that still doesnt justify killing a rando he found on the streets 😭

[@anthonypc1]

You're the most tactful critic I've seen on the internet. Of any topic. If most activists for various causes could present the facts and their views with some amount of this emotional intelligence, I imagine a lot more people could be persuaded and societies could progress more efficiently, and peacefully.

[@Thinkerts]

Great video

[@diabloakland]

I always thought the story of khidr was so weird

[@jakesmith3920]

Lol when I was told this story apparently the lesson was always obey those with higher authority

[@chr_my]

No wonder your channel is blocked in Pakistan and Malaysia. Cool video, thanks Aladdin, please stay safe man.

[@able763]

Always download these videos as dawah will try to fake copyright strike and fake hate speech report it.

[@s.m.morshidularfin4549]

Very insightful

[@KKaz-ho9wz]

HOLD UP... So the wise guy says the kid was gonna grow up to be a disbeliever and cause xyz to his parents... So he killed him and "saved his soul", so to speak... That means according to the "Lawh al mahfouz" (basically book of destiny that is destined to happen, written by Allah before all of creation), the kid was actually destined to have his noggin plucked off by Mr. Wise Guy; not to be a disbeliever. Which is true? Was the written destiny false? Was the wise guy lying? Is the whole story false? Or get this... Does Islam admit to alternate realities/universes??? *Cue Dr. Strange theme*.

[@Noblebird02]

I am actually writing a time travel novel where each act of time travel creates a new timeline, and one character is a sunni Muslim. That's why I am watching Aladdin's channel.

[@iddrissmohammed980]

Great vidéo keep it UP 👍

[@DISCO-munication]

Your wax flower has grown so much, I really like it ^^ But if its leaves are turning yellow this usually means calcium deficiency (or the calcium in the soil can't be absorbed because it's too hot) :/

[@ahmedasem4906]

Hi Alaadin. I frequently hear that "God's knowledge is descriptive, not prescriptive" so when Allah wrote everything, it was like a prediction that can't be false. From watching your video, I assume the hadith that confirmed the child waa destined to be a kafir is the counter-argument as it shows Allah actively chose that the child would be a kafir. How would you respond to the claim that God's knowledge is descriptive, rather than prescriptice. And keep up the amazing work!

[@shassarahaman5247]

It's a stupid claim. It's just word play. A prediction that can't be false is by definition not a prediction but predestination. They play with words to confuse gullible people.

[@greyngreyer5]

It simply doesn't work. Look: "Everything happens by Allah's will" is mildly ambiguous, sure. I think it's clear enough but let's humor the stance for the sake of the argument. So, let us say we don't know what this means exactly. Does it mean that Allah may stop an action from occuring or allow it? Or does it mean he literally makes it happen? Do you see that the two statements are nigh-identical? Still, let's say it's ambiguous once again. Look at this hadith: "Allah struck Adam's left shoulder and black souls sprouted from it. Then Allah said: 'To hell, and I don't care.' Then Allah struck his right shoulder and white souls sprouted from it and Allah said: 'To heaven, and I don't care.'" That's pretty unambiguously stating that Allah was 1. The cause of this and 2. The one who "approved it" Next, Aisha observes a funeral of children and remarks how she is at ease knowing the children will go to heaven. Mohammed says "You don't know if they will go to heaven because Allah may have ordained them to hell when they were still in their father's loins." There is no free will. It's just there to get you to follow the bs.

[@leostarings2535]

By green man's extreme wisdom we can ki.ll a child whenever we dislike one 😂😂

[@lalaland3208]

Please make animation like this about Abu Thalib, Mo's uncle, the one who mostly understand Mo😊

[@iamsheel]

‏‪2:20‬‏ it wasn't miraculous. Fishermen in the past used to put the basket in the water so the fish would stay alive and not spoil very quickly. At least that what they used to do in the Arabian gulf until the 50's.

[@mamdhata1614]

What fish preservation technique did he use? 2. No crows on his route.

[@hassanamirdeen6790]

An interesting question is, assuming Muhammad authored the Quran, was the story of Al-khidr invented to justify his own 'morally confusing' actions, such as killing the children of certain jewish tribes or marrying wives of his conquered enemies (hoping to find their tribes hidden treasure)? And at the risk of getting conspiratorial, it even makes me question whether these stories were 'fabricated' by muslim scholars, long after Muhammad's death in order to justify his historically questionable actions. Im pretty sure that kind of 'after the matter addition' to history is commonly accepted of the stories of Christians, Roman, Chinese etc... so its at least possible with islam. Just a thought...

[@andykrull9297]

Great insights.

[@amuaiz]

Think of how much time have been wasted by the scholars disagreeing with each other while trying to make sense of such silly story. How absurd would it be like if academics putting up convention to discuss humpty dumpty

[@blingcicero6570]

Holy crap! jews and Christians dont have this story. I thought you would told the story of the Egyptian soldier.

[@Noblebird02]

Someone up thread points out that there is a Jewish version of the story. Only the figures in the Jewish version aren't Moses and there is no child murder. So likely this is a case of small reference pools.

[@TheHeavyshadow]

I know with predetermination and the foreknowedgle that he is going to fail it's maybe missing the point, but: How long was Moses supposed to wait to learn the lessons being shown to him? Like ok, I get the fishing boat. Maybe while they are on their way back the tyrant king would have shown up, seen the damage, and said "Ok, you can have that." But how long would it have taken for the orphans to dig up the treasure? And how long would it have taken for the faithful parents to get another child and for that child to either grow up to be a faithful person too, or for that child to grow up, give birth to several prophets, and for those in return to father several prophets each?

[@AD-ot5ok]

Masterpiece with real arguments

[@massinissastoutah7621]

this is the story that made me start questioning Islam, and now it is still the strongest argument against Islam specially when paired with the "maw2ouda" argument, and beside it is a time parodox to lol

[@DonnaShosha]

Great video

[@jamesconnolly5164]

Dude, I was NOT expecting this story. I laughed my *ass* off out loud! This genuinely seems like a comedy skit mocking the cliche of the wise ancient sage. Something that the troupe WKUK might do.

[@MASTERROSHIdb]

you can have a specific topic that you discuss in each video too. Like you can take a statement in Quran or Hadiths and discuss what the caller thinks or what is the justification for it. I am a Muslim by the way, but I like your channel; however, I feel the callers get deviated a lot to talk about random things.

[@Vlogs_Dharma]

As Muslim i would like to know what is your personal opinion about this particular Topic of Innocent Child being Killed which Alladin has made ?

[@MASTERROSHIdb]

@@Vlogs_Dharma I didn't watch it. I don't follow all Hadiths. What is your personal opinion of Krishna raping gopis?

[@Vlogs_Dharma]

@@MASTERROSHIdb I was curious expecting Muslims might have some answers..But unfortunately Islam is Scam thanks for exposing it..and regarding Krishna's Raping Gopis as you accused...You have no Iota of knowledge about Krishna... Ideology which Justifies Sex Slavery cannot see any thing beyond such pervert Ideas like Rape and Murder ...BTW Demon named Narkasur had abducted Young Girls from their Parents and Krishna had rescued them from Narkasurs clutches so all of them prayed to Krishna to keep them as his wife because their Parents will reject them any ways .so out of his compassion Krishna married them and gave them 16108 Palaces and Krishna had expanded himself into 16108 Forms to make sure he is with each one of them for their desrious Relationship..unlike Lusty Ideology you follow there is vast difference between Pure Love and Lust ...

[@frog_230_lover7]

​@@MASTERROSHIdbbut you can't dismiss this hadith cuz it's literally just saying what the ayah says

[@MASTERROSHIdb]

@tubba-dg7to i read the story in Quran but not sure what it means. It sounds bad but we can't judge since Allah knows the best.

[@Lantronic]

It can't get any worse

[@lucy__fer]

He would be a good fictional character with a few changes

[@kayemni]

I absolutely love those stories, to bad there aren't more of them 😫😞😣

[@tamaratamtammorris8151]

What a doozy of a story! There are far better ways to instruct someone in humility than being an accessory to a crime. Musa and Al-Khidr kind of reminds me of the plot of a Turkish tale I read in a magazine when I was a kid. In the story, a sultan throws a grand banquet, but decides to do a test and dresses like a beggar. He is refused entrance to the banquet. Later on, he dresses in his nice clothes and goes to the banquet, where he proceeds to act like a total slob and by the end of the dinner, his clothes are as dirty as that of the beggar's. At the end of the banquet, he tells his bewildered advisors that it was him who was at the door, dressed as the beggar, and that they needed to be more mindful of who wanted to join the feast. Though it had a common moral of "don't judge something at first glance" and it's been many years since I read that story, the fact that deception and trickery are such strong elements of the story have always stayed with me.

[@noname19816]

8:22 "islam discovered quantum mechanics centruries before those kuffar, allhamdullah"