Recycled Reviews #10 - 15 Whiskies Reviewed

[@blissfulmistahd]

Now that the tenth recycled review is out there it needs to be said! Congrats on the 10th installment Roy! 150 bottles reviewed! Yes you're not churning out a video each week, but nobody minds! The originality, creativity and depth of your videos can only be a testament to the energy you put in this channel. Thoroughly enjoyed each one of them, and there's lot's a value in these sub 30 minutes videos. No chit-chatting, no 'shenanigans', just freakishly solid content! Plus the fact you even inspired other channels to copy this format says enough in itself! Keep doing what you're doing, you're great at it! Aqvavitae, the true pope of whisky evangelizing ;) Like, subscribe, support on patreon, all truly and well deserved!

[@Aqvavitae]

You’re asking for a pin aren’t you? You’re getting a pin! Seriously though, thank you.

[@blissfulmistahd]

​@@Aqvavitae not asking for anything! Very happy with my first ever pin though :p Thank you for your efforts! Slainte va!

[@thiscard]

very much agree! (heels please) as a busy dad appreciate the Roy-edited content.

[@agrainofmalt]

Hear, hear!

[@aleksanderk6765]

Hear hear! Cheers from Norway

[@wwrussell180]

Why the Hell would anyone give one of these videos a thumbs down? Roy is a classy gentleman and these videos are fun and informative. Thanks, Roy, for what you do!

[@uilleachan]

In my opinion, "recycled reviews" are one of my big youtube whisky highlights.

[@willbeverly7858]

I'm always excited to see recycled reviews pop up. A good mix of obtainable and lesser knowns like Ben Nevis, Alisa Bay and Vega. Fantastic as usual. Being in the States, Heels please wont help me much, but I did watch until the end. Favorite blooper, visitors stay away, hahaha, that's great stuff Roy!

[@themaltedmancave9499]

HP 18 out for the count:) So sad to see the direction Highland Park is heading. Amazing video as usual Roy!

[@arqueturus]

I have no idea how I've missed Aquavitae over the last few years but I'm really glad I've found it now! Love the format of these reviews in parrticular and the Spreadsheet ois pure genuis. I'll be watching the backlog of videos and aaaall the new content :D

[@erwinlarranaga8128]

Just picked up a bottle of Graigellachie 23. When it was Scotts #1 whiskey also I had to get a bottle. WOW what a dram!!! Here in CA it was just over $200 which is the top end of what I like to spend on whiskey. But I’m going to buy a backup bottle before its gone. Thank you for the review. Great stuff. Slainte.

[@richardagnew4959]

Roy, Rich here in Canada. I sooo enjoy these videos you do. Very helpful and just fun. Please do not stop doing the outtakes at the end. It adds so much. And I think it shows just how much work you put into these videos. 'Visitors? No, go away!' LOL!

[@justinmaizeblue]

Watching the old ones!

[@billyhughes9776]

For someone that sounded as disappointed as you did about that Highland Park 18yo bottle, the 7.5/10 seems like kind of a high mark. Always look forward to these vids!

[@thatguy244]

I got one of those Bunnahabhains when I visited the distillery! Good stuff and fun experience!

[@anguspaterson5713]

I agree with your point about Jura having gone a bit downhill, and fair enough talking about the Whyte and Mackay range. Just to stick up for Fettercairn though, I think they are becoming the pick of the bunch among those distilleries and are doing some really interesting stuff (see recently 16 and 22 year old releases). I'd be interested to see what your thoughts are on the new Fettercairn range Roy

[@gary7890123]

Best Recycled review yet :) Keep them coming. Heels Please

[@DonnerPassWhisky]

Just opened my bottle of Arran 18 (the older packaging). From the neck pour am so happy I have this! A big upgrade from the 14 which is no slouch. Have a 4oz sample bottle of the 14 that I plan to do a side by side tasting with after the 18 has had some time.

[@vetiwearerdaimyo1592]

9:12 Back in the days there were Irish ways And Irish laws, stand up for the 'cause When it's time to rock a funky joint I'm on point When it's time to rock a funky jam I'm the man

[@roboliver9980]

Glad you enjoyed Paul John I found it very enjoyable too.

[@StillIt]

Man I love these episodes!

[@christianeichhorn3328]

Great reviews,particularly interested in some of the indian whiskies,tried Rampur the other day and was very impressed,such a long finish..Enjoyed your video..HEELS PLEASE!

[@manuelnaranjo3255]

Great way to give a short look on many different whiskies. Always loved it. And if you cant get Ben Nevis, go for Nikka from the barrel... And as always: Heels please

[@alexk3088]

Thoroughly enjoying these. Roy, regarding the 44% Jura, do you think odd abv like that could ever be due to them deciding that they have a certain volume in a batch and at 46% it would be a few cases just shy of a full number of pallets (or perhaps bottles shy of a case) and so forth, so they do the math and dilute to get a full number of pallets? That's cynical, of course, but I've wondered if things can be explained like that? I've been staying away from Dalmore and Jura, perhaps instinctively. The geek in me wants to try every distillery, every island, every region, but the miser in me keeps me from being disappointed too much.

[@hybrid5774]

I need to try a Deanston already! Plus other amazing whiskies... thanks for the great video again. And... Heels Please!

[@rivenbeef]

I love these hidden gems that you keep pulling out for us. You have never steered us wrong and the spreadsheet is particularly useful and appreciated. I’m also a huge fan of the new Arran 18. Are there any other whiskies you could recommend in that style? Thanks for all your hard work Roy! It’s clearly a labor of love.

[@Aqvavitae]

Thank you Alex! Try to seek out a Tamdhu or two, and hopefully you’re acquainted with Glendronach!

[@Mose2305]

As always an excellent Recycled Review Roy, just if those pesky interruptions would keep at bay til you were done lol. Cheers!

[@SippersSocialClub]

Always enjoy these videos. Probably the best time to reflect on a bottle is when you finish it. Ill have to hunt down a few of these, cheers Roy!

[@erwinlarranaga8128]

Your recycle reviews are great. Thank you. I just pickup a bottle of Craigellachie 23. WOW very nice. Here in California it was $230. 46% ABV is okay, but it would be nice if it were a wee bit higher. Is there any other Edward & Mackie that you can recommend hopefully a bit more cost effective. Again thank you!!

[@onYTsince2008]

16:16! This was a perfect slam-n-dunk winge 🤣🤣👍

[@joshwalls7302]

Hope I’m not too late for the drawing! This is my first aqua vitae video ever. I enjoyed the video very much. Heels please. I have subscribed and look forward to more videos!

[@Ian-hu9he]

Roy - these are such fantastic reviews. Excellent format. That Ben Nevis 10 review is spot on. Thanks for doing these. Greetings from the smoldering dumpster fire that is America in 2020. Only thing keeping me sane is fine whisky and wonderful reviews like this. Cheers, my friend.

[@Aqvavitae]

You’re welcome my friend, thank you. If there’s a country that can extinguish a dumpster fire, it’s yours my friend. Good luck 🥃

[@WhiskyNeighbour]

I absolutely love your recycled reviews Roy. Thank you so much for your thoughtful conversation and taking us through the journey of these bottles. Cheers!

[@samuelausten]

Love this, further reviews of grain whiskeys and blends would be interesting ... heels please

[@russell3733]

Great bunch of whiskies, Roy. I was tickled pink to see that Ledaig 11yo in there and to hear your very appreciative comments about it. Not sure if there's any of it left on the market, but The Single Malts of Scotland released an updated Ledaig 13yo last year (Sherry Butt, 57.3%, 627 bottles), which I snapped up immediately and boy, was I glad I did. It's a belter. Dirty Ledaig at its best. Many thanks for this excellent review, Roy - and commiserations to your liver! Cheers.

[@cali_weejock]

Totally agree with your Highland Park remarks. No more for me either. Now exploring Deanstown, and Springbank 🤗

[@themaltedmancave9499]

Wise man:)

[@cali_weejock]

Still selling Springbank batch16 12yo (Blackbox) here in Germany. 65€ a pop. Do I clean them out and share with whisky drinking friends or let the unknown vultures snap them up without knowing the bottles potentials?

[@bennevis3449]

Love the recycled reviews. With that aim, you nae gonna make the Scottish cricket team. Sainte, from a very hot and fiery down under. Heels please!

[@robklompstra2976]

This is what I come here for 👍🏻. Hands down my favourite videos to watch. I feel it’s all I need to know about a bottle in a short period of time. Thanks Roy!

[@agrainofmalt]

Followed your advice and opinion on many fabulous bottles over the past 18 months and never been steered wrong! Fantastic as always, cheers Roy :) Heels please!

[@kristiandugstad4906]

Thank you, Roy. You're providing the best whisky content on the internet!

[@billysaunders109]

Ahhhh I’m late to the party this week. Really enjoy the RR’s a different and unique way of giving a whistle stop tour of your opinions and general overview of Malts you’ve drank. Love the sound of a bottle smashing. Almost signifies the end of that journey. “HEELS PLEASE”, my good man.

[@bigjazz83]

Another great recycled review Thanks for the enjoyable whisky content Roy ! Cheers 🥃 Heels please

[@ConcaCon]

Thank you for your insights as always. I just ordered a Deanston Virgin Oak to get an initial taste of what they're about. I thought the price of 23€ was rather appealing. EDIT: The whiskey is phenomenal. Such a nice progression, and then, at the very end of the finish I got dark chocolate and it blew my mind.

[@MegaJohnconrad]

Another great video. Love the honest commentary about Highland Park and Jura. They would be wise to take note and start putting out better products. Heels please.

[@erikevenson4303]

feels like its been ages since i seen you put a recycled review out..i guess too many people are sending samples that you don't get to drink what you have on your shelf. i love listening to all the things you have to say. glad to call you a whisky friend..HEELS PLEASE!

[@samniebylski9058]

Always look forward to your recycled reviews Roy, agree the Ben nevis is a hidden gem of a whisky. Keep up the good work mate. Ps Heels please.

[@wildlifewhiskey3636]

I never thought I would get such joy out of watching someone throw away trash.. and I don’t even drink scotch

[@DavidUKesb]

Maybe you should!

[@WhiskyInThe6]

Love this video Roy. A few bottles I love here and a few I need to seek out. Well done. Cheers brother.

[@martywong822]

I have been a fan of your recycle reviews. I discovered High Coast Whisky from Sweden recently and found that the qualities are good. They do not have age statements on their whiskies, but they release all the cask information including fill date, empty date, volume, ratio, etc. on their website. Talking about transparency, they "can" do a better job than Compass Box because they are not bottling "Scotches". I tasted a bottle of Timmer, which has a clean fruity taste with good amount of peat smoke, and the rubber bandage finish remind me of Longrow. Please give it a try.

[@NZAnimeManga]

Another fantastic recycled review, really enjoyed that Caol Ila Feis Ile sample you sent to me, can’t wait for the next VPub! Cheers Roy!

[@TheBalrogEE]

The pinned comment says it best. Innovative and engaging content. Oh, and "HEELS PLEASE"!

[@ConcaCon]

I must say, I bought the Jura 18 on offer for under 50 EUR. I've gifted it to a friend of mine who loves Jura, but even so, I enjoy that it kind of has some interesting black tea notes. There are other wine-finished whiskies I prefer, but I'd rate it at 7.5 / 10, personally.

[@thewhiskyphoenix]

You could think scotch whisky was utterly abhorrent and still love these videos. Cheers Roy 🥃Well done as usual mate. HEELS PLEASE!

[@thomasbuck303]

One of my favorite series on KZbin, thank you Roy!

[@kevincecco4759]

Roy, truly my most favorite videos! Love the insights. Thank you! Heels Please!

[@OsirisRa]

Best whisky content anywhere. I think I can speak for others here when I say we love these reviews! Thanks Roy. HEELS PLEASE!

[@petewelsh9978]

I visited the Ben Nevis distillery in Fort William today. I was NOT disappointed!!! Such a complex and engaging whisky, probably the best finish I’ve ever experience. I’m off to Pitlochry tomorrow for the double hit of Blair Atholl and Edradour. Sadly the Tomatin visitor centre was closed on my way back from Inverness today.

[@Aqvavitae]

Enjoy Pete! Remember the whisky shopping in Pitlochry itself, but you’ll have spent all your cash at Edradour!

[@petewelsh9978]

@@Aqvavitae sadly the distillery was not open Roy. But Ewan at Robertson’s ensured I left with a Ballechin 10, a 2011 Signatory single cask Edradour and a wonderful Hepburn Talisker Single cask 6 year old! Off to Doune on Friday for you know what

[@Aqvavitae]

@@petewelsh9978 now… what lies in Doune? 🤔 JK - hope you love it.

[@petewelsh9978]

@@Aqvavitae Deanston was superb! Great staff wonderful tastings, the Calvados barrel is very interesting! Not sure it’s my pallet though. I left with a bottle of 1997 PX cask no.598 @55.7% outstanding and my wedding year too.

[@evenflowcss]

Cheers Roy! I feel your pain about Whyte and Mckay. It's currently owned by this conglomerate from my country (Emperador Inc. out of the Philippines) who are more focused on having a diverse portfolio rather than the quality of product.They're pushing Dalmore, Jura and Tamnavulin really hard here in the local market, but for the quality (as you've accurately observed with your reviews of Dalmore and Jura), I'd rather buy myself better malt from Deanston, Laphroaig, or Arran.

[@DonnerPassWhisky]

Another fun recycled review. Really appreciate the little outtakes and jokes at the beginning and end of this. As for AnCnoc any day now they will be rebranded like Old Pulteney and Balblair have, so sad. Heels Please. Cheers Roy

[@lynnduff1178]

Just joined your channel as a member - I'm the 1st! 😁

[@Richie.Z]

Always always love these recycleds, Roy! I get tons of buying ideas off of your takes on the bottles. Cheers brother!

[@maartenromkes353]

Last year I enjoyed a great 'old' 18y Highland Park. To bad for the newer stuff. Keep up the video's, I really like your content. HEELS PLEASE!

[@orangewool]

Cheers Roy, great content as always... and that AnCnoc 24 is great stuff! Look forward to the next Vpub. HEELS PLEASE 😉

[@foodquig]

Excellent review, Roy! Although I have not had many older Deanstons, I preferred the 12 to the 18, and the Virgin Oak was OK. I would not go for Deanston 18 again. Could mine have been an older bottling? I don't know. Of all the bottles you showed, I have only had four of them. I enjoyed the PaulJohn Edited and had their Bold, which tasted to me like dark chocolate and Tic Tac mints. I have a bottle of their Brilliance that I haven't opened yet... Highland park 18 was OK when I had it some time ago. It was the older bottling without all the Viking hype attached to it. To be honest, it was a good whisky but I preferred the Dark Origins, and I know where I can still get some! Ardbeg 10 is a classic. I would have some on my bar, but with things like Laphroaig Brodir, Ardbeg Dark Cove, Bunnahabhain Moine Marsala, and Port Charlotte MC:01 taking up all the space, my Islay section runneth over! Auchentoshan American Oak is, as far as I can tell, the replacement for the old Classic of which I had a bottle five or six years ago, and it was excellent. I happen to like the current American Oak as the purest form of Auchentoshan available. I prefer it to the three wood, and both editions of the Bartender's Malt were just wonderful... I will be going through the rest of the core range of Auchentoshan in the near future; the 18, the 12, and the Virgin Oak... Slainte Mhath!

[@Everest314]

It just struck me that, after 10 of these videos, I have spent several hours of my life watching someone take out the rubbish and talk about what's in it ... and enjoyed it thoroughly. What a curious thing whisky is! :D Regarding Highland Park: The standard 12yo was one of the first whiskies I started my journey with (about 4 years ago) - and it was great at that. But since then I haven't ever really connected with any of their original bootlings anymore. However, I came across a couple of absolutely stunning independent HPs (none of them with HP mentioned, but I know the guys who made them). Definitely something to look out for if you are frustrated with the official HP bottlings. PS: Heels please!

[@jaychung6622]

Absolutely loved this recycled review Roy! Really well done! Granted, I’ve loved all the previous iterations as well, but this one was definitely awesome. Informative w/o being preachy or boring, entertaining, and very well-produced (the outtakes were great & that mega cap rattling about 😂👌🏻)...all the hallmarks of an Aqvavitae video. Brilliant! 🥃😄

[@dutchpagans]

Your honest love and apriciation for whisky is shining show brightly in these videos! You help me enjoy and understand whisky more.... and i am seriously thinking about buying that ancnoc 24 ... eventhough it is a bit over my budget.

[@blissfulmistahd]

hi Reny, maybe consider a try before you buy?

[@dutchpagans]

@@blissfulmistahd just orderd 2 bottles 😆

[@jemsweet3466]

I love this site and the reviews. Watched them all and often repeat watch. HEELS PLEASE!

[@goosebumpsIIVI]

Heels please. Nice one Roy! Love the vPubs and love the recycled reviews!

[@mikekay9529]

Roy, keep up the wonderful work. What you do for the whiskey community is so very helpful. Thank you. Heels please.

[@Claymore_83]

HEELS PLEASE! New to whisky despite also being Scottish! You sound local also! Trying to watch all your videos and soaking as much knowledge up as I can! New subscriber!

[@ConcaCon]

LOL at the Jura toss. I did the "Kobe!" shout out when I saw it.

[@Whisky_in_Saxony]

Thank you so much for that, one of the...or THE best whisky review format in youtube! And: Heels Please!

[@Aqvavitae]

Thanks Rico!

[@alasdair_gray]

superb reviews Roy. Spot on about Highland Park (another distillery in the Edrington Group). They seem to be doing exactly as they have done with Macallan. The amount of new NAS whiskys being churned out at Highland Park, I have lost count. If they just focused on the whisky, rather than all this Viking/Scandinavian bottling nonsense. Its sad to see. Will pick up the AnCnoc 24 this year, its my new favourite local distillery! The vintage 2001 was the quickest I have ever gone through a bottle before, lovely hints of apple and vanilla. Too easy to drink. Also well done on 11,000 subs!!

[@MarkusKreitner]

As always, a pure joy to watch your recycled reviews. Krisztina and myself really enjoy them and I always have to keep myself from searching those whiskys you review otherwise they'd probably be bought (if available). There are many whisky reviews on youtube, many (really) good ones but your format just stands out from the crowd. Also loved the bloopers, please continue with those in the future! ;)

[@dmshampton]

I genuinely smile each and every time I see this video pop into my subscription box. Sublime review as always, Roy. Cheers to 10 videos and to 10 more.

[@royale4318]

Having been a lover of Jura's and HP's malts soon after setting out on my whisky journey some years ago, I have to agree entirely with your comments on both. Out of all the bottles in our cabinet today, these are probably the ones least likely to generate that "I fancy a..." feeling. Part of that, arguably, is that in having developed my palate to a degree, exploring higher ABVs, different levels and qualities of peat etc, I've "outgrown" them in a sense - but it's more than that. These distilleries are guilty, in my opinion, of either trying too hard, or not hard enough with their core ranges. On a side note, it was an absolute joy to meet yourself and Scott in the Pot Still recently. Two of the warmest, most down-to-earth, and generous guys one could hope to encounter in a Glasgow 'local.' Thanks again, and next time First Round is our shout!

[@darrencharters6716]

Great video Roy- new traveller on the scotch whisky journey- enjoy hearing your perspective on your experiences. HEELS Please!

[@stefank.5247]

Great review! I was at Bunnahabhain in 2018. Also tried the Moine PX and loved it! Thank you and heels please.

[@BigJimmyJazz]

Great review as always Aqvavitae, very nicely done and extremely informative. I think Ailsa Bay bottle and its granite topper would have made a nice infinity bottle!!! Oh and of course, Heels Please!

[@mikejohnston2162]

Excellent as always a Roy! Love these videos and gives me the confidence to buy and enjoy quality whisky I’d have otherwise missed,keep up the great work! 🥃 HEELS PLEASE!!

[@grisen35]

Amazing reviews, keep em coming!! HEELS PLEASE!

[@richardagnew4959]

As a newcomer to whiskey I find these videos REALLY helpful! Thanks, Roy. When the next one? End of April? :)

[@choicebarrelscrotes2732]

Love seeing you spend a bit more time with the recycled reviews; 2 minutes per bottle or so is a good length. HEELS PLEASE! ;)

[@Brumstar1]

Yes! I love recycle review day! Enjoyed the slightly longer format - gives time for more insights and explanation. Cheers, Roy! Heels please!

[@jpallen719]

Roy have you seen or tried a scotch blend called Big Peat, a blend of Ardbeg, Bowmore, Caol Ila, Glen Ellen? Non age statement, 53% cask strength non chill filtered? Smokey but light and fruity as well, 40$ on a sale. I really enjoyed it, it hit all the marks that you usually check off as good value.

[@Aqvavitae]

Indeed I have, although very much batch driven I’ve enjoyed a few tasty Big Peat releases, Fred Laing was on the vPub as a guest to discuss this range and others in March last year. Also kzbin.info/www/bejne/oXPbq2qtirR3baMm04s Cheers JP

[@aerormacphault8082]

Classic Aqvatitae ! Well thought through, interesting, informative ... and funny. An RR can never be too long and is always worth the wait. Thanks Roy!

[@maxphillips8895]

These are the best! The empty bottle connection to the heart and memory is the truest review. Thank You!

[@TheBennjina]

HEELS PLEASE. I've only just found your channel and I'm hooked the concept is amazing I'm going back to watch all the Recycled series. Keep up the good work

[@joshgolladay5068]

Amazing as always Roy. I look forward to these more than anything else on whiskytube.

[@djbeacon6895]

Roy, Great stuff and the time just flies when watching these!! And really enjoy scrolling through your spreadsheet summary. HEELS PLEASE! That last bottle wasn't a slam dunk!! CHEERS!

[@meesternibbles]

In the middle of a bottle of the Paul John Edited now. I got it for my birthday a year ago, and it was a pleasant surprise. My wife is pretty risk averse, but bought it for me spur of the moment despite it not being on my wish list. Enjoying it quite a bit, but now that my whisky budget is getting quite tighter, I don't think I'll be replacing it quickly. Definitely worth a try though! Another great review Roy! Sliante!

[@chuckmcewen1293]

This is a great format for quick down and dirty reviews. completely enjoying your channel and format. HEELS PLEASE!

[@WhiskeyQuests]

I always look forward to these recycled reviews. I’m glad my favorite Ardbeg finally made an appearance lol. Cheers Roy heels please (but no need just happy to gain some knowledge here) 🤗

[@Ebbhead2424]

Awesome episode, Roy! A few bottles to chase there ;) and HEELS PLEASE!

[@andrewowens4231]

Interesting and educational as always :) I have recently bought an 18 year old Organic Deanston...must say it's been a pleasure thus far! Thanks to this channel. Oh, heels please!!

[@alanmcgregor3078]

Roy, Thank you for the level-headed reviews. They help me put my money toward value. Love the recycle format. Heels Please!

[@chrisbrown5230]

Another excellent video and great watch Roy....Heels Please!

[@baggieboyful]

Another Great Line up of Bottle Kills , there is something about these reviews they are captivating , the music , the chat about each bottle , the pop of cork , the bottle spin , I wonder how many you have dropped Roy ? , and the drop of glass bottle in the bin . I see good things from these reviews , ive read my tea leafs lol Heels Please !! well done Roy

[@andergarcia7840]

Thank you very much for another wonderful recycled review! i love your more personal and more calm approach. Heels please!

[@moose7611]

Love the recycle reviews, I hope they never end. HEELS PLEASE!

[@skippyvanpob2762]

That was nice to see again, love the recycled reviews! I'm going to say heels please although I know you can't send to Canada I can always pick someone to give it to if I'm that lucky! Thanks Roy!

[@Ryannnnn123]

HEELS PLEASE! From Fife. Pretty new to my whisky experience and looking to sample more variety. Thanks Roy!

[@ScotchontheBayou]

Roy - I'm still dreaming of that Talisker 8! It was so good - almost as good as the time spent with you and the Barflies in the Aqvavitae Lair! Heels please! :)