Arab Israelis: Are you living under apartheid?

Filmed before October 2023 war
HOW TO HELP
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
The Ask Project is made possible by donations from viewers like you.
To donate to the project:
* www.paypal.me/coreygilshuster
* / askproject
WHAT IS THE ASK PROJECT?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
Do you want to know what Israelis and Palestinians really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers. All answers are from random people and all answers are included and unedited. The questions come from you, the viewers.
WHY DO I DO THIS?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
See the following videos where I explain the background and goal of the project • The Ask Project interv...

[@noamto]

6:28 "There's no playgrounds in Arab villages" 30 seconds earlier: Interview in a playground in an Arab village.

[@1969cmp]

.....pretty much. The local council or community could build the playgrounds.

[@rachelil8094]

Pretty sure that wasn’t an Arab village playground

[@Graacie1111]

Has anyone... ANYone ever KZbin searched "Gaza Kindergarten Graduation Ceremony"?? Please do, and report back to us

[@TheNotehead]

@@rachelil8094 Why not?

[@Qiyunwu]

@@rachelil8094 Kfar Kanna is an Arab town

[@almapantoja3068]

If apartheid means discrimination, then we all live in apartheid countries.

[@dummlp]

Congratulations, you have discovered how antisemitism operates. By demonizing Jews and saying all their flaws are unique and the most horrible versions possible of those flaws.

[@user-il3uo6hb9q]

Apartheid is the segregation based on race. and segregation is discrimination. so yeah.

[@markbisson6166]

@@user-il3uo6hb9qsounds like you’re saying all squares are rectangles.

[@nuklearboysymbiote]

@@markbisson6166 well, they are

[@markbisson6166]

@@nuklearboysymbiote yes, they are lol, but not all rectangles are squares

[@siempreleal7213]

There is some descrimination in all countries, and that doesn't mean "apartheid"

[@xaspirate8060]

Simple as that!

[@6eeykwr2]

simp

[@easy8690]

They have segregated schools and the government flat out calls Palestinians "monkeys" and openly says that killing pregnant women is good. I don't care what they're called they're bad.

[@Gideon01]

Israel-haters make exceptions when discussing Israel: it's OK to call discrimination - apartheid, gaining land in a defensive war - land theft, terrorists - freedom fighters, and war - genocide.

[@kusari86]

There are 4 tiers of rights in occupied Palestine. Arabs rights vary depending where they live. Someone in Tel Aviv has more rights than an Arab in Jursalem, who has more rights than an Arab in Nablus, who has more rights than an Arabs in Gaza

[@MrNatrocks]

First guy is a liar. My gf is in physics in uni. They save half the seats for Arabs. Even though they are not half the population

[@YoYo-xz6ql]

In fact you are the liar, but you perceive it not! Even the humans rights watch admit this although they lie too.

[@amirardat1068]

You are such a liar

[@mara3842]

He looks too old for uni anyway lol. Even if this was the case back when he was young, things may have changed.

[@gog7114]

They get scholarships and benefits to study

[@thetsfa3307]

first dude saying only 4 arab student in each class is just disinforming, also in israel there is a law forcing universities to accept arabs at a lower score than rest of population score.

[@opportunisticobserver]

yeah you know more about how it feels to be an arab living in isreali than the arab guy living in isreal..lol

[@sciencescholar3440]

​@@opportunisticobserverhe was a Palestinian

[@hanna319]

@@opportunisticobserver Maybe we will ask what is the experience of the Jews in the Arab universities?? Oh, there aren't any.

[@anthonyjacobs6790]

@@sciencescholar3440, aren't Palestinians Arabs?

[@nuklearboysymbiote]

@@hanna319 there's no more universities in gaza because of idf…

[@user-vm6qx2mx5z]

Apartheid is a constitutional system, not the behavior of companies or specific people

[@PunkiBrooster]

Yes, and Israel has a set of national laws which give Jews, and the culture of Judaism, preference and privileges above anyone who isn't Jewish. Netanyahu has stated himself "Israel is not a country for all of her citizens." He wasn't just talking shit. He was stating a fact.

[@omp835]

Do you really think a semantics argument helps?

[@monicacarolina6480]

@@PunkiBrooster FALSE

[@MoB660]

what is the israel nation state law ?

[@edihayat]

@PunkiBrooster does Egypt gives equal rights to all its citizens? Lebanon? Syria? Iraq? Yemen? Saudi? Algeria? Tunisia? Should I go on? They serve in government, work as doctors in hospitals, heads of banks, serve in the military. This is not apartheid. Not even close. What jews faced in Arab countries could be considered apartheid though! One tiny Jewish state of course there is discrimination in any society. Always a damn double standard for Jews. So sick of it this bullshit.

[@yuvalkoren4070]

Not sure if the first guy actually meant physics, but I'm currently studying physics at the Technion and I can vouch that a lot more than 3 or 4 Arabs are going to the very same lectures as me. Christian, Muslim, and Druze.

[@l_kFF]

30% of first-year students in Technion are Arabs. In Haifa university almost 50%.

[@topasta7411]

i believe he meant to say 4% however that still doesn't make sense

[@khaledassaf6356]

That entire interaction didn't make any sense. I've been in classes where I'm the only Arab, in others there were only 2-3 Jews. Had similar experiences when teaching at Wizo. It is what it is. The thing with the airport also doesn't really make much sense. Only times I've had airport security go through my stuff was when they saw something suspicious in the xray (as they should!), and they were always nice about it.

[@vincent_boss]

I believe the guy meant medical school. He then goes on to say "if you want to be a physician...". I'm just guessing.

[@jamesfullwood7788]

The number is probably proportional to the population right?

[@chris123sim]

No apartheid in Israel, just hostility from both sides. just like in every country with several different populations living together, ask about the rights of Jews and Christians in arab countries will be worse.

[@suhaibalkhazraji9907]

😂😂😂 if he will find any Jews in Arab world And the Christians in Arab countries will not tell the truth without covering their face, because they might be arrested or killed

[@shakeelali5189]

Like we’re exactly? No Muslim country I’ve ever been to discriminate another’s religion plenty of Christian’s and Indians living in many Arab countries Israel sucks

[@SaadI0I]

There are literally roads in the West Bank where Palestinians aren't allowed to take, but Israelis can. The West Bank belongs to the Palestinians.

[@SaadI0I]

Not to mention hundreds of checkpoints to control the movement of the Palestinians, blocking of neighborhoods, walls dividing them, illegal settlers stealing Palestinians houses etc. . So there is an apartheid.

[@suhaibalkhazraji9907]

@SaadI0I there is area where the Israelis are not allowed to go, only for Palestinians, you must provide the whole information not to take the part that supports your agenda Secondly, West Bank is just a silly geographical name. The correct historical name is Judea , it belongs to the Jews, not Arabs

[@rafewheadon1963]

I am arab israeli. The first guy is lying about everything.

[@lailamakhlouf9531]

Because you are support zionisam.

[@arlenegojocco7518]

Thanks for the truth!

[@tarekahmad8884]

Let me guess.. you are durzi

[@irrittt]

@@lailamakhlouf9531if you call someone a Zionist in a degrading way, than you don’t actually know what is Zionism.

[@Pejarlie]

exactly, in every work place in israel theres arabs

[@maxx_thedragondominator]

I don’t think many that you interviewed know what apartheid is

[@opportunisticobserver]

yes they do...jews can walk around with a AK47 but arabs cant...that an exaple...duhhhhhhh

[@christerry1773]

I think it’s tough to define even if you do know because it was so exclusive to South Africa

[@sandraderoubaix734]

So here's the definition: the Afrikaans word Apartheid means to separate or set apart. In 1960 ethnic groups were given tracts of ancestral land where they self- governed. They had government, administration and a fair amount of industrial autonomy. There you are: the exact meaning and how it operated in SA. Itcwas called separate development which is what the Palestinians want

[@netnet161]

neither most of the people say there is apartheid

[@apzzpa]

From B'Tselem website: Citizenship - Jews living anywhere in the world, their children and grandchildren - and their spouses - are entitled to Israeli citizenship. In contrast, Palestinians cannot immigrate to Israeli-controlled areas, even if they, their parents or their grandparents were born and lived there. Israel makes it difficult for Palestinians who live in one of the units it controls to obtain status in another, and has enacted legislation that prohibits granting Palestinians who marry Israelis status within the Green Line. Freedom of movement - Israeli citizens enjoy freedom of movement in the entire area controlled by Israel (with the exception of the Gaza Strip) and may enter and leave the country freely. Palestinian subjects, on the other hand, require a special Israeli-issued permit to travel between the units (and sometimes inside them), and exit abroad also requires Israeli approval. Political participation - Palestinian citizens of Israel may vote and run for office, but leading politicians consistently undermine the legitimacy of Palestinian political representatives. The roughly five million Palestinians who live in the Occupied Territories, including East Jerusalem, cannot participate in the political system that governs their lives and determines their future. They are denied other political rights as well, including freedom of speech and association. www.btselem.org/apartheid

[@gabciel]

minimum score to be accepted into medical studies in Israel: Arabs: 500/800 Jewish: 780/800 Its more much easy for the arabs

[@sheri969]

True, the Israeli system makes it easier for Arabs. But why not make Israel look bad on youtube? It's more fun to be victims.

[@i.c.wiener2750]

So Arabs are the black people of the US. Basically they cry for racism over and over again until the system changes in their favour and then they STILL perform worse than the normal population 💀

[@khaledassaf6356]

Yeah...no.

[@jamesfullwood7788]

I wonder if there's such a discrepancy for the Jews in Palestine?

[@Thinnegan]

Not Doubting you, but I'd love to see a source.

[@Brett.Crealy-kh1sk]

There are 10 Muslim members of the Israeli parliament. An apartheid state wouldn't allow this!

[@D-E-S_8559]

That is daft---even in Jcrows or in white SA's there were blacks and Africans in parliament or local councils and courts. Now, if you want to understand Israeli apartheid first, you MUST determine weather there are two states or one states, and where one jurisdiction starts and where the other ends....who is in legal authority and control....???

[@nabil5535]

10 muslim members in parliament who actively say they're in an apartheid?

[@nabil5535]

You have a Jew in Iranian parliament too.

[@mikeysting3635]

That’s the typical I am not racist I have a black friend syndrome 🤣🤔

[@Brett.Crealy-kh1sk]

@@nabil5535 Yet those Arab members enjoy the freedoms in Israel that Israeli Arab's volunteer to fight for in the IDF alongside their Jewish, Druze, Muslim, & Christian compatriots! Go figure!

[@user-yu8ev6rs2o]

Is this why there are Arab judges, doctors, professors etc?

[@Xoxo27285]

No shit? israel isnt doing a favor here, they worked for it and achieved it, how about arabs cant get weapon liecenes, flying courses, cyber security jobs etc..

[@kevinjames3155]

So your saying because you can be a doctor, judge and professor than there isn’t apartheid, discrimination and racism? What an empty argument!

[@Xoxo27285]

@@kevinjames3155 He thinks Israel is doing a favor here 🤦🏻‍♂️

[@prezervezefunk]

@@kevinjames3155yes a judge will not allow the government to pass any apartheid law . Apparently you don’t know how our society works. I got fined by a policewoman in hijab , do you think she will enforce apartheid law . Btw an arab judge , who passed away recently, sent our prime minister and our president in prison … apartheid ? Having a an arab judge in the supreme court is the proof there cannot be any apartheid. It is also written in our declaration of independence 48 that everyone has same rights ( not same duties as religious jews and arabs are not obliged to serve in the army) . Strangely the apartheid in Lebanon doesn’t bother anyone, as well as the apartheid for jews in many Arab countries

[@user-il3uo6hb9q]

even some slaves in the US were allowed to study law and medicine. this doesn't mean there wasn't slavery and the slaves weren't treated horrendously!

[@momomi104]

None of what said in this video, match the definition of Aparthide..

[@Seanonyoutube]

Obviously

[@ori1676]

They are talking about discrimination from individuals, while Apartheid means discriminate laws by the state towards different races/ ethnicities in the state. so Israel is not an Apartheid.

[@rowboyto]

Discrimination isn't apartheid. The Checkpoints, roads only for jews, giant fences around an open air prison, and limitations created by israel that makes it apartheid.

[@momomi104]

@@rowboyto You are mixing Gaza and the West bank that are under Palestinian Jurisdiction (Govern by Hamas in Gaza or Fatah in the west bank) and the Israeli-Arabs.

[@ill3gal1]

None of them denied it either

[@Femmeaesthetic]

"it's racist regime" "out wives make us carry bags" It's honestly concerning how people in that region don't understand apartheid yet media shouts so much about Israeli aparthied

[@dummlp]

I think that was a joke. But yes it is concerning that every negative thing in Israel gets blown out of proportion by outside forces. It doesn't help anyone.

[@carenebarake1631]

well during Nazi Germany Germans were not aware or believe they were doing something wrong. they had implemented the same discriminatory system as yours before committing the holcaust. it is a systematic progressive violence, exactly like you are doing. the difference is that you cannot directly ethnically cleanse the population because it goes against Human rights following WW2.

[@nofaryaakov4275]

it is like to say that the palestinians have no right. but they have right by UNRA.who give them free serves. the world convices them that not matter what they do they are the victims. the world works in that way. becouse ISRAEL is too sucessfull in so many way-then they try to focus on ISRAEL that make them feel good what they fail.

[@greatmental]

XD "The women make us carry the bags" Oh btw we are payed to do it. The entire conversation is cringe. Because she isnt even translating what hes asking, shes just translating and saying what she feels like it. Thats why there answers are so wrong. She is trying to force them to say bad things. And of course there are border check points between the palestenian authority and israel. One is controlled by Israel and one isnt. Last i checked theres a border between mexico and USA as well.

[@Femmeaesthetic]

@@greatmental checkpoints exists in every country, without checkpoints there no rules or laws. also do you understand the arabic language if she's trying to make them look bad?

[@yyoni93]

Wearing GANT, Nike, Tommy T-shirts and driving new cars, I wish I lived in that kind of apartheid

[@kevinjames3155]

That’s not definition of apartheid clown 🤡

[@ill3gal1]

No you don’t, stfu. You European descent folks can’t handle a single form of discrimination

[@jonclark2797]

Definatly, the percentage of nice cars bmw’s Mercedes that are owned by arab Israelis is much more than 50% but they work hard for it, I don’t take anything away from them

[@garrettlees]

"Do you live in an apartheid state?" "Yes." "Give me an example." "There are many. None happen to come to mind right now, but there are many." Bruh.

[@opportunisticobserver]

So after hearing everyones pov you think they are making it all up?

[@bento8711]

​@@opportunisticobserveryesssss

[@garrettlees]

@@opportunisticobserver Something tells me that if they truly lived in an apartheid state, they'd know it. So yes, they're making it up.

[@docorwhatever2168]

@@garrettlees Many of them said examples, but not saying examples doesn’t mean that what they are saying is wrong.

[@garrettlees]

@@docorwhatever2168 No. Believe me, if there truly was apartheid, they'd have real examples, not this piddly sht.

[@Carla39894]

If the fjrst man lives in Tamallah, he is not an israeli arab, he lives under the PA government

[@HecProman]

True.

[@Smilefortheworld]

He lives under military occupation, PA government is nothing !

[@davidk2471]

I think he's in Ramallah but is a visitor, an Israeli citizen

[@MohammedHassan-ym8qf]

Israel needs a civil rights movement for Arabs

[@MohammedHassan-ym8qf]

Israel needs a civil rights movement for Arabs, Ethiopians etc

[@anthonyjacobs6790]

There was a woman who said Yahood (Jew), about 10 times, and it was translated as Israeli. That's your racism.

[@phyllisbarr4766]

because to them it is the same so when BS artists tell you they aren't anti-semitic just anti-zionists they are FULL OF IT

[@Brett.Crealy-kh1sk]

An estimated 1,500 Bedouin are serving in the IDF. Around 606 Muslim Arabs volunteered to serve in 2020 compared with 436 in 2018

[@ricco6270]

The bedouins serving in the army are forced to and some are traitors, happened in the holocaust too.

[@YoYo-xz6ql]

Means nothing. Even jews joined the nazi party.

[@user-yu8ev6rs2o]

Muslims are exempt from the army and can join if they want. All Jews, both men and women are required to join the army and then be in the reserves until they are 40! Let’s make everything equal and risk their lives equally. By the way, my Israeli friends are visiting for a couple weeks. A friend of theirs was burned alive until she was unrecognizable in her own home in Kibbutz Be’eri.

[@docorwhatever2168]

And..? That doesn’t change that Palestinians are second-class citizens in Israel.

[@dogbert52]

​@@docorwhatever2168i love how you are so open about your supremacist ji hadi colonialism

[@xaspirate8060]

@@docorwhatever2168 A guy leaves a post like that and look where your mind goes --- congrats, you are the Problem! BTW, over the decades a thing called "Sanctions" were put into place.... Israeli's did not implement these for no good reason. DO some research. You have no perspective on this topic -- you're just a cheerleader.

[@groundcontrol436385]

@@docorwhatever2168 It does suggest that an Islamic government would approve of a formal denial of rights to Jews - like the right to life.

[@ennisel]

How could you say they are 2nd class under a government they choose not to be under, like Israeli-Arabs, they're under a different governance; any person going to a foreign territory will not have the same rights as the citizens (this refers to WB & Gazanz wanting to be the same as their counterparts in ideal, but without citizenship) ​@@docorwhatever2168... One of the things I feel for about the Palestinians is they can't freely criticise their government hence #Peacecomms #whisperINgaza

[@avishayperes9219]

06:15 - there's apartheid because not enough playgrounds in Arab towns 😂 (he forgot to mention that it's the responsibility of their own municipality, and Arab towns have the lowest rates of tax collection)

[@rexluscus]

I'm always stunned how these people are so detached from reality.

[@MohammedHassan-ym8qf]

May Allah guide you to the right path 🕋🤲

[@takiyaazrin7562]

@@MohammedHassan-ym8qf The Prophet of Allah (ﷺ), when asked about the women and children of the polytheists being killed during the night raid, said: They are from them. Sahih Muslim 1745a

[@peteregan9726]

@@rexluscus it is truly shocking. similar attitudes exist in the "underclass" of every society. Plato's Allegory of the Cave was a diagnosis, not a parable

[@rexluscus]

​@@peteregan9726 I think Israel should have more strongly regulated what 'Arab' kids learned in school. Like about how their ancestors were Islamized and Arabized, and more about the history of islam, democracy, secularism, the great Greek and Roman philosophers and writers.

[@ntombifuthishabangu]

I am a South African black female who experienced an apartheid regime. The people who are talking haven't been experiencing any apartheid. Maybe they don't know what is apartheid government. Maybe they are confused about racism and the issue of trust. Even right now in South Africa, we don't own the land as black, but the government is a black regime, so you want to tell me that is an apartheid government

[@anthonyr963]

Discrimination and border security is not aparthied.

[@shinespb]

Moreover, I'm jew and I have same problems with security (as was described by first man) at the airport from time to time. Am I live in an apartheid?

[@retepkoweips1237]

without an accurate translator it can't work. Is she his wife? Moreover, the concept of apartheit is not well known in the arab community, and I think in the Israeli society eather.

[@Nancy-mi3xe]

Why wouldn't you expect extra security measures for Palestinians after Israel endured 16 years of suicide bombings against civilians in civilian areas :buses, bus stops, discos, cafes, etc.? And after Hamas' threats?

[@dadaebiko8332]

@Nancy-mi3xe I can understand that.

[@xaspirate8060]

Good to see this -- in recent days I have been letting the uninitiated in on this but I feel I'm wasting my time anyway -- they have long decided who they're rooting for and don't care about facts, history, stuff like that.

[@FactsChecker007]

Because ,Palestinian who needs protection from the Nazi zionist regime. Stop acting as victims.. it's a burned card.

[@ill3gal1]

Why wouldn’t Israel just end the occupation that causes Palestinians to resort to such drastic actions?

[@alfahim9iner]

@@ill3gal1 there's a reason why arab israelis don't really partake in those things nearly as much as west bank arabs. treat west bank arabs with dignity and the desperation that causes one to resort to these actions will decrease. the west bank and gaza has a mental health crisis. the kids are suicidal

[@user-fv9ks2kh5c]

this is so untrue, my mother she is a teacher in university and they have a lower demands from Arabs then Jews to be accepted so its so ugly to see how they lie to the camera with straight face

[@Pure_Boxing]

😂😂😂😂

[@Pure_Boxing]

Fake account comments with exactly the same structure of comments

[@irizzpablo184]

To be honest if the worker is lazy, of course who want a lazy worker, and this is 1 of so many problems un muslim especially women all they want is to sit and eat in work place. And I know because Ive been in muslim country.

[@shehimaliyah3816]

then I guess by your standard USA is an apartheid state for affirmative action

[@bento8711]

They practice taqiya

[@unravelingsoul9705]

"Hi, do you live in an apartheid state?" "No, but some Israeli soldiers have weapons and it scares me" (during a war lol) "No, but when I was searching for a job, in the criteria they were putting arabs first and I don't want things easy for me" "No, but Jewish people have more resources and their cities are better then ours and I would like that also Arabs cities could be like theirs" "No, but I would like more playgrounds and space for my kids" "Yes, but I don't remember, there are some examples but now I can't say". There's no apartheid in Israel, definitely.

[@estebank4592]

Conclusion: it's clear Israel is NOT an apartheid stated. They say it clearly.

[@Xoxo27285]

They are two steps if getting there

[@Broskiii17]

Depends on where they live. He’s talking to arabs with Israeli passports. Westbank a b c is apartheid

[@Offa7a]

It’s just racist 😂

[@PaulaContar]

May not be in this terms properly but what about control, ocupation, how israeli goverment does not allow free coming and going even inside palestinian territory by palestinians, for instance. From Gaza to Cisjordania Israel controls palestinians. Israel controls who goes to Gaza and Cisjordania. They have no right to do that. It would be similar Argentina goverment controls who goes to Uruguai. Palestinian refugees can not go back to Gaza or Cisjordania because of Israel. There are many points. Israel arrests palestinians for many years with no proper trial. Thera are many ways Israel is an oppressor for palestinians.

[@mikiafu]

It depends if you have a citizenship i guess

[@mattrubenstein86]

If only these people had the faintest clue what apartheid was actually like in South Africa...

[@opportunisticobserver]

south africa brought it to the courts that they are living in apartide lol

[@tresbonoeuf]

@@opportunisticobserverLook!up! Gullible is written on the ceiling!

[@afRolowkey]

So basically you’re saying SA knows what apartheid is yet they are wrong that Israel practices apartheid? Even though they brought it to the ICC and with evidence?

[@ubroc]

What is the difference between what SA was like and what it's like on the west bank.

[@alitantawy2222]

Lol, guess which country dragged your terrorist apartheid state to the icj and acknowledge it as an apartheid? It's south Africa, so they know athing or two about apartheid

[@freejay3]

Security because of the palestinian terrorism isnt apartheid

[@ahairshi]

Lol they are Israelis.

[@Tamayo.Sama2023]

Israel is so scared if they let arab/non jews living peacefully in israel. They'll get outnumbered and jew exclusive nation get destroyed 🤣

[@danthaman743]

@@ahairshithe first guy is not Israeli

[@danthaman743]

@@ahairshiall people go thru security when traveling from the different areas. There are NO security checks WITHIN Israeli territory.

[@ghst4487]

@@danthaman743 israel is apartheid state. These European colonizers need to return the land

[@gabciel]

Jewish pays a appartment: 300,000 $ Arabs pays a appartment : 50,000$

[@f0lke]

What does this mean?

[@studiosorek1432]

Jew lives in a densed highrises buildings, the young arab wants land to build his 2 store house. No leicense no tax.

[@leehiyeffet1390]

There are Arabic students in the Hebrew university and other universities in Israel. They are working in Israel and they have lots of rights. There is no apartheid in Israel.

[@phyllisbarr4766]

import tax on new cars for israelis is approximately 100%...we pay twice the price for the same car as in US

[@ahkkariq7406]

@@studiosorek1432 Exactly what I thought. Why don't they buy a property, demolish the buildings, put up a high-rise and secure their financial future by renting out or selling apartments if there is a housing shortage? They can obviously live in high-rise buildings in Western countries. Land that they are slowly taking over by making the neighborhood unlivable for the native non-Muslims. Nevertheless, they complain about discrimination. Muslims are the biggest hypocrites on this planet.

[@timelinewatches2300]

Did a guy literally complain about the Israeli government giving him higher position jobs with ease and even with the preference that he's an arab? Then he said, " I want to be able to earn it, not get it easily. " I'm blown away by that one.

[@rosabellef3582]

It’s totally normal that someone would prefer to earn things rather than having them handed to them as an affirmative action. But also, in his case he was actually highlighting a fact that is contrary to the common discrimination felt in his community. Prior to his example he specified that where they are (in the city where the interview is happening), discrimination exists like in any other places. Sometimes, it’s good not to take someone’s words out of context and run with it.

[@ADv-ll1vn]

Weird the first guy mentions medical school when there were multiple israeli programs showing 50% arab and 50% jewish acceptance. What makes it more difficult for university acceptance and jobs is military service. However, there are non-military civic service that you can elect to do as an israeli citizen, regardless of religious and ethnic identity that counts

[@soltantio]

That's actually super unfair because Arabs are 20% of the population so if you're going to try and be fair about it they should be about 20% of the class.

[@TheTomsijoker]

there's a lot of lies in the video/ or problems that are an Israeli problem that influence everyone here. it's a shame that the interviewer don't show real information on the background when they misspeak...

[@sselemaNrM]

He said physicist, not physician

[@ADv-ll1vn]

Ok my comment is still relevant. You go on Israeli campuses, there are Arab students. The biggest problem obstacle is forgoing military service which for many years since Arabs and prior to new legislation religious Jews did not need to enlist, they had issues getting certain scholarships. Another issue is that most Israeli schools require a certain level of Hebrew language level that many Arab students did not have. This was discrimination, but not a constitutional system of apartheid. Many groups exist to bridge these gaps, however it would require working alongside Jews and Arabs rather than continuing to self-victimize.

[@Stolas1777]

@@ADv-ll1vnit’s discrimination that you should have to be proficient in the language of the country that you live in?

[@Ancel316]

Now go to any Arab country and ask a Jew how he or she feels about living under shariah law.

[@amuzzing67]

Safe, that’s why they’re still in an Arab land instead of used as pawns in Israel.

[@charbelyounes5188]

Not all of them have sharia laws, and they do not apply to non Muslims.

[@hillal8105]

Islamic law doesn't really apply to us in Muslim-majority Morocco. We have rabbinical courts which have autonomy in questions of marriage, divorce, inheritance... We are exempt from certain laws that apply to Muslims such as no eating in public during Ramadan and the ban on purchasing alcohol (although this is more a symbolic law as Muslims can easily purchase alcohol here). The jizya tax has been abolished for over a hundred years. Most of us are rather privileged as we tend to be highly educated with generational wealth and dual or triple citizenships. The only other Muslim-majority countries with "substantial" Jewish populations are all non-Arab: Azerbaijan and Turkey, with around 15k-20k each, but those are secular states, and then Iran, whose Muslims can attest to the oppression Islamic regime. The Jewish expats I know working in the Gulf tend to like it there and have no issues. As for the actual Arab states of Syria, Iraq, Egypt, Yemen, and Libya, not many Jews left to speak of.

[@nuklearboysymbiote]

imagine still making up rumours to slander islamic law

[@levigoldberg901]

@@hillal8105 r u jewish?

[@Annastasia2000]

I lived in apartheid country that I had to flee and I am Christian from Iraq

[@jameswitt108]

Christians lived in peace in Iraq for hundreds of years, American policy is responsible for the sorry state of the Christians today.

[@y.l7455]

​@@jameswitt108 Yeah, sure, tell it yourself more often abdul.

[@interestingyoutubechannel1]

Are you Assyrian? Mandean? You know many Christians from Gaza who had to flee when hamas took power, were given safe haven as residents in Israel. They were massacred by the palestine nationalists.

[@jameswitt108]

@@interestingyoutubechannel1 Liar, Arab Christians always lived in peace in the middle east. Only when so called american 'foreign policy' was implemented did that change.

[@jameswitt108]

@@y.l7455 The population census speaks for itself, Arab Christians have always lived in peace in the middle east before American foreign policy was implemented. US Zionism was the nail in the coffin.

[@gabrielfine6296]

As a Jew I have to say those that say theres discrimination are right. I study in a university in central Israel and at approx half of my economics class are Arabs, that is because they need a lower Psychometry score to be accepted, since the state decided to increase their education and employment rates. They also get other benefits as additional time in exams cause they're in Hebrew and it's not their native language. Arabs that reach the age of 18 start their life whether they go to work or study, I had to go to the army by law and spend 3 years of my life risking it. There's truly a lot of discrimination in favor of the Arabs in Israel, I wish I had some of this discrimination.

[@user-zf8xk5cu4u]

so you mean that they are wrong. not right.

[@phyllisbarr4766]

yes all true

[@rkrmusic2008]

You should asked them: would they will serve in the army to protect Israel? Beside the fact that there is affirmative action in Universities and in Medical sector in favor to the Arab Israelis

[@nikkenikNick]

There are around 600 Arabs Muslims in the IDF surprisingly.

[@MoB660]

i think in israel serving in the army it's not obligatory for arabs but it's obligatory for jews which is very telling and i can understand that they don't want to massacre arabs palestinians that they were just unlucky to be on the occupied zones

[@trespire]

@@MoB660 Druze (who are not Arabs or Muslims), have served in front line positions sinse the estalishment of the State, some reaching very high officer ranks. Same for Beduine (Muslims), many of who have made the ultimate sacrifice as they are expert trackers. Many Christian Arabs have chosen to serve, and even some Muslim Arabs. The IDF take all possible steps to avoid non-combatant casualties, as a standing order.

[@medhany1785]

⁠@@trespire The IDF takes barely any steps to prevent non-combatant fatalities. Just look at all the casualties waving white flags.

[@nuklearboysymbiote]

​@@trespire well, that last point is clearly not true. Might be on paper, but in reality there's been nothing to stop them

[@momomi104]

Just FYI, in Israel, the responsabilty of building parks, and municipal infrastructure, is on the municipal level (meaning the municipal athority is the responsible). All towns and vilages - Arabs and Jews - get the same budget from the govrenment according to their population size. The rest of their income is from municipal taxes (ARNONA), local parking fees etc.. The difference comes because there's a lot of crime and corruption in the Arab communities, and not enough that dares to testify against the criminals. So the funds the local athourites get to improve their lifes, is either embazeled or payed as "protection" money to crime organizations.. The police make important arrests almost daily, but they get released after 48 hrs by the court because of lack of witnesses..

[@Seanonyoutube]

It’s worth noting that part of the problem is that the police are made up by mostly right wing arsim who treat arabs quite badly. So the arabs don’t feel like the police will be on their side if they turn to them. Kinda like african Americans often feel about police in the usa. A vicious cycle…

[@anonymousbrowser4448]

Very interesting, thank you! I thought it was dishonest how that one guy blamed the IDF for arabs stealing weapons and for arab crime. All about denying responsability

[@THEKING1300]

"Arabs are corrupt" So why is Israel a haven for pedophiles?

[@renatomsgomes]

It does look kindda shitty for western europen standards... is like mini usa in terms of zonning but with roundabouts... i guess nothing like following a bad exemple (usa) in order to hope things will get better

[@ElisaAvigayil]

As I wrote above, how does that explain the lack of playgrounds in, for example, Beit Tzafafa and Beit Hanina? How does that explain the poor garbage collection in Sheikh Jarrah?

[@Blackbirdinthedeadofnight]

Arab govern Arab villages so if Arabs don’t have good facilities in many cases it is because of the Arabs themselves. But there are less efforts in investing in resources in arab areas in Israel. Although that is true to the periphery in general.

[@lior9bm]

I study in Haifa university in cs. About 50% of students are arabs..

[@milesreading9585]

There’s a difference between apartheid and racism.

[@abdusshakoorsaafir3985]

What's the difference?

[@beckyweiss6072]

Apartheid was also a term coined to explain what was going on in South Africa in the 80s. The only other system that came close to it, the only other system you can compare it to are the Jim Crow laws that were abolished in the 60s

[@ricco6270]

israel is undeniably forcing an apartheid system in the west bank, it is a fact.

[@guidobolke5618]

Apartheid was the name of the system of society in South Africa where different races where seperated from each other. Apart=seperated, heid=ness, Seperatedness. Racism is a personal believe that the human race is divided into different races and these races have visible and invisible properties that all members of the race inherit. Obviously racism is needed for Apartheid, but Apartheid is not needed for racism.

[@NetanelCharlap]

Ask a black person in south Africa 50 years ago "do you live in apartheid?" and he'll have a quick list to give you. Here, you talk to Arabs literally while they sit freely in a mall, walk in a street inside a mixed city, work, own land etc.. There are a lot of issues that most Jews would agree we need to fix. Regarding the housing issue it's the same for all. My great-great parent bought land 50 years ago and it's still locked for "agriculture only". It requires a lot of approvals and procedures that take years and a lot of money to get approval to build on the land. As Israel has limited space, mostly you get approvals for highrise so mostly you will need to find a developer that would like to buy the land from you and the surrounding land to build a building and then you get an apartment out of it. Buying land to build a private house is very expensive.

[@Thenoobestgirl]

☝️ This. And it's only going to get worse as the population expands...

[@NetanelCharlap]

@@Thenoobestgirl I believe the cost is mostly from Covid, the war and the mess of a Kneset we have.. In the last years we had a rush of "destroy and build" in which the Gov encourages developers to destroy old buildings and build high risers in it place. Also, we have the "strengthening" program in which a developer will buy the building rights from the entire residents of a not-too-old building and he will add a few levels to the building, strengthening the building foundation and adding a room to each apartment. With only these two programs I believe we have plenty of year of expansion..

[@jchan9761]

Look to the W Bank.

[@NetanelCharlap]

@@jchan9761 You mean the area that is controlled by the "Palestinian Authority"? I would agree.. That is an actual example of apartheid. There are literally signs that tell Israelis that they are not allowed in certain roads and villages and it would dangerous for them to do so.. And when Israelis accidentally do go in those roads and villages they mostly get stoned and beaten in the best scenario... There were cases of even Israeli Arabs who got stoned and a couple of tourists who got trapped and threatened because they drove with an Israeli license plate. So.. Yeah, I would call it apartheid.

[@nuklearboysymbiote]

​@@NetanelCharlap so… do you think native americans conservation areas in the US are running apartheid when they put out signs saying ”no tourists”? It's a parallel.

[@rolboler5191]

The claim of apartheid is always told about West Bank, not about arab israelis.

[@dogbert52]

Not only. Also french , norwegians and canadians cant vote in the israeli elections.....

[@fir3drag0n1984]

I've studied in Technion and Arabs there had "corrective discrimination" meaning that the entry barrier was lower for Arabs. Any Israeli Arab here in the comments that can say he/she had good enough grades and wasn't accepted because of ethnicity?

[@garrettlees]

Corey leans into the window of the brand new 2024 Mercedes-Benz AMG and asks the lady in the Adidas jump suit with the 24 karat gold necklace and matching gold earrings, "Are you oppressed in this society?" I mean, what in the actual f, man. Sheesh.

[@samferrell7757]

Yep that's the whole point, they're not oppressed

[@the_specialista6319]

So she learnt the money by working ans that's not thanks to her but to Nazi Netanyahu? Shut up

[@senefff]

Yeah I guess owning a Benz exempts her from the casual racism stupid ass

[@homerun8953]

It all balances itself. Arab citizens hardly pay property taxes, do a lot of work under the table, and do lots of illegal building on top of land they already own. In return they're in extreme poverty and get bad services from the country. Their priorities lead them to buy nice cars. In actuality Arab families only make half of what Jewish families make.

[@Xoxo27285]

WTF? she worked hard for it i guess? she didnt steal it or take it from the governments money

[@scottsimon1]

Not only do Israeli-Arabs enjoy full equal rights, they also enjoy additional privileges such as being exempt from army service ( they do have the option to join). This is a big deal because it means they get a 3 year head start on their Jewish peers. Lod is a mixed Arab- Jewish city, where Jews & Arabs live on the same streets. A new Aarab city was built in southern Israel for Beduoins - Rahat & new Arabs towns have been built in the north.

[@donbarnard82]

Some jews are currently exempt also.

[@billyleonardo8055]

Hahahahahah. Exempt from army services. More like denied access to military training and arms. Unlike settlers

[@nuklearboysymbiote]

wonder where they got the resources to build those cities from…

[@skontheroad]

Interesting! Never thought about the 3 year head start! 🤔

[@user-rj9qx5dk4r]

Irrelevant. The topic here is addressing whether Israel is an apartheid state. It objectively is. End of discussion.

[@israelinyou2020]

The Israeli Arabs enjoy the best conditions in the middle east and the west that they can have

[@PierreLucSex]

And you enjoy the best comfy lies you are able to

[@VitorEmanuelOliver]

So basically there's no apartheid, but there are some problems. It's funny like the word apartheid is being misused, it's losing all its meaning

[@phyllisbarr4766]

correct

[@zjzr08]

It's sadly even making me wonder if South African apartheid was even that bad...and I don't think I want to think of it as less although I frankly haven't researched about it.

[@VitorEmanuelOliver]

@@zjzr08 it you want to compare how Israel treats it's own Arab citizens vs how South Africa treated their own black citizens, it's obvious South Africa is a lot worse

[@talishabodiashgomel9102]

the fourth Israeli Arab forgot to mention that the reason they don't have good infursraction has more to do with them not paying citiy taxes (Arnuna), and the reason for that is to lower the prices on their homes. I talked to an arab israeli friend that told me how much they paid to build their house (a very big 3 stories house with garden) and it cost 3 times less than a house in a more jewish orainted city or village. about the universy. it is correct that a palestinian from area b like Ramalla cann't learn in an Israeli University some subjects. it is though the fact that in the past they studied in Israel and than build bombs to kill israelis with that knowlage. still they can learn other subjects or study in Jordan. About teaching kids equlity, i was raised to love and respect all, i studied and worked with Israeli Arabs. But ever since the operation when israeli arabs stared to a violent and diedly raits against jews in Israel, it put a stain on the relationshio and less Jews trust them now. Trust betwean Arabs and Jews needs to be rebuild in Israel, than their will be less racisem

[@truthhearit1471]

Not all Palestinians are Muslims

[@ayalaostrovsky9550]

Agree with you on everything

[@talishabodiashgomel9102]

​@@truthhearit1471and? Did I say all Palestinians are Muslims? Those that mean that we need to act differently if it's a Muslim? Wouldn't that be antisemitic?

[@abdusshakoorsaafir3985]

Israelis are racist because they think they are God's chosen people and they believe the non-Jew is subhuman. Stop oppressing Palestinians and you won't have anything to fear!

[@tonznz007]

I love the guys at 9.05 who humorously complained about their women being racists for making them carry their bags to the car!

[@AquaTofana.]

My head is spinning 😂😂😂😂

[@orbenlevi123]

apartheid wife's we all have😆

[@tom2443]

​@@orbenlevi123 my wife is making my life very apartheid

[@phatrix123]

I guess a few generation more we are going to see protest against Male carrying bags for women.

[@Hankblue]

My wife told me we should be separate but equal

[@user-jc6zr4dq5h]

Mohammed from the village of Kana is also confused. There is no land for building in my city either, and I, as a Jew who lives in a city in the center, cannot build a house in the city where I grew up... This is not related to apartheid, it is related to the land reserve that exists in Israel.

[@webmus]

It's amazing how humans can twist reality when talking in front of camera... The guy talking about discrimination in uni, reality is actually the other way around, as Israeli Arabs get accepted to uni with much lower grades by law. The woman talking about racism and guns, is actually working in a Jewish town city council... As can be seen in this video, none of them have real examples of apartheid, but most of them still answered Yes.

[@arlenegojocco7518]

It's guilt.

[@HistoryfortheAges]

As a history professor I often have to explain these ideas. If you are an Arab living IN Israel there is no apartheid. You have rights to vote, serve in parliament, you live side by side with Jews, go to the same schools, hospitals etc. If you are living in what people call the West Bank, you are not under the authority of Israel. You are under the PA. Therefore either way you can't call Israel an "apartheid" state. It is just historically wrong. And don't get me started on the "genocide" lie. I made an entire video debunking that.

[@gabriel3888]

Your logic overlooks the Citizenship laws which apply differently depending on if someone is Arab. Article 2(a) of the Citizenship Law: “Every emigrant under the Law of Return will become a citizen of Israel as a direct result of the return.” However the law doesn't apply to Palestinians: Article 3 of the law also deprives Palestinians who were residents of Palestine prior to 1948 of the right to gain citizenship or residence status in Israel based on conditions designed to deprive the Palestinian refugees of the Right to Return.

[@FactsChecker007]

History Professor??? Seriously? What about the Stateless ID Most Palestinians have as Arabs living in israel? Cant vote! No health care/ Cant travel ! unless making a special Visa! Cant build a house nor fix one. Where do you live? Settlement ? you are privilege that cant see or stopped seeing or just Biased to the bones that Dont care?

[@solvingpolitics3172]

Agreed and then some. The saying: “Show me an allegation you have against Jews and I will show you a crime have committed, says it all.” Separate question: what percentage of teachers teach/open young minds vs. what percentage just try and brainwash them with their leftist politics?

[@solvingpolitics3172]

@@FactsChecker007 Tell us about how Islam has treated blacks and minorities?

[@nextmessi4249]

If there is no apartheid why does the association for civil rights in Israel exist? 😮

[@IsraelMilitaryChannel]

Now try ask Jews the same question in more than 22 Arab states and more than 50 Muslims states if you can find any left.

[@ill3gal1]

They are fine and happy with their Muslim neighbors

[@katherinebot]

If a government is discriminating against its people, that is wrong. This is true in both the case of discrimination against Jews and Arabs. Nobody will defend the forceful deportation of Jews from Muslim nations except those who are depraved, and equally nobody will defend the deportation of Muslims from Israel except those who are depraved. Just because one side does harm does not give the other side a blank check to do the same.

[@marko.rankovic]

Before 1948 or after when 700k Palestinians were ethnically cleansed into a corner?

[@JekaBossJeep]

There are no Jews in Muslim countries! Those who lived once, fled because of a threat to their lives, those who dared to stay were murdered! All of this is documented in history and can be read about. Anyone who says otherwise is brainwasher!

[@MrBeneneb]

I would recommend asking Palestinians in the West Bank.

[@leonardogomes7566]

The guy in the end said that a house is 1.5 million shekels, and it’s super expensive, the price for a house in Jewish places are at least the double, a apartment of 65 square meters in Tel Aviv in ok area, it’s 3.5.

[@adamakaru2683]

I am an Ex-South African, non-Jewish, Christian, or muslim 99% of Arabs don't even know what Apartheid is, but 99% of Americans also don`t know.

[@neoinitiative]

Yeah, way to stereotype!!!

[@alessiananni4681]

I heard that Jewish Israeli have the same problems finding houses..I have the same problems in LA!

[@ArchesBro]

You are missing the subtle point. In Israel the Jews in particular, but also Christians and Muslims refuse to sell land or do business outside of their groups. So if a Muslim wants to live somewhere where the Jews or Christians own everything, they wont be allowed because they discriminate to avoid giving resources to other groups. They all do it, its a toxic effect because of what the Jews have done in Israel historically. In the end the Jews have all the levers of power, military and financial in Israel so they are the main offender, but they all do it and it makes life hard for non-jews in particular

[@toddfulton2280]

Give me some examples... Um, i can't think of any right now, but there lots...

[@marksimons8861]

I dare say folk in South Africa also used to have the same trouble thinking of examples where apartheid affected them or their families. LOL

[@matrimcauthon9804]

@@marksimons8861 I highly doubt that. In South Africa public premises, vehicles and services were segregated by race. There was law that did not allow marrying anyone outside of your race. Blacks were not allowed to attend the same school as white students, and the list goes on.

[@JohnDoe-jw5lf]

@@marksimons8861 you "dare say"? I dare say you give a great example of cognitive dissonance.

[@docorwhatever2168]

@@matrimcauthon9804Apartheid is not just about schools and buses (although that’s somehow still practiced in Israel).

[@xaspirate8060]

@@docorwhatever2168So you keep harping on this -- how about this: IF IF it is an apartheid, it is without doubt THE mildest form of apartheid in the history of mankind.

[@yaafa7801]

Not a single person in this video said anything even close to apartheid.

[@petrograd6109]

so, if I got it right, Netanyahu is now responsible for weapons in Arab villages... Arabs killing Arabs is also an Israeli fault.

[@hsiaowangtzu]

Heaven forbid Arabs ever have any agency... It will always have to be a Jew that got to take the blame, right?

[@eshtrogy6458]

They also give Jews weapons and you don’t see so many Jews killing each other so how in your twisted mind the one responsible here is Israel and not the people who chose to become criminals

[@homerun8953]

Anything regarding security in Arab cities is Israel's police's authority, but it's a known secret that Shin Bet has major involvement in sometimes empowering crime and crime hamulot/personnel. Not to point fingers and say people don't have agency but the state doesn't exactly mind or try and enforce the situation there.

[@iaindcosta]

Most Governments support terrorists with spys e.g. the Afghani groups supported by the CIA to fight the Russians, who later fought in Syria and Azerbaijan

[@ACogloc]

Not only did that guy say it's Israel's fault, it's also apartheid. Get it? Organized crime is apartheid.

[@denseterror539]

How these people describe their “apartheid” is how I and many Christian’s feel like in the Middle East, you feel like you’re discriminated against.

[@ill3gal1]

Are you a Christian living in the Middle East?

[@lordsneed9418]

exactly

[@mohamedhafizh9201]

were you born in the middle east?

[@arimoff]

​@@mohamedhafizh9201were arabs livung in Europe demanding sharia were born there? No, so shove your hypocrisy up your as... Middle East was home to hundreds of ethnicities and religions. Islam slaughtered, occupied and colonized them all. Sit your as.. down. Jews are the endigenous population of the land of Israel. Take your islam and fq off back to your Arabian desert. After 1400 years of jews living opressed, colonized, ra.ped and murdered by islamonazi skum, we owe you nothing. You should be thankful jews are not like arabs... or all arabs would be slaughtered and ra.ped

[@Pure_Boxing]

Probably a settler from a first world country

[@leakeisar4155]

Here is the truth: The share of physicians from the Arab sector entering the medical system in Israel has risen and now accounts for 30% of the new physicians in Israel. The proportion of active physicians who are Arab is approaching their proportion in the population (21%).

[@Leoniela]

I've had this conversation many times with Arab citizens of Israel. Whenever I add the question whether if Israel and the Palestinian Authorities came to a peace agreement whereby their city or village could become part of a palestinian state , not one - not even one - has ever said they would agree to that. That's when they cling to their Israeli ID card. I look forward to the day when there is no more Arab terror, that is the only reason Arabs are held up at airport etc. As 80 percent of the population is Jewish and no Jew has ever blown up a bus or plane, it would mean we would all have to arrive not three hours before our flights but ten! Security is for all our good. The HamasISIS nazis did not differentiate between Jews and Arabs as they murdered everyone they could on 7.10.23.

[@Seanonyoutube]

As an Israeli Jew, I enjoyed hearing their different perspectives.

[@tom2443]

As a non religious Australian, im continually impressed by this channel, and by Israel and it's people. They've fought hard for what they have and what they want, and many countries have done the same. 👍

[@johntu1967]

Are you aware of a bill which allows committees to screen people based on race and reject them from living in villages? Does that actually happen?

[@user-nk6dc2wk6p]

but some i think is just perceptions not really a perspective.

[@shirasteingarten2473]

Same here, super interesting

[@Seanonyoutube]

@@johntu1967 yes it happens unfortunately also in the opposite direction (jews can’t easily live in arab villages) it’s similar to certain gated communities in the US where they want the place to maintain a certain character. Btw it also is true about level of secularity etc not just about jewish or not.

[@anonymousbrowser4448]

regarding the first man's point it's actually the opposite. Arabs get more scholarships on universities as minorities from what i heard And i also get searched a lot in the airport as an Israeli jew (wouldnt call that apartheid though)

[@Seanonyoutube]

It’s nuanced on the one hand. They generally have an easier time going to university, but on the other hand, they have a harder time getting into certain prestigious programs.

[@kingab8893]

It’s not “actually” the opposite if it is something you heard. What’s the full story here? What’s been documented regarding giving away scholarships to Israeli Arabs? Is it for all programs as the other response mentioned?

[@l-uk3xm]

I was searched/questioned for hours in the Munich airport for the Israeli flight. Then in the Ben Gurion International yet again. I am not an Arab or Muslim. Apartheid?

[@ill3gal1]

That’s like saying systemic racism doesn’t exist in America because some black people benefit from affirmative action 🙄

[@shaharfetman9275]

@@kingab8893Arabs actually get preferred at Universities. This guy isn’t Israeli

[@oxanacasian4353]

As a tourist, a white Christian from Europe, visiting Israel more than 4 times, I am being treated with suspicion by the border police every time I enter Israel, they are doing additional checks, asking additional questions which makes you feel awkward. Only recently I understood why.. this is because of the internal security and numerous terrorist attacks. I understand the Arabs and I feel very sorry for what they are going through, though, can we just ignore the terrorism threat in Israel?

[@fuentesdaniel77]

Thank you Corey, you are very brave to keep doing this and asking these kinds of questions.

[@Rinapolina]

The guy who said yes and then went to speak about how Muslim towns are not as nice as Jewish towns, maybe invest into your community. It’s not apartheid. We have poor communities and wealthy communities in America, is this apartheid too?

[@zarinaadi04]

He makes no sense. Seems like he was waiting for someone to ask him that just so he can let off some steam and speak from an emotional point of view rather than logic and fact base. Arabs who live in Israel are the first ones who get accepted into nursing school, the jews only get accepted if there is enough place for them. All the hospitals are loaded with arab nurses so saying that they have no rights - who are they trying to fool? Arabs that live in the west bank on the other hand may feel this "apartheid" but that is just common sense because they are not part of Israel. If someone lives in Poland, wouldnt they feel "apart" from Belarus?

[@nuklearboysymbiote]

Redlining in the US was pretty much a racist thing to start with

[@RichardWilliams-bt7ef]

He literally complained about how the Jewish people build nicer towns, and Muslims build shitty towns. As if it’s not their own fault. Then he complained about how they send their kids to crappy schools, instead of nicer schools that are nearby, because they need to “control the narrative.” As if that’s not their fault. And then he complained about how Arabs kill other Arabs, and sometimes they use Israeli weapons, so that’s obviously Israel’s fault also. 😂 Unreal.

[@hanna319]

They avoid finishing constructions to escape the taxes. That's why their houses always look unfinished... It's funny that they blame us for this too

[@easy8690]

How can they invest when they are under attack?

[@MrAkaacer]

That guy complaining about crime in his community is stupid. You're blaming Jews for Arabs committing crimes against Arabs? I'm pretty sure if the Israeli police go in to crack down on crime, you'll be complaining about police brutality, corruption, racism, etc...

[@redtailedhawk663]

Blaming the state of Israel for not protecting the peace inside their borders. Unless you're saying that Israel and Jews are the same thing. In which case, what are Arab Israelis? An oxymoron?

[@no8986]

That's not the point of what he was saying, the cameraman was talking about Netanyahu funding a certain bill to increase funding for police but the guy was saying that that's purely to protect Jews and not to decrease overall crime.

[@ginette84]

Exactly, we have the same situation between cities in our province. In my city, we have pools, children parks, libraries, more policemen, nice rural roads etc. In the city few miles from us, they don't have much recreational facilities, less policemen, lots of holes in rural roads. Etc It depends on the amount of municipal taxes you pay. We pay double while in the next city, people pay less taxes, they get less services. Some services are the same quality for all the province (health system, water and electricity facilities) Inadequate police services are common in each country, it doesn't depend on your race. I don't blame them because I wouldn't want to do their job. Examples: (1) We were robbed in Mexico, we tough we would get help because there were policemen in each street corner. But NO, we didn't, even if we showed them the location where the stolen phone was. (2) In our own country, we showed them the location of the stolen car, no immediate help because stolen cars are not FIRST priority. We had to "steel" it back.

[@ill3gal1]

Actually it’s a known fact the IDF sells weapons to gangs to encourage more crime. They love causing dissent among Arabs

[@7470038]

@@redtailedhawk663 um el-Fahm, there was a murder, the police came to investigate, and to interview the witnesses, everyone is silent, and how to help them if the witnesses themselves are without eggs.

Corey: perhaps it would be more useful/interesting for your viewers if the questions were a lot simpler. For instance: "Do your kids go to a public (Jewish) school or Arab school?" - "Is it by choice or mandated?"; "Do you work with Jews?" - "Do they get different benefits?"; "Did you serve in the IDF?" - "Did you have the option to do so?"; etc.

[@Itush5]

According to their understanding, apartheid is not getiing into universities because it is difficult to be admitted to prestigious universities

[@ultra5057]

Apartheid is an Afrikaans word. There's no such thing as apartheid in Israel.

[@mashkanyc]

Maybe. But we used to have that or something similar in the US. Separate schools and restaurants for the” blacks” and “whites”

[@rowboyto]

Zionism is a earopean ideology not a Jewish one. So the earopean converts should go back home. Am I right

[@eli_here]

The south african government, the country that literally just beat apartheid and experts humanitarians and researchers disagree :)

[@alifleih]

"Sugar is an Arabic word. There's no such thing as sugar in Israel."

[@ultra5057]

​@@alifleih Wrong. 'Sugar' is a Sanskrit word.

[@tsopuaifa]

Whatever it is it is not apartheid.

[@user-rj9qx5dk4r]

😂😂😂 Israel is objectively an apartheid state. Anyone disagreeing with that is either ignorant or purposely lying. To be specific, Israel practices apartheid over both Israeli non-Jews and PRIMARILY Palestinians in the Occupied West Bank. Palestinians in the West Bank live under the PA to the extent of minor civil authority. The actual authority over the west bank which controls trade, construction, utilities, travel, freedom of movement, and “security” is Israel. One authority, two systems for different areas = apartheid. It’s as simple as that.

[@AbdulelahAhmed-nu6zz]

Go to West Bank and east Jerusalem and you will see

[@vien111]

West bank is under PA not Israeli government

[@atolz1352]

​@@AbdulelahAhmed-nu6zzyou live there? And what instance to be precise? Just curious

[@aykutlondon4784]

​​How about Palestinians not allowed to travel down certain roads that Jews are allowed to walk down or different roads for Jewish settlers. Or checkpoints only for Palestinians, or walls and watch towers. And the main one, the lack of the Palestinian right to self determination. I.e no Palestinian state​@@atolz1352

[@ferrokkkk7032]

Question to you Gil! Do you have the impression people answer your questions honestly and without fear? Particularly in this context?

[@user-xt8pv3he3m]

I love how they say, yes I could assimilate into Israel but I choose not to, and then they accuse Israel of apartheid

[@esfiryelin9306]

It is interesting, but in medical schools of Tel Aviv and Beersheva universities 70-75 % Arab students. Is it apartheid and for whom?

[@dogbert52]

Apartheid against the fully serving je wish citizens.....

[@fatimatuzzahra4036]

For occupied people of Palestine in West Bank and Gaza. This guy is interviewing the Arab citizens who are kept in minority by keeping majority locked up in West bank and gaza.

[@BRCorp-rt3eb]

@@fatimatuzzahra4036 gaza is a different entity tho our soldiers left it..of course we wouldnt let them study here are you out of your mind? fun fact hamas planted spies across the south..so yeah it does makes sense on why we wouldnt let them!

[@YoYo-xz6ql]

@@BRCorp-rt3eb You sound like an israeli bot. Indoctrinated much ?

[@martinfernandezmartinez2332]

The ASK project is amazing!

[@jimmyTooFreshh]

It’s just confirmation bias for Zionist propaganda

[@MrStuv]

First dude: Is in Ramallah where Israelis do not live and get murdered by the residents if accidentally entering. He was lying about the university and job things. Actually Arabs have better acceptance requirements and saved places for them only. That's a complete lie. Also arabs are common in every good working place, including as doctors, lawyers, judges, etc. I've never heard about the airport thing and I am skeptic about it, especially after he lied about the rest. Also, What's an apartheid? He is not an Israeli citizen. ofc he won't have the same rights as us, but an Israeli Arab has better rights than I do as an Israeli Jew. Second lady: Afraid of Jews with guns. Are you planning on attacking them? why do you afraid of that? It has nothing to do with discrimination. Third guy: God bless you my brother I wish everyone would raise their kids like you do. You give me hope. Fourth dude: LIAR. Where I live, we the residents pay additional taxes that go straight to the settlement and our democratically chosen representatives choose what to use this money for. The government doesn't take care of us more than they do in Arab cities. Also, he is free to not indoctrinate his children with hate and send them to the exact school that he finds better. That's not an apartheid. Also he claims that IDF soldiers sell their guns to Arabs who then use them for violence instead of admitting that his friends are criminals who steal guns and are violent, just like himself. I'm tired of those liars already.

[@ruthlieberman7157]

Lying is an Arab pastime. Let’s remind the whole world, many in the Arab community don’t pay taxes but get all the benefits, unlike in the rest of the Arab world. But ok… tell me how you feel when the entire Muslim world wants us gone.

[@fadius17]

The guy at 15:35 explained it. It’s a discrimination based on land ownership. It’s been a state policy since the creation of the state. The result is Palestinians citizens of Israel are 20% of Israel’s population yet leave on less than 3% of the land. The West Bank is the definition of an apartheid system.

[@xaspirate8060]

Not necessarily. DO they also choose to live in same tight community? like a high rise perhaps vs buying house that maybe they cannot afford? And instead of making it a systemic issue, maybe in some cases it is a landlord who does not want to rent out to bidder for whatever reasons... again, nothing to do with apartheid or outward discrimination for that matter. Often, demographics aside, some people you just know would make shtty neighbors.

[@fadius17]

@@xaspirate8060 I understand what you are saying but there are municipal laws that allow jewish communities to reject residency applications from arabs for no other reason. Since the creation of the state of Israel, it has been a policy to restrict land ownership to arabs. This is why the vast majority of land is state owned and owned by jewish funds and arabs are not allowed to own this land. They can have residency rights but not ownership rights if that makes sense. They can essentially be tenants of the state. In 1947-48, the jewish militias had a premeditated policy of ethnically cleansing surrounding towns and villages, and either pushing them out to neighboring countries or, like the 150k that stayed and are now citizens, to push the into the couple cities that were not expelled like Nazareth in the Galilee. Hence the density and lack of adequate infrastructure.. This is also why Israel has declared that ONLY jews have the right to self determination in Israel. As Netanyahu declared: "Israel is not a state for all its citizens." I still do not considered there to be an apartheid system within Israel, but just discrimination. However, it cannot be disputed that there is one in the west bank. And a severe one in that.

[@xaspirate8060]

@@fadius17 Thank you for the detailed response...it seems honest. The problem I have is conflicting opinions, esp. re: West Bank day to day life sounds so different depending on party reporting. One day I hope to sort it all out. Yeah, sure😏

[@fadius17]

@@xaspirate8060 no problem :)

[@thk929]

Oh for crying out loud - they have no idea what apartheid really is!

[@opportunisticobserver]

did you not listen,,,jews can walk around with an ak47 in public but if you are arab you cant.. how is that equel?

[@bunb8541]

​@@opportunisticobserverdude what the hell are you talking about.

[@samferrell7757]

​​​ no you clearly aren't educated on the matter, people who served in the army can apply for a handgun after, soldiers walk around with Aks, any Arab that wants to join the army and apply for a handgun can do that, but Arabs are exempt from military service so if anything they have legal advantages that regular Israeli citizens do not.

[@guyeshel9316]

@@opportunisticobserver Wе don't carry AK's here

[@Xoxo27285]

@@bunb8541I can send u pictures if u dont believe, jewish men and women can go out with their rifle on everywhere, i seen them carrying it to the cenima, shopping places etc..

[@masea2]

Is there any Jews in Saudi Arabia ?

[@RealityFirstl]

Ramalla, where he lives, is within the palestinien authority. It is where he voted and where his government (not Israel government)sit.

[@ginette84]

Dicrimination is everywhere in all countries : - Between English, French and First Nations - Between two cities in the same province; or - Between two districts in the same city We have the same issues with our properties, even if you buy a property, it still belongs to the municipality. They impose their regulation, change the building codes. You have to get permission to increase the size of your home. In my case I can't. In the case of a fire, I am allowed to rebuild the same size only if the foundations are still there otherwise it has to be smaller because the city has grown.

[@OrangeHealia]

Exactly! I get called names and was told to leave country by Germans & Spanish being Slovene

[@bigby7712]

You people keep comparing what you do with stuff happen 100s years ago. “But what about ww2, what about Americans colonialism, what about arab colonialism” yeah this is not the medieval era anymore its 2024

[@desertoasis255]

Red herring

[@donbarnard82]

Yes, I see what looks like discrimination, much like what exists in the US, for instance. But there is a difference when a nation is defined as Jewish, there's an implied discrimination in the national identity, so I think it's going to be hard to ever get past it. In the US, there are white nationalist forces, but there are people here oppressed to that. In Israel, on the other hand, that sort of thing is embraced.

[@opportunisticobserver]

difference is jews can walk around with a AK47 but arabs cant...wake up

[@diogok9459]

Many of the things said happens in my country, and we are not even arabs, people from different states of the same country are treated different in some small day to day contact. Also, in my country we can't build new houses as we wish, we need to request and wait if there will be an approval otherwise they will demolish if you build it. If crimes happen, usually is because many in the neighborhood don't want to go to police to testify, which also happens in my country, which leads to the criminal no being caught or held in prison. One good thing about this interview, is that apparently everyone can go to university, in many countries the rich gets the priority, and also from the majority interviewed all israeli-arabs could find a job in Israel. Its sad how things are now, I wonder how many years will be needed for things to be closer to daily life of the days this interview was made.

[@ahmedtoufahi5198]

When Amnesty International and other relevant international organizations talk about apartheid, they are specifically referring to the West Bank, where a military and judicial system is implemented to control Palestinians and keep them in their "authorized zones." A Palestinian there has to be careful about where they go, as they might be harassed by settlers or taken to court. NB: Israel controls the westbank and is implementing a race and nationality based system of segregation and persecution so it qualifies as an apertheid regardless of wether the westbank in legally an israeli territory or not. I invite anyone interested in the apartheid of the West Bank (even if they refuse to see it as apartheid) to check Amnesty International's report on the matter. The soldiers practically exist solely to protect settlers, and assaults and bullying by settlers are often tolerated. What is happening to Israeli Arabs does not qualify as apartheid, and no relevant international group claims that. Misrepresenting the accusation of apartheid that Israel receives as an Israeli Arab vs. non-Arab Israeli issue is hurting the cause and obscuring the actual harassment that most of the West Bank's Palestinians live through.

[@rolboler5191]

THIS

[@476429]

Gee, I wonder why they would question Palestinians more before boarding planes? But it's not just Palestinians. I'm from the southern U.S., and I got pulled out of line at the Tel Aviv airport and questioned heavily. I had never been interrogated before, but that was pretty much an interrogation. I have no idea why they picked me, and it was like they were looking for ways to trip me up. That's just Israeli security. They take it very, very seriously.

[@LizA0488]

I was questioned by British security in London. The Agent placed a sticker on my passport and later was in the departure lounge and removed it.

[@billTO]

On an El AL flight Heathrow-Tel Aviv, I had a nail file taken from my toiletry case. NP. I want to be safe!

[@nuklearboysymbiote]

psst… that's racism

[@skontheroad]

But they will let you go thru with a bottle of water! And if you ask if you need to toss it, they'll say, "Why? Don't be silly, it's just water!" But, otherwise, yes! It is called security, and we take it very, very seriously (Don't you want them to??)! Coming or going, they will pull you out of the line if you are not Jewish, or don't look the part, and ask additional questions. Nowadays, they know the entire story of every passenger before the plane even lands, or everyone gets to the airport to depart home! After 9/11, I saw an interview on Meet the Press or 60 Minutes or something, and it was with the Head of Israeli Sec at the time, and they were discussing stereotyping, so to speak. He said, "If everyone was reporting a criminal on the run who was a 5 ft female who had blond hair and blue eyes, would you be out looking for a 6ft black man?? Obv, that sounds crazy, right? And yet, almost 25 years older, we still do things the same way. And Israel still does it better! (BUT for the literally countless times I have been there, they still question me when we leave! It's nothing personal!)

[@xaspirate8060]

@@billTO Good attitude. Imagine the many on the pages here that would have raised holy hell over a $1 item.

[@denseterror539]

The last two guys’ problems happen on a daily basis where I live in the Middle East as a Christian, we literally have villages evacuated so that Muslims can come in, they creep their lands by the meter every year and generation after generation, they get closer and closer.

[@yasmeenmomani1743]

Really, where do you live

[@Thenoobestgirl]

That's not what he said tho...

[@Pure_Boxing]

Which fake area is this

[@desertoasis255]

Where

[@denseterror539]

@@yasmeenmomani1743 Iraq

[@em-sf7me]

Does this "Apartheid" also extend to Circassians, Armenians, Druze, Samaritans, Bedouins, Thai, Russians, and any other ethnic group I may have missed?

[@EuropeanQoheleth]

This has been one of the most interesting videos yet.

[@draoi99]

Were these people all living in the West Bank? Do they have Israeli citizenship?

[@dszfc]

Israeli citizens, its in the title

[@shainazion4073]

​@@dszfcNot All. Ramallah (the first man) is under the Palestinian Authority, not Israel.

[@user-fq5px2yy4l]

Arab Israelis are allowed in the West Bank, Jewish Israelis are not permitted to enter

[@dszfc]

@@shainazion4073 he is from Taibe, he was at the time of the recording visiting Ramallah, but if you see the subtitles at the start it says Taibe, the title of the video says arab israelis, thus he wouldn’t interview someone who is from Ramallah since they are Palestinians not arab Israelis

[@rocioceciliairibarren77]

Really? What passport they have?

[@RS-fn7wm]

Its as simple as that- without lies Islam dies.

[@ce3547]

That"s not an apartheid, that's predjudice. If the Arab /Jewish relationship was good until an attack by Arabs toward Jews, and the relationship changes, that's fear not apartheid.

[@pandapower5902]

Dude… the people in Gaza haven’t been able to vote or even leave the area freely for YEARS!! Their resources taken away. Land, water, etc. That is apartheid!

[@arlenegojocco7518]

It's guilt. After all, who always starts the violence?

[@abdusshakoorsaafir3985]

A prejudiced legal system is apartheid

[@YoYo-xz6ql]

Maybe you shouldnt take peoples land ?

[@noyes8836]

when you are so "oppressed" that you don´t even know what apartheid means lmao

[@Offa7a]

Go steal lands on the West Bank.

[@afRolowkey]

Sounds like slavery era….you know when they took Africans from Africa and changed their language as well as kept them from being informed and educated so yeah they probably don’t know what apartheid means due to lack of equal education for Arabs in Israel….

[@YoYo-xz6ql]

Its not a normal word for non native speakers to know lol. Hush and be quiet - report to netanyahu like the good dog you are.

[@noyes8836]

@@YoYo-xz6ql lmao. you guys all use the same words that you are being teached by uni professors and ideologues.

[@YoYo-xz6ql]

@@noyes8836 ironic how you are speaking about linguistics, when you lack the ability to spell. Secondly bootlicker, we were not "teached" and many in gaza and Palestine did not go to university. Maybe you should get your "ideologues" checked out boy. Hope you are burning when you read this.

[@tomerbin]

Just visit hospitals in Israel and see how many arab doctors are there. By the way, for a Jew it is much harder to get in to university then for an arab. the qualifications are completely different and not for the benefit of the Jew. If you'll know the arab culture you wont ask this kind of question while their faces are not covered because they can get in real trouble for saying the truth.

[@user-rj9qx5dk4r]

😂😂😂 It doesn’t matter how many Arab doctors there are… don’t break your back doing all this mental gymnastics Israel is objectively an apartheid state. Anyone disagreeing with that is either ignorant or purposely lying. Palestinians in the West Bank live under the PA to the extent of minor civil authority. The actual authority over the west bank which controls trade, construction, utilities, travel, freedom of movement, and “security” is Israel. One authority, two systems for different areas = apartheid. It’s as simple as that.

[@dogbert52]

Sounds like anti je wish abartheid

[@Xoxo27285]

The guy in the video literally said, there is not a single hospital in any arab city or village, so if an israeli arab doctor want to work israel isnt doing him a favor, he worked his ass for it

[@dogbert52]

​@@Xoxo27285if the yahood dont give free icecream to the master religion = abartheid Yes? Thats the trick?

[@LionOfBabylon00]

So you are saying that a nation built for specific people are becoming racist towards their own people ?

[@nurkkr]

someone tell Corey about Jizya, teqiyya and what is a dhimmi.. dude's clueless

[@macmiah5747]

lol. I suggest you don’t read the Bible 😂

[@zjzr08]

​@@macmiah5747The Old Testament nor the New Testament allow sinning for the faith...you must apologize for doing that.

[@macmiah5747]

@@zjzr08 so, killing children and infants, and don’t forget the cattle and donkey, is not sinning? 😱

[@sonjamarx7144]

Me as a visitor went through security all these years and I saw that everybody was treated the same. I understood why they do it because of all the attacks and they must be awake. I was in Israel from 17 April till 2 May and I saw Arabs everywhere, sitting openly with their produvts to sell without any trouble. Even shops in the Old City have mostly Arab owners, so thats so steange that I didnot see them begging or hiding away and saw them still carry on like in the past

[@jameswitt108]

Might be because you're probably of a lighter shade?😒

[@y.l7455]

​@@jameswitt108 Most Jews and Arabs in Israel are of the same skin colour and skin colour has little to do with the Israeli society, we're not Americans.

[@jameswitt108]

@@y.l7455 Sure there's also religious affiliation supremacy and the usual tribalism but don't kid me bro/broess there's also discrimination based on skin shade.

[@y.l7455]

@@jameswitt108 No, there's not. I'm Ashkenazi Jew myself, my younger sister is literally black(her mother is from Uganda). I don't need to believe you when I see all reality on the ground myself.

[@UteHeggenTranswidowHeals]

The second woman was not covering her hair. She was wearing a jogging suit. Does she realize how she'd have to dress in Gaza or Tehran or Doha?

[@adamdernis]

I expect she does, and she seems pretty happy to be in Israel all things considered. Just because life would be worse on the other side of the border does not mean that things couldn't use improvement in Israel.

[@MsBhappy]

She seems like the opposite type of person who would teach their children to hate Israel. I'm sure she knows her privilege as a woman and freedom offered to her in Israel over neighbouring countries. She's lovely.

[@prouddanyxo]

Have you seen how they dress in Gaza? There’s churches in Gaza. Or how they put Christmas trees in hotels and shopping centres around Christmas time stop lying

[@MsBhappy]

@@prouddanyxo You are dangerously ignorant of their laws. 70% of women in Gaza reported being abused and 63% of men said that women should endure abuse to keep a family today. They attempted to impose forced hijab. Many schools and universities are gender segregated. Two free UN reports online: 1. UN Women (2018). International Men and Gender Equality Survey (IMAGES) Palestine Report. 2. UNFPA (2018). Gender, Justice and the Law. Christian churches have been b0mbed/set on fire, and harassed continuously and authorities do not investigate. One church bus was also stolen and authorities didn't care.

[@truthhearit1471]

​@@prouddanyxo Christians in gaza have it very hard.

[@Government-EconomicsTeacher]

So ask the Arab Israelis if they would rather live in the Palestinian area or Israeli. That should be a pretty clear answer as to who is fairer, better etc.

[@ori1676]

He already did it , it is on his channel

[@jaemackie3474]

yeah how more ungrateful could they get

[@leorasotto9587]

A Jew in Israel would not be able to live in an arab village....not only an Arab in all Jewish villages..... The questions should not be only one sided.

[@user-xt8pv3he3m]

I can't believe some of the answers. Arab villages have autonomy over their budgets, as do Jewish villages. If one council squanders money and another doesn't, that's not apartheid