Are 400+ TV Shows Happening In The Same Universe? | Idea Channel | PBS Digital Studios

  Рет қаралды 171,452

PBS Idea Channel

PBS Idea Channel

Күн бұрын

Viewers like you help make PBS (Thank you 😃) . Support your local PBS Member Station here: to.pbs.org/don...
Tommy Westphall Universe Hypothesis!
Tweet us! bit.ly/pbsideac...
Idea Channel Facebook! bit.ly/pbsideac...
Talk about this episode on reddit! bit.ly/pbsideac...
Idea Channel IRC! bit.ly/pbsideac...
Email us! pbsideachannel [at] gmail [dot] com
Is it possible that over 400 television shows all take place in the same universe? Every other week for the next few weeks, Mike is going to tackle theories from different fandoms, and he starts out with one of the most far reaching fan theories of them all: the Tommy Westphall Universe Hypothesis. If the entire series of St. Elsewhere was dreamed up by a young autistic boy, does this include every other role the actors have played? Could Firefly and Castle take place in the same world? Let us know what you think in the comments!
---------------------------------------­­---------------------------
Check out our awesome T-Shirts!!
store.dftba.com...
Designed by:
artsparrow.com/
---------------------------------------­­---------------------------
Last week's Trigger Warnings episode:
• What's The Deal With C...
---------------------------------------­­---------------------------
Tweet of the week:
/ 645990521526161408
---------------------------------------­­---------------------------
Rescued Comments:
pastebin.com/wj...
This Video is WRONG:
• Video
---------------------------------------­­---------------------------
ASSET LINKS:
1:37 St. Elsewhere - Series Finale: The Tommy Westphall Snow Globe Ending
• Video
1:58 Dwayne McDuffie
en.wikipedia.o...
www.slushfactor...
4:27 Tommy Westphall Universe Masterpost
thetommywestph...
6:15 Funny Surfer Dude
• Funny Surfer Dude
7:47 Moviebob WORLDS WITHIN WORLDS (The Big Picture)
• WORLDS WITHIN WORLDS (...
---------------------------------------­­---------------------------
Music:
"Europe" by Roglok (www.roglok.net)
"Level 5" by Room for the Homeless (bit.ly/10N0Ykm)
"Bouncy Castle" by Roglok (www.roglok.net)
":P" by Roglok (www.roglok.net)
"Squarehead" by Roglok (www.roglok.net)
"Number Cruncher" by Roglok (www.roglok.net)
"Little Birthday Acid" by Roglok (www.roglok.net)
"Topskore" by Roglok (www.roglok.net)
"Anti Vanishing Spray" by Roglok (www.roglok.net)
"Tarty Prash" by Roglok (www.roglok.net)
"Carry on Carillon" by Roglok (www.roglok.net)
"Uptown Tennis Club" by Roglok (www.roglok.net)
"Squarehead" by Roglok (www.roglok.net)
"Dream Of Autumn" by Night Shift Master
/ dj-darkmatter-
"Insert Toy For Coin" by Eatme (eatme.pro/music/)
"Dizor" by Outsider
www.jamendo.co...
"Lets go back to the rock" by Outsider
www.jamendo.co...
"Something like this" by Outsider
www.jamendo.co...
---------------------------------------­­---------------------------
Written and hosted by Mike Rugnetta (@mikerugnetta)
(who also has a podcast! Reasonably Sound: bit.ly/1sCn0BF)
Made by Kornhaber Brown (www.kornhaberbr...)

Пікірлер: 850
@GaaradancepartyX
@GaaradancepartyX 8 жыл бұрын
Funnily enough, this would make a great idea for a tv show. Like one person realizes he is being imagined by Tommy Westphall. And then travels between universes to do...things.
@twilightman2816
@twilightman2816 6 жыл бұрын
Some cartoons have done this for one episode (or special). Kim Possible found herself travelling from one "faux" show to another when Drakken and Shego created some weapon that would do that. Timmy Turner (Fairly Odd Parents) also had a full-length TV movie where the characters were hopping from one show to another. Then there's that John Ritter movie where his character was also hopping from one show to another (and yes, he found himself very briefly on a show with two "familiar looking" women). --------------- kzbin.info/www/bejne/r5S5lKioq7eMp7s
@attackofthecopyrightbots
@attackofthecopyrightbots 5 жыл бұрын
Thats basically what ready player one was and it was shit so no after that i dont think it can be done well
@vincente3898
@vincente3898 5 жыл бұрын
Mr. Robot Season 4 teaser kzbin.info/www/bejne/naOleI2jq8p9idU
@raidenstark315
@raidenstark315 4 жыл бұрын
That would be expensive
@johnroscoe2406
@johnroscoe2406 4 жыл бұрын
To kill Tommy Westphall.
@OperationSpider
@OperationSpider 6 жыл бұрын
I'm here after the whole "MCU is empty video"
@connorwhitaker8578
@connorwhitaker8578 6 жыл бұрын
OperationSpider same. Cause I’m an I love Lucy fan and when he mentioned it I was like wtf
@coldaddysupreme2956
@coldaddysupreme2956 5 жыл бұрын
Lol what a shitshow
@donaldwestfall6143
@donaldwestfall6143 5 жыл бұрын
Same. xd
@twig1012
@twig1012 4 жыл бұрын
Same
@calw.9373
@calw.9373 4 жыл бұрын
Terrible video but i’m glad he introduced it to me.
@NerdSyncProductions
@NerdSyncProductions 9 жыл бұрын
I once made a fan theory that Stan Lee is actually playing a little-known DC character in all of his Marvel movie cameos. Started out as a joke, but now I'm convinced. Haha
@jamesgibson4275
@jamesgibson4275 9 жыл бұрын
he's the Impossible Man!!!!! ooooh good one!
@crazyjohnb22
@crazyjohnb22 9 жыл бұрын
nope, he's the watcher
@crazyjohnb22
@crazyjohnb22 9 жыл бұрын
that's a real theory online. look it up
@NerdSyncProductions
@NerdSyncProductions 9 жыл бұрын
crazyjohnb22 I know it is. I made a video about that theory, and I don't really believe it to be true. There's not a ton of evidence to support it.
@crazyjohnb22
@crazyjohnb22 9 жыл бұрын
+NerdSync ohh wow, your pretty big as a youtuber my bad.
@kev3d
@kev3d 6 жыл бұрын
Are 400+ TV Shows Happening In The Same Universe? Yes, in our universe, as shows.
@GaiashKetoji
@GaiashKetoji 9 жыл бұрын
This theory actually inspired me to find a connection between Gravity Falls and Steven Universe. In Gravity Falls a pen, clipboard and mug with a Mystery Shack question mark on it are sucked into a portal > In Rick and Morty these items fall out of a portal > In The Simpsons Rick and Morty crash into the Simpsons during a couch gag > In Family Guy's crossover episode The Simpsons Guy the Griffins and Simpsons are both in a court with Fred Flintstone as the judge > In The Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy Fred Flintstone is defrosted from a block of ice in Billy's back yard > In Steven Universe Uncle Grandpa has a list of other Cartoon Network characters he's visited including Billy and Mandy
@Serje1227
@Serje1227 9 жыл бұрын
+Mathew Gibbons (Gaiash) Don't think you finished your comment there
@junglehero1274
@junglehero1274 9 жыл бұрын
+Mathew Gibbons (Gaiash) Actually, you can connect the two a lot quicker, as Dipper, Mabel, and Connie all appear in the background in the anime short Little Witch Academia 2.
@GaiashKetoji
@GaiashKetoji 9 жыл бұрын
Junglehero127 Those are more of reference designs than the actual ones though.
@junglehero1274
@junglehero1274 9 жыл бұрын
Not really. They look exactly like the ones from the actual shows so I think it counts
@GaiashKetoji
@GaiashKetoji 9 жыл бұрын
Junglehero127 No they look similar but aren't exactly the same. The colours are completely different for one thing. The Dipper lookalike has red hair, the Mabel lookalike has black hair and the Connie lookalike has lighter skin. It's a cool nod to the shows but too different to count.
@AlexLusth
@AlexLusth 9 жыл бұрын
I love the fan theory that Joel schumachers batman movies are actual movies inside of the Tim Burton movie franchise several years after batman retired. thats why they are so over the top and silly, because thats what movies would be like in Tim Burtons Gotham.
@megarandom
@megarandom 4 жыл бұрын
This idea appeals to me. Very good.
@WTFisTingispingis
@WTFisTingispingis 3 жыл бұрын
I like this Theory.
@vashtanerada3701
@vashtanerada3701 9 жыл бұрын
The idea that Calvin and Hobbes is a prequel to Fight Club shot through me like a bolt of lightning, never before have I heard a statement that has made so much sense. The beauty of that concept instantly brought tears to my eyes and I could only question how I did not see it, how something so tangibly obvious could have gone unknown. Thank you, truly thank you for prompting this moment of realization and I'm looking forward to the rest of your series on fan theories.
@Gnoggin
@Gnoggin 9 жыл бұрын
That is a VERY excellent, and I find spot-on explanation of fan-theories.
@firaswaffle
@firaswaffle 2 жыл бұрын
dude never gonna find you here so im gonna ask you. Can you make pokemon video about pokemon with unrealistic weight for the pokemon. please.
@ShawnRavenfire
@ShawnRavenfire 9 жыл бұрын
Kramer from "Seinfeld" appeared on an episode of "Mad About You," but in an episode of "Seinfeld," George was watching "Mad About You" on television, which means that "Seinfeld" and "Mad About You" both exist in the same universe, and at the same time, don't exist in the same universe. This also means that every show that ever crossed over with either of these shows (such as "The Dick Van Dyke Show" or "Friends") becomes part of the paradox. Have I blown your mind?
@MathAndComputers
@MathAndComputers 9 жыл бұрын
+Shawn Ravenfire Unless, perhaps, if "Mad About You" was a documentary or reality TV show in that shared universe. Would that work?
@maduinargentus5878
@maduinargentus5878 9 жыл бұрын
+Shawn Ravenfire Kramer could've won a competition or some such and gotten to act as himself in "Mad about you".
@scribejay
@scribejay 9 жыл бұрын
+Shawn Ravenfire Similarly on The Simpsons Matt Groening is famous for having made Futurama while multiple pieces of evidence confirm that The Simpsons existed in Futurama's past.
@michaelberg9348
@michaelberg9348 9 жыл бұрын
+Shawn Ravenfire Actually, the first half of this points to the main issue i have with the suggested scope of the hypothesis. To what extend are we talking about characters/locations/props made up by Tommy and to what extend are we talking about characters/locations/props Tommy just happens to have heard of. example: is Dr. 'appears in homicide' ever referred in that series as having worked in st. elsewhere (which according to its own ending never existed) or shown to exist, but not be a doctor, post-twist in st elsewhere. If neither, it would be entirely possible for Tommy to have imagined this doctor working in st elsewhere after having seen that particular homicide-episode. (it would limit the scope of Tommy's imagination but keep the 'it means that show also didn't happen'-impact as i doubt the name and face of the doctor would ever have hit the news (allowing tommy to get the character from tv, while still being 'real') ) The cigarette-brand example and in bobs video 'weyland yutani' could be bi-directionally decoupled. Simply because Tommy imagined someone smoking a brand he has heard of (instead of made up) doesn't devalue anyone/thing else smoking the same stuff. Interesting detail about the buffy-verse, connection. The Buffy-verse itsself is also implied to be a figment of imagination, of Buffy's imagination to be exact. (In season 6 iirc) Buffy spends parts of an episode in a mental institution, where she went to after spotting her first vampire (around the time of the movie, predating the series), doubting which world is actually real. While an explanation is given within the buffy-verse for this mental lapse (stung by a demon whose poison has such effects), not only did that previous mental-institution visit happen (in either version) but more importantly, the 'real'-verse option is shown to continue after Buffy decided to believe the Buffy-verse and (as a result) goes complete catatonic in 'real'-verse. (The diagnosis of this state being irreversable is shown, while if it was all the effect of the demon-poison, that world should have ceased to exist the moment she collapsed there) So no, 'Kramer playing the role of Kramer in mad about you' did not blow my mind, these things happen in a world completely imagined by a girl who can't communicate with the outside world in any way. Especially if she herself has been made up by a 10-year old boy. :P Slightly more serious (hopefully only slightly), such 'the universe might not actually be as big as the 'degrees of separation'-approach might imply'-details also hold for your paradox-verse. Not to mention the detail George would probably have no problem calling Kramer a fictional character. Hell, i wouldn't be surprised if Kramer would believe him. (might even watch the 'mad about you' episode he guest-roled in by winning a contest and consider that 'proof George was right about him'') That having been said, one thing your example does prove. the 'looking into fan-theories can be fun'-statement. (off to check the calvin/hobbs fightclub-prequel theory)
@ShawnRavenfire
@ShawnRavenfire 9 жыл бұрын
Similarly, there was a similar episode of Deep Space Nine where Captain Sisko is a writer creating the Star Trek universe (which the other writers suggested would end with finding out that it was a dream), and later finds himself in a mental institution having become obsessed with the story. He later finds out that the mental institution was a "false vision" created by the Pah Wraiths. Charmed also had Piper wake up in a mental hospital having imagined being a witch, but similarly, it was an illusion created by the demons to trick her into renouncing her powers. After thinking about Kramer a little more, I remembered that in the show, they were turning Seinfeld's life into a "show about nothing," where another guy was going to play Kramer. Of course, Kramer is himself based on a real person (Kenny Kramer). So Seinfeld may have created a sort of sit-com-inception crossing all universes including ours.
@relt1554
@relt1554 9 жыл бұрын
I like doing this sort of thing with KZbinrs. Who has done collabs with each other and seeing how big the circle of friends get. Also this sounds like the whole 'six degrees away from' theory that says that you know some one who knows someone who knows someone who... knows any person in the world.
@pbsideachannel
@pbsideachannel 9 жыл бұрын
+Robert Trone Does it make it more or less complicated that me, Wheezy and Michael from VSauce are all actually the same person?
@relt1554
@relt1554 9 жыл бұрын
+PBS Idea Channel Oh! Now it makes so much more sense! Thanks now some annoying loose ends are tied up.
@LazyMasterGamer
@LazyMasterGamer 9 жыл бұрын
+Robert Trone someone needs to map every KZbinr and link everyone ^^
@relt1554
@relt1554 9 жыл бұрын
LazyMasterGamer That would be amazing
@LazyMasterGamer
@LazyMasterGamer 9 жыл бұрын
Robert Trone or like a community thing so everyone could add a link which would be faster like wikipedia ^^
@NerdSyncProductions
@NerdSyncProductions 9 жыл бұрын
I'm waiting for the Idea Channel/Game Theory crossover.
@KiloNovva
@KiloNovva 9 жыл бұрын
ft NerdSync. yea. me too.
@cmckee42
@cmckee42 9 жыл бұрын
+NerdSync I am pretty sure that has already happened.
@Maxzilla60
@Maxzilla60 9 жыл бұрын
+NerdSync More like Film Theory, in this case. But yes, many yes!
@NerdSyncProductions
@NerdSyncProductions 9 жыл бұрын
Did it really?!
@String.Epsilon
@String.Epsilon 9 жыл бұрын
+NerdSync "Here's a theory" and "But that's just an Idea. A GAME IDEA. Thank's for watching"
@KharBrons
@KharBrons 9 жыл бұрын
the theory doesn't hold up. Just because someone dreams about things, doesn't mean those things are only found in their dreams. for example, if I have a dream about idea channel content, doesn't mean idea channel, and anything interconnected to it, are figments of my imagination. it only means I had a dream about something that could be found in reality (arguments aside about what constitutes reality). If anything, the broad scope of characters involved in this hypothesis only stand to show that these... shows.. take place in the same universe. The fact that an autistic kid had a dream about a small fraction of these characters doesn't prove that the characters themselves were created in his mind.
@Renuclous
@Renuclous 9 жыл бұрын
+KharBrons But it still connects the Universe. Because even though you are right about something beeing not exclusive for your mind, it still presupposes that your dreams and the things causing/appearing in them are in the same Universe. Just like you and IdeaChannel are in the same Universe. So i that matter it still holds up.
@GaiashKetoji
@GaiashKetoji 9 жыл бұрын
+KharBrons Really being in Tommy Westphall's imagination is just the starting point and the icing on the cake. The real fun of the Tommy Westphall Hypothesis is finding how you can connect different shows to each other.
@grausammesser
@grausammesser 9 жыл бұрын
+KharBrons This is what I'm thinking myself. Honestly, the theory seems to connect the worlds better if you do not invoke Tommy's imagination.
@LordYon13
@LordYon13 9 жыл бұрын
+KharBrons I'd think of it more like Tyler Durden in fight club. He only exists in the mind of the narrator, and so if anyone else in that world can see him/interact with him then they too must be part of the hallucination (only imaginary friends can see imaginary friends). So if the narrator sees person x talking to Tyler, and then person y talking to person x, person y must be imaginary as we've deduced that person x is imaginary. The question then arises about whether there are 2 versions of person x- one that see Tyler (imaginary) and one that doesn't (real, on which the imaginary one may be based). But then what are you basing the assumption that there are duplicate copies of someone on?
@chrisnotaperson8127
@chrisnotaperson8127 9 жыл бұрын
+KharBrons Largely you are correct to a degree. The idea with tommy is that it is heavily implied everything in the entire show was all in his head. That none of it including the few things that crossed into that show from others were real. So in that case everything in the show at least is clearly part of the dream, as for anything that crosses into it, sure that could have been stuff the kid picked up from his real world. It's just less fun that way.
@moltengarnet
@moltengarnet 6 жыл бұрын
I would argue that characters who showed up on St. Elsewhere wouldn't count since they could have just been characters that he saw somewhere else and added them to his story. It does work the otherway though, if a character from his mind shows up somewhere else, then they would have to be set in his mind.
@dominikusbaur
@dominikusbaur 9 жыл бұрын
The infectiousness of Tommy's mind reminds me of Vonnegut's Ice-Nine from Cat's Cradle.
@MusikCassette
@MusikCassette 9 жыл бұрын
Alternatives: It is likely, that Tommy included characters in his fantasy, he knew from real live. So a large number of lines can be drawn which series take place in Tommy's mind and which just inhabit the same Universe as he does. Furthermore: He could include fictional characters from series he watches on TV. So That leaves us with three categories of series: Those which take Place within the Universe Tommy creates, those which inhabit the same Universe as Tommy, and Those which are shown in this universe.
@Trixiethegoldenwitch
@Trixiethegoldenwitch 9 жыл бұрын
w00t, glad ya'll saved my comment so I can repost it! --- Fan theories are fun, sure, but at least for me, I need them to be artfully so. In the same way analysis, critique, fanfics, whatever, can be art, I like my fan theories to have to merit of that nature too. By this I mean that they have a level of thought and consideration put into them which I could hold up against the actual thing the fan theory is about. "It's all a dream!" theories, for instance, are boring and lazy--sure, anything could be a dream, you can never discredit that as an idea, but who cares? What does that add to the work? At least in the case of like Inception, the movie actually thematically deals with that as an idea, but otherwise it's a pointless question. I want to see the kind of fan theories that expand on and flesh out the world and characters in ways that, if they are true, then the work is made better. I think that's why the John Snow theory is so popular--if it turns out to be true, then it's clever and helps the story to make more sense and be more internally consistent. Fan theories are a group art project; and like all art, they can be more resonant with more people or less. I'd like to see them approached with effort, high standards, and intelligence, so that the "medium" of fan theory might evolve and grow (as it is doing, thanks to the internet and the popularity of videos like this about fan theory).
@AoRyuha1
@AoRyuha1 9 жыл бұрын
+Digibro Well, for one, excellent quality post. As to the actual point, I tend to agree, which is why I prefer to just look at the TWU as a grid of interconnected shows and ignore the delusion/fantasy aspect. It's still pretty awesome if that's all you take from it, I think.
@adninhaikal
@adninhaikal 6 жыл бұрын
sHUT UP DIGI
@laxrulz7
@laxrulz7 9 жыл бұрын
I really like the IDEA of the Westphall Hypothesis. After all, we KNOW that things like NCIS all take place in their same universe. My issue is with the fandom's execution and specifically the branching out into like product types. I can buy into the idea that when Roxanne Turner shows up looking EXACTLY like Roxanne Turner from St. Elsewhere and using the same NAME and obviously being the same character, one has to conclude that Homicide and St. Elsewhere are in the same universe. That's logical and for the writers to suggest they intended to imply anything different seems like silliness. But most product placements just don't do it for me. Most of the products are used for practical purposes because they're props and the names are already cleared through legal. Why create a new product name and have to worry about copywrighting the name and buying the website and, etc. etc... just reuse an old established prop. There's no intent by the writers to imply differently. They don't even KNOW what the baggage is that they're bringing into the show. Contast that with guest appearances. When a character guest stars on Frasier, a show that was a direct spin off of Cheers then the writer is implicitly (though maybe not consciously) stating that that character was also in the Cheers universe. It's a very interesting and very logical fan theory... I just think the implementation has succumbed to zeal.
@Grazzhopper
@Grazzhopper 2 жыл бұрын
I've just heard about this theory for the first time and was delighted to see a PBS Idea Channel video on it, thank you for that. I miss this channel.
@astrophonix
@astrophonix 9 жыл бұрын
I was doing this back in 2000. I wrote a novel in which all the sci-fi movies, books and TV serials all co-exist together so characters and situations from these works would collide and interact. It's called Terminal Crescendo and it's on sale now on Amazon Kindle!
@witchawally
@witchawally 9 жыл бұрын
I just wanted to give props to the flawless transition between the footage from the first video, to footage from the re-released video. Not only was Mike's shirt the same, his hair, even his beard were the same, well done. The only way I could tell was the lighting on the re-released footage was ever so slightly brighter.
@PrimaryOctopus
@PrimaryOctopus 9 жыл бұрын
When he said they were going to talk about fan theories, I paused the video and ran/jumped around the room whisper-shrieking "YES! YES! YAAAAASSSSS!!!!"
@kaylee.4858
@kaylee.4858 3 жыл бұрын
Sabrina the teenage witch is connected to boy meet world and girl meets world is a spin off of that which basically links it into most disney tv shows
@guygeva7375
@guygeva7375 7 жыл бұрын
5:10 What if he saw those sigarettes on TV and included them in his imagionary universes?
@Bluecho4
@Bluecho4 9 жыл бұрын
I'm proud of you, Idea Channel. Not only owning up to mistakes, but rectifying them in a manner that itself is entertaining. I really enjoyed this episode. Props.
@AlbinoTanuki
@AlbinoTanuki 9 жыл бұрын
Gravity Falls and Rick & Morty don't take place in the same universe, but their universes do cross over with easter egg, often coming through portals connecting to their universes.
@Tall_Order
@Tall_Order 9 жыл бұрын
Here's another situation to ponder. Super Mario Bros 2 (USA version) was all a dream in Mario's head, and even though he opened an eye in the credits, he went back to sleep. Since later Mario games have Shyguys and Birdo in them, perhaps he's still dreaming? Any crossovers would be a dream too, such as all the Smash Bros characters and Sonic. He imagined your pokemons. lol
@PIKMINROCK1
@PIKMINROCK1 9 жыл бұрын
+Wolfee Darkfang Assuming SMB2's plot isn't that the deposed kings of Subcon used their combine powers to bring the Mushroom Kingdom's heroes over via their dreams to save them, I think you have to consider how dreams work. Perhaps Shy Guys and Birdos appear in SMB 2 because of the his trauma in Yoshi's Island since Shy Guys are the main enemies and Birdos could be made interpretations of the Yoshis. Birdo for instance, never appears in the main games. Neither do shy guys outside of Yoshi's Island. SMB3 is confirmed to be a play though. Dreaming within a dream is awkward too (Dream Events in Mario & Sonic at Olympic Games) and I'm pretty sure the Smash Universe is separate machinations of children playing
@malfaroangel3896
@malfaroangel3896 3 жыл бұрын
No cause you are assuming the creatures you see in the game Mario made up in his head. When they already exist in the Universe
@Tall_Order
@Tall_Order 3 жыл бұрын
@@malfaroangel3896 Good point. Yeah I've pondered it since I made my original comment. If I can have a dream with long dead relatives in them, mario could easily have dreams involving creatures that exist in his world but just never appeared in a prior game. The franchise was still new at the time anyway, and we only saw the world through marios perspective while the princess was captured.
@baileyholden654
@baileyholden654 9 жыл бұрын
(originally written on the old video but by the time i finished typing the video went down) Okay, I really want comment responses on this because I feel isolated in this position and I feel like there must be a reason why, something I'm missing. I don't 'get' most fan theories, I don't find them in the slightest bit interesting, there are the occasional few that re-frame something so well and it almost becomes canonic but that to me feels like a tiny tiny minority. and i wouldn't put this theory in that category at all. first i should put my bias out there, i wasn't fond of this theory from pretty much second one and that very well could have warped my perception, the concept of something being all in someones head is totally trite to me. it's, for all intents and purposes, and it was all a dream. but my problem with the theory is a sort of 'so what' factor, i'm all for different interpretations of art, i think that's fabulous, but to me there has to be something to gain from that different perspective and i don't know what that is in this case. if 400 tv shows all exist in this kids imagination, well, i don't know. it seems like overselling a silly explanation about cross-overs.
@GaiashKetoji
@GaiashKetoji 9 жыл бұрын
+Bailey Holden But it's not about actors, it's about characters, brands and other things created for one show being in another. TV shows have crossovers and making these means that the two shows either share a universe or a multiverse (depends on how they cross over) and the idea of the Tommy Westphall Universe Hypothesis is seeing how many shows you can connect to each other using in universe connections to each other.
@baileyholden654
@baileyholden654 9 жыл бұрын
Mathew Gibbons right i'll edit the post later, i haven't seen the revised version of the video yet. but i don't think that really answers all my concerns about it though.
@TheMTHouse
@TheMTHouse 9 жыл бұрын
I get you! That's what I was thinking too! Because the theory that all these shows take place in a kids head does nothing to alter my understanding of their primary narratives, I'm stuck going "... and?" I love headcanons/theories that build on characters or analyze intentions because they change the way I view character actions, and therefore the core narrative. But the "Rapunzel is actually Elsa's COUSIN!" ones don't appeal to me at all.
@GaiashKetoji
@GaiashKetoji 9 жыл бұрын
Bailey Holden I haven't seen the old video yet and after I made my comment I saw a post that explained that the thing that was wrong about the old version was including actors. In this video he makes a point of saying "not actors".
@ElDaumo
@ElDaumo 9 жыл бұрын
+Bailey Holden while i really like fan theories, i had the same 'so what' reaction when it came to the tommy westphall hypothesis.
@dragonflame765
@dragonflame765 9 жыл бұрын
This theory kind of reminds me of how in the books of Kurt Vonnegut, many of the characters cross over from one book to another (Kilgore Trout from Breakfast of Champions to Slaughterhouse 5, and so forth), yet the various books can't possibly be within the same universe due to catastrophic events that take place within some of the books, and so forth. Same thing here, where some of the shows within the universe don't seem to be able to coexist.
@MichaelSidneyTimpson
@MichaelSidneyTimpson 4 жыл бұрын
Since real people show up sometimes in some of these shows, WE are living in his universe too.
@DenisRyan
@DenisRyan 9 жыл бұрын
I've always been fascinated by the idea of the crossover universe I heard called the "St. Elsewhereverse", though I do now prefer the Tommy Westphall Universe. It's just great fun to talk about and be amazed at, especially now with smartphones bringing the knowledge of the internet with you everywhere. I will say, I've never considered the props thing a factor. A lot of props get reused just because it's easier to use something that's already made than make a whole new prop, or worry about having to license or give free advertising to a real product. The cigarettes mentioned are a good example, and two other massive ones are the airline company with the worst safety record in history, Oceanic Airlines (Sometimes Oceanic Airways) from Lost, Castle, FlashForward, Fringe, and loads more, and that newspaper prop that shows up everywhere with the article about the missing woman, a warehouse burning and some bill going before the President. Most of the time these props are reused without thought, unlike having characters crossing over, which has to be a deliberate, agreed upon action written into the script. Finally, one other reason I don't agree with using props to connect series is this: In Castle, Rick Castle has the part from a Firefly class ship that breaks in the episode "Out of Gas", an obvious gag as Nathan Fillion is in both, but suggestion that props lead to crossover evidence means that Firefly takes place before Castle in that universe, yet Firefly is based in the distant future. Then again, it's all in the mind of a young boy with autism. Who says things have to happen in chronological order? Oh... Oh dear. I just thought of this now... If it is all in the mind of a young boy with autism, then maybe the repeated recurrences of the same props shows a limit to his imagination on the small details, instead focusing on the characters and stories... Oh. Oh my... Mind blown!
@MinimalistTheatre333
@MinimalistTheatre333 5 жыл бұрын
This Supernatural fanfic gives a slight idea for Tommy Westphall - even if it doesn't mention him by name - and it's a minor part of the story as a whole (most of it is spent with the Winchesters and the Special Victims Unit) but it's still hilarious. In the fanfic 'Demon Vacation', in a flashback it's stated that a demon possessed the Westphall kid before St Elsewhere started in '82 and spent several years using a djinn to trick the boy's dad into thinking he was a doctor at the hospital and did the same to the staff there. He had a whole bunch of snowglobes with people's souls trapped inside (you might need to know how Supernatural's djinns work to understand this) on top of video box sets inside his bedroom and used magic to manipulate others. It doesn't explain this theory by a long shot but it's still funny to read,
@AoRyuha1
@AoRyuha1 9 жыл бұрын
You made a mistake with your Newhart >> Sabrina example thread, one that's very worth pointing out as it's coincidentally one of the most interesting threads on the chart. You conflated Newhart and the Bob Newhart show together into a single show. They're two seperate shows. The Bob Newhart Show is the one connected to the main chart via St Elsewhere, while Newhart in its entirety is a delusion of a character from the Bob Newhart show. Therefore everything linked into the grid via Newhart is a delusion twice over - the delusion of a person who only exists as part of a delusion. That is, if you buy into the delusion aspect of the TWU in the first place. I personally just like it as a web of interconnected tv shows, but I respect people who are into the delusion/fantasy aspect.
@danielbutterfieldmysticmusic
@danielbutterfieldmysticmusic 5 жыл бұрын
Your point is valid, but for the record, Mr. Carlin appeared on both St. Elsewhere and Newhart as well as The Bob Newhart Show.
@kaylabower546
@kaylabower546 9 жыл бұрын
You guys should discuss The Pixar Theory
@thewewguy8t88
@thewewguy8t88 5 жыл бұрын
yes but the pixar theory idk actually makes sense?
@Unseenone445
@Unseenone445 3 жыл бұрын
But even Pixar is connected to family guy too
@kaylabower546
@kaylabower546 3 жыл бұрын
@@Unseenone445 bro i posted this comment 5 years ago
@6to1
@6to1 9 жыл бұрын
Humans see patterns where none exist.
@Reionder
@Reionder 9 жыл бұрын
That's what I said to yo mamma. OOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHH
@cokeMONSTERps3
@cokeMONSTERps3 9 жыл бұрын
+Reionder Fukin Savage.
@LiaThePenguinologist
@LiaThePenguinologist 9 жыл бұрын
+Sure i imagined wayne saying this and then doing the thumbs up thing
@mabiniss2
@mabiniss2 9 жыл бұрын
+Sure If humans can see a pattern then it must exist because if not, humans wouldn't have been able to see them in the first place.
@sinachiniforoosh
@sinachiniforoosh 9 жыл бұрын
+Sure, but patterns are almost by definition the products of minds, and outside minds, patterns don't exist. So if a mind sees a pattern, in a way it does exist.
@twilightman2816
@twilightman2816 6 жыл бұрын
Just checking in to point out that about a year ago, the Disney Channel show "Girl Meets World", which was a spin-off of the 1990's TGIF show "Boy Meets World" crossed over with several other Disney Channel shows. That now means that the entire Disney Channel Universe (yes, that's a thing; several of the shows try and cross over with each other at least yearly) is now connected to the TGIF universe, which is down in the lower right corner of the diagram shown at 3:50 . This "TV Universe" keeps getting bigger and bigger!!!!!! Nice discussion of this theory. I love it!!!!!!!
@balladofcoseypolar4711
@balladofcoseypolar4711 6 жыл бұрын
The Flash is part of the Westphall universe, but they talk about Breaking Bad on the show, which is also part of the Westphall universe.
@pedroscoponi4905
@pedroscoponi4905 9 жыл бұрын
Damn you, Mike, I literally went nuts just from you dropping the Calvin+Fight club theory... * Rushes to google it, hands shaking out of conspiratious awe *
@pbsideachannel
@pbsideachannel 9 жыл бұрын
+Pedro Scoponi Isn't it so good! I think the intertextual fan theories are my favorites. Calvin and Hobbes + FightClub, Tommy Westphall, James Bond is a Timelord, Great Gatsby is an alternate timeline where Jack from Titantic survives...
@DrMustacho
@DrMustacho 9 жыл бұрын
+PBS Idea Channel there is a life recording of a cracked podcast where they discuss various fan theories my personal faforite (i thought it up myself though i'm probably not the first): malcom from malcom in the middle is mr white from breaking bad (brilliant, cynical, grey morality, hates his mom, he'd look like his dad)
@pedroscoponi4905
@pedroscoponi4905 9 жыл бұрын
Batman is a Timelord, James Bond is a Timelord, everybody is a time lord, wow e.e'
@kunyoruyo
@kunyoruyo 9 жыл бұрын
+DrMustacho I've never thought about that!! It amazes me and scares me at the same time
@amaurapond
@amaurapond 9 жыл бұрын
+Pedro Scoponi I wish, because Timelords are cool!
@TheRealFlenuan
@TheRealFlenuan 9 жыл бұрын
So I take it a lot of this is based on connections via "Morley cigarettes"? Look, I get that character crossovers are valid connections, but fake name brands are basically easter eggs, and many people who are into these sorts of theories (myself included) don't like to count easter eggs as links.
@TheRealFlenuan
@TheRealFlenuan 9 жыл бұрын
Also, any connections made only via non-character crossovers, although they do place them in the same universe, do not necessitate that such shows are inventions of Tommy Westphall, for it is possible that Tommy simply incorporated those aspects of his world (i.e. the "Morley" name brand) into his thoughts.
@Patitomuerto
@Patitomuerto 9 жыл бұрын
What about fake products and places that are featured in movies/tv shows made by the same people? Like Kevin smiths works. Do those gain more credence because it's a higher probability that the creator wants you to make that connection?
@rileymckinley
@rileymckinley 9 жыл бұрын
Yeah, like "Sleepless in Seattle and Elf both feature the Empire State Building, so they're in the same universe!!!'! :O" It doesn't really hold up.
@Patitomuerto
@Patitomuerto 9 жыл бұрын
+Riley McKinley They're talking about fictional brands and locations, not real ones. Morley was a cigarette brand that was made up for the shows.
@KiriyamaNox
@KiriyamaNox 9 жыл бұрын
This is exactly why I love role playing on the internet, which with the introduction of Social Media has taken a HUGE step forward, with people creating blogs or social profiles for characters in TV and taking them forward and beyond what we see on TV. I definitely believe that the two phenomena (internet RPs and fan theories) are intrincately linked as they serve to gap and reinterpret the lore surrounding them, which is kind of what myths and folklore do.
@manamaster6
@manamaster6 9 жыл бұрын
"I like to overthink pop culture" that would be perfect for a bumper sticker.
@Korombos
@Korombos 9 жыл бұрын
That was a much more coherent theory than was presented in the first draft. Good job, folks.
@TheChicaPanda
@TheChicaPanda 9 жыл бұрын
I've always loved finding connections in the tv-universe, but this theory was well beyond that! The idea is (in my eyes) lovely, and a great way to find those satisfying moments of cultural connection. It doesn't really hold up, but it's a pretty neat lens.
@ViraL_FootprinT.ex.e
@ViraL_FootprinT.ex.e 3 жыл бұрын
Let us not forget *Let's Chips.* They're all over TV shows: [from _Community_ ] Dean Pelton: If you don't like the crispy-licious taste of Let's, feel free to eat that other greasy brand. Troy: [Eating a bag of Let's] Splingles? Not this guy.
@semi-sweet
@semi-sweet 9 жыл бұрын
Alright, this makes much more sense. The actor thing was so confusing. I don't think it really works with props, though. Tommy could have seen those cigarettes in real life and incorporated them into his fantasy. Therefore those shows take place not in Tommy's universe, but in the same universe as Tommy, which is slightly different.
@Nictator42
@Nictator42 9 жыл бұрын
I like how you used my example as your primary example, thanks for listening!
@moonwhispers
@moonwhispers 9 жыл бұрын
I just want to say, Hooray for mentioning MovieBob. :D
@jaanmerz2145
@jaanmerz2145 3 жыл бұрын
I looked at the map of this universe and noticed that The Office US was on it, however, I also noticed that Battlestar Galactica was there too, which immediately made me start thinking of Dwight's obsession with that show. This made me wonder, how could both shows take place in the same universe if one show is constantly referenced to in the other?
@JR-cw4it
@JR-cw4it 9 ай бұрын
Dwight can hop between universes.
@BlankPicketSign
@BlankPicketSign 9 жыл бұрын
Idea Channel might be visiting Ash in his Hospital bed. I can't wait =^_^=
@pbsideachannel
@pbsideachannel 9 жыл бұрын
+BlankPicketSign We're gonna be visiting a looonnnnngggg list of people in hospital beds for one of these Fan Theory episodes... :D
@BlankPicketSign
@BlankPicketSign 9 жыл бұрын
PBS Idea Channel Toot Tooooot! Fan Theory Train is pulling in!!! Thank you SO MUCH, this is going to be epic!
@saulpaul8422
@saulpaul8422 4 жыл бұрын
Ash Williams from Evil Dead
@Ashtarte3D
@Ashtarte3D 9 жыл бұрын
Awww, I was hoping one of the fan theories you'd have an episode for is that glorious Calvin & Hobbs becomes Fight Club one. Anyway, the Tommy Westphall Hypothesis isn't one I've ever put stock in, but it's definitely fun to see how far the proverbial rabbit hole goes. For instance how the Morley cigaretts prop has been used to link so many more shows into the hypothesis, finally wrangling in shows far outside the modern day era timeline. Such as that they appeared in Castle, and Castle himself dressed up as Malcolm Reynolds, so Firefly must also be in Westphall's head.
@punkinpiez
@punkinpiez 9 жыл бұрын
I think an interesting aspect of fan theories is the idea of head-canon. These are generally ideas that are, by admission, completely unverifiable, but make enough sense or fit so well that someone chooses to think of them as true because, for that person, they make the story better. Some head-canons could be called fan theories, because they are put together from details from the original work. But some head-canons are just imagined moments or stories that involve these characters and there is no basis for believing that they ever happened. But people choose to believe in them because they give you new ways of looking at characters or re-contextualize the story.
@Contrariwise37
@Contrariwise37 9 жыл бұрын
Okay so a lot of memes have been made of TV characters, so it's safe to say at least some of those memes are of characters in the Tommy Westphall universe. It's also not a stretch to say that they the Know Your Meme videos took place in a world where internet memes are REAL, as in they are essentially physical entities. Mike played more or less himself in KYM, and now he plays more or less himself for PBS Idea Channel. He's done collaborations with VSauce, Mental Floss, The Needle Drop, and I might be missing a few more. Those channels subsequently have done dozens of crossover videos. So basically all of KZbin is in the Tommy Westphall universe.
@kurtisnimmert7555
@kurtisnimmert7555 9 жыл бұрын
Brave thing, sir, admitting that you were wrong on the internet. I commend you for it.
@UnReal31337
@UnReal31337 9 жыл бұрын
It's starting to look like Continuum and Dark Matter take place in the same universe because of Roger Cross
@SmoggySandwich
@SmoggySandwich 9 жыл бұрын
Calvin and Hobbes is a prequel to Fight Club? You sir, just blew my mind.
@lott3B
@lott3B 3 жыл бұрын
There is also the brand of chips called "Let's" that appear in shows that are connected, connecting even more shows to that theory.
@Avitymist
@Avitymist 9 жыл бұрын
Oh wow this is pretty amazing, I love fan theories. I remember watching an hour long video on a Mass Effect indoctrination fan theory even though I never even played the games. There's something special about people going out of their way to notice the smallest of details and giving them a lot of importance, creating a completely new backstory. Can't wait for more videos.
@nicoliraymond9422
@nicoliraymond9422 9 жыл бұрын
Getting deep into Tommy Westphall Hypothesis, there's tiers. Like shows that are acknowledged by other shows as shows and thus are "lower universes" inside Tommy's mind. For instance how Happy Days and Laverne and Shirley are acknowledged as TV programs in That 70's Show, or pretty much anything in Community. So I've been thinking about the Scrubs extended universe and the tiers it's a part of a lot lately. I figured it went like this (from top universe down): iZombie 30 Rock- referenced by iZombie, Mad Men-Liz's mom worked at Sterling Cooper. Community-referenced in 30 Rock, Scrubs-referenced in Community , 'Til Death, Cougar Town-referenced in Community plus crossover as a show within a show. While Clearly not in the Scrubs Universe, New Girl and the Office exist as shows in 30 Rock and Community Respectively. But then I realized the last episode of Community references 30 Rock as a show in that world and 30 Rock references Mad Men as a show (the ending of 30 Rock muddles this up as well). So I decided that ultimately none of it matters and there's no grand TV Universe inside a kid's head. It's really fun to try to make it all fit though.
@afekasi79
@afekasi79 8 жыл бұрын
I think it proves that the writers were out of ideas for that last episode of St. Elsewhere.
@dramaticrodent541
@dramaticrodent541 9 жыл бұрын
Some of these "connections" are extremely tenuous. I just looked it up and the reason BattleStar Galactica is included is because a ship that looks kind of like a Firefly class is briefly on screen for a moment in BattleStar Galactica (2003 version). That isn't a crossover that is an easter egg. It is just a fun thing for people who pause shows to study the backgrounds.
@latieraeve
@latieraeve 9 жыл бұрын
You had me with the wrong one, now my head hurts >___
@AdellRedwinters
@AdellRedwinters 9 жыл бұрын
+latieraeve In this corrected version, it's more about direct 'character' or environmental crossovers (like the cigarettes) than just if the actors from one show appear in another show.
@latieraeve
@latieraeve 9 жыл бұрын
so it wasnt wrong, just more information
@paradoxacres1063
@paradoxacres1063 9 жыл бұрын
+latieraeve Yeah..I'm kinda confused, too. No idea why the first video was "wrong", either.
@seaneredia5199
@seaneredia5199 6 жыл бұрын
Who is here from VOX?
@nerdoverlord7039
@nerdoverlord7039 9 жыл бұрын
The thing with fan theories is that it also fill gaps. Take Doctor Who for example. How did all the Doctors knew to save Gallifrey, or what about the previous incarnations that are shown in the mind battle in The Brain of Morbius? Hundreds upon hundreds of fan theories exist trying to fill in the spaces the writers left empty. Some writers leave blank spaces intentionally because they know that, deep down, everybody loves a good fan theory. There are also many theories about how it's possible that some shows are recreations of things going on, or in the case of time-travel shows, things that will be going on.
@amaurapond
@amaurapond 9 жыл бұрын
+NerdOverlord Since Moffat's run, I think pretty much anything happens just because he says so, no matter how much or how little sense it makes. Cough, Amy and Rory's departure. I do agree with your main point though. It adds towards the suspense and keeps the viewers hooked.
@phostetlerart
@phostetlerart 9 жыл бұрын
+NerdOverlord Sometimes when you try to fill in the gaps, it leads to things like midichlorians.
@Lewa500
@Lewa500 9 жыл бұрын
Nothing dinged when you said "ding".
@johnsciara9418
@johnsciara9418 6 ай бұрын
Imagine if the snow globe was also a music box and the St Elsewhere theme was played by the music box
@grkpektis
@grkpektis 9 жыл бұрын
I heard a theory based on this theory, according to this Star Trek and a bunch of other sci-fi shows and Buffy plus a bunch of other supernatural shows take place in the same universe but there are very few supernatural things in those sci-fi shows. In a buffy comic spin-off "Fray" we see that vampires and monsters are almost extinct in the future which explains why in Star Trek we only see a few unexplained supernatural creatures like Q because they have gone into hiding. Shows like the X-files show that aliens and the Supernatural both exist in this universe
@thewewguy8t88
@thewewguy8t88 5 жыл бұрын
fair enough but how do you explain the walking dead happening at the same time.
@Pompo5
@Pompo5 9 жыл бұрын
i simply love the "yeah" that ends the video
@junglehero1274
@junglehero1274 9 жыл бұрын
This goes much deeper then just TV shows. Ever since I've heard of a theory similar to this one over on the Game Theorist Channel its been a hobby of mine to find as many connections as possible, and I've discovered not only can you connect TV Shows, but also Movies, Video Games, Comic Books, and possibly any form of fiction! For example, The Adventures of Superman is part of the Tommy Westphall Universe by crossing over with I Love Lucy, and Superman had a comic crossover with Spiderman in 1976. Spiderman and other Marvel Characters, in turn, appeared as characters in a Tony Hawk game, a franchise that has had characters from Shrek, Doom, Guitar Hero and Star Wars. Star Wars characters also appear in Soulcaliber which has had characters from Tekken, Spawn, Assassins Creed, and the Legend of Zelda, and Zelda in turn leads to all sorts of Video Game Crossovers from Mario to Starcraft! If you look hard enough and find enough connections, you can basically connect any fiction story that you want to to each other. Like Moviebob said, its a really fun thing to do! Also: +PBS Idea Channel If only one of my comments ever gets featured on this show, *please* let it be this one!
@randymcfallon
@randymcfallon 2 жыл бұрын
This is such a rabbit hole. In addition to characters and props, what about references. Like if a show references another, but also real life events. Lol.
@9642SM7
@9642SM7 9 жыл бұрын
I never heard of this before but have wished for more crossover episodes in order to be able to piece "TV Land" together.
@matthewq2365
@matthewq2365 9 жыл бұрын
Finding Tommy Westphall.
@ThePuppyTurtle
@ThePuppyTurtle 9 жыл бұрын
You should do "The Minds of Wolves and Robins." Well, maybe you shouldn't, but it is the final boss of fan theories, at least where a Song of Ice and Fire is concerned. it's almost certainly untrue, but it's just so elaborate, extreme, far fetched, and weirdly well supported despite it being easily disprovable that it feels my heart with glee to contemplate it.
@thekrakenexperiment280
@thekrakenexperiment280 9 жыл бұрын
I was hoping you'd do an episode about this.
@Smirknewmedia
@Smirknewmedia 9 жыл бұрын
Since you use the word "doobly-doo" does that means that Idea Channel and the Vlogbrothers are in the same universe? Whoa. Mind blown.
@junglehero1274
@junglehero1274 9 жыл бұрын
If you are doing video's on fan theories, it would be interesting to see one on why the "Main Character is in a coma" type if theory are so overused and popular. Seriously, nearly any franchise you can think of has a theory like this, and they are all nearly exactly the same!
@GreatSwordNH
@GreatSwordNH 9 жыл бұрын
Fan theories are like playing with action figure when you were a kid. 'How would Ironman and Jason, the Red Power Ranger defeat The Skull from Mighty Max?' 'Which Ninja Turtle would be the first to scale The Aggro-Crag on Nickelodeon's Guts?' It tests the limits of a character but also the author's interpretation of that character, as well as the imagination.
@FlyToTheRain
@FlyToTheRain 9 жыл бұрын
I'd like to just quickly mention that I prefer to use person first language when addressing conditions like autism. Saying "a young boy with autism" or "a young boy who has autism" sounds better to me than "a young autistic boy" because it's recognizing that he is a person, a boy, first, who has autism. Just something that I've personally been taught, I know that other people prefer to say it other ways. I just wanted to point it out since it caught my attention right away. Now after watching the whole episode I just have to ask, why was it necessary to include that the boy has autism? I did not catch any mentions of symptoms on the autism spectrum or how they related or were necessary for the boy to create this universe with his imagination. Should his defining characteristic be that he created this enormous television universe, or that he has autism? Because as soon as autism was mentioned I waited out the entire video for it to become relevant to the theory.
@FlyToTheRain
@FlyToTheRain 9 жыл бұрын
PIKMINROCK1 I definitely agree that many kids with autism are incredibly imaginative and creative, but that is also not exclusive to kids with autism. I guess what I'm caught up on is the need to classify people by their disabilities. Stating that he has autism lends a hand to the theory that his imagination is creative enough to create hundreds of show in one universe, but with that I feel like a lot of people automatically assigned certain schemas and stereotypes in their minds about autism to his character that might not be true.
@Maxmaxmaxmax444
@Maxmaxmaxmax444 9 жыл бұрын
+FlyToTheRain I second this. In psychology there's been a huge push away from calling people stuff like schizophrenics and autistics for the reasons you mentioned and instead these are people who have problems. It can be really tricky with mental health problems to differentiate the person from the disorder which is why this stuff can be so hard to figure or seem counter intuitive.
@maggieedna
@maggieedna 9 жыл бұрын
+FlyToTheRain realsocialskills.org/post/92439024532/autism-language-politics-and-history and realsocialskills.org/post/115487226201/respectful-autism-language-for-people-who-arent are good posts by an autistic person about the history of person first language and why it can actually be really offensive to use it (tl;dr, it almost always comes from someone who doesn't have autism and many people with autism feel like their autism is a significant part of who they are and theirs no reason to cordon it off like its something untouchable. we never make a fuss about "red haired person" vs "person with red hair" so with person first language you can actually be implying that autism is a negative trait, which is not how a lot of autistic people feel about it.) Their recomendation is that if you are talking about people with autism in general you try to alternate "autistic person" and "person with autism," but if you're talking about a specific person you find out which they prefer. Since this is a fictional character who as far as I know doesn't express a preference, either one seems fine. the question of why its necessary to specify that he has autism is sort of interesting. fiction has this whole set of tropes around autism, tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/HollywoodAutism for examples, and I think that the fact that the tv show in question used those tropes is worth mentioning, the same way the setting is. I think that the treatment of autism in fiction is super fascinating in general, the way its used as a short hand for a sort of empirical mysticism and the way that tv shows pussyfoot around actually calling it autism and the fact that there are no tv shows that actually have autistic characters who arent there to do what abed once called "using a social disorder as a proceedural device." kzbin.info/www/bejne/gWrZg6CCiqiha5I like if you were going to use television shows to understand autism you would straight up think it meant something like "shifty, uncomfortable in social situations, highly intuitive, sometimes magical." idk theres probably something to be said there about the way that fears are digested through stories or the way that "the other" is always mystical or whatever but I'll leave you to think about it for yourself disclaimer: I'm not autistic. eta: fixed some links
@weskos
@weskos 9 жыл бұрын
+FlyToTheRain I find it interesting, that in the reference mode that you prefer, the term that comes first is seen to be more important, more intrinsic or germane to recognizance. From my perspective, the term in the last position is the most basic, intrinsic and representational, as it stands in the 'anchor' position. All terms before it are modifiers. So, "A young autistic boy" ends up sounding better. This is, of course, all cultural and lingo-centric. We probably both have the same cringing feeling about terms such as "the autistics" or "the blacks", where the adjective is simply nominalized.
@FlyToTheRain
@FlyToTheRain 9 жыл бұрын
weskos It really is all about perspective! That's why I stated that person first language is my preference, but I can completely see where you are coming from with your preferred wording. I'm glad we can both agree about the use of "the autistics" being cringeworthy.
@FlackNCoke
@FlackNCoke 9 жыл бұрын
I'm so happy to see you guys correct yourselves on this one; it shows a real commitment to integrity over pride, and I appreciate that! Also, the original video's assertion that the Westphall verse was based on actors bugged the hell out of me! :P
@garrett21
@garrett21 5 жыл бұрын
I wouldn’t count props being a connection but it’s still very cool
@motherbrain3758
@motherbrain3758 9 жыл бұрын
What I love most about fan theories is that it gives a space for fandoms to interact, debate and argue about what they believe is happening. There's a certain sort of pride you get when you figure out a major plot point in a story based on loose evidence put in by the creators. A great example of this is in Life is Strange where GeekRemix figured out who the bad guy was after just one episode of game play. There's nothing better than sitting in a forum with a bunch of other people trying to scram together evidence to support a crazy theory. It really adds a fourth dimension to the media we consume.
@TheSugarRay
@TheSugarRay 9 жыл бұрын
This is great because it is another reward for paying attention, which I love being rewarded. It makes me wonder if any shows are very modular or isolated. Also, if there is a child out there who does not know that TV is made of actors and one day sees an Ipad and comes up with their own tiny fan theory.
@JohnMoley
@JohnMoley 9 жыл бұрын
Wow, I've watched both versions of this episode and I have to say, it was a lot more interesting when you got the hypothesis right! Good on you for making the effort to fully address your mistake. :-)
@blindaurora
@blindaurora 9 жыл бұрын
Paradigmatic! I'm using that in a sentence today!
@ashleydunn5015
@ashleydunn5015 4 жыл бұрын
Stumbled on this for the first time in a long time, really missing Idea Channel!
@TheFifthEl
@TheFifthEl 9 жыл бұрын
There is another possibility here: Alternate Universe counterparts. In the DC canon there is not just one Superman. There are lots, spread around countless alternate dimensions (or at least, there were) and in the same way just because a character appears on two shows it doesn't mean that they are the same VERSION of that character. They could merely be the version of said character native to that universe.
@tiIebreaker
@tiIebreaker 2 жыл бұрын
I was surprised to see a dismemberment plan and a boards of canada vinyl in this video, that requires an Instant sub
@GalanDun
@GalanDun 9 жыл бұрын
It's interesting to think that certain TV shows are all happening in the same universe. There's certainly no reason why they couldn't, but to think that it's all imagined would both be impossible, and explain a lot of the bizarre continuity of certain shows. For instance, if we consider both the idea that the Westphall Hypothesis is true and that the Shared Universe Hypothesis is true, that leaves us with an both an imagined world, which explains why so many crises and murders can happen (The imagined world is just repopulating itself all the time), why so many plot-points sometimes repeat themselves across and inside shows, why characters sometimes appear out of nowhere and vanish without explanation, and why certain characters wind up acting completely different from one season to the next. On the other hand, in the Shared Universe Hypothesis, we have a world suffering from massive amounts of crime and terrorism. That world would have to have a MASSIVE population for that to be the case. And it would also have to be suffering from either the same kind of stretched-out timescale the Marvel universe has, or it would have to have a Doctor Who-esque method of erasing history.
@JMShelton42
@JMShelton42 9 жыл бұрын
I'm curious to know how Hannibal fits into this. According to the chart linked in the description, Dead Like Me also is part of this universe, however it's later hinted at that the entirety of that show (and by extension the rest of the Fullerverse) exists within the mind of Georgia Madchen, a minor character in the first season of Hannibal- a show that is otherwise unrelated to the rest of this weird universe/thing. Since you can't connect Hannibal to the rest of the shows in any other way (or at least, no one has found such a connection as of time of writing), this would make Hannibal the starting point for the theory, and the "universe" would work its way down from there by way of Georgia Madchen/Lass.
@3lil0rd82
@3lil0rd82 7 жыл бұрын
In the blacklist episode Isabella Stone if I'm not mistaken a bodyguard was stated to be,"Ex- NCIS" which probably is a refrence to the show. I could be stretching because there is an NCIS in real life.
@Skip6235
@Skip6235 9 жыл бұрын
I think it's actually more interesting if you assume that the Westphall hypothesis is correct, but not because of conscious action by the writers and creators of those shows, but is an organic thing that comes out of how tv shows are made. I think it's cool to think that these fan theories can become "cannon", even if the original author hadn't intended it that way.
@Wreckonning
@Wreckonning 9 жыл бұрын
The main advantage of the Tommy Westfall theory is that Tommy Westfall is purely a framing device. All of those links between shows already exist without that.
@brendankevinsmith
@brendankevinsmith 6 жыл бұрын
Great video. They are all gags when they bring in characters from other series into the shows. And that can be broken down by network.
@pabloriutort5364
@pabloriutort5364 9 жыл бұрын
Ferris Bueller's Day Off is also the prequel of Fight Club... So Calvin is also Cameron?! :O
@EricTheKei
@EricTheKei 9 жыл бұрын
Just a silly thought, and perhaps something worth debating: It's mentioned that props carrying over between universes can potentially constitute a connection. Firefly (connected via Weyland/Alien) has a Han Solo in carbonite toy present somewhere at least once in every episode. I can think of two possibilities for this -- I'm sure you guys can come up with more: (1) At least some of the Star Wars movies have persisted in some form to the time of the Firefly Verse (which is explicitly an area which was colonized by Earth humans), and they made toys for the movies, just as they do IRL. (2) Their universe never had any Star Wars movies, nor a George Lucas, but rather, they have legends of the events of SW in their time, leading to the carbonite image as some sort of historical icon -- which would make SW (Including Extended) part of the Westphallverse. What do you guys think?
@paradoxacres1063
@paradoxacres1063 9 жыл бұрын
........I honestly was not aware that this video was reuploaded (or "remade"?).
@adampkalb
@adampkalb 5 жыл бұрын
Actually, if you remove anything where the only connections between shows were Morley Cigarettes or Yoyodyne or other fake brands, it's closer to 100 shows because Hi, Honey I'm Home's crossovers were just visiting characters behind the scenes of their own series and not an actual connection. February 4, 2019, 10:33am
@3333218
@3333218 9 жыл бұрын
I'm waiting eagerly for that Tetraforce video!
@danferno
@danferno 9 жыл бұрын
It makes a lot more sense now
@sithstormjedi
@sithstormjedi 9 жыл бұрын
slightly off topic, but i know in the case of movies. Many films are filmed in Vancouver, so they kinda are in the same "setting"
@xxprizefighterxx
@xxprizefighterxx 4 жыл бұрын
This was my fav thread in the twisting the hellmouth forums years ago.
@NinjaNanya
@NinjaNanya 9 жыл бұрын
Okay, now I get why you removed it, and I approve because you put it back up. Geez... I feel like I'm going crazy lately because every video I try to watch I get several private videos that I cannot watch and makes me syad ;~;
What's The Difference Between History and The Past?
12:52
PBS Idea Channel
Рет қаралды 199 М.
Do You Want to Believe? | Idea Channel | PBS Digital Studios
12:46
PBS Idea Channel
Рет қаралды 145 М.
Spongebob ate Patrick 😱 #meme #spongebob #gmod
00:15
Mr. LoLo
Рет қаралды 21 МЛН
Don't look down on anyone#devil  #lilith  #funny  #shorts
00:12
Devil Lilith
Рет қаралды 18 МЛН
Как подписать? 😂 #shorts
00:10
Денис Кукояка
Рет қаралды 8 МЛН
A Defense of Overthinking Pop Culture
15:46
PBS Idea Channel
Рет қаралды 103 М.
TVs Most Perplexing Fan Theory: The Tommy Westphall Universe
30:38
Weekend Update: Trump Scrolled Twitter During Jan 6 - SNL
6:29
Saturday Night Live
Рет қаралды 192 М.
To AdBlock, Or Not To Adblock... | Idea Channel | PBS Digital Studios
10:25
I Connected Every Disney Movie In The Same Universe
1:06:43
Seamus Gorman
Рет қаралды 695 М.
The Original Cinematic Universes
10:33
Patrick (H) Willems
Рет қаралды 167 М.
Bankrupt - 99 Cents Only Stores
16:47
Bright Sun Films
Рет қаралды 175 М.
The 'Cougar' Epidemic - Young Men Dating Older Women
20:27
Shoe0nHead
Рет қаралды 1,2 МЛН
Is Super Mario Brothers A Surrealist Masterpiece?
12:59
PBS Idea Channel
Рет қаралды 196 М.