Are Hell and Heaven Eternal in Islamic Belief?

[@interest2006]

Dear professor, Which hadith you find it problematic because chain of narration. Could you please provide us with reference? So we can enlighten ourselves with the knowledge and stay away from fitn

[@daphnegiachero4680]

Salam alaikum Professor, could you kindly tell us where we can find the Hadith you are referring to and could you indicate whether there is any reading or any articles you would recommend on this topic? Thank you

[@FatJackedNerd]

Look up to Ibn Tahmiyyah's work (Salafi) And or Imam Ghazali's work (Sufis)

[@moi379]

you pay of your bill and then go to heaven... sounds like purgatory smth that everyone go through

[@sifatraihan3455]

Is the Shaykh referring the Jahmiyya ?

[@abeadabegum6995]

It's not eternal it's everlasting

[@thunderbear0]

Both are same Eternal means with no start and no end And everlasting is it has start but no ending

[@jamalkhalil77]

@@thunderbear0 you just proved it that both are not same. One has a start and the other does not.

[@HashimAziz1]

@@jamalkhalil77 The definition of eternal in any English dictionary does not include anything to do with a beginning. Both eternal and everlasting are synonyms that mean "to have no end".

[@harrisdean8285]

Genuine question here... If Hell is NOT forever then will Non-Muslims go to Heaven eventually?

[@mcbxbiiix1767]

Yes. There are even non-Muslims who will go directly to heaven. That’s what the Quran says.

[@G_Singh222]

@@mcbxbiiix1767 where ?

[@FatJackedNerd]

Hassan Farhaan al Maliki

[@mohamedbinishaq3169]

@@G_Singh222 only if they really didn't get the message and the message wasn't that good

[@imanf3882]

This is a really complex question that I don't recommend you ask on KZbin!

[@wasay456]

Using the exact same word "Khalideen", we can't draw two different conclusions. To me, that sounds flawed reasoning. If hell is definitely not eternal, heaven wouldn't be either. Otherwise, to convey such a drastic differences between the two, Quran would have used a different "eternity" word.

[@G_Singh222]

Allah promised eternal heaven, not eternal hell

[@davidjohnston7733]

U don't out or pay it off dont go to he'll be sorry

[@davidjohnston7733]

Hell is forever millions of times

[@G_Singh222]

No

[@Alburr250]

Would you want to end up there?

[@g_m15]

I don't believe Heaven is eternal, as for all times. But eternal for as long as time. And God is out of time frame. And Hellfire will not have people that don't deserve being there, dont know more than this regarding it.

[@rabeafaraj1930]

You mean heaven has an expiration date?

[@FatJackedNerd]

Farhaan al Maliki and Javed Ahmed Ghamidi's work.