ARE NASHEEDS REALLY HARAM?? ALI DAWAH

[@AliDawah]

As salam u alaikum. Brothers & sisters I'm genuinely trying my best to get the marriage documentary out, but please understand some footage got stolen so please bare with me. It will be worth it in sha Allah.

[@e17hl97]

Ali Dawah nice video akhi

[@hibadurrani3136]

Ali Dawah in shaa Allah all of us will be patient , thank you so much for making all the effort and sharing with us your experience :) Salamu alaikum

[@taffers147]

Ali Dawah Salaam Akhi, I really liked listening to Omar Eva's halal version of Tum Hi Ho, but I stopped because I thought that it may be that this nasheed is imitating the disbelievers. What do you think about this? Is it ok to listen to that? JazakAllah khair.

[@trueicecoldfire]

Ali Dawah if you wish to know what the majority thinks of you , You'll never know, but you do know what those that matter think of you , now you do., may Allah SWT bless you with patience and Ihsaan of a true Muhsin. JazakhaAllahuKhayran for the nasheed and everything you do especially Hide Park!!!

[@2009abuabdullah]

Tafhim Chowdhury I felt the same! it's buying those 0% alcohol drinks as an alternative to 0% plus alcohol drinks. they look similar but the content is different. so one can mistake you of drinking alcohol from a far distance. so we avoid things that imitate haram things to stop the confusion. Allah knows best!

[@theprince8079]

May ALLAH guide us to the straight path, Ameeen

[@allysuckblackisback7746]

Zainab Abubakar what dya meen?

[@PowerMotivation924]

Ameen

[@AryanKhilji596]

Ameen

[@HalalOrder]

Ameen

[@dawahaltawheed6200]

He also said (may Allaah have mercy on him): There has been a lot of talk about Islamic nasheeds. I have not listened to them for a long time. When they first appeared there was nothing wrong with them. There were no duffs, and they were performed in a manner that did not involve any fitnah, and they were not performed with the tunes of haraam songs. But then they changed and we began to hear a rhythm that may have been a duff or it may have been something other than a duff, and they began to choose performers with beautiful and enchanting voices, then they changed further and began to be performed in the manner of haraam songs. Hence we began to feel uneasy about them, and unable to issue fatwas stating that they were permissible in all cases, or that they were forbidden in all cases. If they are free of the things that I have referred to then they are permissible, but if they are accompanied by the duff or performers are chosen who have beautiful and enchanting voices, or they are performed in the manner of indecent songs, then it is not permissible to listen to them. Al-Sahwah al-Islamiyyah (p. 185).

[@alishataylor9480]

Still waiting for the marriage documentary lol

[@nafreviews3818]

Alisha Taylor yesss

[@afzalrahman]

Still waiting for the marriage documentary 😂😂

[@dssssa100]

Why are people obsessed by it???

[@slaveofthemostmerciful178]

Danyal, RP I’m 2 weeks in the future . Still waiting

[@abdulsubahan3903]

@Alisha Taylor Even in 2020 we are waiting 🤔🤔

[@ahmedw5]

Ali dawah i love you bro and i want to give you a good advice insha Allah. Don't break your words. You promised your fans that documentary different months and didn't release it when those months came. I am sure you have your reasons and i personally don't really mind when you release it either. But always keep your word and promises akhi. May Allah bless you.

[@artinsey]

Akhi I know your only advicing, but you don't know what's going on in his life and it seems like he has been going through a lot lately so if I were you I'd just forgive him.

[@ahmedw5]

Read what i wrote brother. I actually don't care when it's released. I even said " *I am sure you have your reasons and i personally don't really mind when you release it either*". So for me it doesn't really matter. I just wanted to advice my bro Ali to always keep his word.

[@mohammedzakariya428]

Flam Hahahhahahah. Relax bruv.

[@artinsey]

... Not sure what you mean by ó

[@bengaminrdx168]

no chill no sabr

[@anonymoose9322]

The best Halal alternative to music is the the speech of Allaah ('Azza wa Jal), the Qur'aan. And yes, there is a difference of opinion with regards to the permissibility of Nasheeds. But the addictive aspect of it, should also be pointed out. For example, eating food (that is Halal of course) is fine, but eating too much, can have many disadvantages, such as making you lazy, which in turn will make it very difficult for you to worship Allaah. So listening to Nasheeds (with the conditions mentioned in the video) is fine in general, but it can become addictive, so much so that it will have an opposite effect on you than the one it was supposed to achieve (i.e, to bring you to the worship of Allaah, etc). In addition, it should also be pointed out that there is a difference between singing and reciting poetry. The companions did write and recite poems, but they didn't sing as you see Nasheed artists usually doing. In fact, the Salaf regarded singing as a trait belonging exclusively to women. Thus, they regarded men who sing as effeminate. Moreover, we should be following the footsteps of the scholars. The scholars do not listen to Nasheeds, though some of them may view it as permissible. The scholars in general, do not concern themselves with these issues, because they are more concerned with issues that affect the 'Aqeedah and Eemaan of the believer. So like them, we should also busy ourselves with the book of Allaah and the Sunnah of His messenger (sallallaahu 'alayhi wasallam), which will help us boost and strengthen our Eemaan and 'Aqeedah.

[@anonymoose9322]

@Anna No, just a brother sharing the truth and knowledge that is beneficial.

[@dawahaltawheed6200]

Shaykh Saalih al-Fawzaan (may Allaah have mercy on him) said: As for that which is called Islamic nasheeds, they have been given more time and effort than they deserve, to such an extent that they have become an art form which takes up space in school curricula and school activities, and the recording companies record huge numbers of them to sell and distribute, and most houses are full of them, and many young men and women listen to them, and it takes up a lot of their time, and they are listened to more than recordings of Qur’aan, Sunnah, lectures and useful lessons. Al-Bayaan li Akhta’ Ba’d al-Kuttaab (p. 342).

[@val44offame38]

When i thought about the matter i came to this very conclusion. Good to see that this Shaykh has the same stance on it. Thank you for sharing this information.

[@biba3025]

Dawah Al Tawheed finally somebody said what scholar says!

[@ThEOnEanDOnLyZaKiR]

I love ali dawahs laugh 😂

[@____5t]

where's that wedding documentary man??????¿¿¿¿¿¿

[@زينميجيل]

captainKaP yhhh we need that documentary akhiiiu

[@dawahtube136]

Ive been waiting for that too lool

[@sonianoori3005]

Im waiting 2..

[@relaxedplanet3431]

Jazakallahu khayr my muslim brothers. This is a question I had for many years and I never see someone to answer it for me but Allamdullilah its really beneficial and I hope their is some people who are out there like me who got their ansnwer back. May Allah reward you back for this dawa. Amiin.

[@mineabou]

Some people don't understand the concept of "Ikhtilaf"

[@MajinbrineHD]

Sarah H A

[@Savage-jk5he]

the reason i think people had a problem with it was because it sounded so similar to western RNB artist and rappers.

[@MissionIslam]

I was listing to the song Halal habibi from Omar Esa. It reminded me of the rnb songs I was listening in Jahilia. It's so easy to clear this problem. Show a Shaky the anashed clip and he will tell you if this is Halal ore Haram. Very easy Al hamdulillah

[@zakiali677]

Mission Islam did u even watch the video 😂😂😂 they showed all the shuyukh

[@HalalChef]

Good Video Akhi

[@ع.خ-م4ح]

The halal alternative is the Quran..

[@sohailzamani5506]

Lol Ali " we will do what we want and you can do back flips" lol brother Ali ur the best may Allah bless you.

[@dawahaltawheed6200]

Innovation means that anything that is newly invented into our religion not Done By our Messenger or By the Companions. Now ask your self would our Prophet or the companions even imitate those who are opposing The messenger or causing diversion from the Book of Allah.

[@Jjjkluejnek]

Brother Ali Dawah I support you all the way, I support what you do and the way you approach subjects alhamdurillah love your videos much respect to you and Must Adnan:)

[@leisure3683]

Musa's comment @14.29 got to the root of the problem. its a matter of them imposed their standards on others. (esp. people they think they can bully).

[@dawahaltawheed6200]

Hence some of the prominent Shaykhs who permitted nasheeds at first were upset by what nasheeds and munshids have become - and this was before they found out about the video clips - so they retracted the view that it is permissible or they stipulated conditions for it to be said to be permissible. Among these prominent Shaykhs are: Shaykh Muhammad ibn Saalih al-‘Uthaymeen (may Allaah have mercy on him). 1. He said (may Allaah have mercy on him): I think that Islamic nasheeds have changed from what they were before. They were done with voices that were not enchanting, but now they are done with enchanting voices, and they are also accompanied by evil and corrupting tunes and they say that they are accompanied by the duff, but all of this means that one should keep away from these nasheeds. But if a man comes to us and sings anaasheed that have a sound meaning, and which do not include any nonsense, and uses his voice only with no musical instruments, there is nothing wrong with that. Hassaan ibn Thaabit used to recite poetry in the mosque of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him). Duroos wa Fataawa al-Haram al-Madani, 1416 AH, question no. 18.

[@GracefulDeen]

There was nothing wrong with your deen squad nasheed, it's opening their eyes. May Allah guide Deen squad

[@Abdullah-vj1es]

may Allah bless u both and keep u firm on the religion insha Allah. jazakum Allah khair for this excellent video, and as Musa said, the best thing to do is to ignore people who keep attacking u coz you've proven ur point now. no more explanation needed on ur parts. may Allah bless u both insha Allah.

[@Abdullah-qd5gb]

Barak Allah Feekum (for the much needed video), may Allah keep yous on his Sirat al-Mustaqeem and forgive you your mistakes and shortcomings to Him. I think Ali was a bit shocked to when Musa said "50 Cent" due to his facial expressions, which was understandable lol. Once again, may Allah keep you guys on goodness and forgive all your shortcomings to Him. Jazakum Allah Khairaa :)

[@lisagreen1860]

Just watched the video........... Its soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo Good !!!!!!!!! Why such videos don't go viral where there is some real wise beneficial message for the young Muslims and non muslims, a message to the whole humanity............... I hope and pray this video goes viral ................. Surely you will get some stick over it, you will always have someone who cannot bare seeing others actually doing something impactful because they themselves are unable to make any positive impact on others other than just run their talking shops and feel good about it.......... keep up the good work guys !!!!

[@Youman-tu8wr]

I really want to meet Ali dawah one day inshallah

[@RealTarekAhmed]

Have Ali Dawah and Dawah Man gone their separate ways?

[@iesakhan3413]

I don't think so

[@mybigbellybutton1552]

I think so because on snapchat he videoed one of his friends and said "Don't worry this is one of the only safe ones left" or something like that. And also, When Dawah man made a video about ItsKhaled (siddiq) when he listened to that Sufi music. Dawah man was saying something like "even people who don't speak to me anymore and don't associate with me anymore but have worked with Khaled have came out and made a video about him" So i think maybe dawah man could've been referring to Ali and Ali could've been referring to Dawah man in the first quote. Also they don't make vids anymore. Idk tho this is just a guess, could be wrong but that's wot i thought init.

[@SYED7JUNAID7ALI7]

+Max Lames filthy language from a filthy mouth.......no wonder you find Imran problematic

[@SYED7JUNAID7ALI7]

+InsTa Rewind Shaykh Fawzan said t"he whole Qur'an is a refutation"........it is obligatory upon every Muslim to refute falsehood

[@SYED7JUNAID7ALI7]

+Max Lames are you a Muslim?

[@TheBlessedVerses]

watch the evolution of fiqh part 4 by moutasem al-hameedy inshallah. it's a bit long, but near the beginning he talks about differences in opinion and how we shout be tolerant. it's beneficial and worth the watch.

[@battalionlead4128]

Marriage documentary please brother Ali-Dawah ??? may Allah (SWT) bless you.

[@rashedrahman7800]

you said omar esa abstained from music yet he makes Muslim version of "Adele-hello" and many more. He had to listen to the music to create the "halal version" right?

[@khawlaabdusamad5974]

Omar Esa 4 years ago 'Bismillahirrahmanirraheem Assalamu Alikum Warahmatullahi Wabarakatahu my brothers and sisters in Islam and humanity. I wanted to clarify why I have done a version of this song. One of the first reasons I want to point out is, I hear the original ‘Hello’ song everywhere, I can't go outside without hearing this song, it’s played on tv, on radio, shopping centres, even from people cars lol, it's everywhere. So as I write and compose nasheeds, I can pick up melodies that I hear very quickly Alhamdullilah, so because I have heard this song in many places without me knowing they will play this song, I picked up the melody and heard the lyrical content behind the original song, I don’t know the full meaning of the song and this is because I don’t listen to music, so I have not sat down and studied this song or anything SubhanAllah. It’s better to be clear on these matters, so no assumptions are made. So the reason I have ultimately done a version to this song in a voice only nasheed format is because I have seen and heard a lot of Muslims speak about this song, so I thought it is my duty to do a Muslim version of this song into a nasheed and talk about the most important relationship in a muslims life, Allah! And even in a non muslims life God is the most important relationship in their lives. Now my version is re-written, I have used the original song lyrics in just a few obvious places, there is also another point I talk about in my version of ‘Hello’ and that’s about, out of wedlock relationships between a guy and a girl, they are not from Islam, so if you like a girl ask for her hand in marriage and sister if you honour yourself marry him In'shaa'Allah. And lastly I wanted Muslims to have an alternative version to this song, when a song is so popular they are going to promote it everywhere, so the majority of this world will hear that song. So now In'shaa'Allah my Muslim and non Muslim brothers and sisters can listen to my version in their cars or homes In'shaa'Allah. Thanks to Almighty ALLAH (subhanahu wa ta’ala) I believe 'Whatever music can do, so can the voice and my voice is my instrument’ Alhamdullilah.'I FOUND THIS IN THE COMMENT SECTION OF THE VIDEO.

[@gojirarulle6036]

I actually listen to nasheeds almost all of the time.

[@nafreviews3818]

Where's the wedding documentary ?

[@noorakhan9035]

"Shut up its halal!" 😂😂😂

[@ibrahimmahmud2720]

Even though you guys said it wasn't going to be biased. It was still kinda biased

[@sonilzaki]

LOOOOL the ending😭😭 "you can do backflips, you can do front flips, you can do somersault" 😭😭😭😭 you're too funny Akhi

[@khiz789]

"You can do back-flips, you can do front-flips, do somersaults if you like" this cracked me up Ali Dawah you legend

[@UthmanG]

I love videos from these two mash'Allah

[@RadianceNiya]

Love these brothers for the sake of Allah, Masha'Allah keep up the good work! 💯👍🏽

[@grizwoldmayor6671]

So many brothers and sisters in our community call something out to be 'haram', but never provide any halal alternative. Zina is haram, but don't get married till you have ____! Music is haram, but don't listen to permissible (according to many opinions) nasheeds! Etc. Also - don't these people realise that, by calling out each and every thing to be something 'haram', they are walking the tightrope? One mistake is all it would take to throw them into those that change/bring innovations to the religion.

[@salimam6213]

So is maher zain's nasheeds haram because they consist of music however the words he uses is linked to the prophet Muhammed Pbuh and Allah swt.

[@uzeirsantos2061]

Salima M actually his musics are haram, even though it is mentioned God and his prophet

[@salimam6213]

uzeir santös so the haram in it is the instruments played and not what is being said?

[@uzeirsantos2061]

Salima M that is right, the only thing that is not permissible is the instrument, without the instrument you can listen to it

[@salimam6213]

uzeir santös Jazak'Allahu alf khair brother

[@uzeirsantos2061]

Salima M wa'iyak.

[@anas_5485]

Mashallah love ur videos I watched u for soooooooooo long May allah reward you and ur videos make me laugh

[@abdullahislam8083]

It sounded like a bass guitar in the 'Deen squad' nasheed?

[@I.M.CROW.]

is there a rhythm to the nasheeds? Eg 1234 2234 3234 where you know another word will follow on that exact moment.. Is there a certain tune to it?? A certain melody Where you can hum the nasheed without saying the word Does the nasheed stay in your head repeating?? Because of the rhythm and the tune... Is it something that comes to your head random moments especially during prayer?? Like twinkle twinkle little star.. (i have a baby boy so it comes to my head once in a while) Basically the point is, say you used a surah in the rhythem and the tune of twinkle twinkle little star without any background music isn't that exactly like what nasheeds are but with a different tune and rhythms that you can nod your head to??????????? Again I am no scholar/learned individual when it comes to our deen or music for that matter, but you should see how similar nasheeds are to the general music. Take away the words and listen to the tune and the timing of every word, and you will notice what I am trying to point out. Anyway Inn Sha Allah you get what I am trying to say there. kzbin.info/www/bejne/jGGUlIhueN2im8U

[@samidica]

True! The Nasheeds on time of the Prophet s.a.w. are not like the nasheeds that these people are doing today. We twist things so it can be convenient for our life not even thinking or feeling that it is not Islamic. Poetry is the description of nasheed but these people's doings are not nasheeds at all.

[@johnmarston4847]

*Asalamu alaykum* brothers and sisters let brother Ali take as long as he wants with this documentary. Don't ask him remember what the prophet Muhammad salallah hualayhe wasalam said about begging people for stuff even asking. asalamu alaykum brother Ali, even if the documentary is 1 minute long that would be fine it's nice of you to do but these videos are much better:) May Allah let us stay on the haqq til death and have mercy on us all

[@Kiimii_]

😂😂😂😂 I find it so funny how they both started of caaalmm and then towards the end they're like 'WHO THE HELL ARE YOU....' 😂😂😂... But carry on the support brothers towards what's halal and good. May Allah guide us all. ☺️

[@fawzanziyad608]

Assalam Alaikum Brothers, I have a qn about doing vocal effects. Because there are some nasheeds with vocal effects and sometimes also they sound like music.Whats your opinion about it? Just wanted my doubt to be cleared JazakAllahu khayran

[@fatimagaraad3692]

aslaam aliakum brother ali dawah keep doing what u r doing the thing is people don't knw what's haraam and halaal that make's them confused may Allah guide us all

[@cr5653]

Please provide the link of that nasheed which was played to the scholars.

[@tasneemdivelli5475]

Slm can I ask if like Omar ESA does if making songs into nasheeds like the Adler song hello for example or Bollywood songs? Just enquiring brother not judging

[@nayeemhoque9303]

I agree even before this video but I'm happy and Ali Dawah please do more videos

[@muslimndproud2146]

Well said....❤️☝🏼 Keep up the good work.

[@iffatsultana5295]

SubhanAllah I love that musa mentioned Hassan bint Thabit and that the Prophet salalahu alihi wasalam allowed his beautiful poetry about the Prophet salalahu alihi wasalam. Nasheeds are just words or poems bringing hearts towards Allah Subhanahu watala and the messenger of Allah salalahu alihi wasalam there is only goodness in this. May Allah Subhanahu watala allow us the opportunity to continue to bring hearts towards Islam ameen Ya Rabbil alameen

[@danishkim007]

Brother Ali, why did you upload this video only in 360p quality? And I fear that Alfan Group may claim a copyright on your video and may block this video as you have used video clip from "Rahman Ya Rahman" Nasheed of Shaikh Mishary, they have blocked and claimed copy right on this Nasheed when I uploaded it on my KZbin channel. Even they blocked and muted so many Islamic Da'wah videos and lectures just because there was audio Nasheeds of Shaikh Mishary Rashid Al-Afasy in the starting or ending as background sound. So beware of it! JazaakAllahu Khairan!

[@irfansaeedkhan7242]

mean that nasheed is not for ALLAH but only making money as they don't allow other muslims to use them.

[@ayaanali5965]

Oh thanks my special man Ali-dawah nice name mashallah Oh Allah please bless Ali-dawah😍😍😍

[@nas19281]

Is Maher Zain’s ‘Nasheeds’ halal and if not, are his vocals only Nasheeds okay if his Nasheeds with what sounds like instruments in the background allowed?

[@saadsiddiqui9001]

Asak. Just saying when free mixing is mentioned are we talking about the mixing of men or women or free mixing music? That term always throws me off.

[@randomspice6921]

can anyone give me a link to the nasheed they're talking about, please

[@bilalibnfulan8849]

Brother i saw this video as I was searching for anwsers. I've been trying to learn more about our religion hamdollilah and started with binging the stories of the Prophets and these video's contained huming and nasheed etc so I was wondering if this was okay, thats how I stumbled upon your video Subhana'Allah. This might have been the right timing as i remember the stories very well and can pull a resemblence out of them for this situation. As I understand where you're anwser is coming from but I see something far greater happening in this that I fear and please correct me if i'm wrong. But look at the stories of Nuh (AS), Hud(AS),Salih(AS) Shu'ayb(AS) how Shaytaan has deceived those people and I know what you think this sounds extreme but hear me out please. Allah has put these stories in the Quran not for our sake and amusement but to draw lessons out of them and learn from them, and in these stories all the people of the prophets they were deceived by shaytaan to do shirk step by step right? they either worshipped statues of good people, trees or themselves. Now shaytaan did convince them in 1 go, what he did is he started out as a good preacher sometimes saying look at this good soul he passed away how sad or to any other situation and conviced them to first honour the good in some way like a carving to remind them of the goodness it brougth . this could be applied to the tree or to people honouring themselves and it becoming a lifestyle and ideology. And it looked like a good thing not haraam to honour the good souls and remind them to do good right? that generation passed and the next ones came and what did he do? he said look they forgot, ur forefathers honoured them these are ur idiols the bring good, worship them and good will happen Allah u akbar. And every generationhe convinced them to go a step further. Now the resemblence im trying to draw here is with nasheed, its like u said an halal alternative to the haraam music we can't listen to? This could very well be a first step of shaytaan making us believe its innocent and a halal way of listening to something and before u know after several decades or years the next generation will forget what the difference is and small steps could ( i say could allah knows best) be taken towards who knows changing text you know one step could allow a certain sound to be allowed and then the next and the enxt and before you know insturments and beats are comon for 'halal' nasheed as time passes and people forget. That's why i think we should stay away from something the sahaba and our prophet saw didnt do at all. As you mentioned the other sheikh disliked it cuz the sofi's do it and the reason for that is something else, our proophet said you are the people u imitate, and we know they classify themselves as a group a different sort, didnt our prophet said only 1 group will be saved on the day of judgement and that is the one that follows my sunnah ( now this is an explination of the sheikh that prohibits it and not my opinion or thought but i also believe this). If there is very little certainty and proof from the Quran and the sunnah that its permissible, then why take the risk to be questioned about it? thats what i always tell myself upon everything i do now that im studying Islam. My brother this is again my opiniona nd wanted to share it to see where this goes and get a uniting understanding in shaa allah, if there are other things that i dont know as im just deeping myself into Islam then please let me know May Allah bless us all and have peace upon us and our Prophet saw

[@armindedic8953]

Great message Alhamdoelillah

[@nowshinahmed8851]

Assalamualaikum brothers, what is your opinion about Muhammad Nadeem's nasheeds? can we listen to those?

[@saitamagaming977]

Wait so are the Nasheeds which have no lyrics in it, like just humming which we can clearly observe in most of today's Islamic Videos, are they permissible?

[@Khaled-kj1pq]

Is it true that you can only listen to nasheeds sung a member of your own sex? I.e. men can only listen to male nasheeds and women can only listen to female nasheeds. Also on the subject of musical instruments, is tapping and clicking a halal substitute, or is it haram since it's just imitating musical instruments??

[@Fit4mental]

My question is, I am trying to become a film maker and one of the things I see that music plays a huge part in this industry. I am currently trying to find my own style and looking to add something halal but I am really struggling with this. Nasheeds are a little too emotional for me and I don't want to put the quran while I talk because I feel that is disrespectful. Does anyone have any recommendations?

[@TheBlessedVerses]

none of this would happen if people studied usool al-fiqh and learnt about the difference between shariah and fiqh also differences of opinion.

[@realmeee]

@AliDawah , this is showing me in youtube algorithm to say to you . is publishing marriage documentary haram ?

[@muslimhabib7353]

Salamu Alaikum dear Brothers. I‘m from Germany and I love your work. May ALLAH Open you all the doors of Jennah and let you go in without seeing Jahanam. ALLAHUMA AMIN HERE MY QUESTION: If I do Nasheed, is it allowed for me to earn money with it, to reinvest it in my kind of dawah as Nasheed? And even if I woundn‘t reinvest it in my Nasheed could I take it just only to earn something? Maybe do you know how is the oppinion of the scholars about it? How does Omar Esa handle it? Thanks for your help. Your Brother in Deen.

[@aliscripture9334]

Correct me if I’m wrong but isn’t aren’t Nasheeds without music just poetry? And poetry is definitely permissible (as long as the content isn’t displeasing to Allah of course)

[@hibificational]

can you clarify on music that omar esa has done the Muslim version of. isn't this haraam because of the imitation of kufaar

[@rajanr144]

"You can do back flips, front flips, do somersaults if you like." 😂😂😂

[@plexiun7325]

AsSalamuAlaikum Which nasheed did they show to the scholars in Arabia?

[@abdulalbashir1566]

don't care about people's thoughts who are egoistic and are so not clued up stick in a bubble and stick to what your opinions are don't worry about other peoples opinions #its all about respect i like listening to omar esa as he actually sings just with his voice i am a young man 23 and i like listening to his nasheeds

[@zainabali-zr4qpufifhtg6gu6h6]

vocals with nasheed are allowed or not?

[@nouunii]

usually you but this beautiful melody in the begining of your videos could you tell me what it is called?

[@yas8749]

hana amiri farhat al Amr

[@humzaali7398]

legends say if your early ali dawah will reply back 😏😏

[@ibnjareerassuyuti5022]

Humza Ali 2 years later

[@whatpsychology4704]

3 years later 😂🤣

[@HossainAbid1310]

It's been over 4 years🤣

[@zakariyakhan9439]

4 years later

[@muaawiyalangley7292]

Also to point out that the whole argument of the Sufis do it so we shouldn't in batil. One of the most popular nasheed artists in the world is shaykh Mishary, a Salafi so that point is rendered moot. We are just as known for them as they are. If we are going to a abandon something just because the Sufis do it then we should not talk about Dhikir, zuhd/tassawuf, salawat, etc...

[@naimaguhad5232]

Muaawiya Langley Assalamu alaikum Just because a salafi does something doesn't mean that it is good or even permissible. Secondly, some of the things you mentioned are things that have been prescribed for us in the Quran and sunnahs and it doesn't affect our devotion or frequency of said acts even if deviant sects like the Sufi follow these practices

[@muaawiyalangley7292]

Naima Guhad That's my point. The argument of of any of the brothers who categorically say nasheeds are Haram because it's something the Sufis are known for. This argument is weak due to the fact that one, we are just as known for nasheeds as they are and two, just because to devients among the Sufis are known for something does not necessarily mean that we can't do it.

[@rahimo7869]

If a nasheed has music in it but the nasheed was calling towards goodness and the worship of Allah, would it be classed as halal?

[@biba3025]

So even we have this Glorious Qur'an we still need nasheeds? Oh my...😔 There is difference between reciting poetry and SINGING IT!!

[@imraansaleh]

Asalamwalaikum, great job. The message is pure, however I believe this song was mixed, there in an echo when the spoken word is being said, a mixer is a musical instrument. I think is should be edited one more time, without the echo, simplified. Just spoken word. Other than that I have no objections. Allah knows best. Asalamwalaikum. Thank you.

[@abdusalam3ar]

Brother, not only the scholars you qouted say it's okay, but also almost all the scholars in Syria, Jordan, Egypt, Libya and very many others their opinions are just like you described. one more thing You mentioned Sufis, do you know who they are and what the Sufi Way (Sufiah) is? what it actually means?

[@ahlulhadith6367]

مصمم الرسومات sufism is not allowed

[@anonymous-vr4yg]

Well said brother Ali & brother Musa

[@mohammedzakariya428]

Omar Easa makes me cringe :-/

[@ibbyyyyy3577]

Same, he tries way too hard

[@MRYMYHR]

mohammed zakariya check out the nasheeds on our page :)

[@MRYMYHR]

HENCH786 check out the nasheeds on our page :)

[@mooey87]

mohammed zakariya Omg me too. Thought i was the only one 😂

[@AaliyahVawdaHorse]

Then dont watch his videos :)

[@noorakhan9035]

"Piety attack"😂😂😂😂😂

[@mooey87]

The problem is you either get people who say everything is haram or people who say everything is fine, as long as you're Muslim it's cool. People need to realise that unfortunately not every issue is black & white, like salah, hijab etc and that in certain issues you just need to agree to disagree, if someone has evidence to back their argument then leave them be.

[@asadmomin6178]

Which nasheed are they talking about?

[@binoush369]

Nasheed.. that makes people close to Allah💞 without music

[@AT.Dawkins.Plato.Khayam]

dear brothers assalamu alaikum, i allways watch brother ali's videos and have benefitted a lot and will continue to do so in the future. i disagree with your interpretation of music because it is not academically and spiritually right and i advise you to rethink about your approach to the subject. the use of a persons mouth as a music instument (so to mimic the instrument with human voice) in my humble opinion is same as using the instrument itself, if we take the shaytan anology here, he is actually making a mockery out of a person who uses his mouth as a substitute to music instruments. the same goes for using natural sound (water, wind and etc). it is same as bying a house through so called islamic banks who charge people the same interest as conventional banks but call it muzaraba to make it seem halal. i respect you and love you brother Ali and Musa.

[@1milliondiamonds336]

Jzk for this video

[@txtkill6138]

Ali,Does Music really Haram?i mean you make things clear about Nasheed, but do the popular music is haram even the content in the music is not contains any negativity?if it does, is it told in the qur'an or in hadits?

[@hands1301]

Guys even though it says this music/ nasheed is done by deen squad and these guys. I don't see deen squad in this video Am I blind or is there no deen squad in this??????

[@sumibegum8923]

But I want to know if music is haram?

[@tanvirbashar3077]

I mean when it comes to musical instruments, There is a difference of opinion but majority of scholars have said its haram and obviously instruments with bad lyrics and meaning is haram without a doubt. I just try my best to avoid musical instruments. Also there is a fatwa by ibn tamiyyah, that is good for whoever takes the view instruments are haram or something to avoid, that if you hear instruments you are not sinful but if you listen to it attentively or jam to it then you are but allah knows best.

[@truth3137]

Is beatboxing haram?

[@SoRealTube]

Asslamu alykum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuhu Mashallah awesome video. But if anything this should give you a clear insight to those people who support brothers like Deen Squad because they say, "this is giving people an alternative & bringing people closer to Allah". Deen Squad will probably claim their scholars say it's halal & they played it to them as well. Please address if possible. jazzahkum Allahkhyr.

[@MrArchitecture1]

Salam ali Ive been watching your videos for the latter half of the year or so- and i told my brother about your channel- and he told me that you are a wahabi? Can you respond to this comment- as i had thought that you was a sunni- muslim. I enjoy your vids and keep up the good work.

[@MultiSlickguy]

MrArchitecture1 salaam brother, yes they are Sunni Muslims however, if I'm correct when you label them Wahhabis you mean that you are a Sunni who is a follower of Sufism and its branches for example naqshbandi/barelwi. These sects tend to refer to a lot of groups different to them as Wahhabis in a derogatory way. Forgive me for any mistakes

[@MrArchitecture1]

MultiSlickguy to my knowledge- wahabi muslims think muhammad (pbuh) should be praised as a human being- whereas sunni's show special care and respect to Muhammad (pbuh) - but i would love for ali dawah to respond so this discussion can be put to rest.. i dont think his actually clarified weather his a sunni or not.. (i might be wrong, if so please forward the video) im not trying to cause confusion or division.

[@azizbinibraheem]

I always heard the original salafi opinion is that Nasheeds are in general all haraam whether it contains music or doesn't. Also would you agree that the kibaar ulama may differ on many things.

[@kingman5049]

اخي علي انا مسلم من كوردستان العراق اريد رقمك للتواصل معك اخي، ارجوا الرد نحن من دعاة الكرد

[@red_alert]

This was basically true but getting a bit irritating towards the end

[@Nokiman7]

What about that group "The Deen Squad"?

[@ashn7446]

The Shaykh is qualified in giving fatwah and opinions. Not us ignorant unqualified Muslims. I'm totally ignorant but learning. People stop being narrow minded it's truly not spiritually and emotionally healthy but your going to harden your heart even more. I've experienced it. Stop judging people. It's not fair and Allah loves good character and acts justly.

[@kareemahagboola8888]

Every action shall be judged according to intention...

[@remcsqaure]

Sorry bros, i don't see how on earth Omar Esa can cover well known mainstream songs without listening to them. Adele - Hello - Charlie Puth Ft Wiz Khalifah etc all his covers. How does he cover these songs without listening to those songs? Surely he must have to catch the lyrics, to get the melody, structure and all that about the song. Brothers, careful please, saying one thing and doing another is not on. Don't sit there saying you dont listen to music when in fact you do. Love you guys for the sake of Allah, but honestly, please explain this to me. How does he learn these songs and then make covers of them????

[@mahamahdi469]

Lets assume the best. Maybe he heard it when he was out in a mall or restaurant. You can stop but hear music wherever you go nowadays

[@remcsqaure]

@@mahamahdi469 to cover a song you would actively need to engage with the song.

[@tabassumtabassum9635]

can women recite nasheeds in presence of family (include non mehram cousins)

[@amadousabally7958]

Ma'shaa'Allah tabarak'Allah....