Are Stitch Fix or Wantable Worth the Hype? Let's Decide Together! | Jen Luv

Today, we're diving into the world of clothing subscriptions and exploring two of the biggest curated fashion boxes: Stitch Fix and Wantable. Are they really worth the hype? We are putting them both to the test and I need your help to decide which one comes out on top. So sit back, relax, and let's talk about it!
Purchase Links
If you sign up using these links, I earn a credit toward my next box.
Wantable www.wantable.com?invite_token=139DGkEwH84
Stitch Fix www.stitchfix.... (You get $50 credit, and I get $50 credit, but just until March 12th!)
----------------------------------------------------------------
Curious about my current favorite skincare and makeup products? I've got a bunch for you all in one place! shop.howl.me/J...
Thanks for subscribing to my channel (www.youtube.co...) ! I specialize in thorough makeup reviews that give you WAY more than the typical KZbin review including ingredient analysis, close up finger/brush swatches, and MORE! You'll also find What's Up in Makeup on Sunday mornings giving you the most UP TO DATE information about what is happening in the beauty industry, new product releases and MORE!
Want to be part of the Collective Brain Elite? Join HERE for $1.99 per month - / @jenluv
FTC: This is not a sponsored video.
Out-tro Music: Dimples by Oomiee via Epidemic Sound
*******************
Want to help out with What's Up in Makeup? Check out our Hunters group! / wuimhuntersofficial
*******************
Instagram: jenluvsreviews
TikTok: www.tiktok.com...
*******************************
Affiliate Code
Save 20% off at Farmacy with code JENLUVSREVIEWS20
Save $5 at ColourPop with code JENLUV
Save 10% at Alter Ego with code JENLUVS
CURRENT SETUP:
IKEA Alex Drawers (9): go.magik.ly/ml...
IKEA Alex Drawers (5): go.magik.ly/ml...
Main Camera: shop-links.co/...
FAVORITE Lens right now: shop-links.co/...
Lens Adapter for GH5: shop-links.co/...
Best Lights: amzn.to/3adDo7B
Diffuser for Best Lights: amzn.to/2Tarfe5
Good Lights: amzn.to/2TuDjaa
Vlog Cam(Great Starter for YT): amzn.to/2PBgeOm
Good Mic: amzn.to/2NkeNpR
Best Mic: amzn.to/2PyJ1FP
AWESOME LENSES FOR MY PHONE! : shop-links.co/...
Tripod: shop-links.co/...

[@stephanietruax948]

I always use a rule of thumb that if I’m on the fence about something, I just don’t get it because i probably won’t wear it. I’ll reach for things that I know I love over that. The earrings are very cute btw!

[@Andytheevien]

True if you don't love it and it's super useful like I buy shirts from Kathmandu (Australia). They have invisible pockets with a zip, quick dry fabrics, vented in the shoulder blades and the colours is a beautiful miss green.

[@danishgrl3]

just a tip, a lot of these tops/sweaters will look less "frumpy" if you pair it with higher waisted jeans and do a front tuck so you can actually see your waist. leaving a non-cropped top free flowing over your jeans is pretty much always going to look more frumpy than taking an extra second to style them :) that's why I usually try to go from slightly cropped styles to begin with. cropped doesn't have to mean exposing your stomach, you just have to pair it with higher waisted pants so that the shirt hits where your pants end

[@eiremerald]

I’m also noticing how the crotch of Jen’s jeans hang a bit lower than they should, so that’s probably not helping either.

[@laurend7816]

I'm pretty sure Jenn prefers mid to low rise jeans, but the front tuck works with those as well. I'm a fan of the front tuck.

[@subtlesandy632]

Keep the jacket. It will go with everything most of the year. Dress looks great. You can probably get those shoes $20-$25 cheaper in 2 months. I buy shoes off season all the time to save money

[@khills]

@@subtlesandy632 yeah, but she won’t - she doesn’t like shopping, so I doubt she’s going to make a list and check the stores in 2-3 months. She’s basically paying a convenience tax. 🤷🏼‍♀️

[@jkschnik6952]

The dress/jacket/earrings combo looked like it would be great for going out for dinner with John. Cute outfit!

[@Outrageous86]

I agree loved that as an outfit

[@coffeebeforemascara]

And it made for a nice looking bootie 🍑 The dress fabric draped perfectly!

[@eatmyoctopus]

The color of the jacket doesn’t go with the dress at all. Both pieces look good on her but not together.

[@Outrageous86]

@@eatmyoctopus I personally would wear them together. Style is meant to be unique. If we all dressed the same imagine how boring the world would be! 💕

[@eatmyoctopus]

@@Outrageous86 Style is definitely unique! For me, the tones were too different. I’d wear the jacket with the dark pink top. They would look great together with some cool accessories.

[@staceybailey2029]

I would keep the Stitch Fix box. That dress, jacket and earring combo scream date night. Looking good.

[@tia_ln]

The rust colored sweater looks great on you and will be nice during cooler spring days! The entire Stitchfix box was great honestly. The only thing in Wantable that was worth buying was the be a nice human sweatshirt. Everything else was a hard no.

[@wendilafever7357]

Yes the rust looks great

[@bluedropx]

I love the shoes! I'd keep the whole stitch fix box

[@susanpeltier3333]

That light weight sweater seems perfect for Spring…it’s something that’d be cute with shorts too!

[@susanmenn5016]

Agreed. I think she should keep the whole Stitch Fix box. The boots are really cute...just not for spring but would be perfect for fall.

[@Rockin711]

I'd keep the stitch fix box! That dress is GORGEOUS on you!!!

[@Dus10johnson]

LOVE the shoes, LOVE the jacket, love the dress, love the be kind sweatshirt

[@lauriehutchinson791]

That's all I would keep.

[@britbc4461]

Totally agree! The other stuff from stitch fix was nice but about 2x too expensive.

[@coffeebeforemascara]

Heh-heh, that's exactly what I said in a separate comment!

[@angienglish4434]

Now I have to go watch My Best Friend's Wedding...lol

[@kathareenmcknight8065]

You should totally keep the entire Stitch Fix box. I love the dress, earrings, coat combo on you. You could also probably pair the boots with that outfit. I’ve seen a lot of younger women wearing dresses and boot combos like that.

[@Outrageous86]

Some of those tops would have looked so flattering with a French tuck. It’s not always about the shirt but how you tweak it to flatter you personally!

[@AshleyBrooke81]

I think you should keep the entire box. I really liked the sweater on you, actually. That color is great with your skin tone and hair. And the boots were really cute too.

[@michaela3910]

LOVE the dress/jacket/earrings combo! Please keep it 🙂

[@Christine-49]

Everything from Stitch Fix was a big win, in my opinion. I loved that thin sweater, I though it looked amazing on you. Also, a blue jean jacket would be super cute with the dress.

[@erinlynn9962]

"Because I'm cheap!" same

[@Katcraz]

Love your energy so much ❤️ The "Be a Nice Human" sweatshirt is so great, and you look fabulous in the dress - definitely can wear the jacket with it for a more casual look. Also love the boots, but if you prefer your other pair and would reach for those over the new ones with the same outfits, they might not be worth it. For all the shirts/sweaters, I personally just couldn't justify the prices!! But maybe I'm just used to shopping at Marshalls and Goodwill haha

[@redraven7948]

That jacket and dress are BEAUTIFUL! You looked very pretty with the earrings,jacket. & dress combo. The shoes are really nice as well. That pink shirt style I see on more younger people. Think Victoria Secret style. The Stitch Fix box is a winner!

[@Shelbys_Smalltown_Beauty]

I can totally relate when you said about telling them that you are in your 30s when they try to style your box. I get a subscription box and I have to do a beauty quiz and at the end it asks my age and I always put that I am 30 when I'm actually 49, that way I don't get all skincare stuff for wrinkles and aging. I get a nice mix of cosmetics and skincare and lifestyle in my box this way. There is always a way around it to get what you want. Good luck

[@lorindachristine3291]

Stitch Fix nailed it. I like a thinner sweater (like that orange one) for the in-between, spring/fall seasons. The dress, boots, jacket, and earrings are all adorbs.

[@JaimeLeighArt]

Watching Jen try on clothes is the cutest thing ever 😂

[@gdeannecampbell1067]

The jacket is a solid great investment piece that you can wear for many years. LOVE the earrings!!😘👍👍

[@cyntheknitter9927]

Honestly, that orange cable sweater would look beautiful over the dress

[@oceanasong]

You have a fabulous figure and looked good in everything! I loved everything from Stitch Fix. I want those boots for myself. I would keep the whole Stitch Fix box.

[@jo4vt]

Oh my goodness, I would be so freaking excited if you did an online session with Melissa Murrell (MM Peraonal Style). I love watching her videos for fashion and styling advice, and she does online as well as in person styling. You could do a whole collaboration. ❤

[@susanpunako8590]

I do really think it’s in your best financial interest to buy the whole stitch fix box. You can always sell the sweater or get a different bra without the harder seams that show through. Or gift it to a family member. The sweatshirt from Wantable is cool. I’d keep that one too. But as far as the rest of that box. No. The stitch fix was real nice considering a pair of nice boots and earrings a jacket that looks good on you and the pretty dress! I say keep it all.

[@carolineclaudiaplante]

Stitch Fix, keep the box. :) Everything looked great. Much love!

[@mobehindtheskin]

If you do a simple French tuck with your tops/sweaters into your jeans or even joggers it gives you more shape and makes the look more polished in 3 seconds. It’s my go to! (I used to be a rep for z supply 😂)

[@marinac9339]

Yea I would keep the whole box, since you can always use the boots. The dress was beautiful on you and the earrings were cool too! The jacket is nice with that 2 type of material. The neck would bother me, but it looks nice on you!

[@nicoleserra8155]

The whole Stitch Fix box was amazing- I’d keep the whole box! The lighter sweater is great for transitioning from winter into spring and summer into fall.

[@wombatnumbat989]

The nice human sweatshirt is worth every penny! I also liked the brown v-neck top. Love the dress, the boots are a definite yes and the earrings are great - Keep that whole box. If the sweater feels thin, wear a cami - that cinnamon colour is lovely on you.

[@lizmillner414]

Stitch fix hit it over the park! The jacket, dress, earring are so frickin cute on you. The boots are totally wearable as well. Everyone tells me I should have been a stylist but I al 71 so its a little late for that in my life. Very smart looking pieces from SF!

[@TubbyTilly]

Your Stitch Fix rocked this time. If I were you I'd keep that whole box. The other box is trash.

[@nrosenchtejer]

I LOVE the boots! I honestly think everything in the stitch fix box is awesome for you and since you’re getting everything else, I would keep it all for the discount (but I genuinely like all of that on you 🤩) Love your videos!!!

[@aricelystorres4332]

I’m fairly new to your channel and you can take my personal opinion with a grain of salt. The boots and sweater are cute. Keep the Stitch Fix box. You can wear a cami under the cute cable knit sweater, that’s what I do when I happen to find a light/see through shirt/sweater I like.

[@anix670]

The entire dress outfit is fabulous! That jacket and the dress and earrings are a win! I also like the boots, nice colour. And you look good in them.

[@rhysphil9332]

Keep the whole stitch fix box

[@sunnyhollowjill]

The sweater would be a nice weight for layering. In the spring you can have a cold morning but by afternoon it can be very warm. The earrings are gorgeous on you! You have dark hair and they are a nice contrast. Thanks for sharing!

[@christinademaray7588]

Jen, Jen, Jen!!! Everything from the Stitch Fix box was great!! Of course I wasn't there to feel the quality of the rust colored sweater, but it looked nice too. The boots are a definite YES. I think you will be disappointed if you send them back. The dress looks INCREDIBLE, and the jacket...the jacket! I am so jealous! Bonus points if it is comfortable and not stiff in the arms. I think the earrings work great for you as well. In full disclosure, I have had stitch fix in the past, and while there were things I definitely sent back (including whole boxes) I enjoyed probably about 70 to 80% if what they sent. You're tempting me to re-subscribe! I don't know what to say about the Wantable box. I could never stomach paying that much for a sweatshirt - but what do I know. If it brings you joy, then it is very much worth it. The other stuff just didn't seem like "you" at all.

[@itsNinaLeeyo]

The dress is SO CUTE! Yes, love the boots. Will never go out of style. Those earrings are definitely something that I would buy so I like those too.

[@nancyvaden4078]

Keep everything from StitchFix!!! Worth it!! LOVED the dress, jacket, earrings & boots!!

[@palettesandpans]

I loved everything in the stitchfix - the full box is a yes for me! The jacket is drool worthy, and I know you were in the fence about the booties, but I thought they looked great on you!

[@jodenizaltihughes7522]

I would get the whole Stitch Fix as it all looks great on you

[@dolphinsgirl253]

the dress jacket earring combo was my favorite! and despite being overpriced that sweatshirt was made for you! i’m super particular about shoes and i only wear a small handful of brands so if you are on the fence i’d pass. i hate seeing shoes in my closet that i’ve only worn once or twice and end up selling them on poshmark and losing money in the end.

[@ajzmom]

I would keep the stitch fix box! All the pieces looked sooo good on you!! (Including the shoes!!! Love them!!) That box was a clear winner. From the other box, just keep the sweater you love!

[@mrs.jobeth3415]

Keep all of Stitch Fix. Wear the jacket with the sweater too! The boots are too cute!

[@laurend7816]

A tip with the boots, they'll look good with almost any outfit that has a warm palette, even if you aren't wearing red. You could even put on tights and wear them with a dress.

[@KibbyRose]

Keep the box!!! Having been a stitch fix, user myself I’m seriously impressed with the box you got and honestly if you like that many items in it it’s worth the discount to keep it… And the sweater really did look good on you. Just need a different bra😉🖤

[@Liz0519]

I'd probably keep the whole Stitch Fix box. Also that 'Be A Nice Human' sweatshirt is wonderful!

[@karenhowland6027]

I think you’re right-your coloring looks best with deeper tones like that chocolate brown Wantable sweater and maybe jewel tones. The pale pink and beiges wash you out. Color is just as important as fit and style. Try some high-waisted pants! Then do a front tuck with the looser fitting tops. 😊

[@pearlwinters5564]

I’d keep the whole box from stitch fix for sure. Those boots are sooo beautiful!

[@katykanevsky6753]

Hi, Jen! I'm sure you've already made your decisions but just a few things... 1. The color of the lavender haze t-shirt looked really good on you, I don't think it washes you out 🙃 2. That jacket!!! I. AM. HERE. FOR IT!!! 3. Love the boots I've, personally, never tried Wantable, but Stitch Fix has always been a win for me. I love these videos!!

[@AM-oy7cp]

Ohhh my... the dress and jacket worked so well 😍 The earrings are also something so nice. I like to see you in long earrings and dress. Wowwwww

[@abhimac27]

The jacket was so cool, I hate the way they feel with stiff sleeves. That was such a smart design. 🎊

[@lauradouglas4557]

Sweatshirt, boots, dress, earrings for sure. So fun to watch you!

[@snookat]

I LOVED the boots on you!! the top just needed a different bra. Love the earings too. I would get the whole box. I think you should just treat the boots like you do the brown ones and not worry so much about the color. I bet you get a ton of compliments on them even if they do not match your shirt. They look great with jeans. Love these cloths videos and your content Jen!!

[@serenakay5543]

If you buy a brown cami, and wear a different bra, the sweater may work. I agree with your choices! The pearls were so pretty dangling in your dark hair ❤

[@stephystill88]

I would keep the whole box. I usually keep the whole box of stitch fix if i love 4/5 and I “like” the 5th.

[@susanpeltier3333]

The dress, jacket & earring look so good on ya! Those boots are adorable! And the sweatshirt looks so you.

[@lisasmith7]

The dress and jacket are super cute. The boots are very cute. Keep the whole box. Have a great weekend. Mad love ❌️⭕️

[@kimgrandy_art_]

The earrings looked lovely on you. That dress was banging and the jacket gave it a hip vibe. KEEP!!

[@kimberlykreitzer7950]

Keep the whole box their all beautiful on u! I'd love to wear them!

[@audrastruikman8303]

I'd keep the stitch fix box as well. The dress was super cute on you . would be a comfortable dress for a date night as well as the earrings .

[@coffeebeforemascara]

YAAAASSSSS to the dress and jacket and boots. And yes to the Be a Nice Human sweatshirt

[@eleanorlaurent2303]

No to the pleather jacket and the boots, but other than those I agree with your choices 100%. That sweatshirt looks fantastic on you.

[@stacyana5888]

I would really encourage you to keep all 5 SFx pieces. I loved the boots & the burgundy with jeansa& a black sweater or even your Wantable hood would be adorable. I liked the dolman sweater & it's only $2;-)

[@Mama-de-Tia]

Earrings, dress and sweatshirt are all super cute on you but you should buy whatever makes you happy and gives you joy. ❤

[@Issamermaid]

Jen keep that whole stitch fix box!!! Those shoes are soooo cute!!

[@gdeannecampbell1067]

Jen, you have a FABULOUS figure!! Gurl, you totally rock that dress!! Definitely you need to wear more form fitting dresses like that one. I used to be a personal stylist so I’d suggest you get a diffuser jacket to wear with the dress as well as with tee shirts. Maybe a twill or even a dark rinse Jean jacket would be fun, youthful, flirty even. Stitch Fix definitely won in the category of best selection overall. You’d be really fun to dress!! You are simply adorable, Jen!!😘👍👍👍

[@gdeannecampbell1067]

*different jacket

[@adriannyc1]

I love the dress and jacket. All the rest I’d send back…. Except your happy sweater❤️

[@agaymerstale6191]

The dress is giving me serious SATC vibes. Love it!

[@tyrsis]

Tip. With those semi sheer / see-thru shirts you can always get a pretty long line crop cami and wear it underneath. So if it shows technically it’s a top but also you still have coverage.

[@IntentionalObserver]

Stitch Fix outfit at the end - dress, jacket, earrings - perfect outfit and if you already like the boots in another color then you should keep them. I wonder what the jacket would look like with the orange sweater.

[@krisem91]

I LOVE the Stitchfix boots. And that cable knit sweater.

[@marinac9339]

OMG I am fashion challenged also. I realized a year ago after I took a picture that I had that shirt for 10 years! So these fashion type boxes scare me. I'm so glad to see what they are really like. I'm also thinking like you, that $50 for a shirt is a lot!!

[@daphnegarzarelli-lawson324]

I loved everything in the stitch fix box!! The sweater is a spring sweater. It’s mean to be light. I think it would look so cute over the dress. The jacket!!! ❤❤❤ great earrings and I loved the red boots too!! I think you should keep it. Wantable…there stuff always looks like clothing made for no one. It always looks I’ll fitting on everyone. The sweatshirt is cute but I didn’t love the fit. Maybe it will be cuter w joggers. Good luck deciding!!

[@susancarter9504]

I wud keep the whole box, them boots are a unique colour that keeps surfaces every so many years, they r a staple item, the sweater is great for upcoming spring weather, u might get a wear

[@edwina9473]

I really like the brown jacket! I don't know about it with the dress, but I like both of pieces separate. They look great on you!

[@lvlysticgirl]

I loved the blue and white sweater! Do a French tuck and you'd probably have liked it more!

[@jenniferferrara6315]

Keep the entire Stitchfix box!!! This is probably one of my fave type of videos from u as I am same age range and hate shopping for my self! I think you should pair the stitchfix shirt/sweater with jacket, boots, jeans u had on and earrings!! Since the shirt is more lightweight and see thru, topping it with jacket would be perfect and the boots would look great with it as well! If u keep it he whole box, I wouldn’t even bother keeping sweatshirt from other subscription, not worth the money in my opinion…. Hope this helps and thanks for sharing it with us💜💜💜

[@ashleyd7023]

The cable knit sweater looked nice - I really likes the cut. I would just wear a thin tank top/cami under it and that will take care of the lines. I’d keep the full stitch fix box. I love cozy clothes…I loved the ones out of wantable but you’re right that’s a high price point for me! But I buy most of my clothes from TJ Maxx and Target so it may be reasonable to others.

[@nadiazanchetta1388]

Hey Jen, I say yes to the dress, jacket, earrings, and the sweater❤️ My preference in colors are purples, greens, blues for tops 💜♥️

[@luckofthree4301]

Jen, you honestly look amazing! The dress and jacket look so good together. 😊

[@lindarepin568]

I have those boots and wear them all the time. I'm looking for a different colour to add to my collection. I would keep everything in the stitch fix box. The dress is awesome, but then I think you would look good in a paper sack!

[@AMFibers]

I have that orange sweater from stitch fix and love it! It's a great transitional piece since it's lightweight. I can throw a cardigan over it for chilly mornings and then it's the perfect weight for office AC in the summer.

[@liss2503]

Earrings yes, dress yes, jacket yes, sweater yes, a t-shirt bra would make it look nicer or a tank top/camisole, boots if you have outfits that would work with them then yes because it would save wear and tear on the pair you got in the fall. Love the sweatshirt.

[@clarissapietri1149]

The whole box for sure!!, love everything on Stitch fix

[@tayoroa]

Your last Wanntable outfit makes you look like a live action version of the best cup of coffee ever! ☕... I feel like I'm of no use to the buying decision, lol

[@judyhechinger-5946]

The Stitch Fix box is a winner . Keep the box!

[@skincare_explorer]

Keep the whole box! You look stunning in this dress :) I would keep the sweatshirt because it's just cute

[@samcassidy4474]

I loved the wine color boots on you Jen....tbh I actually also loved the rust colored cable sweater. The thinner fabric is definitely a newer trend and I think it hangs amazing on you. Obviously you also saw that the rest of the stitch fix items were amazing (such a cute jacket!) Keep the whole stitch fix box 100 percent. I agree with your wantables opinion. The navy sweater is amazing. Send the rest back. Just my 2 cents. Also I always love these types of videos and I'm thrilled that you've started doing them 😀

[@opensecrets05]

Hell yes on the brown jumper. I'd keep it or the pants from wantable, but not both. I'm personally not a fan of the earrings from stitchfix but everything else is 🔥

[@Aisle89]

aww Jen you are so sweet! the burgundy boots and the jacket are my fave! and your husband is right, you look great in a dress!!

[@genevaalexander3741]

I just love watching your videos. Your not afraid to be yourself.

[@clarisejackson2623]

Keep the whole box! Also you look like you are in your mid 30s! You look great Jen! ❤

[@jacquelinemichele]

I got sucked into stitch fix but after all is said and done, I really only wore 2-3 items enough times to be worth the price. If you have money to blow, definitely worth it and kind of fun.

[@ChrystalVanDusseldorp]

The dress and jacket are KILLER, you look so good! I also like the boots and earrings. The comfy clothes are ok but not worth the price. I understand you liking to wear jeans (I used to be the same way, now I'ma leggings junkie 😄), but maybe after you build your top wardrobe you can try more different bottoms and discover some things that may surprise you! 💕💕💕

[@syster3746]

The dress is really nice with the jacket. Keep the box👍🏻👍🏻

[@teri2466]

I love the vertical cable knit top. You just need to wear the right kind of bra with it ☺️ My fave is the sweatshirt - glad you're keeping it.

[@wendyeno6781]

I would keep the whole box. It looks good on you and the boots are killing it!

[@Flitterbye6424]

I loved the whole Stitch fix box. I think the sweater is lighter for spring. I like the black sweater from wantable but that was it.

[@diamondinmyeye6160]

Glad you kept the Human sweater. It was a great cut and very you. I liked the boots, but if you're unsure I say no. That brown sweater was nothing special. The earrings are cute and I love the dress and jacket on you.