Arkham Horror: The Card Game - Shut Up & Sit Down Review

[@deusex3124]

5 years later and I think this is still one of the best reviews on this channel, despite plentiful competition. Not only is this a great review but the editing is top notch and comedy beats are brilliant.

[@ralphjackson2518]

This game might be worth a revisit, as Fantasy Flight has revised how the sets are organized

[@possibilityspace]

Arkham Horror is great, but it's no crokinole.

[@svensify]

😂 Really well produced, especially the movielike entrance. This way of presenting is really innovative and unique in this genre. I have seen a LOT of your videos, and most of them are awesome! I have laughed so much last time about your cookie-dry humor. Best regards from Hamburg/Germany

[@vanceleon6829]

I know im asking randomly but does anyone know of a way to get back into an instagram account..? I somehow lost the account password. I would appreciate any assistance you can give me!

[@alejandroezequiel265]

@Vance Leon instablaster =)

[@vanceleon6829]

@Alejandro Ezequiel Thanks so much for your reply. I got to the site thru google and Im waiting for the hacking stuff atm. Seems to take a while so I will get back to you later when my account password hopefully is recovered.

[@vanceleon6829]

@Alejandro Ezequiel It did the trick and I actually got access to my account again. I'm so happy:D Thanks so much you really help me out!

[@alejandroezequiel265]

@Vance Leon you are welcome xD

[@smelly551]

Lol the scene of comparing purples. love you guys

[@benanderson46]

JBonn I lol'd irl

[@jmwild1]

"It's not just purple is it?" "Ah that's, that's rubbish."

[@HeinzMcDurgen]

Actual "lol" from me on that part.

[@ZovcDrafts]

Genuinely laughed out loud at my workplace.

[@BardicLiving]

That was a good one.

[@hejin57e77]

It's been two years since I picked up the core set up, and as a fan of 2nd Arkham Horror the board game, the LCG is the best card game I've ever played. I recommend it to anyone who loves cooperative card games, RPGs and Lovecraft. Amazing review that I hope just brings more people to this phenomenal game.

[@paultapping9510]

"You can't lose Arkham the card game" *stares in 'Where Doom Awaits'*

[@mastadonking3816]

Monster: Where's my ancient artifact? Rogue: *sneaking up behind monster with artifact raised *

[@mattanderson1088]

Matt at 15:00 "Quinns this is a family show" Matt at 4:20 - Mug on table instructing you to **** off. :-)

[@carpemkarzi]

Matt Anderson I want that mug

[@artstsym]

Played last night, burgled the bajesus out of my own house, then burnt it to the ground. 10/10

[@devinbaird2470]

This is a seriously hilarious review. I love it!

[@tothemorrow]

This might be the best and most entertaining table top game review in like forever, and ever, and ever

[@astutedunsparce4036]

So glad I stumbled upon this video years ago. This game has taken me and my friends through so many incredible ups and downs and even more memorable moments and inside jokes. Definitely one of my favorite games of all time. Thank you.

[@drew8235]

This is a Living Card Game, which may not be everyone's thing, but it sure as hell is my thing. I've bought so many expansions to this and do not regret a single bit of it, because this is hands down one of the best games money can buy.

[@amedeus40k]

This was my first time watching an SU & SD review video, and I'm actually very upset that I've only just now discovered your work. This review was brilliant, and I rarely use that word. Why? Because I'm a "Yank", but that's how much I enjoyed the video, I enjoyed it so much that you've forced me to use unfamiliar verbiage. lol. The writing was well done, witty, and very funny at times. Also, you both work very well together and have a fantastic onscreen chemistry. The review itself was great and inspired my wife and I to immediately order the core set. We can't wait to play it, furthermore we look forward to watching many more of your videos. I truly wish you nothing but the best with your work. In my opinion you guys are exactly where you should be, in front of a camera. Thanks again!

[@andrewstockdale6084]

11:11 What do we think he's saying? My guess is "What's up, bitches?"

[@tomasxfranco]

"It's not JUST purple, is it!?" LOL

[@davidleiberg2438]

Great review! I really love this game. And although I also like Mansions and Eldritch, I think this game is exceptional. I have been enjoying playing through the scenarios for the first time with my oldest son, but I have also gotten a ton of enjoyment out of going back through the scenarios solo, trying different investigators or deck strategies. I've gotten a ton of time value out of it.

[@thinusconradie4297]

"As if you've just paid for a diploma in Botching Studies from Oh No University in the..." Still one of the best lines on board game reviews, delivered perfectly!

[@EgeveDunyasi]

who else came to watch this after watching Marvel Champions review?

[@reeceharsley]

yep

[@Pokebro921]

That and I saw walmart was selling this for under 20 bucks in the span of a few days

[@Sammo212]

I did mostly because I love Marvel Champions and the cost to play AH LCG seems too high (something they really don't get into).

[@GibletKing]

That's exactly what I did. Sadly; I already bought Marvel and I'm now doing mental gymnastics to figure out why I should buy both.

[@Sammo212]

@@GibletKing FYI there are campaigns coming to Marvel Champions but they are going to release a full story at once time opposed to bilking you for money 6-7x for one storyline.

[@sofiaavgerinou1106]

You make me want to buy it now..NOWW. Your great review just helped me decide which one of the arkham/eldrich/cthulu whatever games are out there to choose. Thank you!

[@SherlockHulmes]

Fantastic review chaps! Really highlights what I love about the game.

[@calumettles4030]

nice to see you here!!

[@jimsmith7445]

Thanks Guys! I never figured out whether I wanted to get involved in these games. This card game looks very accessible. Love the humor, and candor of your reviews. Keep up the good work!

[@MrBlooDeck]

I love the purple sketch.

[@jessewisowaty1227]

You guys are just so goofy lol entertaining and informative! Definitely worth subscribing!

[@SethAGonzalez]

WHAT!? The last "encyclopedia books" shown here is actually a Martin Parr first edition photography book published by Phaidon Inc (2002) - I know because it's a treasured book of mine! I came here to learn about Arkham Horror The Card Game and as a bonus I learn you guys like a kick-ass photographer like Martin Parr too. You guys rock.

[@TheGunslinger019]

This is weird... i was checking this game on the FFG site when my youtube app popped a notification: "shut up & sit down uploaded a new video: arkham horror the card game"... needless to say i am losing my sanity by this "coincidence"...

[@Maftiosi]

Well, it's called "cookie-magic", summoned by google ;)

[@Panquernic]

I saw the Let's play video yesterday and was wondering when they were gonna upload the review. And woke up to the vid :)

[@TheGunslinger019]

Maftiosi if it notified me that the video existed and here it is i can understand it but to be uploaded the same time i remembered to check what the hype is all about and "poof" a video appears it's another thing. The cookie magic is strong though i have to get my lore up somehow :D

[@TheGunslinger019]

AMProductions SU&SD get out of our heads!

[@n.h.alicia3278]

TheGunslinger019 Iä! Iä! Cthulhu ftaghn! Phn’glui mglw’nafh Cthulhu R’lyeh wgah’nagl ftaghn!

[@drewgrgich]

I come back to watch this intro whenever I want a quick laugh. Damn those encyclopedias.

[@sextonj87]

Really great and thorough review. I loved the opening and all of the b-roll throughout.

[@DiceHard]

I LOVE vampires dipped in chocolate. As far as I'm concerned that's the only way to eat them.

[@Henry-lk5pm]

Lovin the content. This video has convinced me to give AH:LCG a go. Any chance you guys would consider doing a quick review of the reformatted expansion releases from FFG? The “investigator”, “campaign” and go expansions are very confusing to a new player.

[@Zacharuni]

Best review to date, hysterical and informative.

[@laurimaijala4984]

This is such a wonderful review. I have been using to spread the love for the game and will link it at my blog post (published on Wednesday). Amazing work.

[@user-iu5fb5hu9n]

Thanks, guys. Love the humor. I was actually giggling like a school girl throughout the review.

[@Karnivori]

The card bending at 13:00 hurts so much to watch

[@justinlenhart4330]

Ok that scene in the beginning with the encyclopedias was the hardest I’ve ever laughed at anything on KZbin... and I’ve watched a lot of KZbin.

[@Golachab]

I did. And I found out about these guys recently. So good. They have my support.

[@VictorSteiner]

I totally disagree with the "you will not play this as often as other boardgames" argument. Changing decks, changing investigators ... I played the first campaign (well, level 1 and 2, with different people) like 30 times and at least scenario 2 is still totally interesting and has very different outcomes every time. Since scenario 1 is more of a "how to" and very simple that one might get boring at some time. But most people I'm playing with play this game over and over again.

[@КириллДектярев]

VictorSteiner Yeah, replay value is very good in this game.

[@0oldschoolgamr0]

I agree. I have logged 46 scenario plays to date. Even the first simple scenario surprises me often due to Encounter card timing and the options in my hand. Given the long tail these LCG games have, I expect this to be my most played game soon. (Currently, that is Space Hulk: Death Angel, with 120 plays).

[@StyxTBuferd]

It depends heavily on the person. If you're the kind of person who likes to rebuild decks and play scenarios with different investigators and player counts, it's very replayable. If however you're here for the narrative and/or you're not much of a fan of building decks, then it's very limited. I'll also add that you basically need two core sets to do any interesting deck building. I found with one set some decks were just not that interesting to tweak because the options were so limited (1 class card per coreset, but up to 2 can be included in a deck). Some classes really need two ofs for certain cards, Mystics in particular (Shriveling and Drawn to the Flame).

[@stacie_everdell]

@@StyxTBuferd Well said! I was the latter and as such very disappointed. I’m not interested it running through the same exact scene sequence simply with another character, I want a whole new experience. But in order to get that, you have to shell out more money. I bought this game largely on this review and it’s ranking among solo players but unfortunately, I will be selling my copy.

[@jackakhan]

The color chart killed me lol. Nice vid guys, thnx!

[@photoben]

Possibly your best review yet. Great work gents.

[@Dunston205]

I love the way you reviewed the game. I just picked up the Core set on Friday and will be playing it shortly. Thank for sharing your thoughts and telling a great story along the way. This was my first time on your channel. Thumbs up and I subscribed. I can't wait to play the game and then watch your video on your first game. Thank you again.

[@wesesheskhnemtuhit]

Oh man friend brought this over to test a little bit last autumn and we've been in a serious hook since.

[@Quietwulf1978]

Sweet review. Already have my own copy and having a blast! Looking forward to seeing what direction they take the game in!

[@КириллДектярев]

I own this game, Arkam horror with all expansions, Elder sign with all expansions and Eldritch horror with all expansions. All of these Lovecraftian games are amazing.

[@groundcontrolto]

Oh gosh, I didn't realise Elder Sign had expansions, not to mention so many of them!

[@darinlagarry3091]

I am a HUGE Elder Sign fan, I definitely recommend it... great for solo play. I also have Eldritch Horror and plan to pick this one up as soon as its in stock again!

[@darinlagarry3091]

w0mbles Yes! There a large variety of locations, investigators and Ancient ones.I would definitely recommend base game + unseen forces + gates of arkham. I have not played omens of ice or omens of the deep yet they are on my wishlist.

[@seileen1234]

Elder sign is such a cool game

[@DeuZerre]

WHen you say it's the first of this theme that you recommend, what do you think of Pandemic: Chtulu?

[@Spartan--yz4qv]

Hello from the United States! Just bought this game and I am thrilled to play. This review was excellent and I enjoyed the humor. Keep it up!

[@fukkhange]

Spartan077 -01 what did you think

[@BecauseOfDragons]

It is a neat game. I've really enjoyed playing through the first three scenarios although I felt like the 2nd and 3rd scenarios were just trying to impress how tough things are rather than threading things together into a story. It's like what happened with some of the later boxes from Lord of the Rings: The Card game (also from FFG) when you get to Numenor. Some friends have played the first big box, Dunwich Horror, and they said that the scenarios in there were much better and it felt like a better thread of narrative. I genuinely think this is a better alternative to Mansions Of Madness and Eldritch Horror as it's a more condensed experience and you get to tailor your character more BUT I think that the opening scenarios could have done with a bit more to them. By no means does this mean that the game is screwed because of this, as it has already taken over from Netrunner for a couple of friends, but I'm looking forward to seeing more of what lies ahead. I just hope that they don't make more scenarios 'hard for the sake of being hard'. I know that the failure aspect of the game is something you should expect with Cthulhu, and I enjoy that (and the way the bag works with the tokens), but just something that niggled me. Oh and seriously FFG...put a bag in the box. Don't make people go out and buy one or use a cup. Doesn't half ruin the theme when you have a terrible tea mug holding your tokens.

[@the_wake_]

Exceptional review even by the lofty standards you've cultivated! Special thanks for directing my play group to the absolute perfect game for our tastes.

[@Johnfslagle]

I just recently got into board games. Now I have about 15. Dice Tower was always my go to but after watching this that’s no longer the case. Great review!

[@APFC95]

at first when i saw this game i thought it was a bit weird, but i have to say, your review just highlights certain things i have not seen much on other games, and the art is beautiful. now i want to buy it

[@VisorVisionary]

I just discovered this channel. I love it more then Wil Wheaton's Table Top.

[@TheFreemanko]

I would love to see you guys review Mansions of Madness 2.0 I am debating between the two for a casual themed board games meet up.

[@DrMcFly28]

7:22 "You can activate a card" Quinns, what are you doing. Leave that cat alone. Also, your character apparently has three hands.

[@4KandChill]

Best board game reviewers period

[@joerobertson7709]

I love this channel so much.

[@mydemon]

This music... Getting incredible chills from it. It's from one of the Android/iPhone games I believe

[@AbsolutZer0-1C3]

It's by Kevin Macleod and it's called (no joke) Quinn's Song. There are actually three pieces with the same melody.

[@NinaLambacher]

Apart from the bit about the eggplant, violet, amethyst, orchid, purple........ I especially love the bit about the Survivor: "...isn't really good at anything... ...with hight tech equipment like: a coat the Survivor does what has to be done. In a coat. And when that doesn't work they hide on a windowsill..."

[@Fu22z]

Awesome review. Played the core set and Dunwich Horror expansion and immediately picked up a Team Covenant subscription... This game is fantastic

[@jmwild1]

The bag with tokens to substitute for the use of dice reminds me of what they did with Runebound 3rd edition, changing combat by replacing dice with tokens.

[@RatOrchestra]

My one major complaint with this game after the first expansion cycle is that while the base game comes in a nice box, all of the subsequent packs have been in those little plastic pack-container-things and it makes getting all of the specific parts of their scenarios together just a bit more of a pain than through the boxes. Still less than the hours of set up for regular Arkham Horror, to be fair

[@johnnygamer23]

I subscribed because I heard them eldritch hounds... They made me do 😅 Also, the buzzing sounds made me like the video... 😮

[@matthewhunt2143]

Time for a new / updated review? Maybe even another scenario play through?

[@russellscott1151]

17:55 but... quite a big but that to me. Maybe something to pickup second/third hand on eBay? Great review.

[@melek_the_weird]

So I played this game with my brother & we completed the core set campaign so here are a few flaws we had with the game. they might not be flaws to everyone but just a few things SU & SD didn't fully claim. 1st: the game is hard. I only played with my bro so maybe more people makes it easier but the game is really hard. 2nd: the "chaos tokens/bag" is very unforgiving & this is a game where every action is important so pulling multiple failures can be quite discouraging. 3rd: this is a big one. the amount of customization for the factions is actually quite small. only about 2-3 cards have an "upgrade" and each faction has 3-4 powerful cards to buy with exp. All in all, the game is quite fun but you really only want to play through it once or twice. Especially since there is alot going on and you may not know exactly what to do but it's helpful to know that going in. Have fun!

[@timpage9424]

Just played this for the first time tonight and loved it. I'm gonna have to get it for myself when I have some money.

[@MPInvictus]

Came here for Matt and Quinns in the shower. I am leaving sorely disappointed.

[@shutupandsitdown]

ok ok ok... kzbin.info/www/bejne/f5fMc6iop9J-qKs

[@Cpt_nice]

I just got this game but haven't played it yet! Now I am even more stoked

[@JosephLachh]

I thought I watched all of the SU&SD videos, and then I find this when I look up this game. Where is this hidden playlist?

[@drmanhattan71]

Does it have the "rich get richer" problem where if you do well in a scenario, the next one is that bit easier and so on, but if you do poorly, the next one becomes next to impossible etc etc? Or do they recommend you adjust the difficulty levels perhaps based on how you succeeded in a scenario (could be based on the XP you received)

[@thomascremese1235]

The base game is a good introduction to this beautiful card game. To me (and my group of players) it shines if you have the time to go through the different campaigns + expansions that add a lot of depth to deck building and in-game combos. The game is quite hard and failure is part of it - but it's always a laugh. However, over time this does become quite a big and expensive game and all the boxes do take quite a bit of shelf space, you've been warned!

[@fatboymig1]

Great video. Subbed and liked. Keep up the good work.

[@caverramos7581]

Tbh this feels like discount Arkham Horror. Men i love original AH, more than a decade and still a Horrific king

[@КириллДектярев]

Caver Ramos They actually play very differently.

[@phillosmaster393]

The LCG is a much shorter and less random experience. That said AH the board game is still fun in my opinion. I don't think this game replaces that, but it is a great game in it's own right.

[@wospy1091]

I often think about this game. While playing it, I felt like success had less to do with good deck building/decision making than getting lucky with the encounter deck and modifier tokens. I really can't overstate this: you have almost no agency in this game. If you think you'll like this game because it's a strategic deck builder, you might be wrong. If you think you'll like this because you like Lovecraft, you might be right.

[@IslanKleinknecht]

I just realized that I'm not /actually/ subscribed to SUSD's youtube channel. I just hang out on your web site too much.

[@TheGunslinger019]

Nick Clinite i think their dedicated channel is rather new. Machinima uploaded their videos in the past. ;)

[@philippludewig8456]

should I buy the Core set or the Arkham Horror (Third Edition)? I am confused for what game are all the expansions work or if its ok for both games.

[@hramsov]

Thank you, guys! Your video it's very funny!

[@maxihrman8467]

10:08 this made me laugh so much! This will be my next game I’ll buy

[@northlakeghost]

Terrific review! I'm a latecomer to this one but thinking about diving in. If playing with 2 players, do we each need a core box or will one do?

[@awanderingmonk828]

Each box is enough for two players. Enjoy and happy gaming!

[@КириллДектярев]

Why 2-4 players? It is one of the best solo games of all time!

[@TorIverWilhelmsen]

Any cooperative game can be played solo by playing multiple characters. Probably they just didn't bother create single-character scaled gameplay though.

[@КириллДектярев]

Tor Iver Wilhelmsen No, I am pretty sure you can play one character.

[@harrymason9913]

Actually, they did. Game is perfectly playable solo, with one character.

[@benanderson46]

you draw 1 bad card per player at the end of each turn. game scales well, but you may feel you're missing the help from one of the other character's niches. you may also play solo with 2 characters to avoid this.

[@harrymason9913]

Ben Anderson There are characters that suited for solo, and characters that are not.

[@DevilboyScooby]

Love the mug at 4:45 😂

[@stumbling]

I've just realised Matt is the illegitimate love-child of Quinns and Paul!... and possibly Noel Fielding.

[@henrikmunkmadsen3190]

WHY ARE YOU SO GOOD!?! You guys are amazing.

[@AppHero123]

Just bought the game and some negatives 1) Cannot play 4 players unless you buy a second copy 2) Even if you play 2 players you cannot play any 2 characters because there is not enough cards when creating the starter decks. 3) Be carful when pulling the components out of the cardboard as they want to peal (not that big of a deal) 4) There is no "chaos bag" included in the box All these things do not really impact the game, but for a $70 box I think that this is un acceptable. Unless you plan on spending $140 plus a bag this game is way over priced.

[@Arteafact]

$70? That's really steep, it's 25 quid in the UK

[@Fergit_]

Everyone I know who bought the core (multiple cores, it's an FFG box after all) has already sold it on but are still all playing the LoTR equivalent. Perhaps it comes down to strength of theme or good old-fashioned mechanics, but that's how it's gone down.

[@yaelakimronzonmorell254]

Hello! First of all I'm a big fan of your channel, I really enjoy your reviews. I have a question of this game. I want to get a new campaign, but maybe I won't be able to buy the whole of the mythos deck, is it worth it?

[@CastleBallad]

While it's better to buy the campaign box and all 6 mythos packs in one swoop, sometimes that's a little too expensive, or imposible due to stock shortage. I'd say it's cool to get the campaign boxes anyway, since they have new investigators, lots of new player cards and usually 2-3 scenarios for you to play with. This will leave itching to know how the story continues, but it's worth it anyway. Check out the reddit for this game, they've got a lot of information about what and where to buy you arkham stuff :)

[@yaelakimronzonmorell254]

@@CastleBallad thank you! I've been trying to get full campaings, but as you said is expensive or imposible. I like the arkham horror series, but is a lot of money for the expansions. I'll check the reddit :D

[@CastleBallad]

@@yaelakimronzonmorell254 Don't give up on this game! It's very much worth the money. I've been bulding my collection slowly, buying a full campaing about twice a year. stackhamhorror.com/ Has info about stock, Boardlandia has the best prices and customer service ever. There's three campaigns on stock right now!

[@technomage116]

funny ass review. well done. clean and concise, but also entertaining

[@blackhand95]

I hate you guys so goddamn much right now. This is a fantastic review and I want to play this more than anything else. But as I'm writing this, for the life of me I can't find a base set in stock. WOE IS ME.

[@frankharr9466]

Well, that was interesting. I wonder if they figured out what that color was.

[@simoncantwell9256]

I MUST have a little black bag like that, but I've no idea where to get one...

[@emilelouisbruh]

Ah quit it already I’ll buy the damn box.

[@BorrisChan]

As amazing as the show has gotten visually, the opening to this one is still just *mwuah*

[@ralphjackson2518]

Card decks are to fantasy flight as dice tables are to Avalon Hill.

[@magicgeeks1955]

Chaos bag !!! That’s what I’m calling mine from now on.

[@nigelmtb]

Freakin hilarious. Count me in, I'm subscribed!

[@Myrdraall]

How well does it work with a partner who has next to no boardgame experience? Are they going to feel overwhlem or make the game extra difficult for the other players?

[@chrisobleness612]

Just got the game a played through the first two scenarios, looking forward to more of this game! Thanks for the recommendation!

[@IronSalamander8]

The Morris dance comment reminds me of the 3rd Doctor story: The Daemons! :D

[@paulstaker8861]

Yesterday I bought Eldritch Horror. And then this morning I remembered this game exists. .... Cthulhu Fhtagn

[@Duxa_]

Whats weird here is that they hated Arkham Horror, yet all of the praising, and positives from this review precisely describe the cool stuff you do in Arkham Horror. Yes Arkham takes forever, but its a forever of doing these awesome things...

[@Thesavagesouls]

When did they say they hated the game ?

[@georgestrob]

i am really thinking about buying this game.ive seen so many positive reviews and i like card games.the only thing that holds me back and bothers me its the replay value.i dont want a game that is kept alive only through buying expansion

[@christophermoore8524]

The "chaos bag" is now my favorite euphemism ever.

[@deerpoob]

Matt that is an awesome shirt I must know of its dark unknowable origins

[@mattRaWr1991]

Whenever I watch your videos I can't stop thinking about how much Quinns looks like Chris Marshal