Arthur Ruined The Life of the Heartbroken Stone Thrower - Eight Years Later - Red Dead Redemption 2

[@fletchbtw6244]

MrBossFTW stole your vid buddy and made it over 10 minutes 😂

[@ChengTeoh]

LOL, of course he did. No surprise, I was pretty much expecting that he'd nick this one since it's gotten big in the recent week. XD Seriously, if ANY of my videos get above 100k he'll most likely have copied it. Just look at some of the videos on my list and see how many of them he's done. I stopped counting at 7. [ ps. I'm working on a video of catching all the legendary fishes as Arthur and going back to Jeremy Gill, hopefully when Gill sees Arthur he'll have a different dialogue compared to when he sees John. It's a bit tricky since I HORRIBLE at fishing. Still have no clue how the fishing mechanic works really, been lucky at catching the legendaries that I already have by catching the fish closer to me rather than having them hooked at the furthest point. XD Stay tuned, and hey if you could help out, just tell the people who are watching MrBossFTW videos, just to check out my videos if they want something straight to the point without fluff. Thanks Much. Big Hugs. ]

[@fletchbtw6244]

Cheng Teoh it’s okay bud you’re clearly a better source so I’ll stick to your vids bro keep up the good work

[@ChengTeoh]

Drats, I caught all the legendary fishes for Jeremy Gill, but it seems like his letter of invitation doesn't want to come since the game still considers the New Austin area a no-go zone even though the glitch can let Arthur free-roam. Oh well, at the very least I FINALLY learned how to fish. Several of the legendary fishes I caught within two minutes of hooking it instead of the thumb hurting half-hour before I did a certain something. XD

[@EnterJokesHere]

Cheng Teoh Damn bro, sorry to hear that. I used to watch him when he was pretty new but over time I found he was stealing and clickbaiting more often. That's what kinda eventually pulled me from his channel. With that said, keep up the great content!

[@FutureHndrxx60]

@@ChengTeoh Do all of us a Favour and Copyright Him

[@forgotsomething4995]

Dudes been stone skipping for 8 years and still doesn’t know how to get the stone to bounce, no wonder he’s pissed

[@the6ix72]

your 1 funny little fella -Arthur

[@elijahtheprophet2202]

@@the6ix72 Oh yeah yeah.

[@bradenfranks7011]

It’s ironic Bc he said “at least there’s one thing I’m good at” but he’s not even good at that

[@Fo4assaultriflefan92]

@@elijahtheprophet2202 oh yeah yeah

[@kevinpeters9756]

@@Fo4assaultriflefan92 it's really funny to comment multiple times on his own shit isn't it XD

[@alejandrohernandez3767]

Arthur giving love advice is like John Marston giving swimming lessons

[@terelosz4097]

Haha best comment ever

[@insanekiller6062]

Roasted

[@arczi1309]

XD. It's like Fuze giving hostage situation lessons (R6 fans will relate)

[@elijahtheprophet2202]

@@arczi1309 got kicked for being fuze (Not even playing Hostage)

[@bananaglue3779]

bUt jOhN mARsToN cAn’T sWiM

[@megailadan]

"Can I hold you?" -John starts riding the horse faster-

[@simpleman3458]

It is Normal i guess

[@aukima771]

*John riding a horse* Michey: god, i wish that were me

[@Sid_The_Maggot]

@@aukima771 💀💀💀

[@tanaysaxena2234]

@@aukima771 ayo

[@ShuparuM1]

Arthur giving love advice is like dutch having a plan

[@favoritedwater1322]

It always backfires

[@brandonaumiller3997]

It always ends up in Tahiti?

[@xLanzer]

Shut up Micah U rat!! Hahaha

[@furioussherman7265]

@@brandonaumiller3997 And to work it needs money, time, noise, smoke, a boat, and loyalty.

[@SenorFluffy]

@@furioussherman7265 WE JUST NEED A LITTLE NOISE ARTHUR AND ONE BIG SCORE AND THEN WE'RE GONE

[@about45otters81]

“Bastard ruined my life!” Me, pulling out a dynamite arrow: “Hey now, how about you calm down.”

[@ChengTeoh]

I wonder if he just disappears after you dynamite him. Gavin from what I heard is immortal.

[@disco5005]

@@ChengTeoh Tell me where the fuck you found Gavin

[@moth-corpse]

disco5005 Haven’t you heard? Gavin is omnipotent. He’s a deity. The man who keeps looking for him, is the man who went insane after briefly seeing the true splendorous form of the one true ancient god, Gavin. He now looks for him boundlessly in search for his magnificence one more time. Nah just kidding Gavin’s probably dead yo

[@IGamingStation]

@@ChengTeoh Speaking of which, have you seen Gavin?

[@ilovemicahbell3831]

Micah Bell wouldn't ruin his life, would he?

[@WhiteGho]

John:" I think he died..." Mickey:‘’They always do...the good ones" tears in my eyes

[@-knightshade-5747]

i almost started tearing up

[@obiwanfisher537]

What do you mean? Plenty of bad guys die.

[@dammmmmxd95]

@@obiwanfisher537 It mean that most of good man die early than bad man, sure there's a lot of bad man that die because they're own sin but what Mickey mean is that most of the good man he knew in his life die earlier than bad man he knew in his life

[@porflimbornapilis2556]

Meanwhile everyone thinks he's a good guy, but honestly, no one is... Folly of humankind.

[@obiwanfisher537]

@@dammmmmxd95 I think you missed the joke

[@imadrifter]

I didn't know Mickey would dynamically follow next to you to talk if you are on a horse going by slowly like that. This game surprises me every day with something new

[@ChengTeoh]

It came as a surprise to me too. :D

[@Jay-nl8lp]

Really?

[@commiedoggo5440]

Arthur Morgan shut up ur game ended

[@awesomedude2556]

Tony Snow I thought Mickey respawns?

[@Stinkyblunt99]

@@commiedoggo5440 ooooooooooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhhhh XD

[@psychoclown9817]

best line ever: "back to the demon"

[@ChengTeoh]

Sadly we never got to see the "demon" in person.

[@mattthompson3714]

@@ChengTeoh Probably for the best

[@fellascallmethedrink]

I just liked your comment and now the amount of likes are 666, how ironic.

[@عبدالله-س7خ9ح]

😂😂😂

[@chrisbenoit4273]

Boomer

[@kowshikjayaraman9267]

I literally have a tear in my eyes when every npc say i used to know a feller like you.

[@MrBlack252]

"god dammit Mickey can't you see im in the middle of stalking someone?!" haha

[@ChengTeoh]

lol yeah I thought it was funny that he started to follow me while I was following someone else. XD

[@theonlydoopymcdoopface275]

The 1k like

[@Megalodon4apx]

XDDDD

[@duewhat9815]

Nah, he knew, it was way too obvious...he was just coming over to do the blending in for him.

[@N30m3g4]

Mr Black! Love watching your videos too man

[@manuelramos360]

Stranger: I wanna do something Arthur: then do it? Stranger: *does it and turns out bad Stranger: YOU RUINED MY LIFE. HOW COULD YOU?

[@DharamShasak]

That's real life for you.

[@MrApoorvaSingh753]

I'll do it again. 😈

[@bryanosegueda6103]

I did a Quick Draw on him when he said “Basterd ruined my damn life”

[@hellohowareyou8396]

@@bryanosegueda6103 _🤚😭_

[@brrttaa]

@@MrApoorvaSingh753 Evil Apoorva Singh: I won't do it again. 😈

[@ququ1639]

3:32 heartbroken guy: my god, could this day get any worse?! SMACK!!

[@ChengTeoh]

yep, horses just don't give a damn. lol.

[@berligonmons7306]

I’m dead😂😂💀

[@Confession68]

Yup, I burst out laughing at that part. 😂

[@sensei_monke798]

It’s like a villain’s origin story

[@mr.pumpkinpie2036]

3:35 almost sounds like John laughed at him

[@hansnilsson8491]

When i was john i killed the boy cuz he was taking smack about arthur

[@jameshiawo2771]

Revenge is a fools game.

[@-_FENRIR_-]

Good choice he didnt do anything special afterwards anyway

[@countdoowho7183]

I was so tempted to do that but then i taught to myself its not what Arthur would have wanted

[@loficat4993]

@@countdoowho7183 That's why you save first.

[@Journey_to_who_knows]

John criticised Arthur

[@Garium87]

Moral of the story is, don't chase someone who doesn't really want you. Even if you would manage to talk him or her into being with you, that person will not love you and ultimately resent you for it. Real love just happens. It is not a plan, nor an act and most certainly not forced.

[@spacechimp3199]

Jeff Martinez it’s a narrative. Same as a book or movie or tv show.

[@TheFlash-dr1kr]

Love doesn't exist.

[@vailimaconnoisseur6538]

@@TheFlash-dr1kr who hurt you?

[@Garium87]

@Jeff Martinez , right but it's not Super Smash Bros or Candy Crush we are talking about here. RDR2 has plenty of meaning in its deep, complex story. The game is wasted on you if you don't realise that.

[@stanettiels7367]

Moral of the story is, chloroform on a rag and you can fill in the blanks. 😉🤔

[@scarecrowjones1]

LMAO it seemed you were torn between keeping your eye on the dude and consoling Mickey... I could never ignore him tbh

[@ChengTeoh]

lol, you noticed that did ya. ;) I had to follow the dude just to satisfy my curiosity. I know that Mickey will always be around, but the dude who the heck knows where he will end up.

[@phrogdad8478]

i killed micky lol

[@gamignmaster6977]

@@phrogdad8478 H E R E T I C

[@TheoAndreas43]

@@phrogdad8478 you will go to the hottest depths of hell-an athiest

[@santosdumont2700]

@@TheoAndreas43 i am atheist and dont want to be compared to this guy

[@jeanswinter679]

Not really.. when Arthur met the boy, the problem was that he wanted to be together with Lily May, well.. it came true, he did end up together with her. So.. the problem is Lily May, not Arthur. I wanted to punch that boy in the face when he said that Arthur ruined his life.

[@unculturedswine5583]

yeah,i guess the moral is dont marry dickheads,even if they're hot

[@90srapfan37]

I mean yeah he was wrong to trash Arthur like that but I think he was just an angry lost soul. As cheesy as that sounds

[@rolfthewolf764]

When he said the bastard ruined my life the bastard could be lily may

[@OutCast907]

@@unculturedswine5583 " That girl was nothing but a problem, but you fell in move cuz she was like a supermodel" YelaWolf

[@scotty420]

I shot him lol

[@taterobinson6172]

I love how the game constantly reminds you of arthur, like rewarding you for exploring and interacting.

[@DeadHardTV]

Both by real and by game standards, Arthur was hell of a person. No wonder folks remembering him

[@bigjohn2441]

I like how you talk to Mickey as you follow him home, how wholesome.

[@xXpatt0nXx]

I antagonized the shit out of this kid as he was running away I even ran over him with my horse (he takes no damage). I was shocked when playing as John I ran into this kid grown up and he mentioned Arthur telling him to grow up, the level of detail and depth of NPC dialogue in the game is mind blowing.

[@ChengTeoh]

Ooo, so there IS a difference in dialogue if you antagonize him as Arthur instead of giving him the nice advice. Now I'm going to have to find him again just to see it for myself. Thanks so much for the info. :D

[@saints360row]

Joe Diets, *Says someone who has never played Mass Effect*

[@juelgrace]

@@saints360row games overrated

[@saints360row]

Juel Grace, The specific game wasn't the point, really; there are many other games out there that are far more immersive with their intracate paths via players' choice than RDD2.

[@dukiroki6891]

@@saints360row boy, mass effect is a dialogue game, rdr2 just put detail in the world, in mass effect the detail is a pillar of the game, rdr2 ia just a open world game ¿where is another game that put that fucking level of detail in a open world?

[@NewGuy2534]

Guy told me to leave him alone and I did. Guess I saved him in the end.

[@ChengTeoh]

Did you run across him as John in the epilogue?

[@NewGuy2534]

Not yet I’m still in chapter 3. LOL!!

[@franktastical7512]

Boss Umbra good luck

[@danielkozma5665]

Me, too. He even said something to me when I was turning around and leaving. Never met him since.

[@NewGuy2534]

Yeah he said “I just wanna be alone now, mister.” So I left. My theory is that he met someone nice and settled down somewhere away from all this craziness. Or was killed in one of Dutch’s plans. You pick.

[@sonjaporkka]

I think it’s amazing that you can interact with people as John like this, and you see the impact you made as Arthur. Really great of Rockstar to do such details, it’s amazing

[@peripateticguy55]

Sad thing Mickey lasts longer than Arthur...

[@ozomini3400]

mickey would've died waaaaay faster if he was the one who had tb (tuberculosis)

[@beanprotein]

unless Arthur shoots him

[@finklebottoms]

@@beanprotein who tf would shoot Mickey? that's like killing your horse or a dog..

[@6vouces837]

@@finklebottoms imagine if YOU could kill cain

[@finklebottoms]

@ً AYO WTF

[@estebanvelazquez353]

Thanks for talking to Mickey my man

[@lannnn7216]

He's a liar, he later reveals how he's not an actual veteran

[@janitor_arya9011]

@@lannnn7216 who cares, i feel pity for him because he only got 1 arm and is homeless, you know thats he's nitpicking to survive, beside, if your arthur is high honor, he can be seen wearing civillian clothe on the epilogue

[@lannnn7216]

@@janitor_arya9011 I care

[@janitor_arya9011]

@@lannnn7216 and who are you?

[@lannnn7216]

@@janitor_arya9011 I'm Lan III

[@Faded_boy09]

Kid:“Bastard ruined my life” Everyone who love’s Arthur: Starts jumping him

[@g.masterlordoftheg-force4770]

Well, people who care about Arthur AND are psychopaths. That's no reason to kill a guy. He was mostly pissed at his life, which Arthur had a small hand in by giving him advice. It's just bad luck.

[@streetkombat6088]

Arthur only gave him advice so he didn't make him take the advice. That guy has to grow up. He is the one who wanted Lily May at the end of the day instead of going after another female.

[@ReapersLove69]

@@g.masterlordoftheg-force4770 well these "psychopaths" happen to take quite the offense to bad mouthing Arthur. Aint bad luck man just couldnt think for himself is all, Arthur gave him the best advice at the time and he ended up skippin stones all over again blamin' everyone but himself

[@g.masterlordoftheg-force4770]

@@ReapersLove69 Bad mouthing is still not a good enough reason to kill. Unless it is an extreme horrible verbal attack that causes the person to be depressed, lose their self-esteem, and possibly become suicidal. Seriously, I have been bullied myself (which includes Bad mouthing me), and not even I wish death upon them. I did hurt them a bit though. But hey, it's just a video game. People don't need much motivation to kill NPCs. My kill count in GTA games is probably through the roof.

[@patrickmiller7440]

lol its sorta funny how mickey just steped in

[@theradicalreviewer6053]

The one wholesome character we need

[@joejacobs6894]

He steals from you if you hug him

[@ekkoekko4610]

0

[@ekkoekko4610]

0

[@Jakethesnake2007]

@@astolfofansunny4047 You mean MrBossFTW

[@hybridgamer4708]

NPC: I knew a fellar that wore a hat once John: OMG! Arthur!! Edit: holy shit guys thanks for the likes I think this is the most I’ve ever gotten

[@Halalawi999]

He knew it was Arthur from the journal

[@hybridgamer4708]

H A that wasn’t in my journal

[@arthurmorgan5432]

m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/iWObYYOnppiHldk

[@Bonbonbon739]

😂😂😂

[@Watchmedome3017]

😭😭😭😭😭

[@TheKawaiiPandaGamer]

"Bastard ruined my life!" Me, as a Spaniard that loves Arthur: Tus muertos! *draws gun and shoots*

[@MrLemon-vt4ky]

Wel then

[@ericglenn9984]

FUNNEEEE

[@TrunksEnjoyer]

😐

[@bogbog4678]

Yeah, it would fix his ruined life very quick :P

[@BigPhilly365]

He had a funny face I think his name was Alan. How tf did John figure that was Arthur?

[@anotherredditchannelbutonm186]

I mean the names do kinda sound familiar, plus John knew Arthur for awhile, so maybe it was just an instinct, like what comes to your mind when you hear a certain word

[@lodii7246]

Arthur saved John's life John really admired Arthur like his own brother Anybody who knew arthur could never forget about him Mickey Never fought in the war And the only person he told that to was arthur when i played in chapter 6 With arthur having TB

[@Rugologist]

Heya Bois or maybe John has a journal that belonged to Arthur?????

[@whoevencaresbrawecb1139]

Rags_ Rili Yeha I don’t think Author actually puts an entry in for it (that I know) but that’s the rp reason

[@Rugologist]

Whoevencaresbra WECB still... he had his things, letters, guns, and more

[@dislocatedthumb6599]

_"back to the demon"_ 🤣

[@regentester72]

When talking to Mickey as Arthur it felt calm and peaceful both battle-scarred men talking to each other about one another problems and the last encounter with Mickey and Arthur said that he's dying it really felt like Mickey actually saw Arthur as somewhat of a friend. I like to see this encounter as a way to make you forget about the problems in-game and in real life, at least for me. Idk I see him as a wholesome character.

[@stonedkoopatroopa2891]

Mickey is alright but the veteran? The real one with the wooden leg. That was the homie.

[@lisagonzalez1371]

didn't he lie about being a veteran?

[@SalvageET]

@@lisagonzalez1371yeah, he couldn’t even name the battle he was in when Arthur asked him about it

[@justarandomextras8350]

I came for the topic. I stayed for Mickey.

[@watervisuals8727]

Same i believe he has many story's to tell

[@-knightshade-5747]

yess sir Amen

[@kot32222]

5:34 Literally Arthur moves in front of John and Mickey, and just listeting.

[@llcoolray3000]

LOL @ the dude getting run over, and Mickey tagging along.

[@SnakeEaterGaming]

Wonder what would of happened if Arthur chose “antagonize”

[@v12vanquish135]

Wondering this also. Maybe he tells him to man up, and it actually turns out better for him?

[@dingus5285]

It stays the same

[@Kamesuko]

Griffin Bohan Shut the fuck up, you troglodyte

[@twinzzlers]

@@Kamesuko Correct his grammar but don't nit pick or be a dick about it

[@hanchockelias5123]

Dudeli 10/10

[@AYVYN]

Arthur: I never told you to marry her, just that she would come around like a broken clock.

[@brodhax6148]

Arthur helped him get what he wanted, its not Arthurs fault the thing he wanted would ruin his life.

[@JD-lj4gt]

Don't chase em, fellas. Ladies, too. Don't chase em.

[@stadbab]

John Deemy amen. it’s no fun chasing and it’s even less fun being chased.

[@LaVidaHermosa]

Barry The fuck?

[@erickandrade8660]

@@Barry-yx8qx *Ya like J I Z..i mean J A Z Z* ?

[@Barry-yx8qx]

Blastin' cum like one o' them fire truck hoses.

[@LaVidaHermosa]

Barry Uncomfortableness 100

[@FEURVERM]

When this game has More life to it that people didnt even Notices much compared to The Cyberpunk 2077

[@lks7842]

Cyberpunk's story is up there with Rdr 2 and it's a good game itself, but Rdr 2 is a better game for sure as hurtful as it is to say

[@sandroedilashvili3651]

@@lks7842 agreed. I wish it Was on same level as RD games...

[@BobbyB24601]

@@lks7842 I like cyberpunk, but I completely disagree about the story being as good as rdr2. It's good, but red dead is fantastic

[@IshanKashyap001]

@@lks7842 I liked the story of Cyberpunk. But it sure as hell is no way near to RDR 2. RDR 2 made me go through so many emotions that I genuinely felt for everyone in that game. CP77 was at max mediocre if compared to RDR 2. It never took me on an emotional rollercoaster and it still doesn't have a dime of immersion. Felt real bad for Evelyn, V and a few others but Johnny's story idk kinda felt missing tho I still loved it (wanted a bit more on that personally that's why). Panam and her nomads were good but most of her gang are generic NPCs they ain't nothing like the Van Der Linde gang.

[@lks7842]

@@IshanKashyap001 I agree, to an extent. I don't agree that there's a "lack of immersion" I think it's the exact opposite, it's one of the first games I've ever felt so immersed in, besides Rdr2.

[@supremebapehype3401]

Atleast Arthur got them together.

[@Jay-nl8lp]

YAY! MICKEY MY BOY!

[@O.LEO.N]

Stop roleplaying asshole!

[@redrebel5367]

💯 just play the game . These are getting old af.

[@TheFlash-dr1kr]

@@liquidcurse4190 stfu

[@scarface1-phoenix38]

I shot micky I kill lies ::)

[@longtranthanh8544]

@@O.LEO.N ha ha jealous.

[@mysneaker8234]

crazy how they put each and every little lovely detail into RDR2..... TRUE LOVE

[@AidenPearce19]

The decision to marry her was his and his only. Listening to someone's advice is undestandable, but it's your life, you make your choices, so the outcome to everything you go through in life is made by your judgement calls whether you deny it or blame it on someone else, he could've decided not to listen to Arthur's advice, but then again, anything can happen in your future, things never fully go as you believe they will.

[@alistairlaura6623]

This is the first game I’ve got to 100% on story and I’m STILL not done with it. Such a rich experience.

[@marcm.official]

npcs on red dead 2 are not just programmed AI, they have personalities and life.. this game is so awesome

[@pandorin2348]

3:33 my life in a nutshell

[@joshualupyan519]

Jesus why do I relate to Mickey so much

[@timothyduff38]

A crazy, homeless, civil war vet pretending drunk? I hope to never meet you. Lol

[@vailimaconnoisseur6538]

Because you're a fraud?

[@meemaylovebeejays]

@@timothyduff38 He wasn't in a war.

[@timothyduff38]

@@meemaylovebeejays "pretending"

[@meemaylovebeejays]

@@timothyduff38 My bad, didn't see that.

[@aziemazri9342]

Stranger: That bastard ruined my life! John: So you've chosen death

[@whistler9788]

“*bastard* ruined my life” *draws pistol*

[@rus778]

*unloads all bullets of every gun into him*

[@friendlyzeldafan9279]

*loads cattleman with malicious intent"

[@JEEPmanDAVE]

5:57 “I think he died” Arthur is right there walking in front of John’s horse... 😂😂

[@yoandinavarro1196]

That’s not him bro

[@whoops2512]

@@yoandinavarro1196 no shit u didn't get the joke?

[@yoandinavarro1196]

@@whoops2512 there is not joke

[@whoops2512]

@@yoandinavarro1196 there is, you just didn't get it.

[@bamang233]

One of the funniest comment 😂😂😂

[@mr2octavio]

Thanks for the whole whole Micky scene, at first I was like "noo we won't know where he goes if he talks to mickey!" But then the conversation was so nice that my hearth melted and I love Micky even more. What a great character

[@ImmortalLlama]

I love when the game has people who reference Arthur as a man like John and had some sort of impact on them

[@xXLoneLoboXx]

To be fair it wasn't Arthur's fault, that dude just picked the wrong woman.

[@zer0_zen189]

Exactly, I was about to comment that. Arthur was just trying to help out a boy with his troubles by giving him advice.

[@gutz1981]

Plot Twist: There was no Lilly-May. This kid has no home and it was all in his head.

[@louisianaredbird5496]

I like how you included Mickey. Really tied in well. Also I can read what’s written at the end as well. Good attention to detail.

[@ChengTeoh]

It was a nice surprise to have Mickey pop up at that spot. :D

[@LucidLando]

He had a long journey he may as well have some company

[@NGMonocrom]

Bah! No one ruined his life. You chase a woman for years, after awhile you come to realize who she really is. And long before you put a ring on that finger. I can relate. I fell hard for a beautiful, very attractive woman not too long ago actually. Spent as much time with her as I could. Woke up, looking forward to seeing her. I got a bit obsessed. Never crossed the line with her. But was a bit obsessed. Well, took awhile but I soon saw all her flaws. She's a good person. But completely disorganized. When it comes to dealing with people, she's very thoughtless. And unfortunately sees nothing wrong with outright lying to others at times. I've caught her in a few lies, but never called her out on them directly. Found out the doctor changed her meds. awhile back. She's not as creative as she used to be (she's an artist). She's also gotten very lazy too. She used to work on her art like crazy. But no longer does. Hate to say it, but it's clear her old meds. helped a lot with her creativity. Oh well.... We remain friends. Relationship a lot more casual than it once was. I got to know her better, realized she just wasn't the right woman for me. She now has a fiance, so things worked out for her. But yeah.... The more you chase a woman, the more you get to know her, the more the fantasy falls apart and you see the real her. Arthur didn't ruin the guy's life.

[@Barry-yx8qx]

Thank you, partner.

[@asdfghjklzxcvbnm3166]

Bah! Humbug!

[@thatbobbi]

We project our desires onto others, that's why the magic fades from the objects of our infatuation sometimes.

[@NGMonocrom]

+Bmore Machiavellian Hate to say it but yeah, that pretty much covers it.

[@adrianvillarreal8035]

Same for me too partner

[@kewe5306]

John: “No harm done." Subtitle: *No armed done*

[@ryandlion6961]

He didn't ruin his life the kids just frustrated,and he'll look back and be more appreciative that he tried instead of doing nothing

[@MrJH101]

Or, you know, he like totally murders her. In which case, he shouldn’t have tried that hard at all. She rebuffed him the first time, Arthur should’ve just taught the kid to move on; although he wasn’t any good at that either (Mary).

[@ryandlion6961]

Arthur realizes its better to have loved and lost than to never loved at all. And as far as Mary I could say a bunch of things but I don't truly know why he holds on to her,maybe Rockstar just thought he should have some kind of female interaction. Because you know he's still hurt over his wife and child dying to ever fully move on.

[@thatbobbi]

@@ryandlion6961 Mary's voice is a teensy bit grating... and her constant "Oh, Arthurrr."s... Not to be mean to a fictional character.

[@ryandlion6961]

Yeah shes such a hopless romantic with the oh Arthurs,if she really loved him she'd wait for him until he took care of his family,being all the gang,its more of a selfish love,but it was pretty damn beautiful that she visited his grave,if only I could have a women do that for me if say I died tomorrow,besides my Mom or grandma I mean haha .

[@thatbobbi]

@@ryandlion6961 To take it a bit further, Mary does sort of take advantage of Arthur's love for her. If I rebuffed a man who proposed to me (and kept the ring for some reason like Mary did), I wouldn't then ask them for favors years later. It's bad taste, Mary! Lol OK I'm done. P.S. I'm sure there are many ladies who would visit your grave. Don't be so damned hard (and macabre) on yourself.

[@thizzleimatic]

Authur and John's explaining is like Uncle trying to explain his lumbago

[@ducluong1992]

Watching this again makes me feel sad. Everyone remembers our good fella Arthur.

[@Trevor_on_Youtube]

“Lilly May.” *immediately pulls out rifle*

[@jonathantromp7270]

Imagine how Arthur would have reacted if he was still alive

[@Anakin_Skywalker47]

Especially low honour Arthur

[@briankasnick4403]

I still can’t believe Mickey will walk with you...this game is legit a masterpiece

[@entrxpic]

They sound exactly like John and Abigail

[@griz312]

Raven except Abigail actually loves John and this fool chased this Lily-May and never even cared that much for him.

[@thatbobbi]

Which part

[@PingasMonkey3rdClass]

And thats love for ya

[@gebyk]

Man, the conbersation between John and Mickey was so emotional and important for me

[@HighTher3]

No one: Rdr2 NPCs: I'm gonna tell you my entire goddamn life story

[@gabrielbrennan4149]

Don’t idolize your love interest and you won’t be shattered when they’re imperfect. Learn to be selfless and you’ll have happiness in helping them to be, too.

[@whitefox52lx32]

Right after my breakup it seems like KZbin is throwing it in my face by putting a lot of girl trouble videos that relate to my problem in my recommendation list 😂😢

[@ChengTeoh]

The algorithm knows all. XD

[@zaeden657]

Well just don’t take advice from Arthur

[@masterson0713]

Haha pusay

[@unculturedswine5583]

meh,most stuff thats really worth it, have big risks with them seeing as how happy some people get in the end ,its a risk worth taking

[@98rzsupy]

Phones listening to you

[@Heisenvald]

All jokes aside, the details and random events in this game are insane.

[@uppercaset12345]

I never saw this guy and I thought I saw everything.

[@ChengTeoh]

Have you seen the preacher in the water?

[@uppercaset12345]

Run into him a couple of times.

[@whoevencaresbrawecb1139]

Cheng Teoh On second playthrough I killed him twice to end his pain that and he’s kinda annoying after the first time I think it’s funny when random events happen after u kill them like in this play through I kill the people who challenge me to shooting contests for the money instead of doing it cuz lazy lol

[@kingpotato7183]

I saw him once and he told me to go away so I did this was in chapter 6 and before the last mission

[@dameonpounders7211]

There's a lot of stuff in the game that probably hasn't been found yet. I'm on my second playthrough and have finally seen the preacher in the water and the chelonian crap

[@gplgs4640]

Watermarking these videos may not prevent MrBossFTW from stealing from the ideas, but he won’t be able to rip your video clips out of your videos, and he’ll have to actually put effort into them. Just a suggestion.

[@lks7842]

He did watermark his video in the bottom right corner

[@porflimbornapilis2556]

Who f*kn cares. The internet is ALL theft. join in or get out.

[@Starkill3r306]

It’s not Arthur’s fault that rock guy pick a bad one

[@FETICHE_CAMINANTE]

So... you´ve been following this dude all the way from San Luís River to Valentine... quite the journey...

[@ChengTeoh]

lol, yes it was long considering the pace that npcs walk at. XD

[@CorneliusBogfrollupFitzgerald]

I only found him after I completed the game. So jack told him to be a “there aren’t so many nice men out there, be one of the good ones, she’ll come around” after he said thanks, he immediately started saying things like “That rotten witch!” Interesting how jack has all Arthur’s diol ogives recorded as well

[@ChengTeoh]

Jack? Do you mean John? Or are you being naughty and using a mod... shhh I won't tell. XD

[@CorneliusBogfrollupFitzgerald]

Cheng Teoh Jim Milton*

[@Lordofcookiejars]

@@CorneliusBogfrollupFitzgerald John Jim Milton*

[@faisalpalevi3305]

This is why red dead redemption 2 is one of the best game all time

[@erielmartin8130]

Never before in gameplay history A broken lover throwing rocks at a river coming near you.

[@idk_9964]

“Never known a more evil women,” Sadie: hold my beer and my gun oil

[@sleufffff]

I didn't realise mickey would just follow you lmao

[@LacyLemur]

I thought I god damn helped him! Damn it.

[@TheMrwacko55]

This is the most insanely in-depth game ever lol. No wonder it took 8 years to make

[@krazykrumz3]

Lol you got me with that one, the Mickey smalltalk was worth it though haha. "My name's Mickey!!"

[@MrGetty-kh1ch]

Eight years later he’s still ranting throwing stones at an ocean

[@Everik-ct6pg]

You can't change a Neckbeard

[@Average22Joe]

Anyone else cry when Mickey started speaking about Arthur???

[@Willthemille]

the way he delivers the "I have never known a more evil woman!" line gets me every time

[@brutalgames9248]

I chose to stay near him, and I kept talking to him like you did. It's crazy how little choice's affect outcomes in this game

[@shaneups]

I’m going through a issue similar to this, whenever I’m alone I’ll complain about all that’s going wrong in the relationship, and when I saw this in the game I thought of me. When I made John give advice to him saying that he should stick to the relationship, I looked at that as a sign that things will get better eventually. I know the advice might be a little bad judging by the comments I’ve read about Arthur’s advice being like “Dutch’s plan”, but I guess you never really know what you’ll lose from a relationship, and that’s one of the things that makes me wanna stay with the person that truly makes me feel special. (By the way, this is not my KZbin account, just wanted to clarify)

[@nomahfuckah2080]

Bro,dont take advice or signs from a game wtf. That might be why your relationships trash.

[@Useless22]

The joke is at first he wanted her more than anything and after he got her he regretted it.

[@tamashi4242]

You've got a nice profile pic

[@DoppelgangerJ]

I wonder if the dialogue is different if Arthur had antagonized him instead.

[@ZeSgtSchultz]

Your videos are short, sweet and to the point. I appreciate your craft sir. Thank you.

[@meltingstream3385]

That's nice you still Kept talking to the guy

[@ethanliedl3743]

I love how the game let's Arthur live on in story

[@vivecald-vehk6978]

"There are two tragedies in life: The first is not getting what you want. And the second, is."

[@chrispresnell1209]

RIP Arthur I miss Arthur😢😢

[@alexwaters4238]

How can John say that Arthur wasn't a good guy???!!!! He saved his damn life!

[@donfrye9185]

I was thinking that too. I wish he said something like “he weren’t a good man or a bad man, he was an extraordinary man with ordinary flaws... and because of that, many people are still breathing... my family and I included... but of course, many... many more are not. Take that as you will.” I could totally imagine him saying something like that

[@BabyScatha]

John is grateful. He told everyone he met that knew Arthur he saved him. But Arthur wasnt a good guy for a long time. Add to that john didnt see the good things he did with OTHER people (if you play him good). Doesnt mean he isnt grateful. He just didnt see everything the player did.

[@AbdallahAzerjawi27]

3:53 micky: i need money please John: A QUEST IAM ON A QUEST!

[@ChengTeoh]

I'm lucky that I didn't "accidentally" run over Mickey on the horse. XD

[@AbdallahAzerjawi27]

@@ChengTeoh if it happend lets say. The kid would run away Bounty 5 dollars And you have to reapet every thing😜

[@shadesensei]

Was so focused, then 3:34 lmao

[@BlazerGirl16]

😂😂😂😂😂 I laughed my ass off at him

[@greg5299]

How did I never meet him? I would pass by that place all the time as Arthur

[@ChengTeoh]

Oh, he appears pretty randomly near bodies of water. It is not a certainty that he'll appear where he did in my playthrough as he will in yours. In a separate playthrough I saw him near a little stream close to Annesburg ( in that run I spent the entire game trying to see how long I could avoid lakes & streams while in free-roam ). XD

[@winterspirit3734]

Stranger: I want Lily-May Arthur: *Helps him get Lily-May Stranger: That guy ruined my life John: Arthur? *SMACK

[@jackthewinter5066]

So the lesson of the story: never get married I think Jeff Bezos wants to know my location now

[@friendlyzeldafan9279]

He doesn't WANT to know, he ALREADY knows.