Arthur's Confession in Red Dead Redemption 2 [All Dialogues]

This video shows Arthur's confession to Reverend Swanson and Sister Calderón from the cutscene at the end of the mission "The Fine Art of Conversation".
===================================
Video recorded on: PlayStation 4 Pro
===================================
GTA Series Videos is a dedicated fan-channel keeping you up to date with all the latest news, video walkthroughs and official trailers of the most successful video games published by Rockstar Games, including Grand Theft Auto series, Red Dead Redemption, Max Payne, L.A. Noire, Bully and many others.
This channel is in no way tied to Rockstar Games or Take-Two Interactive.
Follow GTA Series Videos on:
|| KZbin - / gtaseriesvideos
|| Google+ - www.google.com/+GTASeriesVideos
|| Facebook - / gtaseriesnews
|| Twitter - / gtaseries
For more info and videos visit:
www.GTASeriesVideos.com | www.GTA-Series.com | www.GTA-Downloads.com | www.Games-Series.com

[@GTASeriesVideos]

Here are the three different cutscenes from the mission "The Fine Art of Conversation": 0:20 - Arthur meets Reverend Swanson (Low Honor) 3:28 - Arthur meets Reverend Swanson (High Honor) 6:42 - Arthur meets Sister Calderon (High Honor) [NOTE: You have to complete Brother Dorkins' second mission in Saint Denis called "Brothers and Sisters, One and All", where you meet Sister Calderon for the first time]

[@BellowDGaming]

Seems Sister is suggesting that you HELP John at the end and do a selfless act, making it the canon ending.

[@ThatGuy-ke5ov]

@@BellowDGaming it's also the one where Arthur writes in his journal that he found peace with his death and knows what he must do.

[@davigurgel2040]

What if you vomplete brother dorkin's missions with low honor? Do you get a different variation?

[@kawaii8330]

GTA Series Videos Hello can you help me please ? :( I have high honor at the max but i saw Reverend Swanson :(

[@davigurgel2040]

@@kawaii8330that's because you didn't complete the sister calderon mission. Its a mission you find in saint denis and you have to complete it to talk to the sister

[@CDB2]

The High Honor scenes get me man. ...that's why I can never play Arthur with low honor, he deserves to go out like a hero.

[@walterwhite8563]

I think it makes sense to be bad until arthur is diagnosed with tb. Then it's like his repenting for his sins and trying to make thing's right before he dies.

[@TitoLasma]

@@walterwhite8563 I was good the entire game, but when I replay the story (very soon) I will go rogue before TB and good after. (only downside is I will loose some honor missions in the first chapters, but oh well..)

[@Caleonn]

That’s how it’s meant to be played.

[@justhellbound4206]

I went through with low honor, only because i did rdr 1 with honor. And I didn't know the game had multiple endings. Otherwise I would've gone through with high honor if i knew it would effect the ending.

[@j_doggyo7780]

😢ya

[@scotibot7450]

"I'm afraid" Its the most honest thing a man can say.... but also the toughest

[@fsgaming9788]

That literally put a tear in my eye when I got the scene with sister Calderon

[@Celisar1]

ScotiBot If that is the toughest thing for a man to say then an outdated idea of masculinity is the problem. We all know that men have the same feelings as women so why suppress them and why not admit them? Doesn’t make sense. Being honest to yourself and others always commands my highest respect.

[@scotibot7450]

Celisar1 ever consider its our societal norms that are to blame and not the concept of masculinity or even femininity for that matter? In most societies men are seen as more disposable than women and that’s goes back millennia even amongst the more patriarchal of societies. I mean think about it who primarily fights in wars? Men. Who primarily works the most dangerous jobs? Men. It seems in any society men typically make up the aegis that protect it and the workhorse that labours for it even today. My point is that because of this it’s not easy for men to show such emotions as it could be seen as a display of weakness of deficiency. And many people will often push that narrative both men and women And in terms of emotional projections I’d say that’s just as true now as it was back in 1899 when RDR2 is set

[@Celisar1]

ScotiBot Yes, times have unfortunately hardly changed society in regard to all to many gender stereotypes and cliches. Our societal norms equal the concept of masculinity and femininity. If we think something is not manly according to our concept of masculinity then it becomes the societal norm and vice versa. Body strength is the primary reason why men fought in wars and later had the physically demanding, dangerous jobs. The “men being seen as more “disposable” thing” is not right. The survival of a tribe is only ensured by both sexes (reg. Fighting as well as child care). In most societies it was made very hard for women to make a living by themselves, so a husband was very important. Of course since children are the most precious resource in every society and women were the ones doing child care women and children were in emergency situations prioritized in western countries during the last centuries, but that’s not the same everywhere.

[@scotibot7450]

Celisar1 physicality is one aspect of it but here’s the other you are missing beyond collective cohesion of a tribe. You have 2 tribes one with a larger percentage per head of women and the other with a larger percentage of men. The former has a better chance of continuing as when it comes to repopulating I.e childbirth as it can more easily deal with the rigours of bearing children. As opposed to the latter where the women’s lot would be more arduous. If we look at it in non individualistic terms women are held to a higher value than men because of this. It’s sounds pretty primal I know but ultimately this is why most societies are typically protective of the female of the species... oppressively so in some cases I can grant you but ultimately a loss of a woman is more deeply felt than that of a man from a top down perspective. In regards to the child rearing aspect (and before I continue I wanna be clear I’m talking averages here not absolutes) men and women are wired differently chemically as well as physically. Men tend to be more aggressive (another reason why we end up as frontline troops) women more socially adept.

[@atriggeredboi2218]

When Sister Calderón said "Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act" That legit hit me

[@viniciusbueno2160]

That and i'm afraid got me to drop some tears, the ending destroyed me for a few hours

[@Kanal7Indonesia]

Love = God

[@lil_biscuit]

And his other hitting line here I’m afraid

[@Gabriel-wy5wu]

That's why i am playing this game for the 10th time

[@jimmymurphy898]

Ikr! The writing in this game is so fucking good.

[@jacobnavel4442]

Arthur: "My path is comin' to an end reverend.." Swanson: "I know.." *scoots away*

[@snowconeinthedoublecup]

When he told me, "you're not a good man" I was ready to end his sorry addiction right there.

[@DMCS1917]

@Jacob Navel, он не хочет заразиться туберкулезом, преподобный уже выглядит достаточно больным

[@Hypogean7]

@@snowconeinthedoublecup I mean, Arthur is still a murderer , a thief, and an extorsionist. High honor Arthur found redemption, but he still caused a lot of destruction .

[@mazorki8917]

SORA even tho that was the only life Arthur knew after his family, wife and son passed away. Wild West was a really fucked up age, there were a lot of crimes because of the lack of law and job in that time. So there were not so many opportunities of getting money in the legal way. Arthur was just getting money for the gang in the only way he could: murdering, stealing etc, he only murdered when needed and he stole because it was the only way they could survive. Arthur was a good man living a life that he didn’t chose, the only life he knew and the only way you could live in the Wild West. Sorry for my English it isn’t my native language.

[@skeeterfromsouthpark1414]

That part made me laugh just a little

[@highcookiess]

My confession was with sister Calderon. I didn't even know there was a cut scene with Swanson...

[@rflores.g]

Same.... And the "I'm afraid" made me tear up :(

[@e1337prodigy]

@@rflores.g Same. I've been playing on pc, and I was just trying to find this cut scene again because it was so amazing. I'm so glad I got that cut scene otherwise I probably wouldn't have known it exists. I think the music 7:50 that comes into it, although subtle definitely adds to it, the other cut scenes didn't have music.

[@nicklewis470]

Same

[@brakkinb3830]

Same

[@Toxin___InterHalfer]

It's not cut lol, I had a scene with Swanson

[@Alemelbi]

When he says "I'm Afraid..." I'm not one to get sentimental in movies or games but man, when he said that and the expression he had on his face made my eyes water. What a masterpiece of a game.

[@mikeyw.346]

same here man, he's this resilient man that's been through a lot but when he said that along with his expression, it was real and it gave me a shock. Mainly due to the fact that I've never really felt such closeness to a video game character.

[@stijnmessing3143]

I know right, Arthur always suppresses his emotions and him showing he's afraid for the first time hits really hard.

[@mikeyw.346]

Stijn Messing exactly, there are times where it does get to him but he doesn’t show it but in that instance, it comes out and left me like “wow...”

[@WhiteSharkUK]

Yep same here. The fear and sorrow in his voice and eyes is very touching.

[@WhiteSharkUK]

The bit that also got me was when he says "well I'm... I'm dying sister."

[@Dennis-nc3vw]

"And the women, little jack, you're leaving them?" It's a really nice touch that when he was low honor, he sits down when he says that. But when he has high honor, he looks Swanson right in the face like he's interrogating him.

[@germ4Nn]

Well, it's a low honor line though to get there you have to decide to help Rain Falls, and that's a paragon choice. No matter how low your honor is, the quest started by an honorable path.

[@alec6583]

And Swanson can't even look Arthur in the eye.

[@FerinHite]

It's fascinating, really. It hammers in that there's no karma system, it's an honor system. Low honor Arthur just accepts the loss of yet another friend, because he's in no position to throw stones. High honor Arthur seems like he legitimately scares the Reverend by his sheer presence, because how do you explain your own cowardice to the man who makes your faith look pitiful? Rockstar put a lot of thought into these characters and this scene.

[@JayLiszte]

I think you switch those two up

[@Halterin11]

@@JayLiszte What are you on about?

[@shoogamoogaman]

"We've all lived bad lives Mr Morgan, we all sin... but I know you" Note that the next time we see Sister Calderon is in the stranger mission 'I know you' in RDR 1.

[@gianb3952]

Daaaaaaaaaaaamn I didnt know this

[@yahootheweirdo]

Aw really? thats really neat

[@audreygold7533]

That's very cool

[@wigout3936]

Isn't she stealing money from the church?

[@randomgod6371]

@@wigout3936 noo she collect and reparts Herself she is a true Saint.

[@AlbertFnWesker]

When Arthur said "I'm afraid" I died, too much man. To see such a strong man like that afraid killed me, it really hurt.

[@NXC97]

It got me too

[@stefancristi2493]

Hi Wesker. I’d rather just blame it all on ‘em onion cutters and leave it be... .

[@stefancristi2493]

But seriously, I don’t know why I got so emotional about this that I even shed some tears.

[@vaderownage2000]

It's that vulnerability. The whole scene and especially while playing it and it happens, man I was just overwhelmed.

[@fredlaroche6969]

Me too... that unbelievable voice acting too!!!

[@Ethan-bx8gy]

Saddest Quotes: "I'm dying sister... Yeah, I got TB... I got it... Beating a man. To death. For a few bucks." "I'm afraid..."

[@themax2]

"I'm afraid" was really, really heart breaking for me :'-(

[@blazetieftw]

Yeah, it’s hypocritical for a casual killer like Arthur to fear death, but it’s still a very emotional scene.

[@justaflaminfox9574]

Well rip aurthur morgan you made rdr2 proud

[@MrZorin11]

What about "I gave you all I had..."

[@lafftaff6950]

Arthur got me in my feelings already

[@MrBubz-pq3ck]

Arthur: Avoid Gaurma Soldier: Where? Arthur: FoRgeT AbOuT iT

[@MariusBoss11458]

Aint that funny

[@MrBubz-pq3ck]

MariusBoss 11458 Oh well, just trying to make someone’s day better

[@warutsu5437]

*HeADs tO gAurmA*

[@tamedpassions9523]

IM WALKING HERE

[@tamedpassions9523]

@kaine bolts not funny didnt laugh

[@dylan-kj9zc]

I tried playing a low honor Arthur and I just couldn’t

[@amitr24242]

I tried. In the end, i did... I know its really hard i can do it only if i come back to the save file before i did it. But save my bad deeds? NEVER!

[@hyperfire1134]

Dylxz2 boring

[@lilpp4791]

Hyperfire 11 stfu

[@moonpenguin6298]

Hyperfire 11 stfu

[@justice_of_Youtube]

@@amitr24242 boring

[@TheHelloitslucas]

10:05. Just give Arthur all the damn voice acting awards right there

[@alexk5907]

Roger Clark AKA Arthur Morgan won best voice actor 2018 at the game awards. I was so happy for him.

[@G0nzA10895]

Don't forget that moment is powerful not only because of Alrthur's voice actor but also thanks to the people who made his model and facial animations, if it wasn't for that this scene wouldn't be the same at all.

[@FirstnameLastname-jz1ux]

and give whoever did the facial mocap deserves one too

[@actualzafra]

The actors themselves acted for facial mocap. Props to Roger Clark AGAIN

[@FirstnameLastname-jz1ux]

@@actualzafra wow i didnt know that

[@ogarkovxoxo]

I met sister Calderon. Never knew the scenes might be different.

[@danielkral3046]

Bitsy Yeah, it seems that playing the game with high honor and compleating all honor story missions is the best way how to feel with Arthur and with everything what is happening. Very good and emotional story :(

[@2devil35]

Same here....Never knew there where 3

[@Become-Eggplant]

Same

[@plh8707]

sister calderon is actually in rdr1 in mexico.

[@j_doggyo7780]

Same

[@manintheflannel3693]

I'm very proud of the fact that I got the Low Honor scene with Reverend Swanson but ended up getting the High Honor ending.

[@hunterbrookes]

Yeah did the same on my second playthough

[@jimmilton5465]

Lol i got that too man, i think That's the canon. Starting with low honor, ended up with high honor.

[@organicsmurf5850]

Letnan SAINT DENIS nah. I don’t think so. If one way is canon, I believe it is a full high honor play through.

[@gibraltar2843]

Robert Brooks well, if you look at it closely, Arthur isn’t a good man right from the get go. He doesn’t seem to care much about others or robbing or anything. But right when he gets TB, it’s like he sees things more clearly. He becomes the man he never thought he would. Betraying his old gang and helping his old friend. It feels like the story that makes the most sense. He doesn’t really stop being a bad man (all the robberies and deaths he’s caused), and then all of a sudden he tries to redeem himself. Doesn’t matter, still played with max honor the entire game. Couldn’t handle being a dickhead Arthur.

[@jimmilton5465]

@@organicsmurf5850 of course no bro. Its just like real life. Nobody would become good if they didnt got the "karma", i think. Arthur broke many people , killed and robbed so many folks, after that he got TBC, that disease make him realize his failure he did in the past. Thats mu opinion🙏

[@MegaTeeks]

“Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act” fuck that’s a great line, totally missed it when I played through the first time

[@homeboy6243]

thats how rockstar wants us feel or play

[@jaredfromsubway6755]

Roberto del rio nice name

[@themaskedmutantreal]

"but then, I meet someone like you and everything makes sense."

[@SisyphusCries]

That’s the sweetiest line i ever heard in my life

[@livepositive2058]

Even though people has done bad things and has lived a bad life does not always mean they are a bad person a lot of people like that drown in their ways they want so much to live better but the life keeps dragging them down. The strongest of men can be warriors but there is a place in the heart that still has love and compassion and really just urges for a sweet release one day for it all to just go away and ur spirit to fly away

[@tushnikchakraborty5739]

Those words always get me...

[@mikemiter6088]

That scene was awesome Even tho I dont belive in god that much I do belive being a good man to my core and thats all religion tries to do.

[@unknownymousbiatch9187]

Then she meets John Marston in Mexico in RDR1

[@combathoney1]

"Take a gamble that love exists and do a loving act". Never thought I'd hear words of such simple sincerity from a RockStar game of all places. Just as the game shows Arthur grow as a person, it also shows RockStar have grown and can write without the wearying cynicism that usually pervades their games.

[@samuelevander9823]

Dan Houser grew old... Or maybe he never went soft and Rockstar always sought to criticize society through crime dramas and westerners. I just don't know.

[@ftsrwr]

I did Widow missions after this and it all made so much sense!

[@Apontheon]

Dale Gribble soon to change no doubt

[@mrsenor5233]

Just wait for GTA 6

[@r.b.9162]

Well the Story of the Red Dead Redemption series is written way more serious and emotional than the one of the GTA games.

[@nicklewis470]

The way Reverend Swanson shifts away from the low honor Arthur when Arthur says he's dying... Tiny detail that adds a lot to their interaction...

[@tofferooni4972]

Social Distancing.

[@tofferooni4972]

He is desperately trying to keep distance while also not trying to be rude.

[@Growmetheus]

Yall keep saying that but it was to turn himsef toward him.

[@kevinwatters6472]

I have high honor but I got the Swanson scene for some reason

[@TheVoidofemptiness]

@@kevinwatters6472 did you do the monk and nun side missions?

[@giraffeman326]

“Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act” Love that quote

[@killerworrier4724]

I love that quote as well. Im planning to get a deer tatto with that quote

[@vikks3451]

Indeed

[@temmywemmy8544]

On my second playthrough I was still being a psychopath but still kept good honor and when I heard that I started to change arthur

[@TheDrTopo]

I want to hug arthur so hard

[@windowsdotexe4444]

Then he coughs on your face accidentally

[@negin4651]

Yes :(

[@joshuavillagomez8369]

@@windowsdotexe4444 I'll still do it, giving that man a hug is worth dying for

[@Nokronz]

What about me ? No offense Arthur.

[@uncle8536]

Don’t we all

[@trkthnc]

Years after, we see Sister Calderon Killin' Zombies In The Outbreak. Damn, small world.

[@ilearnedhownottobejealous2301]

They are not the same... And undead nightmare is not cannon

[@ilearnedhownottobejealous2301]

@@trkthnc if Undead nightmare is cannon how do you explain Uncle dieing twice. In Red dead redemption they see Uncle die and in undead nightmare they know he is Alive and comes back as zombie,that just one example. Undead nightmare is a "what if story"does not fit in with the principal story. Undead nightmare is just a DLC for good zombie Halloween fun,its not cannon. Last time UN is not cannon.

[@LonelyLionMain]

@@ilearnedhownottobejealous2301 It's the lumbago

[@ilearnedhownottobejealous2301]

@@LonelyLionMain lol lumbago saved him

[@LonelyLionMain]

@@ilearnedhownottobejealous2301 Uncle is the strange man

[@tigrepd6042]

I love how Rockstar has stepped up their game from, “Guns, drugs, drinking, and bitches and hoes” and chose to show morality and inspiration for those who choose it. Even for those who aren’t necessarily Christian and/or Catholic, that final clip shows a lot of truth about the human heart and it’s reality.

[@VicBaws]

... what do you mean by "their game" and that description? GTA?. Is not the same franchise and GTAV is not comparable to RDR2 (on Storytelling level). I think RDR2 was pretty good and not lame (like you described it) since the beginning

[@herbseinburg449]

Well I mean the first red dead got me emotionally attached to John marsto

[@Scoffslaphead72]

They stepped it up in gta 4 with the tragic story of niko bellic. Gta 5 imo was a low point in terms of story.

[@Scoffslaphead72]

They stepped it up in gta 4 with the tragic story of niko bellic. Gta 5 imo was a low point in terms of story.

[@Scoffslaphead72]

They stepped it up in gta 4 with the tragic story of niko bellic. Gta 5 imo was a low point in terms of story.

[@unwritten_zephyr]

“I’m afraid.” It crazy how two words can you hit you like a freight train. Bravo, Roger Clark. Bravo.

[@BasicShapes]

I know, that subtle choked up voice as he said "I'm afraid". Like you said, freight train smashing through my heart!

[@Spiri7ualShi7]

And bravo to the writer

[@unwritten_zephyr]

@@Spiri7ualShi7 I write screenplays as a hobby and I would love to read RDR2’s.

[@deathrager2404]

them voice actors made this game. without them this game would be even more boring than it already is.

[@gavinmeleck188]

@@unwritten_zephyr lol l

[@yolocl4524]

The one thing I regret about having Arthur's beard to the max length is not seeing that expression when he said he's afraid

[@mr_shay3133]

That beard is worth everything dude

[@terbentur2943]

It's in his eyes too Which is quite amazing for a virtual character

[@chillyconmor]

the beard is legendary

[@yahootheweirdo]

Thank you for making me laugh after watching this 😂

[@user-ur2wi3nn9r]

i always had he’s beard at 3 or no beard lmao

[@AJRodz]

Sucks Swanson just disappears with no send off if you get the nun cutscene

[@Benevoltt]

Is there any way to do the Brother Dorkins mission and still have Reverend? Like are they still available after this scene?

[@redvice6210]

AJ Rodz ikr Grimshaw mentioned him once and that was it.

[@IcySwagTag]

I didn’t care much for Reverend he was one of the worst characters i just found him annoying

[@andytaylor8342]

John Marston go build a house

[@akaybozz6299]

No actually he dont.... I‘ve had a sidequest back in Camp where arthur saw reverend packing up his stuff. And Arthur actually said it‘s the best he could do and supported reverend to leave as fast he could

[@Liquidouz]

Tbh I liked the low honor with Reverend Swanson the best, just something about how he says, "I dont have to, I know you, fight! And keep fighting! And leave the lies and the hypocrisy to men like me." Idk that was just a really powerful line to me.

[@Nibbenji2077]

Agreed

[@eon827]

Same. Thats the best one for me too even though i also like the high honor sister cutscene. Maybe its just me who likes the road less traveled

[@MOJAHED-XAN]

Same

[@LoserLoiue2009]

Its like the games last ditch effort to make you a good person

[@benjifallout4903]

Reverend made me cry when he was at that train station I would always antagonize everybody at the camp except Reverend He was my favourite character

[@nolanblakeley5911]

Reverend was always my favorite character ever since the first time we meet him on the tracks. And how he was always drunken and saying he was gonna become sober one day. It always gave me hope that he would change. I started seeing him change at Shady Belle and I got super happy but Arthur was always mean to him. And when the mission starting with the Reverend scene got so deep until Dutch interrupted them. I had the high honor Reverend scene and I’m happy that I didn’t get the Sister. I played back and got to Sister and I just enjoyed Reverend so much more. People hate Reverend but I loved Reverend’s character.

[@tidester3655]

It is metaphysically impossible for anyone to antagonize Hosea in any playthrough. Try it, see how your finger pulls away from the antagonize button. Pretty neat, huh?

[@carter_RU]

Lmao I always antagonized jack 😂

[@gabrielsage3425]

@@carter_RU "how's the weather down there?"

[@giorgiocialdini3796]

Poor Charles...

[@jtanicproduction7598]

I like how rockstar made so many possible cutscenes depending on your honor bar

[@-fewkey-2362]

JTanic Production this is pretty much one of the reason I god red dead redemption 2 because of the option and your honor. I will always try to have high honor with Arthur but when he died I had to do the same with John Marson.

[@alirafay6030]

King Bradberry because he had to die it is red dead redemption

[@BenPrattJin]

This is the kind of serious storytelling I missed in GTA V.

[@ilearnedhownottobejealous2301]

Are you joking???? GTA is not supposed to be serious. Man im FUCKING mad at you. Red dead series is way different the GTA GTA is more jokes and shit, while red dead is real life 100 years ago

[@BenPrattJin]

@@ilearnedhownottobejealous2301 Are *_you_* joking? How did you completely miss the point of GTA IV's story?

[@FuriousFnF]

GTA V is crap compared to this Masterpiece. All V actually did, introduced to GTA universe the real actors scene, not just voice, (much like LA Noire) they truly built a big world, but not as big as RDR2.... That said, i think Rockstar is really underestimating this game, because it costs as much as V cost back in the day.... Perhaps because of Online....

[@elcascavel]

Why are ppl so pissed? He's not saying GTA V had serious storytelling. He's saying he wish it had. And so do I.

[@redvice6210]

I learned how not to be jealous! So you’re one of those kids who only played gta 5?

[@LordSquirrelShow]

Love to play Arthur as a low honor character up until just after he figures out he's dying or right after these scenes. Such little time for redemption, it really makes the high honor ending hit that much harder.

[@notleviathan855]

I actually did that as well, I was playing as a gunslinger, but when I learned I was probably never going to see Arthur again I tried my hardest to make the other NPC's happy.

[@mario.theboss8511]

@@notleviathan855 exactly

[@mikemiter6088]

@@notleviathan855 sams

[@mikemiter6088]

@@notleviathan855 same

[@Unclerico45]

I did the same, up until a little after Arthur was diagnosed with tb, I was dishonorable af lol I killed random people who disrespected me, robbed innocent people, killed a few innocents in train robberies, hogtied people and executed them etc lol but then the redemption aspect came into play and I raised my honor to max level and died a hero :^)

[@MegaJacko4]

I do love how rockstar greatly encourages you to choose to be honorable. The game is so much more rewarding and all the more so when Arthur dies. I think they wanted Arthur to be one of the good guys with his continence very much intact rather than just a mindless killer. He fears everything we fear and has been through hell. Yet he has the soul of a king. And that's probably why he was named after one.

[@FaynarsSaiqo]

I'm guessing you meant "with his conscience very much intact", but his continence is a very funny replacement for the real words

[@apollo8017]

10:08 that expression... damn.

[@LegoDude568]

Replay i felt that shit and it hurt

[@redvice6210]

Replay I think that’s the first time we see him scared

[@milboxr9772]

It's Arthur's puppy eyes face :(

[@saunderschan9839]

Outside?

[@rooster1335]

That shit gets you in the feels

[@JaimeRodriguez-ok6om]

“Take a gamble that love exist and do a loving act.”

[@rickriot8743]

All abourd

[@crizsha7977]

I shall try.

[@skeeterfromsouthpark1414]

Sister was right. Every time they meet he's helping people and smiling. He's a good person, no matter how much he wants to deny it

[@deathrager2404]

too bad the game wants you to be good but then throws mission in your face to make you be bad. terrible execution. this whole honor bullshit should not have been in this game.

[@trevorphilips9065]

@@deathrager2404 You see no one cares about a whiny child just letting you know

[@tonytan5945]

@@deathrager2404 You say the game is boring and then you say that they should remove all the things that make it interesting.

[@KippySmith1231]

@@deathrager2404 I know you said this 8 months ago, so a bit late on the reply, but you missed the whole point of the story. The game makes you be bad because you're playing Arthur's story, and Arthur's story is one of a life where he's been led into bad situations and into doing bad things constantly by the star he follows, which is Dutch. The theme of the whole game is people can try to be someone else, but they end up becoming more of who they really are over time. Dutch builds himself up to be this moral compass, this kingly character with the love of the finer things in life, but he's wrestling with who he really is, which is a sort of sociopath who will do or say anything to get his way. Arthur is our contrast to Dutch, where Arthur has spent his whole life building himself up to be bad, so he could survive and fit in with the gang he ran with. But Sister Calderon sees who he really is, that he's happiest when he's doing kind deeds and helping people. She knows that deep down, that's Arthur's real character, though he's always been fighting against it. Like Mary says to him, there's a good person within Arthur, but he's wrestling with a giant. So the game, the missions, the story is all there to illustrate Arthur's struggle with overcoming that giant, and becoming the good person that was underneath all along.

[@fuusion8446]

“You lived your life like a man Arthur, and you turned into a good man.” Gets me every time.

[@2woDreaded]

I coughed yesterday and I thought I had tuberculosis

[@enriquepastor3626]

CrackShot Chord I been sick lately and I felt so cool coughing at the same time as him while playing lol

[@2woDreaded]

Enrique Pastor lol

[@dukeofdogs6522]

@@enriquepastor3626 same lol

[@deafgamerguy3290]

Lmao

[@korol4546]

Me too, we are strange people))

[@Nobodysurvivesevenonebit]

Glad I got good honor and met the nun.

[@joedevil29]

you can still have good honor and not meet the nun, because if you don't do Brother Dorkins' missions you won't see her regardless of honor

[@BoomSonic97]

@@HiddenRealm there was originally a comment of a person saying they didn't meet the nun but had max honor. That was the comment that guy replied too, hence why there was no @ to the person who posted the comment your talking about. The comment was probably removed because I think the person posted that multiple times on this video and usually youtube themselves will remove spam comments at times. Also don't know why you're being an asshole because not a lot of people knew you could even meet the nun because they didn't do any strange missions. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[@thegamejunky7223]

I didnt.. and the ending with Good honor, like, the very end was RIVETING.

[@edfaellara109]

I saw Reverend but with high honor

[@commieghost]

Edfael Lara same

[@Crazelord91]

I didn't even know there was a scene with the Rev. I couldn't bring myself to make Arthur a bad person, especially once he got TB. I made sure to be as altruistic as I could so I naturally got the sister scene

[@kingqunt8567]

If you didn’t do one of the side missions you would get RS anyway

[@locopells4406]

@@kingqunt8567 I wish they'd given RS another scene, if you get SC, I always wondered what happened as he just...disappeared, without even a mention like, Bill, Pearson and the women got.

[@user-mu8dm4rk7g]

@@locopells4406 Susan mentions (tells you directly) he left if you got SC prior to that.

[@locopells4406]

@@user-mu8dm4rk7g Ah, right, must've missed that.

[@Sousabird]

Agreed. I missed Sister's mission on my first playthrough and I liked the last talk with Swanson, I wish that they weren't mutually exclusive.

[@qq-sd5hi]

anyone notice how his voice changes depending on the honor , you can really hear it when he says reverend at both starts.

[@Pablo-V]

10:03 Arthur's face after saying he's afraid really made me shed a couple of tears.

[@ramzichaouir7278]

Manly tears but damn wasnt expecting to cry over a character in a videogame one day

[@rockstriker1622]

Really really sad scene. I really loved it and I am glad I witnessed this scene in the game.

[@emvee7408]

Me too! I can’t help crying :(

[@thedavidjscott_]

Ramzi Chaouir it’s okay, the end of the first RDR made me cry as well.

[@Lysdexis]

@@thedavidjscott_ I was so pissed at the end of 1. Dual yielded revolvers. 12 shots. One for each head.

[@nickisweird7976]

When Arthur told sister he was afraid I started tearing up because he finally decided to express his emotions and let everything out and just excepted the fact that he’s running out of time, they took their time making this game and it’s probably the greatest game of all time or even one of the greatest story to show

[@lyakiplays3253]

Nick Is weird I agree, the fact that he is always saying «i’m fine» Even tough he is clearly not also played a role for me here. Seeing Him be completely honest and naked with all cards on the table actually saying «i’m afraid» really makes one feel, amazing game.

[@darklord220]

Accepted

[@punishedandrexi7593]

“But then, I meet someone like you. And everything makes sense.” How many feels can r* fit into a single cutscene? The world may never know

[@erolkartal4314]

You're to Smart for me sister, i guess i'm afraid

[@elsadabbasov8187]

@@erolkartal4314 there is nothing to be afraid, mr. Borgan

[@spaceman9410]

@@elsadabbasov8187 borgan

[@sioptimumpride7854]

"I hear Tahitis nice" I love that line

[@Ryanhaggins07]

It’s a magical place

[@YoursTruIy_]

Just Arthur's expression as he mutters those dreadful two words, the words we all know, the words that rip our feelings apart. "I'm afraid" The expression along with the delivery is one of which that is sure to scar all of us for years to come. Also, to be able to finally say something along the lines of being able to show true feeling in the heart is so beautiful, so dedicated, so wrenchingly saddening, it's what makes us all tear up in this moment.

[@cp5385]

that's three words

[@betancourtj3]

ItsStevieBoy Omg, that part killed me as well 😭😭😭😭

[@Gerardo-jf8yj]

" I'm afraid " is the purest line in the game 😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@PastLifeVillian]

You’re not deep

[@darkhorsed]

@@PastLifeVillian and you are a dick

[@lishalulu]

The high honor scene with Sister Calderon had me crying, especially at the part where he says "I'm dying sister" and "I'm afraid". Also the bit when his horse is shot. I haven't cried so much at a game before!

[@edwardx4979]

As a female gamer, know that a lot of guy gamers were balling their eyes out or were close enough to shed tears! I'm hard core but I choked up...didn't cry but water was about to crack the flood gates!!! Not gonna lie... Lol 😅

[@shay3929]

I wish he could have had a happy ending

[@MariusBoss11458]

I was "afraid" when my horse died lol and LENNAH too jumped out of the bed at every death exept hosea i just "goddamit"

[@yahootheweirdo]

I cried when arthur was taking his final ride back to the camp to confront micah, and the music was playing with the voices of people telling arthur he is a good man

[@StillAtMyMoms]

I used my first given horse the entire game. Didn't expect him to die, either.

[@vwolfee5046]

The only quote that got me to cry was, "I gave you all I had Dutch... I did."

[@JGRJakks]

I love how Rockstar takes things serious when they made the nun's cutscene, even that is a videogame its emotional & it makes us have feelings for Arthur, just from his words: "Im afraid" & his sad face makes us feel heartbroken & want to cry.

[@RandalfElVikingo]

Yeah, Sister Calderón is the wisest character in the whole game. She gives too much clarity to Arthur with few answers.

[@josharntt]

@@RandalfElVikingo Her then Hosea are the wisest

[@manuj2868]

J Arnett Suprisingly, uncle is also very wise. You should watch some camp interactions of him. Hamish also seemed to be wise.

[@maystamirra1179]

What if it’s a twist and he had lumbago the entire time

[@juancremagalvez9769]

it's a serious disease..... i even think that's a miracle that uncle is still alive

[@WJINTL]

He'd be dead instantly. Lumbago is a terminal illness worse than any other.

[@bandanasnek]

LuMbAgO

[@badvibes7582]

W J no its batter

[@samjoseph2572]

Gasp not LuMbAgO

[@thekingbutten]

8:07 So it was the Downes guy that gave it to him... *STRAUS IS THE REAL ANTAGONIST OF THIS GAME*

[@wichogr8396]

Yeah that poor motherfucker killed my man Arthur

[@ProMrLecoq01]

Carlos Gutierrez rip my mans arthur

[@positiivi_teme]

And Strauss is aware of Arthur's condition in the last collection missions. So Strauss knew Downes had died to TB. Someone mentioned elsewhere that there is a camp dialogue where this could be also mentioned.

[@spiderfan1974]

And if you would have read Arthurs journal it's obvious. Right after it happens in chapter 2. If you want to keep a secret hide it in plain sight.

[@kyrridas1573]

well, Strauss got what was coming to him. taken in by the law, interrogated, and beaten to death. but to his credit, he apparently never told them a word.

[@Crazelord91]

10:04 I defy anyone who played up to this moment to not feel some kind of way from that. Can bring a grown man to tears

[@elbeano1721]

After Guarma my honor started to go up, really made Arthur's character more interesting as it added to his character arc.

[@Houratronic]

When he said ''I'm afraid'' with that experssion on his face i cried for like 5 minutes... In my life i've made some really bad decisions and some good ones, been in relationships that have always turned out bad in the end. I don't know, i could just relate so much to arthur with good honor, people also say to me that ''i'm a good man'' but i keep telling my self that i'm not, things like this. ''I had a girl that loved me, i threw that away'' also something i could relate to being in the perfect relationship with a beutiful woman but just me fucking it up for dumb reasons, being in depression and regret.. I wish could go back and do things differently. Just an absolute masterpiece of a game

[@TheDragonSeer]

I cried at that part too. Its so relatable and painful to watch

[@tba113]

This deserves far more than the single 'like' I can give it.

[@jaxon_oconnor]

Just keep on keeping on man, life is short but it’s possibilities are endless. Happiness can find you in the darkest of places.

[@Houratronic]

@@jaxon_oconnor thanks a lot man, i will do my best!

[@DynamicDurge]

You should remind youself about what the whole games about. We can all think about what we want to do again, but it's about the time you have left that matters just as much, if not more. We all deserve redemption

[@RonaldPickering]

I’m a changed man Arthur. “30 mins later”... “Whisky please Barkeep”.

[@RonaldPickering]

This was a joke btw.

[@RonaldPickering]

Hidden I knew. Just a joke. I had no intention of upsetting you lore fan boys. Peace, love and prosperity dude🙌

[@RonaldPickering]

Hidden no worries, hope u enjoyed the game.

[@MariusBoss11458]

One night When i was freasky i fell and tumble and roar ill never get drunk anymore

[@nicklewis470]

Was he an alcoholic? I thought he was a morphine addict.

[@DAN-sf6jd]

When Arthur said "I'm afraid" i cried man, i cant hold it in, also i will never forget when he said "Revenge is a fools game" that we all need to know.

[@crangismcbasketball6062]

I LOVE that in high honor Swanson, Reverend is much more emotional, and saying goodbye to Arthur is difficult, like being more honorable strengthened their bond

[@Max25670]

high honor always has the best cutscenes.

[@aligamerable]

*I'm Afraid* 😢

[@Jr-ll9kk]

aligamerable those eyes will bring the toughest of men to tears

[@aligamerable]

@@Jr-ll9kk I was on Verge of crying. But I didn't. This hit me so hard in the feels.

[@Ryan_Duckworth]

I cried not gonna lie

[@aligamerable]

@@Ryan_Duckworth Ain't no shame in crying

[@Ryan_Duckworth]

I think this is the best scene in the whole game, I felt more emotion in this scene than in the end. At least if you have high honour with the nun.

[@taeminoutdid]

I always see Arthur in high honour, i can't even bring myself to make him have a low honour

[@Pumpkinss]

When he said "I'm afraid" I felt that. I really really felt that.

[@nko7817]

I know GOW was great and was beyond what I expected but... I still feel like RDR2 deserved the GOTY... seriously, I didn’t expect to get emotionally attached this much to a character from a freaking Rockstar Game! Still, RDR2 got other awards so, I’m happy :)

[@jtaput3483]

is it bad i thought GOW meant Gears of War before thinking of God of War?

[@adman4566]

Red dead is better it deserved goty but it in reality is game of the generation for me honestly

[@andreiselaru4374]

Rdr2 got the awards it deserved and so did god of war.

[@aidena8381]

Both games are excellent, both worthy of goty.

[@jackielana9993]

I was about to say “holy fuck Gears 4 did not deserve GOTY” and then I was like “shit that game came out way earlier”

[@nicholasprutzman9915]

Does anyone else find it funny people were pissed to play as jack Marston after john died, and now everyone is pissed to play as John Marston after Arthur died lol. They literally created a character that was better than the original and they tried to correct their mistake from the first one only to end up making the same mistake again lmao. Red dead 3 will have us playing as someone else in the early days of the Dutch gang they will get killed and we will finish out that game as Arthur and probably be pissed we have to do so

[@lordoblivion8038]

Nicholas Prutzman it's a cycle of red dead redemption.

[@ryangofett2433]

It was awesome playing as a younger John... Especially when his theme played when Joe and the other two men confronted him But I did miss playing as Arthur..it wasn't the same when mounting my horse as John "Let's go boah"

[@badabing7305]

We might play as Arthurs father we'll probably find out there was some reason he was an asshole or we'll play as Jack marston though i see no reason why then again Red Dead 2 might be the end of the series

[@nokomisnorth8409]

daniel gudino that’s lowkey genius to play as Arthur’s father, we can progress and see Arthur grow while we also play a dickhead of a character so when he dies and we play as Arthur we’re all happy. Or alternatively he lived a secret life and was actually a good person but Arthur could never see the good to his dad’s work and only that he was neglected or some shit and then we hate Arthur because he was a judgmental prick to his dad. GOD I WANT TO WRITE THIS NEXT GAME

[@frankrabbit2247]

if you think about it its genius. we get to know and love a character and truly miss them when theyre gone. and we are reunited with an old character we went down the same journey with before. so they never truly leave us.

[@taimur74]

Compare the Arthur here to the cold , ruthless outlaw we see in the "keep her in black .. on your behalf" and the evolution is amazing

[@renzotapia7306]

"Save Who You Can And Let The Rest Rot,And Look After Yourself...." My Favorite Line

[@lettuceasparagus5307]

“The greatest wealth is your health, all the gold in the world cannot purchase it and yet it is the most delicate and tenuous of all life’s gifts” This quote wraps it up nicely for we tend to take our health for granted. In fact, apart from the home pastures of the gang, the only valuable posession Arthur ever had was his health. Since his chances of being a family man were destroyed, he never found his true calling in life nor did he ever acquire decent selfworth to appreciate the beautiful guy he really was. Despite his efforts to redeem himself, his end seems so utterly fruitless, I am quite heartbroken because he definitely deserved more. To anyone who reads this, I hope you have a fulfilling and healthy life wherever you are.

[@lettuceasparagus5307]

OriginalDrDeLeon First of thanks for replying, weird though that I did not get a notification. What you are saying is absolutely right, he did make a few things right towards the end. He was one of those who never could have adapted to the changing world around him, he was bound to die from the start, he himself knew it. But I felt that they made him a tad too likable to just kill him off …

[@MrXxsoulessniperxx]

I believe Arthur's actions helped a lot of people in the long run. Jack ended up being an author.

[@enyrooo]

10:08 the look in his eyes :( like a baby 🥺

[@noahwiththehardr5787]

10:06 I always thought that men weren't suppose to cry but seeing Arthur say he's "afraid" and with that expression on his face. It shows me that it takes a real man to say that and I know that feeling. Life is precious 😔

[@ramymedh]

Men aren't supposed to cry? What?

[@graylindblad1261]

Ramy Medhat Gendered double standard

[@temfo]

This game changed me in some way,i think. Really. In a good way.

[@NeedForMead]

TemfO you and me both, it made me start to get my act together.

[@PureOrganic]

NeedForMead y’all keep working on that and don’t let that feeling and motivation fade

[@MrLinkDeity]

TemfO Me too. I was going to move out as soon as I graduated so I could live my life, but when I played this game & saw how Arthur tried to look out for his brothers & taught Jack how to fish, it made me think. Now I’m staying home for a while longer to teach my little brother some things.

[@PureOrganic]

J-Squeezy damn bro this is my situation right now and while I didn’t think about it while playing the game, your comment made me have a realization.

[@mistah6898]

It sounds silly saying it, but I believe you and I think it did the same for me. That's how you know it's a great game

[@PurpleKangaroo4]

the scene with the sister is clearly the most impactful, and in my mind the most canon, but its a shame that you dont really get closure with the reverend when you get it. you just get back to camp and he's left and thats it.

[@bretmaverick7774]

That's still more closure than you get with Karen Jones. She is the ONLY character who just...vanishes. No explanation given, nobody asks about her, nobody has rumors. What, a drunk hooker has to get a worse sendoff than any of the murdering backstabbers and thieves in the bunch...? That's flicted, Rockstar

[@vc180191]

@@bretmaverick7774 She doesn't vanish per say, while her fate is unknown, a letter from Tilly states that she has most likely died from alcohol poisoning during the time-skip, literally drinking herself to death from her depression and addiction (there is signs of this, during the final chapter she's rarely ever sober, wandering around the camp constantly drunk and just being bitter in every conversation, her alcohol problem gets even worse than Uncle's).

[@joelmiller6849]

PurpleKangaroo4 I didn’t give two fucks about the Reverend. Why are people acting like they cared whether or not he for closure? Weak character

[@keegan112099]

@@joelmiller6849 opposed to caring about a nun from a side quest? I prefer Swanson's send off because you see his development. He's no longer using opium and back to trying to be a good man

[@michaellegge7414]

“I know you will face your destiny like a man” That truly broke me

[@eon827]

His "fight, and keep fighting" was also pretty good. It shows that you dont just quit and keep fighting until you face your destiny like a man, like a "warrior". This is why i love the low honor with the reverend the most.

[@jack4810]

I saw the thumbnail with Reverend Swanson that said ‘bad’ and I was like WTF. I had high honour and I got Swanson. Now watching the video I realise why, I didn’t do that side activity in Saint Denis (I had no idea who that Nun was).

[@Broski6592]

"Helping makes you happy" Hinting us to help John

[@keir89]

when he mentions his son, and the way his eyes tear up as he says "I'm afraid", stunning, what a game

[@santanasoza2873]

When Arthur said he said he was afraid, that almost brought me to tears. He’s such a strong man and has killed many, but death is what he fears as well.

[@vaibhav2k13]

When Arthur says 'I am afraid' that frickin hit me hard right in the feels.

[@bahaddinonurciftci]

That ''I am afraid" part gets me everytime. Damnnn !!

[@left4dead2ification]

First time I watched this cutscene it really got me, It takes alot for a piece of entertainment to make me tear up but it got me still rewatching the sister ending. I prefer the sister version but it's a shame that the reverend doesn't get closure if you did those side missions.

[@justinrose850]

When Arthur says “I’m a afraid” it gets me every dang time

[@dylanochoa5787]

"Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act". Damn RDR with the feels.

[@csec9291]

Sister Calderon is Mother Superior from Undead Nightmare in Rdr1 for those who didn’t know

[@willchalloner6643]

I never played undead nightmare , I’ll have to get round to that one day

[@welch_inc6532]

She also appears in a strangers mission in Mexico

[@LieutenantJoey]

Will Challoner Undead Nightmare is literally the most fun I’ve ever had with a video game.

[@grindgoironworks4473]

No shit

[@grandmasterdragonborn6841]

Actually I don't think she is.

[@ft577]

I had a high honor but didn't do the required side quests and had the reverend scene. I'm pissed off now.

[@myotapia]

Wtf me too hahaha

[@georgeventer898]

@@myotapia, me three! XD

[@georgeventer898]

But on my second playthrough I finally got to see her at Emerald Station.

[@Tofflan-tr8zr]

IAmTheWalrus 57 your fault for not doing side missions

[@jinnybucko3353]

The sister mission didnt com up for me

[@goldengamingmodz4324]

Arthur: Beats a man TB: Well well...How the turntables

[@holly9096]

Two points at which I cried: "I'm afraid." "Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act." DAMN NINJAS CUTTING ONIONS!!

[@Kanal7Indonesia]

Also "Life is full of pain... but there's also love and beauty"

[@-bluejay211]

I love the lengths this game goes to, I never knew you could see Swanson instead before you go, it just goes to show how detailed the world really is. Thanks for sharing guys 👍🏻

[@100Rivu]

A game close to the heart.

[@aishiteru0198]

Such a real thing to say "I'm afraid" and coming from this amazing man made it hit way harder. I have never shed so many tears for a person who doesn't even exist. Makes you feel like you can be the toughest person and have seen so much but anyone can be afraid. Aurthur Morgan is the best character of anything I have watched, played or read.

[@emtee7138]

The bravest thing a man could say is "I'm afraid"

[@joshdrumr]

that expression on Arthur's face when he said "I'm afraid.", man... i can't stop replaying that line and his face expression when he said that.

[@vallttdysney7749]

I´m not joking, Arthur felt like a father to me. I literally cried when he died, I really felt like I loved Arthur. He made me a better man. Thank you Rockstar.

[@dawsynlarson696]

“I’m dying sister” 😔 that line will always give me the chills man 😭

[@DieHardRedemption]

It hit me in the feels 😢

[@desperado4247]

"You're too smart for me Sister. I guess I.... I'm afraid." The face he makes makes me tear up-he’s one of the most relatable characters. He always helps *anyone* when and if he can

[@lordmorklen5166]

My Arthur had Shoulder length hair and a stubble. Looked like Thor. Then he got sick and my heart started breaking.....my drive to keep on playing was checking out. Then I reached this cutscene. And I was like, this man deserves his REDEMPTION. His Last Ride.

[@leone41ll]

I had short hair before, but after the mission when he nearly died to the O'driscolls, i grew out my hair, like a revenant

[@MariusBoss11458]

@@leone41ll i dont like Mullets but its kind of nice but i never reached level 10 facial hair only 9 if you never cut it once in the game

[@MossXD]

Is it worth replaying the game and always having high honor?

[@Uknown76]

Yes

[@ilearnedhownottobejealous2301]

Its the same shit

[@geniusn8343]

Of course

[@akaybozz6299]

In the beginning low honor till u get TB is the most realistic way to Play i think

[@MossXD]

@@akaybozz6299 okay thanks for letting me know

[@g0wasu]

Arthur’s facial expression when he tells her he’s afraid is heartbreaking.

[@thisgal422]

"Life is full of pain but there is also love and beauty" -Sister Calderon

[@alexzhou3509]

The scene with sister was the point that really cemented Arthur's change for me

[@aggames3968]

"My path is coming to an end, Reverend" - Arthur Morgan

[@linkthepeargod2664]

These videos must take a lot work give this man props

[@NuggetEternal]

1:14 and 4:20 Note the tiny differences in Arthur's tone and body language with how he approaches Swanson and how he says he's leaving Jack and the girls.