ARY Chae Cast Ep 07 | ft. Former Chairman FBR Shabbar Zaidi

In this interview with former FBR Chairman Shabbar Zaidi, we explore Pakistan's political dynamics, key historical events, taxation challenges, and other thought-provoking topics.
Subscribe to our YT channel:
www.youtube.co....
Subscribe to our channel for the latest videos:
www.youtube.co....
Like and follow our Facebook page for more stories:
/ arystories

[@AmarkantVishwakarma]

Urdu is an Indian language just like Hindi, Sanskrit, etc...its not a Pakistani language. Pakistan has borrowed it from India 😂😂😂

[@Th3L0st0ne]

I'd go one step further. There is no Hindi or Urdu in the sense of two different languages. Call it by whatever name, it is the same one language. You put more Sanskrit words and call it Hindi, we put more arabic and Persian and call it Urdu. But Urdu/Hindi is the same language. These days most of us put a lot of English words in our Urdu/Hindi, it doesn't mean it becomes an entirely different language

[@naherf385]

You are a great philosopher like Suqrat and Buqrat. Thanks for enlightening us. Love from Pakistan. 😉

[@atokimruk937]

Stolen. Not borrowed.

[@Zeeshan-jz6rx]

Agr Pakistan Hindustan se borrow ho skta h to language ku nhi

[@Seeker-p1q]

@@Th3L0st0ne All correct. And the proof is that you cannot create or form a single sentence in Urdu, which is basically an Indian language, without using Sanskrit. Utho, baitho, aao, khao, jao etc. are neither Arabic, nor Persian, they are purely derived from Sanskrit, which is often called the mother of all language. So, Urdu is Indian and is basically Hindi as you said. 🙏

[@madhudutt8836]

He is one of the few Pakistani who speak truth very honest soul God blessing

[@infotainmenttv8542]

Shabbar now is my favorite intellectual + comedian ( I like his last word or sentence eeeeenhhhhhhiiihhhhhhiiii & bas khatam hogai baat

[@muhammadali-rn4sd]

shabar sahb ko ziada sunne se dmagh bhi khrab ho skta hay.

[@ShahidaSarwarShahidaSarwar]

​@@muhammadali-rn4sd no nahi ho sakta, sochny per majboor kerti hn sir shabbar ki baten

[@nitinacharya8375]

@@muhammadali-rn4sd Subhanallah....har Mulle ka dimag (agar ho to...) kharab hona lazmi hai, kyuki woh sach batane ki koshish kar raha hai. 😊

[@AbdulSamad-eh6tu]

Please do program of deterioration of karachi infrastructure roads , sanitation, streets , Since last 50 years karachi has been ignored with planning why i dont know Karachi was the capital city Ayub khan had shifted capital to islamabad why people dont know ... Involve ngos , public figures , .. make accountable responsible who are getting salaries in department ... Enhance awareness of public on infrastructure this is the fact that karachi has been finished ... Decades are required for reconstruction

[@nitinacharya8375]

@@AbdulSamad-eh6tu Karachi kisi Musalle ne nahi banaya... Karachi ko Hindu Baniya, Parsi aur Bohra, Khoja aur Memano ne ( jo converted musalman traders the) aabad kiya tha. Muslims ko aaj bhi business karna nahi aata.... kyuki business karnewala kabhi kisi ko dushman nahi manta. Tarakki ke liye Jung nahi tizarat karnewale chahiye jo Pakistan main nahi hai. 😊

[@Th3L0st0ne]

he mentioned that MQM has 20 seats of karachi which he admits is meaningless in terms of Sindh and the country. In other words politics does not give MQM enough power to do anything. This leaves the only option which is using it as protest. However, he chose words which seems to put all blame on MQM for choosing the only available option

[@sameer_r1a_z93]

Had your grandpa stayed back in India, you would have cast a meaningful vote- see what happened to BJP in recent elections. But your grandpa didn’t want to live with kafirs. Now go protest. I won’t shed a single tear for you.

[@fhksofficial]

Love Zaidi sahab and his words of wisdom. Stay healthy and happy ❤

[@Shobyw]

As a Pakistani I will only vote for a person who is non corrupt, is efficient, has capability, is educated and refined.

[@anjummirza1452]

Excellent information and narration...

[@ShahidaSarwarShahidaSarwar]

1 more podcast with Shabbar zaidi sir

[@sanjayvithalkar3336]

Shabbar sab apne sahi bola ye jo mazhabi jahar ghol ke british hame bus ek dusre se duur karke chale gaye

[@Shobyw]

The tragedy has become that we can own a a/c but cannot pay electricity bill, we can own a second hand car but don’t have money for fuel.

[@ShahidaSarwarShahidaSarwar]

Shabbar zaidi sir se dubara aik or podcast karien thanks

[@ShahidaSarwarShahidaSarwar]

Welcome shabbar zaidi sir

[@rabnawaz9557]

Low voice quality, host should put mike closely, so that everyone can listen quiet well.

[@nizamuddinahmadaali3244]

You forgot to mention Aalim e Deen Zaidi Saheb,i.e Maulana Shabbar Zaidi in your introduction. I mean it.

[@YASAJTV]

One of very few Pakistanis who know what is what. (The sound man had one job)

[@amanatgul3977]

دنیا کا مستقبل ھے جو باچاخان کہا کرتے تھے

[@Shobyw]

Give us access to line water, give good roads, garbage disposal, gutter system, organize traffic, reasonable electricity and then ask us to speak with respect!!

[@Shobyw]

Unfortunately the army has become a political party and business man. Their priorities have changed

[@vg82]

Urdu mai kaunsa gaana hai mujhe koi bataye ..

[@udayn4105]

@@vg82 All songs if Mughal e Azam, Palki, Mere Mehboob, Pakeezah and many many more.

[@landourmarten]

27:00 Karachi is NOT viable as an "AVIATION HUB". 20+ airlines did fly to Karachi 30+ yrs ago bcos MEDIUM-DENSITY LONG-RANGE TWN-ENGINE aircraft did NOT exist. So, 747s landed in Karachi (for fuel & picking up a few pax) b4 continuing to Delhi, Bombay, Calcutta, Bangkok, HK, KL, Singapore etc. NOW there are 767s, 777s, 787s, A350s & A330s to choose from. Karachi is FINISHED, forever. The true test of a VIABLE hub is the number of long-range TURNAROUND flights. Karachi ranks outside the Top 200 airports, globally. Samjhe?

[@Shobyw]

Those who are using vulgar language are using it because they have lost all hope in the system and their lives have become miserable. Give them basic facilities and good standard of life then they will not use bad language! If they use after that then you can take steps to stop it!!

[@AhmedKamal-yd1mq]

Improve video quality pls

[@ShahidaSarwarShahidaSarwar]

Dubara podcast karien sir se

[@ShahidaSarwarShahidaSarwar]

Pakistan ka dharuv rathee is shabbar zaidi

[@nizamuddinahmadaali3244]

Jinnah Saheb had instructed to developed Karachi sea and airport as soon as possible. He also had the desire to develop flower gardens and tourism in Quetta and Ziarat . Jinnah Saheb had a realistic idea which was denied by prepuce against Karachi. This idea is a matter of public record.

[@nitinacharya8375]

Your Kaide Aazam Jinha Sa'ab was a pakka Gujarati Trader ( Converted to Islam from the Thakkar... predominantly a trader community... popularly known as Khojas in India and particularly in Gujarat State of India.) and Mahatma Gandhiji was a Vaishnavi Baniya. The native places of these two great leaders are in Gujarat State of India and they are hardly far away from each other. One more interesting information is that the Khojas, the Bohras ( converted from Brahmins) and the Memons ( converted from Baniyas) were educated, intelligent and forward thinking communities like Parsis, who all contributed immensely in developing the undevided India. These are the communities in whose blood the DNA of their Hindu forefathers run. Their contribution in development of Bombay, Karachi and some places in the Arebian countries of Gulf and Africa is unparalleled and invaluable. Khojas, Bohras and Memons are still thriving in India in all the fields due to their inclination towards education and progressive thoughts. I will be delighted if someone from Pakistan gives the real picture of their situation in Pakistan.

[@nizamuddinahmadaali3244]

@@nitinacharya8375 Your information is 100% correct, but they are not known to be educated, may be they are in India.

[@sunilamarwaha3053]

​@@nizamuddinahmadaali3244Can you become more educated to understand the reasoning og z matter. Paki are more radical then educated because they insert Allah and islaam from bedroom to bathroom.

[@apurvavasavada383]

Prepuce is a fantastic typo. One thing you won’t find in Pakistan. Go google it.

[@Shobyw]

Driving a car or motorcycle on Karachi roads is like riding a camel!! Agree?

[@DrAahad-xo6ev]

Very good, qasaey k pass 3 markets ore hamarey pass aik awdad gahr bhe nahen . . .

[@Shobyw]

Bro situation is hopeless and unlivable!! Wake up

[@Shobyw]

These suv owners think they are owning the roads!!

[@tariqaslam4422]

Shabbar Zaidi Sahib Zindabad.

[@Shobyw]

Bro you make lives miserable for common man and you expect them to throw flowers on you?

[@TrueIndian1900]

Khana Gana hi nahi Indian pakistan ka DNA v ek hai aur pahle Mazhab v ek hi tha

[@SajidSultanMirza]

Music stop please

[@billumandal]

41:14 - ai re pawan, dhundhe tujhe mera man .. chalte chalte 😉

[@Shobyw]

If rangers are removed from Karachi the mqm will fcuk the people!! The rangers have become a necessity for Karachi

[@commonman7730]

😂😂 Not your mistake 😂😂😂😂😂🎉

[@smyasir0]

then kick out BOTH, mqm and rangers, from karachi

[@vineetdeorari8017]

Ye sab ne socha tha naya desh bana ke waha Raj karenge.. dhire dhire waha ke son of the soil Punjabi, Baloch, Pathan apni identity assert karr ne lage.. ye apna madre watan chorne wale mohajir ho gye… na khuda mila na visale sanam.. na eidhar ke rhe na udhar ke rhe

[@udayn4105]

What nonsense!! Bharat Vyas, Pt Madhur and many more wrote many songs which don't contain ANY urdu word. Zaidi saheb, u r wrong this time.

[@shahzadiqbal8798]

Probably u r able to think for the first time

[@sandipbhattacharyya7540]

He is mentioning as in general sence ....and about Hindusthani language songs ...almost 90% Hindi cenema songs are not Pure Hindi but Hindustani...which could be written in Debnagari as well as Persian scripts

[@Seeker-p1q]

One, Urdu is an Indian language. It's not the native language of any people in Pakistan, except those who migrated from India. Two, Urdu and Hindi are the same, it is called Khadi boli. They are just written differently. Three, Urdu cannot exist without Sanskrit or Hindi. Ask this pseudo genius to form a single Urdu sentence without using Sanskrit or Hindi? I will serve him my entire life for free. Ajib ghonchoo admi hai yaar ye. I thought he talked sense but I was wrong.

[@manishjoshi9995]

Shabbar bhai aap gaane maaat likhna chalu karna....fail ho jao gai...😂

[@Shobyw]

Ppp mqm and pmln are a lanat on Pakistan

[@billumandal]

Classical music ki background classical urdu hai 🤣 Kabhi yeh classical sun lein

[@udayn4105]

Songs of dozens of Hindi mythological films are in pure Hindi. Zaidi saheb, sorry to say u have very poor knowledge of Hindi films and their songs. They were popular too. Radio Ceylon would play them regularly. If u havent heard them then it is your problem. U should talk about the field ONLY which u know well.

[@TheGrimStoic]

کچھ بچے پیدا ہوتے ہی چرس کے برتن میں گر جاتے ہیں-

[@masroorkhalil9655]

Pakistan problems has these solutions 1- Free and fair elections by evm- vvpat technology or other advanced technology 2- Referendum on either the political system in pak should be based on presidential or parliamentary system. 3- Divide every province of pakistan into two parts north/south and on basis of better administration (north punjab/south punjab, North sindh/ south sindh) Etc- And give Provincial status tooo Gilgit Baltistan and Azad Kashmir 4- Jooo bheee natural resources hain pak mee petrol,gas,coal unnnn seee anne waleee revenue usss district kaa 70% tak share unnnkeee pass hogee yane unnn natural resources see anee wala revenue kaaa 70% wooo district ki elected govt rakhegi rakheengee baki federal govt or province koo sirf kuch heee hisssa milegaa. 5- Pure pakistan meee ek standard digital or fixed tax policy banaou jismeee 15 seee zyada tax naaa hooo direct or indirect or 10lac seee kam.kamane walae peee tax naa hooo or food item peee 5% seee zyada tax naa hoooo or in taxes kooo bant deeya jayee 5- taxes kooo federal govt kooo 5- taxes provincisl govt 5- taxes municipal govt koooo 6-NFC award kooo change kiyeaa jayeee budget kaaa revenue kaaa share 70-75% federal govt appne pass rakhee (provinces appna tax revenue khud collect karee) or isske sath PFC(provincial finance commision)districts koo milne walee paisee or District financial commision (jooo district govt aggey villages or tehsils koooo deee) 7- Pure pakistan directly elected districts govts and village govt(panchayat raj/india) kee election hooo or constitution mee jese pm or cm kee roles or powers likhee hain wesee hee mayor ki powers or responsibility likhh deee jayee (water, sewrage Police, cleanliness) or tax collection jese water tax property tax, motor vehicle tax, service tax, sab mayor collect kareee or local govt kaa subject provinces see leekeee federal govt keee pass or election bhee unke election commision karwayee naa kee provinces. 8- Pak mee yeee Ethnic based qota system govt jobs mee khtam karkee sareew recuritment 100% css exams or merit or ussske professional degree based peee hooo or pak meee single national curriculum laggo kese karna hain usski planning kiiyee jayee 9- The federal and provincial election should be held seprately(Matlab provincial or federal govt kee election ek din peee naa hooo) There should be a gap of 3 months To 6 months 10- Abolish care taker govt 11- Remove perks, privillages, Protocoals, benefits of every beaureacrate, lawmakers(mna), judges, Military officers. 12- Restoration of student unions

[@OdinIsHere]

India model basically

[@Shobyw]

I am a mohajir but I will never vote for mqm

[@fahadkhalid3983]

Tou bahi ya sab Taliban project ore baki jo log hay unko banaya kesaye. Kachaye ka Daku ko banaya kis naye. Topiya karwana band karaye. Dont create a problem and say we are the solution

[@dr.farahaslam6984]

A failed economist with pesimist, disappointing thoughts. Not necessary Mr. Shabbar you present yourself as a champion of every field. Line is already drawn. In Pakistan most liberty is available for everyone, more than in Europe, USA, India, to utter anything he wants like you doing. What more freedom is needed. No other country allow anyone to speak whatever stupid he wish.

[@smyasir0]

Shabbar Zaidi is a gold medalist in every education level. Served across multiple government posts and walked away from FBR on his own terms (no other official can claim this), has written the PSX rule book. I am just listing the achievements that i remember at my fingertips. What about your obscure self?

[@nitinacharya8375]

Shabbar Zaidi Sa'ab Urdu Hindustani jabaan hai... Pakistani katai nahi. Hame fakr hai ki Urdu jabaan, Punjabi Khana aur har roz Hindustan ki baat kiye bagair ji Pakistanio ka jina muskil hai...

[@sheikhimran.zia82-ji6pt]

How many schools in India teach Urdu language from primary level??

[@nitinacharya8375]

@@sheikhimran.zia82-ji6pt Tumhare waha 2,50,000,00 (Dhai Crore) bachhe school nahi jate...( Nahi jaa pate) uski fiqr kar... Jab se Pakistanio ne Urdu jabaan bolni shuru ki hai hamne yahan ke Muslim bachcho ko woh jabaan Kam se kam padhai jaye isliye dhire dhire bandh karni kab ki shuru ki hai.... kyuki woh ab madari jabaan ki bajaye madar#odo ki jabaan ban ke rahe gai hai. Meri baat sun ke maja aaye to apne abbu ko aur uske bhi abbu ko khub galiyan Dena aur kahena ke Hindustan se alag mulk mangke hamne kya jannat mulk banaya hai...jise sari duniya pagal kutte ki tarah treat kar rahi hai. 😍😍😍

[@nitinacharya8375]

@@sheikhimran.zia82-ji6pt Enjoy your freedom in Pakistan. It appears that the newly installed firewall is working...all my comments not suitable to Pakistan have been deleted. 😏😏😆😆🤣🤣

[@nitinacharya8375]

@@sheikhimran.zia82-ji6pt You should just worry about the 2.5 million children who are not getting school education in your country instead of Urdu Jabaan. Indians don't need Urdu School to teach Urdu to its people. 😏

[@nitinacharya8375]

I hope the firewall may not delete this comments☝🏻😆

[@ruparao2971]

Rangeela Re from Prem pujari is pure hindi.

[@AmitrossyNegu]

Haha inshallah mashallah bol k muhajir kon born hogai kom k name akk abusive word per rakha gaya muhajir haha haha muhajir leader altaf shaib ko maafi nahi mileygi. Imran khan ko maaf kr deya jayega haha haha

[@mashoodmustafa5912]

Ghatia production

[@yashsingh0010]

'Hamari wali Urdu,' Shabbar Saheb Kisko bewakoof bana rahe, Urdu India ki jubaan hai na ki Pakistan ki. Pakistan ki Jubaan Punjabi, Sindhi, Pashto, Baloch. Urdu to Lucknow Delhi Meerut me bani hai, ye kaha hai, Urdu Bharat ki scheduled languages and Saare northern states ki official language Urdu hai. Apna jhut kahi aur beche.

[@vineetdeorari8017]

Ye sab ne socha tha naya desh bana ke waha Raj karenge.. dhire dhire waha ke son of the soil Punjabi, Baloch, Pathan apni identity assert karr ne lage.. ye apna madre watan chorne wale mohajir ho gye… na khuda mila na visale sanam.. na eidhar ke rhe na udhar ke rhe😂😂😂😂

[@moromarket9612]

غلط بات کرہے ہو۔۔۔۔ بنگالی یوتھ سوشل میڈیا پر ہزاروں کی تعداد میں۔ پاکستان سے محبت کا اظہار کرہے ہیں انہیں مجیب اور اس کے خاندان سے سخت نفرت ہے۔

[@hamzaaslam9919]

Chl na TUjhe btaya kia ksi bngali ne ke ko Pyr krta ha 😂

[@commonman7730]

Ok Hope both unite again Bangladesh be blessed to have Pakistan fauj to protect & rule them Both Pakistan & Bangladesh unite & boycott every thing with Kafir India Plz do it Thanks 😂😂😂😂😂

[@atifahmed5660]

Bangali pagal thori hen.. un ki economy dekho aur apni economy dekho

[@AshwaniKumar-mz2ip]

Banda gent hai eh zedi❤

[@pushpendragiri5473]

O chacha.. Urdu bhi hindi se hi nikli hai....

[@amitjuglan5772]

Ek dhanka setup Lelo yaar

[@vg82]

Paisa tumhare pas hai to inn bhikariyo ke paas bhi hoga …

[@Shobyw]

Ppp mqm and pmln are a lanat on Pakistan