Military Business vs Economy of Pakistan |

[@qazianeel]

I met Qaiser Sahab when he visited our office, where I was working as a computer operator and was responsible for handling the presentation while my boss spoke. He took his seat but then realized he hadn’t shaken hands with me, so he stood up again and introduced himself. I was surprised, as I had been attending such meetings and handling presentations, but none of the senior government officials had ever acknowledged my presence. I was moved by his humility.

[@zafaraliindher4083]

Great

[@AR-fr8br]

اس سے اندازہ لگا لو کہ ایسے قابل اور انسانیت سے بھرپور لوگوں کو اس ملک کی رولنگ ایلیٹ پسند نہیں کرتی۔ کیونکہ ان بدمعاشوں کو خطرہ ہے کہ کہیں قیصر بنگالی جیسے لوگ اہم عہدوں پر لگ گئے تو ملک تو ٹھیک ہو جائے گا لیکن ہھر ان چوروں کو کہیں جگہ نہیں ملے گی۔ یہ سبھی لوٹ مار میں مشغول ہیں جنہیں پاکستان کی ترقی سے کوئی غرض نہیں ہے۔

[@DibakarDuttaOfficial]

Difference between good and bad guy

[@rejijai9120]

Salaams to Kaiser saab

[@basitnazir1631]

you were a computer operator of which grade BPS 17?

[@razazaveri557]

This conversation is 100% better than political talk shows.

[@jaalhaq7862]

رفتار ؟. بنگالی بھی مایوسی پھیلانے أیا ہندو قادیانی کافر و رفض کاگھٹ جوڑ کتخانہ مایوسی پھیلانا کیونکو موجودہ حافظ جنرل کی صورت مین انکو ایک اور ضیالحق جیسے سے واسطہ پڑچکا ہے زرداری.رافضی سندھی پکڑ کر چپکا ونا ہے سندھی مسلمان برباد ہے کراچی الطاف کے بعد عمرانی چھتری تلے جمع پاکستان کے مسلمان سمجھتے ہیں اقلیت لبرل سیکولر شیعہ رافضی و قادیانی کافر پاکستان کے لۓ ناسور سے کم نہیں خیر خواہ نہیں جو بھی اس چینل پر بولنے والا أتا ہے اسکا تعلق کس لسانی گروہ یا فرقے سے ہے وہ بہت ضروری ھے الطاف حسین بھتہ خوری کی مجلس کی پہلے صف میں بیٹھٹنے والے افراد و صحافی نما ناسوروں کے چہرے پاکستان کے مسلمان اچہی طرح سے جانتے ہیں رفتا انہی کا کتخانہ تو نہیں؟

[@BarunKumar-v6t]

Gazwa e hind ka sapna bhool gye kya?

[@sar4659]

​@@BarunKumar-v6t😂... Tum q pareshan ho, Kisi k sapnay knliay?

[@thedoctor649]

We're waiting for aid money from Pakistan😭😭😭

[@4628mb]

@@thedoctor649 Pak ArmyGenerals been Zalim&Gaddar since birth of PakWatan as they are foreign Agents and love $$ and are super RichChore;they treat Pakis as slaves;the only Paki,Imran who demands Democracy for PakiAwam is jailed .PakiAwam is weak&helpless as no one will help them except Imran!

[@sonachenab]

Such a nice and gentle human. He can feel the pain of poors.

[@munagalavrr]

Every country has them.. nobody listens to them.

[@Bashir-n2x]

Khalistan Nagaland Tamil Kashmir freedom soon

[@sonachenab]

@@Bashir-n2x ok, great, I will shift to Balochistan.

[@edgecase1047]

In Pakistan for every person like Kaiser saab there are a million people like Bashir who thinks that 'Khalistan Nagaland Tamil Kashmir freedom soon'. Poor chaps like Bashir these cannot think beyond these superficial statements. They think somehow making these statements will improve the economy. No wonder economy is down.

[@HimanshuKumar-mq5bq]

​@@Bashir-n2x freedom of balochistan, kpk and Pakistan occupied kashmir soon ❤

[@narayananpuducode1516]

I am from India. This is an Excellent Interview. Anchor is very polite and respectful. And Sir is very transparent, Knowledgeable and is very Clear in his perspective. A Different Personality from Pakistan. My Respects🙏🏼

[@skysdhprm5067]

Librandu

[@vamsikrishna3855]

@@narayananpuducode1516 53:35 India’s poverty is greater than Pakistan pas per this old gadha.

[@vipinparashar7841]

But giving aid to India is too far fetched

[@thevains]

@@skysdhprm5067 andhbhakt chupp

[@shyamnarayanmishra5363]

Real estate policy is almost similar to NCR of India

[@aamirhasen]

Dr. Qaiser Bengali in high regard, and he is indeed a respected figure in Pakistan. Dr. Qaiser Bengali is a well-known economist and development specialist, recognized for his expertise in public policy and economic reform in Pakistan. His career has spanned several decades, during which he has provided valuable insights and guidance on key economic challenges. His honesty, commitment to public service, and professionalism have earned him a lot of respect in both academia and policy-making circles in Pakistan.

[@AR-yk1kv]

Respected Bengali sb is absolutely right in all aspects. He is very honest and patriotic Pakistani Thank very much Thank you, Raftar

[@jaalhaq7862]

رفتار ؟. بنگالی بھی مایوسی پھیلانے أیا ہندو قادیانی کافر و رفض کاگھٹ جوڑ کتخانہ مایوسی پھیلانا کیونکو موجودہ حافظ جنرل کی صورت مین انکو ایک اور ضیالحق جیسے سے واسطہ پڑچکا ہے زرداری.رافضی سندھی پکڑ کر چپکا ونا ہے سندھی مسلمان برباد ہے کراچی الطاف کے بعد عمرانی چھتری تلے جمع پاکستان کے مسلمان سمجھتے ہیں اقلیت لبرل سیکولر شیعہ رافضی و قادیانی کافر پاکستان کے لۓ ناسور سے کم نہیں خیر خواہ نہیں جو بھی اس چینل پر بولنے والا أتا ہے اسکا تعلق کس لسانی گروہ یا فرقے سے ہے وہ بہت ضروری ھے الطاف حسین بھتہ خوری کی مجلس کی پہلے صف میں بیٹھٹنے والے افراد و صحافی نما ناسوروں کے چہرے پاکستان کے مسلمان اچہی طرح سے جانتے ہیں رفتا انہی کا کتخانہ تو نہیں؟

[@Sam-kd2dc]

Respected?

[@naherf385]

This is called credible video journalism. The credibility of the channel increases when you invite or interview credible people like Dr. Qaisar Bengali.

[@dinozaurpickupline4221]

nanga kardiya dr sahab ne sab kuch

[@TahirBilgrami-ky6uq]

پارلیمینٹ مین لانے سے کمیشن نئے ملے گا

[@TahirBilgrami-ky6uq]

یہ بھکاری چورہوکومت توایسانہی کر سکتا نئے اور بڑی گاری ان کو پٹرول بند کردین اور جو گاڑی سڑک پرنظر آئے اس سی معلوم کرین پٹرول کہان سے آیا اور گاڑی ضبط اور جرمانہ بھی

[@Fun-Free912]

بیشک بہترین ❤

[@TahirBilgrami-ky6uq]

جی بھائی۳۸۵ بالکل درست ملک مین موجود ماہر معاشیات کی کمی نہی قیصر بنگالی یا شبر زیدی کیطرح۔ کے اور بھی بہت محب وطن لوگ موجود ہین لیکن یہ شریفوں کےخاندان کے بھکاری لُٹیرے یا زرداری مرداری بینظیر کے قاتل پاکستان کی اینٹ سے اینٹ بجانے والے آصف زرداری ایسا نہی کرین گے کیونکہ لوٹ مار کمیشن اور بھتہ کیسے ملے گا شبرزیدی کہہ رہے تھے کہوہزرداری کے مشیر خزانہ یا وزیر خزانہ تھے تو زرداری نے کہا زیدی صاحب آپ بہت اچھے ہین لین اس پوسٹ پر فٹ نہی ہین لہذا آپ کا شکریہ

[@FaisalWaheedRaftar]

جب میں قیصر صاحب کے ساتھ یہ پوڈ کاسٹ کر رہا تھا تو واضح محسوس کر سکتا تھا کہ وہ پاکستان کے لیے کتنا درد رکھتے ہیں ۔۔ جن لوگوں نے تعریف کی یا تنقید کی سب کا بہت شکریہ ❤ آپ کا فیڈ بیک ہمارے لیے بہت اہم ہے ۔❤

[@ammaraedits98]

@@FaisalWaheedRaftar you are bringing awareness in youth who is the future of Pakistan and will give their service to bring their country to life. Thank you so much and keep up the good work 💯💯❤️

[@RajeshKumar-kr3nl]

Please keep the Host Name in the Video title.. and honour him.

[@FaisalWaheedRaftar]

​@@ammaraedits98 Spreading awareness is Raftar's mission, and thank you for your valuable comment and support. JazakAllah.❤

[@FaisalWaheedRaftar]

​@@RajeshKumar-kr3nlDear , it's me Faisal Waheed 😊

[@simplegalaxy-y9f]

Excellent,, qaiser bangali sahb se mzeed videos bnaen

[@neerajupadhyay8093]

I am from India and I respect the esteemed guest. Pakistan needs people like him and journalist like you.

[@shehroznadeem388]

We appreciate your concerns

[@mediation2010]

@@neerajupadhyay8093 Qaisar Bangali... Economist

[@AR-fr8br]

Unfortunately if you speak the truth you are not trusted in Pakistan.

[@Rishikumar360]

I too from India ! And heard first logical explanation from Pakistan. Make him PM he will bring good days to Pakistan, Bhaut kaam log hai Pakistan ka patriots

[@nademb4242]

Aamdani Atthanni Kharcha Rupaiya ! Pakistan 🇵🇰

[@saadabdullah9915]

kitna humble or educated insaan hai . Allah app dono ko salamat rakhe.

[@ParvezAli-ji4nr]

پہلی دفعہ کسی تعلیم یافتہ قابل شخص کی گفتگو سنے کو ملی معیشت پر شکریہ ٹیم رفتار ❤

[@valiplayer]

He is half baked, don't get impressed with such talks ...problem statement is missing.He is blaming everyone and glorifying himself.vasael jaida hein, my foot.people can make their nation great .parkis are living in islamic cartoon book where hero has the capability n others are back benchers,dishonest,munafik,blood thirsty,and cunning and all with no character, but in reality it is exactly the opposite.islam can make only pond ka daadu, for daadu pond is the world

[@moosa1372]

Raftaar ki pahli video Dekhi hogi apnay

[@wa5ayy]

True that 😂 ​@@moosa1372

[@ashutoshpandey6392]

It is obvious that a country can become like Pakistan where Maulvi runs the country

[@H.R.Ssheikhg]

کونسی ​@@moosa1372

[@bukhattak]

Economy of Pakistan in an easy , lay man language by Dr. Bengali. Well done the show . This Dr is concise , clear and fluent. We need experts like him . But the elite civil and military bureaucratic won't let them work .

[@anasqayyum8985]

​@Mussadi_Lal Bhai LayMan to yehi Sunna Chahta hai naaw.. Usey fact and figures se kia garz.. B's hala lala honi chahyee.. dhol dhamaka aa gya bae aa gyaa chaa gya bae chaa gya..

[@wise2217]

India has far better economists, who can change the picture of India.

[@jai4096]

Pakistans industrial policy is still colonial. Where raw materials are taken from Pakistan and finished products are sold back to Pakistan. This is what British did to India during colonial era.

[@naherf385]

Absolutely correct.

[@mehrabhossain2000]

Fr

[@AKumar-co7oe]

they never read dadabhai naoroji, can't real kafir economists

[@bbalila]

What resources are exported? 90% exports are textile, sports, IT, food etc , British were rich due to Technology & Industry, you get rich through Industry & Technology not through minerals. Only reason of rich Gulf state are due to small population.

[@shiraznawaz6646]

@@jai4096 they get big kick backs for doing nothing .!

[@RedDiamondXYZ]

I rate this as No 1 Podcast I've seen in my life. I've tears in my eyes what damage we have done with our own hands! Such complex issues explained with such ease! Hats off. Respect 🙏 🤲 👏 🙌 ❤

[@BharatSoni-i5w]

Tears won't work,, have to fight tooth n nail, against corruption, army, mullas, radicals If you want to save Pakistan

[@ghanshyammishra4460]

Congratulation to Dr. Qaisar Bengali for explaining the country's economy in such a simple language which can be understood by even a lay man. Thanks to raftartv. Carry on.....

[@jahanzaibwaheed8683]

This is the first ever podcast on economy that I have watched complete minute by minute.

[@shaguftasohail3152]

Exactly 💯

[@MuhammadAli-jg5md]

same here.

[@Askyourself978]

He's a knowledgeable person, but he is wrong when he said that people live on the streets in India, lol. According to the 2011 census, only 0.1% of people are homeless in India, which has decreased even more because of government initiatives. And homeless people exist in every country, even in the USA. Pakistan giving aid to India? Lol. The TATA group of Ratan Tata has a total valuation greater than the entire GDP of Pakistan. Maharashtra, which is one of the 35 state and union Territories of India, alone has a higher GDP than the whole of Pakistan. Secondly, I want to break one misconception that Pakistanis have about India, which is that Indians don't have toilets. So, you call us 'toilet-less.' In reality, according to the World Bank and other institutions from your own country, 34% of Pakistanis and 47% of Bangladeshis don't have toilets or proper sanitation. Google it to check by yourself. Lastly, I genuinely want Pakistan to become financially stable because an unstable Pakistan is not good for Pakistanis and also not for India. I hope that the relations between the two countries improve. Peace.

[@mominbutt7575]

Sahi kha me b aik mnt b skip nhi kiya Dill ro rha apnay mulk pr Allah hukamrano ko aqal dy

[@Ali-DD1]

True

[@syafqil17]

The best rule of any economy is honesty, honesty and honesty. Where there is corruption, corruption, and corruption, nothing can be achieved in thousands of years. This can be guaranteed.

[@OsmmanKhan-do2vx]

I am also very much certain about your comment

[@LoveBlueColor]

Agree

[@asmahkhan5318]

So True😢

[@TajamalGhumman]

@@syafqil17 کرپشن کوئی چیز نیی۔۔۔ صلاحیت پیدا کرن دی لوڑ اے

[@RamKumar-vy6je]

Yes its true

[@MrALCHEMIST2010]

22:43 " Yeh sab dukandar hain" best words to represent Pakistani elite mentality.

[@eleghari]

He probably wanted to say "yay is dharti Kay Dalal haiN"

[@PfefferNusse-vr4yo]

@@eleghari What? Qaidi Jinnah ka 'pak' sar zameen.......woh jo bade jazbe se.......kalme pad pad ke pad pad ke........ghaas kha kha ke bana tha?

[@KingKong-lb3vh]

@@PfefferNusse-vr4yo

[@sps6]

absolutely right...lazy people dont want to work

[@munaim2024.PC.oriented]

hahahaah 😂😂😂 dukaandaar

[@MehranK1]

Dr Kaiser Bangali is such a gem. His resignation from the economic committee is an indicator that the government and the system aim to keep the rotten situation as is, even when the circumstances demand urgent course correction.

[@shripadmuley5258]

I am from Indian,but I really admire you and your knowledge

[@murtaza860]

I studied finance and he is absolutely spot on. He explained the downfall of our economy very well.

[@sumrgroup]

So inspirational. Such a knowledged and critical thinker. A Real man and a true National.

[@ziazia1012]

زبردست گفتگو سنی۔۔۔۔۔اگر ہوسکے تو ایسا پروگرام ہو جس میں سری لنکا کے حالات خاص کر معاشی اور سیاسی معاملات کا جائزہ لے کر پاکستان کے مسائل کو سمجھنے اور بہتر کرنے کا موضوع ہو۔ جیسے دنیا کےبدسرے ممالک برازیل ارجنٹینا بنگلہ دیش یہاں تک کی انڈیا کی مثال کے ساتھ پاکستان کے گھمبیر مسائل کو سمجھنے کی کوشش کی جائے۔۔۔ Good effort by Raftar team... The way the anchor asking and wait for the complete answers by a speaker with patience- is the learning attitude for others in these days...

[@fkhawaja786]

Every Pakistani must listen this discussion...

[@tanouliskitchen5475]

Somehow, Bengalis have always been the true and genuine Pakistanis from the very beginning

[@suraiyamukesh2493]

Kesar Bangali sir is one of the few persons who understand economy and economics very well

[@kju-dja213]

@@indianview6139 bhakk kya bol rahe ho kuch samjh rahe ho

[@indianview6139]

@@kju-dja213 samanjh ke bole hain, aur samjhna hai to jake ration ki dukaan dekh lo Apne aaspaas

[@BikeAndBeyondChannel]

These discussions were frank, honest, and fearless. I wish the Pakistani elite, its establishment, political leaders, and bureaucrats had the will, courage, and determination to understand the nuances and take action.

[@AR-fr8br]

Do you think they are sincere to Pakistan? We are ruled by dishonest and traitors who in in politics, bureacracy and every department so they will never allow Pakistan to progress.

[@Faizan_khan_dxb]

Faisal Waheed - such a professional, polite, and great host. Qaiser Sahab - a visionary honest person Raftar - Great Job 👍

[@foodexillent5017]

The best Pakistani analysis I have ever hear. This is an honest and intelligent person

[@AjitJadhav-h6b]

Great...not single sec of the video waste of time... great explanation...this is not just for any country this can we implement in our personal life also (financial management)..love from india❤🇮🇳

[@ssjavaad]

Really impressed by Dr. Bengali’s discussion. Well done Faisal, once again!!

[@mirajesh]

Always pleasure to listen to Kaiser Bengali. He s frank and open to facts. Brave Man

[@KanishQQuotes]

Every pakistani is taught from childhood that they are rulers ... Mughalia prince That's how things were in Mughalia sultanate A handful enjoyed everything while masses fought for scraps

[@user-bc9yb8lv5w]

😂😂😂😂 right

[@atifrehmanfarooqui1429]

You have never been to Pakistan. Funny how randians think all their problems get solved by bashing Pakistan.

[@saaj4197]

Visit any office in Pakistan-whether it's a local office,school, hospital, police station, or court-or even a consulate abroad for any legal work is nearly impossible. The dysfunction is evident in areas such as the national airline, PIA, which can barely operate, and in sports, where there is zero patriotism from players or officials. IK, hailed by some as a messiah, uses foul language, has no clear vision, and in his private life refuses to take responsibility for his own children. In his official capacity, he, along with his entire cabinet, signed a sealed document that authorized the payment of illegal funds from the British crime agency to a conman rather than the to country and judiciary approved this deal, yet many Pakistanis still support this as honest deal. As the saying goes, "Pakistanis can even sell their mothers for a few dollars." The reality is that A nation gets the leaders it deserves, reflecting the character of its people.Enjoy IK and his crownies what a future of a country!

[@AstralProjections-oy8ue]

[@Yalla12347]

@KanishQQuotes you need to reduce the hindutva material you are hooked on. Nobody is taught that you are a “Mughalia prince” since childhood.

[@waseemaliwaseemali9075]

I'm just commenting for Kaiser Bengali sahab: His discussions are always sensible, Logical and factual.

[@quickworkmarketingopcpvtlt783]

Moral of the story is, Till 1980 we were doing fine. But then we decided to venture into the booming Industury of International Terrorism. It was booming then, but now our product is not selling and we need a new Industry.

[@klasgroup]

@@quickworkmarketingopcpvtlt783 ,😅😂

[@umerghaffar4686]

Could you explain the international terrorism part? You don’t earn money by bombing places. You just have a story to tell the masses to bring more aid

[@khurshidawan164]

We weren't doing well even in 1980. We were always dependent on foreign aid (bheek) by encashing our nuisance value and serving USA and Western interests instead of developing our institutions, like Singapore. We deceive our own people and tell lies, like the "Empire of Lies" - USA and West.

[@Ma5898673]

Allah kr raftar ki awaaz suni jay... Raftar you are providing basic fuel for change... Salamt raho mushkil waqt main.. Ameen

[@SyedMuhammadAli-t1j]

قیصر بنگالی واقعی بہت اچھی اور معیاری گفتگو کرتے ہے اور تجربات کی بنیاد پر اپنی راۓ دیتے ہے بہت ھی اعليٰ تجربات ہے قیصر صاحب کے اگر ان جیسے افراد کو حکومت کا سربراه بنا دیا جاۓ تو ھمارے ملک میں بہت بہتری آجاے گی۔۔۔۔

[@Jazba-lifestyle]

Legends are those who get out in time ! We have been listening to these for decades ! Nothing will change .

[@vvreddyother]

If you have a lot of barytes ( a kind of stone), it shouldn’t be exported as a stone. You get peanuts by selling stone. Barytes is such a valuable mineral, it not only a source of barium, but main use in the oil industry as a very costly drilling mud density controller; as a molecular sieves in petrochemical and many ionic exchanges. India processes barytes and final industrial grade products are sold by entrepreneurs within India and exported to earn a lot of FE. Someone is making money from Pakistan by taking away as stones and process it elsewhere and sell to middle eastern oil industry. They don’t have barytes in Soudi, Iraq, Kuwait etc. Pakistani entrepreneurs with simple collaboration with Indian entrepreneurs can make millions and billions for a long period from the Mother Earth. But pak people are not benefiting from this resource.

[@MrHorizonkid]

The best 2nd episode from the best guest on the best channel, highlighting the real issues and corrupt system without holding anything back!

[@honeydewroboticsug]

Am from India: I listen this guy regularly. His every sentence I take it as life lesson. Very good for business knowledge. Because, he had first hand experience of what all can go wrong in an economy and business.

[@narayansinght8197]

Nice and excellent economist , brilliance of analysis

[@bhushanrane1616]

How come Pakistanis keeping quiet over corruption of Army

[@cybersecurity9224]

army got guns and security we got nothing we have families to loose

[@Freethinker-vj4ut]

​@@cybersecurity9224bruh, do you think India had f35 when we fought British. No wonder pak citizens can't have a revolution its because this community didn't take part in freedom struggle they got Pakistan for free😢

[@cybersecurity9224]

@@Freethinker-vj4ut sadly ye duniya bohot buri ha na koi india and pakistan ko pasand kerta ha or pakistani or indians apas ma hi lartay rahtay hain or hamaray mulkon ma bohot corruption ha bohot zulm ha.

[@AsifKhan-tw7ye]

We are not quiet brother actually they are very cruel so we speak so little.

[@Freethinker-vj4ut]

@@cybersecurity9224 corruption toh h vro dono mulk me, humare yaha khoon chuss lete h corruption me apk yaha khoon dene se phele hi corruption kr lete h🤣.

[@atharhashmi5762]

A very competent and qualified man with effective knowledge

[@AKumar-co7oe]

'ham India ko aid de sakte hain', joker

[@rxfvy]

@@AKumar-co7oeIt doesn't discredit him, he explained his conclusion with reasoning. 🤡

[@HimanshuKumar-mq5bq]

​@@AKumar-co7oehaha mujhe bhi hasi aayi ki Pakistan jo bheekh maang raha hai woh world ki fifth largest economy ko aid dega. Abhi relations normal ho Jaye, Pakistan bheek maangne aa jayega india ke pass turant 😅😂

[@bilalriaz5441]

The way anchor conducted the interview and the way Sir Given Detailed Information on every aspect is such a huge respect 🫡

[@sajjadlawrence6836]

Appreciate you for this podcast.. Specially. Thanks for bringing the truth.

[@rajatrao]

13:13 Establishment se Kya Matlab Hai….😂😂 Brave Bengali ❤❤

[@mujahidhussain6264]

Military establishment

[@eleghari]

Fauj 🥴🤭🤣

[@sunny_1515]

Although a little misplaced timestamp.

[@abdulsami5085]

🤣

[@Aesthetic.designz]

@@rajatrao 😂😂

[@AS-sf7hr]

Thank you for this very informative and insightful interview of Mr Kaiser Bengali👍🌟

[@nomanaftab2009]

Western interest will never finish here, this country was made for their interest, not for us

[@KanishQQuotes]

So I guess chanting death to America and death to France didn't work

[@priyanshumishra5778]

​@@KanishQQuotes kanishka they are handicapped community Because they keep everything with Allah and do nothing

[@rawahakamran9544]

@@nomanaftab2009 we did it to ourselves. Blaming the west is just our cope by outsourcing blame. India, China, and Sri Lanka got independence with us. Bangladesh got independence from us.

[@asadaziz6429]

​@@rawahakamran9544Sir, India and China are more resourses and have infrastructure rather them Pakistan has not resourses and infrastructure.

[@rawahakamran9544]

@@asadaziz6429 Pakistan had everything. An appropriate size young population, vast agriculture land, decent size and diverse land mass, natural resources, tourism spots, many weathers, a colorful culture and much more. Even most European countries don't have all of these. Taiwan and Singapore are other examples. They made use of what they had. We lost all largely due to our misplaced priorities.

[@Mughal.786]

What a sensible man! Every word of Dr. Sahab was a fact!

[@sigzar16]

Good knowledge on how a country can restructure its economy!! Coming From the country like Nepal we should learn so much from it 🇳🇵

[@techgeek.]

Kudos to Raftar for broadcasting such a thought provoking podcast. We are so unfortunate that despite having such brilliant economists and still we are relying on foreign aid just because of our mismanagement.

[@farameen_mola_ali_a.s]

Indeed we just focusing on debt ❤

[@Fun-Free912]

یہ ہوسٹ بہترین ٹرین ہے ۔۔ آپ کو سرخ سلام آپ نے بہت اچھے سوالات اٹھایے 😊

[@mirfanali1937]

In the 1950s and 60s, when we-the Urdu-speaking community-held the reins of leadership, we propelled this nation to become the 3rd largest economy among 22 Asian countries. Karachi, as the capital, was the epicenter of progress, with our community leading advancements in Science and Technology, including the PCSIR, SUPARCO space program, as well as Banking, Education, Sports, Television, Print Media, Music, Aviation, Shipping, the Oil and Export industries, and nuclear energy. However, our monumental contributions were systematically dismantled by the shift of the capital to Punjab and Bhutto's devastatingly brutal and catastrophically destructive nationalization policies, which crippled these vital sectors.

[@Citizenoftheuniverse23]

@@mirfanali1937 True. The hatred and jealousy against the more educated migrant Urdu speaking community by the sons of soil has led to this downfall. The same hatred, against the Bengalis, led to the creation of Bangladesh in 1971.

[@LoveBlueColor]

Agreed and well said two top comments

[@HR-uf9sj]

Also AQK was muhajir who gave atomic bomb to Pakistan. Look what they did to him.

[@ahmedkauser9996]

@@HR-uf9sj also MM Alam and many others.

[@gmaingforfun]

Agreed 👍💯 😊

[@sohaila.qureshi6517]

What an explanation-hats off to the Raftar team, this topic was extremely needed.

[@ahmedrashid8960]

He is very competent and honest MAN,who want do somthing for this COUNTRY

[@zahidnoonari3712]

آپکے اسی Point view سے آپکو بہت عزت اور فالونگ ملی ہے ، keep it up bro چینل پے جو بھی ویڈیوز پڑی ہیں سب دیکھی ہیں،

[@jeetendraparmar4482]

The best thing Pakistan can do is to make significant cuts in its defense expenditure and make the armed forces to sacrifice their emoluments more than their lives for their country... Mind you, this is a humble suggestion by a humble Indian...

[@mohsinchanna5595]

Nothing will happen here everyone is lotting this country

[@rajeshrkale]

Chahe mulk doob jaye, Pak Army unake budget cut karane denge kya??? 😮😮

[@jeetendraparmar4482]

@@rajeshrkale People don't have power over us, we give it to them... May God bless Pakistanis with the wisdom to differentiate between what is right and what is wrong and then act accordingly...

[@jeetendraparmar4482]

@@mohsinchanna5595 People don't have power over us, we give it to them... May God bless Pakistanis with the wisdom to differentiate between what is right and what is wrong and then act accordingly...

[@motorized736]

Defence expenditure is not the bigger issue. Bigger issue is mismanagement.

[@ahsanhabib9820]

The habit of bringing in IMF, World Bank vetted economists as Finance minister is one of key reason we are in this mess .

[@rishiraaj.580]

Common people are busy in Religious Issue. Politician are doing corruption. 😮

[@Muhammadsamims9]

@@rishiraaj.580 on the point

[@TechCrunchPK]

well it's same across the globe, it's not just here in Faujistan.

[@syedrohaan9744]

This is the best podcast on economy.. he explained the exact situation...

[@muhammadsaadansari]

Such a wise man. He is cent percent right. I want to meet the great person.

[@passionexcel8489]

@@muhammadsaadansari rather than meeting, you should try educating your fellow citizens.

[@muhammadsaadansari]

@@passionexcel8489 Doing so, but it will take little longer. We have not industrialised in the way we were supposed to do. Professor Qaiser Bengali has been enlightening the mass for over 40 years. We should respect our genius legends and visiting their office or meeting them is a way of doing that.

[@ImranAhmad-rz7lw]

Very intelligent person Dr Qasier Bengali, if you close you eyes and listen to him, then you will realize that all his information is already given by Imran khan in his speaches. You can read between the lines

[@kanwalarora363]

Don't compare baalti khan with qaiser bangali

[@aamerahmedkhan4168]

Qaiser Bengali's views explain why we are where we are - victims of our own intellectual poverty and lack of integrity. Heartbreaking!

[@muhammadwaqas9610]

Bengali sahb your respect increases a thousand times in our hearts. You speak for the sake of betterment of people of Pakistan thank you for raising the voice on your part ❤

[@sananpirzada3373]

What the words... incredible

[@nishatkhan3615]

THIS ARMY IS NOT PROTECTING PAKISTAN BUT MAY CAUSE THIS STATE TO FAIL EVENTUALLY

[@tawhidarsalan5423]

Dont say that bro india is destroying your country from inside we bangladeshi experienced it from 16 years

[@aadiplayz7664]

Not may, for sure it will eventually break Pakistan and very soon unlike Mr. Kesar suggests 20yrs...I say 4-6 yrs

[@atifrehmanfarooqui1429]

Everyone is just waiting when it happens so that they can settle their scores.

[@MohinKMoh_Kamran]

The Army is solely responsible for the problem that Pakistan is got into.

[@AstralProjections-oy8ue]

'may cause'?????????

[@UsamaSidhu]

Kind of podcast we want for our growth. Really appreciated ❤

[@muhammadusmankhan7730]

He always seems to me as good,learned, patriotic and honest person. May ALLAH bless him in here and here after .ameen.

[@FarEastConstructionCoLtd]

Every single word of this podcast is a slap in the face of Pakistan's politics and our establishment And salute to Qaiser Bengali Sahib who has presented this economic and social decline of us as a nation in a better way and to the team of Rfatar who decided to make a podcast on this subject.May Allah Ta'ala help us to understand and act on it so that we as a nation can get rid of this oppressive system and give the poor people of our society a better and economically stronger life.Thank you team Raftar and thank you qaiser Bengali sb

[@tech.rabbit]

Wonderful podcast, this is not seen on national tv nowadays, well done Raftar

[@NormalPerson053]

*Lack of democracy *Lack of freedom *Lack of free market *Lack of nation first policy doing bidding of usa and china . *Fighting proxy war.

[@PfefferNusse-vr4yo]

[@ahmedbinyousaf2484]

Worry about manipur mr p@jeet

[@AstralProjections-oy8ue]

@@ahmedbinyousaf2484 NaPak badzehniat:"Dukan pakodon ki....... baatein karodon ki" Napak nakam riasat uz bharpoor pudina - kalme pad pad ke, tokri bhar ghaas kha kha ke mulk bana tha - LEKIN afsosssssss Ya Allah apni habib k sadqe KPK, Balochistan, Sindh ke MAZLOOM muslmano ki madad farma aamen

[@NormalPerson053]

@@ahmedbinyousaf2484 Pakistan problem Indian problem very similar Pakistani problems are worse. I am not worried either about India not about Pakistan . Because all countries of sub continent India, Nepal , Sri Lanka , mayanmar , Pakistan , Bangladesh are fucked to its core. I care about normal people who are duped , frauded , looted , disarmed and enslaved by there government. Never let hate distract you from real issue of lack of freedom . People in power love normal people fighting with each other. And when shit hits the fan they run away in helicopter. There is reason why Pakistani ,Indians , Bangladeshi , Sri Lankan , Nepali etc. Migrate to foreign.

[@mirzamanmirzaman1482]

@@NormalPerson053 انسانېت کا فقدان

[@ramanv.r3422]

At 1:11:25 20 There are over 20 million homeless people in Pakistan.That's around 9% of the total population. There are 1.77 million homeless people in India, or 0.15% of the country's total population, according to the 2011 census consisting of single men, women. Information gathered from Google search just now.

[@TheGrimStoic]

0 seconds ago entire paistan, including this expert, inhabits a parallel universe he's an expert later - first and foremost he's a purebred arab momin

[@sameer_r1a_z93]

Pakistani soldiers are braver than Indian soldiers by 10 times. It’s just that in 1971 they were very far from their supply lines that’s why they lost. Similarly the Pakistanis are very rich compared to India. It’s just that things weee a bit mismanaged till now. Just you wait. The Pakistanis will become superpower soon. It’s just that it hasn’t happened yet. The logic is impeccable, history and current outcomes be damned.

[@mayursawant8891]

@@sameer_r1a_z93 If my aunt had balls she would be my uncle ahh logic.

[@SurajSharma-be2kd]

@@mayursawant8891 😀😀

[@atifrehmanfarooqui1429]

Still you have the time to come and comment here 😂

[@djsachins]

24 baar IMF se bheek mang raha he lenkin akkad nahi gayee . ye he problem

[@Kingjr1821]

@@djsachins mere bhai aisa comment karna jaruri tha kya

[@shivampatil23]

😂😂😂

[@braveheart8318]

Pakistani elite imf k loan ko bhek nhi balke apni services ki salary samajhti he isileay sare funds west me transfer ker k wahin retire ho jate hen. Yahan to aik dhela bhi nhi aata laikin ghareeb awam ko loan plus interest pay karna parta he.

[@ashwanikumar3253]

bilkul sahi naa bijlee heee naa pichwada dhone kee liye paani magar india koo imdaad denge aree apni bhuki nangi kaum koo paaloo phele.

[@kju-dja213]

​@@braveheart8318 ek lafz hai takhtapalat agar woh kar payi tumhari awam toh tabhi tumhare mulk ka kuch hoga tumhari army tumhare liye kaam karni chahiye na ki tum unke liye dusro se nafrat band karo Apne mulk pe kaam karo

[@afrazahmadkhokhar]

1 like is not enough for this podcast. Watched every single second. Great work @raftar and great person Dr. Qaisar Bangali

[@falahbaloch]

Gr8 Work Raftar Team ❤

[@syedalam7654]

People like him should be the finance minister of Pakistan.

[@TheGrimStoic]

ye bhi kr lau

[@eleghari]

Don't be fooled. People like him only speak the truth when not part of the government. As soon as they get a 🍗 thrown at them, they turn into vampires themselves. Don't believe me? See his resume...: "Till recently, he was Head of the Chief Minister’s Policy Reform Unit, Government of Balochistan. Earlier, he was Advisor to the Chief Minister of Sindh for Planning & Development. He was also the first head of the Benazir Income Support Programme and designed the programme. He was also Sindh’s representative on the 7th National Finance Commission, which gave a successful Award. He has now been nominated on the 8th NFC to represent Balochistan."

[@Citizenoftheuniverse23]

He is not a Punjabi.

[@kju-dja213]

​@@Citizenoftheuniverse23 so non Punjabi can't be FInance minister ? If this is the case then your country will surely fall in future

[@Neoluddism]

@@kju-dja213 he is socialist to its core

[@ghazanfaralishah9939]

These are blessings of Zia UL Haq and company.

[@alililani7530]

خدا قیصر بنگالی صاحب کو اپنے حفظ و امان میں رکھے اور طول عمر عطا فرمائے۔۔۔رفتار ثی وی کو پیارے پاکستان کا اکانومیکل چہرہ واضع کروانے پہ خراج تحسین پیش کیا جاتا ھے۔۔۔۔ قیصر صاحب نے مثبت اور حوصلہ افزا راھ حل بھی بتائے ھیں کاش اسٹیبلشمنٹ ان پہ سنجیدگی سے غور و فکر کر کے عملدرآمد کروائے۔۔۔۔

[@mr.techguy6738]

Very Well podcast with Kaiser Bangali shb! We have to viral this video, so the people of Pakistan should know about the current condition and the culprits behind this.

[@NaseemIbnWaheed]

WATCHED THE WHOLE PODCAST..!❤

[@dr.farahaslam6984]

Mr. Qaisar Pakistan need people like you. Why you left the field for less able persons? . Please come and contribute.

[@fighterjet007]

Aise logon ko country ke liye kaam nahi karne deti aapki army....

[@Vick1472]

Bengali was and remains a socialist. He praises Bhutto’s nationalization which essentially bankrupted Pakistan and massively corrupted the govt. India was poor for a 50 years due to similar decisions. Then India became capitalist and befriended USA, and became enormously wealthy. Bengali, a committed socialist, won’t understand this.

[@priyanshumishra5778]

Bengali community in India too are hardcore socialist or communist always want everything from government side . They don't like capital formation , capitalism and Privatisation (anywhere) . They made Calcutta/Kolkata poor all due to ultra socialist approaches . Indian Growth is not driven by Socialist Bengali . It's driven by Capitalists of other parts of India

[@ViikRum]

We didn’t prosper because of USA’s friendship, we prosper on our own capabilities. In fact USA befriended us because it was more benefiting for them then us. We did everything on our own! Don’t give your senseless views with knowing facts @waqargardezi5005

[@NabooHashmi]

@@Vick1472 Pakistan has had cordial and good relationship with USA for way longer than it has been cold and Pakistan has been capitalism leaning way more than it has gone for "socialist" policies, where is the prosperity?

[@kju-dja213]

​@@NabooHashmi Pakistan cannot grow until you people change your mindset India didn't grow due to friendship with USA India is growing due to hospitable environment for business and trade Pakistan won't grow until it makes the environment in their country for this you have to bring peace and stability radicals must be dismissed

[@sohailahmed159]

He was culprit of nationalization by supporting bhutto to nationalize the industries and destroy the country. Bhutto could not tolerate industrialists becoming wealthier than land owners / jagirdars.

[@oriana93]

This guy who is referring to India and poverty in India , doesn't have any idea that the extreme poverty in India is completely wiped off.

[@9Rehankhan19]

Completely wiped out 😂😂😂😂. If you won’t change the poverty line for decades, then obviously you can show there is no extreme poverty. Just google and see when was the last time india changed it and when was the last time an official survey was done. 60 to 70% of the population lives on subsidy. That’s called extreme poverty

[@jspillai1869]

@@9Rehankhan19 Says a Bhikaristani! Atta Chahiye kya? 🤣🤣😂😂

[@SandeepSingh-cc3lk]

Educatied person 😊

[@AmirShahzad-si1hv]

واقعی یہ ایک بہت ہیلپ فل پوڈ کاسٹ تھی مذید سر قیصر جیسے لوگوں کو بلائیں اور ان سے اکنامک انلسز ڈسکشن ہونی چاہیئے جو کے پبلک اویرنس کے لیے بہت ضروری ہے Such podcasts should be conducted in future for the good public financial awareness.

[@matt_canadian]

Let Mr. Qaiser Bengali be Mr. Mohammad Yunus of Pakistan…. We need a Bengali to save us now😊🙏

[@walidalam1238]

No assistant commissioner needs Toyota Hilux, the 3rd gen Suzuki Jimny can go anywhere.

[@scc57-1]

Pakistan reminds me of "Conspiracy of Fools," a book about the collapse of Enron.

[@eleghari]

I used to work at Enron. Wish it was only as bad as Enron...

[@CherryKro]

Real fun is the people still believe that some Messiah will come to get them rid of their problems

[@beowulfourcaucasianshepher8528]

@@CherryKro people will stand up for themselves.

[@CherryKro]

@@beowulfourcaucasianshepher8528 hohoooo U think it's a libero social well educated critical thinking society 😛😜 let me tell you from ground perspective. It's not 🚫🚫🚫🚫🚫

[@subhanzakir70]

Upon hearing it, I felt immense pleasure, and it didn't feel like a waste of time at all. Great job!

[@zeetheleo]

Dr Qaiser, Words clear like crystal , Knowledgeable, Calm and Tactfully handled Interview. Well Done

[@Uudemy-j6t]

Never have I heard anyone speak so clearly about Pakistan's economy.

[@akshaygoel1276]

most of the podcast was good but in the end mr. bengali showed a glimpse of pakistan's understanding of india by thinking that india has around 250 mil homeless population and on top of that in 20 years pakistan will be able to solve all its economic problems but india will remain poor despite knowing the economic history of both countries.

[@mirfanali1937]

How conveniently he overlooks the repercussions of shifting the capital from Karachi to Punjab, the Dacca debacle, and, above all, the brutal and destructive nationalization that Pakistan has never recovered from to this day.

[@hassanazad4627]

Indeed, this is the main cause of where we stand.

[@GuzzarAwan]

PunJab is pakistan pakistan is Punjab. It's natural that capital ahd have been in punjab. Fojis who r real huqmaran as concieved by British are 90% punjabi

[@minhajdesigns]

@@GuzzarAwan bullshit, Punjab didn't contribute anything in the creation of Pakistan. Most of the members were either from the Bengal or Indian side (UP, Bihar etc). Punjab was just lucky that it got separated otherwise Punjabis would still be licking Britishers boot.

[@salmanaziz1125]

he is a great economist but he has a soft side/bias towards PPP and Sindh govt if you have follow him consistently. He will never criticize Bhutto's policy of nationalization, political instability caused by PPP in 1970s etc.

[@doosra95]

@@GuzzarAwan no wonder Bangladeshi people don't call Pakistani Foji (Army) as Pakistani,rather Punjabi Army.Bangladeshi people have deep deep loathing of that Army. Same will happen to Pakistan other 3 subha ( division)Punjabi will be the cause for break up of Pakistan. Hope not for Pakistan's people sake.

[@nfsltd2219]

This is real journalism and a decent talk on solutions and problems.

[@SameerTanoli-1]

Amazing. It is the first time I have understood the basics of the economy, as well as Pakistan's economic crises. Qaiser Sir is just amazing and such an intellectual, an asset for Pakistan

[@spts4747]

The biggest mistake was to move the capital from Karachi to Rawalpindi. The thinking is very limited in the Rawalpindi area. Bengali Sahib says the business people don’t have money. It is False, Karachi has has some of the richest people of the world. Dubai will close if the Karachi business people leave. 90% of Pak economy off the books.

[@sunala1265]

*Biggest joke of Century* *Pakistan have more resources than India,but can't utilise* *If utilise property Pakistan will beat India in next 20 years* *Duffer doesn't know India at 5th economy ,and today's growth will be 3rd in the world, whereas Pakistan at 41st place and by present growth & population will reach at 75th place(as per IMF) Pakistan's current economic situation is challenging, with a high debt burden and trade deficit ¹ ² ³ ⁴ ⁵. The country's debt stands at 77.1% of its GDP, while its trade deficit is around $24.8 billion ⁵. Additionally, Pakistan faces issues like slow economic growth, poverty, and low human development outcomes ⁶. The State Bank of Pakistan has maintained a policy rate of 22% to combat inflation ³. To address these challenges, Pakistan needs to implement deep and sustained reforms ⁶.

[@TheGrimStoic]

entire paistan, including this expert, inhabits a parallel universe he's an expert later - first and foremost he's a purebred arab momin

[@LamyNinja-hh5lk]

❤❤🇮🇳🇮🇳❤❤ He is not fully aware of Indian Economy.

[@SwarajSamuel-ip5ep]

Make him PM for 5 years and he'll solve half of problems

[@languagepathways-piils6612]

"It’s a misconception among some people in Pakistan that India is still stuck in the 1990s. He said that around "25 crore people" live on the streets in India, which is far from reality. These assumptions are made without any understanding of actual facts. It almost seems as though Google doesn’t exist in Pakistan. Perhaps it would be better for them to visit India and see the progress for themselves."

[@NaseemIbnWaheed]

How informative it is.