Asking NYC Strangers to Pick the Prettiest Red Velvet Member?!

We asked random strangers in NYC's Times Square to pick the most beautiful Red Velvet member, from among the amazing Irene, Joy, Seulgi, Wendy, and Yeri. They're all super pretty and are amazing and talented, but it's fun to see what random Americans and people from around the world think about K-pop beauty standards! And just an interesting ranking of Red Velvet members in general.
Subscribe to my channel: / @xiaomanyc
Follow me on Instagram: / xiaomanyc
Follow me on Facebook: / xiaomanyc

[@renebae6588]

"I've never seen them, but i know who that is though. I've seen her face" Miss worldwide Bae

[@Jurmyus]

Her Instagram is in your profile picture XD

[@jellyjambear]

Rin be honestly tho

[@marshalll.8920]

Not surprised since fans will post their faves photos all over time square

[@rgaha5676]

Only real Irene fan can appreciate your DP.

[@PongoXBongo]

That guy looks like he might be into the makeup scene and Irene is the face of a few Korean cosmetic brands.

[@windylizasadela4245]

"Wendy looks like she's a little bit too christian, she ain't trying to get dirty" IM DEAD

[@jonatanbarrang4353]

Wendy is my closest ideal woman in red velvet. eventough she just said yadong in korean (She's honest). but her heart is cleaner than the rest, because she's more christian than the rest.

[@isabobrinha]

@@jonatanbarrang4353 ????????

[@jonatanbarrang4353]

@randomly weird ideas no, i'm never heard about it. where's u got this information?

[@jonatanbarrang4353]

@@isabobrinha ????? :)

[@isabobrinha]

@@jonatanbarrang4353 it's just so wrong, inaccurate and disrespectful towards every non-christian person in the world to say that "her heart is cleaner, because she's more christian".

[@cheese_kimbap1279]

Irene wasn't lying when she said: "I'm original visual..."

[@lumik0]

PERIOD

[@user-cr8xl4hn4u]

ThanosGotSnapped01 it’s mostly like I’m original, visual

[@lizziepool1436]

I'm not a girl kpop fan!I never had a favorite girl artist like...in a while...I'm in kpop for 4 years and i've never delved into a girl kpop group, but when i saw Irene for the first time I was stunned and I'm not an easy fangirl as I said before.I think her personality got me but first of all her looks and I've seen plenty videos mvs and not-mvs to understand what a natural beauty she is! How strong she is, how caring and how dependful!I was mesmerised immediately!Right now, she is the most beautiful woman in the world for me....and I'm from Europe...

[@pwqwpu]

👀👀👀👀👀

[@babsgrayson8432]

URI WOLLAR IRRASEO

[@dinahs639]

"I think Irene is pretty. And I am gay" GOD, YES.

[@ale05344]

Samf

[@Idea_id]

Hahahaha

[@RJinoona]

Lmao 😂😂👍

[@Sajirah]

The gays have spoken! Irene is the ultimate visual!

[@abqaaariii.]

@@Sajirah lol

[@94swenseul32]

"She has a quiet confidence about her!" Yeah you're right😂

[@zoezoe8024]

Spot on!

[@jetia7100]

Sweet when he said: "Beauty is in the hidden heart of the woman" and that he could appreciate Joy's kind heart. For me, Joy looks so stunning and is absolutely gorgeous (eg: MAMA 2017 and Hush Joy are iconic). But even more importantly Joy's someone who is beautiful inside and out. The way Joy loves animals and children, and volunteers at a shelter for abandoned dogs, and how there's so many accounts from her classmates saying how kind-hearted and empathetic Joy's always been... That beauty can't be diminished.

[@JoyismyQ]

💚💚💚

[@channelv7874]

It's amazing that he found out that joy has the confidence just by looking at the picture.

[@vkmksm5714]

TheBible says that

[@nesha1434]

Quote of the year: "I love Red velvet. We love Red velvet. Everybody loves Red velvet"

[@PhysiologyShark]

I actually don't really like RV, but I'm not gonna disrespect them

[@kimmmyeobleop6514]

Physiology Shark I read that wtong and thought you were gonna disrespect them and i was abt to throw hands

[@PhysiologyShark]

Taengoo_fan_Queen Taengoo Now I really love RV because of "Psycho" & "Bad Boy"

[@JChuuu127]

I love (G)I-dle

[@CR35C3ND0]

@@PhysiologyShark this person is an intellectual i might say👏👏👏

[@emilyt6116]

Ppl who chose Irene: "Her skin colour is more tan." Irene irl: the palest skin EVER alongside Wendy lol

[@LM-ix7pk]

Irene & Wendy are the palest while Seulgi Joy and Yeri are more tan

[@jeonskookiee8366]

Ikr! I guess in that pic she looked a little tan.

[@soapy7832]

Exactly 😂

[@mariah0158]

.. thats what I thought too.. lolz:))

[@anonymous-zf1qm]

Ikr🤣

[@gracelim2918]

seulgi : sexy visual wendy : innocent visual joy : charisma visual irene : chic visual yeri : cute visual

[@anggimotti1810]

Real haha ㅋㅋ

[@ryna8442]

Irene dark and sexy xd

[@boriszhivotnoe3201]

Joy is sexy

[@MarsCalamars666]

Irene : (人*´∀｀)｡*ﾟ+ original visual

[@JoeARedHawk275]

Wendy: Christian visual

[@olyviatriapratiwi454]

They :"i love irene, her skin darker than the others,a little bit tan." Me : "dude, she is the palest in red velvet 😂😆".

[@reelea7475]

WHITEST IS AN ANNOYING WORD

[@suesylvester9389]

Yeah, shes the palest. Tan? Its Yeri. She got a beautiful skin

[@requiem5151]

Tbh it's a bit disappointing how so many people only choose the one they liked based on skin color... Those are probably the ones that criticize kpop pale skins but they worship tanned skin... Hypocrites af.

[@ruthstephanysantoso1612]

I’ve seen Red Velvet before at the concert weeks ago and all I can say is that IRENE is the PALEST girl in the gang lmao

[@olyviatriapratiwi454]

@A Princees if u follow red velvet from happines era, u will know irene is the palest

[@LizzyThomson]

“I like Wendy” “Why?” “Cause she’s happy” IM-

[@Purplerene]

FXCKINGSTYLIK lmaooo

[@mrlightningtypefan1949]

That’s like the worst pictures of Joy as possible

[@sl4370]

Also Yeri

[@harmonyfuntime1082]

I like the picture of Wendy, I think she looks really nice in that picture (everyone else actually) but I feel like they could’ve chosen a better picture for Joy (maybe even Seulgi)

[@akirakira9960]

no it normel pic

[@ferjimenez1520]

Joy yes, Wendy not, she looks really good and tbh i would've picked her or Irene

[@anvi7yearsago687]

I don't know why no one is speaking about Yeri, when it literally looks like someone took her photo while she was awkwardly laughing-😭

[@cantyouseeme1413]

i personally like joy's visual the most

[@armhinkyledayao8677]

Same

[@vanessa.s2976]

Same

[@user-gu9wj9qz1e]

I also personally like Joy the most but because she's really hot haha

[@cy1457]

Park Soo-young is love

[@archangbriel]

same samee

[@auritra30]

Someone said Irene is tan. That’s why she chose her. But Irene is the palest member in Red Velvet even in kpop. I am not hating on it. I just love her pale skin.

[@irenenoda]

Auritra30 lmao i think the palets member in kpop is dahyun

[@jeanettedelrosario2074]

It's Iu, the "milky skin Iu"

[@baej6761]

Auritra30 there’s a lot of gg members has pale skin. i think kei, yooA and chaeyeon also kwon eunbi are the palest i’ve ever seen so far

[@irenenoda]

Bae J *qlldjd yooa*

[@serenatadeamor6057]

Yooa has actually darker skin and I think she's perfect that way

[@user-wq2wj2ph8m]

Why No one gonna talk about the response of the man who chose Joy? that's really precious above all!

[@JoyismyQ]

Redu belbet i love his description about Joy... wow.

[@jetia7100]

That was such a precious response! Joy really is someone who is beautiful inside and out. You can see it with the way she adores animals and volunteers at a shelter for abandoned dogs, and how much empathy she has in always wanting to help others. Joy's absolutely stunning to me (and Joy at MAMA 2017 is iconic) but above all her kind-heart is so beautiful.

[@adlynnazurah8559]

Ikr! He doesn't even know her or kpop. It's so heartwarming

[@artreese]

yes ^^ i like his response out of all and his friend too

[@litavibes7788]

Yass

[@ArturoStojanoff]

Everyone: Seulgi This random guy, an intellectual: selloodgie

[@lishthefish1423]

"sell ugie" 😂

[@mamamo69312]

lmao

[@taeomo]

interesting how dirty you did the other girls while irene has an amazing photo for her selection, and this is coming from an irene/joy stan. you did joy no justice with her 4 year old fan pic while irene has an amazing professional taken shot.

[@j6nrod]

same joy is my bias and Irene is my bias wrecker.

[@suhanij4380]

Irene is def his bias since he introduced her differently than the others. And this is coming from an Irene stan.

[@Lemonwater2003]

I think even Irene had another photo she would still win cuz Irene can’t take a bad photo she is no 1 visual for nothing 🦋

[@user-ib1is7ny7r]

agreed

[@vanillaraven2618]

Irene's visual is on next level! But yeah her pic here is on diff level also. Joy is also pretty

[@hallelujercult2638]

Lol at people picking Irene because she's not too pale.. Like, that girl is whiter than snow white lmao

[@chickensruletheworld6503]

ikr? HAHAHAHAHA

[@paulaisabelle7520]

Irene is pale it's just the lightning

[@nt-uf3mt]

Yeah rofl

[@butterrbread]

i was like little did they know she's fuckin pale lol

[@reelea7475]

IRENE IS NOT REALLY PALE.THE MAKEUP AND EVERYTHING MAKES HER LOOK PALE. SHE IS NOT WHITER THAN SNOW WHITE

[@AZULwahoo]

Irene's pic is literally from a photoshoot while Joy and Yeri's pic is like from a fansite yikes.

[@everythingstays5131]

@GOLD Subs I think what he was saying is that all of their pictures should at least all come from a photoshoot, so everything is fair and square.

[@doniduckguy4622]

Ahh its just for fun, why people nagging about it alot?

[@s_27s67]

I was thinking exactly the same, of course they would choose Irene, the others are also beautiful but compared to this pic of Irene...

[@hyakkuyas]

ikr the photos aren't fair

[@zarawilson8352]

Plus irene is not tanned she's like the whitest in the group

[@nadineo7977]

The one who picked joy, I felt that🥺🥺🥺

[@baharihusin9834]

And no one pick Wendy or Yeri but i think Irene and Seulgi is the most prettiest skin .

[@cidneyrose1339]

BRO YOU PICKED THE WORSE POSSIBLE PIC OF JOY. ARE YOU KIDDINGGGGGG. SHE IS THE MOST BEAUTIFUL WOMAN WHY DID YOU DO THAT WHILE PICKING A PHOTOSHOOT PICTURE FOR IRENE LIKE BROOO

[@markiyabr8477]

.. their all gorgeous if others can see that oh well

[@Lemonwater2003]

Are u tryna say joy is only pretty in photoshoot not in real life photo ? Lmao Irene is pretty in every way even photos of fan sites

[@lafee3760]

@@Lemonwater2003 omg why solo stans love to embrass themselves so much

[@lafee3760]

yess he literally choose the worst pics for others especially joy but choose for irene her RECENT photoshoot and its coming from a someone who bias irene

[@cuddlyrene290]

@@Lemonwater2003 shut up solo stan. all the girls are gorgeous but people have there own opinions. let them be clown.

[@bored3217]

"Wendy? Why?" "She just looks more innocent" Me: *remembers what Wendy said to Seulgi while playing a game*

[@jaredabellana8820]

Yadong😂

[@MrAtheos86]

Yasol 🤣

[@rohayatighani961]

yadong(porn)😂

[@bangtansonyeondanchick5096]

What did she said

[@tzuyusbread5713]

Yadongggg HAHHAAHA

[@thaliaaaxo]

You did Joy & Yeri wrong. They have sooo many better pictures & yet you chose those 😪

[@MrAresxy07]

He always does this shit thou he always puts his favorite ones up front 🤷🏻‍♂️

[@floofyliu8819]

Frick dem oof

[@christopherkeroro723]

Im not an rv fan but that seems like an accurate clear face potrayal of their faces.. All of them actually

[@mirowrow4309]

Yeah as a ReVeluv I know there are so many better pictures he could've easily used, they're really not accurate.

[@diovrr5948]

he really should've just used pics from the same photoshoot for all of the girls or even like a selection of pics. i don't even get how he found the fansite pics he used when there's so many other professional ones available that would take 5 seconds to find.

[@tek900]

Lol I love how even though the guy who made this video tried to choose the worst possible photo of Joy, the guy at 4:41 still chose Joy. What he said was actually very fitting and sweet, because Joy is known to be really beautiful inside and out. And so many people, including non-fans, have mentioned that the camera can't capture her kind of beauty. Joy's definitely beautiful inside and out.

[@trulyelish]

most of them: *chooses irene because of her skin color* also irene: the palest member of rv and probably one of the palest among kpop girl group members 🤣

[@akirakira9960]

jalouse bitch shut the fuck up!!!people like this are so toxic !

[@Ily.kenyan]

@@akirakira9960 simply....stfu 🙂

[@x_astrid_x]

Wendy is the palest in RV and Irene comes 2nd

[@moonlightespt1946]

Wendy is the palest

[@ckim6680]

The only man who voted for Joy said the best comment out of all the people here in this video! Yeah we love Joy for who she is. 🥰

[@WolfEpsilon]

We need more people like them in this world.

[@jonatanbarrang4353]

yeah joy named is not lying, she fullfill her "stage" name.

[@jonatanbarrang4353]

this men voted, is counted as 10. quality vote love Joy. the visual wrecker

[@markwilkinson7594]

He's so humble and doesn't judge from outer apparence and that is good moral to have so full claps to him.

[@jonatanbarrang4353]

@@markwilkinson7594 we need more man like this in our society

[@kaziadiana5923]

Bro that's literally the worst possible picture of Joy

[@Monomiibo]

There's no such thing as a bad picture of Joy

[@cheeseoh]

Bitch wtf are you talking about. In what world is there a bad picture of joy

[@katlop177]

lola spade I kinda agree but joy is THE MOST BEAUTIFUL GIRL IVE EVER SEENNN 💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚

[@sophieyau8146]

Same, even though she is pretty in the picture, there are so many other ones he could have chosen from that enhance/show her natural beauty and features more

[@meybae39]

RIGHT i mean Joy's pictures in the albums are sooo amazing

[@dayantiutari8276]

"Seulgi is talented... She can dance,she can sing" Yeaah of course i think so

[@heathersapilan164]

Seulgi's pic is simple yet she has the most votes together with Irene. Men the power of visual

[@kalyrose3712]

He literally picked the worst picture of joy wtf

[@joylove7294]

Yup!

[@diovrr5948]

yeah he picked such a random fansite pic of joy taken back in 2016 where she was just walking down the road (and not even to an event or red carpet, just legit walking down the road). and that pic isn't even hd and is actually slightly pixelated, which is probably why that guy was bizarrely commenting on her skin (when joy has perfectly clear skin)... there's so many other pics that are more suitable he could've easily used but he picked that. i guess at least it's clear from people's comments they know joy's pic doesn't do her beauty justice which says something in itself.

[@justsomerandomfangirl6084]

I feel he’s biased on who he wants to win bc the ones who win always have the best photo while the others are awkward looking

[@frannyn8552]

Namjoon’s Left Man Tiddy THIS

[@megamaurizkafitri1965]

I know rightttt

[@safiasamad3715]

Nobody: Literally no one: Not even James charles: First dude: "I think she's really pretty...... and I'm GAAAAYYYYYY" Yassss love that😂😂

[@nurhidayah9124]

You bring james charles loll

[@BeatrizeDR]

OMG 😂😂😂

[@shawnthorington7723]

He didn't have to say he was gay, we already knew.

[@safiasamad3715]

@@shawnthorington7723 facts😉

[@BlueHat1]

Y'all are so annoying.

[@vatazip.4802]

dont hate me.. personally , joy is the prettiest for me ..she sO unique, exotic 🔥 no word for it 😂

[@via__ishere4234]

agree.. love her so much our joy 💚

[@user-zf7nx3ts4r]

Same! All of them are super beautiful! but I really thought Joy was the visual of Red Velvet when I first got into them!

[@tek900]

Joy's really beautiful, and so many people have said (including non-fans) that she's even prettier in person and that a camera can't capture her beauty. She must be so stunning.

[@kkyutomioka]

agree

[@AdeDueDamballa.]

Shes got weird teeth. I think it’s weird y’all think someone who looks like their dentures are about to pop out is a visual 😂

[@eatsehun4498]

joy's beauty is not just at one glance, the more you look at her the prettier she will be. anyways, just one picture can't determine their beauty

[@akirakira9960]

admit it hhhhh

[@AdeDueDamballa.]

She looks like shes about to lose her dentures.

[@unverified3653]

"SHE CAN DANCE SHE CAN SING" YAAAS SEULGI ACE OF KPOP

[@rickseth9207]

Yasss she is lobe....but even wendy sings so friggen good😍😍💕💕

[@arceliachan9136]

Wendy Be Shaking

[@queendany592]

No doubt that Seulgi is the Ace of Kpop, because you as Sansa and me as Dany is both inlove and mesmirize by Seulgi's Beauty and Talent

[@akguigguhhgggcv]

Seulgii💛💛💛♥️

[@yessi.11]

Yes!! Seulgi is the whole package! 🥰

[@jae4002]

"Irene bcs she looks tanned" Y'all don't know how pale Irene is HAHAHAHAHAHA

[@pinkapple8862]

Judging in pictures is not accurate..

[@calebrich99]

I personally find joy to be the most beautiful and you did her DIRTY here

[@akirakira9960]

no irene clearly we talking about face not vibes darling okey?

[@AdeDueDamballa.]

Lol how can you think joy is the most beautiful? With her teeth? You must like people that look like their dentures are about to pop out of their mouth. 😂

[@hiihiiiihii]

@@AdeDueDamballa. shut it.

[@charm.9929]

@@AdeDueDamballa. you shouldnt talk about yourself on youtube sweetheart. 😊

[@Shtriga_34]

I agree far as girl groups go, red velvet is very average looking. And if somone stands out, its joy. I will never get the irene hype. Shes very average far as kpop idols go.

[@davidarthur7489]

omg you're so biased with Irene, sure you got a really hard time to find joy's worst pic on google...

[@cuddlyrene290]

SERIOUSLY THO!! He chose such good photos for Irene and Seulgi but then for my girls, Yeri, Seulgi, and Wendy, he chose photos that would make them think that they are not beautiful but they really are.

[@sana-hq2mt]

@@cuddlyrene290 yeah She has such good photos But he bought the bad one

[@HelloMello91]

Really? I honestly think Joy looks gorgeous in that photo, to be fair... it's hard to find a bad picture of her in general. I don't understand what's so bad about that picture? She's beautiful in it.

[@d.dritalena]

you calling it the "worst pic" is kinda rude.. and he wasn't biased.

[@scarlett9750]

U basically called joy ugly in that photo lmao.

[@melisamadriaga6594]

Them : Irene coz she's has a tan skin among the others Me: owkay? Never heard of Irene The Snow Queen ????

[@reelea7475]

IN HER DREAMS

[@saphiraevani3043]

Hahahaha ya that photo is lack of brightness

[@rapunjel8242]

Many people said irene is more darker than the other 😂 they didnt know how irene's look like in real person. She has white color lol.

[@atbroyalty9122]

Ikr! Irene and Wendy are really pale in contrast to Seulgi, Joy, and Yeri lol

[@namsin5692]

ATB Royalty ikr haha. Here’s the order of them who has the fairest skin. Wendy > Irene > Joy > Yeri > Seulgi.

[@clairefan1342]

aye when seulgis the most tanned oop

[@amvelvet.9656]

Its seulgi the tanned one

[@reveltreasahi8095]

ayu YP exactly and seulgi is the easiest member to get tan

[@eillenhuas]

I find Irene really pretty, she's my bias. But Joy is so uniquely beautiful and breathtaking, I've never seen someone like her. Actually, all RV members are pretty and their visuals are no joke.

[@junyuan2210]

Joy is the one who managed to catch my attention. So I choose Joy ❤️

[@ningmendoza1903]

Yes Irene's a visual goddess but I think you should have chose a similar concept photo or same photoshoot of the girls. Some actually chose Irene because of the skin color when in fact Seulgi is the one with tanner skin. Anyways all red velvet members are pretty that even other idols had amitted to be mesmerized by them.

[@Sarahsirhan]

The pictures chosen for wendy, yeri and joy were definetly unfair and I'd even say one of their worst. If they had chosen from Bad boy era then I bet most would have chosen them.. They showed a professional photoshooting of irene but for the others randomly taken ones...i smell bias-.-

[@syarose3789]

Lol if you watched the other video, people chose irene as the 2nd prettiest idol after jihyo without mentioning anything about her being tanned. 🤷🏻‍♀️🤷🏻‍♀️

[@cuetzen712]

@@Sarahsirhan ikr! joy's picture was not even a photoshoot picture. it was a casual fansite picture while she was walking while the rest were a professionally taken pictures in the studio with editing💀. thus why irene suddenly appeared the most tanned when she is literally the second palest in the group, bc the pictures selected are not equally quality equal. i mean how do you compare fansite pictures with photoshoot pictures??💀

[@Sarahsirhan]

@@syarose3789 it always depends on the picture chosen for a comparison. Most of the citizens' answers always pointed out a certain hairstyle or posture or even skin tone. I'm really not mad about irene being chosen as the prettiest, really. But if they chose more professional/more flattering pics for the other members i bet the results would be different

[@syarifasyafiranisa3388]

Im sad he pick wrong Joy's picture. It should be peek a boo era

[@verseau2822]

Damn the guy who chooses Joy his words are so inspirational

[@JoyismyQ]

민Black 💚💚💚

[@nounayunus5439]

Yes..

[@aedianemontoya6136]

AMEN TO THAT

[@auniafiqah5390]

Ikr. Even joy got one vote but her comment is the best!

[@JoyismyQ]

auni afiqah that comment is enough for me bec truly Joy is beautiful inside out 💚

[@PhysiologyShark]

"Who's the most beautiful in Red Velvet?" Me : Red Velvet

[@insanityclarity2436]

The picture he picked for joy is definitely not even close to her good ones

[@Arthur-kh4rc]

The picture of Joy that you chose is very old and doesn't show her real beauty. I'm disappointed with your choice ㅠㅠ

[@castleash8463]

Yash!

[@kimnamjoondimples3796]

So you are saying that she ugly back then she look beautiful to me

[@Arthur-kh4rc]

@@kimnamjoondimples3796 Where did you see the word "ugly"? I just meant that the other girls' pictures were recent (more or less) unlike Joy's and the choice of the picture could be better. That's it. Actually, none of the photos can capture Joy's real beauty imo. She's like goddess irl

[@musyaffaazka]

just enjoy it bro lmaooooooooo

[@kimnamjoondimples3796]

@@Arthur-kh4rc ooohhhh ok i understand were you are coming from sorry

[@seulgikang8966]

Seulgi is so attractive thats why she can attract many people. She may not be rv visual but you cant hide that her beauty is known internationally

[@kzdwt9969]

ikr at first i ddint find her pretty probably bc she isnt the usual common standard of beauty face people usually think of but the more i see her the more i see her unique beauty and i end up finding her pretty along w her personality ik they all have screen personalities its their job but her personality seems quite genuine?

[@seulgikang8966]

kzdwt her kind personality is proven by people who work with her. Even the people who is not close to her say she has really a good personality. And thats the reason i fell for her even more

[@anicasantos2185]

💯

[@amirulzarif3678]

Seulgi should be fotg

[@seulgikang8966]

Amirul Zarif she is rv fotg

[@kschapmanj4688]

Irene is indeed the ✨Original Visual✨

[@megawei4134]

Seulgi, Seulgi, and Seulgi (I'll makes 7 for her since she's really beautiful and talented fo me💜💜💜💜)

[@daboo5496]

Joy's photo is so random... it was her literally walking down the street without any professional makeup, lighting, or hairstyle and it was from when she was younger (her face became more defined as she aged!)

[@DivaAngelika]

Joy may be got only one vote but she got the most beautiful reason among them all wow

[@JoyismyQ]

Diva Angelika that’s true 💚

[@aliensuperstar333]

Trueee

[@oumaymaj4123]

TRUUUUE

[@rtexol2139]

Oh yes his answer was a full of wise

[@betterjoy9475]

1:49 joy look little bit of acne? Oh my hearts.. my bias Joy is perfect ❤️

[@RoseFrance]

I love that man who chose Joy, like he literally spoke up the truth 💙😊 we all know all of them is so beautiful inside and out, but as I stan Joy for so many years, she is indeed so gorgeous,not because of her visual, body goals, milk skin, or anything, but also because she is so beautiful as a person and a had a huge warm heart💙 Her genuine beauty shines out the most. And btw I love all Red Velvet Members, omg I'm so proud to all of them 🙈 but the heck with video hahaha, that man is simply bias. 🤔

[@aleksandra59595]

You did Joy and Yeri dirty tho🤷🏼‍♀️ If you just chose more recent Joy pic

[@lailakhan1677]

And also wendy.... Their pics were quit random... Only irene's was the one with a proper photo shoot and also editing... I love irene but just a bit sad for the rest, I mean their pics

[@AyAReI00]

I was looking for this comment, why not choose JOY in peek-a-boo era ir Bad boy , that photo from ootn era

[@indahanisah1508]

AyAReI00 youre right:(

[@maryjoybio2698]

That's what I'm trying to say.

[@joylove7294]

Yup I said the same thing!

[@sofi-yj2bg]

Maybe this is just me but I feel like you did joy dirty with the photo like all of there photos they looked like done up, or it was some sort of photo shoot but for joy chose the pic where she was clearly battling the wind I’m-

[@diovrr5948]

you're definitely not alone in thinking that. he used a random fansite pic of joy from back in 2016 where joy was just walking down the street not even for any event or red carpet. on top of that it's not even hd and is slightly pixelated. there are so many other pics that are more easily accessible and suitable that he could've chosen.

[@megamaurizkafitri1965]

Me too

[@azelietoly8520]

Yeri too

[@mirowrow4309]

I agree. Joy's photo is the only one where she's crossing the road and it's just a fansite capturing her casually outside not even for an event (and therefore as you said she isn't done up). The other pics at least were red carpet pics (Seulgi and Yeri), an official press pic (Wendy), and from a photoshoot (Irene). This guy should really use photos from the same shoot or at least from the same era for all the members.

[@sofi-yj2bg]

mirow row I agree because it’s not even the first time he’s done this I noticed with other groups there will always be one or two pictures that aren’t as good quality as the other and that doesn’t give her a fair chance at all

[@itsmeee5169]

Why you choose the worst picture of Joy!?? For me she's the prettiest!❤

[@akirakira9960]

hhhhh no admit the truth

[@AdeDueDamballa.]

Lmfao how can you think joy is the most pretty? With her teeth? You must like people that look like their dentures are about to pop out of their mouth. 😂

[@fresitqjk]

@@AdeDueDamballa. stfu

[@oliviaaurora3954]

@@AdeDueDamballa. wtf?

[@Mia-jc6uj]

Some people are so fucking rude, there is absolutely nothing wrong with joy she is beautiful inside and out, clearly given the worst picture out of all of them considering she wasn't in a photo shoot, had any makeup on and the picture was taking whilst she was walking and it was windy and was from way before this was posted.

[@sugaudacity]

i hate how the other's visuals are slept on.. they're all so gorgeous

[@heyitsmeocha1274]

I know this video is not that deep, but if you want to make this kind of video, you should've use the pics with the same "vibe". JoyRi pics are from fansites and kpop fans knew fansites always white-washed the pics, seulrene pics are from magazine pictorial/k-media who don't really do white-washing, so yeah, it's normal for them to choose people who look "normal".

[@indigoblues8454]

Ah that's true

[@anahablado6722]

Yes I agree

[@junkyuseum]

He always chooses photos that are not exactly captured with the same quality. That's why this has not been as reliable as it should be.

[@frannyn8552]

PERIOD

[@MrAresxy07]

What do u expect he is white too and he doesn't really look too much into his research he just grabs whatever but this video is racist in a way

[@psy2612]

Joy got the lowest vote but if you let people watch their MV’s she’s definitely a stunner! ✨

[@mynameishope484]

yeah but for her body, she is hot.

[@sabrinachowaM05]

Not for her face...everyone just concentrate in her height and body...tbh

[@prive1382]

Her picture was the worst. Should've gotten more votes tbh, even though I think Irene would've still won. She's beautiful... and not just her body

[@alwiyaawi3358]

@@sabrinachowaM05 you must see her in real life. She's goddess

[@sabrinachowaM05]

@@alwiyaawi3358 my friend saw red velvet in real life ....she told me that everyone in red velvet is pretty..but irene's beauty is an another level...she just couldn't believe her eyes when she saw irene in real life...IRENE IS A VISUAL OF RED VELVET FOR A REASON U KNOW Everyone has their own choices on beauty....Its irene for me..🙂

[@theresahoang5401]

This comment is living for Joy and I love it

[@venicexx974]

To be honest, Seulgi is the one who caught my attention when I first watch their song Psycho ☺️😂

[@park-bw9hn]

"I like Irene because she looks tan" Girl- wait till you see her in other pictures/in person 😂

[@faisaatharaninugroho8550]

Omg this is what i was thinking lol 😂😂

[@-yourstruly9730]

Yeah, I saw her in Music Bank once (irl) and I was shook. She was so pale.

[@yarrowgreen1218]

As an American I don't get why other Americans value tan skin so much lol it doesn't even look that good.

[@park-bw9hn]

@@yarrowgreen1218 for me, it depends on the person with what type of skin tone suits their appearance the best. just as long as they're not blackfishing/whitefishing ❤️

[@cameronporras5921]

Seulgi is pretty and cool and chic and hot just everything she's a little bit of everything

[@maricieloromero3338]

seulmin

[@queendany592]

Maricielo Romero stop

[@jae4002]

@@maricieloromero3338 stop it. Get some help.

[@ohraiaj]

Maricielo Romero stfu

[@michellep3183]

And has an amazing figure too no cap

[@dwardybendana3089]

the man who chose joy and characterize her with bible... yeahh your definitely right sir!!!

[@mauixromero]

"wendy looks more innocent" wendy: yadong! yaseol! lmao 😂 but it's true that she has the purest heart in the group, she's like an angel that's why i really love her. 💙

[@lalalalalahappiness422]

HAHAHAHA Wendy Innocent 🤣👊

[@Mandice]

He should meet greasy Wendy.

[@hazardofficial]

*This is a popular band called Red Velve-* "Irene, Irenee, Irene by far" MOOD

[@_rosette]

“No need to look at everyone else! Irene.” “I think she’s pretty- and I’m gay.” A whole package indeed

[@yarrowgreen1218]

@Kyle Beltran are they really??

[@myathegrandma]

@@yarrowgreen1218 Nope they've only been a group for 6 years now. Apink has been a gg for 9 years now so RV is not the longest gg in the kpop industry. I think Brown Eyed Girls are.

[@nrftrhrmli2862]

Kyle Beltran noo ! Red velvet has only been 6 years since their debut. Only 1 year difference with Twice and 2 years with Blackpink. Brown eyed girl is the oldest 14 years since they debuted in 2006. And the 2nd one is SNSD, although they are hiatus for now but they are still not disbanded yet so they may be the 2nd oldest girl group which is for 13 years since they debuted in 2007. And there is still f (x) too, they debuted in 2009.

[@slaycgirlsitsgoingdown9800]

@Kyle Beltran Apink says hi

[@xoxo-kl8qr]

seulgi's cuteness overflows no matter what photo you use

[@erniealmelia8536]

I think there's something wrong lol joy is pretty I really admired her beauty. Her face and personality is really great you just should pick a picture that have a really great look like what you pick in Irene picture

[@fishcakesticks]

i know irene is the prettiest, but idk, my heart thumps for joy and seulgi. joy has this cute eye smile, and seulgi is too charmismatic yet cute at the same time

[@Irina-wm8jf]

"she' dirty, she's clean" -random NYC guy

[@chinnnzilla]

Totally went nuts with that guy 😂

[@_melala]

-this is red vel- first dudes: *iRENEEEEEEE*

[@khanh9751]

Okay Joy didn’t have a good photo but Yeri and Wendy are absolutely gorgeous in those photos. You guys are acting salty because they are underrated

[@kennymccormick7269]

Boy on the right: They all look the same bro" Boy on the left: "IRENE"

[@aloof3896]

joy, yeri, and wendy's visuals are so underrated... irene probably more tanned because her picture was a photoshoot and the others were just them literally outside. smhh... *my underrated babies*

[@chaeyeonwannieson9339]

galaxii i can say wendy is the most underrated member. Yeri has quite big fanbase actually. I can see most of the comments about her. My poor wendy.

[@cyndixx]

Siti Adilah she gets more hate than Wendy tho my poor yeri

[@masakitube]

Seulgi is the prettiest for me but Irene is also a goddess

[@1anfinity08]

Same

[@ugh1218]

Same

[@zoeychan5395]

yeahh Seulgi's beauty is underrated!

[@nabilanurussafitri4817]

@@zoeychan5395 underrated but populer, what if she's pretty? HHAHAA 

[@conibf9011]

Irene's mood: I'm original visual.

[@radiiish6033]

“I think she’s pretty. And I’m gay.” YO THIS IS INSANE LMAO 😂

[@heoldaebaksageon5688]

my favorite line *”Beauty is in the hidden heart of the woman instead of the outer adornment”*

[@moonstarmo3167]

IRENE, WENDY, SEULGI, JOY AND YERI!!!!!!!!!! RED VELVET

[@exosellie]

Same!❤

[@danyyy4203]

4:41 Thank you little old man for being the only one to pick my bias Joy 😀

[@soyoungredvelvet2368]

Best comment goes for Joy. Indeed, beauty can't be seen only on the outside. Stan Joy! Stan Red Velvet! ❤❤❤

[@sanchira138]

joy and yeri deserved better, if their bad boy concept pics were chosen everyone would pic them

[@jolin1369]

mhm or zimzalabim or peek a boo or even just the instagram pictures

[@heejiniemuah5117]

Agree! They are prettiest for me! Their photos here just different than real JoyRi

[@madzsuarez17]

Yeah he could have picked better ones or same concept and joy is the sexiest of them all. period.

[@megamaurizkafitri1965]

I know right!!

[@jonathanbadon9771]

Irene's Bad Boy photos were gorgeous tho.

[@notes5882]

I'll just say based off my own experience after seeing Red Velvet in person they are all pretty but I can confirm that no photo does Joy’s beauty justice, she is absolutely breathtakingly beautiful. Like legitimately, Joy is the most beautiful person I’ve ever seen in my life. And I've seen a lot of other people (including those who don't even bias her) say the same thing. Anyway Red Velvet are gorgeous.

[@eeyana7929]

You’re so luckyy

[@rgaha5676]

Yeah Joy is a little Sexy type of Beauty. She got height too.

[@klaire5720]

if she was prettiest, every photo would do justice.

[@brianmarvinn]

please do moreeeee i like this kind of content

[@nguyenmon7572]

MAMAMOO PLS Because I like all of them and I looking forward to you making video about them 🙆‍♀️

[@ladylove6552]

Seulgi isn't even fully smiling in that pic but the natural cuteness is just visible

[@lalalalayayaya1250]

kang seulgi is so gorgeous🔥🔥💛

[@HorribleHarry]

Joy then Seulgi or you’re blind everyone.

[@user-jg1wz6io7f]

Seulgi stands out for me the most she could slay any looks and is very unique and undeniably cutee 😌💗✨✨

[@Cookincrazy]

Had to stop watching because you’re wrong for choosing that pic of joy

[@ocktaviacristyarisuwandi2509]

seulgi just give a flat face in that photo but damn she still look so gorgeous yet cute. she is cute gorgeous pretty without force, so natural.. even she is the most cute and innocent among the member.. this is my opinion

[@parkjinyyyoung]

when the guy said “idk her, but i’ve seen her before” i mean she is in pretty much every cf 😂

[@Orblinkluv]

Loll you should do it again with some newer pictures of them! I'm curious how people will respond today.

[@nounayunus5439]

I like his comment to Joy.. not to her visual but inner beauty with quiet confidence

[@JoyismyQ]

Rachma Mocodompis me too... actually his comment is enough. I like how he described Joy’s beauty. I’m so touched for my Queen.

[@carmenreed1831]

That's are confident queen

[@GuitarGirl4ever]

The way they a lot of them chose Irene cuz she looked tanned from the lighting in the picture when in reality she's the palest one in the group lmao. It's crazy that people who don't know kpop know her face though. Love that.

[@ratinthehat_]

Wendy is the palest 😂

[@dylancole298]

Seulgi is more tanned

[@cuetzen712]

i think the pictures they used were unfair bc only irene and wendy? were professional pictures, while the rest were just casual pictures taken by fansite/reporters. joy was even the most unfortunate, bc while the rest were donned in makeup and pretty outfit/studio/complete edited/professional settings, hers was a fansite? picture taken on road on her way to schedule in jumper and coat💀.

[@reelea7475]

NO SHE IS NOT

[@notyou5995]

I know it was unfair but admit it, even if they used the same kind of picture like the others for Irene, she'll probably still get as much as votes as she did here. It won't really change anything.

[@ofeliaborlagdan8772]

J0Y is a total package. she has everything and I just love her voice, personality and beauty.

[@micaluvie4151]

"Is this one of those trick questions where every Asian girl is a man?" BRUH😂😂

[@queenie4859]

This dude didn't listen to other people's recommendations, he did the twice and blackpink video dirty by not picking the beautiful pictures for all members. You literally pick the worst photos for Joy, Yeri and Wendy

[@George-li1yv]

Its a good picture of Yeri imo

[@mynameishope484]

Joy, yeri and wendy look pretty tho

[@chaeyeonwannieson9339]

He just wanna look for irene fans i think. 😂 he’s being so biased in this video

[@moaxiv1010]

All pics were good your just insecure cause your bias is joy and she didnt win

[@ashiipots]

@@moaxiv1010 its not aboit that, she is just making a point about him just being unfair to some members cause he only got the best one fore irene while the other members' photos were only taken from fan pages while irene had the photoshoot pic

[@김태형46]

Girl crush Kang Seulgi , she's super talented 🔥🔥

[@bambvis]

He needed a better picture of Joy

[@hymn4048]

I love how the way xiaomoa speaks tho....😂 He's just as energetic as me 😍