At 78, David Gilmour FINALLY Confirms WHY Roger Waters DESTROYED Pink Floyd

[@bluemoon-20]

They did their best work together, collaborating. And to take sides regarding endless disagreements is a waste of time. Any Pink Floyd fan will agree it's a sad ending to one of the great bands in music history.

[@floydiandreamscapes5145]

@@bluemoon-20 it was when I first learned they had broken up, still is. Even sadder is the death of Rick and Syd.

[@davemarriott]

Pink Floyd's greatest work was done when they were all together. I'm not going down the finger pointing path it's pointless.

[@bluemoon-20]

Good observation. The fact is they did their best work together, collaborating. And to take sides regarding endless disagreements is a waste of time. A sad ending to one of the greatest bands in music history.

[@HugoRJ]

@@davemarriott of course, absolutely true what you say, but... collaborating together with the brilliant leadership of Waters... recognised by all they except Rick

[@johncunningham4820]

@@HugoRJ. It's the " Collaboration " that Roger Waters disputes . As far as he's concerned , it was all HIM . And quite frankly , Rick was more ESSENTIAL to their Sound than Roger was .

[@PaulFormentos]

That damn YOKO.....

[@josiplilic3384]

Maybe Roger was jerk back then,but calling him an antisemite was the worst thing Dave's ever done publicly! It happened recently! My all time favorite band😢😢

[@MarkRoss-v4y]

Surprisingly little mention of his musical/personal relationship with Rick Wright, which seemed fundamental in Pink Floyd. RIP Rick 💗

[@vasylhorodetskyy8876]

Agree brother Rick was brains of Pink Floyd and amazing human being unlike Waters

[@theibault]

They kicked him out of the band, and then brought him back on as a hired hand. Those two giant egos clearly don't realize how much of an impact Rick had to the Pink Floyd sound. And Nick is just lukewarm water.

[@kenhoward3512]

Pink Floyd wasn't necessarily "destroyed" when Roger Waters left, but they certainly lost their brilliant lyricist who gave their songs such timeless depth and biting sarcasm.

[@AnthonyMichaelAMguitar]

and waters wrote 80% of the music

[@telestratblues]

@@AnthonyMichaelAMguitar I have 4 Pink Floyd albums. All 4 have lyrics written by Roger Waters. I preferred David Gilmour's singing. I miss that band.

[@KimBioni]

Exactly, i mean, division bell still sounds like pink floyd (musically), but in terms of lyrics, is not comparable to roger waters's era

[@alistairmcintyre]

@@telestratblues Fortunately, most of the music and the vocals come from Gilmour and Wright.

[@vasylhorodetskyy8876]

Waters should have stayed in music and not tell other people how to live he lost it and it is getting worse the older he gets. I'm not taking away his contribution to early Pink Floyd but I personally hate stuck up people and Waters is an example of that

[@sharonrichards1627]

David and Roger clashed in the studio but onstage they meshed heavenly.

[@metricdeep8856]

Waters and Gilmour would almost certainly be nothing without each other. If they had to start from scratch knowing what they could become....I wonder how they would proceed.

[@FinalBoys1982]

This ☺️☝️

[@firestarter000001]

True, but i also am not sure if they would reach their heights without Syd Barrett, imho his spark ignited the talents of the whole band. I think its a common misconception, looking at poeple who achieved much, and having an image they were great from start. We will never know how many poeple were critical for these persons to develop.

[@acmejia]

21:19 I just went to his concert in Rome 10 days ago (Oct 2, 2024). He played Wish You Were Here and Comfortably Numb and Time. And it was magical.

[@alistairmcintyre]

Poor you.

[@DexterHaven]

Did he play "Have a Cigar," one of my faves?

[@eric6cartman9]

@@DexterHaven no :/ I saw his last show of the tour (last night at MSG) it was the best concert ive ever seen tho, I got a little emotional in realizing this may be the last time ill ever hear these beautiful songs live

[@RussellCalvert-d8q]

I' am not interested in the disputes and bitching at each other, I listen to PINK FLOYD and simply marvel the lyrics, the outstanding guitar playing, the fantastic drums, along with amazing sound effects, as well as the phenomenal show this band provides. Concentrate on that people instead of bloody finger pointing, these guys are fantastic musicians and that should be respected.

[@DexterHaven]

Yeah, what he said. Have a cigar.

[@christopherparsons3224]

I will use your testimony to make a point about BOTH of them. They would quibble over how Nick should play the drums for a certain part of a song, and ultimately it was things like this which led to their breakup. Imagine if they just let Nick, who is the expert on the drums, decide how he thought the drums should be played and they left it at that? My understanding is that the differences would be so small that you'd probably not notice them, unless someone pointed them out on recordings with the slight differences they were fighting over. When I thought about how insulting this would've been to Nick, I realized that BOTH of them were lucky to be working with two other guys in Nick and Richard, who were obviously more about the music and the band, and less about themselves. Truthfully, I hope they both apologized to their bandmates while they still had a chance. I think that in the end it became a fight about ego, control, and ultimately money. It is sad considering those 3 things tend to ruin most good things. Thanks for your post.

[@DexterHaven]

@@christopherparsons3224 Paul would tell Ringo how to play the drums too, despite how good Ringo was. So what. It shows they care about their vision for the song as writers. It's called passion, while you navel gaze about "how insulting" is was. Bosh! Buhu.

[@christopherparsons3224]

​@@DexterHaven, it is painfully obvious that some people don't know what respect is.

[@DexterHaven]

@@christopherparsons3224 And who might those people be in your haughty opinion, Mr. Word Mincer?

[@saeedmir7999]

waters is one of the greatest songwriters of our time and gilmour is one of a greatest guitar player...

[@murilohumbertocmcb]

Waters is the main composer. The foundation of PF's sound. OF COURSE the others have a giant part on the sound, but the composer is the composer.

[@chrishall2090]

Not much news here.

[@pedrognrd]

After watching the video I found nothing related to with the title. It it seems that this channel is all like that.

[@punker-gamer-trucker-guy]

Blue thanks for telling me. I won't waste any more of my time

[@muffdvr5396]

@@punker-gamer-trucker-guy 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@lancetaylor1334]

Ego and pride are a mountain with an empty pit on either side: only humility and acceptance bring the light needed for stable footing and safe paths.

[@larbueno]

Nice...

[@ericajohnson7535]

great band, great singer, great guitarist, great visionary songwriter... they worked so well together. Individually they could not have achieved the same success.

[@Road_Rash]

Some people are difficult to replace, but nobody is irreplaceable...

[@DexterHaven]

Said the guy who replaced Paul McCartney after he 'died'.

[@Road_Rash]

@@DexterHaven yeah, right... keep believing rumors...🙄🙄🙄

[@DexterHaven]

16:21 video starts here, after the usual windy intro.

[@ZachAttack313]

Pink Floyd will always be my favorite band. But I have to admit it makes me feel slightly sad and disappointed that David and Roger resent each other so much

[@DexterHaven]

Roger can't stand a partner, it seems. He has to be the top dog.

[@gregoznowich5196]

So sad. Two giants not realizing that their mutual heights helped to grow us all.

[@rswpt]

polly samson ended pink floyd, thats it, some people actually call her polly yoko ono samson, go figure why.

[@angusgow1887]

Any surprise she has been stirring the pot in the back round

[@krikeyitstimeforcricket967]

Don’t like her one bit.

[@md4933]

She never "Ended" floyd, she wasn't even around gilmour in 1985. Stick to the facts please..

[@andreichivu7653]

Boring..far-left words like antisemitic,mysoginistic etc...are boring people already

[@TbsDltn]

The Division Belle....PS

[@AKICITA]

Without ROGER, it will NEVER be Floyd! ALL parts must be present, just like Led Zep, or Sabbath!

[@juliosanchez8263]

I never knew that when Dave Gilmour was young he looked like the Karate Kid

[@acmejia]

Totally

[@RobDTom]

Yeah that was weird

[@patrickmohan2220]

He did unfortunately, yeah. He never had a minute's peace as a teenager. Mr. Miyagi was always hanging around trying to make him paint the fence and wax the floor. That would go on until the 80's when Dave lost his boyish good looks, and Miyagi started on Ralph Macchio.

[@alexanderarmitage6834]

@@juliosanchez8263 Gilmour was a male model back in the day before he joined Floyd.

[@HighlanderNorth1]

You seem a bit confused, so let me explain... You see, "Dave Gilmour" wasn't his real name. He adopted that name once he joined Pink Floyd because it sounded cooler and more "hip" than his birth name, which was obviously "Ralph Macchio"...🙃

[@louissaraiva2296]

I wish David , Roger could get along . Nick gets along with both . Still have hope

[@Dreamstreetdiecast]

I saw David at MSG for the Luck and Strange tour. Not only did he play Time and Great Gig in the Sky, but he also played Wish You Were Here and then Comfortably Numb for the grand finale. It was an amazing show.

[@Star-qc4br]

Dave and Roger are to Floyd what Paul and John were to the Beatles. One is a musical and instrumental wizard while the other in a content and lyrical artist. They compliment each other and when combined, ICONIC music, TIMELESS art and a LEGENDARY band is the result! They NEED each other...even if there's nothing but hate left between them. A bit pointless now. There can NEVER be a true Pink Floyd "reunion". THAT ship sailed a long time ago when the INCOMPARABLE Rick Wright sadly passed away.

[@Vince-lq3ve]

Or Tony Banks and Peter Gabriel. Gabriel a brilliant lyricist, Tony the basis of the majority of old and post Gabriel Genesis music. Luckily, Phil was the replacement, not that he was Gabriel, but he was massively talented in his own way.

[@Star-qc4br]

@@Vince-lq3ve VERY TRUE!

[@TbsDltn]

....and Syd Barrett was the Piper at the Gates of Dawn🎷🎷

[@andygookey]

I think this was confirmed when David was more like 38. Do keep up with the news... Last I heard, he's fed up with people asking the same boring old questions they've been asking the 40 odd years.

[@crazylikeafox1000]

Some things you just don’t need to know. I can never listen to Gilmour the same ever again. 😔

[@derekroberts6654]

“Flowers and Bullet” …. “Guns and Roses”😂😂😂 I’m sorry that just popped in my head when I heard that…

[@ALTERNATIVEMIXTAPES]

Gilmour and his wife have been overly cruel to Roger Waters over the years. The past is the past but Gilmour and Poly just won’t let it go and they continue to attack Roger to this day.

[@DexterHaven]

Naw, Waters was the instigator of trouble, stamping his feet like a child and trying to stop other band members from continuing the group in court was low. He wasted all that time & money on a losing cause too. Screw him. He's a fathead.

[@sharonhaywood2818]

WE LOVE YOU DAVID GILMOUR 🎸💕🎸🎸

[@5.2litrecat45]

Perhaps it would be a different picture being painted if the interview also included Roger, Nick and Richard.

[@badbulgarian1]

Roger Waters has a soul, that's why he "DESTROYED" the band!

[@cristiancrucianelli2343]

Politiclaly, always with Roger Waters for ever!!!

[@ericbitzer5247]

Absolutely! That's what the definition of politically correct should mean!

[@itsourlife]

Agreed

[@markb3786]

His support of "peace" means the destruction of Ukraine and its 1000-year-old culture that gave birth to Russia. He is on the wrong side of history.

[@miguelporras8366]

Great, so you endorse assasins like Maduro and Fidel😂

[@guilhermebahia6050]

Lmao ​@@ericbitzer5247

[@AlexPavlovic]

To have your wife and then yourself try and cancel Roger on social media is beyond despicable. That tells me more about David than I ever wanted to know.

[@floydiandreamscapes5145]

I agree. It's very disappointing to learn one of your rock hero's has jumped on the censorship bandwagon. You may not like what someone says, but you have no right to try to silence them.

[@patthewoodboy]

@@floydiandreamscapes5145 check out Gilmours son and how he behaves .

[@AKICITA]

I haven't listened to ANYTHING post Roger! I tried, but it is NOT Floyd... a decent band among a great many decent bands, but certainly NOT in the same realm as the Almighty Floyd!

[@dayuhanspace]

​@@patthewoodboyRoger was known to be antisemite and keeps bullying band members

[@ALTERNATIVEMIXTAPES]

David needs to get over his bitterness of the past and move on.

[@liquidSpin]

I could care less about Roger Waters. Pink Floyd with David Gilmore is perfection

[@BarbarraBay]

Roger wrote those classic lyrics. PF would have been nothing much without him. regardless, PF are boring, which is why you are probably obsessed with them

[@Zigmeister67]

Yeah so many hits. Hahaha

[@jetteroheller]

I think what Dave did for Roger was, with Rick’s help of course, translated Roger’s emotions to music. He did it based on actually a real sensitivity and familiarity with the man. That’s a pretty hard thing to do human-to-human for the best of us. Roger’s complete failure to acknowledge that is the issue. I don’t know what more you can ask for from Dave.

[@minervavila8235]

I went to his concert in MSG on November 4th . Believe me, IT WAS ONE OF THE BEST DAYS OF MY LIFE! Brilliant incredible music . He played time, and I wish you were here, but the moment, the most magical moment at the end when David masters HIS SOLO with Comfortably Numb made the entire venue explode. Every soul present deeply moved , and I moved to tears. Waters was not there. No one missed him.

[@ColinJohnston-i9e]

Dave Gilmour is god and dont forget it

[@thomasmazur6916]

From the Wall on their music sounded depressed.

[@DexterHaven]

The last song they did that I really liked was "Have a Cigar."

[@marksargent2440]

A clash of egos

[@bryandraughn9830]

Waters . "You're not Pink Floyd without me!" Gilmore. Sells out 10 world tours as Pink Floyd.

[@PhilCar-mi7zr]

I think roger would be hard work, he's very opinionated

[@jeremywanner4526]

He’s an only child,I think that had alot to do with it,he doesn’t play well with others

[@PhilCar-mi7zr]

@@jeremywanner4526 haha yeah, what he says goes

[@ukkfayooyay]

Polly had no business blowing up Waters publicly. And I am no fan of Waters.

[@PhilTheProf]

If he shows disrespect then he deserves it back.

[@pink_kino]

fr

[@jpr3665]

David is a rock God and will be revered by generations to come Also humble and civilised Roger immensely talented has an unhealthy ego and sadly is not a happy chappy

[@krikeyitstimeforcricket967]

I’m a huge fan of the original band and love Gilmours guitar playing since i was a little kid. It’s what inspired me to play guitar. I don’t care much for Polly. Sadly David has been silent on some major global issues and that is a major disappointment. Waters has a point of view and he’s not scared to lay down, no matter what the consequences. For that he will always have my deepest respect. Hope they all go well. 🙏🏼

[@miguelporras8366]

Yes, Waters is not scared of taking Maduro's and Fidel's blood money in spite of all the atrocities, bloodshed and misery they have brought to Venezuela, Cuba and the whole America (the continent). Guy is a monster artist but a fucking hypocrit Speaking as a Venezuelan who actually lives in Venezuela, by the way

[@koszim]

If you want to know what truly happened just search who was the band member who didn't respect at all Richard Wright. Rick was a gentleman, a great person with very good character and stunning offer to the sound of the band. That's how it all started...

[@Davidlcorzine]

It’s crazy how many comments feed into Waters overly infrated ego. Syd was the creator of Pink Floyd’s identity, Gilmour’s solos in comfortably numb and Shine on and Time and Money and Wish You Were Here are considered greatest of all time solos, Wright’s keys in Great Gig, Us and Them and Echoes are some of my favorite of all time. Waters has downplayed all of them. He was the luckiest lyricist of all time, he didn’t have to create an identity or create band chemistry with incredibly musicians. Instead, he already had it and destroyed it.

[@koszim]

@Davidlcorzine I agree 100% with you. And all these great songs you post here are my favorite songs from PF as well. And not Roger Waters songs at all...

[@josephabela1922]

Roger fired Rick, and bad mouth him. David re- instead him for the momentarily laps of reason Album till his passing.

[@LiliaSammer78]

THANKS FOR EVERYONE, to be part of the history - ALL IS SAID !

[@ThomasOldenburg-h8c]

Nothing ever lasts forever, I’m glad to have enjoyed this band in their best!

[@stevew6910]

Two alphas with creative differences, Hard to maintain a band that way

[@DexterHaven]

Lennon led the Beatles as a boss, as Billy Preston confirmed on KZbin. Paul grew older and got very good. Someone asked John why the band broke up, and John said, "I couldn't control them any more."

[@johnandrewmayne]

I went to a Hollywood bowl show last week, he played the Floyd greats ending the show, after a 10 min ovation, with an 11 minute version of comfortably numb.

[@johncunningham4820]

When one mans ego " Shits in the Nest " .

[@jeff0247598]

The rift and bitterness between Waters and Gilmour is frustrating but WTF does Polly Samnson have to do with any of this. I've never read any of her books, she may be a fantastic novelist, I don't know. As a lifelong Pink Floyd fan, I don't feel like Polly Samson's name should be significantly credited with anything Pink Floyd, even if she wrote lyrics for later albums. I haven't enjoyed new PF music since the Division Bell. IMHO Polly Samson's inovolvement in Pink Floyd is only because of one reason.....she shares a bed with David Gilmour. Fight me.

[@ianbower827]

Not to mention her son, Charlie.

[@winstonsmith8240]

When egos collide.

[@jcg9998]

Gilmour is a better guy than Waters but he is in the wrong. He was not even an original member. Geniuses often are a-holes and it goes with the territory. Gilmour, Mason and Wright were lazy and Waters was very motivated. These guys needed to accept Waters for what he was because they were nothing without him. Waters needed them as well but he was the glue.

[@HugoRJ]

@@jcg9998 Absolutely true!!! 👏👏👏

[@Mick-h7i]

Yes Waters and Sid has always been my favourite..Just something about Gilmour, I’ve just never taken to him at all..

[@jampin09]

Waters was and is a useless total dick of a human being.

[@jampin09]

Says all you need to say about Waters that Wright, when he was alive, and Mason, both prefer work8ng with gilmour.

[@jcg9998]

@@jampin09 No doubt but that isn't any different than saying lazy employees like working for bosses who let them sit around and do nothing. Go look at the history of 'The Wall'. Waters was working his a$$ off to get the album done to get a bonus while his bandmates were moving like molasses.

[@lennypersonalized]

who the f is Pete Townschhend?

[@PaulFormentos]

A good friend of the late Keith Mourn

[@Tapp-Mourningwood]

German cousin? 🤷‍♂️

[@jeremywanner4526]

Pedo

[@capecyn]

It made me think it was an automated reader

[@OfAngels444]

That one dude who tried to play guitar on stage with the Dead and ended up just making a fool of himself

[@youfilin]

Love Animals! Love Dogs! Love both of them Dav and Rog!

[@driesanalog4187]

Roger's solo albums "Amused to death" and "The pros and cons of hitch hiking" are best examples of his genius. I don't see that with David.

[@timwheeler8523]

Both truly great albums. Amused is up there with DSOTM and Animals (imho).

[@alistairmcintyre]

They are so dire that even Waters seems to have forgotten them both and prefers to tour these days by flogging DSOTM and The Wall to death.

[@carlosbanales5816]

@@alistairmcintyre they sound more like PF than whatever Gilmour has done.

[@mickeydoodle69]

“Flowers and bullet” sounds like a folk Pink Floyd tribute.

[@hooligan_56labelle22]

I have continued to listen to pink floyd for the musicianship. The lyrics come to me after repeated listening. A group that plays tight together. Beautiful beats and notes

[@Paner835]

To any re-union or revival of the old collosal bands and group I always say : 'Things happen on their time. We should live by the moment and not have nostalgia trip us'. Pink Floyd was one of the greatest bands but their time is over now. They will forever live with their epic music, we do not have to scratch wounds just because we all want to be younger again.

[@nickbarton3191]

Meanwhile... I caught Nick Mason's "Saucer" tour, it was wonderful.

[@srthellcathemi3037]

I don't see Roger Waters destroying Pink Floyd, rather, I see Waters stepping aside and allowing Gilmour to work his magic, and thats when the 2 albums I like were formed, A Momentary Lapse of Reason and Division Bell. Thanks Waters for making the Decision

[@marcocatano]

As abrasive as Roger may seem, he is on the right side of history, both regarding Pink Floyd and politics. Gilmour and his wife have shown themselves to be despicable. I stand with Roger. Always.

[@W4rriorOfLight]

sure.... on the right side, LOL

[@deedubs602]

I’m sorry but Waters quit the band, went as far as putting it to paper. There’s some actions that you don’t come back from. You can’t complain about them not letting you use the website when it was you who thought the band couldn’t go on since you weren’t going to be in it and did everything in your power to make sure it didn’t.

[@Star-qc4br]

AGREED!!!

[@Greg-cq8wg]

Bravo!

[@frankmatassa5228]

You're appsolutly right Waters needs to grow up besides Syd Barrett came up with the name not Waters

[@ninehundreddollarluxuryyac5958]

Meddle, Echoes, Atom Heart Mother were awesome. I was disappointed in the darker lyrics and screaming on The Wall, and Final Cut was really awful. Pulse was brilliant and David's newer music is nice as well.

[@MikeBodo]

Roger's problem is he thought he could assume leadership of the band once Syd was no longer able to function, as he was arguably second in command. Problem was he wasn't an accomplished musician at the time, let alone songwriter, which made David the obvious choice for musical direction. The bands first two albums without Syd were jumbled messes, but you heard glimpses of what they eventually would become soon after. To Rogers credit, he made himself into a great lyricist and composer and came up with material that complemented Gilmours. On the rare moments the two could put their egos and creative differences aside, they made absolute magic together. Unfortunately, it was never enough for either. There was always this push/pull between them with each feeling they knew what was best for a partricular song or album. That friction produced some absolute brilliant material, but it also led to the bands ultimate demise. If the two of them could have worked more in tandem as Lennon/McCartney, Plant/Page, Townsend/Daltry and John/Taupin did they would have been unstoppable. They were always better together than they were apart, but they were too damn stubborn and prideful to put their differences aside for the greater good of the band.

[@AllenPortman]

Such a shame people allow actually the pettiness's of life to divide and destroy what "could have been"! Life passes so quickly and in then end none of this stuff really will mean anything!

[@bhxxbtx]

This is just a puff piece on Gilmour. I love both Waters era and post Waters Floyd. But this is really all about Gilmour.

[@johncarter-zd1wq]

Waters skill with lyrics and Gilmores interpretation of those lyrics was a combination made in heaven. It's one of the greatest losses to modern music that they could not work together. There is not enough said about the influences provided by Wright on keyboards and Mason on drums.

[@TbsDltn]

no Anthony Phillips no Genesis prog rock band...

[@marcusmattau7334]

I do like Roger Waters and criticism against him is unfair. However, without David Gilmore's talent and expertise there would not have been a successful Pink Floyd. Most of the hit songs were performed by Gilmore even to the bass instrument. Gilmore was under appreciated by Waters.

[@AKICITA]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@payambehtash7124]

each member could pursue his own dreams yet remain dedicated to the brand. they killed a brand for their ego

[@alexanderarmitage6834]

Really, has Gilmour have anything else to do except bitch about Waters. It's a 30 year old dead horse he keeps flogging. Move on already. Apparently Waters has.

[@foreverpinkf.7603]

Pink Floyd was at its best with Waters, Gilmour and Wright. Gilmour wrote nice tunes, but the best lyrics came from Waters. Polly Samson finally sounded the death knell for Pink Floyd.

[@jtmcnasty]

Rumor has it 😉 a movie is in the works with Nolan attached

[@jonathanmarkbotterell1926]

The two have kept the Pink Floyd name in the press and musical world. They have always protected the Brand. All the key arguments are about who owns the brand, fighting like two children over who contributed more to its success. Haven't they got enough. Have you ever heard someone with nothing, complaining. No......because they would be thankful for anything. Peace, love and understanding😎☯️🌱

[@Dr.Dark1331]

As awesome as a lead guitar player & vocalist as Gilmour is, Roger Waters is the one who took the broken reigns from Syd when Syd got too ill to carry on and became Pink Floyds best song writer and without him Gilmour, Wright & Mason most likely would not had became the stars they did as just because you are a great guitarist,keyboardist or drummer doesnt make you successful as nobody eants to hear just your talent on your instrument they want great songs and that requires a song writer and Waters was a great song writer, better than Syd in my opinion but none the less Gilmour is awesome but Roger Waters ruined absolutely nothing as he is the one that saved the sinking ship of Pink Floyd once Syd could not be its main song writer anymore, so where I like Gilmour And Waters and respect both, Waters is & will always be Pink Floyd to me, as he has had no problem finding great guitar players who can match Gilmour on his solo work like Snowy White, Jeff Beck and Eric Clapton while Gilmour can write great songs they are one great song per 8 filler songs where Waters wrote very few fillers in my opinion, In my mind I could replace Gilmour with another great guitarist, not that i would want to, but can not think of anyone to ever replace Waters as he is Pink Floyd, "By the way Which One is Pink" I have always thought Roger is Pink and Syd & Gilmour are secondary

[@savagecutts]

Gilmour looked a lot like Ralph Macchio when he was a young man

[@kennethcarter5720]

Just a rehash of others material

[@unicorn-ge7kf]

I just went to see David at the Hollywood bowl, he sang two songs from the dark side of the moon, wish you were here, high hopes, and comfortably numb and others and new songs. I wish however, the wives would stay away from personal feuds between band mates. Beatles dejavu.

[@Justin-td4bb]

the Division Bell proves that Waters ego is greater than his input into PF.

[@johnrees6290]

Roger Waters IS Pink Floyd. David Gilmore is a replacement guitarist.

[@alistairmcintyre]

Hmmm, Guitarist, Vocalist, Songwriter, and Bass player for when Waters couldn't be bothered.

[@DarinW-gx3mm]

@@alistairmcintyreOh yawn with that bass nonsense.

[@ricardosousa7150]

Polly is correct. Not everyone is blind.

[@mbrontiu]

It's all about money. This is a common story among every band in history who got rid someone who helped found the band. Just like KiSS, Iron Maiden, Motley Crue, Guns 'n Roses, Megadeth, Metallica and so many more. But Gilmore is Pink Floyd now. Not waters. Waters is just jealous of the bands success without him, because he thought Pink Floyd was his baby. But too bad, so sad. He abandoned his baby. So Gilmore adopted the band and became the new father of the band. In doing so he and the other band members have got rich and famous. So Waters just became a side note now. So now, even though Waters hasn't contributed a thing to the band's success since the mid 80s. Now Waters wants a piece of that action after almost 40yrs. It's the same old story. Greed, Envy and jealousy.

[@jms7726]

I turned on Ukraine when they put Roger waters on a "kill list"... what a great show!

[@lilBugger35]

I love them both but I would stand with Roger Waters.

[@Ron-x9q1w]

Ah! The real reason! left and right! can never get along!

[@gary_dabbah]

The two of them are relics of the past, making money of their iconic music of the 70's. Who listen to their solo new music?

[@peterbustin2683]

3:49 Guitar at bottom left is an extremely rare Vox guitar-organ.

[@unclebob1959]

Nick described the band as four drunks fighting over the steering wheel. They are all to blame!

[@alexanderarmitage6834]

except for the fact 3 of them became coke heads which they all admitted to.

[@Tiemen.M]

21:12 You might've used the wrong examples here, 'Comfortably Numb' and 'Wish You Were Here' are on the setlist of the Luck & Strange Tour.

[@acmejia]

Thank you for pointing that out. This video released a day ago obvs. didn't look at the set list.

[@Tiemen.M]

​@@acmejia Ahhh understandable! I knew because Comfortably Numb was used in the online promotion of the tour, and he confirmed the setlist during the rehearsal shows in Brighton a bit earlier. :)

[@cactuspharmer]

Such a shame that the band that gave us Live from Pompeii ended up like this.

[@carlosbanales5816]

People like to downplay Roger's importance as just being a lyricist and that's where all of those people are dead wrong. He was never a vocalist, nor guitar player but he sure is a composer. Like it or not (or continue to be ignorant) that's a BIG difference. Fancy solos are fantastic David is a monster in doing that but that was actually his job. AND whether you want to accept it or not, once Roger left floyd, that's when a statement was made. What did David and Mason do after? They release 2 albums. Yes, only 2 albums, one that doesnt sound like anything PF and the other with some great songs but that was IT! Gilmour carried over with the success of the name of the band on his back and capitalize with it when going solo.

[@jameswillard-brown6697]

Waters was right and this proves it.

[@sharonhaywood2818]

If Rodger is doing his world tours then why did he leave a band in 1985.

[@sharonrichards1627]

They sure jumped over Ginger in a hurry. Who put this video together, Polly?

[@brightlightwitch3211]

There's no inch in my heart with doubt that Samson is behind Gilmour's media accounts. Roger is wrong about David believing he is PF, Polly actually believes she is. I see her as PF's Yoko Ono.

[@doggosandfriends5500]

Spot on, I despise the woman. If she wasnt around since the 90s they would have reunited at latest after live aid Im sure.

[@williammcdowell3718]

There is Pink Floyd ltd, and Roger Waters ltd, Roger is no longer in Pink Floyd. They had a long legal battle.

[@fernandinand]

So, Gilmour is a thief...

[@olivermeier2949]

One without the other doesn't work, neither of their solo efforts comes close

[@heavymetal6910]

Momentary lapse of reason was a dreadful album, lack of Roger was painful to hear

[@alistairmcintyre]

Lack of Roger's singing was a blessing.

[@pink_kino]

I listened to it on CD and is it just me but the original album is horribly mixed? Like I could barely hear it sometimes. The Remix is DEFINITELY a better listening experience

[@pink_kino]

@@alistairmcintyre Roger's singing is great actually

[@AliensAnonymous]

PF was buried when Rick died