Atom - The Great Gig in the Sky

The Great Gig in the Sky, ao vivo no Cine Theatro Brasil Vallourec. 25/11/2015
Performance de Viviane Donner
Direção Executiva: Helio Guimarães
Produção Artística: Lucas Nordo
Produção Musical: Pedro Estrela
Áudio:
Captação: Mix2Go
Mixagem: Renato Cipriano
Masterização: Maurício Gargel
Video: Produtora Hard
Direção: Gustavo Vargas e Rafael Avancini
Operadores de Câmera: Gustavo Vargas, Philipp Norman, Rafael Avancini, Sabrina Duarte e Victor Amenda.
Operador de Grua: Rod Caiu
Edição e Finalização: Rod Cahui
Show Cine Theatro Brasil
Produção Executiva: Rafael Piazzi
Direção Técnica: Diego Soares

[@GISAVT1]

This woman is absolutely amazing. She can do this solo live and give it a twist without ever compromising the original one. I love it!!

[@underthebluetakemein.]

I concur, fantastic performance !!!

[@sandracrespo5059]

I've heard the original at least 100 times and I could have sworn this was her singing. Awesome!!!

[@daletessier9926]

Wow

[@Totaro17]

@@sandracrespo5059 you haven’t listened enough.

[@Totaro17]

As much of Floyd purest as I am, she did amazing. And not really much of a twist. She kept it true.

[@gabotdf]

It takes some serious balls to even attempt this legendary song. Respect!

[@yat3700]

Well said 😁😁😁

[@tiagocardoso1237]

You know it! That’s a trust that you felt a lot in this life at least … sound of a life at the most true experience 😌

[@user-nd7on3pl6b]

Энергия! Слезы и сопли в 4 ручья

[@l1u1c1k]

You know nothing

[@timhoovermusicman]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/gp6zp6yqm7WVr9Esi=bPzRgtVqUi8lJfOH

[@dave1728]

in 40 years, I haven't heard anyone that could replicate this vocal...TILL NOW!

[@64fairlane305]

she`s good but does not replicate: kzbin.info/www/bejne/rIXJiJiviJJgedU

[@brandonmcheyenehoward1077]

I’ve never heard this version .. holy moly .. her voice is just perfect for this

[@peapod9999]

One of my absolute Pink Floyd favorites!! I NEVER thought that voice could be re-created. I was wrong. This is hands down one of the best band tributes I have ever heard. thank you Atom and that backup band!

[@panblue43]

Hi! Absolutely great.. But my favourite version in the moment is on Roger Waters - Us and Them album. Awesome, dynamic, brilliant. Best regards.

[@djonatanmatheus3077]

Que orgulho saber que são brasileiros

[@racer2c]

Huh? Not much of a PF fan. I'll help you; Sam Brown, Durga McBroom and Claudia Fontaine. You're welcome.

[@volkerfunke7705]

Her voice is absolutly perfect.

[@sylviewander7644]

Fantastique🤗 grandiose🤗 exceptionnelle .🤗.J'adore 🤗Une voix qui donne la chair de poule 😃jadore j'écoute en boucle 💕et la musique sensationnel .

[@joeking433]

This song always gives me chills. Sounds like all the horror and pain in someone's life coming out in one song.

[@Leesie924]

You nailed it. Intense grief for me. Good one, Joe.

[@franksaieva4952014]

And it is so. RIP Syd Barret

[@Leesie924]

CPTSD

[@danielcifuentes7198]

Feelings expressed thru voice.

[@antiurbanizm]

'i am an intense, complicated being, how can i not be?'

[@davidhines4880]

Late to the party as usual. This kid is KILLING it. I've seen this tune performed live three times. Twice by Waters, once by a cover band. This young lady kills it. Best cover, hands down.

[@clarkadams895]

Never too late just hearing this for the first time myself. I heard the original live and never heard it done so well since. \m/

[@andrew13758]

I am speechless, this singer has it all: technique, passion, balance, soul, no overdoing, simply heart ripping: bless you madame!!

[@spacepotato2277]

I'm kind of surprised anyone would even try this... but she/they absolutely nailed it. Wow.

[@Paul_Halicki]

No they didn't. There's something too busy about it.

[@Paul_Halicki]

@Azrael Hex Sorry, didn't do it justice at all.

[@Paul_Halicki]

@Azrael Hex You have your right to your opinion. I have the right to disagree. This is terrible, in my opinion.

[@lola.lola1147]

Truth

[@evan-qq1ku]

@@Paul_Halicki as a musician i can clearly see how you know nothing about it

[@Imhalfamazing]

I was scared to listen to this, I'm sure everybody else was getting ready to be dissapointed. Holy shit she killed it.

[@AndreaMartinez-jm4lh]

Yesss

[@YTatheist]

meh....

[@Anduth69]

Amen to that brother!!!!!

[@Martin-qd9ok]

Ya, me too... the world is still on it's axis...but Clare's still Queen...

[@rfly9530]

She's carrying a torch, too...x

[@billpo]

Man…did she ever do this justice…respect

[@jamesfulton8619]

She absolutely nailed it

[@eileenheitman4351]

Goose bumps. Almost tears. This is emotional stuff. Magnificent. I’m 71. Listened to Pink Floyd for a long time. This lady is GREAT. Dave Heitman

[@stvbrsn]

I had tears. Twice.

[@tomschneider4870]

Yea, Copy that. Nothing else I can say at this point.

[@coconuut8718]

I agree. This was so well put I had to cry a little

[@TheTarkus10]

Dave's not here :)

[@MTSElectrical1200]

Same feeling, I was transported back to my youth👌

[@TheMcKeand]

Few people alive do this song justice, she is one of the rare few.

[@donnerviviane]

Thanks! I feel really happy to hear that. Indeed, it is difficult to perform this song!

[@TheMcKeand]

It definitely looks hard, the power and passion you put into is amazing, and I got a reply from you 🙏 thank you.

[@andrewrobins4143]

@@donnerviviane Well done indeed - few renditions can have me tear up like this, thank you so much :) And I was trawling for all Sam Brown's works - good job!

[@tonysmith7034]

@@donnerviviane i totally agree with big Mac. I can't stop playing the video. Very professional. Would love to see you guys tour down under in Australia, when everything calms down. That would be awesome. Love your work. 👌👌👌take care

[@johndodge8999]

Viviane Donner you are definitely one of the best ever. Subscribed to your channel!

[@youraccount7003]

Having heard this song thousands of times over the last fifty plus years, I can honestly say that this is so close to the original and incredibly well performed by an exceptional vocalist. Thank you.

[@TwoUpTourer]

Didn't think it was possible to re-create this, but they did, to perfection, magnificent!

[@dodgydave1564]

57 years old...i still cry when i hear this

[@MultiCappie]

Then you're sorta missing the point, aren't you? Hahaha.

[@marclasserve5686]

Me too ! so beautiful, so light, so....

[@chickenlampbrent]

Yeah man. Can't stop it. I usually need a minute to come back to myself afterwards.

[@siriusjiones]

Me too....

[@Ardass486]

Gives me a hard on.

[@markthemay8210]

This is the classical music league. In 300 years, we will still listen to it, along with Mozart.

[@bleepbleep1961]

"we will still listen to it" ...... THAT would be "they" as opposed to "we" .... as in "Us" as opposed to "THEM" ..... LOL , LOL . !!! tee hee !

[@johansterk354]

I have no doubt!!

[@turk_dogan]

But not katy perry🙂

[@valedictorianism]

Maybe he believes in reincarnation, @@bleepbleep1961. I do :-P

[@Mrjohnboyd1959]

So very well said...thank you.

[@Xenthorx]

I never thought this could be performed live with such precision, incredible, absolutely fantastic performance!

[@stellagirl7625]

As a die hard Floyd fan in her 60's, stand up, lighters lit performance!!! You guys nailed it! And the emotion in my body goes out to your vocalist... she is AMAZING! That is the closest I have heard yet, and with her own feeling in it. 👏👏👏❤

[@patricevert]

I think that this is one of the best versions of The Great Gig in the Sky since the original one sung by Clare Torry. Viviane has the perfect voice for singing it...!

[@philippepohu9447]

yes

[@kontrasti1863]

I think you are right - its wonderful

[@andreyakovleff4103]

Agreed. Magnificent.

[@ravenmeadows7350]

Bravo!! Not an easy song to pull off... but Viviane Donner DOES!! WOW

[@torbicssandor4868]

Angela Cervantes is also great.

[@petrus666love]

I’ve got cancer and if I have to die, let it be listening and watching this band play this song , I’d die happy 😃 if that makes sense , it would to another cancer patient 🙏

[@RasMajnouni]

Y O U are not another can-er patient. You are the one who must care for your soul as long as G-d wants it in your body. At age 67 I literally live each day as if it will be my last.A number of times daily I consider my options and decide "naaaaw, not a good idea to do".The fact that you are willing is wise.The body will rot as it does since birth as it grew and shed cells but the soul never dies as nothing alive can be dead or will be.G-d bless you for only great joy. Torah says that joy and happiness in worshipping G-d can break down any barrier between you and the Infinite One. Please G-d may you find a complete recovery.(A friend from israel)

[@siriusjones5168]

Yeah, it does. Not a cancer patient, but very aware of mortality. This song has always summed up stages of dying for me, and the lady captured it flawlessly. Peace.

[@PeterPanoramics]

gavin cox it makes sense to anyone a beautiful way to transcend to a higher level of enlightenment

[@Phoenix-tv4gb]

IAM pure light 💖💖💖

[@mrroyixo]

God bless all cancer patients

[@phucue887]

Vivian Dohner(?) Nails this ! And the band especially the guitar player are on fire too !

[@Rusanovka]

It's a great tribute to Clare Torry. I hate when singers begin to improvise on this piece. No matter how talented they are, whatever they do, sounds like crap, just because it's impossible to rearrange this masterpiece. This girl paid respect and learned the original aria, with some altered notes here and there. Well, close enough, and she put some heart into her version too. It's the best cover so far I heard.

[@tathus77]

I agree !!

[@ReligiousZombie]

Singers have been doing that for the last 30 years or so, and it still annoys me. I hate it especially when they do it to the National Anthem, which is a shitty enough song to begin with, without making it worse.

[@Rusanovka]

@@user-dc7wf4mj9f Any reason you reply to my post using unreadable crap in non-existing language?

[@Rusanovka]

@@user-dc7wf4mj9f Well, then don't put your comments about a subject you don't know about.

[@juanorgen344]

Rusanovka, I can only agree with you 100 percent. Real Pink Floyd fans hear every single note that deviates just a little and reveal the song and memories as a copy. I had the privilege of listening to the original with a nice-smelling girl in my arms 😍, surrounded by peaceful people. Yeep - guess my years 😁. In this case, however, Viviane Donner respects the original, is mostly perfect on the original and thereby proves her ability many times more than all those who "want to make it better". Viviane Donner's small deviations no longer bother you after listening several times. Respect Viviane Donner, you are great.

[@TimLondonGuitarist]

Great to see a performance of this focussing on the vocalist, she's amazing

[@raundahledbetter2724]

Vivian Donner is so believable in her version of this. She is the only one Ive heard that comes close to Claire Torrys recorded version of Great Gig in the Sky. Not an easy piece to accomplish. Good job Vivian

[@elmerluardo9198]

Claire Torry - studio recording Vivian Donner - live concert

[@Tonkistador]

is it true that the recording singer was barely paid for her performance on the album?

[@UrBaNlLeGeNdZ]

Aymeric Hantin she sued later and got paid great

[@adolforuiz5492]

Bianca Antonella did it great too! Reccomend

[@adolforuiz5492]

Bianca Antoinette!!

[@jasonlamour4787]

She just owned that! I have seen Pink Floyd twice in my life. This artist would have been a great addition to either of those shows! Outstanding!

[@ernestdavis3237]

Firstly, to even give it a go is ballsy. But to nail it like she has..just WOW !!, seriously goosebump material 💕💪

[@marcovissini]

Clare Torry performed and sang this song on Sunday 21 January 1973. She made history. Pure emotion Unfortunately, she was no longer able to do it the same again. I have attended many Pink Floyd concerts live, but no vocalist has ever been up to it. For the first time, with Viviane Donner, it's like having a video recording of that incredible 1973 performance. An infinite THANKS to VIVIAN DONNER for the emotion he gives. The musicians are also great. Promote this video, Pink Floyd fans will be happy. ORIGINAL ITALIANO: Clare Torry ha interpretato e cantato nella domenica del 21 gennaio 1973 questa canzone. Ha fatto la storia. Pura emozione Purtroppo non è più riuscita a rifarla uguale. Ho assistito dal vivo a molti concerti dei Pink Floyd, ma mai nessuna vocalist è stata all'altezza. Per la prima volta, con Viviane Donner, è come avere anche la registrazione video di quella incredibile interpretazione del 1973. Un GRAZIE infinito a VIVIAN DONNER per l'emozione che regala. Grandi anche i musicisti. Promuovete questo video, i fans dei Pink Floyd saranno contenti.

[@sandracrespo5059]

Amazingly, I found a 2020 copy of Clare Torry performing it! Enjoy. kzbin.info/www/bejne/hHLGdYKmmZV_rJI

[@marcovissini]

@@sandracrespo5059 Many thanks, I know the footage, but Clare's voice doesn't is that 1973.

[@burns1210]

There's only one original, but Jesus Christ this is close.

[@ruymoraes199]

Just one question, the original version is a studio record, BUT this version, with Viviane Donner, IS A LIVE VERSION!

[@timrackovan35]

The original is always best. It’s like saying someone else can play Eruption better than EVH. The path was laid at her feet. Talented, yes. Better, no. Replicated, possibly.

[@UrBaNlLeGeNdZ]

@@ruymoraes199 even if that’s so, it was recorded with so few takes and she came up with it on the spot. It was destiny

[@PaulGappyNorris]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/gGTblGh-lLNrmtU

[@lpms5973]

@@ruymoraes199 so, what's the question ?

[@williamdunbar8554]

The sweet little smile on her face at the end of her performance is a perfect finish to a perfect delivery of one of Pink Floyd's most cherished classics. Excellent is not a big enough word to describe her rendition, but it is the best I can do. Well done Viviane, extremely well done!

[@jonathanborchardt4176]

A truly masterful performance. Brilliant

[@blizzdog3881]

I'm 58 years old seen Pink Floyd 2 times and seen a lot of videos of bands trying to capture the essence of the song, just have to say this band & lady did a wonderful job 2 thumbs up 👍👍

[@malu_arkeman_yeager766]

With all due respect to the original, this is the best version I’ve heard . This lady sings just like an angel.

[@AishaBordas]

Listen to Eva Avila's. Flawless.

[@mjrsnafu]

@@AishaBordas I just checked it out and her performance verges on the magical

[@juliettedelides9400]

Utterly beautiful

[@mathisdacquarica7611]

Good screamer! I find it hard to believe that Glimour and Co. do not know how to choose a good voice to interpret their songs. If you don't understand anything about music, avoid littering the web with such nonsense. Please!

[@andytaylor2321]

@@mathisdacquarica7611 we love her man, you’re tone deaf

[@timleland4787]

One of the best versions I have ever heard. Her voice is amazing

[@ZT_9999]

This was phenomenal wow. The best artist tribute ever, her voice is unbelievable

[@lpms5973]

When she said "hAaA WhAaA wHaA aAaH oUuHaA hAaA wHoAaA" I really felt that.

[@CosmicCompassionQuest]

Ha ha

[@98greenp]

No soul & certainly no sense of humour !

[@MeMe-ef5fw]

@@98greenp don't say that about yourself.

[@rikimathe]

I fell the same !!

[@jjlarson74]

BWAAAAAHAHAHAHA!!!!! (you achieved god status with that!)

[@hmnrad]

It made me cry ))))): Definently this song is one of the best song of pink floyd I love it.

[@littlewing1083]

I cried too......after 3:08 where they're accepting death, rather then fighting it.....is so soulful, how can anyone not be moved to tears?

[@leggyfredbob3965]

Fantastic singer. That Lady has a fantastic voice

[@lianabl1]

Women’s voice! The great voice! Understanding, yelling, singing, having fun, Having pleasure, woman being woman!!!!

[@GR8GTRFAN]

Wow! Covers are what they are. Never to be expected to sound like the original. Because they are not the original band. Plain and simple. Bands playing tribute to those they admire. I myself do the same thing. But this vocal track stands right up there on its own with Clare's.. Absolutely beautiful rendition. Hats off!

[@Lumperator]

Absolutely amazing. She sings so smoothly, close to the original. I'm impressed

[@Bluebark64FIS]

That was some mighty fine vocals...that song always brings chills ma body.

[@jimlenhart690]

What else can I say, Viviane is incredible!

[@bigconejo1]

I am a Floyd fanatic. They are my all-time #1 band hands down and I've heard many excellent vocalists sing this cover and this is by far the best I've ever heard. AMAZING! What a pleasure to listen to her and her talent. She just makes me smile and shake my head. All I can say is .....wooooooowwww.

[@joyce89881]

seen floyd over 20 times in concert, seen claire torry about 6 times, this is the nearest anybody has been to claire well done vivane.

[@details2365]

Steven Beard -So true💯💯💯

[@wuchta7812]

i must say, she's the closest to the original. And her high notes sound pretty good.

[@mldnd..]

have u ever seen brit floyd?

[@seafox61]

Indeed...

[@SyTheMetalhead]

Steven Beard I agree totally, this is as close to the original as you are going to get without it being Claire Torry herself. Fantasic performance, would love to see these guys live.

[@colinsmall3368]

Magnificent Vivian. Most beautiful version ever from an incredibly talented vocalist! Reduced me to tears!!

[@KennyEvansUK]

What an absolutely KILLER version of this song. Bravo, bravo, just nailed every single little nuance. Brought me to tears when those drums kicked in. You did yourselves proud.

[@simuppal9709]

I'm so glad I stumbled across this, chills everywhere. She killed it. I'll forever be amazed at the vocals in this song, original and covers. Takes some guts to even attempt a song like this. Beautiful.

[@richardtarter5184]

I feel the same way you do!🙂

[@karmanowable]

Same to me, she kills me too. I don't know, but looks like a cry of something, maybe the earth ?

[@grenvillemills3562]

❤

[@syncout]

having been a Floyd fan since 1967 and know every note i fail to understand how anyone let alone 1.1k can give a thumbs down, for me this was pure magic

[@CFLJAMES]

Jealous and simply not having a soul or appreciation for this woman's work as well as the rest of the band, or simply not PF fan's who can only wrap their heads around some catchy hook or lyric's verses this woman pouring here soul out on stage. She nailed it on all levels... Beautiful work...

[@steveb2893]

Completely agree....she smashed it. Very difficult to sing, and she nailed it.

[@MarcoPolo-je5ej]

Agreed.

[@BackwoodsFilms]

Why on earth are people so concerned about the number of thumbs down? Just listen to the music and enjoy.

[@jimthebrit]

There are bots that thumbdown every video. There are also a billion people with internet access and time to waste. Accept the spam, and feel sorry for people who can't appreciate something like this.

[@angelocapuzzimato5902]

What a wonderful performance !!! Anytime I listen it gives me shivers and a deep emotion ! Very Well done and thank you very much indeed for having posted it!

[@geoffreyjoseph9145]

My first time hearing you guys, but really fantastic, ❤

[@yamelamadorfernandez7416]

Oh man this is unbelievably close to the original and yet sang with a particular energy, definitely one of the best tributes almost perfectly done.

[@robertaninfamoraraimondo1308]

Why "almost"? It's actually perfectly done, on a technical level.

[@BrianFromBoise]

Viviane Donner absolutely perfectly nailed this. Wow. PURE MAGIC.

[@camiloborges6146]

Falar alguma coisa dessa performance é chover no.molhado. Mas não posso deixar de dizer que depois da gravação original, é a melhor! Em nenhuma das apresentações ao vivo do Floyd conseguiram reproduzir tão bem como essa brasileira. Sinto orgulho 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

[@paulagomes9458]

Pode dizer-me quem é esta cantora? A versão mais parecida com esta é a de Olá Bienkowska e Amy Smith, na Australian tour

[@marcostrindaderamos6806]

verdade

@@paulagomes9458 Viviane Donner. Ela tem carreira solo e dá aula de canto hoje em dia.

[@marciamachado5124]

Concordo! Sozinha! Brilha muito❤

[@agridoce.]

Chocada que ela é brasileira, eu viciei nesse vídeo e nem sabia

[@silviae.solier2641]

Soy Argentina.....que impesionante voz!!!!!!!!y la música in comparable.....gracias

[@richiep5715]

This is the greatest cover possible. As close to clare torry as is possible, i love it

[@sugerace1]

Thanks for the Clare name yes this moved me like hers..soo emotional close...got to listen again.

[@juliocesaroliveira3402]

Better...

[@cov71]

@@juliocesaroliveira3402 Smashed it as a cover, really thought it was awesome, but not as good as the original.

[@malcolmbrimecome5992]

@@cov71 she nailed it better than clair live but clairs on DSOM is just fantastic

[@cov71]

@@malcolmbrimecome5992 it’s all about opinions really. I’m very sentimental towards the original and the raw emotion from Clare live was haunting.

[@tommy--k]

So many talented people in the world. Congratulations to Viviane Donner, a job WELL DONE! Should have been a standing O.

[@billysolhurok5542]

she nailed it...

[@TomCoppell]

This gave me chills. Singer is incredible and the entire band. Best cover I’ve ever seen.

[@jb-ik8sj]

Prettiest song ever sung by the prettiest voice ever heard, written by one of the greatest bands in all history, written without any words.

[@gaspode2005]

This actually sent shivers down my spine. Fantastic work.

[@roozbehshayeganfatemy9254]

This is a everlasting Rock classic masterpiece that never be forgotten.

[@rbevans4581]

Man, she freaking nails it! Torrey would be impressed.

[@fritshits65]

this is pretty goddamn GREAT !...and I've seen this Live like 4/5 times...also with Sam Brown....this is a good as I've ever heard it.

[@FConstantino]

What makes this song so special is that Clare Torry sung her soul out and embedded it on the original record (this is why everybody has goosebumps hearing it... ;-). Afterwards nobody did it again, not even Clare herself ! But you Viviane, you did it. You made the Great Gig in the Sky again. Bravíssimo!

[@rudavalek]

Flavio Constantino not true!

[@kiwilobo7751]

Bravo. deserved a standing ovation. heathens!

[@davidvalensi8616]

Need 3 things to do this 1) has to be a young voice 2) talent(wide range) 3) the singer has to "get it" really like the song and understand what was really intended, all the stops are out and the music goes beyond music and takes flight. She achieved that, nothing will be as good as the original on dark side, but that's just the way it goes.

[@thomascleland735]

Yes. This. Exactly.

[@elmerluardo9198]

it's allan parsons magic.

[@crupert23225]

What a voice. She does Clare proud. Magnificent performance.

[@PCTubone]

I lost my mind to listen to this amazing vocal performance. Absolutely perfect 👍👍👍

[@giovannifioretto1605]

Indicibile atmosfera, musica da brividi ,Intensa Passione, profonda emozione, intima dolcezza, sconfinato amore, incredibile forza della voce ...bravissima Viviana

[@halilujah]

this is absolutely the best great gig in the sky cover of all time. even pink floyd's itself couldn't do that in their concerts. wow

[@MisterWillow]

Wow (wo)man! This woman nailed it! Never heard of her before, but, well, now I did. :-) She's got talent.

[@user-dc7wf4mj9f]

Фантастика!!!!!!!! Как поёт!!! 100раз слушаю, точно первый раз. Все ноты взяла, все ноты. Умничка девочка. Слов нет. Молодец!!!

[@user-yw7ws3qm8j]

Точно, почти оригинал!

[@user-dc7wf4mj9f]

@@user-yw7ws3qm8j По правде сказать. Оригинала то нет. Никто не спел оригинал. Клэр Торри, первая певица, в одиночку навыла звуки. А Ричард райд, пианист и композитор из группы Пинк Флойд, из этих звуков вытянул мелодию, отбросив остальные звуки. В будущем Клэр Торри звали петь эту мелодию на концертах. Она не справилась, точно она не смогла спеть, то что навыла. Многие брались петь это произведение и даже втроём пели и лажали, а эта девочка в одиночку всё исполнила в ноты. Очень молодчина. Хотя в других видео и она бывало лажает. Ну что то не получаются иногда звуки.

[@CommonSenseRevolution]

I grew up a fan a progressive rock. Bands like Genesis (w/Gabriel), Yes, King Crimson, Supertramp, and yes, Pink Floyd). These bands struggled and succeeded in breaking new ground and raising the bar of excellence in music. This song is perhaps one of the most DIFFICULT for ANY band to reproduce, and Atom Pink Floyd NAILED IT. Viviane's astounding mastery of the vocal track sent chills down my spine. It was so perfect it was like listening to the album. I had to replay the video and have bookmarked it. BRAVO!!!

[@nuancolar7304]

Maybe the best rendition of this I have seen. She comes pretty darn close to Clare Torry.

[@fredgotschalg9585]

Better pink floyd cover that i've ever seen. Pf never came to brazil, but their show makes me imagine that they are the real pf

[@steveowsley6475]

I personally think Brit Floyd does it slightly better.

[@juanluengo3198]

I agree, second best after the gorgeous original. On the plus side, it is done in one take. On the minus, her voice deserves even more presence in the mix. Thanks Ms. Donner.

[@davidgregory5471]

This is the best this song has ever been performed outside the studio, this girl got one take live and she nailed it.

[@craigherriot4026]

She gave that every last shred of emotion she could muster. The most incredible , perfect performance of my favourite song ever. I thank you Viviane and band.

[@user-mu2fu9yv7s]

The most beautiful voice I’ve ever heard 😢

[@georgziegan4445]

my soul is deeply touched .a strong voice. perfect. love it

[@sproutyDP]

The lady nailed it - best I've heard - spellbound

[@donnerviviane]

Thanks!

[@cobeone1]

Viviane, I've listened to your performance numerous time. Your incredible vocal send chills down many spine every time. You are amazing.

[@marcossteyer7985]

@@donnerviviane Espetacular!!! Sou louco por Pink Floyd e, para mim, foi melhor que a original!!! Parabéns!!

[@Frankencougie]

@@donnerviviane Wonderful performance, brought tears thinking of past years. Thank you.

[@EZ8E]

My god... you would think this was the original. The best recreation I have heard ever. I saw this live... 1994 Division Bell Tour. It was magic.

[@akywhizzbang]

What a seriously beautiful voice. Brings a heighted reality to the original.

[@michaelfontanelli2450]

Nailed it! Best version since the gold standard: Clare Torry’s original.

[@lucianofonseca6982]

Verdade top

[@lucianofonseca6982]

Top

[@Richard.Hybels]

Sam Brown a close runner up but this is number one.

[@selfhelp69]

So nailed.

[@lucianofonseca6982]

@@selfhelp69 vero

[@MarcusDantus]

Incredible, beautiful, on-the-spot rendition

[@pmac5934]

That performance really does justice to the original studio version. I normally run miles from tribute bands but I would go a long way to see this performed by this lot . God almighty that woman got some voice ! I'm in love ....

[@elloco1841]

Toda vez q vejo esse video eu fico abismado com a perfeição do atom.

[@DelaG29]

Finally someone who does the original version justice! ❤️

[@revlo1557]

Besides the original Pink Floyd version, this is the best version I have heard of this classic. Amazing!

[@kirkericson2722]

Well done - great band, great vocalist, great production!

[@RandyWeber]

First time I'm hearing this. This woman's voice brought chills to my body and soul. WOW!!!

[@albertotulum]

The best voice by far !!!!

[@sherlockinaforever]

Viviane Donner sings in a very controlled (but emotional) manner, like an opera singer, which is great. Clare Torry sung it like a hurt animal, with all her guts. Both are absolutely brilliant !

[@stevejackson8094]

Said perfectly. Clare Torry sang it like when you see David Gilmore playing guitar.... they both feel and experience every single note.

[@stubbieoz]

My apologies, at my age I am just thankfull I can remember what a name sounds like, let alone how to spell it.

[@thebrightsideofthemoon5829]

sherlockinaforever , no shit Sherlock

[@albertocoimbra9751]

Well said! Thais performance was really great and you were able to define both performances.

[@paulsurette5828]

It's called singing with soul!

[@kieranrankie203]

My, my, my, that's one of the most beautiful things I've ever heard. Excellent cover.

[@nogayi0212]

Beautiful!!!! so much power wowwwww!

[@Richardd-rk6pr]

this is the best live performance of this song on youtube

[@deanwiseman12]

Absolutely brilliant. Best version I’ve heard since Clair. Too Many try to to over do it. She nailed it. Love love love

[@niceguy2171]

Quite well said, as others do try to "overdue it" as you've said.

[@Demogrunt]

I agree Dean Wiseman She is spot on for the the most part. gave me chills up my spine! Love it.

[@sproutyDP]

Spot on Dean

[@jorgemerino46]

You must be kidding! The version with Brown, Fontaine & McBroom is cosmic! A cover will never exceed the genius of the original Pink Floyd! that's why there are levels

[@grayaj23]

> Many try to overdo it It's my opinion that it's the *less talented* who overdo it. When your "instrument" is this good, there's no need for embellishment.

[@juniord.santos973]

Sem dúvidas, a melhor apresentação dessa canção.

[@mikescott2767]

that was totally awesome, have heard so many folk try to cover the origonal and not make it. This lady is fantastic I would say this is as good as the original in every way, Love it , Love it , Love it

[@Manup2day]

Bought tears to my eyes. Fantastic 👏 👏 👏 👏

[@martinmueller2133]

Tribute is the highest form of flattery and this is flattering at its finest

[@MetalMaven]

Love that voice!!!

[@RabeloBach]

❤The amazing Viviane Donner!❤ Pink Floyd FOREVER!