I keep coming back to listen to this wonderful anti-war song, Thank you for allowing us to listen to it. It makes me proud, not as a Russian or for being Jewish, but for its sublime humanity.
@Elabeta114 жыл бұрын
I love chasidic music and Russian songs!!! Thanks very much... Elżbieta
@LioraC13 жыл бұрын
Thank you for posting this - it sings to my soul
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
atsaliuk i have nothing against your video or your chorus, sounds good, and its a good song, a simple question one became in a fight, so i repeat it, good interpretation and video.
@atsaliuk14 жыл бұрын
Please, take a look at another song by our choir: Sluchayniy Vals. Посмотрите на наше видео: Случайный Вальс.
@Antifacio14 жыл бұрын
Очень красивая песня. Очень душевная. Great song. Very patriotic and russian.
@mcfrdmn14 жыл бұрын
Lovely performance
@Blacktony8616 жыл бұрын
Прекрасная песня!
@JohnAnonymous6 жыл бұрын
Great performance of this wonderful Russian song!
@CINEDIGITAL16 жыл бұрын
ok thanks for your answer.
@eugeniodimilano14 жыл бұрын
Наши евреи не прятались по сусекам, а встали с нами на защиту нашей общей Родины. Они такие же русские как и я, а местами и фору мне дадут. Френкель, Блатнер, Ошанин, Дунаевский - это моя русская гордость!
@19041098 жыл бұрын
I'd love to see lyric in English.
@CINEDIGITAL16 жыл бұрын
i would like to know what says the song, anobody can translate it to spanish or english please? and, what is the relation between this song, rusia and the jews?
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@MUTalberg you should to see what button do you press, cause you said that your answer arent for me, but the email alert me that you answer one of my posts. The only way to nule confusions its clicking the right button, and not click and response in automatic. in this answer you didnt pressed my answer button, i saw it cause ive read another postl continue trying.
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@jevrej1977 you dont want understand the point, you can wear any clothes you want, but if you sing a FOLKLORIC MUSIC and you wear another clothes thats irrational do you get ir or not?
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@jevrej1977 ths song IS SOVIET MUSIC, and the author is unkowed. How you can say that he (or she) was jew? was russian and SOVIET RUSSIAN no israeli SOVIET, look another videos about this song here in youtube and may be you will understand it.
@ulik88813 жыл бұрын
@maciekc60 I do not know Polski at all I can write in Russian but I do not have Russian fonts JA NJE UMJEU PISAT< CHITAT ILI GOVORIT NA POLSKOM JAZIKE VOOBSHCH IZVINITI
@CINEDIGITAL16 жыл бұрын
oh thanks for the answer i would like to know about this scandal if you can talk me above it please, if you want by pm. thanks a lot.
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@jevrej1977 thanks for your sapience but im not asking only to you, and I think that your answer sont explain the doubt. My point is that a chorus singing SOVIET FOLK MUSIC cant dress other clothes, thats all.
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@Burrrry6969 ok your first comment its respectful, so mine will be also (only in this), thats can be an explanation about this, a concert of jew music and sing another kind of music in the same place. They will not to change their clothes to sing it. well, end of respectful comment, in way of your comment.
@Stas246814 жыл бұрын
@CINEDIGITAL @CINEDIGITAL ROLF 1.) Before you copy something from the internet, inform yourself. In our times medicine is on a such high level that people with down syndrome are able to finish high-school, so you still would be able to write.
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@jevrej1977 this look that a FOLKLORIC ISRAELI CHORUS, not like a "sovietic jews" where is the red color? or something that i can see that show me they are a sovietic jews and not israelies jews? when the catholics sings any song about partisans they are not drees habits or something like that. This chorus look like will sing Yerushalayim shel zahav or something like that.
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@jevrej1977 you need a very urgent History class, May be the USSR dont exist any more but the song tha you hear its from the IIGM when the sovietics fights vs Nazis. its very easy, see another folk chorus here and see the clothes, thats CULTURE, try to understand the anthropological concept.
@Stas246814 жыл бұрын
@CINEDIGITAL It is a song from the time of WW2. I guess you don't understand that this song is not from 7th century or so that is the reason why they don't wear some stuff you would expect. There is no special outfit for that song because it is not that old. Man you are very small minded.
@ulik88813 жыл бұрын
השיר הזה יפה מאד ובכוונה אני מגיב בעברית מפני שמרבית השירים הטובים שנכתבו בימי מןלחמת העולם השניה נכתבו בידי יהודים לא מעט גנרלים של הצבא האדום היו יהודים זמרים אין ספור התרומה היהודית למלחמה היתה מעל ומעבר לכל יחס למספרם באוכלוסין של המדינה הסובייטית. מה לעשות שהאמת מרגיזה כמה צרי מח כאן? ד"ש מירושלים הבירה הנצחית של ישראל
@Stas246814 жыл бұрын
@CINEDIGITAL I am sorry but I see that you are a very small minded person. 1.) There were and still are many Jews in Russia. 2.) Why in the world should the wear red things? I mean they are not communists. 3.) at time 4:13 you can see in the background the Russian flag. I really don't see your problem.
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@jevrej1977 lol you are aberrantly contradictory, you said that what about jews sing soviet music, and now you tell me that i cant talk about this cause im mexican lol thats stupid, you mean, we the jews can do all that we can but no all the world? hey, there are some things called BOOKS and he hasnt owner and nationality, so somebody that read can understand it, do you know the word UNIVERSAL HISTORY?
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@jevrej1977 understand first that i called RACIST to burrrry. If you dont read it its your problem, understand first that i tell you and that i tell others, if you want to comment obviously.
@CINEDIGITAL15 жыл бұрын
am i wrong? may be you should to learn to read first, im asking, im not answering.
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@Stas2468 open a book. In the WW2 the red army fought for the USSR, for the workers and farmers of the world and for their liberty. The societ culture ITS FOLKLORIC, not only the culture of 7th century. Another SOVIETS songs here in youtube, wear soviets clothes. Man, you havent more than 2 neurons.
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@jevrej1977 anti-semite word its not my favorite word, its a favorite word of some jews. You dont need to write it exactly the word to tell it.
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@jevrej1977 you are moving your mind over suppositions, if you know the thruth, welcome, any other case you are not a big help. the sing, the dance, and others cultural manifestations, should be go accompanied to an adapted clothes, they are not singing a britney spears song, but yes folk song. i understand, you are jew and you think that all the world are anti-semite, of course no the jews.
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@jevrej1977 dont you understand anything rigth? do you know that the nuns are CATHOLIC? they sings catholic music and its normal, send a video of they singing punk and your "great ponit" will be validated. Bach is not "folkloric music" ok? understand first the concept. ekh dorogui ITS FOLKLORIC MUSIC, ITS NOT CLASSICAL MUSIC. Learn to view the diference between classic and folkloric and after give your points.
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@Stas2468 whats your problem? your comment is stupid, why they should use other clothes? simply, because there are singing a FOLK MUSIC, may be if they sing an ISRAeLI FOLK MUSIC the clothes are fine, but not in this case, i hope you understand the point.
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@jevrej1977 do you will to tell me my rights? lol come on. hey, the problem here its that you dont know the FOLKLORIC concept. You should to watch folk dance, MEXICA, RUSSIAN, COLOMBIAN, GERMAN, etc. and ALL THEY dress FOLK dress. Bach music? haha, hey man, bach its NOT FOLK MUSIC, ok? dominique? its a CHRISTIAN SONG, thats mean that you dont understand the point, what a pit, bye.
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@Burrrry6969 IM more seroius than you, you speak and speak and speak and you say nothing, only shit emanates of your mouth. Comprende and amigo its all that you know in spanish? fucking racist, i speak more words in english (and french and italian) that you in spanish. American dollars? oh yeah the world its in crisis, do you know whos the country that initiate the crisis? do you know the unemployment in USA? los you are so stupid, go to drug yourself, cocaine addict, and kill your students
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@jevrej1977 non-jews? what stupid word is that? all the word except the jews are non jews. if somebody ask anything about the jews you use inmediatly the stupid word racis, when we know that some jews are more racist than other cultures. If you think was a stupid question, you gave a stupid answer, so we are ties.
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@jevrej1977 learn to say appropriately the words. Some mexican dont knows the real History, so some jews dont knows the real History. you speak like a child, only repeating my words, you cant think by yourself? be mature.
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@jevrej1977 personally i have nothing against jews but some are so stupids, mainly the sionists. you should to learn to read, i called RACIST JEW to burry for his kind to talk about the mexicans ok? yes, were slaughtered 50mill of humans (no-jew? what is that?) and your point is?
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@Burrrry6969 America its all the continent, your brain undesrtand thats so simple? USA its not all america, mexican and brasilian and venezuelans ARE AMERICA, and all are CIVILIZED. what critic about culture? im talking about FOLKLORIC MUSIC, what fu..k critic? may be your mind its in another place.
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@Burrrry6969 ok stupid, first, the racist law are in ARIZONA not in ALABAMA, take a newspaper before your look like an ignorant. second, about a lot of shit vomitingof your lips, i can tell you, are you a racist jew? lol thats absurd and very stupid, like you.
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@Stas2468 your "opinion" if we can to call so, its not important for nothing only for your mom, your IQ is under 30 and itsnt problem for me, i can live with that. The fucking zionist stink like you. You are the part nazi of the jews. I have parents in Russia and you cant come to tell me what they did it. They belive yet that the USSR was great and Russia not. May be only your friends says that. May be you should to read REAL books and no tv series.
@Stas246814 жыл бұрын
@Stas2468 2.) It is interesting that you trying to explain me what Zionism stands for. But again you showed your low education. I think you should be at least able to read Wikipedia. btw. Let us see what the UN thinks (where you find a lot of Islamic radical countries): United Nations General Assembly Resolution 46/86
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@Stas2468 are stupid? you are telling that you are "educated" your education is attack other people? connect your neurons please, Stop to vomiting stupidities, the zionist are terrorist, but in your stupid mind you are the god boys, only in your stupid mind. So go to distill your frustration with other people, you have a poor life. when I ask you something so answer, but I speak only with people that are respectful and intelligent, and you aren´t in that level. BYE.
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@Burrrry6969 you stink out with this kind to "think", i repeat it, a racist jew. I cant belive it. What do you know about mexican CULTURE stupid? (alabama ha ha, ARIZONA idiot) and all the world are against idiot racist like you. A racist jew lol come on! dont you learned nothing from History?
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@Stas2468 not all the people with down syndrome can finish the highschool, only they who has a slight delay, like you. 2.my low education? whats your "high" education when you are attacking to me, you are a walking contradiction. there are fanatics in all religions, puritans, al-qaeda, and zionist, the name is the only changed my friends they are not of your concern, is it clear? you sound very stupid talking about education and attacking to me at the same time. Read yourself
@CINEDIGITAL14 жыл бұрын
@Stas2468 zionist=nazi there are not difference, both thinks are superiors and they discriminate others, so you can continue laughing, your laugh it reflects your mental poverty. IQ under 60 its impossible also because its level of down syndrome, and you couldnt to write here neither so... Luckyly I have better friends as you... do you? i doubt it.