BMW M340i vs Mercedes C43 AMG vs Audi S4 comparison REVIEW

[@autogefuehl]

►Follow us on Instagram @autogefuehl and @thomas.letsgo ►Subscribe here: kzbin.info 00:00 Performance sedan comparison 00:17 Audi S4 in Ascari Blue 00:38 BMW M340i in Frozen Grey matt 00:56 Mercedes-AMG C43 in Hyacinth Red 01:28 Exhaust, length and rear 02:57 Key fob comparison 03:14 BMW M340i interior 05:05 Mercedes C43 AMG interior 07:58 Audi S4 interior 09:06 Rear seat comparison 10:21 Trunk / boot comparison 11:11 Engines 12:52 Driving BMW M340i 18:24 Driving Mercedes C43 AMG 25:16 Driving Audi S4 31:01 S4 / S5 US V8 petrol 32:05 Which one is better? #Mercedes #BMW #Audi Transparency note: Autogefühl videos are independent and free from editorial influence on opinion and rating. But since manufacturers enable us to do the reviews in the first place, for legal reasons this video is marked as _advertisement_.

[@bezputink]

все было нормально до момента погружения в их салоны. Эти кошмарные мониторы просто сводят с ума... Интересно как сказывается на безопасности вождения их наличие?

[@Joseluis-vs7dv]

Video in spanish please, canal Auto Sensacion

[@sanchaynarain3532]

Nothing can beat the B58 Motor 😍

[@kiplingordon]

Phenomenal motor

[@sol0matrix]

The 330i can beat slingshots i can imagine what the b58 can do my next upgrade for sure fun fact when you own these cars you start seeing a lot of them when you never seen them before

[@Dilly_Dil1y]

Engine and drive bmw hands down. But look wise I’m taking Audi and Benz. Interior Benz for sure.

[@dorakid2008]

S58

[@sol0matrix]

@@dorakid2008 yep m3

[@steve7572]

I looked at all three of these (US Versions) and got the M340i LCI. TO me, the fastest and best looking. The Mercedes looks great too, but the B58 performance overshadowed the Mercedes looks. Mine is fully spec'd and it's just an amazing driving car. The torque is 50ftlbs underrated by BWW too. Actually pulls about 420ftlbs. The acceleration is incredible and you can do 100mph without even knowing it. It has no problem just going. And I came from a Mustang GT A10

[@Leester-70]

You made the right choice.

[@Imperialbbuilding]

Definitely best choice

[@Radiation580]

M340i definitely the best here

[@cooksindatrap627]

I just did the same ! Took in my 5.0 A10 and got m340i LCI and LOVE IT

[@ego_sum_liberi]

Yes. Siiir!!!

[@duck8280]

That BMW is the best hands down, especially when I found out it has the B58. Looks delicious as well!

[@lyricaldistributionsupport3280]

Went from an M4 to a C63s facelift and now have an S5 petrol. Agree with Thomas completely that the Audi is the most balanced and the most comfortable as a daily driver. Performance is there when you need it but understated enough to not be unnecessarily noticed.

[@autogefuehl]

💪

[@Qrzychu92]

I went for a S5 Sportback, 2018 so it's still a petrol. If I were to buy an avant, it would be the M340i though, but to my eyes, nothing beats the looks of an S5 (at least in this price range :P)

[@sunilthakur76]

B58 is way more reliable than Audi 3.0T v6

[@madpistol]

BMW's B58 straight 6 is just epic. It's such a smooth and refined powertrain, but it also delivers the power when you ask for it... and it makes an amazing noise. It's such a perfect motor.

[@TheLumberJacked]

Great motor? Absolutely. Perfect motor? No…

[@hettmannsperger42]

@@TheLumberJacked Its perfect.

[@tubejorrit]

@@TheLumberJacked Sold my C63s for the M340i. I really miss the M177 engine from the AMG. I hope a remap of the B58 can keep me happy until I saved some money to buy a (facelift) C63s coupe next to the m340i.

[@catalincasian1857]

Audi for me,please!!!

[@92Godzilla]

I think BMW takes the style win, it’s what the M3 should have looked like.

[@cockshield]

I really miss the "it doesn't matter who knows, YOU know" approach to M car design.

[@anwarabdullah8581]

A face that M3 deserved😢😢😢

[@cockshield]

@@anwarabdullah8581 The Alpina B3 is still a beautiful looking thing.

[@anwarabdullah8581]

@@cockshield yes bro.but G8X front grills are not giving a car look it looks like a beaver.

[@fregyt]

@@cockshield e46 m3 comes to mind

[@tanzil88]

BMW 3 series of course, but the one from pre LCI.

[@moutsydumezweni2915]

You delivered on your promise! The video came sooner rather than later

[@DMCarReviews]

I will have to say the BMW seats with SensaTec are by far the most comfortable. I took a trip for 13 hours in my BMW, and my back wasn't even tired. Volvo seats exhaust me faster. I also owned an Audi S5, and while the sporty seats were very cool and supportive, they did make my back more tired in long-distance driving. They would sort of "ram" into under my armpits and over time it became more noticeable. I guess it also depends on your body shape and other factors. I think all cars in this class are very comfortable.

[@TheLumberJacked]

I test drove a car which sensaTec and it was so frigging hot. I prefer leather. It was an X3 M40i, ended up with a GLC AMG43 and the leather seats are far more comfortable, but also a bit cooler for day to day use. This is my personal experience, but I swore off SensaTec after that.

[@filipeviola]

this BMW is just too good

[@MrQuashu]

M340 without even smallest doubts, mercedes is joke with this price for 4cylinder.

[@Queenfan007]

I own the BMW M340i Touring, pre-facelift version, so my choice is already made. I have to say that I prefer the interior of this version to the LCI because of the real air-conditioning controls, the real gearshift and also because I'm not a fan of this huge digital screen. Externally, the new one is nice. Otherwise, I am basically an Audi driver. Before the BMW, I only owned Audis, including two S4 Avant, a B5 and a B8. Only, when it came time to switch cars in 2020, the TDI engine in the new S4 became eliminatory in my choice. I also tried the C43 AMG V6 which I really liked (nice sound), but after trying the M340, the magic of the B58 engine and the dynamic behavior of the car convinced me. I haven't tried the new C43 yet. Too bad about the 4 cylinder, but from the comments, the handling seems great.

[@kenoh818]

BMW M340i of course!

[@limpunsing2229]

Excellent comparison review

[@autogefuehl]

thanks !!

[@themercedestraveler9566]

For those in the US, the new c43 exhaust is loud and awesome in US spec due to no opf. I test started one yesterday

[@axcn4733]

nah, the 2l is cringe on amg car

[@Turborider]

It can never sound as good as a straight six 6

[@ymlccc]

Thomas always has the 1st hand report for us who live outside of Germany. Well done, so much details in your videos!

[@chetachiezihe9316]

Your videos are the best, always shows what I really want to see in a new car. The camera angles and all ❤❤

[@quoostonator]

I have a m140i (B58) but don’t want a hatch anymore. Test drove an S4 today and it’s incredible. Engine sound reminds me of my Busso V6 in my Alfa 156. It’s so comfortable and quiet in the cabin. The tech is great and the layout of the controls and mix of tactile buttons with the screens is great. The driving cluster is incredible. It’s honestly hard to believe it’s the same year as the m140i. I recently test drove the 340i of the same year and it’s that B58 that makes the vehicle, but honestly the Audi is just so much more car overall. I love it.

[@ShanePajak]

I have to say, I took delivery of a C43 in the US this last week and will say the sound of the exhaust is different here versus the European spec vehicles that most of the reviews are on. I believe the US version does not have the OPF, which absolutely changes the sound.

[@autogefuehl]

Yeah that can do a lot

[@LemtemPoktui]

Hi Shane. Would you be so kind to make a video on your C43's exhaust? So far on youtube there hasn't been a W206 C43 exhaust sound comparison between OPF (European) vs Non-OPF (Rest of the World).

[@ShanePajak]

@@LemtemPoktui let me see what I can do

[@LemtemPoktui]

@@ShanePajak Appreciate it Shane! I'm this close 🤏 in ordering the C43. The sound from the OPF versions is what's holding me back. I'm not expecting the sound to rival the BMW or Audi, but it at least have to sound decent for an AMG, which the OPF version doesn't.

[@g8joe]

Saw a very sexy titanium exhaust with remote control cutouts through Armytrix sounded tits. (Mercian slang for 👍 good)

[@Kurlach]

Well my M340i LCI arrives in three weeks so I already made my decision 😉😆

[@leslyjones718]

You still going for that or you changing it??

[@Kurlach]

@@leslyjones718 no reason to change. Looks great, it’s very quick, has plenty of space for me. Can’t wait!

[@LemtemPoktui]

C43 for me. Driving fun trumps anything else. The C43 AMG is basically an emotional buy. The BMW is the smart buy and the Audi is if your friends already have the BMW and Mercedes.

[@TheLumberJacked]

C43 is amazing. I don’t think the BMW is a better buy. The one you want to spend time in is the smart buy. You made a great choice. (Though admittedly I prefer the V6TT in the old one for its howling exhaust and stupidly loud pops/bangs and shift farts) but I’d happily own your car in a second.

[@Mj-uo7bc]

S4 TDI and c43 with 4 cyl 😂. I lost everything for Mercedes and Audi. I would pick that bmw any day

[@Enko063]

Audi has V6.

[@titibobo2000]

@ 15:40 - Not necessarily. In my 540i I use Sport Individual with engine in Sport and transmission in Comfort mode. Engine in Sport gives you better (faster) throttle response and transmission in Comfort keeps it one gear step higher than Sport, thus avoiding unnecessary high engine RPM and higher fuel consumption when they are not needed. When required, (overtaking or fast driving through a set of curves), I just slap the gear shift lever to Sport and I get the Sport transmission. I'm gonna miss that gear handle so much...

[@bradulovic82]

Alpina B3 starts around 90k euros in Germany, so if you don't go crazy with options you can have a 500 HP Alpina under 100k which is much better car than any of these 3 for almost the same money.

[@Von__Rx]

This is so enjoyable to watch. Excellent analysis of all three. I agree with your well throughout conclusion. Keep up the great work Thomas!

[@mr.lassig3671]

The Mercedes looks soo good 😍

[@rickzagor]

I took the C43. It was very expensive compared to the older one. But, I’m so happy with it.

[@questionyourself718]

Nice to hear that you are happy with it! Can you say something to the interior quality? Every review says that they are cutting cost and its not as good as last generation. Whats your experience with that?

[@KDub-1]

@@questionyourself718by far the nicest interior in this class. Performance is also basically the same

[@questionyourself718]

@@KDub-1 i mean, its for sure not as good as bmw's interior. That was proven by countless videos. But i was interested about the comparison to the old c-class. Because i couldnt try the new one yet but everybody said it has gotten worse.

[@KDub-1]

@@questionyourself718 not sure what videos you’re watching. BMW’s interior in the 3 series are old, bland and outdated. Can’t compare in refinement, technology, appearance, ambient lighting or luxury to the merc’s. The new 5 series is getting better… I know because I have a beemer

[@questionyourself718]

@@KDub-1 i watch all the good ones. Autobild, Auto Motor und Sport, Throttle House, CarandDriver, Doug Demuro, Hagerty, Removebeforerace, Adac, Carwow and more. What you is objectively wrong. Idrive 8 is more responsive and has more functions than Mercedes Mbux. It won more tests. It uses the better processor with the higher graphic power. Second the Materials used in the BMW are more expensive and the quality of assembly is better as all tests say. Mercedes is cutting costs with each new generation and the w206 c-class took it to a new extreme. 80% of the cabin is made out of plastic or artificial materials.

I already placed an order for an M340i Touring. All great cars but I'm happy with my choice and can't wait to have it delivered!

[@Patrick_T_Peni]

Finally!!! The comparison I had been waiting for.

[@autogefuehl]

💪

[@DnBDubstepManiak1]

To be honest, the BMW looks the most interesting to me. Unfortunately the Audi only has a diesel for the S-variant and the C-class is way to expensive for what you get. The whole luxury doesn't fit the C43 that much and performance wise it's barely an upgrade to the previous one. Also the M340i has a lot of potential to tune etc. It's also the only bmw that I like for the looks, except for the 8-series and some X-models. But to me it looks so much better than the new 2-series, M3, 4-series, 7-series and fromwhat I've seen the new 5-series won't look that good as the current one either.

[@boondockbwoy14]

Actually the new next gen 5er should be sleeker and more handsome than the current one..

[@barebilobrk]

Whole luxury doesnt fit in C43? What are you talking abt?

[@DonMwanx]

BMW ❤

[@frumpd63]

I personally think the high spec 2.0L Giulia is the best overall package for a sport sedan available today, but the B58 in the BMW and the Audi seats and interior are incredible.

[@jet_man]

I am in love to with Alfa, but 3.0 R3 in BMW is also worth of considerations. Plus bmw is available in touring spec …

[@drumdone]

The Giulia does look great but interior is cheap in comparison to these, also the 2.0 engine is rough and slow. They are also very unreliable. If Alfa improved quality and gave it 360hp it would be perfect, unfortunately the 280 hp version just can't compete at the same level as these 3.

[@hassanger8128]

Julia looks so outdated with very cheap interior and garbage reliability

[@MitchM240]

You are joking right? It’s a Chrysler. It looks nice but thats it.

[@jet_man]

@@MitchM240 what is a Chrysler? 😀

[@autogefuehl]

WATCH OUT FOR SPAM/FAKE ACCOUNTS. Across KZbin/Whatsapp/Telegram etc., you'll find fake accounts taking the identity of original channels or people claiming to work on the behalf of original channels, they sometimes even use the same profile pic, similar names and include a telephone number in the name or their comments, trying to get you to message them on Whatsapp or Telegram. DO NOT MESSAGE THEM, they are trying to get your personal details, bank accounts etc. and in the end, they will ask for money or they will misuse your bank account. They promise you giveaways, prices, payment etc. Do not fall for these cheap tricks and PLEASE HELP everyone and MARK THEIR MESSAGES and their whole accounts/channels as Spam and/or report their telephone numbers/Whatsapp to the police. We from Autogefuehl will never ask for your bank details. Check out our original channel marked with the verified badge. We do have other official channels, so you can identify them and also subscribe if you like e.g. in your native language: 2nd channel for shorter reviews: kzbin.info Spanish: Auto Sensación - Prueba de coches a fondo kzbin.info/door/ZospzTclE4Uf6Jvxbh842Q Arabian: حس السيارات kzbin.info/door/YSBKhMY_UpvcU1_4j8xJcg Korea: 오토센스 kzbin.info/door/6S_5hXKrjJ87xOg9GE_AHA Japan: カー フィーリング kzbin.info/door/8wumItayAPJnk059DLa30g Russian: Анатомия Автомобиля kzbin.info%D0%90%D0%BD%D0%B0%D1%82%D0%BE%D0%BC%D0%B8%D1%8F%D0%90%D0%B2%D1%82%D0%BE%D0%BC%D0%BE%D0%B1%D0%B8%D0%BB%D1%8F Chinese: 車之感 www.youtube.com/@AutogefuhlChinese BMW theme channel: kzbin.info/door/IUeo4Kjlq7F2XrTwyXUYcA EV theme channel: kzbin.info/door/_KxbHUPuqC8JaUmDV9bGSQ

[@devinmorgan7587]

BMW for sportiness Audi interior And Mercedes overall 🥇

[@Michaelwave64]

I driven an m340 and a c43 and the handling of both is amazing but the c43 handles on another level

[@vladdorel9081]

1. BMW inline 6👌 2. Audi but with v6 3tfsi 3.mercedes PS - mercedes - very expensive, small engine, week sound......bleah.........i have audi rs3 2.5 400 hp.....that is the engine that i look for or inline 6 from bmw....just order the new m2 with 450 hp

[@aleksei8884]

Thank you sir, exactly what I was waiting for

[@autogefuehl]

🙌🙌

[@addictedtocheese3688]

1. M340i 2. Audi S4 (diesel but at least 6cyl) 3. C43 (absolutely boring, C43 used to be nice with that 6cyl/sound)

[@berryhappy2625]

c43 in us version is definitely way louder than EU version.

[@Gojo1911]

@@berryhappy2625 so? It‘s still a 4cylinder engine. But I guess some people still believe louder = better, especially when talking about a 4cylinder

[@TheLumberJacked]

I agree on the C43 being super cool with the v6biturbo. But the C43 AMG absolutely feels more special to drive than the M340i (having driven both). However I am brand agnostic. I’d own any of these without reservation and in fact have the last gen GLC AMG43 with V6. The driving dynamics on all of these cars is fun, but I’ve always found the AMG’s to be more hard edged when comparing M sports to Baby AMG’s. either way my next vehicle will mean test driving all of them again and I do love that beautiful B58, though I think I’ll aim for a Full M or Full AMG (63s) next time. I have my eye on an X3 M Competition right now. So we will see. I recommend driving a C43 for real…it’s surprising, even with that little engine (that is also underrated)

[@nickthequick]

I didn't expect it but the Audi petrol version is my favorite. Mercedes looks the best from the outside, but I am completely turned off by their interior.

[@christiantan5341]

The gearbox is really jerky in the C43- hated it so much. The S4 is the way to go if you already have a weekend car. BMW interiors tend to age really badly, so... Great video! S4 always was and always will be the thinking man's choice! So glad my market doesn't get the diesel though

[@TheLumberJacked]

At low speed it takes some getting used to but the way it slams into gears in S+ is so freaking good. Love the feel of that car, feels so much more edgy and sporty IMHO.

[@angelanaya82]

C43 by far looks and better and comes with more. Bmw i feel needs to step it up, and im not talking bigger grill 😂😂

[@erjonsyla802]

Great review as always 👍

[@autogefuehl]

cheers!

[@Joe-mx4co]

Audi S4. I’ve had a few BMW 3 series cars and always got tired of them. The S4 is so easy to live with.

[@ikarugaxx3749]

It's not easy to me to fathom why Audi don't make 4-cylinder quattro models rear-wheel drive biased, like the 6-cylinder (disappearing quickly) ones. Interior aesthetics: it's clear to me how the focus on (large) displays has become what everything interior design hinges on. As a result Audi, where the display isn't yet the king of everything, have now the best-looking interior. 19:26 🤞🏻That very truly is.

[@hardywoodaway9912]

because the engine is in the worst position possible in an audi…

[@CharlieBrown-mx4gq]

@@hardywoodaway9912 what’s wrong with Audi, funny is bmws are well known for being unreliable, yes they sound nice, and yes they are broken 50% of the time.

[@maXXik1337]

Regarding engines my opinion goes semthing like: You buy premium brands also (not only) for experience that other common brands can't deliver. So in this case i expect to have bigger engine than 4cyl you can have in Octavia RS or so. Yes, merc 4 cyl has great power, but it is still just 4 cylinder, does not matter how much artificial sounds you "slap" on it. I was huge fan of previous c43 because of great sound. But now, 340i all the way (and i don't like BMW as a brand really... so it says a lot). Let's not talk about that TDI S4 please, it is almost inappropriate.

[@Josephsl78]

I wish there was a way to get these three brands to collaborate on a special edition model that only has strengths from each of them 😅

[@sj.hammer627]

Love your video and channel, this is my first time watching your channel and was looking between the blw and the Mercedes

[@autogefuehl]

Most welcome!

[@jamiep61]

C43 Is my favourite 😊

[@dsokac12]

BMW 😀😍

[@jarnoblokken]

I bought a new c43 at 19 January and the car should be the first of august at my dealer.

[@JohnSmith-nz4bn]

In Australia, BMW every day of the week! Merc and Audi have very poor after-sales reputations compared to BMW. I also prefer its looks too.

[@robertreid9079]

I love watching John Cadogan over here in the UK who describes Mercedes as the three pronged suppository .

[@JohnSmith-nz4bn]

@@robertreid9079 He is very informative! I quite enjoy his content too!

[@abaranikow]

So informative! Leaning towards the M340i

[@autogefuehl]

Thanks! Feel free to recommend our channel :-)

[@hgrigo13]

There are some things that I don’t agree with you, and one thing that I absolutely disagree with you is that AMG cars were the most different with their non AMG cars. I think that BMW M cars differ the most from the normal cars. On the Audi part, I agree. There is the gap little and the transition is smooth.

[@knotkool1]

the ultimate driving machine in a walkaway. the c43 sounded pretty good though

[@rickscheflen8713]

I wish I was as confident in my opinion as many of those who responded are. I like all of these cars and would be happy with any of them except for one feature. I am 73 years old and from a generation that prefers screens to be integrated into the dashboard, not tacked on. I note that Porsche has no trouble achieving this, but all three of these cars have this Achilles heel. I held onto my 2020 BMW G20 solely because its screen did not look like a billboard erected onto the dash. The huge Mercedes iPad, I feel, will soon look silly, and the Audi's perched iPad seem like a lazy engineering choice. I am hoping that the next Audi A4/S4 design will look more like the current A3 and A6, but I fear that Audi won't invest the money in this because they are focused on the electric versions. I know I am showing my age and may just need to accept that this is the future, but it's just the way I feel. Feel free to tell me to get with the times. Thank you, Thomas, for another great comparison review; I truly respect your knowledge and instincts.

[@autogefuehl]

Thanks Rick!

[@pragadoegito]

I am 32 years old and totally agree with you.

[@n1klasmxms251]

I am 20 and fully support your opinion

[@roscodotemmas]

Now BMW is getting really good, it’s now getting popular than Mercedes-Benz

[@GirishAdhi1985]

BMW is only for speed Lookwise aweful With the introduction of EVs which go faster than BMWs.! BMW will have tough time in the future

[@germanengineering204]

​@@GirishAdhi1985 Keep crying kid lol! BMW number 1 seller in luxury cars, and deemed the most reliable in recent years!😂🤡

[@F90-s7q]

@@GirishAdhi1985 Lookwise BMW is the best lmao what are you talking about. You must be a Woman if you prefer the Benz looks

[@futurehofer1564]

The way that 3 series looks....wow

[@MrWilburlandaverde]

The B9.5 S4 for me. It's very comfortable and looks great. The navigation is displayed on the HUD along with speed limit and lane positioning keeping me from looking away from the road. The handling is great with the sport diff making mountain roads very enjoyable. The volume knob is right by the armrest so the only thing i have to reach for is my drink.

[@권영준-h3x]

Love your video!! I just got myself an audi S4❤❤

[@autogefuehl]

cheers and enjoy ! :)

[@ihsanjayadi88]

People saying the M340i, but it seems to me that the one with the most worth for the common people is the C43. The engine is perfect for countries with heavy tax on engines bigger than 2.0l. It also got the best looks and interior imo.

[@TheLumberJacked]

Very true and that engine is a beast. A marvel of enginerding for sure

[@jansimonteambondi143]

Excellent review 1 Mercedes - most modern and best looking as well as the best handling and, most importantly, the best improvement when you're spending way above the price of the standard sedan 2 BMW - ok looking. At least it doesn't have the massive teeth grille. Let down in styling and cheap finishes 3 Audi - looks like it is from 2010 and should have some soft hats and a tissue box on the rear parcel shelf

[@Enhanced94]

the bmw has better handling and driving dynamics than audi no doubt

[@elvissmeu6758]

BMW interns quality is better than Mercedes - Mercedes has more bling bling looks - Audi is just an old people car 😜😂

[@Enko063]

​@@elvissmeu6758 Audi for old people? Are yoi nuts? Hahahah I have never seen old fellow in Audi. 😂 From statisticks, Audi has youngest clients.

[@F90-s7q]

The BMW has way better handling than the Mercedes and is also much faster. What ´´improvement´´ are you talking about? The new 4 cylinder? Don´t be silly

[@divides_by_zero]

I wish Audi offered Ascari blue in the USA. It is better than the (somewhat boring) Navarra blue we get. I eliminated the Mercedes because of too much use of touch screens. The B58 in the BMW is amazing, but you can't get cooled seats and it leans heavily on the touch screens as well. I'm trying to make up my mind between the A4/S4 and the Cadillac CT5-V (non-Blackwing). The Audi is getting to be an old design, but I like the simple dials and buttons for the climate controls and its blend of sport and luxury for an everyday driver.

[@rmixfaats]

BMW with or without ur review. End of discussion

[@g8joe]

I LOVE ZEE GERMAN ACCENTS .. nice video and review on a serious note I love all the cars . Mercedes is my choice.

[@autogefuehl]

hehe keep tuning in =)

[@G82Watts]

Ive had all 3 cars and only someone biased would pick something other then that m340i. By far the most head turning and mean aggresive looking car. Every review ive watched has said the bmw is faster and handles better. Gives u more feedback while driving and is overall a more fun vehicle to whip around in. Mercedes has really gone down hill in terms of performance and looks. The benz looks so bloated. The audi and benz look more like a normal sedan then a sports sedan. Just by their vehicle shapes. Drivers car=BMW for this generation. Id still try an strech an m3 or m4 XDrive with an adro grille if im able too one day.

[@lima5421]

BMW all day long and the B58 is a peach of an engine!

[@pierre7981]

another great informative review!

[@autogefuehl]

You re welcome!

[@bmeng7152]

Wonderful comparative review!

[@MrHav1k]

Clearly you had the most fun in the Mercedes, and the only real drawback to it that I saw was the fact that it's a four cylinder + hybrid which everyone makes a big deal over, but I personally don't care about. Whatever is the best driving experience. Only thing holding me back from the Merc would be the pricing, but also the reliability. I doubt it will be as reliable as the other two.

[@autogefuehl]

good thoughts!

[@senorgato70]

I'd have to go with the Mercedes. It looks the best to me, inside and out. I do like the engine in the BMW and the exterior doesn't look bad. The interior of the BMW is a huge improvement with the screen/insttrument panel. Still, would go with the AMG.

[@saurabhawasthi7898]

That special appearance on 2:29 was the most aesthetic one. He was indeed a lovely 🐕

[@istvan368]

Great comparison 🎉

[@that-guy213]

The c43 sounds awful even with the fakeness the way that b58 in the bmw revs out in lower gears and downshift sounds so much more exciting and actually gives you a sport car feel. Merc really dropped the ball with the 4 cylinder its not even any faster with its 400 odd horsepower they just achieve that through massive boost through a tiny 4 pot I mean look at the size of the turbo its almost as big as the engine. The c43 is just a fashion accessory the bmw gives you the meat with the chops not just the chops with no meat. I actually don't believe the c43 is pumping out 400 hp with those acceleration figures its just an insult to amg

[@amgtim4636]

the best three on the planet. the best automotive industry of all time

[@jbo2471]

You must note that the s4 TDI depreciated heavily, even more than some 45 tfsi models.😅 You can find one used and use the money gap to buy a proper week end car (like an mx5 or gt86)

[@billshoe22191]

Great job on this Thomas. Between these three the best car is the pre facelift M340i. Nothing beats the B58 inline six cylinder. Pre facelift still had majority physical climate controls so it was the best of both worlds. Mercedes’ C43 is the least appealing of the three by some margin.

[@thenorthwatch777]

Thomas, this was a fantastic review. My choice lies between BMW and Audi, with more bias to BMW.

[@BinhTran-io4ck]

I love your videos. Thanks for the great work.

[@gavinlewis3049]

As a driver of a 4 cylinder cupra formentor, my next car will be the 6 cylinder b58 in the bmw m340i, but in touring form, it is a good balance of fun, luxury and practicality, thank you Thomas for comparing all these cars, just reaffirms my decision on what I'm going to look at in a year or so time, best thing is a year old model you can save around 15,000 pounds in the uk 👍

[@MaciejDrelichowski]

You cant go wrong with any of them. Good review as allways.

[@axcn4733]

yes you can. c43 and s4 are the inferior cars when we talk about engines

[@Fastwalker27]

@@axcn4733 meh The c43 has more power and the s4 is more economical

[@axcn4733]

@@Fastwalker27 yeah, you are lost :)))

[@that-guy213]

​@@Fastwalker27 but the c43 isn't any faster that 4 pot is not making 400bhp no way if it was running 408bhp it would have a faster 0 to 60

[@tumeloruiters3233]

The BMW 340i xDrive all day everyday even after 10 years!!! That car is golden!!! I would never pay that amount of money for a turbocharged 4 cylinder engine. I would rather buy a VW Golf R/ GTi if I wanted a turbocharged 4 cylinder engine.

[@jabberwockytdi8901]

Low Profile horizontal screens make no sense for sat nav, I want to see wher I am going not way off to the left and right, a proper portrait screen is way better

[@philipilizarov4624]

the BMW has the nicest engine. In terms of looks though, 1st is Merc 2nd is Audi 3rd BMW. But all very beautiful :)

[@Sky-dt1zv]

c 43 everyday, i dont hate on the others two, they are GREAT, but if mercedes had that 6 cylinder as well it would ve destroyed the two

[@AaronRandolphChen]

Was that your dog, Thomas? Very handsome dog he is. Wonder if he can do car reviews too? Hope he will make more guest appearances.

[@autogefuehl]

hehe no, used to have a dog but that's sadly long ago.

[@Boguardis]

So I am guessing in the states we are finally getting the m139 engine? Or are we still stuck with the anemic m133?

[@P-Dub206]

Am I the only one that prefers actual digital speedometer/tachometer? To me a nice instrument cluster is like a nice watch. Just classy.

[@skies44]

Wouldn’t it be more fair to compare with Audis next gen model which will be coming soon, rather than the older model shown

[@caliwong]

Holy hell those prices are crazy!

[@Niles-Guy]

BMW fun to drive but not when it ends up in the shop for repair’s because we all know it lacks reliability long term. So I’d pick the Benz

[@kaym7549]

You probably last owned a BMW 10 years ago if you still think it has worse reliability than the other 2 cars. Or you just take things said on social media without any practical experience.

[@XChiefxBanditX]

ill get the M340i LCI next year. overall the best car in looks, engine, performance.

[@younow1511]

1:33 sorry but if you’re going to show the preface s4’s sound then why not do the same for the merc?? The old c43 sounded amazing, better than the s4 and m340i prefacelifts.

[@m27gio]

I actually think these three cars are the best looking out of the entire lineup for each manufacturer. From an exterior perspective the only sedan I could stand looks wise above these would be the S5/A5

[@JohnUSA7]

I recently bought a new 2023 BMW M340i xDrive. It is a very enjoyable and fun driving machine. Except..... I hate the controls on this irritating car. Everything that you need to do you have to do through the center screen and many options are buried several layers deep. It is a horrible, lousy, poor, very difficult and time consuming design. Whoever designed this horrendous controls should be fired. I wish I knew these designs fault as I would have never bought this car. It is my fault. A big shame on BMW. Check these controls before you buy this model. You have been forewarned. Check everything thoroughly.

[@kiplingordon]

M340i all day easy choice

[@RobCos-io1tu]

Looking for the sportiest drive, but I was comparing the S5 Vs C43 AMG. Going to Mercedes dealer tomorrow, I like the tech. We shall see. I have had 4 BMWs so looking for something different now.

[@jabberwockytdi8901]

Since we only get the TDi version of the S4 in the UK it's not really comparable to the Merc or 340i for us. Bring back the TFSi S4 in Europe!

[@superchargedsteve3411]

I'm in the US and currently have an Audi S4 and love it, but I have to say I really love the new LCI refresh on the BMW and may switch to the M340i as my next daily driver. I just don't care for the 4 cylinder in the Mercedes regardless of how fast it is.