Bach - Opening Chorus Herr, unser Herrscher from St John Passion BWV 245 | Netherlands Bach Society

The opening chorus 'Herr, unser Herrscher' from St John Passion, performed by the Nederlands Bach Society for All of Bach. The St John Passion was the first Passion Bach had written as cantor in Leipzig. The Passion story as told in the Gospel of John is different from that told by the other three evangelists - Matthew, Luke and Mark. John’s version places the emphasis on Christ’s divine origin. Throughout his suffering, this divine origin still plays a role and nowhere is Jesus as human as in the other gospels.
For this performance, we selected a cast of singers under the age of 35. Apart from the leaders, all the orchestra members are also younger than 35. The concert series was preceded by a course of auditions and masterclasses.
Recorded for the project All of Bach on March 11th 2017 at the Grote Kerk, Naarden. If you want to help us complete All of Bach, please subscribe to our channel bit.ly/2vhCeFB and consider donating bit.ly/2uZuMj5.
For the behind-the-scenes of the auditions for the St John Passion go to • Bach - St John Passion...
For the behind-the-scenes of the masterclasses for BWV 245 go to • Bach - St John Passion...
For the behind-the-scenes of the general rehearsal of BWV 245 go to • Bach - St John Passion...
For more information on BWV 245 and this production go to allofbach.com/en/bwv/bwv-245/
All of Bach is a project of the Netherlands Bach Society / Nederlandse Bachvereniging, offering high-quality film recordings of the works by Johann Sebastian Bach, performed by the Netherlands Bach Society and her guest musicians. Visit our free online treasury for more videos and background material allofbach.com/en/. For concert dates and further information go to www.bachvereniging.nl/nederla....
Netherlands Bach Society
Jos van Veldhoven, conductor
Soloists
Raphael Höhn, evangelist (tenor)
Myriam Arbouz, soprano
Maria Valdmaa (Maid), soprano
Daniël Elgersma, alto
Marine Fribourg, alto
Gwilym Bowen, tenor
Guy Cutting (Servant), tenor
Felix Schwandtke (Jesus), bass
Drew Santini (Peter), bass
Angus Mc Phee (Pilate), bass

[@madavi6321]

Sometimes Bach can be the best reason to live..

[@harryjoseph1802]

Hear, hear!

[@rexel666]

There are no words to describe the power of these dissonances.

[@Mjollnir1234]

^^^ Someone gets it.

[@thegoalfather9922]

For real, you can only feel it, and not describe

[@JazzBlack]

100% agree

[@johnunkerman]

So spot on! Nobody did tension like J.S. e.g. the last 1 minute and 10 seconds of the toccata and fuge in D minor are off the hook tense. So much so that he makes a minor chord feel like a major resolve @ the end. We so miss those diminished chords in modern music. So blessed he was a human. Miss you forever Johann. ❤️

[@johannsebastianbach4983]

@@johnunkerman What do thou mean? I am still in this world!

[@PointyTailofSatan]

Most people have no idea how revolutionary this was in Bach's time. Those opening strained harmonies are more like something from the Romantic era, not the Baroque.

[@margaretharypkema9290]

"Revolutionary" what do you mean??

[@PointyTailofSatan]

@@margaretharypkema9290 That amazing dissonance in the opening. After Bach, you don't hear harmony like that for almost 75 years.

[@parduetheholyman]

I know right! The amount of emotion is staggering, Bach really knew how to use his music to stir the feelings of his audience. I get chills listening to it now, I can only imagine how a group of baroque listeners would react to this.

[@DaviSilva-oc7iv]

@@PointyTailofSatan You are talking about the ninth symphony?

[@PointyTailofSatan]

@@DaviSilva-oc7iv Later. I'm thinking something like Mahler.

[@notallthatbad]

I don't think there will ever be another Bach. He must have been from another planet where the beauty was so exquisite and the only way he knew how to express it was through music. Calling this a masterpiece is an understatement, it's a miracle of sound, harmony and emotion.

[@philipnorris6542]

While I am not really a classical fan, I have to agree.

[@mortenkeiser-nielsen7311]

Part of it is to realise that the beauty of our planet is that magnificent! As above, so below. Bach seems to have had his mind OPEN!

[@sethweisberg4792]

History is long and our greatest hope is another bach someday.

[@pdruiz2005]

I think I've heard this piece over 100 times. And I am always left in awe, especially with those incredible chromatic dissonances at the very beginning. They remind me so much of thorns, sticking right into your conscience. How did this man hear these sounds all by himself, with practically no influence upon his thought processes, so early on? This was written in the year before 1724 or so, precisely 300 years ago. Bach is truly without peer in Western music for having concocted these marvelous, aching sounds from whole cloth. A true genius among geniuses.

[@Musicienne-DAB1995]

What astonishes me is that CPE Bach said that Bach would compose from his head, then play the work on a keyboard. So he heard all of this intricate contrapuntal texture in his head first. Mindblowing. Sure, his extensive musical education was the primer for such genius, but when you get to works like The Art of the Fugue and The Musical Offering, it's still incredible.

[@yamilfranco285]

More than 1000 😅

[@michaelhowarth4302]

This must be one of the most moving and dramatic choruses in all of music...and such a wonderful performance with period instruments. The constant beat, the discords, the way it rises to a climax and then falls away and builds again is magnificent...thank you!

[@handsomechuck1]

I know of nothing like the moment when the chorus enters with "Herr!" Have listened to this piece endlessly and it's shocking every time.

[@Danleesixoneonetwofive]

You should watch “Mirror” (1975). The director makes great use of Bach’s music, and it’s breathtaking

[@frenchimp]

@@Danleesixoneonetwofive Tarkovski.

[@ericlopez6866]

Bach wasn't ahead of his time. He was timeless. Music like this wouldn't be around again until deep Romanticism, and still, with the constant bass moving and implied percussion due to the persistent rhythm in the strings, this is as proper in the 20th Century as Jazz or heavy metal is. Bach is the Alpha and the Omega of music.

[@raultifrea5549]

He is a gift and a measure unit. Maybe we have more complex options today, but few speak to the soul the way his work does. His pieces never miss the aim.

[@dominiquepeytraud406]

Oh yes to both of you blessings

[@deanschulze3129]

Bach is the Isaac Newton of music. All the other geniuses stood on his shoulders.

[@alfredvikingelegant9156]

​@@deanschulze3129I. Newton said that he was sitting on giants shoulders ...

[@deanschulze3129]

@@alfredvikingelegant9156 - That was probably (uncharacteristic) modesty by Newton. There were prominent scientists before Newton but he exceeded all of them. And probably all that have come after him. The same with Bach. I'll stick with my analogy.

[@davidhynd4435]

I wonder if Bach was moved when he heard this in his head for the first time? There is so much longing and melancholy being driven along by that throbbing beat. Dissonances playing off each other. Rising and falling. Just stunning. And beautifully performed. What a genius this man was!

[@incription]

of course he was, do you think he composed for nothing?

[@evelyn8467]

❤

[@bobmcgahey1280]

@@evelyn8467 he composed only for the glory of God and wrote that on all his MS Soli Deo Gloria

[@raultifrea5549]

@@bobmcgahey1280 people forget about this or chose to ignore it, but that denies the whole purpose of his creations. Bach served God, all his work was an offering. I believe that is why he holds the spot he does in the history of humanity, since all other great composers looked up to him. You don't get that position and hold it for centuries without being contested. And nobody does it...

[@frenchimp]

@@bobmcgahey1280 I don't believe that for a second. He composed because that was his life's passion and he derived an immense joy from it. He was passionately in love with music. Many a devout musician produces crap.

[@MinecraftAddict991]

No one's talking about the excellent quality of audio and cinematography! Well done capturing the magic of the performance.

[@TomCloyd]

I couldn't agree more. And a great deal of work has gone into the editing as well. Wonderfully done, and most impressive.

[@no42arak-st-floor44]

💯💯💯💯💫

[@no42arak-st-floor44]

100%....thank you!

[@raultifrea5549]

When you have a delicious meal, do praise the plate?

[@bertspeggly4428]

@@raultifrea5549 An unnecessarily negative comment. The meal wouldn't be edible without a plate.

[@Morigi5]

This opening Chorus from “Johannes-Pasion” and alto Aria “Erbarme dich mein Gott” from “Matthäus-Pasion” are the pinnacles of Western sacred choral music - they transcend time, truly eternal masterpieces created by Bach’s genius!👌🏻👏🏻 Beautiful performance, tutti bravi! 👏🏻

[@_____c___482]

Morigi5 also sheep may safely graze bwv 208, jesus bleibet meine freude 147, Mozart’s requiem, ave verum corpus, Beethoven missa solemnis

[@sidneimigueldossantossidne9426]

@@_____c___482 Mozart K. 427 "Great Mass" in C minor.

[@archaeopteryx91]

If you haven't seen it, you might appreciate Tsrkovsky's The Sacrifice. Erbarme dich plays at the climax of the film

[@Morigi5]

The Calcium Kid I have seen it, of course, as Tarkovsky is one of my favourite ‘intellectual’ film directors (the other ones are Kubrick and (selectively) Mallick). Though I didn’t like ‘The Sacrifice’ - my favourite of Tarkovsky films is «Зеркало»/‘The Mirror’.

[@rayancharafeddine4982]

@@Morigi5 we get nun komm der heiden heiland in that

[@no42arak-st-floor44]

when you're in the state of deep depression caused by losing a wonderful and extraordinary wife after 40 years; the induced climax causes your mind to reach the peak! with tears covering your entire face, along with it the promise of resurrection and having a chance in joining her regardless of where? and in what form? thank you NPS your performances is as stellar as well compatible with the master of his craft J S Bach!💯💯💯💯

[@valtergilenardi2639]

Dalla Depressione si può uscire. Io ne ho sofferto per 6 anni. Avendo una volontà d'acciaio ho lasciato gli Psicofarmaci e sono guarito ✌😎👑

[@no42arak-st-floor44]

@@valtergilenardi2639 muito..obrigado...dios...vendigas...🥲🖐🙏

[@ginobee3585]

Lifting you up to Our Father. ❤

[@no42arak-st-floor44]

@@ginobee3585 thank you and may God protect you and your family.

[@dominiquepeytraud406]

Same with my little Kitty

[@k.auan2375]

Greatest music ever written

[@erexford]

I went to a concert with my friend. I had never heard this music before. I was enthralled by the opening, before the chorus comes in and then, POW!, or should I say "HERR"! I felt my very spirit heading up to heaven. My whole body was trembling! What music! And here, I love seeing the singers faces. They all express the deepest feelings............great performance!

[@marbifrost7667]

I can say, you're the luckiest person on the whole earth 🥹🥹❤️

[@marcvolpe8252]

ELIZABETH YOU ARE SO BEAUTIFUL ADORABLE SEDUCTIVE RAVISHING SEXY CAPTIVATING AND PASSIONATE YOUR BEAUTY IS PHENOMENAL IF MICHELANGELO WERE ALIVE TODAY YOU WOULD BE HIS MUSE ❤

[@miladyaqo7150]

No matter how developed the world gets, there would be no better version or performance than this one! Absolutely astonishing, much love!

[@abdito721]

I must admit that the most laudable feature in this rendition is clarity of meanings. For instance, if you listen to other renditions of this introduction, you wouldn't perceive the realization of the third HERR as more contemplative in contrast with the other first realizations which are euphoric and dramatic, which undoubtedly changes the semantics of this passage. Again, bravo!

[@frenchimp]

Yes, I noted that. The three "Herr" are articulated in a very subtle way.

[@tacitusk7056]

Je crois que c'est l'une des musique les plus puissante que j'ai jamais entendue

[@bahrss]

I cannot hold my tears

[@vkumv2493]

I gotta admit, this type of music gives me mixed emotions. Some happy some sad and some chaotic type emotions. This music is pure art in audio.

[@ramanattri3937]

Herr, herr , herr-- one of the most powerful words i have ever heard in my life. This rendition is just perfect. There is no one who guarantee that this is not bach preferred. In every aspect human emotions one can perceive, this is the one, the honoured rendition the honoured perfection that we deserve. These people are just perfect. Thank you soooo much Netherlands bach society. I don’t have words to thank you enough.

[@davidstedeford387]

Herr, unser Herrscher, dessen Ruhm In allen Landen herrlich ist! Zeig uns durch deine Passion, Daß du, der wahre Gottessohn, Zu aller Zeit, Auch in der größten Niedrigkeit, Verherrlicht worden bist! Lord, our ruler, Whose fame In every land is glorious! Show us, through Your passion, That You, the true Son of God, Through all time, Even in the greatest humiliation, Have become transfigured!

[@baptist1611]

Verherrlicht is better translated as "Glorified" . Here is the ultimate contrast with the Niedrigkeit (humiliation) which immediately precedes Verherrlicht. And to emphasise this Bach places "forte" between the two. This is the stupendous contradiction of Christ's passion. It was the deepest imaginable humiliation, yet at the same time he was glorified above all, as very God of very God (John 13:31-32).

[@davidstedeford387]

@@baptist1611 Thank you for that correction. It's a pity you tube doesn't allow corrections. I don't know where I got that translation from. My main purpose was that the words of this wonderful chorus should be on view.

[@pbj4184]

@@davidstedeford387 I think from here www.emmanuelmusic.org/notes_translations/translations_cantata/t_bwv245.htm

[@frenchimp]

@@baptist1611 And of course the cognate words Herr, Herrscher, verherrlicht... hence the endless repetition of the syllable herr... that doesn't work in English.

[@evandrofelipe2569]

Jesus Cristo é maravilhoso

[@TheMarcHicks]

The thing that amazes me most is, how do they get such a full sound from such a relatively small ensemble? Its amazing!!!!

[@zacharybond23]

I imagine supreme amounts of skill and good acoustics.

[@sergioazevedo7390]

It's easy to answer: the tuning in those times was lower, and the strings made in gut, so the instruments were less brilliant but more resonant, even those doscret "continuo" tiorbas and other plucked instruments have a lot of bass open strings who resonate plenty. Also, as the music is tonal, the triad is always doubled in several instruments, adding strength to the whole, which does not happen, for example, in Webern, where there are no doubling. Also, the music was conceived for small, resonant spaces, like churches, and is in a church that this performance, as it should, is taking place.

[@RosieHarp]

Venue size and acoustics. Live string instruments are actually very loud, even a quartet will sound rich in a smaller setting.

[@ParischneiderMUSIC]

During tbe pandemic, this was sublime. . . It is the same now.

[@mattfox762]

There's nothing like when those voices enter. Fantastic work, NBS, as always.

[@Musicienne-DAB1995]

And the suspensions!

[@davidriggenbach6672]

A miracle of music! At a time when music was blue, red and yellow Bach introduced for the first time a whole pallet of colors and textures. Sadly his employer didn’t understand Bach. The Passion was reworked a few times and the definitive version had to be canceled when the city council decided not to perform it a third time leave Bach with partial scores of this final version.

Besides the obvious quality of the performance, there is an amazing care to the whole visuals. Thank you Netherlands Bach Society, can't thank you enough. Best regards from the southeastern Pacific Ocean.

[@thegoalfather9922]

This tension and emotion is just so unreal, you understand it but can't describe it with words

[@harryjoseph1802]

What an ominous hair raising opening chorus! So full of dread and foreboding. 300th Anniversary of this Great Work!

[@Musicienne-DAB1995]

I have listened to this several times over. It's a masterpiece. I have goosebumps-- and this is just the beginning! Van Veldhoven has balanced all the parts well here, and this choir is great!

[@SilverKnobsHMDT]

Absolutely beautiful, probably the best version I've ever heard

[@dr.tillzoom7616]

What will Bach have done after finishing this stunning piece? Celebrated the moment? Fallen into bed, exhausted? Felt nothing special, thinking already about the next project/ composition?

[@margaretharypkema9290]

😊 Perhaps all four?

[@johannsebastianbach4983]

Well, I then started to write the next recitative! I was thinking about how it sounded with a full orchestra!

[@dr.tillzoom7616]

@@johannsebastianbach4983 Welcome Bach from the dead!!! 😀👍👍

[@margaretharypkema9290]

May be he fell on his knees and thanked God for what HE had enabled him to accomplish??

[@EcstasyJesus]

@@margaretharypkema9290 Even if most of Bachs output was written with god in mind, chalking this amazing feat of art up to divinity instead of the ingenuity of humanity is a disservice to humanity. God may have provided the inspiration, but Bach still executed it. Bach's immaculate musicality and revolutionary mind enabled him to accomplish this, not god.

[@haxstir]

Beethoven I love. Mozart I love. Bach is absolutely divine. Mozart achieves sometimes the same tension and build but not as often as Bach does.

[@ofsabir]

I have never seen the sheet music but listened this marvelous recording so many times, that I think I can sing any part in my vocal range. Thank you for saving Bach's tresure like works!

[@tobiasstudtheol]

imslp.org/wiki/Johannespassion,_BWV_245_(Bach,_Johann_Sebastian) Try this, 😉! Maybe you try the autographs/ manuscripts because no Urtext version of this movement is available.

[@thefreckledcormarant6431]

I still have no idea how, at any time in history, let alone 300 years ago, someone was able not only to conceive these sounds in their head, but transcribe them so that they could be recreated by musicians.

[@parislovesrachmaninoff]

This is the BEST recording. Reminds me of the early 2020 lock down when I first heard this recording. I miss those times.

[@RosieHarp]

I enjoyed the peace of lockdown

[@RosieHarp]

This is a joy to sing in the chorus, an absolute masterpiece

[@zemaria1077]

Purest form of music.

[@jeanmarieguillaumegerardde7127]

The best Bach performers in the world

[@jean-michelhakin4983]

Probablement la plus belle ouverture... Bach m'accompagne tous les jours...

[@Musicienne-DAB1995]

Je suis fana de la musique médiévale, surtout celle de Guillaume de Machaut. Mais je retourne toujours aux oeuvres de Jean-Sébastien Bach. Il représente le sommet de la musique occidentale, même la civilisation occidentale. C'était l'avis de Franz Liszt en ce qui concerne la grande messe de Bach, la messe en si mineur.

[@jean-michelhakin4983]

@@Musicienne-DAB1995 Merci pour votre réponse. Je m'en vais découvrir Guillaume de Machaut. La "Messe en Si", autre merveille de Bach...

[@tibadelespierre6081]

Fantastic! Blessed be thé Lord Jesus Christ !

[@ProdigyImprovisation]

Absolutely Stunning in dreadful & viscous sorrow!

[@KNALLisgettinfamos]

FINALLY a performance with dynamic! Big thanks to all!

[@Hannodb1961]

Oh and the theology that goes with this music is just as deep. "Show us through your suffering, even in your deepest humiliation, how You are being glorified!" How many Gospel writters would even think of writting something so profound in their music? Truly, Bach was a man who knew his Saviour well.

[@keithorrell681]

Just listening to this after the Oxford Bach soloists St John in isolation. Love the shaping of 'Herr, Herr, Herr'. Fabulous musicianship & very moving

[@jpenak6]

Thermonuclear opening...

[@cagriben]

We don't deserve such a gorgeous piece. Incredible performance!

[@EdmondoTassi]

It is as if it were still composed, the spiral of the strings seems to come from a distant galaxy. In the three exclamations addressed to the lord lies the ineluctable human destiny. A timeless masterpiece.

[@xzevedo]

Acho que já assisti/ouvi este vídeo desta Paixão completa mais de 10 vezes. Sou músico e ateu, mas impossível não me emocionar com a grandiosidade desta obra. Minha vida não seria a mesma sem Bach! ❤

[@abdito721]

NBS always bringing excellent renditions of Bach's masterpieces, I dear to say NBS is one of the best ensambles nowadays for this kind of pieces. Congrats! Really moving and well interpreted.

[@anneoliveira6120]

Génial! La meilleure interprétation que je connaisse.

[@odettewesterlinck883]

Effectivement ! Superbe

[@mrbanks5344]

Este inicio de la Pasión es misterioso. Parece tétrico, es verdaderamente perfecto. Y esta versión te pone la piel de gallina. Me encanta.

[@jpenak6]

Es San Juan Evangelista... Apuntaba maneras... Johannes Sebastian simplemente lo entiende como nadie pudo hacerlo.. y Veldhoven lo interpreta todo a la perfección.

[@Garrett_Rowland]

Great performance of a powerful piece.

[@davidc5191]

I grew up on the Karl Richter performance, but this is quite good, the creepy dissonance capturing the flavor of Christian mysticism.

[@gyes99]

For me the best part starts at 5:34 - 6.27, I can't stop to rewind and listen again. And I can't stop it playing in my head when I don't listen to it.

[@tjmangos]

Me too

[@heleniovilladiegomontiel9683]

Between 8:50 and 9:05 you can ear and see God's voice and face.

[@rafikbaladi6555]

Breathtaking. Wonderful performance, with tensions, dissonance, power, glory and flame of faith

[@PetStuBa]

this is without doubt the best version I've ever heard OMGGGGG ... this was so musical this conductor is a genius, period !!

[@MrMeyerjean]

Bach toujours un moment super

[@b8hovenusa]

Bach unser Herrscher!

[@tatianareinhard2772]

Ohne Worte! So wunderschön!

[@gerardomena9745]

Me encanta Bach! Soli Deo Gloria!

[@ericoschmitt]

This gives me chills

[@Arteshir]

Notice the always present pulsating base tempo (the fire amber) from start to the end... and the voices are the flames and sometimes one spikes higher than the rest of the flames(the soprano)

[@vijayapaulj6946]

Sounding like heaven....loved it

[@Blazagg]

Could you please upload this to Spotify? Please please please, pretty please!! This is my favourite version

[@odettefrancois6566]

Bach es el padre dela música ,sus obras sublimes llegan al alma, la Pasion san Juan tuve el privilegio de cantarla y llegó a mi espiritu comprendiendo el significado de la pasion de su muerte pero RESUSITÓ,amen, me emociona siempre escucharla , saludos desde Chile 🎼🎶❤

[@estudiosfolkloreiberoamericano]

creo entender lo que dices es la exaltación de lo sublime

[@spartahristova2631]

oh, so wonderful, thank you

[@bimac44]

A wonderful ,excellent performance .The best one.

[@DrSmithIbri]

Awesome!

[@johnunkerman]

One of the greatest interpretations I’ve ever heard. Leave it to the Dutch. The acoustics in that cathedral don’t hurt either! 😉

[@ludwigvanbeethoven61]

Imagine Bach would have written Symphonies. It would have absolutely dwarfed every other composer ever (maybe with exception of Beethoven)

[@_Athanos]

Overall I find his orchestral works to be lacking, especially compared to the rest of his music. Bach's music is very structural and thus, orchestration doesn't matter much, which is in direct opposition with the very idea of the symphony + he was a baroque composer and symphonies aren't really compatible with how baroque composers thought about music.

[@rjuttemeijer]

I love the tempo of the opening choir.

[@renatehiebendaal3687]

Amazing beautiful! Praise God, Almighty! 🙏💖

[@dynis15]

Beautiful

[@TheGreatDigitalism]

Beautiful. Thank you for uploading.

[@fazylo2054]

Bach is simply God transcribed into music.

[@user-pq9yg2pq6h]

Hier in Kroatien gibt es einen Witz unter Musikern. Ich entschuldige mich, wenn es sakrilegisch klingt, es ist nur ein Witz. Als Mozart starb, begrüßte ihn der heilige Petrus im Himmel und nahm ihn mit, um Gott zu begegnen. Als sie sich langsam auf den Weg machten, war Mozart begeistert, die himmlischen Klänge dessen zu hören, was er für die schönste Musik hielt, die man sich vorstellen konnte. Es war der Chor und das Orchester des Himmels. Als er dies dachte, traf er den Herrn und der Herr sagte zu ihm: "Oh Mozart! Ich freue mich sehr, dass Sie hier sind. Sie werden das Ensemble leiten." Und Mozart, ein bisschen verwirrt, antwortete: "Ich wäre sehr geehrt, oh Herr. Aber ... verdiene ich eine solche Position? Ich meine, ist Bach nicht irgendwo in der Nähe?" Und Gott sah ihn ruhig an und sagte: "Ich bin Bach." There is a joke among musicians here in Croatia. I apologise if it sounds sacrilegious, it's just a joke. When Mozart died Saint Peter welcomed him in Heaven and took him to meet God. As they slowly made their way Mozart was thrilled to hear the heavenly sounds of what he thought was the most beautiful music one could imagine. It was Heaven's choir and orchestra. Thinking this he met the Lord and the Lord said unto him: "Oh Mozart! I am very pleased you're here. You will be in charge of the ensemble." And Mozart, a little bit confused, responded: "I would be most honored, oh Lord. But... Do I deserve such a position? I mean, isn't Bach around somewhere?" And God looked at him calmly and said: "I'm Bach." ☺ 😁

[@thegoalfather9922]

What an amazing video, thank you for spreading the magic of the human beings

[@matthijshebly]

J.S. Bach was 200-300 years of his time... No wonder people of his time did not understand.

[@hugoclarke3284]

More than that. People are still trying to understand Bach today.

[@margaretharypkema9290]

Who says they didn't understand...?

[@frenchimp]

@@margaretharypkema9290 I guess the Leipzig councelors who deplored that the 4 best candidates had preferred other positions and they had to be content with the mediocre Bach, or Scheibe's attack on Bach, whose music was "too complicated and bombastic" represent some of the many testimonies to the fact that most people didn't understand...

[@Claude_van]

There’s probably no progress in art and music. See the cave paintings.

[@giulioandreetta4226]

Great masterpiece, good performance...

[@JazzBlack]

Sooo many goosebumps what an entrance wow!!

[@joselopes2293]

Superb orchestra and choir interpretation. Perhaps the best that I heard so far. Bravissimo to the orchestration and fantastic voices.Bravissimo!!!!!

[@makaksumatransky2930]

MAGNIFICENT SPACE PERFORMANCE.

[@robinblankenship9234]

Transcendental; both in conception and realization.

[@stephanebelizaire3627]

BRAVO !

[@3xofind3r28]

Merci pour cette impressionnante prestation divine à vous tous!!!Je me suis découvert une nouvelle passion BACH de loin le meilleur:,-)

[@ludwigvanbeethoven61]

So much drama, this would be even too much for Shakespeare xD. Bach was such a killer, he wrote the deepest music ever

[@raultifrea5549]

When you speak of at least what he thought was the most important thing there is, you can't have it any other way. Soli Deo Gloria!

[@ludwigvanbeethoven61]

​@@raultifrea5549 In my opinion there was no god that created the music. It was the genius of a man who devoted himself to a christian god. His spiritual belief was just a vehicle to have the endless endurance to write everything down what was in his incredible mind.

[@bobmcgahey1280]

Soli Deo Gloria

[@karinanunez5458]

Hermoso!!!

[@gagaimnaishvili5274]

Great 💝

[@ralphhage8953]

Magnificient!

[@LIITANNA]

Thank you ♥️

[@arpitdas4263]

The ending is perfect

[@ysaicardenas8721]

So great¡¡¡¡¡ so coOl¡¡¡¡ congratulations from México¡¡¡

[@franciscoe.novalessalinas4981]

DESLUMBRANTE, GENIAL, ES TAN BELLA Y POTENTE LA INTERPRETACIÓN QUE MÍ EMOCIÓN SE DISPARA Y CUESTA RESPIRAR. GRACIAS DESDE MÉXICO.

[@pieterjansen6701]

In één woord: fantastisch.

[@MrGregor65]

Phantastisch!

[@bruin4Christ]

“the Hero is slain” “the Hero will reign” What a dichotomy in the music!😮

[@ramanattri3937]

This is epic.

[@1932Nono]

Bravo!

[@normasharkey1770]

Love the use of Baroque instruments!

[@ozielich]

Thank you!!!!!

[@alfredoihldausend4093]

Wunderbar !!!!!!!!!!!