Backhoe VS Excavator? (Case 580L)

In this video we answer the age old question... Backhoe VS Excavator? What is your opinion? please leave a comment and let us know!
Check out my other backhoe video here!
• TURBO CASE 580 BACKHOE...

[@mileshearn7404]

I love my 580SM it is a farm machine used regularly for digging lifting and loading. yes for just digging excavator is king but all around handy machine a backhoe is awesome. My option is Case leads in backhoe engineering and versatility, it does not feel like it is as big as it is in tight areas.

[@michaelmccord5764]

Thanks again! Enjoying your honest opinions!

[@davidmays2161]

Enjoyed the video. More videos like this brother.

[@down2earthconstructioninc.109]

The TBL is a very versatile piece of equipment in the right hands

[@AndrewOborny]

Keep the backhoe. Nice to have a backup for either skidsteer or excavator. Obviously isnt as handy as skidsteer or excavator in every situation but can definitely get the job done.

[@georgeenriquez612]

Good video, you mentioned some good key points. I love excavators but I grew up around backhoes and I’m a backhoe person. They’re tough to beat on certain job sites where there’s some digging involved and loading or packing material around. They’re good at a lot of things but not perfect at one. Also I like your blue square body dually in the background 👌🏻

[@AlexKall]

"They’re good at a lot of things but not perfect at one." Very well put!

[@davidtipton7234]

Plus on the case backhoes. You can still get parts thru case. Unlike alot of the others where parts have been discontinued.

[@DirtDoctors]

I’m just getting started, doing little jobs as a side business. I have a subcompact TLB and it works for what I do. I needed a loader and an excavator, but could only afford one purchase. I ended up with the TLB. If I start doing more work and bigger jobs, I may buy an excavator. I already have my eye on a Sany.

[@diggingwithdylan9092]

I love my Sany ! Don’t think you’d be disappointed!

[@donstewart2059]

A backhoe is a updated old tractor your backhoe does not have side shift which can help dig a trench next to a wall and the backhoe can only go to the left or right and a excavator can load a truck and push the dirt into all four corners of the tray but the backhoe is good to pick-up alot of dirt and backfill a trench or hole

[@AlexKall]

As a old operator told me, the backhoe is a bad excavator, it's a bad loader (our backhoes are based on wheel loaders instead of tractor) but it's a great excavator-loader, or something along those lines. In other words, it has it's uses but it will not replace either machine, it's versatile but not great at specific tasks. They are great as service machines on work sites, they are (the ones we have) great at powerline work and cable laying work.

[@MrTizenhatkarakter]

An excavator with a tilt rotator is the most universal of all these machines. It can even be used as a bucket loader if you have the skills!

[@MrRerod]

If you could only have one, which would it be.. I'm looking at the 90XT or 580L

[@diggingwithdylan9092]

Really depends on the application. It’s hard to do any precision work with the backhoe when it comes to fine grading. But if you have ditching and clearing to do it will put perform!

[@user-kr4yh4mo1q]

There not out dated if you can't oford an escavater, I also can use it as skip loader, can't do that with that escavater, also that case can use many more atachments.

[@JesseKlaus]

I'm looking for a piece of equipment for clearing some land on my property. I'm really leaning towards a backhoe with 4in1 bucket. I'm really tempted to change out the bucket attachment to go to SSQA so I could run a skid steer grapple for moving logs around. I just don't know what all I'd be giving up going that route. I'm sure there's a reason why they're still mounting buckets that way on backhoes.

[@diggingwithdylan9092]

Some smaller backhoes run the skidsteer quick attach! Pretty sure cat has quick attach for their backhoes now but it is a bigger more HD design!

[@nigelmchugh5541]

4in1 front bucket is a necessity for land learing work. Makes an enormous difference to their versatility.

[@caseyjones6197]

So do you operate on backhoe or ISO?

[@diggingwithdylan9092]

Backhoe controls. Even in my excavator

[@excavatorpalembang1728]

I am very happy to see your video friends... Explaining useful tools... I wish you good health and success my friend

[@brandonbowser5487]

hows the loader vs the skid steer like i never ran a real backhoe but i run a massey 1245 with a hoe on the back and it doesnt seem to keep up with the skid steers power to push and kinda level stuff if that makes sense .

[@diggingwithdylan9092]

4x4 makes a big difference. And the backhoe is designed more for dirt. Big difference in the feel of it and a tractor. It beats the skid steer for moving a lot of material over a distance. But skidsteer is the way to go for any type of precision work or grading

[@brandonbowser5487]

alright thanks for the info @@diggingwithdylan9092

[@johngreer3004]

Great video man. Case really does make a great backhoe. Hard to beat the cummings 4bt .looken forward to seeing what you did to your sany.

[@caseyjones6197]

I mean you excavator.